Hicham Abou Oualidab,
Othmane Amadineb,
Younes Essamlalib,
Karim Dânounb and
Mohamed Zahouily*ab
aLaboratoire de Matériaux, Catalyse & Valorisation des Ressources Naturelles, URAC 24, Faculté des Sciences et Techniques, Université Hassan II, Casablanca B.P. 146, 20650, Morocco. E-mail: m.zahouily@mascir.com
bMAScIR Foundation, VARENA Center, Rabat Design, Rue Mohamed El Jazouli, Madinat Al Irfane, 10100 Rabat, Morocco
First published on 6th June 2018
In the present study, we investigate a simple and effective synthetic protocol to produce zinc oxide foams by a facile solution-based method using alginate gelation. The influences of the zinc concentration and the drying process on the structural, textural and morphological properties of the synthesized ZnO nanomaterial were studied and discussed. The components of these nanomaterials were characterized by several techniques to demonstrate the effectiveness of the adopted synthetic route in controlling the growth of the ZnO nanoparticles. XRD analysis revealed that the as-prepared ZnO nanomaterial crystallizes in the hexagonal wurtzite structure. The room temperature photoluminescence (PL) spectra of ZnO show ultra-violet (UV) and visible emissions. SEM analysis revealed the porous texture of the prepared zinc oxide. TEM analysis confirmed the nano dimensions of the synthesized zinc oxide nanoparticles. A comparative study of conventional air drying versus supercritical drying was conducted to determine the influence of each mode of drying on the structural, textural and morphological as well as optical properties of the synthesized ZnO nanoparticles.
Additionally, the structure and porosity of the synthesized materials, and therefore all of their physicochemical properties, depend directly on their method of synthesis and especially their drying process.56 This step consists of extracting the solvent contained in the pores of the hydrogel by trying to best preserve the structure and integrity of the solid network formed during the material growth step. Different drying methods are possible.57 The main drying methods are the conventional evaporation process of the interstitial solvent, which gives rise to xerogels, or supercritical drying which leads to aerogels. The first method of drying is the most used, but it suffers from various disadvantages. It causes densifying and cracking of the dry gel, due to the presence of a liquid–gas interface, which produces the appearance of a high surface tension (capillarity) effect on the solid network. To overcome the constraints of the capillary pressure during conventional drying, Kistler developed the second mode (supercritical drying) during the 1930s.58 The aim is to eliminate the impact of the surface tension while operating at supercritical conditions of the interstitial solvent. Ideally, CO2 is used a lot because it has several advantages: (i) its critical temperature and pressure which are more moderate, (ii) its high chemical inertness, (iii) its non-flammability, (iv) its non-toxicity, and (v) its low cost. Furthermore, it is miscible with many common organic solvents,59 which facilitates an advantage of the drying process, after replacing the synthesis solvent with another miscible with CO2 such as alcohols to obtain alcogels.60,61
In the context of a series of research studies that we are leading dealing with porous nanomaterials, we were able to synthesize Ag/ZnO xerogels by an air drying process in a previous publication.62 The as-obtained xerogels exhibit a shrunken random micro-structure with limited porosity and a low surface area. Aiming to compare the advantages of aerogel materials, in our present research study, we investigate the effect of a supercritical CO2 drying process on the physical–chemical properties of ZnO materials. The supercritical drying process was chosen in order to replace the liquid in the prepared material with CO2 gas which isolates the solid component from the material without destroying the material’s delicate nanostructured pore network. To the best of our knowledge, the preparation of ZnO foam-structures via gelation of alginate by Zn2+ using supercritical CO2 drying technology has never been published before. It is in this context that this current study is being taken, to meet the objective of preparing ZnO foams by a novel, simple, low-cost and ecofriendly approach. Thus, we described the eco-design of Alg/Zn via alginate gelation by Zn2+ cations followed by supercritical CO2 drying and heat treatment of the ensuing aerogels which leads to ZnO foams. A comparative study of conventional drying versus supercritical drying was conducted to determine the influence of each mode of drying on the passage of the hybrid material (xerogels or aerogels) to the hard material (zinc oxide).
Fig. 1 Schematic representation of the chemical route used for the synthesis of ZnO aerogel and xerogel nanomaterials. |
The first step consists of the preparation of the hydrogel beads by cross-linking reactions between the alginate solution and the Zn2+ aqueous solution. The shape and size of the hydrogel microspheres can be controlled by the method of bringing the two solutions into contact. Gelling of the alginate occurs when Zn2+ cations were cross-linked in the inter-chain binding between the biopolymer chains, affording a three-dimensional open network. This method leads to the spontaneous diffusion of a Zn2+ ion inside the alginate chains and formation of a three-dimensional network of well-shaped white microspheres, as shown in Fig. 1. In a typical experiment, 1 g of SA was dissolved in 100 mL of deionized water (18 MΩ) at room temperature, forming a viscous solution. A separate solution was prepared by dissolving an amount of Zn(NO3)2·6H2O in 100 mL of deionized water to obtain solutions with different final concentrations: 0.1, 0.2, and 0.3 M. Then, the SA gel (1%: w/w) was added dropwise at room temperature to the zinc(II) precursor solution via a syringe with a 0.8 mm diameter needle and the mixture was constantly stirred for 2 hours. The obtained hydrogel beads (Alg/Zn) were processed via two different drying routes. The first one was a conventional air-drying method performed at room temperature to obtain xerogel beads (denoted Alg/Zn-X1, Alg/Zn-X2 and Alg/Zn-X3). The second method deployed was drying with supercritical CO2 to generate aerogel beads (denoted Alg/Zn-A1, Alg/Zn-A2 and Alg/Zn-A3). For this, hydrogel beads were first transformed into alcogels by putting the hydrogels in a succession of different ratios of water/absolute ethanol: 100/0, 95/5, 90/10, 80/20, 70/30, 60/40, 50/50, 40/60, 30/70, 20/80, 10/90 and 0/100. The alcogels were then placed in a supercritical reactor where liquid CO2 was injected under pressure and the mixture was heated to the critical temperature of CO2 (31.1 °C at 7.4 MPa). Both forms of the prepared materials (aerogels or xerogels) were calcined at a temperature estimated from the analysis of these materials using TGA. The calcined xerogel beads were coded ZnO-X1, ZnO-X2, and ZnO-X3, and the calcined aerogel beads were coded ZnO-A1, ZnO-A2 and ZnO-A3.
Fig. 2 Digital images of (a) Alg/Zn hydrogels, (b) Alg/Zn xerogels and (c) Alg/Zn aerogels (grid square side is 1 mm). |
Thereafter, a heat treatment of Alg/Zn xerogel and aerogel bead materials was performed to release the inorganic matrix and to obtain the zinc oxides ZnO-X1, ZnO-X2, ZnO-X3, ZnO-A1, ZnO-A2 and ZnO-A3. After that, the minimum calcination temperature necessary to remove organic residues was determined by thermo-gravimetric analysis; the details are described in the ESI (Fig. A1).† In the following section, we restrict ourselves to the results of the thermal treatment of Alg/Zn-X1 and Alg/Zn-A1 (Fig. 3). The thermal degradation of the Alg/Zn-X1 sample showed three weight losses. The first weight loss (11.66%) at 156 °C can be attributed to the evaporation of surface bonded water, the second weight loss of 63.77% observed at 218 °C can be assigned to the thermal degradation of alginate via decarboxylation,61 and the third weight loss (75.24%) around 385 °C can be attributed to full degradation of the alginate backbone. In the case of the Alg/Zn-X1 sample, we showed the first weight loss at 93 °C due to the removal of the alcohol residues remaining after CO2 supercritical drying, while the second weight loss (54.09 wt%) and third weight loss (80.49 wt%) which occurred at 254 and 383 °C respectively can be attributed to the thermal degradation of the alginate.62 Thus, the Alg/Zn aerogel and xerogel were calcined at 500 °C for 4 h under air wherein the Alg/Zn xerogel gave definite nanostructured zinc but this was not foamy in nature.
All samples prepared in this study have been characterized by X-ray diffraction. Firstly, we should note from this analysis that the Alg/Zn xerogel and aerogel beads are amorphous (Fig. A2†), thus no typical diffraction peaks were detected. Fig. 4 shows the X-ray diffraction patterns of ZnO-X1, ZnO-X2, ZnO-X3, ZnO-A1, ZnO-A2 and ZnO-A3. The ensuing zinc oxides exhibit hexagonal phases with wurtzite faces for all of the samples, according to the international database (PCDJ 001 036 054), and the main crystallographic planes are (100), (002), (101), (102), (110), (103), (200), (112) and (201). As can be seen in Fig. 4, the presence of intense and narrow shaped peaks indicates the formation of highly crystalline ZnO nanoparticles. The crystallite sizes calculated using the Debye–Scherrer formula are depicted in Table 1. These results revealed that the concentration of the Zn precursor significantly affected the crystallite size of the ZnO phase. In the cases of ZnO-X1, ZnO-X2 and ZnO-X3, the crystallite size was increased from 19.7 to 22 nm. The dependence of the crystallite size on the Zn2+ concentration could be due to the Ostwald ripening phenomenon. At higher concentrations, a high-density network of small nanoparticles seems to be formed when compared to lower concentrations, in which the formed small nanoparticles were relatively far from each other. Furthermore, the crystallite size of ZnO samples was also affected by the method of drying. As can be seen in Table 1, supercritical drying of ZnO samples was observed to give the smallest crystallite size compared to the case of using conventional drying. These results can be explained by the elimination of capillary force among particles during supercritical drying, which can inhibit particle agglomeration.63
Fig. 4 X-ray diffraction patterns of (a) ZnO-X1, ZnO-X2, and ZnO-X3 and (b) ZnO-A1, ZnO-A2 and ZnO-A3. |
Samples | ZnO-X1 | ZnO-X2 | ZnO-X3 | ZnO-A1 | ZnO-A2 | ZnO-A3 |
Lattice parameter (nm) | 3.2422 | 3.2394 | 3.2392 | 3.2391 | 3.2444 | 3.2440 |
5.1962 | 5.1891 | 5.1899 | 5.1937 | 5.2022 | 5.2000 | |
Cell volume (Å3) | 47.300 | 47.150 | 47.156 | 47.190 | 47.420 | 47.390 |
Crystallite size (nm) | 19.7 | 22.8 | 22 | 17.8 | 20.2 | 21.4 |
In the ionotropic gelling of alginate, zinc was chelated by two carboxylic groups of two polymer chains via electrostatic bridges which led to the formation of a stiffened gel. To understand the influence of this complexation on the vibrational bands of alginate, both alginate gel and cross-linked Alg/Zn xerogel and aerogel beads prepared using three different concentrations of the zinc source were analyzed using FT-IR spectroscopy. Fig. 5 shows the FTIR spectra of the alginate gel, and the Alg/Zn xerogel and aerogel beads with different concentrations. According to these figures, all analyzed samples exhibited the same vibrational modes and the same characteristic bands (Table 2). On the other hand, no characteristic vibrational bands ascribed to the crystalline phase of zinc oxide were observed in the FTIR spectra of both Alg/Zn xerogel and aerogel beads, suggesting that these samples are hybrid materials formed by amorphous zinc oxide. These findings are in agreement with those obtained in our previous study.62
Sample | (O–H) | (COO−)asym | (COO−)sym | (C–O) |
---|---|---|---|---|
Sodium alginate | 3244 | 1596 | 1404 | 1023 |
Alg/Zn-X1 | 3278 | 1590 | 1415 | 1026 |
Alg/Zn-A1 | 3269 | 1594 | 1422 | 1030 |
The N2 adsorption–desorption technique has been applied to determine the textural properties of all of the prepared samples. First of all, it should be noted that Alg/Zn xerogel beads are considered as non-porous materials since the corresponding N2 adsorption–desorption isotherms were difficult to collect.64,65 In this case, the most appropriate technique to evaluate the textural properties of the Alg/Zn-X samples is intrusion mercury porosimetry. Firstly, the N2 adsorption–desorption isotherms of the three Alg/Zn aerogel beads prepared using three different concentrations of zinc solution are reported in Fig. 6a. As can be seen, all of the recorded isotherms are intermediate between type II and type IV with a distinct H2-type hysteresis loop according to the IUPAC classification,65 indicating the presence of a significant mesoporosity with an interconnected network and a high outer surface area. Similarly, the isotherms of the solid obtained by calcination of both xerogel and aerogel beads at 500 °C are also intermediate between type II and type IV.
Fig. 6 (a) N2 adsorption–desorption isotherms and (b) pore size distributions of Alg/Zn-A1, Alg/Zn-A2 and Alg/Zn-A3. |
The surface areas of all of the samples were determined by nitrogen adsorption (BET method). Based on the results obtained, the surface areas of the three materials Alg/Zn-A1, Alg/Zn-A2 and Alg/Zn-A3 were 143, 137 and 131 m2 g−1 respectively, which indicates that the surface area of the aerogel microspheres is slightly affected by the concentration of the zinc precursor and also the method of drying. Furthermore, the pore size distribution of Alg/Zn-A1, Alg/Zn-A2 and Alg/Zn-A3 presents narrower mesopore distributions centered around 6.938, 7.052 and 7.171 nm, respectively (Fig. 6b), indicating that this sample contains ordered mesopores as mentioned above. Such a result was expected since supercritical drying is expected to enable drying without leading to the collapse of the structure, affording an aerogel with a high surface area.
However, it can be observed that the calcined aerogels present a high surface area compared to the xerogels due to less pore shrinkage. The surface areas of ZnO-X1, ZnO-X2, and ZnO-X3 are 9.45, 13.04, and 11.94 m2 g−1, respectively, while the surface areas of ZnO-A1, ZnO-A2, and ZnO-A3 are 22.94, 16.62, and 14.21 m2 g−1, respectively. These results indicate that the surface area values depend on the concentration of the precursor used and also on the drying process adopted for the microsphere preparation. In comparison with our previous report,62 herein we report that the concentration of zinc used for the gel bead preparation significantly affected the textural properties of the produced zinc oxide since the surface area of the prepared zinc oxide increases when increasing the concentration of the zinc precursor. Also, it was demonstrated that the surface area of the zinc oxide nanomaterial not only depends on the zinc concentration but also on the adopted drying process since the surface area of the produced ZnO nanomaterial was slightly improved. Thus, the present study introduces a moderate approach for the synthesis of zinc oxide with improved textural properties.
The influence of the drying mode on the morphological properties of the as-prepared materials was investigated by SEM. The SEM images in Fig. 7a–c present the morphologies of Alg/Zn-X1, Alg/Zn-X2 and Alg/Zn-X3. Generally, a porous surface with roughened rib structures was observed for all xerogel samples. Furthermore, observation at high magnification revealed that when the zinc concentration increases, more visible folding was observed, and these folds become thicker at higher concentrations of zinc solution. In the case of Alg/Zn-A1, Alg/Zn-A2 and Alg/Zn-A3 (Fig. 7d–f), it is clearly observed that the drying mode had an obvious influence on the morphology of the prepared beads. Supercritical drying plays a very important role in the conservation of the bead morphology. As shown in Fig. 7d–f, the supercritically-dried Alg/Zn beads retain the spherical shape of the hydrogel but the size of the aerogel spheres is nearly half of the size of the parent hydrogel spheres. This drying process preserves the spherical-shaped morphology of the alcogel and avoids the pore collapse phenomenon via the reduction of the capillary tension between polysaccharide chains. It should be noted that the external diameter of the alcogel beads was reduced from 3 to 1.4 mm after supercritical drying. On the other hand, the scanning electron micrographs of ZnO-A1, ZnO-A2 and ZnO-A3 samples are shown in Fig. 7d′–f′. It is obvious that ZnO nanoparticles obtained from supercritically-dried aerogels exhibited a highly porous structure consisting of a hollow tubular network. Indeed, the supercritical drying technique was effective in preserving the network structure and preventing the shrinkage or collapse of mesopores, resulting in the formation of a well-defined porous structure. However, as can be seen in Fig. 7a′–c′, the ZnO-X1, ZnO-X2 and ZnO-X3 samples are porous yet contain a partially closed-cell structure. Furthermore, the observation of cross-sections of the microspheres indicates that the core of the bead is totally occupied by a radial pattern of channels, lined by a macroporous alginate matrix. Besides, the examination of SEM images reveals that the ZnO samples tend to become more porous when the concentration of the Zn2+ was increased from 0.1 to 0.3 M. Additionally, the mesopores of the calcined aerogels became more accentuated and strongly interconnected when compared with the calcined xerogels.
Fig. 7 SEM images of: (a) Alg/Zn-X1, (b) Alg/Zn-X2, (c) Alg/Zn-X3, (a′) ZnO-X1, (b′) ZnO-X2, (c′) ZnO-X3, (d) Alg/Zn-A1, (e) Alg/Zn-A2, (f) Alg/Zn-A3, (d′) ZnO-A1, (e′) ZnO-A2 and (f′) ZnO-A3. |
The obtained ZnO nanocrystals were further characterized by TEM. Fig. 8 shows the TEM images of the ZnO nanocrystals obtained by thermal decomposition of both Alg/Zn xerogels and aerogels. As can be seen in Fig. 8, at low concentrations of zinc solution, a quasi-spherical shape was obtained, whereas at relatively higher concentrations, regular spherical-shaped nanoparticles were observed, supporting the idea of the Ostwald ripening phenomenon. Indeed, the nanoparticle size is bigger than the crystallite size, suggesting that particles can be formed by one to several crystallites. Furthermore, the nanoparticle size distribution revealed that the nanoparticle size ranges between 13.6 and 31.37 nm for ZnO-X1 and ZnO-X3 respectively, and between 30.36 and 44.2 nm for ZnO-A1 and ZnO-A3 respectively. It is clearly observed that the mean particle size seems to be influenced by the kind of drying process. Conventional drying results in the formation of smaller particles with a more uniform distribution than supercritical drying. This can be due to the different binding capacities arising from zinc alginate and zinc nitrate. Moreover, this difference in particle size could also be due to a large difference in growth times between the conventionally- and supercritically-dried gel beads.
Fig. 8 TEM images of ZnO nanoparticles obtained from fine grinding of ZnO foams: (a) ZnO-X1, (b) ZnO-X2, (c) ZnO-X3, (d) ZnO-A1, (e) ZnO-A2 and (f) ZnO-A3. |
In contrast to our previous study62 where 20 nm quasi-spherical ZnO nanoparticles were obtained, the spherical particles in Fig. 8 are much larger, probably due to the chosen zinc concentration and the adopted drying method. Indeed, it can be seen that there is a significant increase in the particle size with increasing zinc concentration for both conventionally- and supercritically-dried samples calcined at the same temperature.
The UV-Visible absorption spectra of the as-synthesized ZnO-X1 and ZnO-A1 are shown in Fig. 9a. As can be seen, all of the analyzed samples exhibited two excitonic absorption bands in the range of 250–450 nm. The ZnO-A1 nanomaterial showed two strong adsorption bands at around 310 and 365 nm while the ZnO-A1 sample exhibited typical adsorption bands at approximately 307 and 381 nm. It should be noted that the same pattern was observed for all of the prepared ZnO samples. For the ZnO-A1 nanomaterial, the absorption band located at 365 nm was blue shifted by about 16 nm compared to that for the ZnO-X1 sample, which appears at 381 nm. Such displacement was probably due to the pronounced quantum confinement effect in the ZnO nanocrystallites.66 The band gaps (Eg) of ZnO-X1 and ZnO-A1 are estimated using a Tauc plot, extrapolating the linear portion of the plot of (αhν)2 vs. photon energy (hν) (Fig. 9b). The typical linear fittings of ZnO-X1 and ZnO-A1 are shown in Fig. 9b. The Eg values of ZnO-X1 and ZnO-A1 were found to be 3.57 and 3.13 eV, respectively. Furthermore, RTPL emission analysis of both ZnO-X1 and ZnO-A1 was performed. As shown in Fig. 9c, two bands at 401 (blue emission) and 600 nm (red emission), due to zinc vacancy related defects,67,68 are observed for both materials. In addition, broad bands in the blue-green region are observed at 494 and 446 nm for ZnO-X1 and ZnO-A1, respectively, and these can be associated with the oxygen vacancy related defects.69
Fig. 9 (a) UV-Vis absorption spectra, (b) Tauc plot and (c) RTPL emission analysis of ZnO-X1 and ZnO-A1 nanomaterials. |
Footnote |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available. See DOI: 10.1039/c8ra02129e |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2018 |