Loveleen K. Brar,
Gourav Singla and
O. P. Pandey*
School of Physics and Materials Science, Thapar University, Patiala, India. E-mail: oppandey@thapar.edu; brarloveleen@thapar.edu; gsinghla@gmail.com; Fax: +91 175 2393020; Tel: +91 175 2393130
First published on 21st November 2014
Carbon-coated nano tantalum carbide (TaC) has been synthesized at 800 °C using tantalum-ethoxide precursor by the single step chemical reaction route without using any external carbon source. The XRD results of the synthesized samples indicate that formation of TaC starts immediately upon heating but the complete transformation is observed only after 10 h of holding at 800 °C. The 10h sample shows distinct decarburization and oxidation peaks in DSC/DTG. The surface weighted sizes obtained from double-Voigt method were confirmed by BET. The BET analysis shows that synthesized powders have large surface area and contain a mixture of micropores and mesopores. The morphology and particle size distribution analysis shows that the powders are of faceted to spherical shape with thin carbon coating having size variation primarily between 20–40 nm. DSC/TG, XRD and microstructure analysis results have been used to predict the mechanism for the formation of the carbon coated nano-TaC particles.
Over last few years many methods have emerged for the synthesis of TaC nano-particles. Ta2O5 and TaCl5 have emerged as the most common precursors for the synthesis of TaC. These along with various carburization sources have been used for the synthesis of nano-TaC either in vacuum or inert atmosphere where the single phase TaC nano-particles are obtained only at temperatures greater than 1000 °C.4,14–21 Addition of catalysts such as Mg, Ni7,16 and/or halogenation agents such as NaF16,20 can reduce the reduction temperature. Recent reports indicate that TaC can be synthesized using TaCl5 precursor at temperature range of 600–900 °C.5,6,22 Use of organic precursors has mostly been limited to multistep processes involving formation of dispersed Ta2O5 followed by carburization using an external carbon source.16,23,24
Cubic carbides like TaC can tolerate large deficiencies of carbon without changing the structure type.1,22,25 But the carbon content is related with the mechanical properties of the material and also the surface stoichiometric properties which ultimately affect the catalytic response of the material.1,4 So the synthesized TaC powders need to be characterized for size, specific surface area as well as stoichiometry.22 The final characteristics of the synthesized product depends largely on the carbon content in the reaction mixture as well as the homogeneity of mixing.26 In most of the currently prevalent methods the reduction in reaction temperature and product size is achieved by multiple steps involving formation of nano – Ta2O5 followed by its mixing with carbon source and/or heating in reducing carbon rich atmosphere. Slight variation in any one of the steps can change the properties of the final product drastically.15,22,26
To control the particle size and maintain the purity of the synthesized transition metal carbide nanopowder, the single step chemical reaction method in autoclave has been developed.27,28 In the present study we report the single step synthesis of carbon-coated nano-TaC. Commercial grade Ta-ethoxide has been used as Ta precursor as well as carbon source. Here the in situ carbon, produced during the decomposition of Ta-ethoxide, has been utilized for the reduction and carburization in the presence of reducing agent Mg at 800 °C to get TaC nanopowder. To the best of our knowledge synthesis of nano TaC from Ta-ethoxide or any other organic precursor has not been reported so far at such a low temperature.
X-ray line profile analysis allows for meaningful determination of size and strain of the product which can be used to correlate the microstructure of the synthesized powders with their properties. Scherrer relation is still the most commonly used method for the determination of domain size for coherent scattering in the given sample. The domain size obtained from the Scherrer relation is a volume weighted quantity. Scherrer relation uses full width at half maxima (FWHM) of the XRD peaks for the determination of domain size, t:
(1) |
Wilson defined “integral breadth apparent size” where the integral breadth, β (A/I0, A: area of the peak, I0: maximum intensity) is used instead of FWHM29 to define the volume weighted crystallite size, 〈Dv〉:
(2) |
For both the above cases the peak broadening is attributed to the coherently diffracting domain size. Stokes and Wilson gave the relation for broadening solely due to strain.29 The maximum strain, e, is given by:
β = 4etanθ | (3) |
Willamson–Hall plot is used extensively to separate the size and strain effects:29,30
(4) |
In the above equation it is assumed that the strain and size broadening functions are Lorentzian in nature. Since Lorentzian or Gaussian functions cannot satisfactorily model the specimen broadening exclusively, it is assumed that both size and strain effects are approximated by either Voigt or its approximation – pseudo-Voigt function.31 In the present case individual peaks have been fitted with pseudo-Voigt function which is a linear combination of Lorentzian (L(x)) and Gaussian (G(x)) functions:31,32
F(x) = ηL(x) + (1 − η)G(x) | (5) |
For the peak fitting the peak shape is assumed to be symmetrical. The split pseudo-Voigt function is known to provide better fits. Here, the results after best-fit were chosen taking into account the minimum error as well as realistic values for the fitting parameters. The obtained integral breadths are a combination of instrumental and specimen broadening so the instrumental corrected integral breadths were estimated from the measured data.31
(6) |
(7) |
(8) |
βSL, βDL are modified Lorentzian components of size and strain integral breadth.
βSG, βDG are modified Gaussian components of size and strain integral breadth
and,
(9) |
This method is called “Double-Voigt” method. βL and βG2 are plotted w.r.t. s2 and the corresponding strain and size components βSL, βDL(hkl), βSG, βDG(hkl) are obtained. The analytical expressions for the volume weighted domain size, 〈Dv〉, strain, 〈ε2〉1/2 and size coefficients, As(L) are:29,31
(10) |
(11) |
(12) |
Eqn (11) is used to determine the r.m.s. strain distribution w.r.t. size (L) and direction. The initial slope of the As(L) vs. L graph is used to determine the surface weighted domain size.29,31 Surface weighted domain size determination of the powder is important for the applications where the active surface area is important e.g. catalysis.33 The single line and double line analysis were carried out using Origin software.
DTA/TG (Diamond TG/DTA, Perkin Elmer) and DSC/TG (NETZSCH STA 449F3) were done at a heating rate of 5 °C min−1 in air atmosphere to determine the phase transitions and thermal stability of the materials. TG provides information in two forms: mass change as a function of either temperature or time which is a direct indication and the derivative of mass loss (DTG) as a function of temperature or time which helps to pinpoint any shoulders present in data.34 The micro-structural features of synthesized TaC powders were analyzed with field-emission scanning electron microscope (FE-SEM) (QUANTA 200 FEG) operating at 20 kV and transmission electron microscope (TEM) (JEOL 2100F) operating at 200 kV. The N2 sorption studies for surface analysis were conducted using a BELSORP-max (BEL, Japan) to determine the Brunauer–Emmett–Teller (BET) surface area, the pore size, and the pore volume.
Ta2(OC2H5)10 + 30O2 → Ta2O5 + 20CO2 + 25H2O | (13) |
Fig. 2 XRD results of acid leached samples synthesized from Ta-E precursor with different soaking times at 800 °C. TaC (peaks indexed) is the major phase formed for all the samples. |
Sample name | Soaking time | Minor phases | χ2 | Rwp | a (nm) | x |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
2h | 2 h | Ta4O, Ta2C | 2.10 | 8.47 | 0.445547 | 0.990 |
5h | 5 h | Ta4O, Ta2C | 2.38 | 9.16 | 0.445557 | 0.991 |
8h | 8 h | Ta4O, Ta2C | 2.14 | 8.56 | 0.445533 | 0.989 |
10h | 10 h | Ta2C | 1.99 | 7.57 | 0.445738 | 1.000 |
12h | 12 h | Ta2C | 1.72 | 8.24 | 0.445532 | 0.985 |
Detailed analysis of the XRD patterns reveals that nearly 90% conversion to TaC has taken place even for 2h sample. However, the complete conversion to TaC needs 10 h. For the 10h sample the minority phase T4O is absent indicating complete reduction of the oxide and intensity of Ta2C is also smallest for this sample. A further increase in soaking time results in an increase in the Ta2C peak indicating that the carbon is getting removed from the TaC and the concentration of Ta2C phase is increasing. The XRD data is best fitted with cubic space group Fmm and it was observed that the lattice parameter changes as the synthesis time is varied. Fig. 3a gives the Rietveld refinement plots for the 10h sample.
The Wyckoff positions used for Rietveld refinement of XRD data are 4a (0, 0, 0) for Ta and 4b (0.5, 0.5, 0.5) for C. Table 1 gives the lattice parameter, RWP and χ2 – values obtained from the Rietveld refinement of the XRD data. The lattice parameter of the synthesized samples from the Rietveld refinement have been used to determine x, the fraction of C in the TaCx:25
a (Å) = 4.3007 + 0.1563x | (14) |
The data (Table 1) clearly shows that for the 10h sample, the phase formed is TaC1.0 (ICDD – 01-089-2870). With further increase in the soaking time the decrease in lattice constant supports the conjecture about the carbon loss from TaC as the soaking time is increased beyond 10 h.
Single line and double-Voigt integral breadth analysis methods have been used to determine the strain and size of the synthesized samples from the XRD profiles. Peak position (2θ), gaussian integral breadth (βG) and Lorentzian integral breadth (βL) of the Bragg peaks from the XRD data were determined by profile fitting technique using pseudo-Voigt function. Fig. 3b shows the results obtained from the fitting of pseudo-Voigt function for the (111) peak for the 10h sample. Fig. 4 gives the single line and double-Voigt integral breadth method analysis graphs for the 10h sample. Similar graphs have been used to analyse all the samples. Table 2 gives the details of the size and strain values obtained for the single line and double-Voigt integral breadth methods. A comparison of the volume weighted particle sizes and strains obtained from single line method and the double-Voigt method shows that the single line method which takes into consideration only the Lorentzian contributions to size and Gaussian contributions to strain ends up overestimating the size and underestimating the strain in the samples.
Sample name | Single-line analysis | Double-Voigt analysis | |||
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Crystallite size (nm) | Max strain (×10−4) | r.m.s. strain (×10−4) | 〈Dv〉 (nm) | 〈Ds〉 (nm) | |
2h | 71 | 2.14 | 1.71 | 22 | 13 |
5h | 39 | 2.37 | 1.89 | 20 | 12 |
8h | 39 | 0.71 | 0.56 | 21 | 8 |
10h | 113 | 2.53 | 2.02 | 45 | 25 |
12h | 49 | 2.30 | 1.83 | 21 | 12 |
From the single line analysis the strain obtained for the 8h sample is minimum and the size is comparable to 5h sample. This is counterintuitive since the peaks for 8h sample are broadest (Fig. 2). Double-Voigt analysis shows that though the volume weighted column lengths for 2h, 5h and 8h samples are comparable but the surface weighted column length is actually smallest for 8h sample (Fig. 5a). This implies that the particle size and hence the surface area will be largest for 8h sample.
The analysis of XRD data (Tables 1 and 2) clearly shows that for the 10h sample the unit cell size, particle size and strain are maximum. Since double-Voigt method allows for the determination of the r.m.s. strain distribution w.r.t. size and direction so the strains for different planes within the particles for synthesized samples are compared. For the 2h, 5h, 8h and 12h samples the r.m.s. strains are isotropic. Inset in Fig. 5b shows the variation of the strain in all the directions for 8h sample. But for the 10h sample the strain for the (111) plane is very large (Fig. 5b) as compared to that for the other planes. The large amount of strain present in (111) plane may be due to complete filling of octahedral voids with carbon for this sample. The same may also be responsible for increasing the unit cell size and the particle size.
The results of XRD data analysis show that both 8h and 10h samples are good prospective candidates for the electro-catalytic activities; the 10h sample due to its enhanced strain which makes it more reactive and the 8h sample due to its larger surface area which provides more reaction sites. The electrochemical activity of both the samples will need to be probed to assess the comparative importance of strain and surface area for the catalytic activities.
Fig. 6 DSC-TG-DTG curves of sample (a) 2h (b) 10h. For the 10h sample the peaks for carbon removal and oxidation are well separated. |
Sample name | Weight gain start (°C) | DSC main peak (°C) | DTG peak 1 (°C) | DTG peak 2 (°C) | Average pore diameter (nm) | Surface area (m2 g−1) | Pore volume (cm3 g−1) |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
2h | 167 | 578 | 584 | 715 | 12.244 | 74.909 | 0.2293 |
5h | 162 | 595 | 604 | 710 | 12.404 | 95.383 | 0.2958 |
8h | 183 | 586 | 590.5 | 716 | 9.1541 | 159.67 | 0.3654 |
10h | 339 | 573, 598 | 576, 601 | 720 | 14.023 | 44.851 | 0.1572 |
12h | 206 | 580.4 | 581 | 721 | 14.199 | 56.113 | 0.1992 |
Initial heating from room temperature onwards results in mass loss which is followed by mass gain. The initial mass loss is indicative of the amount of chemical species adsorbed onto the surface of the particles.22 For our samples before oxidation nearly 2 mass% of surface adsorbed species is removed. This corresponds to potentially large surface area available for adsorption. The start of mass gain in TG curve is an indicator of the stability of the synthesized samples since the weight gain in the samples is due to oxidation of TaC resulting in formation of Ta2O5 and CO2.8 The 2h and 5h samples have nearly the same oxidation stability (Table 3) but as the soaking time is increased the samples are becoming more stable. The 10h sample is most stable for oxidation in air with the weight gain in TG starting at around 339 °C (Fig. 6b). The 12h sample shows decrease in stability which is expected as it is carbon deficient.
The first peak in DTG with a corresponding exothermic peak in DSC and maximum mass gain in TG gives the temperature for the conversion of TaC into Ta2O5. This conversion is a two-step process: release of carbon from the TaC followed by oxidation. For the TaCx (x < 1) samples the two processes occur simultaneously as there are already carbon vacancies present in the system. But for the case where x = 1 (10h sample) the oxidation occurs after the removal of carbon and the DSC as well as DTG curve show well defined peaks for the two processes: the carbon removal occurring at 573 °C followed by oxidation at 598 °C (Fig. 6b). The ΔH values represent the amount of heat required for a reaction and were determined from the total area enclosed by the thermal analysis peak using software package provided with the thermal analyzer. The ΔH for the two processes is 25.73 J g−1 and 21.2 J g−1 respectively. The high temperature inflection point (>700 °C) in DTG curve, with a corresponding peak/hump in DSC, occurs at nearly the same temperature for all the samples and is attributed to oxidation and combustion of the carbonaceous residue.13
If the sample consists of pure TaC, its oxidation will result in 14.5% increase in mass. In our case this is never achieved. Maximum increase encountered is nearly 4.5 mass% after the initial weight loss stops for the 8h sample. This small increase in mass as compared with the expected value is due to the presence of carbonaceous content in the synthesized samples.8 The presence of carbonaceous residue is indicated/supported by XRD data as well as TEM images. As the sample is heated the mass increase due to oxidation is being offset by the decrease in mass due to oxidation of carbonaceous residue. The residual mass at 800 °C for all the samples is 85–90%. This leads to the conclusion that the carbonaceous content in our samples ranges from 20–25%.36 All the TGA curves become nearly stable after 780–795 °C. Even heating up to 1200 °C further shows a loss of 1% indicating that carbonaceous substance is not removed completely (data not shown). So the determination of exact TaC content in the individual samples is not possible.
Fig. 8a and b shows the representative TEM images of the synthesized TaC nanoparticles for 10h sample. The presence of carbon coating on the surface of each particle is clearly visible. Moreover, the morphology of carbon coated nanoparticles varies from faceted to spherical and they have a tendency to aggregate. Fig. 8c gives the High Resolution-TEM (HRTEM) image of a single crystalline TaC nanoparticle and shows the (111) facets of the particle. The distance between the adjacent lattice fringes is the interplanar distance of cubic TaC (111), which is 0.26 nm (ICDD Pattern – 01-089-2870). This suggests that the synthesized TaC powder has cubic crystalline structure.
It is observed from TEM images that the particle size distribution is broad (Fig. 8d). The particle size measurement was done on nearly 100 particles from different areas/scans and follows the well documented log-normal distribution.37 The log-normal probability distribution (Fig. 8d) is calculated by adopting the following equations:
(15) |
(16) |
(17) |
Fig. 9 shows the N2 adsorption–desorption isotherms for the synthesized samples. The adsorption isotherms exhibit the characteristics of a type-II isotherm according to IUPAC classification.3,38 An empirical classification of the hysteresis loops which gives information about the texture of the adsorbent has also been given by IUPAC and the isotherms show H-4 hysteresis characteristics.38,39 This implies that the powders are forming a complex structure with both micropores and mesopores. This behaviour is because of agglomeration of particles in the synthesized product.
Fig. 9 N2 adsorption–desorption isotherms for the synthesized samples. Inset shows the variation if BET surface area for the synthesized samples with increasing soaking time. |
Ta2(OC2H5)10 → TaO + gaseous organic intermediates | (18) |
The exact nature of the gaseous organic intermediate(s) cannot be determined as the decomposition of Ta-E is taking place in a closed oxygen deficient environment. MgO is one of the most active catalysts for reduction.40 Hence, its presence results in reduction of the gaseous organic compounds to hydrogen and carbon.
Since the carbon is present in excess in Ta-E so the amount of carbon produced is high enough to completely coat the initially formed TaO powder. This carbon coating helps to increase the reaction rate for reduction and carburization by ensuring the close proximity of the reactants. Moreover, the carbon coating also prevents the oxide particles from coalescing which ensures that the final product is in nanometer range.35 The initially formed TaO transforms to TaC via formation of Ta4O and Ta2C (Fig. 2). In the entire set of experiments no evidence of Ta was found in any of the samples, rather Ta2C was present. Since the carbon is present in sufficiently high concentration so it is possible that Ta obtained from reduced oxide may get converted into Ta2C immediately and then to TaC. Fig. 11 gives the schematic of the proposed mechanism. In the present system the formation of TaC starts with the reduction of TaO rather than Ta2O5 so this leads to lowering of reaction/formation temperature and time.
Reaction rate within the autoclave is also very high as is evident from the nearly 80–90% conversion within 2 h for all the temperatures (data not shown). However, the complete conversion needs 10 h at 800 °C (Fig. 2 and 10). The higher time required for complete conversion is because of the fact that in the initial stage diffusion of carbon through the surface leads to formation of TaC on the outer surface of the particle and this formed TaC layer creates hindrance for further diffusion of carbon inside. The large concentration of carbon in the outer coating still facilitates the diffusion of carbon into inner unreacted core even through the TaC.
However, the carbon atoms now need to travel longer distance which makes the final process time dependent as the diffusion path of carbon increases with time as the reaction progresses. In order to facilitate the entire process the travel rate of carbon can be made faster by increasing the holding temperature as is evident from Fig. 10 where complete conversion is not taking place at 700 °C in the same time duration (10 h) as has been obtained at 800 °C (Fig. 2).
The presence of graphitic carbon along with the nano-size of the powders makes the final product a good candidate for superior consolidation properties.41,42 Samples obtained from the present method have high surface area and are also strained. Both these conditions are conducive for high absorption of the reactant species and hence make the synthesized powders good candidates for catalytic applications. Presence of adherent carbon coating on the surface is favorable for the material so as to have conductive behavior of both C and TaC. The carbon coating will also contribute towards the stability of the powders in the harsh environments in reaction chambers.
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2015 |