Iluminada
Gallardo
,
Gonzalo
Guirado
*,
Jordi
Hernando
*,
Sandy
Morais
and
Gemma
Prats
Departament de Química, Universitat Autònoma de Barcelona, 08193 Cerdanyola del Vallès, Spain. E-mail: Gonzalo.Guirado@uab.cat; Jordi.Hernando@uab.cat
First published on 19th November 2015
Although the quantum nature of molecules makes them specially suitable for mimicking the operation of digital electronic elements, molecular compounds can also be envisioned to emulate the behavior of analog devices. In this work we report a novel fluorescent three-state switch capable of reproducing the analog response of transistors, an ubiquitous device in modern electronics. Exploiting the redox and thermal sensitivity of this compound, the amplitude of its fluorescence emission can be continuously modulated, in a similar way as the output current in a transistor is amplified by the gate-to-source voltage.
In all probability, the most relevant analog devices are transistors, three-electrode circuit elements applied for signal switching and amplification in modern electronics. In spite of this, little attention has so far been paid to the development of molecular switching compounds aiming at reproducing their analog response.8 To date this has been mainly achieved by covalently tethering an organic emitter to several photochromic units, which can be reversibly photoisomerized between fluorescence quenching and nonquenching states. Variation of the light excitation intensities used to simultaneously trigger the forward and backward photochromic reactions allows controlling the concentration ratio of these states and, as such, all-photonic continuous modulation of the total emission registered.10–12 More recently, similar fluorescent constructs have been prepared using ionic quenching receptors, with which the analog operation of triode vacuum-tubes, the precursors of transistors, has been mimicked in solution using chemical signals.13
In this work we report a novel strategy to accomplish analog transistor-like behavior with stimuli-responsive compounds, which exploits the combined use of electrical and thermal inputs. A major advantage is expected from this approach, since signal modulation is to be achieved for the first time through variation of an intensive property of the system (i.e. temperature). As a result, this should allow removing the need to adjust the stimulus amplitude (i.e. excitation intensity10–12 or ion concentration13) to the population of active molecules in the sample when targeting defined output levels.
Compound 1 was directly synthesized by reaction between 2,6-dinitro-4-(trifluoromethyl)phenol and N,N′-diisopropylcarbodiimide (Scheme 2). After removal of the aromatic by-product 3 formed in this reaction, an equimolar amount of base was added to yield the anionic state of the target compound (1a). In analogy to previously described switch 2,16 acid addition to organic solutions of 1a resulted in selective protonation of its guanidine group. In this case, however, the formation of a mixture of two different products was observed, as clearly demonstrated by 1H NMR (Fig. 1a). For the deprotonated product 1a, only one set of signals was observed at 298 K in CD3CN, consisting of a singlet at δ = 8.05 ppm for the two cyclohexadiene protons, four different multiplets at δ = 3.80–2.98 ppm for the –CH– isopropyl nuclei, and four methyl doublets at δ = 1.53–1.07 ppm. Upon protonation, these signals disappeared and split into two new groups. Thus, two new uncorrelated singlets were found at δ = 8.19 and 8.51 ppm, while several multiplets were registered in the aliphatic region suggesting the coexistence of more than one protonated species (Fig. 1a). In spite of this, a single value of molecular mass was determined by HR-MS for this mixture, which was chromatographically irresoluble and reverted back quantitatively to 1a after base addition. These results and the additional measurements conducted (see below) suggested that protonation of 1a afforded a mixture of two interconverting isomers, which we assigned to the zwitterionic state of 1 (1b) and the neutral aromatic compound 1c resulting from the ring-opening of its spiro-cyclic structure (Fig. 1b). This proved the success of our molecular design, which aimed to reduce the thermal stability of the bicyclic scaffold of 1 by introducing a trifluoromethyl substituent. In this way, we converted the two-state switch 2 into a three-state multi-stimuli responsive system.
Fig. 1 (a) 1H NMR (CD3CN, 400 MHz) spectra at 298 K of 1a and the equilibrium mixture of 1b and 1c. Solid and hollow squares are used to discriminate the signals corresponding to 1b and 1c, respectively. For the sake of clarity, the intensity of the signals at δ > 3.0 ppm has been magnified (×3). (b) Interconversion between 1a and the equilibrium mixture of 1b and 1c. In the redox conversion of 1a into 1b + 1c, acetonitrile is used as the source of hydrogen atoms.15 |
Upon acid-induced conversion of 1a into the mixture of 1b and 1c, clear changes in these optical properties were observed. First, a large decrease in absorption was measured, although minimal changes in the shape of the spectrum were detected (λabs,max = 564 nm for 1b + 1c, Fig. 2a). Taking into account that 3, an aromatic compound analogous to 1c, only absorbs in the UV-violet region (λabs < 400 nm, Fig. 2a), we concluded that: (i) the visible absorption band at λabs ∼ 575 nm of the neutral state of the system can be fully assigned to 1b, which actually presents the same cyclohexadiene chromophore as 1a; (ii) the decrease of this signal upon protonation should be attributed to the low thermal stability of 1b and its partial conversion into non absorbing 1c. Indeed, the ∼3-fold absorption decrement observed in Fig. 2a is in agreement with the 1:3.3 molar ratio found by 1H NMR for the 1b:1c equilibrium mixture in acetonitrile at 298 K. In spite of this, a large increase in emission intensity (∼25-fold) was observed for this mixture at λexc = 532 nm (i.e. when selectively exciting 1b). As expected, this indicates that the quenching effect of the guanidine group on cyclohexadiene chromophore emission is suppressed upon protonation, thus producing a highly fluorescent zwitterionic species (Φfl,1b = 0.76 in acetonitrile).
Similar electrochemical properties were found for 1 with respect to the previously studied switch 2.15Fig. 3 shows the cyclic voltammogram of 1a in acetonitrile at 298 K. In the first cathodic scan, a one-electron reversible reduction wave at E0 = −1.14 V (vs. SCE) was found, which can be attributed to the reversible formation of the corresponding dianion. In the subsequent anionic counter scan, two oxidation peaks were observed: a one-electron irreversible oxidation peak at Epa = +0.89 V (vs. SCE) and a one-electron reversible peak at E0 = +1.37 V (vs. SCE). Since the former indicated the evolution of the oxidized neutral radical of 1a into a new product, a controlled potential electrolysis of 1a at +1.00 V (vs. SCE) was conducted. Characterization of the product formed by 1H NMR, cyclic voltammetry and UV-vis absorption and fluorescence spectroscopies demonstrated quantitative transformation of 1a into a 1b + 1c mixture after the passage of 1 F. According to our electrochemical experiments and the well-known hydrogen atom donor properties of acetonitrile,15,18 this transformation should proceed via one-electron oxidation of 1a followed by hydrogen atom abstraction from the solvent with an estimated rate constant of 106 s−1 (see Scheme S1 in ESI†).
The cyclic voltammogram of the 1b + 1c equilibrium mixture in acetonitrile at 298 K is also depicted in Fig. 3, where a one-electron reversible oxidation wave is seen at E0 = +1.37 V (vs. SCE) in the anodic scan. This wave matches that previously found for 1a upon irreversible oxidation, which confirms that it arises from 1b + 1c. In the cathodic counter scan, a first one-electron pseudo-reversible peak Epc = −0.78 V (vs. SCE) was detected, which suggested irreversible reduction-induced transformation of 1b + 1c. As such, the 1b + 1c mixture was subjected to a controlled potential electrolysis at −1.00 V (vs. SCE), which led to the quantitative formation of 1a after the passage of 1 F as demonstrated by 1H NMR, cyclic voltammetry and UV-vis absorption and fluorescence spectroscopies. In this case, the electrochemically-induced conversion of 1b + 1c into 1a is proposed to take place via one-electron reduction of the reactants and subsequent elimination of a hydrogen atom (k = 78 s−1, see Scheme S1 in ESI†), which is expected to eventually evolve into molecular H2.19
Nevertheless, 1 presents an additional switching feature with respect to 2, which is crucial to emulate the analog behavior of transistors: the amplitude of the fluorescence modulation between the “off” (1a) and “on” states (1b + 1c) of the system ultimately depends on the 1b:1c concentration ratio upon acid- or redox-induced protonation, since only the former of these species is emissive. As such, increasing the molar fraction of 1b in the mixture should allow continuous amplification of the fluorescence response of the switch.
In view of this, we investigated whether the composition of the neutral state of 1 could be modulated externally and, in a first step, we considered thermal control. Fig. 5a plots the low field region of the 1H NMR spectrum of the equilibrium mixture 1b + 1c registered at different temperatures in acetonitrile (see Fig. S2 in ESI† for the complete spectra), where the signals for the cyclohexadiene protons of 1b (δ ∼ 8.19 ppm) and the aromatic protons of 1c (δ ∼ 8.50–8.60 ppm) are found. Two different dynamic effects were observed for those signals at distinct thermal ranges. First, the 1c signal broadened and ultimately split into two different peaks upon cooling below room temperature. Since no concomitant changes were observed for the 1b signal at T < 288 K, we ascribe this behavior to the hindered rotation of the bulky urea substituent around the aromatic moiety of 1c, which must be sufficiently slowed down at low temperatures as to be resolved by NMR. By contrast, the 1b and 1c tautomerization process must occur at much lower rates at such conditions, the 1b signal thus preserving its lineshape and frequency (i.e. k1b→1c and k1c→1b must be lower than 1 s−1 at T < 288 K).20 However, broadening of both 1b and 1c signals was observed when heating above 288 K, which demonstrates acceleration of the 1b–1c interconversion reaction with temperature. Actually, lineshape analysis of those signals allowed the tautomerization rate constants to be estimated,20 which increased from k1b→1c = 1.16 s−1 to k1b→1c = 196 s−1 within the 288–328 K interval (see Table S1 in ESI†).
More importantly, the composition of the 1b–1c equilibrium mixture and, therefore, the equilibrium constant of the tautomerization process (Keq,1b,1c) could be determined at each temperature from the integrals of the NMR signals (see Table S1 in ESI†). In this way we could demonstrate that the stability of the spirocyclic structure of the protonated state of 1 dramatically decreased with temperature. In particular, 1b relative concentration in the neutral state of the switch could be tuned from 53% at 238 K down to 6% at 328 K (Fig. 5b), a behavior that was found to be fully reversible upon a complete warming–cooling cycle (see Fig. S3 in ESI†) and further confirmed by absorption measurements (see Fig. S4 in ESI†).
As expected, thermal variation of 1b concentration in the neutral state of the switch enabled amplitude modulation of its fluorescence response. This is clearly proven by Fig. 5c, where the temperature dependences of the emission arising from acetonitrile solutions of 1a and 1b + 1c are plotted. While negligible thermally induced changes were observed for the “off” state of the system, a continuous variation of the “on” state fluorescence was found with temperature. In this way, the “on”–“off” emission contrast of the switch could be amplified up to 455% when cooling down the sample from 328 K to 248 K, the largest temperature range available for our optical experiments. An even larger amplification effect was predicted from pure concentration arguments, since 1b molar fraction increased around 680% along the 328–248 K interval according to NMR data. Most probably, variation of 1b absorptivity and Φfl values with temperature accounted for the ∼1.5-fold lower emission changes monitored, which are however large enough as to permit significant amplitude switching of 1 using not only chemical or electrochemical stimuli but also temperature variations.
Fig. 6a depicts the principal components and typical response of field-effect transistors (FET), the most common type of transistor in current electronic circuits. It consists of a semiconductor connected to a three-electrode system (source (S), drain (D) and gate (G)), where the current flowing from the source to the drain (output signal, IDS) does not only depend on the voltage applied between them (input signal, VDS), but can also be tuned upon application of a variable gate-to-source electric field (VGS). In particular, VGS controls the shape and size of the conductive channel in the semiconductor through which current flows from the source to the drain, thus allowing the output signal of the device to be amplified (by enlarging the channel) or switched off (by squeezing it).
To mimic this behavior, a conductive and nonvolatile thin film of the ionic liquid 1-ethyl-3-methylimidazolium bis(trifluorosulfonyl)imide ([EMIM][NTf2]) was doped with a 2 × 10−5 M content in 1a, sandwiched between a glass substrate and an ITO layer, put in contact with two additional auxiliary (Pt) and reference electrodes (SCE), and finally placed onto a hot plate (Fig. 6b). In such a construct, the analog functioning of FETs was devised to be emulated by: (i) measuring the fluorescence of the film (output signal) when electrochemically interconverting between the emissive and nonemissive states of 1 upon controlled electrolysis at defined potentials (input signal); (ii) modulating the resulting input/output (I/O) response through temperature variations, which must function as the gate-to-source voltages applied in field-effect transistors. As a proof of concept, Fig. 6b shows for the results obtained in this way at three different temperatures (293, 303 and 313 K), for which the “on”–“off” fluorescence amplitudes measured are plotted against the charge injected (Q) during the oxidative electrolysis of 1a. It must be noted that Q is a time-dependent parameter, in contrast to the VDS variable used when recording the I/O curves of FETs. However, Q is also related to the electronic properties of the switching system and, more importantly, to the interconversion between its different states, thus emerging as an appropriate variable to monitor the transistor-like behavior of 1.
At Q = 0, minimal fluorescence was measured at the three temperatures of choice, since the molecular switch remained in its nonemissive 1a state. A nearly linear increase of the emission with the charge injected was then registered upon oxidative electrolysis, which led to 1a → 1b + 1c conversion via radical formation and hydrogen atom abstraction from the ionic liquid solvent. This behavior resembles that observed in the linear region of the I/O curves of FETs at low VDS values. However, as approaching to passage of 1 F and, therefore, quantitative transformation of 1a into 1b + 1c was achieved, the signal saturated and further injection of charge did not result in an additional rise in emission, thus mimicking the saturation of the transistor response at large VDS values. Noticeably, the amplitude of the fluorescence curves measured in this way dramatically varied with temperature, as expected due to the thermal dependence of the equilibrium constant of the tautomerization process between 1b and 1c. In particular, a ∼100% increase in maximal fluorescence signal was determined when cooling down the system from 313 to 293 K, since stabilization of the spirocyclic structure of the emissive species 1b takes place at lower temperatures. It is worth mentioning that this value is larger than that measured in acetonitrile solution for the 318–298 K range (∼60%), which we ascribe to the different thermal dependence of Keq,1b,1c with the solvent. Despite this, Fig. 6b clearly shows that similar I/O curves to those typically displayed by FETs can be obtained by exploiting the multi-stimuli responsive behavior of switch 1, thus demonstrating the capability of this compound to behave as a molecular analogue of transistors.
When comparing the performance of our molecular system with that of transistors, it must be noted that it provides a different type of output signal as well as operates under distinct external stimuli, which hampers the direct use of our molecular switch as a substitute of transistors in current circuits. However, it enables its application in other fields where transistor-like responses could be exploited. Actually, fluorescent molecular analogues of electronic components are currently being successfully applied as local probes of relevant biological systems and processes, since they can report on physical and (bio)chemical conditions in vivo, with minimal perturbance, high sensitivity and sub-micrometer resolution.4,28 Of special interest in this area is the development of compounds capable of simultaneously detecting and quantifying several analytes, which should not only broaden the density of sensory information but also allow direct screening of medical conditions related to a combination of different biological indicators. Lab-on-a-molecule24e,29 and keypad lock systems30 are some of the most popular strategies to achieve this goal, and they have already been used to investigate complex processes such as enzymatic activity,31 neuronal exocytosis32 or mitochondrial metabolism.33 Among the variety of analytes that could be monitored by these molecular devices, the multiplexed sensing of pH,34 redox state35 and temperature,36 the input signals of compound 1, would be of paramount importance, because these parameters are known to change during regular cellular processes37 and their abnormal values are often related to common diseases (e.g. cancer38). Therefore, taking advantage of the multi-stimuli responsive, transistor-like behavior of 1, this and related compounds could be envisaged as lab-on-a-molecule systems for the simultaneous in vivo detection and mapping of cellular redox state and temperature (or pH and temperature).
Footnote |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available: Detailed experimental procedures and additional data on the characterization of 1. See DOI: 10.1039/c5sc03395k |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2016 |