Molecular evidence for improved tribological performances of MoDTC induced by methylene-bis(dithiocarbamates) in engine lubricants

Abstract

During engine tests, it has been observed that the combined use of molybdenum dithiocarbamates (MoDTC) and methylene-bis(dithiocarbamates) (MBDTC) in formulated engine oils resulted in better fuel efficiency, keeping the friction coefficient stable at low values for a longer period of time as compared to the same oil devoid of MBDTC. Therefore, the interactions between MBDTC and MoDTC have been investigated at the molecular level. The qualitative and quantitative evolution of MoDTC in two engine oils similarly formulated, but with and without MBDTC, were compared during engine tests using a specifically developed high performance liquid chromatography-mass spectrometry (HPLC-MS) analytical method. Parallel to the molecular study, the evolution of the friction coefficients of both lubricants as well as the evolution of the fuel consumption of the engine were determined. The combined use of MoDTC and MBDTC was shown to exhibit better fuel efficiency and to maintain a relatively low friction coefficient for longer periods of time as compared to the oil devoid of MBDTC. It could be determined that the enhanced performances observed were presumably related to an extension of the lifetime of MoDTC in the engine oil containing MBDTC. Since the MoDTC remaining at the end of the engine test in oil containing MBDTC exclusively bear ligands corresponding to the dithiocarbamate moieties of MBDTC, it can be concluded that the prolonged existence of MoDTC was due to the progressive replacement of the degraded dithiocarbamate ligands on MoDTC educts by those released from MBDTC during engine functioning. As a result, the concentrations of MoDTC could be maintained at a useful level for a longer period in the engine oil containing MBDTC, leading to better fuel consumption performances.