Merlin N. M.
Walter
a,
Ashkan
Dehsorkhi
b,
Ian W.
Hamley
b and
Che J.
Connon
*a
aInstitute of Genetic Medicine, International Centre for Life, Newcastle University, Newcastle upon Tyne, NE1 3BZ, UK. E-mail: che.connon@newcastle.ac.uk
bDepartment of Chemistry, University of Reading, Whiteknights, Reading, RG6 6AD, UK
First published on 2nd December 2015
C16-YEALRVANEVTLN, a peptide amphiphile (PA) incorporating a biologically active amino acid sequence found in lumican, has been examined for its influence upon collagen synthesis by human corneal fibroblasts in vitro, and the roles of supra-molecular assembly and activin receptor-like kinase ALK receptor signaling in this effect were assessed. Cell viability was monitored using the Alamar blue assay, and collagen synthesis was assessed using Sirius red. The role of ALK signaling was studied by receptor inhibition. Cultured human corneal fibroblasts synthesized significantly greater amounts of collagen in the presence of the PA over both 7-day and 21-day periods. The aggregation of the PA to form nanotapes resulted in a notable enhancement in this activity, with an approximately two-fold increase in collagen production per cell. This increase was reduced by the addition of an ALK inhibitor. The data presented reveal a stimulatory effect upon collagen synthesis by the primary cells of the corneal stroma, and demonstrate a direct influence of supra-molecular assembly of the PA upon the cellular response observed. The effects of PA upon fibroblasts were dependent upon ALK receptor function. These findings elucidate the role of self-assembled nanostructures in the biological activity of peptide amphiphiles, and support the potential use of a self-assembling lumican derived PA as a novel biomaterial, intended to promote collagen deposition for wound repair and tissue engineering purposes.
Peptide amphiphiles are ‘a class of molecules that combine the structural features of amphiphilic surfactants with the functions of bioactive peptides and are known to assemble into a variety of nanostructures’,4 comprised of a hydrophobic ‘tail’ region and a hydrophilic peptide ‘head’. These molecules have demonstrated potential for a range of biomedical applications, either via their amphiphilicity and resultant compatibility with the lipid bilayer of cell membranes, capacity to present functional peptides in high densities upon the surface of supra-molecular assemblies, or suitability to form bioactive or cell-responsive ‘smart’ biomaterials,3,5,6 or a combination of these factors. Previously, a PA (C16-KTTKS) frequently used in commercially available skincare cosmetics, under the trade name Matrixyl™, was shown to stimulate the production of collagen by fibroblasts in vitro.7 Matrixyl is a lipidated peptide based upon a KTTKS pentapeptide head sequence, derived from a human type-1 collagen propeptide attached to a palmitic acid (C16) hexadecyl lipid chain.8,9 In this study we have investigated the effects of a PA based upon a 13-residue sequence, YEALRVANEVTLN, derived from the C-terminus of the small leucine rich proteoglycan lumican, also attached to a C16 hydrophobic tail (Fig. 1). In particular we focused on the enhanced bioactivity of the PA in supra-molecular form and its specific mode of action. Whilst there have been numerous publications studying the bioactivity of various PA's none, to the authors knowledge, have directly compared this activity of a PA in aggregated and unaggregated forms at the same concentration.
Fig. 1 C16-YEALRVANEVTLN PA is comprised of a 13 amino acid sequence (Tyr-Glu-Ala-Leu-Arg-Val-Ala-Asn-Glu-Val-Thr-Leu-Asn) and a hexadecyl (C16) lipid chain. |
Lumican, along with keratocan and mimecan, is a major keratan sulphate proteoglycan found in the ECM of many collagenous tissues including skin, tendons, cartilage, and the corneal stroma.10–12 More specifically, in the cornea, lumican has been shown to be essential for the maintenance of corneal transparency10,13 by influencing epithelial and stromal cell behaviors though matrikine function i.e. stimulating corneal epithelial wound healing14 and regulating collagen fibrillogenesis.15,16 A recent study by Yamanaka and co-workers demonstrated the binding of lumican to the TGF-β superfamily type I activin receptor-like kinase, ALK5, by its C-terminal domain; an approximately 50 amino acid sequence. Within this sequence, a 13-residue peptide (YEALRVANEVTLN) capable of stimulating epithelial migration17 was identified. This work, as well as the collagen stimulating effects of another ECM-derived peptide sequence based PA (Matrixyl™), and the well-documented role of TGF-β signaling pathways in ECM synthesis and fibrotic response,18 has informed the current investigation. The peptide amphiphile C16-YEALRVANEVTLN, incorporating a biologically active amino acid sequence found in lumican, has been examined for its effects upon human corneal fibroblasts in vitro, and the contribution both of supra-molecular assembly and ALK signaling in these effects have been investigated.
Human corneal fibroblasts cultured in 0.0025 wt% and 0.00125 wt% PA solutions showed the normal fibroblastic morphology expected for cells in 2D culture (Fig. 4) and displayed good, though reduced, viability after seven days exposure to both monomeric (blue) and diluted-aggregated (green) PA as assessed by the Alamar blue assay (Fig. 5 and 6). Notably, 0.00125 wt% PA solutions resulted in viable cell numbers that were not significantly different to those cultures maintained in SFM alone for both monomeric and diluted-aggregated PA forms (Fig. 5 and 6 respectively). Higher concentrations of PA were less well tolerated; solutions of 0.01 wt% and 0.005 wt% both caused a loss of over 30% of cells compared to control (no PA) after only 72 hours in culture (ESI Fig. 1†).
Fig. 4 Fibroblasts tolerate PA concentrations of 0.00125 wt% and 0.0025 wt% and maintain normal morphology over 7 days in PA supplemented cultures. |
Fig. 5 Viability and collagen synthesis by human corneal fibroblasts after culture for seven days in monomeric-PA supplemented SFM. |
Fig. 6 Viability and collagen synthesis by human corneal fibroblasts after culture for seven days in diluted-aggregated PA supplemented SFM. |
Over seven days in culture, human corneal fibroblasts produced significantly greater total amounts of collagen both in monomeric and diluted-aggregated solutions of PA, at both 0.00125 wt% and 0.0025 wt% concentrations, where those cells in solutions of monomeric PA produced 6.7 μg (±0.2 μg) 7.4 μg (±0.8 μg) respectively, compared to 3.6 μg (±0.1 μg) in SFM alone (Fig. 5). Similarly, fibroblasts cultured in diluted-aggregated PA produced 7.8 μg (±0.2 μg) and 7.7 μg (±0.2 μg) of collagen respectively, compared to 4.4 μg (±0.2 μg) in SFM alone (Fig. 6). As the number of cells in each culture would undoubtedly influence the overall amounts of collagen synthesised, the total mass of collagen was normalized to viable cell number as determined by the alamar blue assay, revealing an approximately two-fold increase in collagen production per cell between fibroblasts in 0.00125 wt% PA and those cultured in SFM alone, in both monomeric PA (Fig. 5) and diluted-aggregated PA (Fig. 6) solutions, with a further, albeit less pronounced, increase in collagen per cell in 0.0025 wt% solutions compared to those at 0.00125 wt%.
Over an extended period of culture (21 days), human corneal fibroblasts cultured in PA solutions maintained good viability, where the least tolerated condition (0.00125 wt% diluted-aggregated PA) nevertheless retained >70% of the viable cell number observed in SFM controls. Fibroblasts in monomeric PA solutions showed improved viability compared to that observed over seven days, relative to controls. Cell numbers were not significantly different in the presence of 0.0025 wt% PA compared to 0.00125 wt% PA in either monomeric or diluted-aggregated PA solutions (Fig. 7). When directly compared over 21 days, values for both total mass of collagen produced and collagen per cell were shown to be significantly greater in response to diluted-aggregated PA solutions than monomeric PA at the same wt% (Fig. 7).
Fig. 7 Viability and collagen synthesis by human corneal fibroblasts after culture for twenty-one days in monomeric PA and diluted-aggregated PA supplemented SFM. |
Fibroblasts treated with diluted-aggregated PA at these efficacious concentrations in the presence of the ALK receptor inhibitor (+SB 431542) were unresponsive to the PA, failing to synthesize more collagen over 7 days than those cells cultured without PA (no significant differences were observed between PA-treated and zero PA-treated control cultures), whereas those cells treated with the PA in the presence of the DMSO diluent only (−SB 431542) maintained their ability to produce significantly more collagen than the zero PA-treated control cultures (Fig. 8).
Low concentrations of PA in either monomeric or diluted-aggregated form are shown to be well tolerated by corneal fibroblasts in culture and C16-YEALRVANEVTLN strongly stimulates the synthesis of collagen. Of particular note, this enhancement is significantly greater in the case of the diluted-aggregated PA, suggesting a role of the secondary structure of this molecule in its biological activity. This was particularly apparent when the two conditions were directly compared over 21 days as shown in Fig. 7. It is worth noting that no similar direct comparison of the effects of monomeric and diluted-aggregated PA can be made from the differences shown between Fig. 5 and 6, as these experiments were run independently of each other using potentially variable primary cells derived from different sets of (n = 3) donor corneas. This variability may account for the observable difference in the negative controls in each of Fig. 5 and 6, which are otherwise identical conditions. The effect of C16-YEALRVANEVTLN on corneal fibroblasts was abrogated in response to the inhibition of ALK receptors, a known lumican binding site.17
As previously stated, the maintenance of the collagenous matrix of the corneal stroma by fibroblasts is essential to corneal transparency, and by extension to the function of the entire eye. Similarly the deposition of collagen by fibroblasts in vitro is of interest as a potential method for the production of native like tissue for the engineering of ‘organotypic’ cornea to eventually reduce or remove the demand for donor tissue. We have previously demonstrated the ability of cultured fibroblasts to synthesize a collagenous membrane with distinct similarities to stromal lamellae, and that can be recovered from culture, handled with relative ease, showing excellent potential for further investigation as a scaffold for the tissue engineering of an artificial corneal stroma.3 Tissue engineering processes such as this or the direct repair of diseased corneas via topical application, would likely benefit from an enhancement of extracellular matrix secretion by resident stromal fibroblasts. The peptide amphiphile C16-YEALRVANEVTLN showed good cyto-compatibility, as concentrations sufficient to induce a marked enrichment in collagen synthesis demonstrated little or no reduction in cell number, whilst higher concentrations capable of further enhancing collagen production still maintained cell numbers greater than 70% of those in standard medium. This compares favorably with Matrixyl™, a PA approved for commercial use in cosmetics for skin care. In similar conditions, Matrixyl™ was shown to reduce the number of viable fibroblasts by 70% or more.7 In terms of collagen production C16-YEALRVANEVTLN displays effects similar to those of Matrixyl™ on both corneal fibroblasts as shown here, and on dermal fibroblasts19in vitro, but with seemingly less pronounced effects upon cell viability. Thus, as it is presumed that the effect of Matrixyl™ upon facial wrinkles7,23 is due to its collagen stimulating activity, C16-YEALRVANEVTLN may be equally or better suited to the commercial niche in skincare applications currently occupied by C16-KTTKS.
In addition to the observed effects of C16-YEALRVANEVTLN in solution, PAs have previously been used as coatings for culture surfaces or as scaffolds to mediate or instruct cell behavior.3,5 The PA investigated here may make a suitable addition to such systems, either individually to stimulate the production of collagen by cells for tissue engineering purposes, or as part of a multi-molecular system wherein a range of bioactive peptide motifs are presented in controlled ratios within the same supra-molecular structure. We have previously used a bi-molecular system incorporating RGDS presenting peptides along with a PA containing an inactive ‘spacer’ peptide head (ETTES)3,5 to reduce the amount of RGDS groups per unit area. The native ECM is formed of numerous fibrillar proteins, proteoglycans/glycosaminoglycans, and other molecules, each displaying a variety of motifs that are recognizable by cell surface receptors. The orientation and relative abundance of these motifs contribute to cellular recognition of the microenvironment and instruct cell behavior accordingly. It seems feasible, then, that PA superstructures that can present a range of precisely spaced and concentrated peptide motifs might be developed to mimic the instructional and regulatory properties of native tissue and thus perhaps reproduce in vivo niche conditions in in vitro culture systems and upon the surface of synthetic biomaterials. In this respect there is certainly a strong rationale to investigate the self-assembly and bioactivity and their inter-relationship of PAs containing bio-derived peptide sequences, as has been performed in this study.
These data support the potential of peptide amphiphiles for use as a novel class of bioactive molecules, in this instance for the support of tissue regeneration through stimulating the synthesis of the collagenous extracellular matrix. The in vivo repair of corneal injury extending beyond the epithelia into the stromal tissue requires the synthesis of new matrix material to replaced damaged tissue. This is dependent upon the activation of the quiescent fibroblast population. Within 6 hours of injurious insult, fibroblasts enter into the cell cycle, increase their organelle content and migrate towards the site of injury adopting a more fibroblastic phenotype.24 These cells then synthesise new extracellular matrix proteins and, over time, model the newly secreted matrix to reconstitute functional corneal tissue.25 Although responsive to stimulatory factors secreted by platelets, the avascular nature of corneal tissue means that many of the cues for this transition are provided by the cells of the corneal epithelium, and its basement membrane.26 This outside-in (i.e. from the external epithelial side of the tissue rather than internal vasculature) instruction of the fibroblast response to injury supports a potential role for topical application of factors that mediate the behaviour of fibroblasts. The ability to stimulate the production of extracellular matrix proteins, such as the collagens that form the bulk of this tissue, by the endogenous cell population may have potential in the treatment of diseases such as persistent corneal stromal ulcerations, and keratoconus, both sight threatening conditions characterised, in part, by ECM degradation.27,28
TGF-β is a common ligand against ALK receptors and its addition to cells in vitro has been shown to enhance the synthesis of collagen29,30 Similarly, lumican has been previously shown to be complementary to ALK receptors17 inducing receptor dimerization and activation of the SMAD dependent signaling pathway that can result in up-regulation of collagen synthesis.31 Thus it seemed probable that the peptide ‘head’ of the C16-YEALRVANEVTLN molecule would also interact with this pathway. Indeed, the effects of the PA upon collagen synthesis were considerably abrogated in the presence of the ALK receptor inhibitor (indicated by the loss of the statistically significant response observed in the absence of exogenous ALK inhibition) giving a nascent mechanistic insight into the biological action of this PA. Future studies could confirm these results using corneal fibroblasts from SMAD knockout mice.32
Interestingly the significance of the diluted-aggregated form of C16-YEALRVANEVTLN on collagen production may be dependent upon the enhanced activation of ALK receptors. The retained supra-molecular structure of the diluted-aggregated PA has the unique capacity to present a highly concentrated amount of the bio-active peptide to the cells. Dense peptides along the surface of the nanotape could lead to a localized concentration (many times higher than the overall concentration of PA in solution) at the cell surface. As such these regions of high ligand density could aid in the assembling and clustering of the ALK receptors resulting in a focal point for SMAD phosphorylation (Fig. 9). Achieving such a ‘critical mass’ of localized signaling may not be so readily achieved when using the same wt% PA solution in its monomeric form (as indeed our data suggests).
In summary, a peptide amphiphile has been designed based upon a biologically active peptide derived from the C-terminal domain of lumican. This PA self assembles at 0.1 wt% to form bilayered tape-like structures that are stable in aqueous solution and maintained upon subsequent dilution, is biocompatible at efficacious concentrations, and stimulates collagen synthesis by corneal fibroblasts. This stimulatory effect is enhanced by aggregation of PA into supra-molecular structures and the biological effects of this nanotape form may be mediated by ALK receptor activity. As such these findings demonstrate the cyto-compatibility and bioactivity of C16-YEALRVANEVTLN, reveal the influence of supra-molecular assembly and, overall, support the potential use of a self-assembling lumican-derived PA as a novel biomaterial, intended to promote collagen deposition for wound repair and tissue engineering purposes.
ALK | Activin receptor-like kinase |
ANOVA | Analysis of variance |
CAC | Critical aggregation concentration |
CD | Circular dichroism |
DMEM | Dulbecco's modified eagle's medium |
DMSO | Dimethyl sulfoxide |
ECM | Extracellular matrix |
FBS | Fetal bovine serum |
HSD | Honest significant difference |
ITS | Insulin, Transferrin and Selenium |
PA | Peptide amphiphile |
SEM | Standard error of the mean |
SFM | Serum-free media |
TGF-β | Transforming growth factor-beta |
Footnote |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available: DETAILS. See DOI: 10.1039/c5bm00428d |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2016 |