Irene Bennia,
Matilde Cardoso Trabucoab,
Enrico Di Stasioc,
Alessandro Arcovitoc,
Alberto Boffide,
Francesco Malatestaa,
Alessandra Bonamorea,
Simone De Panfilise,
Valeria de Turrise and
Paola Baiocco*e
aDepartment of Biochemical Sciences “Alessandro Rossi Fanelli”, Sapienza University of Rome, P.le A. Moro 5, 00185 Rome, Italy
bMolirom srl, via Ravenna 8, 00161 Rome, Italy
cInstitute of Biochemistry and Clinical Biochemistry, Catholic University, Largo Francesco Vito, 1, 00168 Rome, Italy
dInstitute of Molecular Biology and Pathology, National Research Council, P.le A. Moro 7, 00185 Rome, Italy
eCenter for Life Nano Science@Sapienza, Istituto Italiano di Tecnologia, V.le Regina Elena 291, 00161 Rome, Italy. E-mail: paola.baiocco@iit.it
First published on 3rd April 2018
Ferritin self-assembly has been widely exploited for the synthesis of a variety of nanoparticles for drug-delivery and diagnostic applications. However, despite the crucial role of ferritin self-assembly mechanism for probes encapsulation, little is known about the principles behind the oligomerization mechanism. In the present work, the novel “humanized” chimeric Archaeal ferritin HumAfFt, displaying the transferrin receptor-1 (TfR1) recognition motif typical of human H homopolymer and the unique salt-triggered oligomerization properties of Archaeoglobus fulgidus ferritin (AfFt), was site-selectively labeled with N-(1-pyrenyl)maleimide on a topologically selected cysteine residue inside the protein cavity, next to the dimer interface. Pyrene characteristic fluorescence features were exploited to investigate the transition from a dimeric to a cage-like 24-meric state and to visualize the protein in vitro by two photon fluorescence microscopy. Indeed, pyrene fluorescence changes upon ferritin self-assembly allowed to establish, for the first time, the kinetic and thermodynamic details of the archaeal ferritins oligomerization mechanism. In particular, the magnesium induced oligomerization proved to be faster than the monovalent cation-triggered process, highly cooperative, complete at low MgCl2 concentrations, and reversed by treatment with EDTA. Moreover, pyrene intense excimer fluorescence was successfully visualized in vitro by two photon fluorescence microscopy as pyrene-labeled HumAfFt was actively uptaken into HeLa cells by human transferrin receptor TfR1 recognition, thus representing a unique nano-device building block for two photon fluorescence cell imaging.
Recombinant mammalian ferritins, however, are difficult to disassemble into subunits as they can be dissociated only under extreme conditions, thus rendering the encapsulation of many substrates impractical. Commonly employed cargo encapsulation techniques8 involve the disassembly and re-assembly of ferritins cage by pH jump, reaching drastic pH values (pH 2)9 which cause a partial and incomplete re-assembly.10 On the other hand, the oligomerization mechanism of a unique ferritin from Archaeoglobus fulgidus is easily controlled by altering cations concentration in physiological conditions.11 In this framework, the humanized ferritin from Archaeoglobus fulgidus (HumAfFt)12 represents a uniquely suitable scaffold for incorporating diverse substructures at neutral pH while being recognized and internalized in mammalian cells by human transferrin receptor TfR1 as human ferritin H homopolymer.
Surprisingly, however, despite structural determinants of the unique assembly of Archaeoglobus ferritin were thorough described11 and several studies tried to shed light on the mechanism that drives the monomers association into a mammalian 24-meric ferritin shell13,14 under acidic conditions, the unique assembly–disassembly properties of archaeal ferritins were only investigated by light scattering or size exclusion chromatography while the kinetic behavior of the salt-triggered oligomerization is still unknown. Thus, in the present paper, we engineered the HumAfFt ferritin to site-selectively introduce two overlapping pyrene moieties at the ferritin dimer interface with the aim of exploring archaeal ferritins association/dissociation mechanism by exploiting pyrene sensitive fluorescence emission. Pyrene fluorescence properties were widely used for many biological and bioimaging investigations15–22 as the probe's high extinction coefficient allows studies of proteins in solution at physiologically relevant concentrations and its high stability and long fluorescent lifetime give it resistance to photodamage and photobleaching.23 Pyrene versatility is due to a spatially sensitive fluorescence emission that displays an ensemble of monomer emission peaks and an easily distinguishable red shifted broad peak corresponding to the excited state dimer called excimer.24,25 Excimer formation arises when two pyrene molecules, one in the ground state and the other one in the excited state, are located in close proximity (∼10 Å) and are involved in a non-covalent π–π stacking interaction.26 Any subtle structural change in a pyrene-labeled protein could alter orientation and distance between the two pyrene molecules involved in the excimer, thus strongly affecting stacking interactions and therefore resulting in a clear shift in the fluorescence emission.15,24
Pyrene–HumAfFt bioconjugate, thanks to the peculiar pyrene excimer properties, helped unravelling the kinetic details of the archaeal ferritins oligomerization process, by means of an easily accessible spectroscopic technique and, at the same time, allowed the visualization by two photon fluorescence microscopy of HumAfFt uptake by HeLa cells.
The thermodynamic and kinetic analysis of the assembly process highlighted a complete reversibility and a surprising difference between the association rates induced by mono and divalent cations. In addition, the HumAfFt functionalities were not altered by pyrene-labeling and the bioconjugated ferritin was successfully visualized in vitro by using two-photon excimer-based fluorescence microscopy, highlighting a cellular distribution typical of a clathrin-coated endocytosis pathway,27 in agreement with the intracellular pattern of the unlabeled HumAfFt previously reported, but with the major advantage of visualizing the protein by low energy wavelength irradiation, thus ensuring longer penetration depth while reducing photodamage.28
Fig. 1 Ribbon diagram of the antiparallel homodimer structure of HumAfFt (pdb 5LS9). Two NPM molecules are depicted in magenta sticks bound to C54, establishing a π–π stacking interaction, at the dimer interface. |
In addition, a mutant of Pyrococcus fulgidus ferritin (PfFtP77C) was designed with a cysteine residue on the external surface for NPM labeling and used as pyrene monomer fluorescence standard, whereas a distance of 24 Å between two cysteines did not allow for excimer formation.15 Moreover, as PfFtP77C was uniquely found as a 24-meric assembled cage in solution, the protein was used as a standard independent of cation concentration.32
The hydrodynamic diameters of both pyrene-labeled HumAfFt and AfFt proteins showed similar size to the respective native ferritins and were found to be monodispersed in solution. The hydrodynamic diameters measured by DLS experiments were 5.8 nm for the dissociated state in the absence of MgCl2, in agreement with the predicted theoretical value for a dimer,33 and approximately 14 nm for the associated state in 20 mM MgCl2 (Fig. S2†).
The overall oligomerization process was unchanged by pyrene-labeling as the Mg2+-dependent titrations confirmed the comparable self-assembly properties of AfFt and HumAfFt, with and without pyrene (Fig. S3†).
Remarkably, in the tetraeicosameric state, the overall amount of excimer decreased, as shown in Fig. 3 and S4,† probably due to movements at the inter–dimer interface that cause a destabilization of π-stacking interactions between the two pyrene moieties. Moreover, the excimer amount was successfully restored after EDTA addition, confirming that the chelating ability of this agent promoted protein disassembly by removal of magnesium cations (Fig. 3, Fig. S4†).
To corroborate that the fluorescence excimer broad band variation was actually related to the oligomerization process and was independent from the ionic strength, we measured fluorescence emission at fixed ionic strength using different concentrations of either MgCl2 or NaCl. According to the Debye–Hückel model, the experiment was carried out at two different ionic strength conditions: at low salt concentrations (i.e. 150 mM NaCl or 50 mM MgCl2), where the protein was associated in the 24-meric state only in MgCl2, and at high salt concentrations (i.e. 600 mM NaCl or 200 mM MgCl2), where the protein was known to be associated in both salts.11,12,30,31 As shown in Fig. 4 and S5,† in the first condition, the excimer content without salt and at 150 mM NaCl were similar, in agreement with a dissociated state, whereas at 50 mM MgCl2, therefore at equal ionic strength, the excimer content revealed the presence of an associated state for both proteins. Moreover, the pyrene monomer emission profile of PfFtP77C did not change at various salt concentration, excluding any ionic strength influence on the pyrene fluorescence emission (data not shown).
Fluorescence emission dependence on the protein oligomerization state was thus investigated by monitoring magnesium induced association at equilibrium. A sigmoidal curve was obtained by plotting excimer/monomer (e/m) ratio as a function of MgCl2 concentration, suggesting a strong cooperativity within the association process, with a complete assembly at about 5 mM MgCl2 in both ferritins (Fig. 5).
The strong effect of Mg2+ ions on subunit assembly was then analyzed in terms of possible contributions to specific binding within the three-dimensional crystallographic structure (pdb 5LS9) by using PISA software (CCP4 suite). No significant evidence of Mg2+ presence at the interface between dimers was observed. In fact, as it was previously reported,11,34 it was evident that the hydrophobic network connecting the dimers' interface played a key role in stabilizing the cage structure in high ionic strength buffers to minimize the solvent exposure. In turn, in the X-ray structure, Mg2+ cations were found to bind the ferroxidase center through explicit coordination provided by Asp52, Glu19 and His55, according to HumAfFt numbering, thus strengthening the Sana's assumption that divalent cations occupy and competitively inhibit iron binding under conditions of iron deficiency.34,35 In the light of these observations, it might be hypothesized that coordination of Mg2+ in the ferroxidase center can therefore assist the assembly process by exerting some subtle conformational rearrangement within the dimeric species, thus explaining the different behavior respect to a monovalent cation which is prevented from binding.
Magnesium-triggered assembly was too fast (time scale < 10 ms) to be followed by stopped-flow measurements at 25 °C. However, it was possible to single out a clear decay curve at lower temperature (4 °C). Despite the assembly occurred close to the instrumental time limit, some semi-quantitative estimates on Mg2+-induced association could still be obtained. Fluorescence emission decreased with a double exponential trend and the reaction was complete within 25 ms, as shown in Fig. 6A. Reaction rates increased proportionally with both Mg2+ and protein concentration with a major contribution from the protein concentration, which showed an apparent second order rate constant of about 106 M−1 s−1. In contrast, the EDTA-triggered dissociation process was slower than the assembly and was measured both at 25 and 4 °C. Faster dissociation rates were observed at higher temperature, with completeness reached in 0.1 s at 25 °C and in 0.25 s at 4 °C. Dissociation showed a biphasic profile, dependent on EDTA concentration but independent of protein concentration (Fig. S6†), as expected.
Since the kinetic reaction in the presence of magnesium cations appeared to be too fast, we investigated the slower NaCl induced association process. In comparison with magnesium, higher salt concentrations were required to monitor Na+-triggered association as the oligomerization was complete only at 500 mM NaCl.30 The assembly showed much slower rates and a multiphasic kinetic profile (Fig. 6B) with an initial lag phase (Fig. 6C), typical of a nucleation process commonly found in protein oligomerization,36 that evolved in four exponential phases toward the end of the reaction, which was reached only after 20–30 minutes at 25 °C. These changes in the total fluorescence emission over time, could be due to multiple pyrene rearrangement during the assembly. Additionally, while the association rates were proportionally increasing with NaCl concentration, at fixed NaCl concentration and varying protein concentration the reaction rates were approximately constant. These evidences documented the complexity of the aggregation mechanism and suggest that a different pattern might be involved in the magnesium-triggered association compared to the sodium-triggered one. Previous work on the mechanism of self-assembly of ferritins is limited to only a few set of experimental investigations. The pH-triggered reassembly of apoferritin from horse spleen, has been followed by means of sedimentation velocity and circular dichroism experiments.37 This work suggested that dimers, tetramers (or trimers) and octamers (or hexamers) are in rapid equilibrium on the ultracentrifuge time scale and that the assembly process is complex and dependent on buffer type and the presence of chloride and phosphate. In other work,38 the kinetics of reassociation of horse spleen ferritin were followed by intrinsic protein fluorescence, circular dichroism and chemical crosslinking which essentially confirmed the sequential nature of the assembly process in agreement with Stefanini et al. (1987).37 Finally a more recent investigation, that made use of time-resolved small angle X-ray scattering successfully monitored the pH-induced oligomerization of Escherichia coli ferritin on a time scale from milliseconds to minutes.14 These experiments strongly suggest of significant formation of intermediate oligomers during the assembly reaction, although in the proposed mechanism third-order reactions were included to fit the data.
The present experiments are a first step in unraveling the details of the aggregation process of ferritins by using a simple spectroscopic technique. Protein–protein association rate constants span a quite large range of values from 103 to over 109 M−1 s−1.39 From Fig. 6A the halftime of the reaction is ∼1–2 ms it may be roughly estimated that the second-order rate constant is in excess of 108 M−1 s−1 at 4 °C, and larger at higher temperatures, when using Mg2+ as the triggering ligand. Thus, the structural determinants that confer the large stability of the ferritin tetraeicosamer is likely due to the fast association constants of the ferritin polypeptides.
A careful analysis of the monomer and excimer spectra showed that, independently of the excitation wavelength, their spectral behaviour was remarkably different, as a further confirmation of the excimer formation in the ferritin cage-like structure.
Determination of free sulfhydryl was performed on a UV5600 Spectrophotometer using Ellman's assay according to standard procedure. Briefly, a stock solution of 5,5-dithio-bis-(2-nitrobenzoic acid) (Ellman's reagent) was mixed with the protein sample in a 20-fold molar excess. The solution was incubated for 5 minutes at room temperature and UV absorption was measured at 412 nm, using as blank, a sample containing the same amount of Ellman's reagent in buffer. The sulfhydryl per protein ratio (SPR) was calculated from the ratio between the Ellman's reagent concentration (ε = 14150 M−1 cm−1) and the protein concentration. Every experiment was repeated 3 times and the results were calculated based on the average of the 3 experiments.
Association kinetic experiments were performed at 5 μM protein before mixing (b.m.) in 20 mM HEPES pH 7.4, increasing concentrations of MgCl2 or NaCl and, at constant salt concentration (either 20 mM MgCl2 or 2 M NaCl b.m.) increasing protein concentrations (5 to 100 μM ferritin b.m.). Dissociation kinetic experiments were performed at 5 μM protein b.m. in 20 mM HEPES pH 7.4 and MgCl2 increasing EDTA/Mg2+ molar ratios or, at a fixed EDTA concentration (20 mM) increasing protein concentrations (5 to 100 μM ferritin in 20 mM MgCl2 b.m.).
Our results clearly demonstrate the strong correlation between pyrene excimer fluorescence and ferritin oligomerization state, thus highlighting the importance of this pyrene-based method as a powerful tool through which easily gain insights into the thermodynamic and kinetics details of protein oligomerization mechanism. Indeed, while both mono and divalent cations were capable of triggering ferritin association, divalent cations showed very fast kinetics, within a millisecond time scale, and were able to completely form the 24-meric cage at low MgCl2 concentrations, thus potentially representing a convenient alternative to NaCl for the synthesis of drug-delivery nano devices. The oligomerization process was also confirmed to be remarkably cooperative and fully reversible by EDTA treatment. Furthermore, pyrene–HumAfFt was highly internalized by HeLa cells and pyrene excimer displayed an intense fluorescence emission by two photon fluorescence confocal microscopy, which was comparable to common fluorophores emission such as TRITC. The pyrene-based bioconjugate system confirmed to be an excellent building block for two photon fluorescent nano-particle design, which could be further optimized for diagnostic and biomedical application based on the ability of HumAfFt to target the overexpressed TfR1 receptor in human cancer cells.
NPM | N-(1-Pyrenyl)maleimide |
TPFM | Two photon fluorescence microscopy |
TCEP | Tris(2-carboxyethyl)phosphine |
EDTA | Ethylenediaminetetraacetic acid |
Footnote |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available: Experimental procedures and characterizations (PDF). See DOI: 10.1039/c8ra00210j |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2018 |