Yevhen
Karpov
a,
Jatindranath
Maiti
b,
Roman
Tkachov
a,
Tetyana
Beryozkina
c,
Vasiliy
Bakulev
c,
Wei
Liu
a,
Hartmut
Komber
a,
Uwe
Lappan
a,
Mahmoud
Al-Hussein
d,
Manfred
Stamm
a,
Brigitte
Voit
ae and
Anton
Kiriy
*ae
aLeibniz-Institut für Polymerforschung Dresden e.V., Hohe Straße 6, 01069 Dresden, Germany. E-mail: kiriy@ipfdd.de
bGachon University, Department of Chemical Engineering, 461-701, Republic of Korea
cUral Federal University, Mira str., 28, 620002, Yekaterinburg, Russia
dThe University of Jordan, Physics Department, Amman 11942, Jordan
eTechnische Universität Dresden, Center for Advancing Electronics Dresden (CFAED), 01062, Dresden, Germany
First published on 22nd March 2016
The present work aims at the extension of the scope of a recently discovered polycondensation of AB-type anion-radical monomers. To this end, we investigate the polymerization of isoindigo-based monomer and its copolymerization with the naphthalenediimide-based monomer. Although polycondensations of parent naphthalenediimide- and perylenediimide-based monomers involve chain-growth mechanism, we found that the corresponding isoindigo-based monomer polymerizes in a step-growth manner under the same reaction conditions. In contrast to Stille, Suzuki and direct arylation polycondensations which require prolonged stirring at high temperatures, the polymerization approach we employed in this study proceeds fast at room temperature. It was found that near statistical copolymerization of isoindigo-based anion-radical monomers with corresponding naphtalenediimide-based monomers proceeds smoothly resulting in a library of copolymers with varying composition and properties depending on the ratio of the monomers.
N-Type (or electron-conducting) polymers are essential components in organic devices such as ambipolar and n-channel field-effect transistors and organic photovoltaics.1 Particularly, naphthalene diimide (NDI) and perylene diimide (PDI) alternating main chain copolymers,17 as well as diketopyrrolopyrrole-18 and isoindigo-19 based copolymers constitute an intriguing class of electron-conducting materials with excellent charge transport properties. Recently, we discovered Ni-catalyzed polymerization of highly unusual monomer – a complex formed upon reaction of activated Zn powder and 2,6-bis(2-bromothien-5-yl) naphtalene-1,4,5,8-tetracarboxylic-N,N′-bis(2-octyldodecyl) diimide (Br-TNDIT-Br).11 It was particularly found that addition of activated Zn powder to equimolar amounts of Br-TNDIT-Br resulted in an immediate color change from red-orange (inherent to Br-TNDIT-Br) to deep-green and accompanied by dissolution of the solid phase. Interestingly, the acidic work-up of the thus-prepared Br-TNDIT-Br/Zn complex resulted in a quantitative recovering of Br-TNDIT-Br but not of Br-TNDIT-H indicating that Br-TNDIT-ZnBr was not formed under these conditions. We proposed that either single- or two-electron transfer process occurs between electron-deficient Br-TNDIT-Br and electron-rich Zn. Consequently, anion-radical or dianion species may be responsible for the formation of complex Br-TNDIT-Br/Zn (Scheme 1). Electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR) measurements of Br-TNDIT-Br/Zn revealed the presence of paramagnetic species (signal at g = 2.0035) suggesting the formation of anion-radicals. Despite of the fact that Zn is not inserted in any of the two C–Br bonds of Br-TNDIT-Br, polymerization is going on in the presence of Ni and Pd catalysts resulting into corresponding n-type copolymer PTNDIT. Importantly, under Ni(dppe)Cl2 catalysis, the polycondensation involves the chain-growth catalyst-transfer mechanism and leads to P(TNDIT) with controlled molecular weights and relatively low dispersity (Đ = Mw/Mn) in a range of 1.3–1.7. However, molecular weight (MW) achievable with this catalyst is limited to only about 100 kg mol−1.11a It was further found that Pd complex having a bulky, electron-rich t-butylphosphine ligand is much more efficient catalyst and P(TNDIT) with MW up to 1000 kg mol−1 can be routinely obtained.11c Unfortunately, Pd/PtBu3-catalyzed polycondensation is not controlled and it involves the formation of shorter chains being formed on the chain-growth manner which further polymerize via the step-growth mechanism.
Very recently, we found that another rylene-diimide derivative-2,6-bis(2-bromothien-5-yl)perylene-1,4,5,8-tetra-carboxylic-N,N′-bis(2-octyldodecyl) diimide (Br-TPDIT-Br) – behaves similarly to Br-TNDIT-Br/Zn and forms, upon reaction with Zn, the charge-transfer complex Br-TPDIT-Br/Zn.15 Furthermore, Br-TPDIT-Br/Zn was shown to undergo chain-growth polycondensation in the presence of Pd/PtBu316 into corresponding polymer PPDIT2 with moderate molecular weight and moderate polydispersity although it appears to be unreactive in the presence of Ni catalysts. In the present work, aiming at extension of the scope of new polycondensation, we attempted polymerization of isoindigo-based monomers, as they were shown to be useful building blocks for construction of highly performing semiconducting polymers. We supposed that isoindigo,19–22 being an aromatic lactam by its chemical structure, may react with active zinc similarly to rylene-diamides forming charge-transfer complexes even though that isoindigo contains two times less amount of electron-accepting carbonyl groups.
EPR measurements of Br-TiIT-Br/Zn reveal the presence of paramagnetic species with an intense signal at g = 2.0031 (Fig. 1). This observation is consistent with electron transfer from Zn to the electron-deficient Br-TiIT-Br which leads to the radical-anion (Scheme 1). As such, Br-TiIT-Br behaves similarly to rylene-diimide-based compounds in the presence of Zn.
Scheme 2 Polymerization of zinc-activated isoindigo-based anion-radical monomer Br-TiIT-Br/Zn and its copolymerization with Br-TNDIT-Br/Zn. |
Polymerization course was monitored at [Br-TiIT-Br/Zn]/[Pd/PtBu3] ratio of 100/1 (Table 1). As seen from the evolution of GPC traces which correspond to crude reaction mixtures sampled-out at different polymerization times (Fig. 2), the monomer peak almost disappears already after one hour polymerization when only short isoindigo-oligomers are formed. During the polymerization, the oligomers’ peak gradually shifts to higher molecular weights and levels at Mw ≈ 200 kg mol−1 (Table 1). Importantly, polydispersities Đ of sampled polymers are large and increase with the increase of the polymerization time. These data are not consistent with the chain-growth propagation mechanism observed earlier in polycondensations of Br-TNDIT-Br/Zn and Br-TPDIT-Br/Zn conducted under similar conditions. Rather, these data suggest that the polycondensation involves the step-growth mechanism (see ESI, Fig. S6 and Table S1†).
Fig. 2 Evolution of GPC curves of crude reaction mixtures obtained upon the polymerization of Br-TiIT-Br/Zn at the [Br-TiIT-Br/Zn]/[Pd/PtBu3] ratio of 100/1. |
Polymerization time | M n (kg mol−1) | M w (kg mol−1) | Đ |
---|---|---|---|
1 h | 4.5 | 16 | 3.7 |
2 h | 9 | 51 | 5.9 |
4 h | 12 | 125 | 10.2 |
6 h | 16 | 150 | 9.3 |
8 h | 17 | 220 | 13.0 |
16 h | 18 | 370 | 20.5 |
Although exact reason of the suppressed chain-growth behavior (compared to rylene-based monomers) requires further elucidation, it can be proposed that the presence of a double bond in the TiIT monomer may cause a strong coordination of Pd(0) catalyst formed after the reduction elimination step. It is known that olefins are much stronger ligands for transition metals than aryls.24 This complexation process may prohibit the intramolecular transfer of the catalyst toward the growing chain end (ring-walking)25 and thus, prevent the intramolecular oxidative addition of Pd(0) to C–Br. In this case, an alternative intermolecular oxidative addition may be a more favoured process because it involves a direct attack of arylhalides (i.e., another monomer or oligomer having C–Br bonds) onto Pd(0) and thus it does not require for Pd(0) to be mobile.
As such, preparation of complex polymer architectures via chain-extension route, such as of all-conjugated block copolymers, is problematic by using this polymerization route as it requires clean chain-growth propagation. Nevertheless, we assumed that synthesis of random-copolymers, such as of Br-TNDIT-Br/Zn and Br-TiIT-Br/Zn, might be possible because polymerization of both these monomers occurs at the same polymerization conditions and in the presence of the same catalyst. To verify this idea, polymerization of Br-TiIT-Br/Zn and Br-TNDIT-Br/Zn was attempted at different monomer ratios of 75:25; 50:50 and 25:75, respectively. We found that the monomer mixtures smoothly polymerize at room temperature giving dark-blue polymeric products. To suppress possible aggregations, their molecular weights were determined by GPC at different temperatures (at 40 °C in chloroform and 60 and 150 °C in trichlorobenzene, Fig. S8†). The GPC traces are more broadened and exhibit multimodal distributions at lower temperatures which may reflect an aggregation of chains. The measurements at 150 °C provided much sharper and monomodal peaks indicating that aggregation is suppressed at this temperature. The latter measurements gave number-average Mn in 15–22 kg mol−1 range and Đ in 2.1–2.5 range.
To elucidate chemical structure of the polymerization products, they were further investigated by 1H NMR spectroscopy and their spectra were compared with the spectra of corresponding homopolymers (Fig. 3). Both the homopolymers and the copolymers tend to form aggregates in solution at lower temperatures. However, well resolved 1H NMR spectra could be obtained in C2D2Cl4 at 120 °C for samples with medium molecular weight. The spectrum of P(TNDIT) (Fig. 3a) shows a low-field-shifted signal of the NDI proton and an AB spin system for the thiophene protons having almost the same chemical shift. A significantly low-field-shifted signal is also observed for PTiIT representing H8 which is located within the deshielding region of the carbonyl group (Fig. 3d). Again, the chemical shift difference between both thiophene protons is small (0.1 ppm) but a ROESY effect between H5 and H6 allows to distinguish both thiophene proton signals. It is obvious from the spectra of the copolymers (Fig. 3b and c) that the isolated polymeric products contain both NDI and isoindigo monomers (marked in Fig. 3 as “N” and “iI”, respectively). The monomer ratio was determined from signal integrals of H3 (TNDIT) and H8 (TiIT), respectively. Copolymerization is proved by composition-dependent signal splitting observed for H1 of NDI and H6 of iI units. As indicated in Fig. 3c, these splittings are due to NDI-centred triads and TiIT–TiIT and TiIT–TNDIT diads, respectively. Unfortunately, only the diads’ content could be determined with good accuracy by signal deconvolution. Relating these values to those expected for random copolymerization reveals that for both copolymer compositions the content of the TiIT–TiIT diad is increased in the copolymers (47% vs. 27% for P(TiIT27-co-TNDIT73) b) and 65% vs. 53% for P(TiIT53-co-TNDIT47) c). Hence, the copolymers show a certain degree of blockiness. Moreover, the increased content of homodiads points to somewhat preferred homopropagation in the copolymerization process. Nevertheless, compositions of the obtained copolymers, as determined by integration of TiIT and TNDIT units, are close to the feed ratios of respective comonomers (compare experimentally found compositions and feed ratios, respectively: 47:53 versus 50:50 and 27:73 versus 25:75).
Films of PTiIT and PTNDIT homopolymers as well as P(TiIT-co-TNDIT) copolymers were prepared on electrodes and their redox behavior was studied by cyclic voltammetry in acetonitrile in the presence of 0.1 M NBu4PF6 as electrolyte (Fig. S5†). The polymers oxidize irreversibly so that determination of their HOMO levels was problematic. In contrast, the polymers exhibited reversible reduction behavior and reduction of PTiIT homopolymer occurred at 0.25 eV more electronegative potential than that of PTNDIT. In general, our data for homopolymers are in accordance with previously reported data for the same polymers obtained by Stille polycondensation which report LUMO levels of −3.7 eV (ref. 19 and 20) and −3.95 eV for PTiIT and PTNDIT, respectively. As expected, the volagramms of the P(TiIT-co-TNDIT) copolymers with near equal TiIT/TNDIT composition contains features inherent to both homopolymers. On the other hand, redox behaviour of the copolymers with the major TiIT (80%) or TNDIT (73%) components resembles the behavior of the respective homopolymers.
To further verify the successful copolymerization of TiIT and TNDIT units, UV-vis absorption and fluorescence spectra of the homopolymers and copolymers were recorded in chloroform solutions. As seen from Fig. 4a, the UV-vis spectrum of PTiIT has an absorption of a moderate intensity around 400 nm assignable to the π–π* transition and two low-energy absorption maxima at 650 nm and 725 nm corresponding to the charge transfer (CT) excitations. Further evidence of successful copolymerization comes from fluorescent spectroscopy. As seen from Fig. 4b, incorporation of TNDIT units leads to almost complete quenching of the TiIT fluorescence even in the sample with the lowest TNDIT content. The fluorescence quenching is likely due to energy and/or electron transfer from TiIT to TNDIT. Since the energy and electron transfer processes may proceed when the donor and acceptor units are located closely to each other, the quenching occurring in solution confirms the covalent connection of the TiIT and TNDIT units.
Fig. 4 UV-vis (a) and luminescence (b) spectra of the homopolymers PTiIT and PTNDIT and copolymers in chloroform solutions (concentrations: for UV-vis – 0.05 g L−1; for luminescence – 0.001 g L−1). |
In conclusion, reaction of isoindigo-based dibromide Br-TiIT-Br with activated Zn leads to anion-radical species without insertion of Zn into C–Br bonds similarly to the case of rylenediimide-based dibromides. Thus-activated Br-TiIT-Br/Zn polymerizes in the presence of Pd/PtBu3 catalyst giving PTiIT with a relatively high molecular weight of Mw = 370 kg mol−1. Unlike the polymerization of rylenediimide-based monomers which involves the chain-growth mechanism, isoindigo-based monomer polymerizes on the step-growth manner under the same reaction conditions. X-ray diffraction measurements reveal a semicrystallinity of PTiIT. Statistical copolymerization of isoindigo-based anion-radical monomers with corresponding naphtalenediimide-based monomers proceeds smoothly giving a library of copolymers composition and properties of which can be varied depending on ratio of the monomers. Particularly, reduction of PTiIT homopolymer occurred at a 0.25 eV more electronegative potential than that of PTNDIT (LUMO levels of −3.7 and −3.95 eV, respectively); increase of the content of isoindigo-based units in the copolymers enhances intensity of more electronegative reduction peak. An important feature of the developed polycondensation is that in contrast to Stille, Suzuki and direct arylation methods for preparation of polyisoindigos, polycondensation studied herein proceeds fast at room temperature. We believe that findings of this work are useful in a view of very promising performance of isoindigo-based polymers in solar cells and transistors, reported previously.
Footnote |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available: Monomer preparation procedure. See DOI: 10.1039/c6py00055j |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2016 |