Ying Huanga,
Yadong Heab,
Weidan Dingc,
Kunxiao Yanga,
Dongquan Yua and
Chunling Xin*ab
aCollege of Mechanical and Electrical Engineering, Beijing University of Chemical Technology, Beijing 100029, China. E-mail: xincl@mail.buct.edu.cn
bEngineering Research Center for Polymer Processing Equipment, Ministry of Education, Beijing 100029, China
cDart Container, 500 Hogsback Road, Mason, MI 48854, USA
First published on 17th January 2017
In this work, a triangle arrayed triple-screw extruder (TTSE) was used to prepare in situ polypropylene/polyamide 6,6 (PP/PA66) microfibrillar composites (MFCs) by direct extrusion at a processing temperature between the melting points of the two phases. The dispersed phase, PA66 particles, deformed, merged and was stretched into fibrils under the alternating shearing and extensional flow field in the TTSE. The fibrillar morphology was controlled through adjusting the PA66 content and processing parameters (temperature and screw speed). Dynamic oscillatory shear rheological properties and extensional viscosity of PP/PA66 microfibrils with different aspect ratio were studied. The obtained results showed that the storage modulus and complex viscosity of PP/PA66 MFCs were improved with increasing fibrillar aspect ratio. Meanwhile, the loss tangent tanδ value decreased and the radius of the Cole–Cole plot circle increased with an increase in fibrillar aspect ratio. The PP/PA66 MFCs exhibited a pseudo-solid or gel-like behavior. The gel point concentration, which was determined by the Winter–Chambon criterion, decreased with the increasing fibrillar aspect ratio due to the increased interfacial area and enhanced entangled network structure. Additionally, high-aspect-ratio PA66 fibrils have dramatically improved PP's melting temperature, crystallization kinetics, and mechanical properties.
Many studies have also been carried out to explore the influence of in situ microfibrils on the polymers' rheological properties such as shear and elongational viscoelastic behavior.15–19 Currently, it has been acknowledged that the presence of a physical entanglement network defined by topological (entangled) interactions can significantly enhance the composite's melt elasticity, and thus, affect the material properties and its processability. The enhanced melt elasticity is very important for some processing such as blow molding and foaming, where biaxial strength is needed.11 Dong et al.6 observed that the poly(trimethylene terephthalate) (PTT) microfibrils had a greater influence on the rheological properties of polyolefin elastomer (POE) than PTT particles because the PTT microfibrils could form a physical network within the POE matrix. Zhao et al.10 and Wang et al.8 prepared in situ MFCs with different methods and measured the effects of dispersed phase concentration on the complex viscosity. Both studies illustrated that the microfibrils are conducive to increase complex viscosity of polymer matrix. Jayanarayanan et al.20 found that the storage modulus, loss modulus and complex viscosity of PP/PET MFCs were enhanced as draw ratio increased up to an optimized level. The authors attributed the increase in the viscosity to the formation of a physical PET fibril network which hinders the relaxation of the PP phase, as indicated from the frequency-independent tanδ curve.
Generally, the method of Winter–Chambon analysis21,22 is used to identify the gel point,9 that is, the critical fibril content at which a rheologically percolated network forms. The formation of such a network is a typical characteristic of the composites with deformable and long (that is, high aspect ratio) fibers. For example, Kakroodi et al.11 and Rizvi et al.16 applied this method and found out that 3.0 wt% PA and 4.5 wt% PP were needed for the PLA and PE systems, respectively. The strain hardening behavior of polymer blends with fibrillar morphology has been reported, and the dramatic improvements in strain hardening response of polyethylene (PE) was observed through the in situ fibrillation of 1 wt% PP.23
Different MFC systems have been studied to demonstrate the significant effect of fibrillar structure on the properties of the polymer matrix, including PLA/PA,11 PP/PET,12,20 PE/PP16 and POE/PTT.6 In these studies, fibril concentration was taken as the governing factor affecting the formation of a fibrillar network. However, it is well known the network structure is not only dependent on the fibril concentration, but also on the fibrillar morphology such as its dispersion, diameter, aspect ratio, and deformability.24 So far, no study has been found on the influence of specific fibrillar aspect ratio on the formation of network structure. Therefore, it became the primary objective of this study.
Currently, most of the microfibrillar composites are prepared by melt extrusion, continuous hot stretching, and quenching process.5,11,25 That is, three steps should be adopted: (1) melt extrusion: melt blending of the dispersed phase and matrix phase at a temperature above the melting point of the dispersed phase; (2) continuous hot stretching: drawing the extrudate to fibrillate the dispersed component at a temperature between the melting temperature of dispersed phase and matrix phase; and (3) isotropization of the oriented blend. Although this processing method has been widely used for preparation of MFCs, it is undeniable that it is complicated and involves multiple stages. Rizvi et al.12,16 attempted to adopt another method to prepare microfibrillar composites. In their work, the polymers were first melt compounded at a high temperature in a co-rotating twin-screw extruder with a built-in back-flow channel which enables material recirculation for several minutes, and followed by a low-temperature mixing for extra minutes before drawing. Despite that the above process was successful in producing the high aspect ratio fibril, the polymers were retained in the extruder for quite a long time and the productivity was low. Thus, it is not suitable for thermal-sensitive polymers and is inefficient for industrial production. Jurczuk et al.26 demonstrated that compounding molten polymer matrix with solid state polytetrafluoroethylene (PTFE) powder in co-rotating twin-screw was effective to in situ fabricate the fibrils. As far as we know, almost none exploration of utilizing the deformation of other thermoplastic polymers into nano- or micro-fibers such as PET/PBT/PA6/PA66 for microfibrillar composites by this mechanism had been investigated.
Triangle arrayed triple-screw extruder (TTSE) is a novel type of polymer processing equipment with special mixing characteristics and high productivity. It consists of three meshing zones and a central region and generates greater shearing and extensional flow field for polymer compounding.27–29 In this work, we demonstrated that a single extrusion process with TTSE was effective to prepare polyamide 6,6 (PA66) microfirbils in PP polymer matrix without post-extrusion drawing. By varying the processing conditions, in situ PP/PA66 MFCs with well-dispersed high aspect ratio PA66 fibrils were prepared. After that, the dynamic rheological behaviors and uniaxial extensional rheological behaviors of PP containing various aspect ratio fibrils were investigated. The gel point of PP/PA66 MFCs with different aspect ratio PA66 fibrils were thoroughly analyzed according to the Winter–Chambon criterion. Furthermore, the effects of fibrillar morphology and fibril content on the thermal and mechanical properties were studied.
Fig. 1 The schematic of the experimental set-up for the in situ microfibrillar composites preparation. |
An injection molding machine SA900/260 (Ningbo Haitian, China) was used to prepare specimens for mechanical test. The temperature profiles from hopper to nozzle of the injection molding machine were controlled at 170, 190, 210, 210 and 205 °C. The low processing temperature was used to preserve the original fibrillar morphology of PA66 in the composites. The internal mixer was employed to dilute the masterbatch samples into different fibril contents with the temperature, screw speed, and mixing time of 180 °C, 40 rpm, and 4 min, respectively.
Measurements of uniaxial extensional viscosity were made using a Sentmanat Extensional Rheometer (SER) attached to the HAAKE MARS III. Samples were tested at strain rates 0.05 s−1 and at a sample environment temperature of 170 °C. We empirically found that this temperature provided us with the most reproducible and consistent results.
Sample code | Processing parametera | Diameter range (μm) | Average diameter (μm) | Average aspect ratio |
---|---|---|---|---|
a Note: the processing parameters represent PA66 mass content/processing temperature/screw speed. | ||||
MC–LT | 20/230/150 | 1.22–8.57 | 2.28 ± 0.39 | 73 ± 10 |
MC–MT | 20/245/150 | 0.84–5.39 | 2.17 ± 0.25 | 128 ± 8 |
MC–HT | 20/260/150 | 1.15–7.32 | 2.76 ± 0.72 | 42 ± 23 |
LC–MT | 10/245/150 | 1.30–8.57 | 4.51 ± 0.47 | 13 ± 5 |
HC–MT | 30/245/150 | 1.68–8.84 | 4.02 ± 0.31 | 210 ± 11 |
HC–LS | 30/245/100 | 1.77–8.68 | 4.83 ± 0.65 | 178 ± 13 |
HC–HS | 30/245/200 | 1.93–7.95 | 3.70 ± 0.27 | 225 ± 20 |
NB | 20/275/150 | 0.84–6.13 | 3.08 ± 0.31 | 1 |
The influence of PA66 content (10, 20, and 30 wt%) on fibrillar morphology at processing temperature of 245 °C and screw speed of 150 rpm is presented in Fig. 3. Average diameter and average aspect ratio of PA66 fibrils at different processing conditions are summarized in Table 1 and Fig. 2. Compared to low temperature extrusion (Fig. 3a–c), no fibril was formed in PP/PA66 blends obtained by normal extrusion (Fig. 3d). As the PA66 content increased from 10 wt% to 20 wt%, the average diameter of fibrils decreased from 4.51 μm to 2.17 μm and then rose to 4.02 μm when the PA66 content further increased to 30 wt%. However, the aspect ratio rose significantly with an increase in the PA66 content, which was mainly attributed to the fact that higher chance for the dispersed phase to coalescence occurred in the extruder flow field with the increasing PA66 content.
Fig. 2 The effect of (a) PA66 content, (b) processing temperature and (c) screw speed on the average diameters and aspect ratios of PA66 fibrils. |
Fig. 3 Morphology of in situ PA66 fibril with different PA66 content after extraction of PP: (a) LC–MT; (b) MC–MT; (c) HC–MT; (d) NB. |
Fig. 4a–c demonstrates the PA66 morphology after extraction of PP prepared under low, medium and high temperature (230, 245 and 260 °C). The observation of diameter and aspect ratio of the fibril revealed that the medium temperature (245 °C) was favorable for the formation of high-aspect-ratio fibrils (Fig. 4b). Softening and maintaining deformation of particles were tremendously affected by temperature. At the low processing temperature (230 °C), PA granules were not softened enough to be stretched into long fibrils (Fig. 4a). On the contrary, at 260 °C, which is close to the melting temperature of PA66, the PA molecular chains tend to relax and recoil back after stretching in the extruder, resulting in greater and non-uniform diameters (Fig. 4c) compared to the low-temperature cases.
Fig. 4 Morphology of PP/PA66 blends at different processing temperature (a) MC–LT; (b) MC–MT; (c) MC–HT and screw speeds (d) HC–LS; (e) HC–MT; (f) HC–HS after extraction of PP. |
Additionally, the effects of the screw speed on the morphology of fibrils with the PA66 content 30 wt% and processing temperature of 245 °C were studied, and the results are shown in Fig. 4d–f. It can be seen that, at medium processing temperature, all three screw speeds could generate high-aspect-ratio fibrils and higher screw speed producing thinner and higher-aspect-ratio fibrils (Fig. 2). It is understandable that higher shear generated from higher screw speed helped the PA66 domains deform into much uniform and smaller fibrils.
Such a preparation method of in situ microfibrillar composites has been proved to be exercisable by the evidence of fibrillar morphology with wonderful dimension parameters without drawing. The formation mechanism of fibrils in TTSE can be interpreted from two aspects. On the one hand, the spherical particles convert into ellipsoid primarily under strong shearing and drawing field of the extruder and following ellipsoid bond with other similar neighbors, eventually forming large aspect ratio and uniform fibrils suffered from the shearing and extensional flow field.30 On the other hand, another part of the dispersed phase form sheets or blocks from starting, breaking into a network and fibrous structures through interfacial force because of the instability of sheets or blocks.31
Fig. 5 shows the shear responses of molten PP and the PP/PA66 compounds with spherical and PA66 fibrils at 190 °C. Fig. 5a and b illustrate storage modulus (G′) and complex viscosity (η*) as a function of frequency for MFCs with different fibrillar aspect ratio ranging from 1 to 210. The increasing of the aspect ratio leads to a gradual increase in both G′ and η* but the increasement in G′ is more pronounced than that in η*. Furthermore, the storage modulus (G′) had strong dependence on the fibrillar aspect ratio at low frequency. Interestingly, G′ becomes increasingly independent of frequency as the fibrillar aspect ratio increased, which is consistent with the phenomenon that G′ showed increasingly independent of ω as the fibril content increased in previous studies.16,32 Both indicated that the viscoelastic response was changing from ‘liquid-like’ to ‘gel-like’.33,34 The plot of tanδ–ω is shown in Fig. 5c. Tanδ decreased with fibrillar aspect ratio increasing. Specially, for the blend with fibrillar aspect ratio of 210, tanδ nearly exhibited frequency independence. Such an increase in the melt's elastic behavior suggests the formation of a physically entangled network, which would have been created by the topological interactions of the PA66 fibrils.35
Fig. 5 Effect of fibrillar aspect ratio on (a) the storage modulus (G′), (b) complex viscosity (η*), (c) loss tangent (tanδ) and (d) dynamic viscosity (η′′) of the composites. |
The Cole–Cole plot (i.e., dynamic viscosity η′′ versus η′) was often used to characterize the relaxation mechanism of long-chain branched molecular chain under small amplitude oscillatory shear.36 A larger radius of Cole–Cole circle suggested a longer relaxation time. For long-chain branched polymers, the relaxation was primarily governed by the degree of entanglement of molecular chains; and a higher degree of entanglement resulted in a longer relaxation time. Similarly, in PP/PA66 MFCs, a longer relaxation time indicated a higher degree entanglement of PA66 fibrils. As shown in Fig. 5d, the radius of Cole–Cole circle increases as the fibrillar aspect ratio increases. Therefore, we concluded that higher aspect ratio had formed a higher degree of entangled network structure at the same PA content.
Fig. 5 confirms that the fibrillar aspect ratio significantly influenced the formation of physical entanglement network structure. The structural implication of the enhanced elasticity observed with the increase in aspect ratio was that the solid-state PA66 fibrils tended to restrict the long range motion of the matrix polymer chains and prevents them from complete relaxation when subjected to external force.12 The Winter–Chambon criterion had been widely used to accurately determine the gel point of physical and chemical gels from rheological data. A multi-frequency plot of tanδ versus the fibril content revealed an intersection that precisely marked the gel point, as shown in Fig. 6. We observed that, for a specific fibrillar aspect ratio, the plots of tanδ at different frequencies gradually decreased with an increase in fibril content and intersected at one fibril content. And this fibril content was considered as the gel point beyond which a rheological percolated fibrillar network was formed in the system regardless of the applied frequency. This was attributed to the magnitude change of G′(ω) and G′′(ω) before and after gel point at different ω. Thus, the Winter–Chambon theory was also applicable to find the gel points of the PP/PA66 microfibrillar composites.
As shown in Fig. 6a1, the curves of tanδ intersect at a fibril content of 7.0 wt%, thus, the gel point concentration can be accurately identified to be 7.0 wt% for the PP/PA66 MFCs with fibrillar aspect ratio of 42. Similarly, the gel point of AR73, AR128, AR178 and AR210 were determined as 6.7, 5.9, 4.5 and 3.8 wt% (Fig. 6b1–6e1), respectively. This phenomenon could be concluded that the fibrillar aspect ratio indeed significantly affected the formation of the gel point. Moreover, the higher aspect ratio was, the lower fibril content was required to form the physical entanglement network (Fig. 7a). The fibril content was reduced from 7.0 to 3.8 wt% when the fibril aspect ratio increased from 42 to 210. This could be due to two aspects: on the one hand, fibrils with higher aspect ratio have greater surface area, thus increasing the interfacial area between PP molecular chains and the PA fibrils. On the other hand, the high-aspect ratio PA fibrils tended to form a higher degree of entanglement than low-aspect-ratio ones.
The zero shearing viscosity η0 and relaxation time λ of PP containing PA66 fibril with different fibril content and aspect ratio were obtained through fitting the plot of lgη*–lgω based on Carreau model37 and the effect of aspect ratio on η0 and λ is shown in Fig. 7b and c. According to Doi–Edwards model,38 the relaxation time can be used to characterize the material's elastic behaviour and it exhibited an exponential increase with the growth of branching chain length and entanglement. It was noticed that both the η0 and λ increased remarkably not only with increasing fibril content, but also with increasing fibrillar aspect ratio. This confirms that the fibrillar aspect ratio greatly affected the relaxation time of PP matrix; and higher aspect ratio was more effective to form a physical entangled network.
Fig. 8 illustrates the uniaxial extensional viscosity, ηE + (t,έ) at a extensional strain rate of 0.05 s−1 for the neat PP, PP containing 5 wt% PA66 with spherical domains (NB), and PP containing 5 wt% fibrillated PA66 with various aspect ratios (AR73, AR128 and AR210). The solid line in the figure is to show the linear viscoelastic prediction of extensional viscosity, ηE+ = 3η+(t). The η+(t) was the sample's shear viscosity in the linear viscoelastic region and was obtained from dynamic shear experiments at a strain rate of 0.001 s−1. The deviation from the extensional viscosity prediction was used to evaluate the degree of strain hardening. As seen in the graph, there is no strain hardening observed for the neat PP and NB samples. In contrast, the PP/PA66 MFCs exhibited pronounced strain-hardening behaviors and higher-aspect-ratio fibrils induced strain-hardening much earlier. The rheopectic response of PP with PA66 fibrils suggested that the entangled network of fibrils was not readily to disentangle in response to the strain hardening. The similar phenomena were also observed by others.16,39
Fig. 8 Uniaxial extensional viscosity of PP, PP/spherical-PA66 (97/5 wt%) and PP/fibrillated-PA66 blends (97/5 wt%) with various fibrillar aspect ratio. |
Fig. 9 (a) DSC thermograms and (b) nonisothermal crystallization curves of PP phase in the neat PP, PP/PA66 normal blend and PP/PA66 MFCs. |
The PA66 domain morphology had a significant effect on PP's crystallization temperature during the cooling process (Fig. 9b). The crystallization temperature of the neat PP was around 110.90 °C and they were 117.85 °C, 120.67 °C, 121.15 °C, and 121.5 °C for NB, AR73, AR128, and AR210 samples, respectively. The presence of PA66 phase shifted the crystallization temperature of PP to higher levels considerably due to the heterogeneous crystal nucleation effect of the PA66. Compared to the unstretched PA domain, PA66 fibrils improved the crystallization kinetics of PP more significantly. This is because fibrillar domain had a larger specific surface area than spherical one, thus providing more heterogeneous crystal nucleation sites. Furthermore, the thermal properties parameters such as, melting temperature (Tm), peak or maximum crystallization rate temperatures (Tp), melting enthalpy (ΔHm) and percentage of crystallinity (Xc) are tabulated in Table 2. The crystallinity of PP phase was slightly shifted to higher values with an increase in fibrillar aspect ratio. The transcrystallization effect could be the reason for an increase in Xc for PP/PA66 MFCs which possesses long PA66 microfibrils. In addition, more heterogeneous crystal nuclei could be induced by a larger specific surface area from higher aspect ratio fibrils.
Samples | Tm (°C) | Tp (°C) | ΔHm (J g−1) | Xc (%) |
---|---|---|---|---|
PP | 162.3 | 110.4 | 101 | 48.3 |
NB | 164.2 | 117.8 | 69.3 | 41.26 |
AR73 | 165.7 | 120.6 | 85.7 | 51.2 |
AR128 | 166.1 | 121.1 | 88.1 | 52.6 |
AR210 | 169.3 | 121.5 | 82.4 | 56.3 |
Fig. 10 The tensile and impact properties under (a) different PA66 content with aspect ratio of 210 and (b) different fibrillar aspect ratio with PA66 content of 10 wt%. |
In order to study the effect of PA66 aspect ratio on the mechanical properties of PP, the PA66 content was fixed at 10 wt% and the detailed results were present in Fig. 10b and Table 3. As the PA morphology changes from spheres-ellipsoid-short microfibrils to long microfibrillar structure, the tensile strength and impact strength increased significantly. Specifically, as the fibrillar aspect ratio increased from 1 to 225, the tensile strength and impact strength increased by 17.81% and 64.41%, respectively.
Sample code | Average aspect ratio | Tensile strength (MPa) | Tensile modulus (GPa) | Impact strength kJ m−2 |
---|---|---|---|---|
MC–LT | 73 ± 10 | 31.24 ± 0.30 | 1.26 ± 0.09 | 7.09 ± 0.22 |
MC–MT | 128 ± 8 | 32.82 ± 0.33 | 1.37 ± 0.12 | 7.28 ± 0.20 |
MC–HT | 42 ± 23 | 30.19 ± 0.32 | 1.22 ± 0.10 | 6.72 ± 0.20 |
LC–MT | 13 ± 5 | 29.44 ± 0.25 | 1.08 ± 0.07 | 5.61 ± 0.15 |
HC–MT | 210 ± 11 | 34.02 ± 0.31 | 1.73 ± 0.08 | 8.91 ± 0.21 |
HC–LS | 178 ± 13 | 33.94 ± 0.27 | 1.65 ± 0.05 | 8.71 ± 0.24 |
HC–HS | 225 ± 20 | 34.47 ± 0.28 | 1.92 ± 0.07 | 8.73 ± 0.23 |
NB | 1 | 29.26 ± 0.31 | 0.91 ± 0.11 | 5.31 ± 0.22 |
We suggest that for higher PA66 fibrillar aspect ratio, the entangled network occurred more easily and stronger during compounding, which is primarily responsible for a significant improvement of tensile strength and impact strength of PP matrix. Also, with the amount of fibrils added, adhesion between the fibrils and the matrix can affect the reinforcement of a composite system. Herein, the abundance of the long PA66 fibrils is acting as excellent stress transfer neurogen, which contribute to the enhancement of the mechanical properties. Additionally, there is a strong possibility for the formation of a shish-kebab structure and transcrystalline layer of PP around PA66 in the case of samples with high aspect ratio, and this structure improved the adhesion between both phases obviously.41
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2017 |