Taizo
Mori
a,
Mutsumasa
Kyotani
b and
Kazuo
Akagi
*a
aDepartment of Polymer Chemistry, Kyoto University, Kyoto, 615-8510, Japan. E-mail: akagi@fps.polym.kyoto-u.ac.jp
bTsukuba Research Center for Interdisciplinary Materials Science, University of Tsukuba, Ibaraki, 305-8577, Japan
First published on 17th May 2011
Orientation-controlled asymmetric reaction fields consisting of chiral nematic liquid crystals (N*-LCs) were comprehensively studied to elucidate the formation mechanisms of horizontally and vertically aligned helical polyacetylenes (H-PAs). The alignment of the N*-LC was controlled by tuning the concentration of a chiral molecule added as a chiral dopant to a parent nematic LC and/or by using a rod-like molecule used as a vertical orientation inducer. It was found that the horizontal N*-LC gives rise to horizontally aligned H-PAs, and the vertical N*-LC consisting of two types of multilayered arrangements provides U- and V-shaped fibrillar morphologies of vertically aligned H-PAs. The observed formation mechanisms are useful for understanding asymmetric polymerisations of helical conjugated polymers prepared in chiral nematic or cholesteric liquid crystal reaction fields.
The solid state structure and morphology of PA are determined during the polymerisation process.9 The H-PAs hitherto synthesised have a horizontally aligned morphology because the N*-LC used for acetylene polymerisation has a homogeneous (horizontal) alignment. In a previous work,10 the formation mechanism of a horizontally aligned H-PA in a horizontal N*-LC was examined. The helical axis of the horizontal N*-LC is parallel to the substrate on the free surface and perpendicular to the direction of the depth. Thus, the PA fibrils are parallel to the substrate when the H-PA is synthesised in the horizontal N*-LC. The relationships between the H-PA and the N*-LC are as follows: (i) the screw direction of the H-PA fibrils is opposite to the twisted direction of the N*-LC, (ii) the half-helical pitch of the N*-LC is nearly equal to the interdistance between the fibril bundles of the H-PA, and (iii) the helical axis of the H-PA is perpendicular to that of the N*-LC. The formation mechanism of the horizontally aligned H-PA in the horizontal N*-LC is described in Fig. 1.
Fig. 1 (A) Model structure of the horizontal N*-LC and (B) the formation mechanism of horizontally aligned H-PA in the horizontal N*-LC. The N*-LC molecules and the H-PAs are represented as ellipsoid bodies and blue tubes, respectively. |
From the viewpoint of evaluating the physical properties of H-PAs, a macroscopically aligned H-PA is desirable. The macroscopic control of the N*-LC morphology, i.e., the conversion from a poly-domain to a mono-domain structure, needs an external perturbation such as magnetic force, electric force, shear stress, or rubbing.11,12 An alternative method is to use the oriented substrate that has been pre-treated homogeneously (horizontally) or homeotropically (vertically). Among the aligned H-PAs, the vertically aligned H-PA could be useful for evaluating the single-helical bundle of fibrils.
To synthesise the vertically aligned H-PA, the PA fibrils should be perpendicular to the substrate as shown in Fig. 2.13 Because the H-PA grows perpendicular to the helical axis of the N*-LC, to prepare the vertically aligned H-PA, vertical N*-LC is necessary. The vertical N*-LC is prepared by adding not only a vertical orientation inducer but also an axially chiral binaphthyl derivative into the N-LC. The vertical orientation inducer (PCH50)2n (n = 6, 8) has a rod-shaped structure containing two phenylcyclohexyl (PCH) mesogenic moieties linked with a hexa- or octamethylene chain (see Table 1).
Fig. 2 Schematic representation of (A) the vertical N*-LC and (B) the vertically aligned H-PA. The N*-LC molecules and the H-PAs are represented as ellipsoid bodies and blue tubes, respectively. |
Parent LC | |
Vertical orientation inducer | |
Chiral dopant | |
System 1 | PCH302: PCH304: (R)- or (S)-(PCH506)4-Binol = 100:100:0.5 |
System 2 | PCH506: (PCH50)26: (R)- or (S)-(PCH506)4-Binol = 100:5:1.0 |
System 3 | PCH506: (PCH50)26: (R)- or (S)-(PCH506)4-Binol = 100:5:0.5 |
System 4 | PCH506: (PCH50)26: (R)- or (S)-(PCH506)4-Binol = 100:5:0.2 |
The macroscopic arrangement of H-PA fibrils is controllable by the N*-LC structure. It is necessary to clarify the formation mechanisms of not only the horizontally aligned H-PA but also the vertically aligned H-PA. The formation mechanism could be useful for understanding other helical conjugated polymers synthesised in the asymmetric reaction fields composed of N*-LCs or cholesteric LCs.
In this work, the orientation of N*-LCs was controlled by tuning the concentrations of both the chiral dopant and the vertical orientation inducer. The horizontally and vertically aligned H-PAs were synthesised in the horizontal and vertical N*-LCs, respectively. The higher-order structures of the horizontal and vertical N*-LCs were evaluated from the observation of polarizing optical micrograph (POM). The morphologies of the H-PA films were examined by scanning electron microscope (SEM). The relationship between the vertical N*-LC and the vertically aligned H-PA was examined, and the formation mechanism for the vertically aligned H-PA in the vertical N*-LC was elucidated.
The catalyst solution was added into a flat-bottom container placed in a Schlenk flask by using a syringe that was warmed beforehand to maintain the fluidity of the highly viscous catalyst solution. The Schlenk flask was connected to a vacuum line via a flexible joint and then degassed. The acetylene polymerisation was carried out by introducing acetylene gas into the catalyst-containing N*-LC. Polymerisation temperature was kept constant at 39 °C by circulating water through an outer flask enveloping the Schlenk flask, to prevent the phase transition to an isotropic phase from the N*-LC phase that is accompanied with exothermic polymerisation. Acetylene gas of six-nine grades was used without further purification. Polymerisation temperature was controlled by immersing the Schlenk flask in a temperature-controlled water bath. The initial acetylene pressure was approximately 40 Torr, and the polymerisation time was 5 min. After polymerisation, the PA film was washed with purified toluene several times and then with 1 N HCl–methanol mixture and THF under argon at room temperature. The film was dried by vacuum pumping on a Teflon sheet and stored in a freezer at −20 °C. The film thickness was in the range of 3 to 6 μm.
As shown in Fig. 3, the miscibility test between system 3 (containing (R)-(PCH506)4-Binol) and cholesteryl oleyl carbonate showed a Schlieren texture in the POM. In contrast, the miscibility test between system 3 (containing (S)-(PCH506)4-Binol) and cholesteryl oleyl carbonate showed no change in optical texture. The results demonstrate that the N*-LCs containing (R)-(PCH506)4-Binol and (S)-(PCH506)4-Binol have right-handed and left-handed helical structures, respectively. Table 2 summarises the phase transition behaviours of the N*-LCs. Systems 2 to 4 showed N* and smectic (S) phases in the cooling process but only N* phase in the heating process. System 2 containing (R)-(PCH506)4-Binol showed the N* phase between 30 and 52 °C and the S phase between ca. 9 and 30 °C in the cooling process. The sufficiently wide temperature region of the N* phase enabled us to perform the acetylene polymerisation in the N*-LC.
Fig. 3 Miscibility tests between (A) system 3 containing (R)-(PCH506)4-Binol and a LC standard (cholesteryl oleyl carbonate) with left-handed screw direction, and (B) system 3 containing (S)-(PCH506)4-Binol and the LC standard. |
The helical pitches of the N*-LCs were evaluated with Cano's wedge method,15 and they are summarised in Table 3. The Cano's wedge method is based on the observation of discontinuity lines that appear when an N*-LC is inserted into a cell with a gradient thickness. The helical pitches of systems 2 to 4 varied from 1.2 to 7.0 μm with change in the mole percentage of (R)- or (S)-(PCH506)4-Binol.
System | N*-LC | H-PA | |||
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Mole ratios between components of N*-LCs | Helical pitch (μm) | Distance between fibril bundles (μm) | Diameter of a fibril bundle (μm) | Diameter of a fibril (nm) | |
2 | PCH506: (PCH50)26: (R)- or (S)-(PCH506)4-Binol = 100: 5: 1.0 | 1.2 | 0.7 (±0.1) | 0.3 (±0.1) | 130 (±20) |
3 | PCH506: (PCH50)26: (R)- or (S)-(PCH506)4-Binol = 100: 5: 0.5 | 2.3 | 1.2 (±0.2) | 0.7 (±0.1) | 200 (±100) |
4 | PCH506: (PCH50)26: (R)- or (S)-(PCH506)4-Binol = 100: 5: 0.2 | 7.0 | 3.5 (±0.3) | 0.8 (±0.2) | 200 (±100) |
Fig. 4 shows the POM photographs and the model structures of the horizontal N*-LC (system 1). The model structures depict LC surface layer I, intermediate layer II, and inner layer III. The fingerprint texture is observed in layer I. Thus, the helical axis of the N*-LC is parallel to the substrate in layer II. However, the Grandjean texture is observed in the inner layer III of the horizontal N*-LC. It is suggested that the helical axis of the N*-LC in layer III is perpendicular to the substrate. The intermediate layer II ensures conformity of the surface layer I with the inner layer III in the horizontal N*-LC. As a result, the lower site of the intermediate layer II forms a semicircular column in which a half-helical pitch of the N*-LC is assumed to be a radius.
Fig. 4 POM photographs of the horizontal N*-LC (system 1). (A) The fingerprint texture observed at the surface of the horizontal N*-LC and (B) the Grandjean texture observed in the inner layer of the horizontal N*-LC. (C) The cross section of model structure of the horizontal N*-LC and (D) the schematic representation of the horizontal N*-LC. The N*-LC molecules are represented as cuboid blocks. |
Fig. 5 shows the POM photographs and the model structures of the vertical N*-LC (system 3). The vertical N*-LC shows the fingerprint textures in both layers I and II. Thus, the helical axes of the N*-LC in both layers I and II are parallel to the substrate. The Grandjean texture might be formed in the inner layer III, which means that the helical axis in layer III is perpendicular to the substrate, as in the case of layer III of the horizontal N*-LC. The formation of the Grandjean texture in the inner layer III of system 3 is discussed in more detail by using supplementary data in the Supporting Information.†
Fig. 5 POM photographs of the vertical N*-LC (system 3). (A) The fingerprint texture observed at the surface of the vertical N*-LC and (B) the fingerprint texture observed in the inner layer of the vertical N*-LC. (C) The cross section of model structure of the vertical N*-LC and (D) the schematic representation of the vertical N*-LC. The N*-LC molecules are represented as cuboid blocks. |
The SEM images of the H-PA films synthesised in the N*-LC systems 2 and 3 are shown in Fig. 6. The fibrils of PA synthesised in system 2 are twisted in a one-handed direction but grow parallel to the surface of the film (Fig. 6(A)). When the concentration of the chiral dopant decreases, the fibrils are increasingly twisted and vertically aligned to the substrate (Fig. 6(B)). The helical axis of the fibril bundle is perpendicular to the film surface. The left- and right-handed screw directions of the fibril depend on the chirality of the chiral dopants that have (R)- and (S)-configurations.
Fig. 6 SEM images of H-PAs synthesised in the N*-LC containing (S)-(PCH506)4-Binol. (A) Horizontally aligned H-PAs prepared in system 2 [PCH506: (PCH50)26: (S)-(PCH506)4-Binol = 100: 5: 1.0] and (B) vertically aligned H-PA prepared in system 3 [PCH506: (PCH50)26: (S)-(PCH506)4-Binol = 100: 5: 0.5]. |
It should be noted that the horizontal or vertical orientation of the N*-LC crucially depends on (i) the relative concentrations of the vertical orientation inducer and the chiral dopant, (ii) the miscibility of the vertical orientation inducer to the parent N-LC, and (iii) the helical twisting power of the chiral dopant. Namely, the balance in effectiveness of the roles between the vertical orientation inducer and the chiral dopant dominates the macroscopic orientation of the N*-LC and hence the morphological alignment of the H-PA.13d
Fig. 7 shows the SEM image of the H-PA films synthesised in system 4 containing (S)-(PCH506)4-Binol. The fibrils are composed of two types of ridge lines: one line resembles an arch abbreviated as a “ridge line (a)”, and the other line resembles a horn abbreviated as a “ridge line (b)”. It seems that the difference in the ridge line morphology is caused by the surface structure of the N*-LC. The fibrils of the ridge lines (a) and (b) form right-handed curves extending from the inside to the surface of film when the PA film is synthesised in a left-handed N*-LC containing (S)-(PCH506)4-Binol. In contrast, the PA films synthesised in a right-handed N*-LC containing (R)-(PCH506)4-Binol show the ridge lines with left-handed curves. The two types of ridge lines have a rotational symmetry of 90° with respect to each other.
Fig. 7 SEM images of H-PAs synthesised in the vertical N*-LC (system 4) [PCH506: (PCH50)26: (S)-(PCH506)4-Binol = 100: 5: 0.2]. The fibrils are composed of two types of ridge lines: one line resembles an arch abbreviated as a “ridge line (a)”, and the other line resembles a horn abbreviated as a “ridge line (b)”. |
Next, we investigated the structural parameters of the H-PAs, such as the interdistance between the fibril bundles and the diameter of a fibril bundle as well as that of a single fibril, with magnified SEM images. The structural parameters of the H-PAs synthesised in systems 2 to 4 are summarised in Table 3. The interdistance between the fibril bundles of H-PAs decreased with decreasing helical pitch of the N*-LCs. The interdistance between the fibril bundles is equal to the half-helical pitch of the corresponding N*-LC. Although the diameter of the fibril bundles decreased with decreasing helical pitch of the N*-LC, the diameter of a single fibril showed no change, retaining a value of ca. 200 nm.
1. The screw direction of the H-PA fibrils is opposite to the twist direction of N*-LC.
2. The half-helical pitch of N*-LC is nearly equal to the interdistance of the fibril bundles of H-PA.
3. The helical axis of H-PA is parallel to the polymer chain, and the director of the N*-LC is perpendicular to the helical axis of the N*-LC.
It was found that the horizontally aligned H-PAs formed in the horizontal N*-LC (systems 1 and 2), and the vertically aligned H-PAs formed in the vertical N*-LCs (systems 3 and 4). There were two types of ridge lines in the fibril morphology of vertically aligned H-PA (system 4).
It is necessary to consider the inner structures of the N*-LCs to differentiate between the horizontally and vertically aligned H-PAs. Fig. 8 shows the formation mechanism of horizontally aligned H-PA in the horizontal N*-LC. In the horizontal N*-LC, it is unlikely that PA fibrils grow along the director where the LC molecules are perpendicular to the substrates because there is not sufficient space for PA fibrils to grow up. Therefore, the H-PAs (shown as blue ribbons in the figure) are assumed to grow along the N*-LC molecules (red rods in the figure) horizontal to the substrate.
Fig. 8 SEM images and formation mechanism of the horizontally aligned H-PA in the horizontal N*-LC. (A), (B) SEM image of H-PAs synthesised in the horizontal N*-LC. Formation mechanism of the horizontally aligned H-PA in the horizontal N*-LC, showing (C) top, (D) isometric, (E) front and (F) side views. The N*-LC molecules and the H-PAs are represented as cuboid blocks and blue tubes, respectively. |
Fig. 9 and 10 shows two types of formation mechanisms of H-PAs in the vertical N*-LCs. The vertical N*-LC has a thicker layer fingerprint texture, and the PA fibrils can grow perpendicular to the substrate. When the PA fibrils grow centring on the director where the LC molecules are parallel to the substrate, the fibril morphology shows the ridge line (a) like an inverted U-shape (Fig. 9). The fibril morphology shows the ridge line (b) like an inverted V-shape if the fibrils grow centred on the director where the LC molecules are perpendicular to the substrate (Fig. 10). Thus, there could be two types formation mechanisms of the vertically aligned H-PA synthesised in the vertical N*-LC. In the case of right-handed N*-LC, the inverted U- and V- shaped fibrils show left-handed curves and have rotational symmetries of 90° with respect to each other. In both mechanisms, the interdistance of the fibril bundles of H-PA is equal to the half-helical pitch of the N*-LC, and the helical axis of PA is perpendicular to that of the N*-LC.
Fig. 9 SEM images and formation mechanism of the vertically aligned H-PA (inverted U-shape fibrils) in the vertical N*-LC. (A), (B) SEM images of H-PA fibrils of the ridge line synthesised in the vertical N*-LC. Formation mechanism of the horizontally aligned H-PA in the horizontal N*-LC, showing (C) top, (D) isometric, (E) front and (F) side views. The N*-LC molecules and the H-PAs are represented as cuboid blocks and blue tubes, respectively. The fibril morphology shows the ridge line like an inverted U-shape. |
Fig. 10 SEM images and formation mechanism of the vertically aligned H-PA (inverted V-shape fibrils) in the vertical N*-LC. (A), (B) SEM images of H-PA fibrils of the ridge line synthesised in the vertical N*-LC. Formation mechanism of the horizontally aligned H-PA in the horizontal N*-LC, showing (C) top, (D) isometric, (E) front and (F) side views. The N*-LC molecules and the H-PAs are represented as cuboid blocks and blue tubes, respectively. The fibril morphology shows the ridge line like an inverted V-shape. |
Lastly it is useful to remark an overall interfacial acetylene polymerization in the N*-LC. When discussing the formation mechanism of the H-PA in the N*-LC, one has to consider that the acetylene polymerization occurs interfacially between the gas and liquid phases, and that the PA chains grow along the LC molecules. The latter has already been revealed by the external force-oriented LC reaction field17,18 where the aligned LCs form so-called “one-directionally lined guardrails” and the PA chains are only allowed to grow along and between the guardrails.
In the N*-LC, (i) the PA chain grows along the twisted LC molecules, particularly around the LC ones horizontally placed to the substrate, to give a helical chain. (ii) The neighboring helical chains spontaneously form a helical fibril through van der Waals interaction. (iii) Furthermore, the neighboring helical fibrils are gathered through van der Waals forces to produce a bundle of fibrils with helically twisted structure. (iv) Similar growths of helical PA chains, fibrils, and bundle of fibrils should occur simultaneously around the horizontally aligned LC molecules which are separated by a half helical pitch of the N*-LC, and (v) hence the bundles of fibrils are separated by a half helical pitch the N*-LC. (vi) When the N*-LC molecules exhibit a spiral or aligned structure, the bundle of fibrils also forms spiral or aligned morphology. The helical axes of N*-LC and H-PA are orthogonal to each other, irrespective of the structure of the N*-LC.
It is important to emphasize that in the right-handed N*-LC, for instance, the H-PA chain grows from the catalytic species in a left-handed manner. The H-PA chains with a screw direction opposite to that of N*-LC smoothly propagate along the LC molecules. When the H-PA chains with the same screw direction as that of the N*-LC encounter the LC molecules, a sterically unfavourable polymerization results. Thus, the acetylene polymerization mechanism in the N*-LC is called “bevel type screw arrangement” mechanism between the forming PA fibrils and the LC twist.10 The interfacial polymerization in the N*-LC on the basis of the “bevel type screw arrangement” mechanism should provide insights into construction of helical fibrils under asymmetric reaction field from molecular levels.
Footnote |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available. See DOI: 10.1039/c1sc00007a |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2011 |