Impact of carboxylate ligation on the C–H activation reactivity of a non-heme Fe(iv)O complex: a computational investigation

Abstract

A comprehensive DFT investigation has been presented to predict how a carboxylate-rich macrocycle would affect the reactivity of a non-heme Fe(IV)O complex towards C–H activation. The popular non-heme iron oxo complex [Fe^IV(O)(N4Py)]²⁺, (N4Py = N,N-(bis(2-pyridyl)methyl)N-bis(2-pyridylmethyl)amine) (1), has been selected here as the primary compound. It is transformed to the compound [Fe^IV(O)(ⁿBu-P2DA)], where ⁿBu-P2DA = N-(1′,1′-bis(2-pyridyl)pentyl)iminodiacetate (2) after the replacement of two pyridine donors of N4Py with carboxylate groups. Two other complexes, namely 3 and 4, have been predicted sequentially substituting nitrogen with the carboxylate groups. Ethylbenzene and dihydrotoluene were chosen as substrates. In terms of C–H activation reactivity, an interesting pattern emerges: as the carboxylate group becomes more equatorially enriched, the reactivity increases, following the trend 1 < 2 < 3 < 4. This also aligns with available experimental reports related to complexes 1 and 2. Fe(IV)O complexes exhibit two-state reactivity (triplet and quintet), whereas the quintet state is more favourable due to the stabilization of the transition states through exchange interactions involving a greater number of unpaired electrons. A detailed analysis of the factors influencing reactivity has been performed, including distortion energy (which decreases for the transition state with the addition of carboxylate groups), the triplet–quintet oxidant energy gap (which consistently decreases as carboxylate group enrichment increases), steric factors, and quantum mechanical tunneling. This investigation provides a detailed explanation of the observed outcomes and predicts the higher reactivity of carboxylate-enriched Fe(IV)O complexes. After potential experimental verification, this could lead to the development of new, optimal catalysts for C–H activation.