Michael
Benz‡
,
Henrik
Braband‡
,
Paul
Schmutz
,
Jonathan
Halter
and
Roger
Alberto
*
Department of Chemistry, University of Zürich, Winterthurerstr. 190, CH-8057 Zürich, Switzerland. E-mail: ariel@chem.uzh.ch
First published on 5th September 2014
Bis-arene complexes of technetium represent a fundamental class of organometallic compounds. Due to complex synthetic routes, no detailed insights into their properties have been reported so far. Reacting [99TcO4]− with arenes in the exclusive presence of AlCl3 gives highly stable [99Tc(arene)2]+ in good yields. These complexes have extraordinarily high stabilities, where oxidation is found to occur at potentials higher than +1.3 V and reduction at potentials below −2 V vs. Fc/Fc+. The 99mTc analogues are similarly synthesised by applying a novel ionic liquid extraction pathway. Complexes of 99mTc with suitably functionalized arenes will represent new building blocks for bioorganometallic pharmaceuticals in molecular imaging.
Bis-arene complexes [Re(η6-C6HnR6−n)2]+ (n = 1–6) are known but have been rarely studied and not in great detail. The first bis-arene complex of 99Tc was prepared by a very uncommon method, namely by element transmutation from [99Mo(arene)2] via β−-decay 99Mo → 99mTc → 99Tc, the latter resulting directly from weighable amounts of 99TcCl4 in the presence of Al0 and AlCl3,7,8 in low yields.9 Only recently, Kudinov and coworkers reported an improved synthesis of [Re(arene)2]+ in moderate yields directly from K[ReO4] with Zn0 as the reductant, AlCl3 as a Lewis acid and the arene as solvent.10 For over 50 years, no progress was made in the study of [99Tc(η6-C6HnR6−n)2]+ type compounds, not only due to the radioactivity of this element but also because of synthetic difficulties. The preparation of binary halides such as 99TcCl4 as starting materials for accessing bis-arene complexes has made a significant impact over the past couple of years.11–13 Their syntheses are well described but their preparation and isolation are still not routine. A direct, high yield route to [99Tc(arene)2]+ complexes from [99TcO4]− salts would therefore be highly desirable since it would allow for the chemical exploration of these fundamental complexes and for classifying their properties in relation to neighboring elements. In addition, arene complexes with metastable 99mTc are potential molecular imaging agents: phenyl groups are frequent in pharmaceuticals and coordination of a 99mTc fragment to such arenes enables labeling without additional, pendent ligands,14 a concept verified with the {Cr(CO)3} moiety bound to e.g. a phenyl ring in estradiol.15,16 The importance of the {M(arene)}n+ moiety is corroborated by the impact of the {Ru(cymantrene)}2+ fragment in medicinal inorganic chemistry.17,18 Among their endeavors for new myocardial imaging agents, Wester et al. reported the synthesis of [99mTc(arene)2]+ complexes in the early nineties. However, since the yields were “variable”, the syntheses were multi-step, and the pharmacology was not satisfactory, the compounds were not studied any further.19 Enthusiastic about new 99Tc chemistry and convinced that the application of [99mTc(arene)2]+ complexes will extend beyond myocardial imaging, we developed practical, one step syntheses of [99(m)Tc(arene)2]+ complexes in high yields and radiochemical purities, working towards a deeper understanding of the chemical and reactive properties of fundamental [99Tc(arene)2]+ complexes.
To confirm the identities of [1][PF6], [2][PF6], [3][PF6] and [4][PF6], their structures were elucidated by single crystal X-ray diffraction (ESI, Section 4†). An ellipsoid representation of the tetralin complex is given in Fig. 1. These structures complete the series of bis-arene complexes with respect to the neighboring group 6 and 8 elements and the straight forward preparation paves the way for exploring fundamental chemistry and physico-chemical properties of [99Tc(η6-C6HnR6−n)2]+ type complexes.
Fig. 1 ORTEP representation20 of the [99Tc(tetralin)2]+ ([4]+) cation of the [4][PF6] structure. Thermal ellipsoids are represented at the 50% probability level. Hydrogen atoms are omitted for clarity. Selected bond lengths [Å] and angles [°]: Tc1–C1 2.219(2), Tc1–C2 2.228(2), Tc1–C3 2.231(2), Tc1–C4 2.227(2), Tc1–C5 2.250(2), Tc1–C6 2.250(2), C1–Tc1–C4 77.82(10), C2–Tc1–C5 78.34(9), C3–Tc1–C6 78.43(9). |
We emphasise that no metallic reducing agent is present in these reactions. Whilst chloride reduces [99TcVIIO4]− to TcV or TcIV, arenes may also act as reductants under Friedel–Crafts conditions to achieve oxidation states lower than TcIV. Indeed, when the reaction was carried out in cyclohexane and AlCl3 with [NBu4][99TcOCl4] and with no arene present, a yellow precipitate formed from a blue solution. Evaporation of the solvent and crystallization of the crude solid under N2 in dimethylformamide (DMF) gave large yellow crystals. From X-ray analysis the intermediate was confirmed to be [Al(DMF)6][99TcCl6]Cl·DMF. The presence of this TcIV complex supports the role of AlCl3 as a reducing agent of TcVII or TcVto form TcIV. Consequently, the reaction to afford [99Tc(arene)2]+ complexes can also be performed from K2[99TcCl6] with otherwise identical conditions as those from K[99TcO4] (ESI, Section 1†). The complexes [2][PF6] and [4][PF6] were prepared by this route in good yields.
These reactions represent a new procedure towards bis-arene complexes of group 7 elements. They combine pure arene substitution with elements already present in the desired oxidation state with concerted reduction–coordination, but without additional reductants such as Zn0 or Al0. Only one similar process, for [Fe(C6H6)2]2+, has been reported in the literature.21
The reaction of K[99TcO4] in benzene with AlCl3 did not lead to [99Tc(C6H6)2]+ ([1]+). In this reaction, only unidentified products formed and 99Tc NMR spectra gave no evidence for TcI species. Significant amounts of [99TcO4]− (∼50%) could be recovered. We concluded that substituted alkenes with enhanced donating properties stabilised the intermediate oxidation states better than unsubstituted benzene. This interpretation is supported by the marked electrochemical differences found between the complexes (vide infra). Complex [1][PF6] could be synthesized from [99TcO4]−via the Fischer–Hafner route in moderate yields with Zn dust as a reductant.
99Tc NMR spectroscopy provides valuable insights into the symmetry and electronic properties of technetium complexes.17,22 TcI signals are typically found between −3000 and −1000 ppm relative to [99TcO4]− at 0 ppm.23 Due to a scalar coupling of the nuclear spin (I = 9/2) to the quadrupole moment of the 99Tc nucleus, decreasing symmetry of the complexes is accompanied by a strong line broadening. However, the presented [99Tc(arene)2]+ complexes have highly symmetrical first coordination spheres, reflected in their small half line widths (8–26 Hz). The observed 99Tc NMR signals, [99Tc(benzene)2]+ at −1860 ppm (ν1/2 = 8 Hz), [99Tc(toluene)2]+ at −1744 ppm (ν1/2 = 26 Hz), [99Tc(tetralin)2]+ at −1586 ppm (ν1/2 = 11 Hz) and [99Tc(mesitylene)2]+ at −1532 ppm (ν1/2 = 14 Hz), suggest that a higher substitution pattern at the aromatic backbone leads to a shift in the 99Tc resonance to lower field. The 99Tc NMR spectrum of [4][PF6] (including the side product [5][PF6]) is shown in Fig. 2. All 99Tc NMR spectra are given in Section 3 of the ESI.†1H NMR spectra show the strong influence of the metal center on the shift of the aromatic protons, which appear in the region around 5.5 ppm. Comparable features are found for isoelectronic complexes of the benzene complexes of RuII and Cr0, for which the arene signals are found at around 6.9024 and 4.21 ppm25 respectively.
Fig. 2 99Tc NMR spectrum of [99Tc(tetralin)2]+ (−1586 ppm, [4]+) and the side product [99Tc(tetralin)(OHPhen)]+ (−1471 ppm, [5]+). |
The small but significant chemical shift differences in the 99Tc NMR spectra of the complexes are caused by the different numbers of groups with negative Hammett constants. Increased electron donation to the 99Tc center should be paralleled with corresponding electrochemical properties. Cyclic voltammetry (CV) investigations are in agreement with this prediction and reversible oxidation waves for the TcI/II couple were found at surprisingly high values, generally E01/2 > +1.4 V vs. Fc/Fc+ in acetonitrile (Fig. 3 and ESI, Section 5†). Along the series [1]+ → [4]+, the oxidation potentials become less positive with an increasing number of donors on the arenes. Irreversible and essentially arene independent reductions assigned to the 99TcI/0 couple appear below −2 V. As expected from general trends in the triads of the d-block elements, the rhenium homologues of [1]+ → [4]+ showed the ReI/II couples shifted by about 0.19–0.15 V towards more negative potentials as compared to the 99Tc compounds (see ESI, Table ESI5.1.1†), i.e. they are more easily oxidised than the 99Tc homologues, albeit still at considerably positive potentials. Comparing the herein reported 99Tc potentials with those of the neighbouring elements, for those which are available, confirms general trends for d-block elements in the periodic system. For instance, E01/2 for [Cr(C6H6)2]0/+ is reported at +0.82 V vs. Ag/AgCl, and hence, although to our knowledge unreported, the corresponding molybdenum complex should have an even more negatively shifted potential. For [Ru(C6H6)2]2+/3+, no potentials for the RuII/III couple are reported, probably because observation of the oxidation is not possible in common solvents. On the other hand, E01/2 for the RuII/I couple is found at −1.02 V, almost 1 V more positive than the potential of its 99Tc analogue (Table ESI5.1.1†).26–28 Spectroelectrochemistry measurements in an OTTLE cell supported the reversibility of the [Re(arene)2]+/[Re(arene)2]2+ couple. The ReI complex is oxidised to ReII and reduced back to ReI as is evident from the isosbestic points detected in the electrochemical experiment (Fig. ESI5.10.1†). In agreement with these electrochemical potentials, the [99Tc(arene)2]+ complexes are difficult to chemically oxidise and are very stable under ambient conditions. They are also insensitive to pH changes and do not decompose over the whole pH range even at elevated temperatures, an important feature for their potential application as molecular imaging agents.
The high yields and one step syntheses to [99Tc(arene)2]+ complexes are the incentives for translating the reaction conditions to attain short-lived 99mTc complexes. Apart from fundamental interests, conjugation of biologically active groups to the arene ring will open a path to novel, functionalised and targeted SPECT imaging agents. In the original preparation of [99mTc(arene)2]+ complexes,19 the multiple steps required for transferring [99mTcO4]− from the generator saline eluate into an organic solvent were difficult and time consuming, and ultimately prohibitive for any application. To facilitate this step, we coated a glass vial with a thin layer of ionic liquid (IL) by evaporating a dilute solution of [P(C6H13)3(C14H29)]Br in MTBE. Addition of the generator eluate to this vial resulted in extraction of 80–97% of [99mTcO4]− into the IL layer within 10 min by an anion exchange process (Scheme 2). The saline was removed and the IL was dissolved in the corresponding arene and added to a vial charged with AlCl3 under N2. The vial was heated for 10 min at 100 °C in a microwave reactor. Upon addition of water, the [99mTc(arene)2]+ complexes were extracted in yields of 35–87% and in radiochemical purities of >93%. Loading the aqueous solution onto a SepPak column and rinsing with water removed hydrolyzed AlCl3. The product was then eluted with an aqueous EtOH solution and isolated with >96% radiochemical purity (ESI, Section 1.2†).
The procedure was successfully applied for the toluene and mesitylene complexes. As described for [99Tc(tetralin)2]+, the yield of the [99mTc(tetralin)2]+ complex was reduced due to formation of the trans-alkylated side product in a 1:0.8 ratio ([99mTc(tetralin)2]+:[99mTc(tetralin)(OHPhen)]+). Comparable to the reactions with 99Tc, no additional reducing agent was required (except for the synthesis of [99mTc(benzene)2]+). We emphasise that the 99mTc bis-arene complexes are extraordinarily stable. Heating in an aqueous solution at 180 °C in a microwave oven in the presence of air does not decompose the complexes to a measurable extent. This stability against oxidation (and hydrolysis) is in agreement with the observed redox potentials and makes the complexes resistant to oxidation in air.
Assessment of the identities of the 99mTc complexes by HPLC coinjection with fully characterised rhenium homologues and subsequent comparison of retention times is an FDA accepted procedure. Due to the serial arrangement of the UV- and radio-detectors, the respective γ-signal (99mTc) is separated by a constant time delay (here 0.5 min) from the UV signal (Re). This time delay was quantified with [99Tc(toluene)2]+ (UV- and β−-detection for the same compound, Fig. 4).
Fig. 4 HPLC traces (UV-/β−-detection) of [99Tc(toluene)2]+ (UV-detection: 16.39 min, black line; β−-detection: 16.90 min, red line). |
Despite their isostructural nature and comparable physico-chemical properties, slightly different retention times (Rt) (ΔRt different from the 0.5 min) are sometimes observed for homologous 99mTc and Re complexes. This makes their identification by Rt comparison somewhat ambiguous. The reported [99mTc(arene)2]+ complexes provide good examples for this ambiguity, where the Rt for [99mTc(benzene)2]+ is 0.58 min shorter than that of the corresponding Re complex. This effect diminishes with the increasing number of arene substituents ([99mTc(toluene)2]+: 0.45 min, [99mTc(mesitylene)2]+: 0.42 min, [99mTc(tetralin)2]+: 0.39 min). These small but non-negligible uncertainties in the assessment of the identities of 99mTc complexes can only be ruled out by HPLC coinjection with fully characterised 99Tc analogues; ΔRt must be approximately 0.5 min (for our instrumental arrangement). This has additionally been verified by coinjection of [99mTc(tetralin)2]+ and [99Tc(tetralin)2]+; the separation of the UV signal (99Tc complex) and the γ-signal (99mTc) showed the expected separation (ΔRt = 0.51 min, ESI, Section 2†). We emphasise that such direct comparisons between 99mTc and 99Tc complexes are very rarely reported, if ever, but are ultimately the only way to truly assess the identity of a 99mTc complex.
Method (a) NH4[99TcO4] (18 mg, 0.10 mmol), Zn-dust (22 mg, 0.34 mmol), AlCl3 (134 mg, 1.00 mmol) and the corresponding arene (6 ml) were heated to 85 °C. After 8 h, the solvent of the resulting dark brown suspension was removed with a stream of N2. The residue was washed with Et2O (3 × 2 ml). The remaining solid was extracted with H2O (3 × 2 ml) and the aqueous solution was filtered. NH4PF6 (150 mg, 0.92 mmol) in H2O (1 ml) was added to the red-brown filtrate. The colorless precipitate was filtered off, washed with H2O (2 × 0.5 ml) and Et2O (2 × 0.5 ml) and dried in vacuo to give [99Tc(arene)2](PF6) as a pale yellow powder. Alternatively, the precipitate can be extracted with CH2Cl2 from the aqueous suspension.
Method (b) K[99TcO4] (20 mg, 0.10 mmol), AlCl3 (200 mg, 1.50 mmol) and the corresponding arene (8 ml) were heated at 85 °C. After 4 h, H2O (6 ml) was added to the hot dark brown solution and the aqueous phase was separated and filtered. The process was repeated with additional H2O (2 × 2 ml). To the combined aqueous solutions was added a solution of NH4PF6 (150 mg, 0.92 mmol) in H2O (1 ml). The formed colorless precipitate was filtered, washed with H2O (2 × 0.5 ml) and dried in vacuo to give [99Tc(arene)2](PF6).
Method (c) K2[99TcCl6] (37 mg, 0.10 mmol), AlCl3 (134 mg, 1.00 mmol) and the corresponding arene (8 ml) were heated at 85 °C for 4 h. H2O (4 ml) was added to the hot dark brown solution and the aqueous phase was separated and filtered. The process was repeated with additional H2O (2 × 2 ml) and to the combined aqueous solutions was added a solution of NH4PF6 (150 mg, 0.92 mmol) in H2O (1 ml). The colorless precipitate was filtered, washed with H2O (2 × 0.5 ml) and dried in vacuo to give [99Tc(arene)2](PF6) as a pale yellow powder.
Footnotes |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available: Additional synthetic and characterization details (including HPLC, NMR, CV), and crystallographic details. CCDC 1017765, 1017766, 1017767, 1017768 and 1017769. For ESI and crystallographic data in CIF or other electronic format see DOI: 10.1039/c4sc02461c |
‡ The first two authors contributed equally to this work. |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2015 |