Richard A.
Campbell
*a,
Andrea
Tummino
ab,
Boris A.
Noskov
c and
Imre
Varga
*b
aInstitut Laue-Langevin, 71 Avenue des Martyrs, CS20156, 38.042 Grenoble Cedex 9, France. E-mail: campbell@ill.eu; Tel: +33 476 207 097
bInstitute of Chemistry, Eötvös Loránd University, Budapest 112, P. O. Box 32, H-1518 Hungary. E-mail: imo@chem.elte.hu; Tel: +36 204 890 440
cInstitute of Chemistry, St. Petersburg State University, 198904 St. Petersburg, Russian Federation
First published on 12th May 2016
We describe a new methodology to prepare loaded polyelectrolyte/surfactant films at the air/water interface by exploiting Marangoni spreading resulting from the dynamic dissociation of hydrophobic neutral aggregates dispensed from an aqueous dispersion. The system studied is mixtures of poly(sodium styrene sulfonate) with dodecyl trimethylammonium bromide. Our approach results in the interfacial confinement of more than one third of the macromolecules in the system even though they are not even surface-active without the surfactant. The interfacial stoichiometry of the films was resolved during measurements of surface pressure isotherms in situ for the first time using a new implementation of neutron reflectometry. The interfacial coverage is determined by the minimum surface area reached when the films are compressed beyond a single complete surface layer. The films exhibit linear ripples on a length scale of hundreds of micrometers during the squeezing out of material, after which they behave as perfectly insoluble membranes with consistent stoichiometric charge binding. We discuss our findings in terms of scope for the preparation of loaded membranes for encapsulation applications and in deposition-based technologies.
Recent work on non-equilibrium effects in the bulk has shown that aggregates produced in the two phase region that are then diluted to the one phase region, e.g., due to concentration gradients present during mixing, can persist over extended time scales as a result of their kinetic charge stability.10–12 It has also been shown that aggregate production can have important effects at the air/water interface. Either there can be depletion of the amount of material due to a reduction in the concentration of surface-active material in the bulk13,14 or enhancement by a range of different direct non-equilibrium interactions.15,16
The key roles that P/S aggregates can play in determining the properties of the air/water interface have been recently highlighted. In one study on poly(ethylene imine)/sodium dodecyl sulfate (PEI/SDS) mixtures, it was shown using the expanding liquid surface of an overflowing cylinder that the dissociation of aggregates on a sub-second time scale results in the formation of transient monolayer patches by Marangoni spreading.17 It was inferred that under dynamic conditions relevant to processing and applications even more polyelectrolyte can be delivered to the interface by the spreading of material from aggregates than by the adsorption of molecular components. In another study on poly(amido amine) dendrimer/SDS mixtures, it was demonstrated that only aggregates with sufficient charge became embedded intact in the interfacial layer.18 It was inferred that the aggregates closer to charge neutrality, more abundant in the two phase region yet not detected intact at the interface, must dissociate and spread material upon contact with the surface layer. As the equilibrium state in the two phase region is complete precipitation,7–9 with coagulation of the aggregates taking up to several weeks or even longer,10,14 their fast, spontaneous dissociation at the air/water interface highlights the important role of surface forces in the dynamic spreading process.
The spreading process is thermodynamically favorable as the self-assembly of amphiphilic material at the air/water interface lowers its free energy. Equally, thermodynamics predicts that that in equilibrium the bulk chemical potential of the P/S complexes in solution is finite, hence some of the polymers should dissolve in the solution. Nevertheless, kinetic barriers to the dissolution can result in the trapping of material at the interface in the form of loaded surface films. Exploitation of non-equilibrium effects to create loaded films of macromolecules dates back to almost one century with work on spread protein films.19,20 In the following decades, studies of spread films of amphiphilic macromolecules became an important field of interface science.21,22 More recently, some groups have studied the dynamic properties of adsorbed P/S layers with Jain et al. noting the possibility of compressing them.23 Bergeron et al. later commented on their gel-like behavior24 and Noskov et al. described their surface heterogeneities.25 Edler et al. went on to work extensively on film formation in mixtures of PEI with surfactants of the same charge.26
Approaches to control the interfacial properties of P/S mixtures by tuning the experimental pathway have been recently employed. For example, Dhar et al. described the preparation of films from refined P/S nanoparticles,27,28 while Tong et al. reported the interfacial disassembly of positively charged P/S nanoparticles triggered by particle–particle interactions.29 Also, Lee et al. formed stable films of poly(sodium styrene sulfonate) and alkyltrimethylammonium bromides of different chain lengths by spreading a small aliquot of mixed solution in an organic solvent.30 In that work, the interfacial stoichiometry of the films was resolved following their transfer to a mica substrate. Even so, quantitative information on the interfacial stoichiometry in situ at the air/water interface during dynamic measurements has been limited by the accuracy and kinetic resolution of measurements using the available experimental techniques.
Complementary to the methodologies employed to date, in the present work we exploit explicitly the rapid dissociation of hydrophobic neutral P/S aggregates present in an aqueous dispersion to create loaded films by Marangoni spreading. The loaded films are more efficient than layers formed by bulk adsorption in terms of the ratio of the surface excess to the amount of material used. This may have certain economic and environmental advantages, and the preparation of such films using only aqueous media include reduced cost and toxicity as well as potential for biocompatibility. The system studied is poly(sodium styrene sulfonate)/dodecyl trimethylammonium bromide (NaPSS/DTAB). It was chosen to emphasize the significance of spreading from neutral aggregates, which are produced at bulk compositions far from stoichiometric charge mixing. A powerful new implementation of neutron reflectometry with superior kinetic resolution and accuracy in the interfacial stoichiometry than has been previously achieved is applied in situ during dynamic measurements for the first time to reveal the high robustness of the films created.
Adsorbed layers were formed in a static trough by mixing equivalent amounts of materials in a different way. First, 100 μL of 200 ppm NaPSS was diluted in 25 mL of pure water to make 0.8 ppm solution, and 100 μL of 12 mM DTAB was diluted in 25 mL of pure water to make 48 μM solution. These solutions were then poured together simultaneously into a freshly cleaned vessel. Then 30 mL was poured into the dish, and around 5 mL was aspirated using a suction pump, which was essential to remove any kinetically-trapped material.15,16,31 All the measurements were carried out at 25 °C.
It should be noted that due to the large scattering cross-section of the formed aggregates, the freshly mixed samples exhibited multiple scattering and we could not measure them directly. To overcome this problem, we took samples at regular intervals and diluted them tenfold to reduce multiple scattering. This was possible because the samples contained neutral aggregates where the amount of surfactant bound to the polyelectrolyte is equal to the monomer concentration of the polyelectrolyte, and therefore the equilibrium free surfactant concentration was precisely determined (5.5 mM DTAB). Practically, this meant that the dilution of the samples with 5.5 mM DTAB did not affect the surfactant chemical potential or the extent of surfactant binding, and therefore the physical state of the aggregates was preserved.
There are various different approaches in the literature to calculate the surface excess (Γ) from the measured values of Δ. An optical matrix model can be used to derive either a linear relation for an oil-like layer (i.e. constant density with changing thickness) or a quadratic relation for a particle-like layer (i.e. constant thickness with changing density). However, it is often considered better to calibrate the relation with reference to a direct measure of the surface excess from a technique such as neutron reflectometry.32,33 We opted for the latter approach, given that the interfacial stoichiometry of a spread film was measured directly using this technique, and hence we had already a direct measure of the total surface excess. This scaling for sample A, a spread film of equimolar interfacial stoichiometry where counterions are assumed not to be present at the interface, was then also applied to samples B–E. The presence of any counterions at the interface in those samples would mean that the actual surface excesses are in fact slightly lower than the values reported, but this does not affect our interpretations of the data. A Beaglehole Picometer Light ellipsometer was used with a wavelength of λ = 632.8 nm, an angle of incidence of θ = 50°, and a data acquisition rate of 0.2 Hz.
(1) |
NR has been used extensively to resolve the interfacial stoichiometry of binary mixtures at the air/water interface by fitting a common physical model to experimental data recorded in different isotopic contrasts of the surface material and solvent.6,13,14,36–40 However, even at leading instruments today, the measurements take typically up to a couple of hours in total as data are required in multiple isotopic contrasts across a broad range of Qz values where the reflectivity values descend to ppm levels. As such, resolution of the interfacial stoichiometry of a mixture at the air/water interface during surface area cycles has not been achieved to date. A further limitation of this approach is that the layer roughness values used in the model have an impact on the derived polyelectrolyte surface excess values, yet they are a priori unknown, limiting the accuracy of the measurement.
In the present work, we resolve directly the interfacial stoichiometry much faster and more accurately than in previous studies (in the absence of deuterated polyelectrolyte) using a recent approach14,41 that has been applied to a dynamic system for the first time. The approach is based on the sequential acquisition of data recorded only at low Qz values in two isotopic contrasts: (1) NaPSS with dDTAB in ACMW, where the strong scattering is dominated by the deuterated surfactant, and (2) NaPSS with cmDTAB in ACMW, where the very weak scattering is determined only by the amount of polyelectrolyte. The approach exploits the high flux at low Qz values accessible on the FIGARO instrument. The data were binned to 1 min slices for contrast 1 and 2 min slices for contrast 2, as a result of the difference in magnitudes of the measured reflectivities. These two scattering excesses are then resolved using linear equations into both the polyelectrolyte and surfactant surface excesses. Examples of the experimental data and model fits are shown (Fig. 1).
The physical basis of the approach is described below. The surface excess of a single-component monolayer at the air/ACMW interface may be determined using42
(2) |
σ·d = NA·(Γ1·bi,1 + Γ2·bi,2) | (3) |
(σ·d)1 = NA·(Γsurf·bi,d-surf + Γpoly·bi,poly) | (4) |
(σ·d)2 = NA·Γpoly·bi,poly | (5) |
Fig. 2 Electrophoretic mobility data of freshly mixed NaPSS/DTAB samples, and optical density data measured at 400 nm. Lines joining the data are only to guide the eye. |
DLS data are presented for samples with 100 ppm NaPSS and 6 mM DTAB with respect to the sample age (Fig. 3). It can be seen that the size of the aggregates is already ∼500 nm immediately after mixing. The size then increases continuously with further aggregation and after 10 min it reaches 1000 nm. We determined the evolution of the particle size distribution during this early aggregation state using the CONTIN method. We found narrow unimodal particle size distributions in all cases. In the experiments that follow we dispense P/S aggregates on a clean water surface within the first minute after mixing the components; hence we may infer that the samples contained aggregates with a well-defined size distribution of 500 ± 50 nm. As such, the samples used comprised a dispersion of aggregates that had not precipitated nor were separated from the supernatant. Note that while the internal structure of the NaPSS/DTAB aggregates was not investigated in the present work, Sitar et al. presented data on the phase diagram of the PSSDTA/water system and found that above 43% water content coexisting hexagonal (‘precipitate’) and micellar (‘dilute’) phases form.44
We begin our focus on the interfacial properties by examining how the dissociation of neutral P/S aggregates can be used to create spread films. Thus, we spread a small aliquot (100 μL) of a freshly prepared mixture containing neutral aggregates (100 ppm NaPSS and 6 mM DTAB) on 25 mL of pure water using a pipette. Ellipsometry was used to measure the surface excess for 1 h. Even though the final concentrations were just 0.4 ppm NaPSS and 24 μM DTAB, a substantial spread film is immediately formed with its surface excess remaining practically constant throughout the measurement (Fig. 4; sample A). While there is excess surfactant present in the aliquot, adsorption from an equivalent amount in the absence of NaPSS results in only a minimal adsorbed layer (Fig. 4; sample E). These results highlight the key role of NaPSS in the spread film.
Next we compared the efficiency of aggregate spreading with the adsorption of P/S complexes from the bulk. We prepared a mixture directly in the one-phase region with 0.4 ppm NaPSS and 24 μM DTAB (free of aggregates) by mixing previously-diluted components in a stoichiometric charge ratio. The adsorbed layer only slowly forms, approaching a lower steady state surface excess (Fig. 4; sample B). Although the mixtures in samples A and B each contain the same total concentrations of NaPSS and DTAB, the initial surface excess is four times higher in the case of the film spread from neutral aggregates. This result highlights the non-equilibrium nature of the spreading process by exploiting aggregate dissociation.
Lastly, we carried out experiments on spread and adsorbed layers where aggregates were absent in both cases: the DTAB concentration in the aliquot was decreased to 0.4 mM (Fig. 4; samples C and D). It may be noted that this bulk composition is close to that of stoichiometric mixing of the polyelectrolyte and surfactant charges, which is a common reference point in literature studies of P/S systems.9,45 In this case, the resulting surface excess is much smaller than for the film spread from neutral aggregates, which emphasizes the importance of aggregate dissociation in the kinetic-trapping of material at the interface.
We go on now to examine the dynamic properties of the spread films during 5 compression/expansion cycles on a Langmuir trough (Fig. 5). Following an increase in surface pressure during the 1st cycle, the values reach a plateau, which corresponds to the minimum surface tension of 44 mN m−1 for the NaPSS/DTAB system.36
There is a large hysteresis upon expansion only during the first cycle, after which lower surface pressures are achieved during expansion, possibly due to squeezing out of material from the interface. The system approaches a limit cycle with minimal hysteresis in subsequent cycles, which may suggest that the material is trapped at the interface in an insoluble membrane. Quantification of the amounts of the components at the interface, however, would be required to qualify such statements. Therefore we applied our new NR approach to resolve the interfacial stroichiometry of binary mixtures (described above) to dynamic P/S films in situ for the first time. Data from the 5 compression/expansion cycles are presented (Fig. 6).
Fig. 6 Interfacial stoichiometry of NaPSS/DTAB films spread from neutral aggregates resolved using NR where the maxima mark full compression and minima mark full expansion corresponding to the surface area cycles in Fig. 5; the deviation of the interfacial stoichiometry from unity prior to and during the first compression is attributed to differences in the spreading dynamics of NaPSS/DTAB aggregates of different isotopic contrasts, which is reset when the films are compressed beyond a complete surface layer. |
A striking observation is the consistent stoichiometric charge binding at the interface after the first compression. Such a stoichiometry could be expected for this system since it represents the lowest surface energy state while keeping the material at the interface charge neutral. The adsorption of excess surfactant resulting in electric double layer formation and the accumulation of polyelectrolyte loops are both energetically unfavorable given the very low bulk surfactant concentration and ionic strength. In fact this interfacial picture was inherent in the equilibrium co-adsorption model for oppositely charged flexible P/S mixtures proposed by Asnacios et al. two decades ago.5 Such an interfacial stoichiometry was also previously resolved by Lee et al. using X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy on NaPSS/alkyltrimethylammonium bromide films that were first spread on water from a dispersion in an organic solvent and then deposited onto a mica substrate.28 However, the present work marks the first time that stoichiometric binding has been convincingly demonstrated in situ at the air/water interface both for static P/S films and for films subjected to dynamic perturbations of the surface area.
Our accurate approach to resolve the dynamic interfacial stoichiometry of binary mixtures is clearly much faster than was previously possible, and is suitable for application in a range of systems where the interfacial stoichiometry is totally unknown. Indeed work is underway already to determine the properties of films created by aggregates with a range of compositions and ionic strengths. The latter variable is particularly important given that this is a key parameter to tune to balance between equilibrium and non-equilibrium behavior.46,47 As one looks to future advances in neutron instrumentation, such as the RAINBOWS48 upgrade planned for the FIGARO instrument where at least another order of magnitude in flux is anticipated from the use of a dispersive beam, resolution of the dynamic insertion of macromolecules in biological interfacial films on time scales relevant to respiration seems soon to be a realistic prospect.49,50
During the first compression, the plateau in the surface pressure is accompanied by one in the surfactant surface excess (see green circle in Fig. 6). We can conclude therefore that material is indeed expelled from the film as the complete surface film is compressed further. Interestingly, Brewster angle microscopy images indicate a change in the morphology of the film only during the squeezing out process (Fig. 7). In contrast to images prior to the surface pressure plateau (A) and during expansion (C), which are black due to the low optical contrast of the film, the image during the squeezing out process (B) has faint linear white features indicating ripples with a length scale on the order of hundreds of micrometers. This effect cannot be connected with the propagation of longitudinal surface waves because the corresponding dispersion relation leads to wavelengths much longer than the trough length at low frequencies <0.01 Hz.51 It is more probable that the ripples are due to the film buckling like in the case of layers of polystyrene microparticles at the air/water interface close to the collapse state.52 It is likely that the lower regularity of the ripples in the present work is connected with the distortion related to buckling of the film when the material is squeezed out of the interface. Interestingly, the surface excess values after each expansion are constant but lower than the starting value. As such, we may conclude that the surface excess is effectively reset after the first compression when any material in excess of a complete surface layer is eliminated from the interface.
Following the first compression, the interfacial excess and stoichiometry are highly reproducible during the cycles. Since no decrease in the surface excess is observed over the course of the repeated cycles, we may infer that the spread films are effectively insoluble on the investigated time scales and their behavior is similar to that of the monolayers of insoluble surfactants.53 This result has an important implication. While the polyelectrolyte at 100 ppm is not even surface active alone,54 36% of the total amount in the system is confined in the spread films using our approach; we note that this efficiency may be increased further by optimization of the spreading process. In comparison with techniques like electrospray deposition,55 such a method could be a more efficient and cheaper way to generate thin amphiphilic films for transfer, and there is scope for encapsulation of hydrophobic additives, such as drugs or dyes, in the films.56 This way to produce loaded amphiphilic films could also result in reduced environmental impact in certain applications.57 As the basis of our approach was built on recent studies of a number of different systems,13–18 it follows that there is capacity for its general exploitation with the choice of macromolecule tailored to the spreading characteristics of the target molecule to be released.
Lastly, it should be mentioned that different interpretations have been proposed in the literature for the behavior of the NaPSS/DTAB system at the air/water interface. Taylor et al. assumed that the interfacial layer is in dynamic equilibrium with the aqueous bulk phase following the adsorption of molecular components hence the interfacial properties are determined by bulk chemical potentials,38 and thermodynamic models within a framework of chemical equilibrium were later applied to the data.58,59 (Note that recent discussions revealed that these samples were freshly diluted using NaPSS solution shortly before their measurement so as a result of the high free surfactant concentration in the two phase region they must have inevitably contained a dispersion of aggregates far from equilibrium.60) In contrast, Lee et al. showed that NaPSS/alkyltrimethylammonium bromide mixtures spread as molecular dispersions from an organic solvent form films that are practically insoluble on experimentally accessible time scales, although we note that they used a higher molecular weight (70 kDa) polyelectrolyte.30 In the present work, we have advanced this understanding in a number of respects. First, we have outlined a methodology to exploit the dynamic dissociation of hydrophobic neutral aggregates formed in the aqueous bulk to create loaded films at the air/water interface by Marangoni spreading. This result is significant in terms of film preparation approaches given that water is cheaper and less toxic than organic solvents. Second, we found that even the lower molecular weight (17 kDa) NaPSS can form insoluble films with DTAB at the air/water interface. Indeed in spite of fast equilibration of the interface, as the surface film is formed on a sub-second time scale, there is an extreme lack of equilibration between the interfacial film and the bulk, which persists at least for minutes and hours, not only under static conditions but also under the dynamic conditions relevant to processing and applications. This result implies that the application of equilibrium models to experimental data for oppositely charged P/S systems must be carried out with great caution, especially given how any aggregates present in the samples can dissociate and spread material at the interface under equilibrium conditions. Third, by utilizing a new implementation of neutron reflectometry, we determined that stoichiometric charge binding is characteristic of NaPSS/DTAB films on a dilute aqueous subphase under both static and dynamic conditions. We believe that a comparison of this behavior with films prepared from aggregates of different charges and using different ionic strengths of the bulk can lead to the optimized preparation of films with a range of different properties in the future.
The application of our new methodology to other P/S systems is straightforward: one simply has to determine the point of zero aggregate charge in the bulk (electrophoretic mobility) and an aliquot containing a dispersion of fresh hydrophobic neutral aggregates can then be used. Even so, the factors that affect the efficiency of the spreading mechanism in different systems (e.g. polymer size, molecular weight and architecture, ionic strength, surfactant properties and the aggregate internal structure) are exciting topics for future investigations.
Using the NaPSS/DTAB system as an example, we have shown that these films can result in the interfacial confinement of more than one third of the polyelectrolyte in the system. Even though the surface excess never exceeded that of a complete surface layer of each component, the value of our methodology is related to the efficiency of the surface loading, i.e., a substantial surface excess can be achieved by using only a minimal amount of material in comparison with a system relying on bulk adsorption. The dynamic properties of the films were examined using a new implementation of neutron reflectometry, which enhanced the accuracy and time resolution of the interfacial stoichiometry measured in situ during dynamic surface area cycling for the first time. Consistent stoichiometric charge binding at the interface was observed, and following the squeezing out of excess material beyond that of a complete surface layer during the first compression the material at the interface was conserved during subsequent cycles. The films behave subsequently like perfectly insoluble membranes. These results revealed the potential to set the coverage of the films simply by tuning the dynamic surface area, which has been only inferred indirectly from surface pressure measurements until now.
It is interesting to consider that P/S aggregates like those exploited in the present work also exist in the mixed systems that have been studied for decades in the context of molecular adsorption and that are widely used in consumer products. We have shown previously that such aggregates can interact with interfaces by different mechanisms,16 and that the resulting effects can dominate the interfacial properties.17 In the present work, the properties of films formed through the explicit exploitation of dissociation and spreading from neutral P/S aggregates have been characterized under static and dynamic conditions for the first time to show that they are robust and insoluble on the accessed time scales. We conclude that the interfacial properties of oppositely charged polyelectrolyte/surfactant systems in general may be highly influenced by direct aggregate interactions: even in cases where the interfacial properties seem to have reached steady state the system can be far from equilibrium.
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2016 |