José G.
Hernández
and
Eusebio
Juaristi
Departamento de Química, Centro de Investigación y de Estudios Avanzados del Instituto Politécnico Nacional (CINVESTAV-IPN), Apartado Postal 14–740, 07000 México, D.F., Mexico. E-mail: gregoriojose_@relaq.mx; juaristi@relaq.mx; Fax: +52 55 5747 3389; Tel: +52 55 5747 3722
First published on 19th April 2012
In line with the principles of “green” chemistry, organocatalysis seeks to reduce energy consumption and to optimize the use of the available resources, aiming to become a sustainable strategy in chemical transformations. Nevertheless, during the last decade diverse experimental protocols have made organocatalysis an even “greener” alternative by the use of friendlier reaction conditions, or via the application of solvent-free methodologies, or through the design and synthesis of more selective catalysts, or via the development of multicomponent one-pot organocatalytic reactions, or by the recycling and reuse of organocatalysts, or by means of the application of more energy-efficient activation techniques, among other approaches. In this feature article we review some of the remarkable advancements that have made it possible to develop even more sustainable asymmetric organocatalyzed methodologies.
José G. Hernández | José Gregorio Hernandez obtained his Bachelor in Science degree in 2007 from Universidad Industrial de Santander in Colombia under the direction of Prof. Vladimir V. Kouznetsov. In 2008 he joined Prof. Eusebio Juaristi's group at CINVESTAV-IPN in Mexico, where he is currently completing his PhD studies. His research interests include organic synthesis, green chemistry and asymmetric organocatalysis. |
Eusebio Juaristi | Eusebio Juaristi was born in Querétaro (México) and studied Chemistry at Instituto Tecnológico y de Estudios Superiores de Monterrey (B.Sc.) and at the University of North Carolina in Chapel Hill (PhD). Following a postdoctoral stay in the University of California-Berkeley, he returned to Mexico in 1979 as a Professor of Chemistry at CINVESTAV-IPN. He has been a Visiting Professor at the ETH-Zurich and UC-Berkeley. In 1998 he received Mexico's Presidential Medal of Science and in 2006 he became a member of El Colegio Nacional, highest academic distinction in Mexico. |
Scheme 1 Some characteristics fulfilling the “green” chemistry principles in the asymmetric aldol reaction catalyzed by L-proline.1a |
Nevertheless, during the last ten years significant efforts have been made by several researchers in order to render organocatalysis even more sustainable. Particular improvements involve the use of friendlier reaction conditions, the development of even more regio-, diastereo-, and enantioselective organocatalysts, the design of more energy-efficient activation techniques, the application of novel multicomponent “one-pot” protocols, the implementation of simpler work-up and purification procedures, the application of continuous flow processes, and the development of supported and recyclable catalysts. All these advancements contribute to the making of more sustainable organocatalytic processes.
With the purpose of reviewing recent advancements in the field of asymmetric organocatalysis from the point of view of “green” chemistry, we present and evaluate in this feature article some novel and ingenious approaches directed towards the development of “greener” organocatalytic processes. The examples reported here arise from a selection of significant contributions from the recent literature, which in our opinion demonstrate how progress in an emerging new area can be achieved in a sustainable manner.
In this regard, the attractiveness of water as solvent in organic reactions was first highlighted in the 1980s with the reports where Breslow describes a strong rate acceleration in Diels–Alder reactions that are carried out in water relative to organic solvents.3,4 Indeed, in addition to the unique physical properties displayed by water, aqueous reactions have been catalogued as privileged “green” processes, because they present desirable advantages from the point of view of environmental concerns, safety, and low cost.5
Nevertheless, the real “greenness” of aqueous-based organocatalytic reactions has been questioned.6 Indeed, for reactions performed in aqueous media, there is a significant possibility that the water being used as solvent will get contaminated by the organic compounds involved. Furthermore, Blackmond et al.6 argue that the disposal of discarded water by discharge into the normal drainage can end up being more polluting than a reaction carried out in traditional organic solvents with the proper after-treatment work-up.
Returning to the evaluation of the potential benefits attained from the use of water in chemical reactions, the first report of the use of water in an organocatalyzed aldol reaction comes from Barbas et al.7 In this work, it was found that the reaction between acetone and 4-nitrobenzaldehyde proceeds well in the presence of a small amount (less than 4 vol%) of water. By contrast, with increased amounts of water the enantioselectivity of the process decreased.
Following the work of Barbas and co-workers published in 2001,7 many reports have appeared describing the use of water, either as solvent, as co-solvent, or as additive in organocatalytic reactions.8 In an illustrative example, Barbas et al.9 found that hydrophobic diamine 1 (10 mol%) constitutes an efficient bifunctional catalyst in the aldol reaction of cyclic ketones with aromatic aldehydes in solvent water and in the presence of one equivalent of TFA, affording the aldol products with high diastereo- and enantioselectivity (Scheme 2).
Scheme 2 Aldol reactions catalyzed by diamine 1–TFA in water.9 |
Simultaneously and independently, Hayashi and co-workers10 reported the use of TBDPS-protected hydroxyproline 2 (10 mol%) as organocatalyst in the aldol reaction of cyclic ketones with aliphatic and aromatic aldehydes in water, obtaining the anti-aldol adducts with up to 99% ee (Scheme 3).
Scheme 3 The asymmetric aldol reaction in water catalyzed by 4-tert-butyldiphenylsiloxyproline 2. |
In addition to the work mentioned above, a great number of studies in aqueous media or in brine solution have been reported in the last decade.11Fig. 1 shows some of the most prominent organocatalysts employed in aldol, Michael, Mannich, and cycloaddition reactions, which have proven not only to tolerate aqueous media, but that actually benefit from the presence of water in the reaction medium.
Fig. 1 Examples of some water-compatible organocatalysts. |
In spite of the well-established effect of water as an enhancer of reactivity and selectivity in many organocatalytic processes, the role of water is not fully understood. Nevertheless, the exceptional physical properties of water, such as its high polarity, high surface tension, the ability to induce the hydrophobic effect, and especially water's capability to participate in hydrogen bonding, are frequently associated with the observed improvements.12
In this context,11h,x Tao and co-workers recently reported examples of aldol and Mannich reactions catalyzed by several amphiphilic organocatalysts derived from isosteviol and proline. In the presence of water the reactions proceeded efficiently affording the expected products in good to excellent yields and high stereoselectivity. The authors propose that water plays an important role in the transition state of the addition reaction through the formation of a hydrophobic chiral pocket induced by the presence of the lipophilic isosteviol unit. Additionally, the free hydroxyl groups of water in the interfacial surface could be involved in hydrogen bond formation, which leads to the observed improvement of the activity and stereoselectivity as a consequence of the more rigid transition state (Fig. 2).
Fig. 2 Proposed transition state for aldol reaction in the presence of water.11h |
In conclusion, from the “green” chemistry perspective, the use of water as a reaction medium offers a number of benefits: (1) it obviously avoids the use of toxic, volatile and/or corrosive solvents, (2) it usually minimizes the amount of catalyst that is required, (3) it frequently induces a significant acceleration of the reaction rate, and (4) it facilitates the isolation and purification of the products. Nevertheless, a frequent criticism directed to reactions using water consists in the lack of a general or practical procedure for the treatment of the aqueous phase at the end of the reaction to prevent the contamination of clean water sources.13
Scheme 4 Proline-catalyzed aldol reaction in [bmim][PF6].15 |
Since the disclosure of the two previous experiments, the popularity of ionic liquids has increased notoriously.16 In particular, a number of novel organocatalysts have been evaluated using ionic liquids as reaction media, for example in the aldol reaction,17 as well as in other important reactions such as Michael additions,18 α-amination19 and α-aminoxylation,20 Mannich reaction,21 Diels–Alder reaction,22 among others.23
A common problem encountered with immobilized organocatalysts when using ionic liquids or modified-ionic liquids is the substantial loss of catalyst during the stages of recovery and recycling, making it difficult to maintain high reaction yields and stereoselectivities after 3 or 4 cycles. A convenient way to minimize this drawback is to modify the organocatalyst's structure by incorporation of an imidazolium moiety, which reduces losses of the recovered catalysts. For instance, in 2006 Miao and Chan described the synthesis of novel organocatalyst 3 derived from (2S,4R)-4-hydroxyproline, which was evaluated in the direct aldol reaction between various ketones and several aldehydes.24 By comparison with reaction in conventional solvents such as acetone and dimethylsulfoxide, the ionic liquid-supported catalyst 3 (30 mol%) afforded the aldol products in good to excellent yields (40–92%) and with good enantioselectivities (60–87% ee). Furthermore, organocatalyst 3 showed superior catalytic efficiency than (S)-proline, and could be recovered readily and reused up to 4 cycles24 (Scheme 5).
Scheme 5 Aldol reaction catalyzed by ionic liquid-supported catalyst 3. |
Shortly thereafter, two reports in the literature described the use of structurally related catalysts in aldol reactions with IL as solvent.25 For instance, catalyst 4 (5 mol%) was used in the aldol reaction of cyclohexanone or hydroxyacetone with aromatic aldehydes in [bmim][Tf2N]. The expected products were obtained with good yields and stereoselectivities (Scheme 6a).25a
Scheme 6 Aldol reaction catalyzed by 4 and 5 in ionic liquid media. |
On the other hand, ionic liquid-supported proline 5 (10 mol%) was also evaluated in the aldol reaction of acetone and several aldehydes in [bmim][BF4]. The reaction proceeded efficiently and the products were generated with good enantioselectivities (Scheme 6b).25bFig. 3 shows salient examples of organocatalysts that have proved to be efficient in ionic liquid or as ionic liquid-supported catalysts.
Fig. 3 Representative examples of organocatalysts used in ILs and ionic liquid-supported catalysts. |
Relative to organocatalytic reactions performed in traditional organic solvents, the main benefits derived from the use of ILs as the reaction medium are (1) the possibility of exploring many diverse, potentially efficient combinations of functionalized ionic liquids, (2) the convenient recovery and efficient reuse of the catalyst, and (3), also in keeping with the tenets of “green” chemistry, the easy reutilization of the reaction medium.
However, it must be mentioned that moving from an organic solvent to an IL not always leads to a significant improvement in the selectivity of the catalyst or in the associated reaction rate. Furthermore, there are still many issues and unanswered questions regarding the real benefits of using ILs as reaction media. Some of the main concerns refer to their relatively high cost, potential human and environmental toxicity, poor biodegradability, high viscosity, and the need for laborious purification methodologies.26
Fig. 4 Common organic carbonates as potential “green” solvents. |
In 2009 North et al.28 evaluated ethylene and propylene carbonate (6 and 7, respectively, Scheme 7) as sustainable solvents in the asymmetric aldol reaction catalyzed by (S)-proline (10 mol%). The reaction of cyclic and acyclic ketones with aromatic aldehydes led to the formation of the desired aldol products in good chemical yields and good to excellent stereoselectivities (Scheme 7).28
Scheme 7 Asymmetric aldol reaction in cyclic carbonate solvents. |
In related work, North and co-workers studied the chiral solvent effect of propylene carbonate (R)-7 in organocatalyzed aldol reactions. These researchers found that using the appropriate combination of carbonate solvent and the “matching” proline enantiomer, the stereoselectivity of aldol adducts can be improved considerably (Scheme 8).29
Scheme 8 Asymmetric aldol reaction in chiral propylene carbonate. |
Recently, North et al. extended the application of cyclic carbonate solvents while studying the α-hydrazination of aldehydes and ketones by diazodicarboxylates organocatalyzed by (S)-proline (5 mol%).30
Regarding the actual “greenness” of organic carbonate solvents, the principal drawback is related to their preparation. Traditionally, the synthetic routes followed in the industrial-scale preparation of linear carbonates include the use of hazardous phosgene. On the other hand, the preparation of cyclic carbonates, despite involving 100% atom economical reactions, requires as starting material propylene oxide, which is highly toxic.
Nevertheless, new approaches directed to the preparation of organic carbonates using “greener” methodologies have been reported recently.27,31a–d
A strategy explored in some organocatalyzed processes has been the use of a large excess of a reagent which acts as reaction medium, avoiding the use of auxiliary solvents. For example, in aldol and Michael reactions it is possible to employ an excess of the nucleophilic component to perform the reactions under solvent-free conditions.32 In this sense, Gong et al.,32a Zhao et al.32c and Xiao et al.32e evaluated the aldol reaction of aromatic aldehydes using an excess of acetone (27–45 equiv.) under “solvent-free” conditions. For example, (S)-proline derivatives 8 and 9 catalyzed the desired reaction affording the aldol adducts in high yields and with excellent enantioselectivities. In the case of derivative 10, its organocatalytic activity was evaluated in several traditional solvents (e.g., CHCl3, CH2Cl2, THF, DMF, water); nevertheless, highest enantioinduction was obtained when using acetone both as reagent and solvent (>45 equiv.) (Scheme 9).32a,c,e
Scheme 9 Organocatalyzed asymmetric aldol reactions under solvent-free conditions using excess of acetone. |
Nevertheless, the use of a large excess of one of the reagents is not a true “green” solution. A better option has been the use of approximately equimolar amounts of reactants (1:1–1:10 equiv.), in more real solvent-free green methodologies.33 For instance, in 2007 Oriyama and Ishino33a reported a highly enantioselective asymmetric conjugate addition of thiols to α,β-unsaturated aldehydes catalyzed by organocatalyst 11 (10 mol%) under solvent-free conditions, using only a slight excess of aldehyde (1.5 equiv.). The reaction proceeded to give the corresponding chiral sulfides with excellent enantioselectivity (up to 99% ee) (Scheme 10).
Scheme 10 Asymmetric conjugate addition of thiols under solvent-free conditions.33a |
By the same token, prolinol sulfinyl ester 12 has been employed as organocatalyst in the absence of solvent. In particular, Zeng and Zhong33e found that when using only 3 equivalents of cyclohexanone as substrate, the Michael addition to nitroolefins catalyzed by 12 (10 mol%) proceeded in excellent yields and with high enantio- and diastereoselectivities, under solvent-free conditions at room temperature (Scheme 11).
Scheme 11 Michael addition of cyclohexanone to β-nitrostyrenes catalyzed by 12 under neat conditions.33e |
Recently, Li and co-workers reported the asymmetric Michael addition of diethyl malonate to nitroalkenes under solvent-free conditions using thiourea 13 as catalyst (10 mol%). The reaction was performed using stoichiometric amounts of reagents, in the complete absence of solvent, affording the corresponding Michael adducts in good to excellent yields and enantioselectivities. The versatility of the methodology was demonstrated in the key step of the synthesis of pregabalin, an amino acid derivative of γ-amino butyric acid, which has demonstrated to be an anticonvulsant drug used for neuropathic pain. The reaction allowed the formation of pregabalin hydrochloride 14 with high enantioselectivity (98% ee) (Scheme 12).33h
Scheme 12 Enantioselective Michael addition under solvent-free conditions. Application of chiral organocatalyst 13 in the enantioselective synthesis of pregabalin.33h |
The organocatalyzed aldol reaction has also been performed under solvent-free conditions. In 2009, Worch and Bolm applied the prolyl-substituted sulfonimidamides (S,S)- and (S,R)-15 as catalysts (10 mol%) in solvent-free asymmetric aldol reactions.33d Using 5 equivalents of cyclohexanone, the reaction proceeded to afford the aldol products in moderate to very good yields and with good to excellent stereoselectivities (Scheme 13). Also in 2009 Nájera and co-workers prepared and evaluated a series of prolinamides and prolinethioamides as catalysts in the direct asymmetric aldol reaction between various ketones and aromatic aldehydes under solvent-free reaction conditions.33f In particular, prolinethioamide 16 (5 mol%) proved to be an excellent catalyst when using only 2 equivalents of cyclohexanone as substrate under traditional magnetic stirring. The reaction took place efficiently, and the major anti-aldol products were obtained with high enantioselectivities (Scheme 13). Very recently, Lygo and co-workers reported the synthesis and application of the chiral primary tertiary diamine salt 17, as an organocatalyst (5 mol%) in the enantioselective aldol reaction between cyclohexanone and a series of aromatic aldehydes. After evaluation of several different solvents, the reaction proved to be more efficient under solvent-free conditions, using 3 equivalents of ketone (Scheme 13).33i
Scheme 13 Examples of organocatalyzed asymmetric aldol reactions in the absence of solvent. |
An interesting research work was recently reported by Concellón, del Amo, and co-workers. These researchers studied the direct aldol reaction organocatalyzed by (S)-proline but using TBD (triazabicyclo[4.4.0]dec-5-ene)-derived guanidinium salts as co-catalysts. The results revealed that the use of (S)-proline and achiral guanidinium salt 18 led to the formation of the anticipated aldol products in good to very good yields, and with very high diastereo- and enantioselectivities under solvent-free conditions and with no stirring (Scheme 14).33j,34
Scheme 14 Asymmetric aldol reaction under solvent-free conditions, in the absence of stirring. |
The historically most significant organocatalyzed transformation is the intramolecular aldol reaction (Robinson-type annulation),1i–m which has proved to be a most useful strategy in the asymmetric preparation of the Wieland–Miescher ketone 19 (WMK), a well-recognized synthon in the synthesis of natural products.35 A solvent-free Robinson annulation procedure in the synthesis of WMK 19 was reported by Rajagopalan and Swaminathan in 1996.36 Using L-proline as catalyst and under neat conditions the reaction afforded the ketone 19 with low enantioinduction. More recently, Nájera, Bonjoch and co-workers have reported solvent-free, highly stereoselective syntheses of WMK 19 and Wieland–Miescher ketone analogues.11q,33f,34,37a,b For example, using the binam-prolinamide 20 as catalyst, the reaction proceeded efficiently to give the corresponding bicyclic diketones in high isolated yields and with excellent enantioselectivities (Scheme 15).
Scheme 15 Solvent-free intramolecular aldol reaction.37a |
In a very recent report, Luo et al.37c described the asymmetric synthesis of WMK 19 as well as several analogues, through a solvent-free intramolecular aldol reaction catalyzed by chiral primary amine 21 (10 mol%). The protocol was also applied in the preparation of Hajos–Parrish ketone, affording in general the desired cyclic diketones in high yields and enantioselectivities (Scheme 16).
Scheme 16 Primary amine catalyzed intramolecular aldol reaction in the absence of solvent. |
The implementation of the solvent-free philosophy in organocatalyzed reactions represents a genuine advancement towards the goal to make the organocatalytic process “greener”. Indeed, reactions performed under highly concentrated conditions or in the total absence of solvent present relevant advantages such as environmental safety, cost savings, and decreased reaction times. The attributes associated with solvent-free strategies help make the overall organocatalyzed process more sustainable. Nevertheless, it is important to understand that although the reactions may take place efficiently, the work-up, the separation of the organocatalyst from the product mixture and the subsequent purification steps generally involve the use of chromatographic techniques which require large amounts of volatile solvents.
Scheme 17 Enantioselective aldol reactions under solvent-free conditions, using High-Speed Ball Milling (HSBM). |
In this regard, Nájera and co-workers have reported the use of (Sa)-binam-L-prolinamides as organocatalysts in solvent-free aldol reactions. In particular, the prolinamide 22 (10 mol%) proved to work well as an organocatalyst in the reaction between cyclohexanone and 4-nitrobenzaldehyde using a planetary ball mill. The reaction was carried out using only 2 equivalents of ketone at room temperature. The anti-aldol adduct was obtained in high yield and with good diastereo- and enantioselectivity (Scheme 17).33c,41
Recently, Hernández and Juaristi42 carried out the asymmetric aldol reaction between representative ketones and various aromatic aldehydes, catalyzed by the methyl ester of (S)-proline-(S)-phenylalanine, (S,S)-23 (7 mol%). The reactions were performed under solvent-free conditions in a ball mill, using essentially stoichiometric amounts of the starting ketone and aldehyde (1.1:1).42 In general, the reaction proceeds efficiently affording the anti aldol products with good diastereo- and enantioselectivities. Furthermore, it could be demonstrated that dipeptide (S,S)-23 is a more efficient organocatalyst in the asymmetric aldol reaction under solvent-free conditions, relative to the same reaction in solution. In addition, it was found that reaction times were shortened relative to the same reaction employing 10 mol% of amino acid (S)-proline, also in a ball mill under solvent-free conditions (Scheme 18).
Scheme 18 Asymmetric aldol reaction catalyzed by dipeptides 23 and 24 under ball-milling conditions. |
In more recent work, Hernández and Juaristi reported the asymmetric aldol reaction between ketones and various aromatic aldehydes under solvent-free conditions in a ball mill, with organocatalysis by several (S)-proline-containing dipeptides. It was observed that in the presence of an equimolar amount of water and a catalytic amount of benzoic acid, dipeptide (S,S)-proline-tryptophan-CO2Me 24 (3 mol%) was a particularly efficient catalyst affording the anti aldol products in good yields with high diastereo- and enantioselectivities. The better organocatalytic activity observed for 24 was explained as a result of the large aromatic area present in the lipophilic residue of tryptophan, which under solvent-free conditions and in the presence of an equimolar amount of water may promote the creation of a hydrophobic environment that could enhance non-covalent π–π interactions between the aromatic rings of the catalyst and the aldehydes, creating a more rigid transition state that induces higher stereoselectivity (Scheme 18).43
In related work, Hernández and Juaristi prepared and evaluated a series of (S,S)-proline-containing thiodipeptides, 25–27, as potential organocatalysts in aldol reactions under solvent-free reaction conditions using the HSBM technique. The thiodipeptide 25 (7 mol%) proved to be the most efficient catalyst in the reaction between cyclic ketones and aromatic aldehydes, affording the anti aldol products in good yields with high diastereo- and enantioselectivity. It is worth mentioning that the activity of catalysts 25–27 was also evaluated in the challenging aldol reaction between isatin derivatives and acetone. In that case the thiodipeptide 27 showed the major catalytic activity generating the hydroxy oxyindole derivatives in moderate to good yields and regular enantioselectivities (Scheme 19).44
Scheme 19 Solvent-free aldol reaction catalyzed by thiodipeptides 25–27 under ball-milling conditions.44 |
Recently, Xu et al. reported the Michael addition reaction of 1,3-dicarbonyl compounds to nitroolefins under solvent-free conditions in a ball mill. The reaction using catalyst 28 (0.5 mol%) afforded the corresponding adducts in very short milling times with high yields and stereoselectivities (Scheme 20).45
Scheme 20 Organocatalyzed Michael addition reaction under ball-milling conditions.45 |
Very recently, Lamaty and co-workers reported the enantioselective synthesis of amino esters under ball-milling conditions, using a chiral ammonium salt derived from cinchonidine 29 (10 mol%). The reaction of the Schiff base of glycine tert-butyl ester with several electrophiles under basic conditions afforded the desired alkylated products in excellent yields and with moderate enantioselectivities (Scheme 21).46
Scheme 21 Enantioselective alkylation reaction under ball-milling conditions.46 |
In summary, the High-Speed Ball Milling technique has proved in the last few years to be a useful option to promote solvent-free organocatalyzed reactions. Relative to solution reactions, under HSBM conditions reaction yields tend to be higher, milling times (reaction times) are usually shorter, and selectivities better. The latter is probably because in the absence of solvent no solvation effects exist and non-covalent interactions (e.g. hydrogen bonding, hydrophobic effect, π–π stacking) are enhanced. Another highlight of HSBM is that relative to other activation methods such as microwaves and ultrasound, the ball milling technique is more energy efficient, which is directly related to the “greenness” of the process.38c On the other hand, the principal drawback of HSBM is associated with the difficulty associated with the accurate measurement and control of the temperature and pressure inside the grinding jars.
On the other hand, the use of supercritical fluids as a reaction medium or the use of high pressure methodologies have the inconvenience of requiring extreme conditions (thus, high energy costs), and are accompanied by the requirement of special high-pressure apparatus to achieve the appropriate reaction conditions. Nevertheless, Hayashi and co-workers have reported an easy procedure to carry out organocatalytic reactions under high pressure. These researchers developed a convenient method for inducing high pressure by water-freezing in a sealed autoclave, taking advantage of the increased volume of liquid water when it freezes.48 This methodology has been used successfully in the asymmetric Baylis–Hillman reaction as well as in stereoselective aldol and Mannich reactions. The most evident beneficial effect of high pressure was observed in the Mannich reaction between various aldehydes, p-anisidine and acetone, organocatalyzed by (S)-proline (30 mol%) at −20 °C and 200 MPa. In particular, using p-bromobenzaldehyde the corresponding product was formed with better yield and with similar enantioinduction when compared with the same reaction at low pressure (Scheme 22).48
Scheme 22 Mannich reaction under ambient pressure and high pressure induced by water-freezing. |
It must be said that in addition to energy efficiency considerations, organocatalytic reactions employing MW, ultrasound or high pressure are generally performed in organic solvents such as DMF, DMSO, THF, CH3Cl or CH2Cl2, which are considered undesired reaction media in the “green” chemistry field. A real improvement in the “greenness” of organocatalysis using these special techniques could be obtained by performing the MW, ultrasound or high pressure reactions in the absence of solvent. In this context, in 2010 Procopio and co-workers reported the microwave-assisted organocatalytic conjugate addition of diethyl malonate to several enones, under various conditions. Surprisingly, the reaction catalyzed by 15 mol% of (S)-proline proved to work well under solvent-free conditions, using only a slight excess of diethyl malonate (1.2 equiv.).49 The Michael adducts were obtained in short reaction times with good yields and moderate to excellent enantioselectivities (40–99% ee) (Fig. 5).
Fig. 5 Michael adducts obtained under solvent-free conditions using MW irradiation. Reaction conditions: enone (5.0 mmol), diethyl malonate (6.0 mmol), piperidine (6.0 mmol), (S)-proline (15 mol%), 1.5–2.0 h of reaction time at 55 °C under MW irradiation. |
Indeed, the central principle of green chemistry is the high selectivity and efficiency of the catalytic materials. Of course, the use of highly selective catalytic reagents is superior relative to the employment of stoichiometric reagents. In this sense, it is common to find in organocatalytic reports that special attention is given to the specific effect of the amount of catalyst used. Generally, evaluation of the use of different amounts of organocatalyst shows that when using lower amounts reaction times become longer. Nevertheless, it is important to note that in many cases the stereoselectivity of the process remains remarkably high even when the amount of catalyst is diminished.
This at first sight unexpected effect was recently studied by Gröger, Berkessel and co-workers, who performed the aldol reaction between acetone and 3-chlorobenzaldehyde organocatalyzed by (R,R)-30. Surprisingly, these researchers found that a reduction in catalyst loading led to a dramatic improvement of the enantioselectivity for the formation of aldol product 31 (Scheme 23).51
Scheme 23 Effect of the amount of catalyst on the direct aldol reaction of 3-chlorobenzaldehyde with acetone catalyzed by (R,R)-30. |
The authors explained this result in terms of a change from kinetic control to thermodynamic control when the quantity of the catalyst is increased.51 This observation offers a new “green” alternative for making organocatalysts even more efficient: the traditional screening of the amount of catalyst in organocatalytic processes has to be carried out more carefully, since it could reveal that the ideal quantity of the catalyst is lower than anticipated, in fact diminishing costs by simply reducing the catalyst loading, and avoiding the use of excess catalyst and the addition of additives in the reaction media.
Indeed, several recent reports in the literature describe reactions that proceed more efficiently with rather low amounts of organocatalysts. Salient organocatalysts used in low quantity in aldol reactions, Michael reactions, Mannich reactions are presented in Fig. 6.52
Fig. 6 Structure of representative organocatalysts used in low loading. |
Regarding the recovery of organocatalysts, it is worth mentioning that some unsupported catalysts have been recovered by extractive acid–base work-up, simple filtration or centrifugation and reused with only minor decrease in its organocatalytic activity.11p,33f,34,37a,53
Nevertheless, a convenient strategy to render organocatalysts “greener” consists in their immobilization on a support with the purpose of facilitating catalyst recovery and reuse by simple work-up protocols.54 Additionally, in some cases immobilization processes allow the use of low amounts of the catalyst, because the active molecules are better distributed in the supporting material relative to a non-supported catalyst. The immobilization approach has been applied to simple organocatalysts such as proline, although the major benefits have been reported with support of more complex organocatalysts.
Recent strategies employ immobilized organic catalysts in friendly reaction media such as ionic liquids, water,8b or solvent-free methodologies. For example, Wennemers and co-workers55 reported the immobilization of a potent tripeptide H-L-Pro-L-Pro-L-Asp-NH2 organocatalyst on different resins. The anchored catalysts were evaluated in the aldol reaction between acetone and various aldehydes. Best results were obtained using TentaGel (polyethylene glycol–polystyrene) and PEGA (polyethylene glycol–polyacrylamide) as solid support. In particular, under solvent-free conditions and using an excess of acetone, solid-supported tripeptide 32 exhibited comparable or better reactivity and selectivity relative to a non-supported tripeptide (Scheme 24).55 Catalyst 32 could be recycled and reused up to 8 cycles, preserving the stereoselectivity of the aldol process, although the chemical yield diminished after 3 runs.
Scheme 24 Asymmetric aldol reaction under solvent-free conditions catalyzed by supported tripeptide 32. |
Recently, Gao, Lu and Li used the chiral diamine-polyoxometalate (POM) acid combined organocatalyst 33 in the asymmetric direct aldol reaction of long-chain aliphatic ketones with various aromatic aldehydes, in the absence of solvent and using an excess of ketone. Catalyst 33 (2.5 mol%) activated the formation of the corresponding aldol adducts in good to high yields (54–95%) and with good enantioselectivities (80–91% ee) (Scheme 25).56 Chiral diamine-POM 33 could be easily recovered by simple filtration and recyclability was verified in 5 consecutive cycles showing only minor diminution in yield and enantioselectivity.
Scheme 25 Solvent-free aldol reaction promoted by catalyst 33.56 |
In this context, in 2008 Yan and Wang prepared several Merrifield resin-supported dipeptides and tripeptides, and evaluated them as organocatalysts in the asymmetric direct aldol reaction. The best catalyst proved to be dipeptide H-L-Pro-L-Ala-O-resin 34 (10 mol%), whose efficiency was then optimized via screening of different reaction media, observing best results under neat conditions. For example, the reaction of cyclic and acyclic ketones with aromatic aldehydes afforded the corresponding aldol products with good to excellent yields (52–98%), good diastereoselectivities (anti:syn = 20:80–90:10) and enantioselectivities (75–95% ee) (Fig. 7).57 Additionally, catalyst 34 was reused up to 7 cycles without loss of activity or stereoselectivity.
Fig. 7 Representative supported organocatalysts used under solvent-free conditions. |
In related work, Nájera et al.58 described the preparation of polystyrene-supported binam-prolinamide 35, and its evaluation as an organocatalyst in asymmetric aldol reactions. Immobilized prolinamide 35 proved to be an efficient catalyst under solvent-free conditions (8 equiv. of ketone) or aqueous conditions. The reaction afforded the aldol adducts in high yields and stereoselectivities (Fig. 7). Furthermore, anchored prolinamide 35 showed recyclability in the reaction between cyclohexanone and 4-nitrobenzaldehyde, up to 6 cycles with only a slight decrease of yield and without loss of stereoselectivity in the aldol reaction.58
To close our discussion about “greener” organocatalysts, it is important to mention their potential role in asymmetric one-pot reactions, which is one of the most effective strategies for the “green” synthesis of complex molecular structures by carrying out sequentially multiple chemical steps in a single reaction vessel.59 The field of organocatalytic one-pot reactions is in fact an emblematic example of “green” chemistry, because in addition to all the advantages associated with organocatalysts, one-pot processes avoid the time and cost-consuming steps of protection and deprotection, as well as the corresponding work-up procedures. Furthermore, organocatalytic one-pot reactions minimize or avoid the generation of waste associated with the purification of intermediates. Finally, organocatalytic one-pot reactions frequently exhibit high yields and stereoselectivities. The above-mentioned attributes have made multicomponent one-pot protocols a priority option in natural product synthesis.60
Fig. 8 presents some of the most representative organocatalysts used in one-pot reactions, such as the Jørgensen–Hayashi catalyst, MacMillan imidazolidinones, cinchona derivatives, thioureas, and bifunctional amino-thiourea catalysts.61–66
Fig. 8 Examples of salient catalysts used in organocatalytic one-pot reactions. |
Unfortunately, space limitations prevent discussion in this feature article of the “green” characteristics of organocatalyzed cycloaddition, epoxidation, multicomponent, cascade, and other interesting reactions. Nevertheless, the analysis made here with aldol, Michael, Mannich or alkylation reactions is also valid and easily extendable to other organocatalyzed processes.
All “green” contributions in the field of organocatalysis are very valuable because in addition to the preparation of the desired products, chemists implicitly have the social compromise to be more creative in the design of friendlier methodologies that prevent or at least reduce deleterious environmental impact.
During the last ten years, the progress of organocatalysis has been accompanied, in a synergetic combination, by “green” approaches that have made organocatalytic processes even “greener”. The above considerations motivated us to review and highlight here some salient approaches that from our perspective show clearly how the expansion of a new area can be made in a sustainable way.
Having discussed in the above sections the advantages and drawbacks associated with some “green” alternatives in organocatalysis, it is worth mentioning that a “green” reaction does not imply a “green” global process. Indeed, “green” processes not only have to evaluate the type of reaction media, the recyclability of the catalyst, or the activation strategy: a true “green” process must take into account all aspects involved, from the design of the chemical route to the final after-treatment of undesirable waste. Nevertheless, all the approaches described here, as well as others such as the use of fluorinated solvents, continuous flow, and microreactor techniques, are already contributing to the important goal to make organocatalytic processes more sustainable.
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2012 |