Neethu
Sundaresan
a,
Thresia
Thomas
b,
T. J.
Thomas
b and
C. K. S.
Pillai
*a
aChemical Sciences & Technology Division, Regional Research Laboratory (Council of Scientific and Industrial Research), Thiruvananthapuram, 695019, India. E-mail: ckspillai@yahoo.com
bDepartments of Medicine and Environmental Community Medicine, University of Medicine and Dentistry, Robert Wood Johnson Medical School, NJ 08903, USA
First published on 5th October 2011
The effect of alkali and alkaline earth metal ions on the spermine induced condensates of high molecular weight DNA was studied. The spermine induced DNA precipitation was facilitated by the alkali and alkaline earth metal ions, suggesting that the metal ions instead of getting into competition with spermine in DNA binding, had acted in concert to precipitate DNA from solution. Spermine-DNA–metal ion condensates exhibited mainly two different phases and at least one of them was fluid in nature, which is the cholesteric phase and a columnar hexagonal phase with a restricted fluidity where the DNA molecules are more closely packed. In the presence of alkali metal ions spermine–DNA aggregates were mainly in the cholesteric phase but at higher spermine concentrations, in the presence of Rb+ and Cs+, they adopted a cholesteric to columnar arrangement, suggesting that the increased size of Rb+ and Cs+ facilitated the cholesteric to columnar phase transition. Among the alkaline earth metal ions, the existence of fluidic cholesteric textures in the presence of Mg2+ can be thought of probably as a clue to the possible synergistic role of polyamines and the Mg2+ in the cell nucleus, in preserving the fluidity required for the biological functions of DNA within the condensates. The evolution of the columnar phase from the cholesteric phase in the presence of Ca2+ also indicates the probable role of Ca2+ in packing DNA into hexagonal arrangement in vivo. Among all the metal ions studied, the behavior of Na+ was exceptional in inducing DNA resolubilization at a very low concentration of 12 mM spermine whereas with the other metal ions DNA got resolubilized at or above 400 mM spermine concentration. Small angle X-ray diffraction peaks obtained at 2θ value between 0 and 5 also indicate the formation of the columnar hexagonal phase with Rb–DNA, Cs–DNA and Ca–DNA systems.
Polyamines are now believed to interact electrostatically with the charged DNA phosphates22 and it has been shown recently that spermine exhibits possibly very weak, base sequence dependence.22,23 It has been recently established that metal ions can be treated as factors modifying the character of interactions between polyamines and fragments of nucleic acids.24 Similarly polyamines interfere in the reactions of metal ions and bioligands. The stability and character of complexes with polyamines and fragments of nucleic acids depend mainly on the type of metal ion. Generally “hard” ions of alkaline earth metals interact mainly with hard oxygen atoms from phosphate groups, whereas more soft nitrogen atoms from purine and pyridine bases interact with soft ions of transition metals.24–26
In general, the affinity of a cation for a specific site on a polynucleotide is a function of its charge, hydration-free energy, coordination geometry, and coordinate bond forming capacity.27,28 Those metal ions that bind primarily to the phosphates stabilize the helix by reducing the intermolecular repulsion, which provokes LC ordering by maintaining the rigid rod like shape of the DNA molecule, which is the determinant factor of its LC ordering.
Saminathan et al. in a recent study have reported the effect of spermine, spermidine and its synthetic analogues on the LC behavior of high molecular weight DNA.14 This study showed a structural specificity effect of polyamines on LC phase transitions of DNA and suggests a possible physiological function of natural polyamines. It is believed that many metal ions in combination with ubiquitous cellular molecules such as polyamines serve critical functions across a multitude of biochemical processes, and are necessary to reach the ultimate states of condensation in the cell.27,29 Detailed investigations on the combined effects of spermine and metal ions are limited except for a few reports where the spermine induced LC organization of low molecular weight fragmented DNA was investigated in the presence of Na+, K+, Mg2+ and Ca2+ under defined ionic conditions.9–13 As the stability and character of complexes with polyamines and fragments of nucleic acids depend mainly on the type of metal ion, the present work was undertaken to investigate the spermine induced LC organization of calf thymus DNA, phase transitions and its stability in the presence of alkali metal ions such as Li+, Na+, K+, Rb+ and Cs+, and alkaline earth metal ions such as Mg2+, Ca2+, Ba2+ and Sr2+ using polarized light microscopy and small angle X-ray diffraction techniques.
Spermine·4HCl was purchased from Sigma Chemical Co. (St Louis, MO). LiCl, NaCl, KCl, RbCl, CsCl, MgCl2, CaCl2, BaCl2 and SrCl2 of analytical grade were used. Autoclaved Millipore water was used as the medium in all the experiments. The concentrations of alkali and alkaline earth metals for the preparation of metal–DNA complexes were selected as 300 mM and 10 mM respectively in the present experiments, considering their abundance at the cellular level.
DNA–metal systems were prepared by dissolving 5 mg of DNA (15.01 mM), 0.3 M LiCl, 0.3 M NaCl, 0.3 M KCl, 0.3 M RbCl, 0.3 M CsCl, 0.01 M MgCl2, 0.01 M CaCl2, 0.01 M BaCl2, and 0.01 M SrCl2. In order to attain homogeneity prior to the start of the experiment DNA–metal ion solutions were vortexed for about 15–20 minutes and were allowed to attain equilibrium at room temperature. The concentration of calf thymus DNA was determined by measuring the absorbance at 260 nm and using the molar extinction coefficient of 6900 per M cm−1.
The DNA concentration of 15 mM was selected for the present series of experiments because LC phase transitions could be observed with spermine at this concentration. Spermine solutions of concentrations varying from 0.1 mM to 600 mM were prepared in autoclaved Millipore water. DNA and spermine solutions were stored at 4 °C. The solutions were homogeneous at the start of our experiments. The critical spermine concentration required for inducing DNA precipitation in the presence of each ion was determined by mixing spermine solutions of appropriate concentration with aliquots of DNA. Following the addition of salts to the solutions, the sample was incubated at room temperature (26 °C) for 15 minutes and centrifuged at 10000 × g for 5 minutes. The pellets were then sandwiched between a microscopic glass slide and cover slip and sealed using DPX (DPX is a neutral solution of polystyrene and plasticizers in xylene) to prevent dehydration of the sample.
The in vitroprecipitation/condensation of DNA by spermine has been investigated by a number of researchers and it was found that the DNA precipitation efficacy of spermine is highly dependent on the other counter ions bound to DNA.11–17 The spermine induced DNA pellets/aggregates appeared as transparent colloid-like mass to white opaque gels, which exhibited multiple macroscopic polymorphic behavior depending on the concentration of both spermine and the counter ions. They are either dense or partially fluid in nature flowing spontaneously under the microscope. The fluidity of the ordered phase suggests that spermine binds along the strands, which would allow the strands to slide on each other. When deposited between the glass slide and the cover slip these aggregates show multiple textures (Fig. 3–5), which depend on the nature of the phase and also on the thickness of the preparation. Two main phases, cholesteric and columnar hexagonal, are found in our study, either separately or in coexistence, with variations depending on local conditions. A cholesteric phase is frequently obtained in the samples, but its characteristic fingerprint pattern could not be observed usually. Instead, birefringent domains are usually seen with homogeneous illumination. But the presence of tear-shaped defects attest to the formation of the cholesteric phase. Numerous isotropic droplets of various sizes are also seen trapped in the birefringent cholesteric phase. Sometimes nematic textures were also observed with two or four branch brush defects. These textures probably correspond to the previously observed cholesteric phase, and are formed rarely where anchoring effects on the glass slides prevent the twist. They are slightly distorted into squares in very thin preparation.
It should be pointed out here that blue phases commonly known as precholesteric phases32 which are a transition from the isotropic to the cholesteric phase, are not observed in the present case. However, the higher ordered columnar hexagonal phases were observed when the concentration of spermine is above 200 mM, but only with metal ions of higher sizes. These domains are much more viscous than the cholesteric phase. In the columnar hexagonal phase, the DNA molecules are unidirectionally aligned with a lateral hexagonal order.16 Undulations typical of the hexagonally ordered columnar phase were also noticed. The fluidity and order required for a LC state are observed here. It is important to note here that the time dependent changes in LC textures of DNA occurred under conditions in which solvent evaporation was prevented by sealing the glass slides with a neutral solution of polystyrene and plasticizers in toluene. Therefore, the observed changes are a consequence of the reorganization of polyamines and metal ions on the DNA strands.
Fig. 1 shows the Csp values of spermine concentration required for the onset of DNA precipitation in the presence of metal ions differing in their charge, size and hydration energy. Two distinct plateaus can be seen from Fig. 1. Plateau 1 for the alkali metal–DNA systems occur around a concentration of 0.75 mM. It should be noted that spermine alone precipitates DNA at a concentration of 0.85 mM. In the presence of alkaline earth metal ions, spermine precipitates DNA at a concentration of 0.275 mM. In short, Csp (spermine alone) > Cspalkali metal ions > Cspalkaline earth metal ions. This suggests that alkali and alkaline earth metal ions might have acted in concert with spermine which facilitated the precipitation range of spermine (Fig. 1). Fig. 1 also reveals that charge and size of the ion are playing important roles in the precipitation of DNA in the presence of metal ions.
Fig. 1 Critical spermine concentration (Csp) required for the onset of DNA precipitation with alkali and alkaline earth metal ions. |
Fig. 2 gives the overall LC phase behavior of DNA in the presence of the metal ion studied with respect to the change in spermine concentration. It can be seen from Fig. 2 that at or near 400 mM of spermine concentration, the precipitated DNA resolubilizes due possibly to the screening of short-range electrostatic interactions between the polyamine molecules and the DNA strands and goes to the isotropic state. Another important finding is that of the sodium ion, which resolubilizes the DNA at extremely low spermine concentration. Any increase in spermine concentration after the precipitation of DNA would naturally increase the osmotic stress of the medium. The increase in number of the spermine molecules around DNA would screen the intermolecular interaction between DNA strands thereby reducing the order parameter and finally to the isotropic state.
Fig. 2 LC behavior of spermine induced DNA condensates in the presence of metal ions of varying size and charge. |
In the presence of Li+, Na+ and K+, spermine-DNA aggregates were mainly in the cholesteric phase (Fig. 3a–c) that flows spontaneously under the microscope (Fig. 4a–c) and no transition to the columnar phase has been observed. In our previous study, both cholesteric and columnar phases were observed when high molecular weight DNA was condensed with spermine,14 but these experiments were carried out in the absence of any counter ions.
Fig. 3 Time dependent phase transitions of spermine induced DNA condensates in the presence of alkali metal ions. |
Fig. 4 (a) Li–DNA was treated with 200 mM spermine and incubated in a glass slide at 37 °C—a fluid cholesteric phase was obtained after 3 h. (b) Cholesteric phase obtained after 3 h. with Na–DNA when treated with 200 mM spermine and incubated in a glass slide at 37 °C. (c) Cholesteric phase with tear shaped defects obtained after 3 h. with K–DNA when treated with 200 mM spermine and incubated in a glass slide at 37 °C. (d) Dendrimeric growth obtained after 1 week with Rb–DNA when treated with 200 mM spermine and incubated in a glass slide at 37 °C. |
Pelta et al. and Saminathan et al. have studied the precipitation of short DNA fragments by the polycations spermidine and spermine in the presence of Na+, and have shown that resolubilization of DNA aggregate is essentially dependent on the Na+ concentration present in the DNA solution.13,27 This is comparable to the present observation with high molecular weight DNA molecules also. Na+ appears to be exceptional among alkali metal ions in resolubilising precipitated DNA (see Fig. 3), which suggests that spermine and Na+ concentrations would be balanced in the cell nucleus to maintain DNA in the condensed states. Na+ and K+ are the major extracellular and intracellular cations respectively in the body fluids of animals including human beings. Even though, Na+ and K+ are abundant in biological systems, Na+ concentration is always maintained low inside the cell (high K+ inside the cell) by a Na+–K+ pump with the help of an enzyme Na–K ATPase present in the cell membrane through the active ion transport mechanism.33 Each operation of the pump pulls out a larger number of sodium ions from the cell than the number of K+ ions it pumps into the cell. The maintenance of low Na+ concentration inside the cell could also be due to the fact that higher Na+ concentration will not favor the existence of condensed states of DNA essential for its biological functions such as replication, etc. Below 12 mM spermine, DNA exhibited an iridescent fluidic cholesteric phase in the presence of sodium, which remained stable for two weeks. The influence of Na+ in the presence of a polyamine in controlling the supramolecular order of DNA will have many biological implications.
Fig. 3 shows that at higher spermine concentrations (200 and 400 mM), in the presence of Rb+ and Cs+, spermine–DNA condensates adopted a cholesteric to columnar arrangement, showing broken-fan shaped textures (Fig. 4d) but at lower spermine concentrations transition from the cholesteric to columnar phase was not observed, and the cholesteric phase directly underwent isotropization. It appears that the size of the ion exerts additional influence on the induction and stabilization of the LC phases of DNA.
The X-ray diffraction patterns of few spermine–metal ion–DNA condensates are presented in Fig. 7. In general, a sharp and strong peak at a low angle (1° < 2θ < 4°) in the small angle X-ray scattering (SAXS) curve and a broad peak associated with lateral packing in the wide angle X-ray diffraction region (WAXD) can be observed for the columnar structure. For the cholesteric structure no patterns appear in SAXS, however a broad peak occurs at 2θ = 16–18. The diffraction angles of the cholesteric structure at wide angle are obviously less than that of columnar and nematic structures and this is a very important character to judge the cholesteric structure.34,35Small angle X-ray diffraction patterns obtained at 2θ value between 0 and 5 also indicate the formation of a columnar hexagonal phase (Fig. 7). The broad peak obtained at the wide angle region could be of the cholesteric phase. It appears that higher spermine concentration and the increased size of Rb+ and Cs+ presumably facilitated the cholesteric to columnar transition. In the presence of Li+, an unusual stability of DNA mesophase was reported in our recent work.36 However, in the presence of spermine lithium did not impart the unusual stability. The hydrated structure of Li+ ions37,38 which is responsible for the stability factor might have been disturbed in the presence of spermine. The stability of the phases was in the following order: TisoCs+ = TisoRb+ > TisoLi+ > TisoK+ > TisoNa+. In the case of all the alkali metal ions, except sodium, higher spermine concentrations rendered more stability to the LC phases.
Fig. 5 Time dependent phase transitions of spermine induced DNA condensates in the presence of alkaline earth metal ions. |
In the presence of Mg2+, below 400 mM spermine concentrations cholesteric with nematic thread-like fluidy structures (Fig. 6a and c) were formed initially which got darkened eventually without transforming into the higher ordered columnar phase (Fig. 5a). The existence of fluidic textures gives a clue to the possible physiological role of polyamines and the Mg2+ in the cell nucleus, where chromatin is condensed, still maintaining the mobility of the double strands required for the biological functions of DNA within the condensates. A cholesteric organization of DNA was reported in dinoflagellate chromosomes42–44 and in certain bacterial nucleoids.45 It was also shown that the condensed DNA in the presence of polyamines can stimulate the functional properties of DNA such as the efficiency of replication and transcription of DNA.18
Fig. 6 (a) Fluid cholesteric phase obtained after 3 h when Mg–DNA was treated with 100 mM spermine and incubated in a glass slide at 37 °C. (b) Cholesteric phase with striped pattern obtained after 12 h with Ca–DNA when treated with 200 mM spermine and incubated in a glass slide at 37 °C. (c) Cholesteric phase with nematic threaded structures obtained after 3 h with Sr–DNA when treated with 200 mM spermine and incubated in a glass slide at 37 °C. (d) Fan shaped textures of columnar phase obtained after 1 week with Ca–DNA when treated with 200 mM spermine and incubated in a glass slide at 37 °C. |
A cholesteric with nematic thread like fluidy structure (Fig. 6c) was observed with Sr2+ also, the phase instead of darkening transformed itself into the higher ordered columnar phase. This transition from cholesteric to columnar hexagonal phase could be considered mainly as a size effect.
In the presence of calcium and barium below 400 mM spermine concentrations, the cholesteric phase was formed initially which developed a striped appearance followed by broken fan shaped textures typical of the columnar phase (Fig. 6b and d) and became darkened subsequently (Fig. 5b and d). Small angle X-ray diffraction patterns obtained at 2θ value between 0 and 5 also indicate the formation of a columnar hexagonal phase (Fig. 7). Our earlier work with spermine alone did not give a well-defined hexagonal order, instead some antiparallel arrangement adopting a hexagonal order was observed.
Fig. 7 XRD patterns obtained with the biphasic sample obtained on precipitation with 200 mM spermine. The low angle peak corresponds to the columnar packing of DNA molecules and the wide-angle broad peak is related to the cholesteric phase of the sample. (a) Rb–DNA and (b) Cs–DNA (c) Ca–DNA system. The arrows indicate the curves of the corresponding metal–DNA condensates. Rb–DNA (a) and Cs–DNA (b) being biphasic have peaks both at the small and wide angle region, whereas Ca–DNA ‘c’ has only one peak at the wide angle region. |
The formation of well defined, broken fan shaped textures typical of the columnar phase suggests the importance of the synergistic effect of calcium ions and spermine in inducing the most efficient columnar packing of DNA molecules in vivo. A hexagonal packing of DNA was observed in bacteriophages and certain sperm heads.46 As alternate condensation and decondensation of DNA are believed to occur when DNA functions in the cell nucleus, both cholesteric and columnar phases may exist according to the local requirement.
Earlier studies with the induction and stabilization of the LC phases with metal ions of varying sizes indicated that the transition from the cholesteric to columnar hexagonal phase was facilitated by the size of the concerned ion.31Fig. 2 also indicates a similar effect. It can also be noted for Fig. 5 that as the spermine concentration increases the stability of the phases also increases. Thus at 400 mM, TisoMg2+ = TisoCa2+ = TisoSr2+ = TisoBa2+. Thus <400 mM, TisoMg2+ > TisoCa2+ = TisoSr2+ > TisoBa2+.
Among all the metal ions studied, the behavior of Na+ was exceptional in inducing resolubilization at a very low spermine (12 mM) concentration whereas with the other metal ions DNA got resolubilized at or above 400 mM concentration of spermine. Small angle X-ray diffraction peaks obtained at 2θ value between 0 and 5 also indicate the formation of a columnar hexagonal phase with Rb–DNA, Cs–DNA and Ca–DNA systems. It appears that the alkali and alkaline earth metal ions might have been involved in a condensation process in concert with spermine, which facilitated the precipitation of DNA.
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2011 |