Muhammad
Zubair
a,
Saadat
Hussain
b,
Mujeeb-
ur-Rehman
b,
Ajaz
Hussain
c,
Muhammad Ehtisham
Akram
c,
Sohail
Shahzad
d,
Zahid
Rauf
e,
Maria
Mujahid
d and
Aman
Ullah
*a
aLipids Utilization Lab, Department of Agricultural, Food and Nutritional Science, University of Alberta, Edmonton, Alberta, Canada T6G 2P5. E-mail: ullah2@ualberta.ca
bLEJ Nanotechnology Center, HEJ Research Institute of Chemistry, ICCBS, University of Karachi, Karachi-75270, Pakistan
cInstitute of Chemical Sciences, Bahauddin Zakariya University, Multan 60800, Punjab, Pakistan
dDepartment of Chemistry, University of Sahiwal, Sahiwal 57000, Pakistan
ePakistan Forest Institute (PFI), Peshawar 25130, Khyber Pakhtunkhwa, Pakistan
First published on 1st November 2024
Natural resource based polymers, especially those derived from proteins, have attracted significant attention for their potential utilization in advanced wound care applications. Protein based wound care materials provide superior biocompatibility, biodegradability, and other functionalities compared to conventional dressings. The effectiveness of various fabrication techniques, such as electrospinning, phase separation, self-assembly, and ball milling, is examined in the context of developing protein-based materials for wound healing. These methods produce a wide range of forms, including hydrogels, scaffolds, sponges, films, and bioinspired nanomaterials, each designed for specific types of wounds and different stages of healing. This review presents a comprehensive analysis of recent research that investigates the transformation of proteins into materials for wound healing applications. Our focus is on essential proteins, such as keratin, collagen, gelatin, silk, zein, and albumin, and we emphasize their distinct traits and roles in wound care management. Protein-based wound care materials show promising potential in biomedical engineering, offering improved healing capabilities and reduced risks of infection. It is crucial to explore the potential use of these materials in clinical settings while also addressing the challenges that may arise from their commercialization in the future.
In recent times, the focus of biomedical engineering has been on developing biodegradable wound dressings composed of natural and synthetic polymers. These dressings are designed to provide efficient and rapid treatment for wound injuries while simultaneously minimizing the potential for bacterial infections.9 This method, which utilizes biopolymers, is considered to have significant promise for enhancing skin restoration and recovery. It is reported to overcome the constraints associated with autografting, debridement, and allografting techniques.10 The rise of persistent high-risk wounds, particularly in the elderly, immunocompromised individuals, and diabetics, has enhanced the relevance of wound management. Four successive physiological phases, namely coagulation, inflammation, cell proliferation, and tissue regeneration, make up the intricate process of wound healing. Bacteria can readily infect the wound during these processes, increasing inflammation and inhibiting wound healing.11 Currently, most commercial dressings available are made from cotton-based sterile gauze, which often has large pores, making it challenging to prevent the entry and growth of germs. Infection is a crucial issue that can slow down the healing process of wounds.12 To promote better wound healing, advanced wound dressings can be designed to protect the wound from bacteria and maintain moisture.13 These dressings offer comfort, allow oxygen to penetrate, and shield the wound bed from mechanical shock. The materials used in wound dressings must also satisfy specific criteria, including nontoxicity, biocompatibility, and biodegradability.14
Natural polymers that are biodegradable, biocompatible, and have chemical properties similar to the extracellular matrix (ECM) are promising materials that can be used as efficient wound dressing applications. Living organisms produce these polymers which consist of proteins and carbohydrates that combine chemically. Natural polymers, unlike synthetic ones, are predominantly hydrophilic and biocompatible, as illustrated in Table 1. These characteristics make them particularly suitable for biomedical applications.15 Recently, a study reported by Wei and coworkers synthesized gelatin-based anti-inflammatory hydrogels with carboxymethyl chitosan, aloe vera, and glutaraldehyde, showing elasticity, self-repair, shear properties, and anti-S. aureus and E. coli activities, and 12-hour lomefloxacin release, suitable for wound dressings.16 Reisi-Vanani et al. developed wound dressings from thymus oil, PVA, gelatin, and licorice extract, producing smooth nanofibers with enhanced diameter, strong resistance to S. aureus and K. pneumoniae, and efficient fibroblast migration in vitro.17 Gong et al. (2023) developed a biphasic aerogel-hydrogel (AHB-gel) dressing using β-lactoglobulin fibrils (BLGFs) and polyvinyl alcohol (PVA), enhancing liquid interaction, softness, and in vitro biocompatibility. In vivo, studies confirmed the effectiveness of AHB-gel dressings with BLGFs for hemostasis and wound healing.18 Wang et al. (2023) developed a genipin-cross-linked carboxymethyl chitosan-gelatin hydrogel delivering dimethyloxallyl glycine (DMOG) for improved wound healing. The study indicated enhanced cell migration and proliferation in vitro, and the co-loaded drug hydrogels significantly accelerated in vivo wound recovery.19 Jia et al. (2024) created a sodium alginate (SA) hydrogel with recombinant human collagen III (rhCol III) for site-specific, sustained release of extracellular vehicles (EVs). The rhCol III/SA-EVs hydrogel's antioxidant and anti-inflammatory properties aid in healing diabetic wounds, characterized by hyper-inflammation and high oxidative stress. This multifunctional hydrogel offers sustained EV release for multimodal wound healing therapy in diabetic mice.20 Sellappan & Manoharan (2024) developed an antibacterial wound dressing using C. roseus leaf extract and M. recutita chamomile flower, incorporating green synthesized ZnO into keratin and alginate based dressings. The biopolymeric mats exhibited better mechanical, thermal, and hydrophilic properties, and allowed oxygen and water vapor permeability, promoting cell–material interactions. The mat also showed potent antibacterial activity against E. coli and B. subtilis.21 Similarly, phloretin and γ-cyclodextrin complex-incorporated polycaprolactone and silk protein nanofiber wound dressings displayed antibacterial activity against S. aureus, antioxidant capacity, blood compatibility, improved cell viability,22 and suitable physical and chemical properties for promoting diabetic wound healing and reducing bacterial infections.
Sr. no. | Feature | Protein-based wound care materials | Synthetic polymer-based materials | Ref. |
---|---|---|---|---|
1 | Biocompatibility | Highly biocompatible, composed of natural materials like keratin, silk, and collagen, which lowers the possibility of allergic responses | Exhibit reduced biocompatibility, requiring alterations to minimize immune responses or inflammatory reactions | 25 |
2 | Healing promotion | Collagen and silk proteins, for example, actively stimulate tissue regeneration to improve wound healing | Provide defensive barriers and inactive support, they lack the ability to promote active healing processes | 26 |
3 | Biodegradability | Biodegradable and readily absorbed by the body | Non-biodegradable or degrading slowly | 27 |
4 | Moisture Regulation | Maintain optimal moisture levels | Certain materials can hold water, they often need extra processing to replicate the conditions found in natural wounds | 28 |
5 | Mechanical Properties | Exhibiting exceptional elasticity and durability | Potentially possesses increased stiffness or necessitates substantial alterations to align with the mechanical characteristics of biological tissues | 29 |
6 | Antimicrobial properties | Some proteins possess inherent antimicrobial properties (e.g., keratin), reducing infection risk | Do not possess innate antimicrobial properties; they require special coatings or substances to achieve such properties | 30 31 |
7 | Cost and availability | Cost may be higher due to the use of natural ingredients, and the supply could be constrained by the availability of biological resources | Abundantly available, cost-effective and easy to scale up | 30 |
8 | Environmental impact | Eco-friendly, with minimal harmful environmental | Commonly synthesized from petroleum-based resources, leading to environmental issues | 31 |
9 | Customizability | Ability of modification is constrained by its biological nature, though enhancements can be achieved through techniques such as crosslinking or genetic manipulation | Offers extensive customization options; can be tailored and developed with characteristics | 32 |
10 | Risk of disease transmission | If not properly obtained and handled, there exists a slight, albeit possible, chance of transmitting diseases | While there is no danger of transmitting biological diseases, it may trigger reactions to foreign substances in the body | 29 |
11 | Adhesion to tissue | Superior adherence to tissues occurs through natural interactions with components of cells | Enhancing adhesion to biological tissues might necessitate the use of adhesives or modifications to the surface | 26 33 |
Despite abundant research on natural polymers and their potential for wound treatment, there is a lack of commercial natural polymer-based wound dressings in the market. The disconnect between academic research and commercial products creates a gap in the market where not all the capabilities of natural polymers are utilized to treat different types of wounds. Given the various forms of wounds, it is crucial to have access to a broad range of wound dressings with diverse compositions and structures. Natural polymer-based wound dressings often exhibit the ideal qualities for treating wounds, but the primary differences between them are cost and patient comfort.23
Proteins are a necessary component of almost all tissues and have been widely used in tissue repair. Proteins have good biocompatibility, low immunogenicity, and regulated disintegration.24 The advantages of protein-based biomaterials compensate for the limitations of traditional non-biogenic materials. The present review article aims to provide a comprehensive analysis of studies conducted within the past five years, which focus on protein transformation into wound care materials using various chemical methods, their different 7forms and various proteins that are used so far in the wound care applications aimed at accelerating the wound healing process. Additionally, this review delves into the attributes of keratin, collagen, gelatin, silk, zein and albumin derived material for wound care applications in great detail. Lastly, the review concludes by highlighting the limitations and challenges associated with using protein wound care materials.
Methods | Description | Advantages | Disadvantages | Examples |
---|---|---|---|---|
Electrospinning | Produces nano-scale fibers from protein solutions using electric field | High surface area, biocompatibility and fine nano-fibers | Limited control over fiber diameter and protein complexity | Zein, soy, pea proteins, casein and lactoferrin based materials |
Phase separation | Separates homogeneous solution into phases forming scaffolds or wound dressings | Simple, scalable, porous structures and favorable for cell growth | Limited control over pore size | Protein-based polymers and Coacervates |
Self-assembly | Spontaneous arrangement of molecules into ordered structures | Biodegradable, non-toxic, controllable size and biocompatibility | Complex design requirements | Gelatin-recombinant type III hydrogels, aneroin-based hydrogels and Fibronectin-based hydrogels |
Ball milling | Grinds materials into nanoparticles using stainless steel balls | High surface area, customizable size and suitable for drug delivery | Energy-intensive, potential contamination | Metal-based Nps and protein-based Nps (PBNps) |
Lactoferrin is a protein with a wide range of beneficial properties, including its ability to fight bacteria, reduce inflammation, and protect against oxidative damage.47 Researchers have found that it can be combined with materials like polycaprolactone (PCL), polyacetic acid (PLA), and gelatin using electrospinning.48 Moreover, lactoferrin can be applied to the affected area of the skin to prevent the growth of harmful bacteria.49,50
Certain aspects of proteins are considered in the process of phase separation; for example how they rearrange themselves during evaporation as its rate determines the pore size of the scaffold.55 During this process, depending on the length and amount of the proteins, two different structures can be formed i.e., clumps and small jelly-like globs known as coacervates. The coacervates possess special properties that change with the size of the protein. They act as good adsorbers and can support the wound healing process.56
Self-assembled hydrogels have diverse applications in wound healing such as hemostasis, infection prevention, and inflammation control.64 These materials are designed to deliver drugs, cytokines, or cells to the wound site, they degrade into bio-active peptides or natural amino acids for tissue repair.65 Advanced self-assembled materials enable spatio-temporal analysis throughout various healing stages, offering long-term, multi-modal treatments and regulating the wound microenvironment.66
Another method is freeze–thawing, which involves subjecting the protein to repeated cycles of freezing and thawing without chemical linkers. This process crystallizes the protein to a higher degree, forming a 3D hydrogel with enhanced elasticity and interconnections. Increasing the number of cycles leads to more crystalline regions in the hydrogels, resulting in a stiffer structure. Varshney and colleagues conducted a study where they employed the freeze–thaw method to design gels from soya protein isolates (SPI) and polyvinyl alcohol (PVA). They found that increasing the freezing time and number of cycles improved the mechanical properties of the gel. The interaction between the –COOH group of SPI and the –OH group of PVA resulted in a gel with improved biocompatibility, proliferation, and cell attachment.75
The layer-by-layer assembly offers another approach to creating protein-based nanoparticles for wound care. This process involves depositing oppositely charged polyelectrolytes onto a charged layer, which can be either a protein or a nanoparticle with the opposite charge. This technique allows for the design of protein-based nanomaterials with specific surface charges and controlled sizes, enabling features such as the regulated release of therapeutic agents or drugs.76,77
Zhou and coworkers developed a self-assembled bio-gel using SPI, polydopamine-reduced graphene oxide (PGO), and gallic acid (GA) in a dopamine-glycerol/water solvent through self-assembly.78 Similarly, researchers employed self-assembly to produce beta-conglycinin/bacterial cellulose (BC) and glycinin/BC membranes. These combinations stabilized soybean release, enhancing wound healing by reducing inflammation and promoting angiogenesis and collagen deposition. The glycinin /BC membrane demonstrated superior wound healing compared to beta-conglycinin /BC.79 Heating proteins unfolds molecules, revealing active sites and promoting aggregation through covalent and noncovalent bonds, forming a gel network at high concentrations. Chien et al. developed an injectable, biocompatible, and biodegradable SPI hydrogel dressing with sustained drug release, as confirmed by in vivo and in vitro analyses.80
Photopolymerization employs visible or ultraviolet light to initiate the polymerization reaction in the creation of photopolymerized hydrogels. The molecules become excited upon absorbing energy from UV or visible light, generating free radicals. These radicals then trigger the formation of unsaturated bonds in monomeric units, which subsequently undergo polymerization to form hydrogels. A study reported the hybrid hydrogels of SPI and silk fibroin (SF) by subjecting them to 50 W (LED) visible light for 2 minutes. The SPI hydrogel produced through photo cross-linking exhibited superior water resistance and mechanical strength compared to hydrogels obtained through conventional methods.83
This method improves protein solubility and distribution by altering the pH of the solution to a value considerably different from the protein's isoelectric point, causing the protein to unfold. The solution is then cast into a mold and dehydrated to form a film. The drying process can be expedited using ambient temperature, infrared radiation, or microwave energy.84. In a study by Zhao et al., a composite film was developed by blending hydroxypropyl chitosan (HPCS) and soy protein isolate (SPI). Utilizing the solution casting technique, they discovered that a 50% SPI content yielded a film with ideal cytocompatibility and hemocompatibility. This film demonstrated enhanced wound healing, accelerated skin regeneration, and notably improved granulation tissue formation and collagen deposition.85
An innovative injectable polypeptide-protein hydrogel was created for treating infected wounds by forming a porous structure through the coordination of thiolated BSA protein and thiolated polypeptide with Ag+ ions.95 The hydrogel demonstrated efficient gelation and self-healing properties, along with biological functions such as vascularization and antibacterial activity, due to the S–Ag coordination in the presence of Ag+ ions.97In vitro studies confirmed its role in the healing process, while in vivo experiments on infected mouse wounds revealed its antibacterial effect, wound healing, hair follicle formation, and angiogenesis. These findings highlight the hydrogel's potential in treating infected wounds.98
Scaffold construction employs diverse techniques which modify properties significantly. Despite the availability of various methods, developing scalable and cost-effective approaches for producing customized scaffolds in large quantities remains a continuous struggle.106,107 An ideal wound healing scaffold should possess appropriate physical and mechanical properties to prevent infections, promote cell adhesion and proliferation while absorbing fluids and maintaining a moist environment.108 Conventional materials, such as cotton pads, have limited fluid retention capacity.100 Therefore, the optimal scaffold should exhibit high absorbency, porosity, and the ability to retain fluids and swell effectively.109,110
Silk fibroin and chitin are combined to synthesize films with remarkable dimensional structure, which have applications in electronic and smart contact lenses.128 Plasticizers such as glycerol are added to replace water to increase the flexibility of silk fibroin films. It stabilizes the helical structures in the films.73 These films can be easily molded and adapted to fit any wound location on the upper skin of the body. Films that incorporate bitter vetch protein sourced from Vicia Ervilia display remarkable tensile strength when combined with a small amount of glycerol and the positively charged compound spermidine.129 Spermidine functions as a plasticizer, enhancing the flexibility and extensibility of the films. Additionally, these films exhibit improved barrier properties against gases and water vapor.73
Silk nanomaterials are ideal for repairing damaged corneal tissue due to their transparency, flexibility, and slow degradation.132 These nanoparticles can be functionalized with specific molecules to enhance cell attachment, growth, and corneal regeneration. Consequently, they are advantageous in optical surgeries and can expedite healing for individuals recovering from eye injuries or surgeries.124 These nanomaterials are similar to the extracellular matrix (ECM) in our bodies and help in repairing damaged blood vessels. They mainly deal with an inner layer of skin injuries which are sometimes not detectable by the naked eye. An interesting fact is that we can use them for a long time unless the wound heals and it does not affect the skin cells during the process.133 It safeguards the wound from external bacterial or viral infections. A 3D environment constructed with fibrin nanomaterials can encourage the growth of blood vessels by releasing various growth factors in pre-established settings. This facilitates the transformation of stem cells into muscle cells and accelerates the regeneration process.62 Another example of a material used in dental gums regeneration is silk fibroin nanoparticles (Nps). By combining these Nps with a sensor molecule called basic fibroblast growth factor (bFGF), the dental pulp stem cells can grow more effectively. This process can result in the formation of tissue that is similar to natural tissue and the development of blood vessels within the new tissue.134 A comparison of different forms of proteins derived materials for wound care applications is summarized in the Table 3.
Material | Properties | Advantages | Limitations |
---|---|---|---|
Hydrogels | Biodegradable, porous and moist support | Enhances wound healing and tissue regeneration | Limited mechanical strength |
Scaffolds | 3D structure, biocompatible and porous | Enhances tissue regeneration | Commercial scalability challenges |
Sponges | Porous, radial shape and promotes angiogenesis | Accelerates wound healing and blood vessel growth | Variable efficacy |
Films | Thin, flexible and biodegradable | Wound protection and drug delivery | Limited durability |
Protein-based nanoparticles (NPs) | High surface area and biocompatible | Enhances stem cell adhesion and bone regeneration | Potential toxicity |
The sequence of amino acids that form peptide bonds and bind together to form the basic structure of proteins interact to form a three-dimensional structure. Hydrophobic, electrostatic, and hydrogen bonds, as well as covalent bonds like disulfide bonds, are all present in protein interactions. Because proteins include a variety of functional groups that may change chemically, enzymatically, and physically, they can be designed for different uses. Protein-based biopolymers 3D structure and functional characteristics are closely linked. Foaming/emulsibility and fat binding ability are primarily influenced by hydrophilic–hydrophobic and hydrophobic interactions, respectively, whereas hydro-solubility, swelling capacity, and gelation capability are pertinent to hydrophilic interactions within the protein network.137
Since biopolymers have been used for years to heal wounds and illnesses, the use of protein based biomaterials in the biomedical field is not new. The advancement of methods to assess and classify protein materials as well as better extraction procedures from their sources have influenced trends in protein based biopolymers for medicinal applications. Biomedical applications often utilize non-immunogenic proteins to create nano/microfibers due to their exceptional fiber-forming properties, high nutritional value, relatively biocompatible polymers, and other advantages.138
The exceptional qualities and distinctive tunability of protein-based biomaterials remain intriguing as the biomedical industry turns its attention to smart materials. They may be made to react to a variety of stimuli, such as temperature changes, oxidative agents, pH changes, and even the presence of specific biomolecules. Additionally, protein based biomaterials provide a multitude of potential for the development of precisely engineered biomaterials since they can be made to self-assemble into a wide variety of forms, from porous architectures to nano-sized materials.139
Antibacterial, antifungal, and cytocompatible polysulfobetaine/keratin-based hydrogels incorporating chlorhexidine were reported through free radical polymerization of sulfobetaine and oxidative self-crosslinking of reduced keratin. These hydrogels exhibited release behaviors of acidity, glutathione, and trypsin, leading to the rapid release of chlorhexidine within the wound matrix. The hydrogels were transformed into powders (xerogels) and applied to wounds, where they reformed in situ by absorbing wound fluid. In vivo testing on infected wounds showed that the xerogel powder dressing reduced inflammation and promoted collagen deposition, resulting in accelerated wound closure. The study demonstrated that the prepared xerogel powder has great potential for promoting wound healing.147 A nanofibrous hydrogel composed of keratin and poly(L-lactate-caprolactone) (PLCL) copolymer, incorporating fibroblast growth factor (FGF-2), was developed using the low-pressure filtration-assisted method in one study. The hydrogel was designed to mimic the dermis, with keratin representing the dermis and PLCL replicating it. The hydrogel was highly porous, biodegradable, and biocompatible, and in vivo experiments demonstrated enhanced re-epithelialization, collagen deposition, hair follicle regeneration, and new blood vessel formation. Moreover, the incorporation of FGF-2 resulted in a superior wound-healing effect as exhibited in. Fig. 1. The study provided an in-depth explanation of the role and mechanism of the bilayer hydrogel dressing in wound healing and resolved the issue of poor interface adhesion of electrospinning nanofibers.148
Fig. 1 In vivo studies of wound healing process. (A) Representative photographs of wound tissues in different groups on days 0, 3, 7, 11, and 14. (B) Traces of wound-bed closure in three groups during 14-day observation. (C) Wound healing rate of samples in different groups. Reproduced from ref. 148 with permission from Elsevier, copyright 2023. |
According to Demir et al., both xanthan/gelatin and keratin/xanthan/gelatin hydrogel dressings with exceptional fluid absorption capacity have been developed for the local delivery of vitamin C. The xanthan/gelatin hydrogels were prepared through crosslinking with varying concentrations of glycerol. The addition of keratin with the xanthan/gelatin/glycerol (1:1:2) hydrogel, improved its mechanical properties, collagen synthesis, and viability of L929 fibroblasts, as well as the release of protein. Both xanthan/gelatin and keratin/xanthan/gelatin hydrogels containing vitamin C exhibited excellent water absorption capabilities, making them suitable for exudate wounds. All the synthesized hydrogels tested inhibited bacterial growth, indicating that both xanthan/gelatin and keratin/xanthan/gelatin hydrogels incorporating vitamin C can be utilized as wound dressing materials.149
Kaviyashri and colleagues examined the potential of keratin, activated carbon, and aqueous garlic extract as components of wound dressings. The study revealed that activated carbon exhibited effective adsorption of keratin due to its numerous pores, making it a suitable carrier. The presence of 5% to 10% garlic extract was found to inhibit bacterial growth effectively. Based on these findings, the study concluded that these components could be optimized and combined to design an ideal dressing material for wound repair.150 On the other hand, carboxymethyl cellulose (CMC) was used by Sadeghi and coworkers to develop novel antibacterial sponge-type dressings using keratin, derived from human hair, for the topical delivery system for clindamycin. In addition, the researchers incorporated halloysite nanotubes to facilitate the sustained release of the antibiotic. The addition of larger amounts of keratin to CMC hydrogels resulted in improved water stability, slower clindamycin release, enhanced antibacterial activity, and increased cell attachment and proliferation, although it did not significantly affect water vapor transmission rate.151 In another study, Yao et al. reported a bilayer wound dressing that consisted of a gelatin/keratin nanofibrous mat as the inner layer and a commercial polyurethane dressing as the outer layer. Scanning electron microscope (SEM) analysis revealed a uniform morphology without beads and with an average fiber diameter of 160.4 nm. In vitro analysis using L929 fibroblast cells showed that the gelatin/keratin nanofibrous mat promoted cell attachment and proliferation. Furthermore, the gelatin/keratin/polyurethane bilayer wound dressing demonstrated a better healing response by producing more blood vessels and reducing the wound area at 4 and 14 days compared to the bilayer membrane without keratin, gauze, and the commercial wound dressing (Comfeel),152 as depicted in Fig. 2.
Fig. 2 In vivo study of healed wounds. (a) Macroscopic appearance of the wounds after treatment with the gelatin/keratin/commercial polyurethane (GKU) membrane, gelatin/keratin (GU) membrane, gauze and Comfeel® on the fourth, seventh and fourteenth postoperative days. (b) Wound closure with the healing time (4, 7 and 14 days). Reproduced from ref. 152 with permission from Elsevier, copyright 2017. |
Keratin from chicken feathers was also utilized to synthesize three types of nonwoven dressings, including pure keratin, keratin-sodium alginate, and keratin-chitosan compositions. These dressings were analyzed using FTIR and SEM, and their physical properties, such as thickness, air permeability, and areal density, indicated their potential use as wound dressings. The keratin-sodium alginate and keratin-chitosan dressings exhibited antibacterial activity against both Gram-negative and Gram-positive bacterial strains, with inhibition zones greater than 2.0 cm. Further investigation of these dressings’ potential was assessed through cytotoxicity, cell viability, and in vivo studies on Albino Wistar rats. The results revealed that the prepared materials were non-toxic and provided good support for cell viability. Wound dressings composed of keratin-chitosan and keratin-sodium alginate exhibited complete wound healing in rat models within 15, 17, 21, and 23 days, respectively. In contrast, dressings made solely of keratin proved to be less efficient in promoting wound closure.153
Material shape | Composition | Active ingredients | Method of fabrication | Animal Tested | Wound size | Healing time | Notable findings | Ref. |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
N.A: not available. | ||||||||
Fibrous scaffolds | PCL, gelatin, ε-polylysine | — | Fused deposition modeling and electrospinning | S. aureus, P. aeruginosa, E. coli | N. A | N. A | Antibacterial, skin cell toxicity | 162 |
Hydrogels | Xanthan, gelatin, keratin | Vitamin C | Crosslinking with glycerol | N.A | N. A | N. A | Biocompatible, sustained release up to 100 hours, good mechanical properties | 149 |
Bilayer sponge/nanofibers | Gelatin, carrageenan | Fibrin | Cross-linking of gelatin with sodium tripolyphosphate, solution casting, electrospinning | Male Wister rats | 10 mm | 14 days | Tensile strength increased by addition of carrageenan/fibrin layer, adhesion and proliferation of L929 cells, angiogenic potential | 163 |
Hydrogels | Gelatin, dimethyl aminoethyl methacrylate | — | Chemical and physical cross-linking | Wister rats | — | 21 days | Mechanical strength improved by cross-linking, biodegradable, non-toxic | 164 |
Hydrogels | Gelatin, oxidized chondroitin sulfate | Curcumin loaded chitosan nanoparticles | Freeze drying | — | — | — | Non-toxic, In vitro Curcumin stable release | 165 |
Electrospun membranes | Poly(L-lactide-co-glycolide)/gelatin | Zinc oxide nanoparticles | Electrospinning | Rat | 10 mm | 14 days | Cytocompatible, hemostatic, antibacterial | 166 |
Nanocomposite hydrogels | Modified gelatin/iron | Camellia sinensis extract | Metal organic framework (MOF) | B. serous, S. aureus, S. mutans, P. aeruginosa, E. coli, K. pneumoniae | — | — | Antibacterial, sustained release, adding MOF increased water absorption | 167 |
Hydrogels | Modified hyaluronate, gelatin | Doxycycline | Crosslinking by boronate ester and encapsulation of doxycycline | Rats | 20 mm burn wound | 14 days | Antibacterial, bioadhesive, injectable, biocompatible | 168 |
Film | Carboxymethyl chitosan-gelatin- | mesoporous silica nanoparticles containing Myrtus communis L. extract | — | Mice | 7 mm | 6 to 12 days | Antioxidant, increased tensile strength by adding nanoparticles, reduced cytotoxicity, reduced drug release | 169 |
Film | Gelatin/Persian gum/bacterial nanocellulose | Frankincense essential oil and Teucrium polium extract | Solution casting | S. aureus, P. aeruginosa, E. coli, A. baumannii | — | — | Better anti-inflammatory and antibacterial activity, biocompatible | 170 |
To tackle the challenge of rapid degradation and poor adhesion in gelatin-based traditional dressings in fluid environments, Lin and colleagues developed more adhesive dressings using gelatin, silica, and 3-glycidoxypropyltrimethoxysilane as a coupling agent. By employing the sol–gel method to create hydrogels, the stability of the structure was enhanced through the formation of covalent bonds between gelatin and silica, as a result of the coupling reaction. Moreover, dopamine was added to further increase adhesiveness. The study showed that these hybrid dressings were 2.5 times more adhesive to soft tissues than pure gelatin in humid conditions. In vitro and in vivo tests also revealed their superior healing capabilities as exhibited in Fig. 3.158
Fig. 3 (a) In vivo skin wound healing assessment. Untreated (control), gelatin, gelatin-silica hybrid (G-H) and gelatin-silica-dopamine (G-H-D) samples were applied to a 2 cm diameter round wound created using a surgical scalpel for wound recovery observation over different time periods (b) the wound recovery trend was calculated based on the changes in wound area observed in (a) Reproduced from ref. 158 with permission from Elsevier, copyright 2024. |
Developing wound dressings that can effectively control rapid bleeding during accidents and surgeries is a significant challenge. Li and his team developed effective sponges for wounds based on methacrylated gelatin-dopamine, quaternized chitosan, and glycerol to control rapid bleeding. The results demonstrated that these composite sponges were biocompatible, could absorb water, displayed good self-adhesion properties, and exhibited better antibacterial activity compared to commercial gelatin and chitosan dressings. Animal studies conducted on rat tail and liver bleeding models showed that the hemostasis time and blood loss in these prepared dressings were better than those of commercial gelatin and chitosan dressings. Therefore, these dressings/sponges have significant potential to be employed as hemostatic agents for surgeries and emergency accident treatments.159 Khan et al., have developed a multilayer nanofibrous wound dressing using electrospinning, chemical functionalization, and electrospray techniques with a layer-by-layer method. The dressing comprises a coating of diethylenetriamine-functionalized polyacrylonitrile TiO2 nanoparticles and a bioderived gelatin layer. It includes an outer layer that acts as a barrier against pathogens, an interlayer that kills microbes, and a contact layer for improved biocompatibility and cell viability. The nanofibrous membranes demonstrated antibacterial properties, and showed better cell morphology, proliferation, and viability in comparison to 3T3 (3-day transfer) fibroblasts (Fig. 4), making them suitable for wound healing applications.160
Fig. 4 Fibroblast (3T3) cell morphology on the various NFs membrane scaffolds at 24, 48 and 72 h. Reproduced from ref. 160 with permission from Elsevier, copyright 2023. |
In response to the growing need for plant derived antibiotic alternatives, Vanani et al. have developed antibacterial core–shell nanofibers as wound healing scaffolds to evaluate their synergistic effect. The scaffolds were composed of PVA/gelatin/thymus essential oil as the core and PVA/gelatin/licorice extract as the shell. The nanofibers were found to be free of beads, smooth, and had an average diameter of 119 nm. The addition of essential oil and licorice extract increased the diameter of the nanofibers. The nanofibrous scaffolds exhibited antibacterial properties, were non-hemolytic, and promoted the viability and proliferation of L929 fibroblasts, (Fig. 5) showing them as potential candidates for use as wound dressings.17
Fig. 5 Wound healing micrographs and fibroblast migration into the scratch area after one- and two-days cell culture on the nanofibrous scaffolds. Reproduced from ref. 17 with permission from Elsevier, copyright 2017. |
Chronic wound healing is often hindered by infections, creating a need for wound dressings that can release antibacterial and antioxidant substances. These advanced dressings are highly sought after due to their potential to combat infection-related complications in the healing process. Lv and his team have developed nanofibrous membranes composed of polycaprolactone (PCL) and gelatin, incorporating varying ratios of curcumin and borneol using the electrospinning technique. The resulting membranes demonstrated excellent water absorption capabilities, improved mechanical properties, and enhanced dissolution of curcumin. Additionally, the membranes were shown to exhibit antibacterial and antioxidant properties, while also demonstrating biocompatibility. These features, combined with the use of biodegradable polymers, an eco-friendly production method, and promising results in living organisms, indicate the potential for large-scale production.161
Material shape | Composition | Active ingredients | Method of fabrication | Animal tested | Wound size | Healing time | Notable findings | Ref. |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
N.A: not available. | ||||||||
Hydrogel | Collagen, xanthum gum | Ketorolac, methylene blue, dexamethasone and quinic acid | Interaction of functional groups | Fibroblast cells | N. A | N. A | Controlled release of ketorolac and methylene blue | 200 |
Hydrogels | Collagen-polyurethane-alginate | Ketorolac | Electrostatic interaction | E. coli, In vitro wound healing on fibroblast cells, anti-cancer activity on colon and breast cancerous cells | N. A | N. A | Proliferation of fibroblast and monocytes, anti-cancer activity against breast and colon cancer, anti-bacterial activity against E. coli | 201 |
Vesicles | Peptides [CLP (G8): (GPO)8GG or (GPO)8GC and ELP (F6): (VPGFG)6G′] | Vancomycin | Vancomysin encapsulation in prepared vesicles and in liposome | Methicillin-resistant Staphylococcus aureus | — | — | Sustained release and higher % encapsulation compared to liposomal version Novel antibiotic delivery system | 202 |
Infuse | Recombinant human bone morphogenetic protein-2 (rhBMP-2) on an absorbable collagen sponge (ACS) | rhBMP-2 | rhBMP-2 absorbed on ACS | Non-human primates | — | — | Osteoinductive autograft replacement | 203 |
Hydrogels | Collagen | Gallic acid and naproxen Metal nanoparticles | Through polymerization and cross linking | — | — | — | Potential drug delivery agents, anti-microbial hydrogel films Higher encapsulation and release of drugs | 204 |
Scaffold | Collagen-chondroitin sulfate scaffold | Stromal derived factor-1 alpha (SDF-1α] | Dehydrothermal treatment | Human umbilical vein endothelial cells | — | — | Enhanced pro angionic response for wound healing | 205 |
Scaffold | Collagen/heparin bi-affinity multilayer delivery system (CHBMDS) | CBD-bFGF (a collagen-binding domain (CBD)) | Specific or electrostatic interaction | SD rat | — | 5 weeks | Sustained and localized release of CBD-bFGF Enhanced angiogenesis | 206 |
Nanofiber | Collagen and chitosan | Curcumin | Electrospinning | Escherichia coli Pseudomonas aeruginosa, and Staphylococcus aureus | — | — | Sustained release of curcumin up to 72 hours, tend to be potential patches for wound healing | 207 |
Hydrogel | Collagen and chitosan | Cross linked by dialdehyde starch | Mixing different ratios | — | — | — | Characterized as potential biocompatible wound dressing | 208 |
Hydrogel | Human like collagen and chitosan | Crosslinked via dialdehyde starch | Mixing in different ratios | In vitro and In vivo Model (post injection) | — | 1, 9, 12 and 28 weeks | Reduces inflammation, can be potential skin patch scaffolds, wrinkle treatments, and tissue cavity fillers | 209 |
Collagen is mixed with natural and synthetic polymers, including alginate, chitosan, hyaluronic acid, elastin, polyethylene oxide and silk fibroin, etc., to develop collagen based wound dressings.181–183 These modified fabrics have also additives such as antibiotics,184 insulin,185 or gold nanoparticles186,187 and have primarily been studied in small animal wound healing models or in vitro investigations. Although initial findings are promising, a comprehensive evaluation of the effectiveness of antibacterial wound dressings for clinical diabetic foot ulcers remains inconclusive. To establish the true efficacy of this treatment, more extensive and rigorous clinical studies are necessary.
In scaffolds and matrices, collagen is applied as a surface coating to maintain a moist environment and enhance cell adhesion.188 Water retention is essential for preserving moisture in the wound bed. In vitro studies on collagen have demonstrated that the arginine-glycine-aspartic acid (RGD) sequences interact with cell integrins, promoting the attachment and movement of fibroblasts and keratinocytes. In recent years, there has been growing interest in collagen nanostructures. A relatively new material has emerged, consisting of collagen reduced to nanoparticulate dimensions. This nanoscale form provides an enhanced surface area to volume ratio. A key advantage of these nano-collagens is their ability to be delivered to specific targets using a material that is biocompatible with the microenvironment of wounds.189,190 One constraint is the lack of understanding and investigation into these nanoparticles, necessitating more in-depth study. A recent pilot study using Porcine derived hydrolyzed collagen (PDHC) to treat chronic ulcers of various causes revealed that the product was safe to use and sped up the healing process.191 The large-scale production of recombinant human collagens from non-animal sources may face challenges due to the potential requirement for post-translational proline hydroxylation. Following the identification of collagen-like proteins (Scl1 and Scl2) in Streptococcus pyogenes, researchers developed constructs in a recombinant E. coli system to explore large-scale production methods. Utilizing bacterial collagens provides a synthetic approach to creating non-animal collagen without specific bioactivity, allowing for customized interactions. An experiment using human mesenchymal stem cells demonstrated this system's potential for chondrogenesis.192 Research findings indicate that recombinant human collagen shows promise as a future wound healing agent.
Shields of collagen were synthesized as corneal bandages to aid in the healing of wounds following radial keratomy, corneal transplantation, keratorefractive surgery, and epithelial debridement procedures. When applied to the eye, the thin collagen films take on the shape of the cornea, allow for adequate oxygen transmission to support corneal metabolism, and function as temporary bandages. When the shields dissolve, a layer of collagen solution is left behind that appears to lubricate the eye's surface, reduce rubbing of the lids against the cornea, and promote epithelial healing.193–196 Li Zhiye and colleagues recently reported a study on phycocyanin-loaded hydrogels made from collagen, chitosan, and genipin. The study evaluated the biocompatibility and cell migration potential of these hydrogels in vitro. A gel containing collagen/chitosan (25:75) demonstrated the best performance in promoting cell migration. Subsequent in vivo studies confirmed these results, establishing nanocomposite hydrogel as the most effective formulation for promoting diabetic wound healing through increased cell migration and reduced MMP-9 expression.197 Malathi and coworkers studied about the use of collagen-based zinc oxide nanoparticles (ZnO NPs) for wound healing. Their study proved that the developed nanocomposite enhanced the rate of wound healing to a high level. These innovative bio-nanocomposites possess several advantageous properties including strong antibacterial properties, non-toxicity, short, adjustable, economical, and large-scale fabrication process.198 Recently, researchers developed a novel wound dressing made from a blend of fish collagen, oxidized sodium alginate derived from seaweed, borax (a boron compound), and polyvinyl alcohol (a plastic-like material). This dressing is designed to effectively heal deep wounds. The fish-skin collagen-based dressing is self-healing, injectable, adheres to various surfaces, and degrades naturally in the body. In experiments involving mice, the dressing demonstrated superior performance compared to traditional gauze, rapidly stopping bleeding and accelerating wound healing by stimulating skin cell growth, collagen production, and new blood vessel formation.199
Tatlisulu et al. (2024) explored the use of honeybee silk (HS) as an alternative to silkworm silk in tissue engineering (TE) applications. Their research revealed the potential of HS, a previously unexplored material, for TE purposes, paving the way for new research directions. The study findings, based on the materials employed and the favorable results obtained, indicate that the developed CH-HS scaffold displays antibacterial qualities and exhibits cellular characteristics. These discoveries hold promise for additional biomedical applications, particularly in the realm of wound healing.215 In another study, a natural hydrogel composed of silk fibroin (SF) and soybean protein isolate (SPI) was prepared using the main components. To enhance the bioactivity of the hydrogel, quercetin was incorporated to create an SF/SPI-Q hydrogel. The resulting hydrogel was effective in accelerating wound healing in an infected burn wound model as shown in Fig. 6. The SF/SPI-Q hydrogels promoted the re-epithelialization process, collagen synthesis, and neovascularization in burn wounds. Additionally, they exhibited anti-inflammatory effects that further helped reduce inflammation. Therefore, the SF/SPI-Q hydrogels have the potential to be one of the most effective treatments for wound healing.82
Fig. 6 (A) Effect of different treatments on chorioallantoic membrane (CAM)-trypan blue stained assay CAM. A−: negative control (0.9% NaCl solution); A+: positive control (0.1 M NaOH). (B) The amount of trypan blue adsorbed on CAM after different treatments. (C) Hemolysis ratio of quercetin, silk fibroin (SF)/soybean protein isolate (SPI), SF/SPI-quercetin (Q) 10%, SF/SPI-Q 20% and SF/SPI-Q 30% hydrogels; A−: negative control (0.9% NaCl solution); A+: positive control (H2O). Reproduced from ref. 82 with permission from Elsevier, copyright 2024. |
A study was conducted by Shuiqing and their colleagues to construct a scaffold using silk fibroin nanofibers films (SNF) to promote wound healing and prevent scar formation. The scaffold was engineered to resemble the extracellular matrix of the skin, and the resulting silk film exhibited greater mechanical strength and hydrophobicity, protecting the wound and dermis from external stimuli. Additionally, the scaffold displayed improved water uptake, which facilitated moisture retention at the wound site. This feature, along with the scaffold's resemblance to the components of normal epidermis and dermis, inhibited scar formation. In vitro and in vivo studies confirmed the scaffold's effectiveness in promoting tissue regeneration and preventing scar formation216 as exhibited in Fig. 7.
Fig. 7 Observations of wound healing and scarring in the rabbit ear, after treatment with different artificial grafts. (A) Scheme of scaffold application in a rabbit ear wound model, (B) wound changes, including control (untreated), SNF films, and SNF-silk fibroin (SF)-hyaluronic acid (HA) scaffold, (C) wound closure time, (D) scar elevation index. Reproduced from ref. 216 with permission from Elsevier, copyright 2024. |
Silk sericin based hydrogels with plant extracts were synthesized by Zahoor and coworkers. They studied their efficacy in promoting wound healing in mice with alloxan-induced diabetes. Researchers produced 6 mm excision wounds and then applied topical hydrogel treatments. Results indicated that all hydrogel-treated groups showed significantly higher wound contraction from day 3 to day 11 compared to the negative control, with the 4% sericin + 4% banyan + 4% onion hydrogel performing best as shown in Fig. 8. Serum levels of anti-inflammatory cytokine Interleukin-10 and tissue inhibitor metalloproteinase (TIMP) were significantly higher in the hydrogel groups, while pro-inflammatory cytokines tumour necrosis factor-α and Interleukin-6, and matrix metalloproteinases MMP (matrix metalloproteinases)-2 and MMP-9, were significantly lower.217 Silk fibroin hydrogels show potential as burn wound dressings due to their regenerative properties, but difficult gelation conditions limit their clinical application. Sushma Indrakumar and his colleagues employed a white light-responsive photopolymerization technique for gelation through tyrosine photooxidation. A silk fibroin gel-incorporated dressing (SFD) was developed to fit irregular burn surfaces. The mild gelation conditions enabled drug incorporation for localized delivery. The dressing demonstrated favourable swelling capacity and moisture retention. In vitro, cytocompatibility was assessed using HaCaT cells, and in vivo performance was evaluated on a rodent model with a second-degree burn, showing scarless healing in SFD-treated groups via gross and histological analyses. The SFD developed in this study shows promise as an advanced burn wound care solution.218
Fig. 8 Wound healing area at different post-wounding days in mice of (A) negative control; (B) positive control; (C) sericin based treatment group; (D) sericin + banyan based treatment group; (E) sericin + onion based treatment group and (F) sericin + banyan + onion based treatment group. Reproduced from ref. 217 with permission from Elsevier, copyright 2023. |
A study revealed that sericin, a bio-waste product derived from the degumming of silk cocoons, effectively exfoliates the MoS2 layers, resulting in improved dispersity and stability of MoS2 nanosheets (MoS2-NSs). MoS2-NS/Sericin maintains its photothermal properties when illuminated by an 808 nm light source, exhibits strong antibacterial activity, and accelerates wound healing by promoting fibroblast migration. In vitro experiments have shown that MoS2-NS/Sericin scavenges reactive oxygen species (ROS) during the inflammatory stage of wound healing and transforms M1-type macrophages into M2-type, which supports recovery. Full-thickness skin wound tests conducted on rats demonstrated that MoS2/Sericin, under 808 nm irradiation, optimally promotes wound healing. Consequently, MoS2-NS/Sericin holds significant potential for treating bacteria-infected wounds.219
Regenerated silk, derived from protein extracted from Bombyx mori silkworm cocoons, exhibits numerous desirable properties. These include high transparency, compatibility with biological systems, ability to degrade naturally, and suitability for modification with optically active nanoparticles and biochemical markers. Its porous structure facilitates the transfer of nutrients and oxygen while also providing protection against bacterial infections in wounds, making it an ideal material for wound dressing applications. Various chemical and physical cues can enhance the bioactivity of silk fibroin (SF) wound matrices, simultaneously optimizing these cues is challenging due to their complex interactions during the fabrication process.220–222 A recent study explored a biodegradable silk-curcumin composite for extended drug release in wound treatment. The study found that curcumin integrated into the silk surface exhibited sustained release for 10 days, significantly outperforming traditional wound care drug delivery systems. The silk's superhydrophobic nature prevented wound wetting, while its pH sensitivity allowed for visual monitoring of wound healing progress.223 Another study utilized β-Sheet β-rich silk nanofiber (BSNFs) and amorphous silk nanofibers to create bioactive matrices with various cues optimized through aqueous media self-assembly.224,225 Additionally, BSNFs were employed to develop an anisotropic gel under electric field influence. Nerve growth factors (NGF) were immobilized within this hydrogel to fabricate bioactive systems, providing multiple physical and biological cues for addressing spinal cord injuries.226 Similarly, researchers designed a silk fibroin-based matrix with adjusted hierarchical microstructures and introduced various physical cues. An anisotropic porous scaffold was created using silk fibroin nanofibers under an electric field. This engineered nanomaterial demonstrated improved cell migration, leading to more effective wound healing.227 The incorporation of Desferrioxamine (DFO) into a silk nanofiber hydrogel, demonstrated prolonged drug release over a 40-day period. Both in vitro and in vivo analyses revealed improved endothelial cell migration and gene expression, along with a decrease in inflammatory macrophages.228 In a similar study, Sang and colleagues developed scaffolds with a microstructure resembling the extracellular matrix, using amorphous silk fibroin. These scaffolds showed potential for tissue repair and regenerative medicine applications.228 Gang and coworkers engineered scaffolds using β-sheet rich silk nanofiber infused with deferoxamine. They combined deferoxamine-loaded BSNF with amorphous silk nanofibers (ASNFs) under an electric field to create a uniform mixture. This novel scaffold exhibited enhanced wound healing efficacy in both in vitro and in vivo.229
Bari et al. investigated silk sericin (SS) microparticles for non-surgical intervertebral disk degeneration treatment, enhancing SS with growth factors, platelet lysate (PL), and platelet-poor plasma (PPP). Spray-drying produced smooth microparticles, and the PL and PPP combination promoted nucleus pulposus cell growth. SS microparticles, with or without PPP, exhibited antioxidant properties by reducing reactive oxygen species (ROS). Co-incubating SS microparticles with PL protected nucleus pulposus cells from hydrogen peroxide-induced oxidative stress. This indicates that SS microparticles with PL + PPP are promising for non-invasive drug delivery in regenerative medicine and wound treatment.230 Karaly et al. developed an aerosolized nano-powder using Avicenna marina extract and neomycin-loaded SF nanoparticles for wound healing. The extract exhibited antioxidant, antibacterial, and cell proliferation properties, effectively combating various bacterial strains. In vitro and in vivo studies demonstrated superior wound healing, achieving complete closure within 24 hours in fibroblast scratch assays and enhancing fibroblast proliferation while reducing inflammation in rodent models, suggesting its potential for wound healing applications.231
Material | Composition | Active ingredient | Method | Animal tested | Wound size | Healing time | Notable findings | Ref. |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
N.A: not available. | ||||||||
Hydrogel | Pectin | Doxorubicin | Liquid–liquid dispersion method | N/A | N. A | N. A | Controlled release of Doxorubicin | 248 |
Zein solution | Propylene glycol alginate | Curcumin | Hydrogen bonding | — | N. A | N. A | Sustained release of curcumin | 249 |
Zein solution | Polyacrylate, glycerin | β-Carotene | Hydrogen bonding, hydrophobic interactions | Female Sprague-Dawley rats | — | 21 days | Promotion of wound healing and collagen synthesis | 250 |
Zein nanoparticles | Glycerin | Quercetin | Electrostatic interactions | N/A | — | N/A | Delivery and controlled release Higher % encapsulation efficiency | 251 |
Emulsion gel | Sodium alginate | Curcumin and resveratrol | Electrospinning | — | — | — | Encapsulation of nutrients | 252 |
Membrane nanoparticles | Oleic acid, pectin | 253— | Solvent evaporation | — | — | — | The viscous behavior of pectin was changed | 253 |
Nanoparticles | Chitosan-polyvinyl alcohol, Fe3+ | Gentamicin | Liquid–liquid dispersion method, imine bond | E. coli (K12) and S. aureus (ATCC 96) | — | — | Synergistic antibacterial effect, against drug-resistant bacteria. | 254 |
Nanofilm | Zein prolamine, tea carbon spot, CaO2 | Ir-Zein protien | Electrospinning | Male Sprague-Dawley (SD) rats | 15 mm | 10 days | A versatile antibacterial wound dressing, promoted diabetic wound healing | 243 |
Zein nanofiber | Zein/CeNP1%, 3%, and 5% NFs | Cerium oxide nanoparticles | Electrospinning | E. coli, Pseudomonas aeruginosa, and Staphylococcus aureus | — | — | Significant mechanical, antioxidant, and cytotoxicity properties | 255 |
Nanofiber | Zein protein and tungsten oxide | Tungsten oxide | Electrospinning | Melanoma cell lines | — | — | Promising and safe candidate for anticancer applications | 256 |
Using phase separation methodology, Lu et al. developed ivermectin (IVM)-loaded zein microspheres with an average diameter of 1 μm. The researchers proposed these zein microspheres as potential nanocarriers, noting that their dimensions were suitable for macrophage uptake. The study concluded that the sustained-release properties of zein microspheres could be beneficial in creating scaffolds that promote cell growth and tissue engineering. Zein-based composites have diverse applications, including drug delivery systems, tissue engineering, bone reconstruction, and wound repair.237 In a related investigation on biomimetic mineralization, Yao et al. conducted a study where hydroxyapatite (HA) nanocrystals were formed on zein fibers produced through electrospinning. The researchers reported that the HA crystals were irregularly dispersed on the nanofibers, and these biomineralized structures had a beneficial effect on osteoblast proliferation. Additionally, Zhang et al. explored the formation of calcium phosphate using zein as a template and examined the process of biomineralization at the interface between air and concentrated simulated body fluid (SBF).238 Studies have shown that applying a continuous calcium phosphate layer to pure zein film enhances its mechanical properties, including hardness and modulus. Additionally, research indicates that zein films with biomineralization are excellent for supporting fibroblast cell attachment, multiplication (Fig. 9), and development, owing to their water-attracting nature and mechanical characteristics. These films also have potential applications as a biometric scaffold in bone tissue regeneration.
Fig. 9 Fluorescence micrographs of the fibroblast cells that were cultured for 7 days on (a) the pure zein film and zein/minerals films biomimetic mineralized for (b) 0.5 h, (c) 1 h, and (d) 2 h. Reproduced from ref. 238 with permission from the American Chemical Society, copyright 2013. |
Studies on zein composites have explored combining zein with other substances to enhance matrix properties. Zhang et al. used zein as an additive to impart antibacterial qualities, creating a zein protein composite by mixing it with silver nanoparticles. They found no significant difference in the effects on Escherichia coli and Staphylococcus aureus between silver nanoparticle composites and silver alone. However, silver samples with acidified zein showed superior bacterial inhibition. The study suggested that zein improves hemocompatibility and broadens wound care applications. To avoid potential toxicity, the silver content in the composite must be optimized.239
Agnes Gagliardi and colleagues developed a biocompatible, eco-friendly gel composed of zein loaded with rutin. They assessed its efficacy in vitro and in vivo for treating burns and sores compared to DuoDERM®. The gel showed improved migration and rapid gap closure within 24 hours in vitro, and a 90% reduction in wound area within 10 days in vivo in Wistar rats, outperforming both the free form and standard gel. Additionally, the gel significantly reduced inflammatory markers like TNF-α, IL-1β, IL-6, and IL-10.240 Similarly, Momgain et al. developed zein nanoparticles incorporating Moringa oleifera leaf extracts via nanoprecipitation for wound treatment. They optimized the formulation, prepared a gel, and characterized it for pH, spreadability, extrudability, and homogeneity. Testing in an animal model demonstrated significant wound healing activity. The study suggested Moringa oleifera leaves as a superior intervention for wound healing over other oral or topical extracts, indicating zein-loaded Moringa oleifera extract's potential as a diabetic wound healing agent.241
A study conducted by Gabriela et al. utilized electrospinning to prepare zein nanofibers reinforced with graphene oxide, enhancing their mechanical properties. The team incorporated various concentrations of curcumin into these GO-strengthened nanofibers to boost bioavailability, adhesion, and oxygenation. In vitro testing of this curcumin-loaded GO-Zein nanofiber composite showed improved safety, with evidence of cell growth throughout the fiber structure. The engineered nanofibers displayed a biphasic release pattern in vitro, suggesting cell proliferation. However, the effectiveness of these nanofibers in living organisms remains to be investigated.242 Lenian Zhou and colleagues developed zein proteins with hydrophilic and hydrophobic properties, loaded with CaO2/carbon dots (CD), for improved healing of diabetic wounds. The modified zein film with irradiated (Ir-Zein) calcium oxide nanoparticles and carbon dots used as a wound dressing demonstrated remarkable effectiveness in accelerating the healing of diabetic wounds. The study demonstrated the effectiveness of the CaO2/CD@Ir-Zein film in enhancing the progression of chronic wounds from the inflammatory stage to skin repair243 as shown in Fig. 10.
Fig. 10 In vivo assessment of CaO2/CD@Ir-Zein for diabetic wound healing in rat. (A) The representative images of full-thickness skin wounds after treatment with control, Ir-Zein, CD@Ir-Zein, and CaO2/CD@Ir-Zein. (B) Change of wound closure percentages with time. (C) H&E staining of the wound on day 10. (D) Quantitative analysis of scar widths in re-epithelialization. (E) Masson's trichrome staining of tissue regeneration within the wound on day 10. (F) Quantitative analysis of mean intensity. Reproduced from ref. 243 with permission from Elsevier, copyright 2024. |
Nasrin Salehi and colleagues developed curcumin-loaded zein nanofibers as a wound dressing with poly(sodium 4-styrene sulfonate) serving as a polyanion and poly(diallyldimethylammonium chloride) (PDADMAC) acting as a polycation, using electrospun nanofibers. The designed nanofiber facilitated the controlled release of curcumin, which exhibited antioxidant activity, and the PDADMAC demonstrated antibacterial properties. The nanofiber also exhibited better cell migration and adhesion, and cell attachment.244
Moiz Uddin Khan and his fellow researchers developed an innovative invasive thermo-responsive hydrogel that combines glycerophosphate and biologically active zein for tissue engineering applications. Chitosan (CS) and hydroxyapatite (HA) were used to fabricate the gel. The gel exhibited a solution phase between 4 to 10 °C and transitioned to a gel at body temperature within 4 to 6 minutes. The gel's mechanical strength (52.2 MPa at 40% strain) was significantly enhanced by the addition of zein, and it demonstrated good injectability and ease of shaping into complex structures for treatment.245
Zein scaffolds were transformed into fibrous structures resembling the extracellular matrix using electrospinning. The zein scaffold was crosslinked with trimethylpropane triglycidyl ether and then evaluated for human mesenchymal stem cell (MSC) adhesion, growth, and infiltration into the scaffold in vitro. The study revealed that the plant-derived zein scaffold was a potential carrier for MSCs for tissue engineering applications, offering an alternative to animal-derived gelatin protein-based carriers.246 Biopolymer-based films, such as chitosan and zein, may be more effective than conventional bandages in promoting wound healing. These films can store and release beneficial molecules like ellagic acid to combat infection and promote healing over time. The films demonstrated bactericidal and fungicidal properties against samples of bacteria and fungi while retaining their elasticity and comfort. Additionally, one of the formulations showed an accelerated wound healing rate in animal models, reducing inflammation, and could be a promising candidate for future wound dressings.247
Fig. 11 Histological assessments. (a) Representative microscopic images of the tissue sections treated with or without NO/ANCs, ANCs, and DT/NO after H&E staining. (b) Representative microscopic images of the tissue sections after Masson's trichrome staining. The scale bar represents 200 μm. Reproduced from ref. 264 with permission from Springer Nature, copyright 2024. |
Fatemeh Saadat prepared nanofibers containing albumin and caffeine to enhance wound healing. The application of these nanofibers to wounds resulted in improved blood flow to the affected area, thus speeding up the recovery process. The study found that caffeine played a crucial role in stimulating the growth of new blood vessels in the skin, which led to more effective wound closure.265 In another study, Mohammed A. Naseer and fellows designed albumin based composite material with greater biodegradability and biocompatibility for enhanced wound healing applications. Novel sutures were designed using extrusion method from human albumin serum. Promising results were obtained from physicochemical and mechanical tests of the designed suture. The designed suture is proposed to be used as a 3D filament to design custom scaffolds.266 Furthermore, Elias Madadian and colleagues have developed a hybrid foam for use as a wound dressing. Sodium alginate and albumin were used as the main components, with calcium chloride mist serving as a cross-linking agent. The researchers employed rhodamine B as their model drug in the study. The designed scaffold underwent porosity, degradation, mechanical, and drug release tests. The results showed exceptional mechanical properties and sustained drug release. Additionally, they found that altering the concentrations of sodium alginate, albumin, and the crosslinking agent could regulate the drug release.267 A study conducted by Neives Vanaclocha et al. discovered that individuals with higher serum prealbumin levels experienced improved re-epithelialization and wound healing compared to those with lower prealbumin levels. Patients with higher prealbumin levels demonstrated a shorter time to full wound recovery and were found to be an independent predictor of successful graft outcomes.268 Adnan and his colleagues developed a hydrogel comprised of bovine serum albumin-riboflavin retinoic acid. This bovine serum albumin (BSA)-riboflavin retinoic acid (BHG) hydrogel increased the expression of the transglutaminase-2 enzyme, leading to improved epithelial cell regeneration and Wnt-B-caretin signaling, which promotes stromal cell growth. The study showed promise for healing wounded corneas and could be further explored for wound healing and progenitor cell remodeling in an in vivo model.269 Recently Jia and fellows270 developed human serum albumin-Zn-vascular endothelial growth factor (HMS-Zn@VEGF) microspheres, integrating antibacterial and angiogenic human serum albumin to address infected wounds. In vitro experiments showed total bacterial elimination with one application, while rat studies demonstrated fast wound healing via decreased inflammation, improved collagen production, and enhanced angiogenesis (eee Fig. 12). VEGF was successfully loaded onto the microspheres through HSA adsorption on zinc ions and His-tagged VEGF crosslinking. The microspheres displayed potent, broad-spectrum antibacterial activity and promoted neovascularization, confirming their biocompatibility, antimicrobial efficacy, and angiogenic properties, indicating their potential as an infected wound treatment.
Fig. 12 HMS-Zn@VEGF promoted healing of infected wounds in rats (a) representative pictures of different treatment groups on days 0, 3, 6, 9, 12, and 15. The scale bar is 50 mm. (b) H&E staining of the wound. The scale bar is 1000 μm. (c) Mockup of wound healing. (d) Healing curves of infected wounds in each group of rats. (e) Quantitative statistics on wound width. Reproduced from ref. 270 with permission from Elsevier, copyright 2024. |
Moreover, researchers have synthesized a wound dressing that accelerates the healing of diabetic wounds by using a composite hydrogel containing bovine serum albumin and aloe vera. This hydrogel is unique due to its porous structure, self-fluorescence, and biocompatibility, which were achieved without adding any toxic chemicals or dyes. In preclinical studies, this hydrogel showed promising results in promoting collagen synthesis and angiogenesis, leading to faster healing. Additionally, this hydrogel can be 3D printed for customized wound care treatments.271
A further crucial issue is the long-term safety and biocompatibility of protein derived materials used in wound healing and dressings. Despite their promising potential for wound care applications, it is vital to confirm their compatibility with biological systems and establish a comprehensive safety profile for successful clinical use.275,276 Finally, there is an urgent need for more comprehensive clinical trials to fully determine the efficacy and safety of wound dressings. Although preclinical studies and early-stage clinical trials often show promising results, the transition to routine clinical application can reveal unexpected complications, such as allergic responses, increased infection risks, or long-term biocompatibility issues.277
The field of wound healing has seen remarkable progress due to innovations in protein based materials. Various techniques for creating protein derived wound care products yield specific forms and notable advantages for different wound types. These materials are excellent in facilitating the biochemical processes necessary for wound repair. Research indicates that variations in cellular shape, movement, specialization, and survival significantly impact the healing process.278,279 It is anticipated that next-generation wound care technologies incorporating advanced proteins will precisely track crucial healing indicators, such as oxygen concentration and heat, and make appropriate modifications. These innovative devices are expected to relay collected data to medical professionals for further evaluation.
Despite progress, challenges persist in the field of protein-based wound care technologies. To achieve efficient and cell-specific transformation, these technologies require refinement without causing any adverse effects. Optimal wound healing treatments should enable precise, autonomous delivery of multiple molecules at the wound site to speed up the healing process. Advancements necessitate identifying specific wounds, protein mechanism of action and developing materials with adjustable properties. Continued research in this field is crucial for the development of translational wound care materials and their applications. Prospect studies should emphasize developing methods and mechanistic insights to produce different forms of wound care materials from abundant protein resources. Only a small number of protein based wound dressings have made it to the commercialization stage, despite substantial research on the use of proteins in wound healing applications. The majority of research on proteins in wound healing has primarily focused on their ability to promote cell migration and their antimicrobial properties. Nevertheless, there is a lack of research on multifunctional smart systems derived from proteins, especially regarding smart dressings that demonstrate specific stimulus-responsive behaviors. In the future, the focus should be on developing intelligent systems substantiated by understanding healing and infection mechanisms, particularly in the context of chronic wounds. These systems can potentially showcase the effectiveness of proteins in promoting the healing process.
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2025 |