Zhe Suia,
Tong Lia,
Ran Anab,
Wei Wua,
Makoto Komiyama*ac and
Xingguo Liang*ab
aCollege of Food Science and Engineering, Ocean University of China, Qingdao 266003, China. E-mail: liangxg@ouc.edu.cn
bLaboratory for Marine Drugs and Bioproducts of Qingdao National Laboratory for Marine Science and Technology, Qingdao 266235, China
cNational Institute for Materials Science (NIMS), Namiki, Tsukuba 305-0044, Japan. E-mail: makotokomiyama@yahoo.com
First published on 25th April 2018
In order to detect a predetermined gene in a field test, a facile, visual, and ultrasensitive approach without the need of special and expensive machines is required. In this study, a gene in the Ebola virus was targeted as an example for diagnosis. The key strategy is to incorporate molecular blockers (azobenzene-bearing moieties or thymine dimers) in tandem in one of the PCR primers and stop the polymerase extension there to form a single-stranded overhang. The PCR product was added to the dispersion of gold nanoparticles which were labelled with a probe oligonucleotide. When the Ebola virus-specific gene existed in the specimen, the oligonucleotide on the gold particles formed a double-helix with the single-stranded overhang, and thus the dispersion remained red in color. In the absence of the gene, however, the dispersion rapidly turned to blue because of nanoparticle aggregation. The difference was explicit even when the initial specimen involved only 1 copy of the gene. Accordingly, “whether the patient is infected by the virus or not” can be easily and visually judged by the naked eye.
Gold nanoparticles (AuNps) have been widely used for biosensors due to the unique optical properties which make them easily observable by naked eyes or detectable by costless equipment like UV-vis spectrometer.15 As compared with AuNps coated with proteins (e.g. streptavidin), the DNA-labelled AuNps are much more efficient for POC, because large amount of DNA strands could be attached onto the surface of AuNps and enable sequence specific detection with high sensitivity to nM. In addition, the DNA-labelled AuNPs are more easily prepared than protein-coated ones.15–18 However, AuNps are difficult to be used for direct detection of normal PCR products because they are dsDNA without a single-stranded overhang. Although single-stranded DNA products have been detected by using DNA-labelled AuNps after rolling circle amplification (RCA), hybridization chain reaction (HCR), and strand displacement amplification (SDA), these amplification approaches are not comparable with PCR.19–23
Here we propose a more straightforward methodology in which target gene is visually detected in extremely high sensitivity without using complicated machines. The point is to attach single stranded overhangs onto the end of PCR products by using modified primers. In this way we could detect PCR products directly with DNA-labelled AuNps, thus our new approach combines the advantages of both PCR technique and colloid Au science.
As presented in Scheme 1, the procedure is composed of two steps. In the first step (a), DNA specimen, obtained from potential patients by conventional methods, is amplified by “indenting PCR” to the products which bear a single-stranded overhang. The key feature of this newly developed PCR is to incorporate to pathogen-specific primers either azobenzene-bearing moieties or thymine dimers which function as “molecular blockers” of polymerase extension (the blue circles in Scheme 1a). During the amplification, the polymerase stalls at the position of these blockers to form required overhang structure. In order to suppress the run-through extension completely and confirm the reproducibility of diagnosis, multiple blockers are introduced in tandem to the primer (vide infra). Accordingly, the products bearing a single-stranded overhang at the end are obtained, only when a gene from the pathogen exists in the primary specimen. Our approach is better than using asymmetric PCR which gives single-stranded DNA products.9 In some cases it is hard to carry out asymmetric PCR because the concentration of one primer is usually much lower. In addition, the long ssDNA products may cause aggregation of AuNPs.23 For indenting PCR, the products are dsDNA with high rigidity, which is much more efficient for avoiding AuNP aggregation.
In the second step (b), the PCR products are added to the dispersion of gold nanoparticles (AuNps) labelled with a single-stranded oligonucleotide as probe. If PCR products are produced in the step (a), their single-stranded overhangs are complementary with the probe on the AuNps, and thus double-stranded helixes are formed between them. Mg2+ was then added into the mixed solution of AuNps and PCR products. It neutralized negative charge of labelled DNA on Au nanoparticles.17,20,24,25 If the PCR products with single overhangs hybridized to the surface of AuNps, it provides additional negative charges and steric hindrance to protect AuNps from aggregation. Otherwise, if there exist no PCR products, the AuNps aggregated rapidly since the electrostatic stabilization effect is lost. In order to enhance the difference between these two situations, appropriate concentration of Mg2+ is added to the system. Thus, the presence of the designated gene in the original specimen or its absence can be differentiated simply by observing the color change of the solution. The present strategy employs the advantages of both PCR and Au colloidal science, and thus satisfactorily fulfils all the factors required for Point-of-Care detection (easiness, visibility, low cost, promptness, and no need of expensive machines).3
ODNs | Sequence (5′ → 3′) | Length/nt |
---|---|---|
a The bold characters refer to the portion which is not covered by the primer and potentially subjected to elongation by the polymerase. | ||
Pr19 | CAATTTGGACGACGACGAT | 19 |
Pr20 | CAATTTGGACGACGACGATG | 20 |
Pr21 | CAATTTGGACGACGACGATGT | 21 |
XF39 | CCATGTCTAATGCTGATXGXACAT-CGTCGTCGTCCAAATTG | 39 |
T10F50 | CCATGTCTAATGCTGATGAT(10)ACAT-CGTCGTCGTCCAAATTG | 50 |
NF39 | CCATGTCTAATGCTGATGACAT-CGTCGTCGTCCAAATTG | 39 |
R24 | GTTGACCCGTATGATGATGAGAGT | 24 |
F21 | ACATCGTCGTCGTCCAAATTG | 21 |
In addition to remarkable blocking activity of tandem X residues for “indenting PCR”, we have found that thymine–thymine dimers (Fig. S1b†), placed in tandem in the primer, also satisfactorily work as “molecular blockers” of the extension of Taq DNA polymerase. Although these dimers (both the cyclobutane dimers and (6–4) adducts) were previously reported to suppress primer extension,29–31 complete blocking of polymerase extension has been for the first time envisioned here. From the viewpoints of practical applications, these thymine dimer-based molecular blockers are advantageous in that they can be easily prepared simply by photo-irradiating oligonucleotides obtained by DNA synthesizers. In order to construct thymine dimers in tandem, consecutive thymine sequences were incorporated to the precursors of primers, and these oligonucleotides were photo-irradiated under air by using a simple handheld UV lamp with the intensity of 0.4 W m−2 at 254 nm (measured by a UV-c light meter). This light was much weaker than the ones (>10 W m−2) employed previously.
After careful optimization of conditions (Fig. S2 and S3†), the primer for the present indenting PCR was prepared by irradiating T10F50 (involving 10 consecutive thymine residues) for 28 h. Complete blocking of polymerase extension by this primer was confirmed by primer extension experiments (Fig. S3†). It is noteworthy that the blocking effect was minimal when T2F42 and T4F44 (involving 2 and 4 consecutive thymines) were irradiated for 28 h. The blocking effect gradually increased with the increase of the length of consecutive thymine sequence, and was notable for T6F46 and T8F48. Finally, almost complete inhibition of the polymerase extension was accomplished by T10F50 which was photo-irradiated for 28 h. These results substantiate that two or more thymine dimers in the primer are required to block the polymerase extension effectively.
In indenting PCR using the combination of the irradiated T10F50 and R24 as the primers, several amplification products were produced (lane 2 in Fig. 3). All of them migrated more slowly than the 103 bp double-stranded DNA in lane 1. In the T10F50-derived primer, thymine dimers are formed by photoirradiation at various positions in the T10 sequence, and block the polymerase extension there. Thus, the lengths of both double-helix portions and overhanging tails of the PCR products should be different from each other, providing multiple bands of different gel-mobility. Consistently, when the products in lane 2 were treated with nuclease S1, all of them were converted to new bands which show similar mobility as the 103 bp duplex (compare lane 4 with lane 1). The smearing character of the bands for these enzymatic digests is probably reflecting the different lengths of the double-helix portions of the indenting PCR products. It is noteworthy that the band for the run-through product in lane 3 was never perceived in this nuclease S1 digest. Apparently, tandem thymine dimers in one of the primers can almost completely block the polymerase extension with Taq polymerase, and is successfully applicable to indenting PCR.
Fig. 3 Indenting PCR using the primer bearing tandem thymine dimers. The gene in Ebola virus, used in Fig. 2, was also the template. In lane 2, T10F50 was first irradiated by a handheld UV lamp for 28 h, and used as the primer, together with R24 primer. In lane 4, the product in lane 2 was digested by nuclease S1. Lane 1, the amplification product (103 bp) obtained by using unmodified primers (F21 and R24); lane 3, the product using primer precursor T10F50 (without irradiation) and R24 as the primers. |
Fig. 4 Visual and spectral detection of the product of indenting PCR using XF39 involving two X groups and R24 as the primers (red line). The product of this indenting PCR (lane 2 of Fig. 2) was treated with AuNps dispersion. For the purpose of comparison, the results with the product of conventional PCR using unmodified primers (bearing no single-stranded overhang) are shown by blue line. The inserts are the corresponding pictures. Almost the same results were obtained for indenting PCR using thymine dimers as molecular blockers (see Fig. S5†). |
The color of the solution remained red (the picture inserted in top-left). As shown by the UV-vis spectra (red line), the absorption maximum was located at around 535 nm. The ratio of absorbance at the plasmon peak (525 nm) to that at 700 nm (A525/A700) was 4.10.9 On the other hand, when the PCR product using non-modified primers which had no single-stranded overhang was mixed with AuNps, the red solution rapidly turned to blue upon the addition of MgCl2 (the right-top picture). The absorbance maximum was at 610 nm (blue line), and the A525/A700 ratio was 1.12. This color change of the solution occurred within minutes. Almost the same results were obtained when thymine dimers were used as molecular blockers of polymerase extension (Fig. S5†). The principle of the gene detection in Scheme 1 has been confirmed. It is well known that highly concentrated salts screen the electrostatic repulsion between AuNps and lead to their aggregation. Without any protecting factors, the AuNps dispersions thus immediately turn from red to blue.9,20,24 When the product of indenting PCR is added to the solution, however, its complementary overhangs form duplexes with the probes on the AuNps, and stabilize the dispersion through increased negative charges and steric repulsion. Furthermore, the PCR products cover the particles by thick polymeric barriers, inhibiting their mutual access.24 Notably, the selectivity of this assay detection is not only limited to the primers, DNA-labelled AuNps ensures specific detection due to the specificity of base pairing.32 We confirmed that the detection of PCR products is positive only when the labelled probe is fully complementary to the overhangs attached on the PCR products, which may be used for multiplex PCR by using several kinds of AuNPs (Fig. S6†). As comparing to other assays combining PCR technique and colloid Au technique, we were the first to detect PCR products directly and specifically with labelled AuNPs.9,33 Besides, the effect of pH was also checked, and found that our method works well at a pH range of 5–9 (Fig. S7†).
Fig. 5 Sensitivity of the present visual detection of the gene from Ebola virus. The copy number of Ebola virus gene in the starting specimens is shown in the top. In (a), two azobenzene-bearing groups were introduced to one of the primer (XF39 in Table 1), which was combined with R24. In (b), T10F50 was irradiated for 28 h and used as the primer together with R24. In both cases, the specimen containing the designated copy number of Ebola gene was amplified by nested PCR (38 cycles) where the conventional PCR and the “indenting PCR” were simultaneously carried out in the specimen. The final products were added to AuNps dispersions without purification. The A525/A700 ratios as the measure of suppression of AuNps aggregation are presented above each sample tube. |
According to the strategy of nested PCR, the upstream primer (ElongF23) of the conventional PCR was bound to 60 nt upstream from the part amplified by the indenting PCR. The upstream primers ElongF23, XF39 and downstream R24 (or the combination of T10F50, irradiated for 28 h, with ElongF23 and R24) were simultaneously added to one vessel, and PCR (38 cycles) was carried out. Then, a portion of the final product of the PCR amplification was added (without purification) to the AuNps dispersion, and the color change was checked by our naked eyes. In a wide range of the number of Ebola virus gene (from 5 × 101 to 5 × 106), the presence of this gene was clearly detected in terms of the appearance of red color (Fig. 5a and b). In addition to this facile diagnosis by our naked eyes, further reconfirmation of the diagnostic result was possible, if necessary, with the use of UV-Vis spectroscopy. For the specimens containing the gene, the A525/A700 ratios were 2.0–4.0 depending on the copy number, and always much larger than the values for the non-gene samples (about 1.0), as shown in Fig. 5. For example, the two samples starting from 5 copies (the 2nd vessels from the left) showed the A525/A700 ratios around 1.4.
On the basis of these results, the diagnostic procedures were further optimized to allow the detection of minimum amount of designated gene. In Fig. 6, the initial specimen contained only 1 copy of Ebola gene (see Fig. S8† for details). It was amplified by the nested PCR (45 cycles) involving the conventional PCR and the indenting PCR. Except for the increased number of PCR cycles, the primers and the other conditions were exactly the same as descried for Fig. 5. In both off the molecular blockers, the difference in color from the non-virus sample was still more clear-cut, and a concrete conclusion could be easily obtained on the crucially important question: “whether this patient is infected by Ebola virus or not”. The sensitivity is similar to the previous reports, e.g. 1.9 × 104 PFU mL−1 of Ebola virus by one step qRT-PCR, 10 copies per cDNA reaction by nested RT-PCR.2,34 We also confirmed the applicability and selectivity of this method in detection of pathogenic bacteria (Fig. S9†). High sensitivity was obtained and even 1 CFU (a multicopy gene target was selected) could be detected without non-specific signals.
Fig. 6 Visual detection of 1 copy of Ebola virus gene by the present method. The primers used for indenting PCR are (a) XF39 involving two X residues and (b) T10F50, which was irradiated for 28 h and contained thymine dimers. The specimen was amplified by nested PCR (45 cycles) involving both the conventional PCR and the indenting PCR, and visualized by Au nanoparticles (see text for more details). For both of the molecular blockers ((a) and (b)), the diagnostic results starting from the sample containing about 1 copy of Ebola gene are shown in the right (see Fig. S8† for experimental details). The results of control experiment starting from non-gene specimen are in the left. Note that these two diagnostic results can be unanimously differentiated with the use of our naked eyes, although reconfirmation of the result using A525/A700 ratio is also possible as described above. |
Footnote |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available: Supporting information consists of: a figure of the structures of the molecular blockers, a figure on the influence of the irradiation time on the formation of thymine dimmers, a figure on the influence of the length of continuous thymines in primer precursors on the formation of thymine dimers, a table containing the sequence information of the oligonucleotides used for primer extension experiments to study the blocking effect of thymine dimers, an image showing the effect of the concentration of Mg2+ on AuNps dispersion-induced visual detection of the product of indenting PCR, a figure showing the visual and spectral detection of the products of indenting PCR when thymine dimers were used as molecular blockers and the figure on of the analysis of PCR products amplified from specimen containing low copies of target gene. See DOI: 10.1039/c8ra01471j |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2018 |