Fan Xua,
Kaili Zhanga,
Ying Zhoua,
Zhichao Qua,
Haijun Wangb,
Yamei Zhanga,
Haijun Zhoua and
Chao Yan*a
aSchool of Materials Science and Engineering, Jiangsu University of Science and Technology, Zhenjiang, 212003, P. R. China. E-mail: chaoyan@just.edu.cn; Fax: +86 511 84407381; Tel: +86 511 84415618
bShaanxi University of Science and Technology, Xi'an 710021, Shaanxi, China
First published on 17th March 2017
Uniform active films are highly desirable for electronic applications, but still challenging. This work proposed a convenient and effective approach for the production of uniform oriented PVDF thin films with high content of polar β-phase by blade shear. The obtained films not only had a smooth surface, but also achieved uniform component distribution. The results revealed that PVDF crystals preferentially oriented perpendicular to the shear direction and the largest relatively β-phase content was up to 93% calculated from FTIR. It was also found that an appropriate elevated temperature is helpful to the formation of all-trans β-phase with the aid of shear. The oriented uniform PVDF films showed outstanding switching and piezoelectric properties with a polarization switching voltage as low as 3 V and a relatively small coercive field of ∼6 MV m−1. The observed properties may result from the enhancement of crystallinity of the β-phase and the orientation of crystals. The results suggest that oriented PVDF films can be suitably implemented in the fabrication of electronic devices.
Since the β-phase has the best electrically active properties, allowing possible commercially applications in the areas of sensors,17 actuators,18 energy harvesting materials,19,20 and biomedical field.21 A variety of additional processes have been established to fabricate the β-phase in PVDF. The most common way of triggering the transformation from α to β is mechanical stretching, which transits original spherulitic structure into crystal array. However, this method results the PDVF film in roughness surface and weak leakage properties.22,23 The solution control method was also used to obtain β-phase of PVDF, but the micropores formed during the solution evaporation and roughness hampered its applications.24,25 The application of electric field on both sides of PVDF film can also promote a higher spontaneous polarization for the β-phase, but a strong electric field is required.26,27 The PVDF/CNTs nanocomposites have the potential to be the smart materials, not only because of the piezoelectric properties of β-phase, but also the conducting properties of CNTs.12,28 The extreme nanoconfinement into the pores of anodic alumina membrane (AAM) can induce preferential orientation of the crystalline domains of β-phase. Whereas the piezoelectric properties cannot usually be detected accurately because of the existence of the AAM template, removing the template to obtain nanowires is necessary.29,30 Recently, the Langmuir–Blodgett (LB) technique was used to obtain PVDF nanofilms containing the β-phase content up to 95%.31,32 It was claimed that hydrogen bonding between PVDF and water contributes to the formation of β-phase and the dipole orientation. However, production of oriented PVDF films with high content of β-phase without using external agent and sophisticated process is a challenging.33 Moreover, the morphological and component uniformity is important in a practical scenario, which was seldom investigated in the previous works. The obtained films in present work not only had a smooth surface, but also achieved uniform component distribution. From this point of view, an investigation of facile method to obtain β-phase with more content and superior ferroelectric and piezoelectric performance of PVDF was worthwhile.
In this paper, we demonstrate an efficient method to produce oriented uniform PVDF thin film with high content of polar β-phase by blade shear. We systematically investigated the structure, morphology, and ferro- and piezoelectrical properties of the sheared PVDF films. Different crystallization behaviours of sheared and unsheared PVDF were compared by polarizing optical microscope (POM) and atomic force microscopy (AFM). Significantly, to prove the formation of different polymorphisms, we performed wide-angle X-ray diffraction (XRD), Fourier-transform infrared spectroscopy (FTIR) and micro-Raman spectroscopy. Piezoelectric and ferroelectronic properties related to the molecular packing were investigated by piezoresponse force microscopy (PFM) and standard ferroelectric testing system, respectively.
Moreover, the blade shear induces not only orientation of crystals but also smooth surface. As shown in the magnification of the sheared region (Fig. 1c), the morphology presents a relatively smooth surface. To better verify the smoothness of the surface, the root-mean-square roughness (RMS) of around 5.6 nm was achieved by tapping-mode atomic force microscopy (AFM) (Fig. 1d). The uniformity, including morphology and component, is important in a practical scenario. The morphological uniformity of sheared film was proved by POM and AFM (Fig. 1c and d). In order to verify the uniformity of component, Raman mapping of the Iβ, the intensity of characteristic Raman shift of β-phase, over the sheared region was performed. As shown in Fig. 1e, it was clear that the color of the mapping is relatively uniform, indicating the uniform β-phase contribution in the films (detailed Raman characterization will be discussed in the later part). These results verified that the blade shear produced high quality films with smooth surface and uniform component distribution.
To further demonstration of the orientation of sheared film, the microstructure of a PVDF film sheared at 158 °C and an unsheared film isothermal crystallization at the same temperature were investigated by AFM. It was found that the edge-on lamellae were well perpendicular to the shear direction (indicated by the arrow) in the sheared film, as shown in Fig. 2a. On the contrary, the film isothermal crystallization without shear process predominantly exhibits the typical banding spherulitic morphology with the mixture of flat-on and edge-on structures, as illustrated in Fig. 2b, which is the part of a spherulite. In addition, crystal size in sheared region was much smaller than spherulite, which indicates that the shear gives rise to very strong nucleation, resulting in the formation of abundant micro-crystallites. The shear caused the formation of well oriented microstructure. In other words, the lamellae were randomly distributed along the direction of crystal growth in the unsheared sample, while the shear induced the molecular chains preferable orientation along the shear direction and formed oriented crystallines.
Fig. 2 AFM images of (a) A PVDF film sheared at 158 °C, the shear direction indicated by an arrow. (b) A PVDF film without shearing and subsequently isothermal crystallization at 158 °C. |
In order to demonstrate the predominant crystalline phase of sheared samples at different temperatures, X-ray diffraction, FTIR and Raman spectroscopy were performed. Fig. 3a showed the XRD patterns of the PVDF films were sheared and subsequently crystallized at four different temperatures, 152 °C, 156 °C, 158 °C and 160 °C. The unsheared film isothermal crystallization at 158 °C was chosen as a representative. It was clearly shown that only the 17.6, 18.3, 19.9, and 26.5° diffraction peaks attributed to α-phase can be distinguished for unsheared sample, which suggests that only the α-phase can be produced by melt-crystallization without shearing at the temperature below 160 °C. However, when the shear was imposed on the PVDF films, except for the aforementioned diffractions, the sheared films showed a new peak at 20.56°, which is assigned to the β-phase and is attributed to the overlapping of (110) and (200) diffractions. Moreover, the relative intensity of peak at 20.56° gradually increased with the shear temperature.36 To quantitatively evaluate the crystalline and β-phase content at different conducting conditions, the degree of crystallinity (Xc) and the phase content of β (Xβ) were calculated using the following equations:37,38
The use of FTIR and Raman spectroscopy for material characterization is important because it provides fast, simple, qualitative and quantitative analysis. The FTIR spectra of sheared and unsheared films were presented in Fig. 3c. For the unsheared sample, the characteristic peaks at 610, 765, 796, 855, and 976 cm−1 ascribed to α-phase were clearly detected,39 which is in agreement with previous results. However, it is not surprising that relatively strong absorption peaks at 510, 840, and 1279 cm−1 assigned to β-phase were observed in the sheared films. The result also indicates that the blade shear is helpful to induce the formation of β-phase. Fig. 3d shows Raman spectra of the sheared and unsheared samples. It is evident that only α-phase exists in the unsheared film, because only the characteristic peaks at 284, 535, 610, and 795 cm−1 attributed to the α-phase can be found.40 However, the characteristic peaks of the β-phase appear at 263, 510, and 839 cm−1 were clearly seen in the sheared films at 152 °C, 156 °C, 158 °C and 160 °C, which indicates that the blade shear induces the formation of β-phase even at a temperature lower than 160 °C. The Raman observations agree well with the results of XRD and FTIR.
As shown in XRD, FTIR and Raman measurements, the relative intensity of the β-phase characteristic peaks gradually increased with the temperature, while the intensity of the α-phase gradually decreased. In order to quantify the β-phase content presented in each sample, quantitative FTIR analysis was utilized. Assuming that FTIR absorption follows the Lambert–Beer law, the fraction of the β-phase was calculated using following equation:6,39
The results obtained from the different samples were presented in Fig. 3e. It can be found that the β-phase content, representing by F(β) and the intensity ratio Iβ/Iα, increases remarkably with the shearing temperature at blow 156 °C, and gradually reaches a plateau after that. The relatively high content of β-phase up to 93% was obtained. It was well documented that the shear force induces orientation of polymer chains. In the present case, higher temperature prefers to induce all-trans conformation (β-phase) with the existing of a shear field.
The piezoelectric properties of the sheared samples were also examined by piezoelectric force microscopy (PFM) with an additional voltage amplifier, as shown in Fig. 4. For this measurement, the PVDF films sheared on cleaned ITO coated glass substrate were loaded on a conducting sample holder that is directly connected to the ground of the high voltage amplifier. A conducting AFM cantilever with a Pt coated tip was brought in contact with the films. The response of PVDF films was measured by the reflection of a laser beam from the cantilever as like the regular atomic force microscope (AFM). Fig. 4a shows the evident piezoresponse phase–voltage hysteresis loops for the samples of sheared and unsheared isothermal crystallization at 158 °C. No obvious hysteresis loop was observed for unsheared sample indicating its nonpolar property. The evident hysteresis loop represents the existence of a switchable polarization of the sheared film. When the DC voltage was reversed from −10 V to +10 V, the change in the phase signal was 180°. The DC voltage of abrupt phase change for the sheared film was about 3 V. It can be estimated the apparent coercive field of 500 nm-thick sheared film was about 6 MV m−1. The value is comparable to that of the optimized ordered P(VDF-TrFE) film (∼10 MV m−1)43 and much smaller than that of the corresponding bulk PVDF and P(VDF-TrFE) (50–100 MV m−1).44,45 It is reasonable to speculate that the small apparent coercive field of the sheared sample is attributed to the high polar β-phase crystallinity and the orientation of β-phase crystalline.46,47 The amplitude signal is directly related to the strain of the microscopic region under the tip. Fig. 4b shows the amplitude–voltage butterfly loop. The sudden change of the strain happens at DC voltages of −1.7 V and +0.47 V, respectively. In other words, this electric field is sufficient to polarization switching. The shift of the center of the hysteresis loops from 0 V indicates the possible existence of a built-in field inside the sheared films.48 With decrease of voltage, the amplitude decreases due to contraction of the sheared film. Thus, the amplitude–voltage curve is linear at low and moderate voltage, which also indicates converse piezoelectric effect in the sheared films. The piezoelectric results suggest that the energy cost for electrically polarization switching decreased, and the lower polarization switching voltage was well suited for integrated driving electronics.
Fig. 4 PFM phase–voltage hysteresis loops (a) and amplitude–voltage butterfly loop (b) of sheared and unsheared PVDF films. |
A short pulse train was required to obtain ferroelectricity. Here, a forming time of one second at a frequency of 100 Hz was sufficient to obtain a well saturated hysteresis loop for the sheared film. Gold was used as the upper and lower electrodes. The upper electrode was approximately 300 μm2. Fig. 5a shows the ferroelectric hysteresis loops of the sheared films. The unsheared PVDF film did not show P–E hysteresis loop when the electric field was applied due to the α-phase exhibit no polarization and the chains were packed with the dipoles in the opposite direction in the unit cell. On the contrary, well saturated hysteresis loops were observed for the sheared films crystallized at different temperatures. The remnant polarization (Pr) was 4.05, 4.34, 5.02, 6.44 μC cm−2, respectively, with the increase of sheared temperature from 152 °C to 160 °C (Fig. 5b). The gradual increase of Pr is caused by the crystallinity enhancement of polar β-phase with increasing of sheared temperature.49,50 For all sheared samples, the coercive field (Ec) was around 5 to 6.5 MV m−1, which is consistent with the PFM result and is much lower than the value of the bulk samples.44 This effect was associated with the formation of the high content of polar β-phase as well as the preferential orientation of the crystalline due to the shearing of the blade. The shape of the hysteresis loops was not significantly altered, demonstrating similar switching behaviours for all the samples sheared at different temperatures.
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2017 |