Chandrasekar M. Subramaniyamab,
N. R. Srinivasanc,
Zhixin Taia,
Hua Kun Liu*a and
Shi Xue Doua
aInstitute for Superconducting and Electronic Materials, Australian Institute for Innovative Materials, University of Wollongong, Innovation Campus, North Wollongong, NSW 2500, Australia. E-mail: hua@uow.edu.au
bTexas Materials Institute, Department of Mechanical Engineering, University of Texas Austin, 204 E Dean Keeton St., C2200, Austin, Texas 78712, USA
cDepartment of Chemical Engineering, Indian Institute of Technology Madras, Chennai 600036, India
First published on 15th March 2017
Herein, we investigated the electrochemical performance of nitrogen-doped commercial activated charcoal (R-AC) for lithium-ion batteries (LIBs). With this aim, nitrogen was doped into R-AC via a solvent-free approach, which involved annealing R-AC under N2 and NH3 atmospheres at 800 °C, and the product was tested as an anode for LIBs. The sample annealed under an NH3 atmosphere (NH-AC) had a nitrogen doping level of 4.7 at% with a specific surface area of 894.5 m2 g−1 and a reduced O/C ratio of 0.31 in comparison to the sample annealed under an N2 atmosphere (N-AC) and R-AC. Raman spectroscopy detected disorder/defects owing to the introduction of various C–N–C terminal bonds on the surface of R-AC, which significantly improved the electrical conductivity of both N-AC and NH-AC. Therefore, endowed with these physicochemical properties, NH-AC delivered a high specific capacity of 736.4 mA h g−1 at 50 mA g−1 (up to 150 cycles) and 524 mA h g−1 at 200 mA g−1 even after 500 cycles, which indicates much better performance in comparison to those of R-AC, N-AC and commercial graphite. This remarkable electrochemical performance of NH-AC can be attributed to the synergistic effect of its large specific surface area, disordered graphitic structure, and low charge transfer resistance, which enable it to act as an anode for high-performance LIBs.
The mechanism of intercalation and deintercalation of lithium with carbonaceous materials could be expressed as 6C + yLi+ + xe− = LiyC6, in which y is the stoichiometric factor, where y = 1 for graphitic carbon and 0.5 < y < 3 for low-temperature-annealed non-graphitic carbon.8 Although the latter displays a high specific capacity, it also suffers from large irreversible capacity losses in the first cycle owing to decomposition of the electrolyte and the formation of a solid-electrolyte interphase (SEI) over its surface at an operating voltage close to that of lithium. It traps a large amount of lithium ions in its network during intercalation owing to oxygen-containing surface functional groups or diffusion constraints.9 Even so, the initially formed SEI layer prevents further decomposition of the electrolyte at the anode surface and reduces the diffusivity of charge carriers between the anode and the electrolyte. Therefore, the thickness of the SEI layer could be adjusted by tailoring the properties of carbon and the surface functional groups. Numerous strategies are used to mitigate the formation of an SEI by tuning its morphology, such as the use of graphene, carbon nanotubes, carbon nanofibers, and porous carbon.10 Nanostructured porous carbons are of great interest as they provide enhanced reversible lithium storage and excellent cycling life. This is achieved because of their large electrode–electrolyte interface, which promotes the charge transfer reaction by reducing the diffusion length of lithium. Another approach comprises the modification of their surface functional groups with non-carbon elements such as nitrogen, sulphur, and phosphorus.11,12 The presence of heteroatoms enhances the reactivity and electrical conductivity and thereby increases the lithium storage capacity.13 In addition to these advantages, amorphous carbon also displays high mechanical stability against the volumetric changes that occur during the insertion and deinsertion of lithium. Hence, surface-modified nanostructured carbon provides an excellent network for interstitial connections, which results in superior electrochemical performance, and also acts as a buffering agent for mechanically weak inorganic electrode materials.9
Because commercial activated charcoal (R-AC) possesses a large specific surface area (>500 m2 g−1) and pore volume (0.8 cm3 g−1), it is widely used in supercapacitors and also finds applications in the areas of hydrogen storage, water treatment, and separation techniques.10,14 As mentioned earlier, the introduction of nitrogen heteroatoms into carbon leads to the modification of its surface with functional groups, which further enhances its electrochemical performance with respect to Li+/Li0. Multiple ways of introducing N atoms have been investigated in recent years10 using nitric acid and melamine as N sources. These chemical precursors tend to give rise to a low nitrogen percentage with morphological changes and also leave unreacted chemicals/inactive species in the product, which impede its electrochemical performance. With this aim, a solvent-free inexpensive method has been chosen in this study for doping heteroatoms into commercial activated carbon (AC) to understand the behaviour of the electrode during the cycling process in LIBs. The selection of R-AC as the anode was based on its commercial availability at a low cost in comparison to that of conventional graphite.
Fig. 2 Morphology of (a and b) raw activated charcoal (R-AC); (c and d) R-AC annealed under an N2 atmosphere (N-AC); (e and f) R-AC annealed under NH3 atmosphere (NH-AC). |
Morphological investigations using scanning electron microscopy (SEM) were carried out for all samples (R-AC, N-AC, and NH-AC), and the SEM images are presented in Fig. 2. Fig. 2a and b show that R-AC contains numerous macropores. On annealing R-AC under a nitrogen atmosphere for the preparation of N-AC (Fig. 2c and d), the nitrogen reacted with the surface of the carbon and removed oxygen in the form of CO and CO2 gases. The evolution of these gases will probably have created more pores, leading to a larger specific surface area. It is believed that the reaction between a carbon surface and gas molecules (NH3) can lead to the substantial removal of carbon in the form of CH4. As a result, NH-AC (Fig. 2e and f) exhibits a larger specific surface area than that of N-AC and R-AC.20,21 It is evident from these SEM images that the porous structure was retained in all samples, even after annealing at 800 °C.
X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy (XPS) analysis was performed to determine the elemental compositions and chemical states of the samples. The complete survey spectra of R-AC, N-AC, and NH-AC (not shown here) indicate that C and O elements are the major components, of which the peaks are centred at 284 and 532 eV, respectively, whereas the minor elements are N and Si. The elemental surface compositions of the samples are summarized in Table 1. It is observed from Table 1 that the nitrogen content increased with a decrease in the oxygen content when R-AC was annealed under both nitrogen and ammonia atmospheres. Moreover, from the O/C ratio it is clear that the amount of polar functional groups was also drastically reduced during the heat treatment of R-AC. These polar functional groups were responsible for the formation of a thick and irregular SEI film on the surfaces of carbon particles. The high-resolution C 1s spectra of all the samples can be deconvolved into four peaks, as shown in Fig. 3a, c, and e. The peaks around 284.6, 285.5, 287, and 289.2 eV can be assigned to CC, C–N and C–C, CO, and OC–OH, respectively. Similarly, the high-resolution N 1s spectra can be deconvolved into 4 peaks (Fig. 3b, d, and f); these are centred at 398.6, 400.1, 401.6, and 403.4 eV, which could be assigned to pyridinic N, pyrrolic N, graphitic N, and oxidized N, respectively.18,22–24 The doped nitrogen contents were found to be 2.6, 3.2, and 4.7 at% for R-AC, N-AC, and NH-AC, respectively. From the point of view of electrochemical performance, a nitrogen-doped carbon matrix (in particular with pyridinic N and pyrrolic N) could generate more active sites for lithium-ion storage, as well as electron transport. A possible reason for the enhancement in electrochemical performance is the faradic reaction of the nitrogen-containing functional groups.18,22–24 Furthermore, nitrogen doping also improved the wettability and conductivity of the carbon matrix. It is evident from Table 2 that the concentrations of pyridinic N and pyrrolic N are higher in NH-AC in comparison to those in R-AC and N-AC. The evolution of these functional groups in the NH-AC matrix increased the amount of pores, which is in good agreement with the BET analysis.
Sample ID | Elemental composition (at%) | O/C ratio | |||
---|---|---|---|---|---|
C 1s | N 1s | O 1s | Si 2p | ||
R-AC | 64.3 | 2.6 | 32.5 | 0.6 | 0.51 |
N-AC | 72.9 | 3.2 | 23.3 | 0.6 | 0.32 |
NH-AC | 72.5 | 4.7 | 22.2 | 0.6 | 0.31 |
Fig. 3 XPS high-resolution C 1s and N 1s spectra of R-AC (a and b), N-AC (c and d), and NH-AC (e and f). |
Sample ID | Composition (at%) | |||
---|---|---|---|---|
Pyridinic N 398.2 eV | Pyrrolic N 400.1 eV | Graphitic N 401.6 eV | Oxidized N 403.4 eV | |
R-AC | 0.2 | 0.8 | 1.3 | 0.4 |
N-AC | 0.4 | 1.2 | 1.0 | 0.5 |
NH-AC | 1.0 | 1.4 | 1.4 | 0.9 |
To acquire insights into the effects of N doping, commercial graphite, R-AC, N-AC, and NH-AC were tested as anodes at a moderate current rate of 50 mA g−1. The initial specific discharge and charge capacities were found to be 402.3 and 284.1 mA h g−1 (graphite); 984.6 and 353.6 mA h g−1 (R-AC); 1165.3 and 482.9 mA h g−1 (N-AC), and 2376.1 and 1092.6 mA h g−1 (NH-AC), respectively. The initial coulombic efficiency was greatly increased for NH-AC (45.98%) in comparison that of to N-AC (41.44%) and R-AC (35.91%). This irreversible loss could be attributed to the irreversible formation of Li2O and the solid-electrolyte interphase (SEI), which retains lithium ions, and the decomposition of the electrolyte at lower voltages, as confirmed by CV (Fig. 4a, inset). This is in good agreement with other reports that refer to carbonaceous materials.8,10,13,16,21,25 Nevertheless, all the electrodes exhibited a coulombic efficiency of 98–99% from the second cycle onwards. The NH-AC electrode delivered the highest reversible specific capacity of 736.4 mA h g−1 in comparison to N-AC (464.9 mA h g−1) and R-AC (459.9 mA h g−1) when the electrodes were cycled at a current rate of 50 mA g−1, even after 150 cycles, which indicates superior performance to that of commercial graphite (259.1 mA h g−1), as shown in Fig. 4b and S2.†
The voltage–specific discharge capacity profile can be divided into three regions (R-I, R-II, and R-III) according to the intercalation of Li+ in different regions of carbon.26–28 Region R-I (0.002–0.1 V) can be mainly assigned to the intercalation of Li+ ions into the interplanar spaces between aligned graphene sheets. In the case of region R-II (0.1–0.9 V), the contribution to the specific capacity can be ascribed to the intercalation of Li+ between disordered and ordered graphene sheets. In the voltage range above 0.9 V (R-III), the contribution to the capacity can be attributed to the intercalation of Li+ into edge sites, in particular surface functional groups. Table 3 shows the contributions to the specific capacity for all regions of the profile.
Region | Specific capacity (mA h g−1) | |||
---|---|---|---|---|
Graphite | R-AC | N-AC | NH-AC | |
R-I (0.02–0.1 V) | 216.1 | 148.4 | 257.5 | 563.5 |
R-II (0.1–0.9 V) | 139.7 | 706.4 | 726.4 | 1435.5 |
R-III (above 0.9 V) | 46.5 | 129.8 | 181.4 | 377.1 |
Total specific capacity (mA h g−1) | 402.3 | 984.6 | 1165.3 | 2376.1 |
As can be seen, in the case of graphite the contribution to the specific capacity mainly originates from the graphene sheets. NH-AC possesses higher specific capacity in the R-I region, which could be related to the number of available graphene sheets per unit area as well as the interplanar spacing between the graphene sheets, as confirmed by XRD. Furthermore, the increased specific capacity of NH-AC in the other regions (R-II and R-III) may be related to the disordered structure and surface functional groups, as confirmed by other characterization techniques such as XPS and Raman spectroscopy. Therefore, the contribution of the first cycle to the specific discharge capacity is correlated with the findings obtained from characterization techniques.
To test their long-term cycling stability at high current rates, NH-AC and N-AC were subjected to electrochemical performance testing at 200 mA g−1 for 500 cycles (Fig. 4c) and 500 mA g−1 for 1000 cycles (Fig. 4d) and rate capability testing at various current rates (Fig. S3†). NH-AC delivered high reversible capacities of 523.9 mA h g−1 and 281.1 mA h g−1 at current rates of 200 and 500 mA g−1 after 500 and 1000 cycles, respectively, whereas the N-AC electrode exhibited capacities of only 201.1 and 353 mA h g−1 at the same respective current rates and cycle numbers. It is believed that the intercalation of Li+ into graphene sheets contributed to the discharge capacity when the potential was below 0.11 V. Furthermore, the contribution of defects and surface functional groups to the capacity appeared above 0.1 V.29 Therefore, carbon with a large surface area and a disordered graphite structure is preferred for accommodating a large quantity of lithium ions. Moreover, the specific surface area is beneficial for the adsorption of lithium ions at interfacial sites and reducing the overpotential (small charge transfer resistance) owing to a decrease in the local current density.
Fig. 4e shows the electrochemical impedance spectra of these electrodes, which provide further insights into their remarkable electrochemical performance. The Nyquist plots consist of a semicircle at high frequencies and a straight line at low frequencies, which are attributed to the electrolyte or solution resistance (Re) offered at the electrode–electrolyte interface and the charge transfer resistance (Rct) in the case of the semicircle and the Warburg diffusion (Wo) of lithium in the case of the straight line, together with a constant-phase element (CPE-1) and a non-ideal constant-phase element (CPE-2), as represented in the equivalent circuit model. N-AC and NH-AC displayed a negligible electrolyte resistance of 2.43 Ω in comparison to 34.74 Ω for R-AC, whereas NH-AC exhibited an initial Rct value of 306.85 Ω in comparison to 431.52 Ω for N-AC and 393.8 Ω for R-AC. Therefore, the remarkable enhancement in Li storage for NH-AC can be considered to be due to (1) the high at% N content in the form of pyridinic N and pyrrolic N, which increased the electronic conductivity and induced defects, creating new surface active sites that enhanced the reactivity of lithium; (2) the porous structure with a large surface area, which helped to accommodate the changes in volume during lithiation and delithiation; (3) the lowest solution/electrolyte resistance at the electrode–electrolyte interface, which could further reduce the build-up of the SEI during cycling; and finally (4) the reduced Rct value of NH-AC after 1000 cycles in comparison to that before cycling, which indicates that new sites were generated during cycling that promoted remarkably stable electrochemical performance, even after 1000 cycles at a high current rate of 500 mA g−1. The electrochemical performance of NH-AC was also compared with that of other reports in the literature, as shown in Table 4. This electrode's outstanding performance may be due to its increased nitrogen content18,30–34 and reduced O/C ratio16 and the solvent-free approach, which left no chemical residues to impede its electrochemical performance.16,18,19,24,33 Thus, owing to its unique porous structure and low cost, NH-AC is able to deliver excellent reversible specific capacity, high rate capability, and very good cycling stability, as well as shows great potential to be competitive with other next-generation anode materials for secondary rechargeable batteries.
Synthesis method/morphology | Composition of carbonaceous materials (N, C, O) at% | Surface area (m2 g−1) after N doping | Potential (V vs. Li+/Li0) | Current rate (mA g−1) | Initial capacity (mA h g−1) | Capacity retention (mA h g−1)/(cycles) | Reference |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
N-Doped activated charcoal (N-AC) annealed in ammonia gas atmosphere at 800 °C for 8 h | N – 4.7 | 894.47 | 0.002–3 | 200 | 2080 | 523.5 (500) | Present work |
C – 72.5 | |||||||
O – 22.2 | 500 | 1327.9 | 281 (1000) | ||||
N-Doped carbon produced by carbonization and activation of phenol-melamine- formaldehyde resin at 700 °C for 2 h under an N2 gas atmosphere | N – 7.24 | 674.28 | 0.001–3 | 100 | 917 | 251 (20) | 16 |
C – 63.66 | |||||||
O – 22.88 | |||||||
H – 1.61 | |||||||
N-Containing activated carbons prepared from polyaniline (PANI) by KOH activation | N – 3.72 | 2287 | 0.001–3 | 100 | 2201 | 747 (20) | 30 |
C – 86.55 | |||||||
O – 9.73 | |||||||
N-Doped porous graphene material prepared by freeze-drying a graphene/melamine–formaldehyde hydrogel and subsequent annealing | N – 5.8 | 1170 | 0.005–3 | 400 | 458 | 496 (200) | 24 |
Remainder | |||||||
C and O | |||||||
S- and N-dual-doped porous carbon produced by carbonizing the shells of broad beans by chemical activation | N – 2.2 | 655.4 | 0.01–3 | 372 | 845.2 | 261.5 (100) | 33 |
S – 0.97 | |||||||
Remainder C and O | |||||||
N-Doped MWCNT synthesized by an aerosol-assisted catalytic CVD technique using toluene and acetonitrile in various ratios | For 25% CH3CN | — | 0.01–2.5 | 0.26 mA cm−2 | 568.3 | 270 (30) | 35 |
N – 1.23 | |||||||
Remainder C and O | |||||||
N-Doped hierarchical porous carbon derived from fish scales | N – 3.95 | 1980 | 0.01–2.5 | 75 | 1521.2 | 509.7 (75) | 36 |
C – 84.53 | |||||||
O – 11.52 | |||||||
N-Doped chitosan-based carbon cryogel synthesized via a combined process of freeze-drying and high-temperature carbonization | N – 3.14 | 1025 | 0–3 | 100 | 1148 | 395 (100) | 34 |
O – 14.97 | |||||||
Remainder C | |||||||
N-Doped carbon xerogels obtained from melamine–resorcinol–formaldehyde precursors | N – 1.8 | 2912 | 0.01–3 | 37.2 | ∼1450 | 645 (50) | 18 |
Remainder C and O | |||||||
N-Doped porous carbon obtained from garlic peel as high-capacity anode | N – 4.12 | 1710 | 0.01–2.5 | 100 | 570 | 540 | 31 |
C – 86.39 | |||||||
O – 9.39 | |||||||
N-Doped amorphous carbon nanosheets synthesized by thermal decomposition of EDTA manganese disodium salt hydrate | N – 9.8 | 242.3 | 0.02–2.5 | 250 | 1193.4 | 465.8 (600) | 19 |
C – 77.87 | |||||||
O – 12.96 | |||||||
N-Rich hierarchical porous carbon monoliths produced via ice-templating | N – 16.4 | 173 | 0.005–3 | 50 | 745 | 560 (100) | 23 |
C – 72 | |||||||
O – 10.56 | |||||||
H – 1.04 | |||||||
N-Doped 3D free-standing porous graphene/graphite foam obtained by in situ activation | N – 2 to 3 | 943 | 0.01–3 | 186 | ∼550 | 397 (300) | 22 |
Remainder C and O | |||||||
N-Enriched ordered mesoporous carbons | N – 24.4 wt% | 251 | 0.01–3 | 100–300 | 1034 | 505 (300) | 25 |
Remainder C and O | |||||||
N-Doped graphene obtained using hexamethylenetetramine as a single source by a hydrothermal method | N – 1.68 | 466 | 0.01–3 | 100–200 | 1420 | 600 (50) | 32 |
Remainder C and O | 500 (150) | ||||||
N-Doped porous carbon microspheres produced under an ammonia atmosphere | N – 6.3 | 1630 | 0.005–3 | 50 | 816 | 660 (50) | 21 |
C – 91.5 | |||||||
O – 2.2 |
Footnote |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available. See DOI: 10.1039/c6ra27836a |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2017 |