Zhonglin Luo*abc,
Yan Lia,
Cong Duana and
Biaobing Wang*ab
aSchool of Material Science and Engineering, National Experimental Demonstration Center for Materials Science and Engineering, Changzhou University, Changzhou, 213164, P. R. China. E-mail: zhonglinluo@cczu.edu.cn; biaobing@cczu.edu.cn
bJiangsu Collaborative Innovation Center of Photovolatic Science and Engineering, Changzhou, Jiangsu 213164, P. R. China
cState Key Laboratory of Molecular Engineering of Polymers, Fudan University, Shanghai, 200433, P. R. China
First published on 1st May 2018
In this study, a facile one-step dip-coating approach was reported for fabrication of superhydrophobic copper mesh by using PDMS, SiO2 nanoparticles, PVDF microparticles and a couple agent 3-aminopropyltriethoxysilane (KH-550). It is found that undesirable SiO2 agglomeration was obviously reduced by introducing KH-550 and PVDF microparticles. The KH-550 acts as the bridge-linker and binds SiO2, PVDF and PDMS together. The as-prepared superhydrophobic mesh exhibited a promising water contact angle of 160.1° and a small sliding angle of 2.5°. The coating displayed excellent resistance to various pollutants and retained its superhydrophobicity after abrasions (sandpaper abrasion or adhesive tape tear). The strong chemical stability was also observed when the mesh was immersed in various solutions, especially in neutral and alkaline solutions. The applications of the superhydrophobic mesh for quantitative water droplet manipulation and oil spill cleanup were also illustrated. The method is facile and economic, and could be used for large-scale fabrications for industrial applications.
Nanoparticles are promising materials used to construct roughness.3,5,17,18 Based on solvent techniques, nanoparticles are readily introduced onto the material surfaces. In order to enhance the adhesion between the superhydrophobic coating and substrate, the bonding layer5,17 and nanoparticle/polymer blends19,20 have been applied. Nanoparticles always tend to agglomerate due to their high surface area and surface energy. The inter-particle forces within the agglomeration stem from the van der Waals, capillary, and electrostatic forces.21 Nanoparticle aggregation usually form multi-scale roughness including the nano-scale roughness of primary nanoparticles and the micro-scale roughness of nanoparticle aggregates,22 which is beneficial to form Cassie–Baxter contact state,23 that a liquid droplet sits on the surface asperities with air pockets trapped in between, and therefore increases the water repellency. Double structured roughness was also constructed with both nano- and micro-particles recently.3,24 These fabrications usually included complicated self-assembling techniques and multiple operation procedures. Usually, the more the nanoparticles deposit on it, the higher roughness the surface has, but the less the binding strength between nanoparticles and substrate surface becomes.19,20 The resistance to mechanical tear and wear is a very important issue of superhydrophobic surfaces to their practical applications. Without proper design, the surface hydrophobic layers are prone to be damaged by mechanical abrasion, leading to undesired loss of water repellent properties.
Polydimethylsiloxane (PDMS) is a typical elastomeric material with a low surface energy of about 20 mJ m−2. PDMS and silica (SiO2) nanoparticles have been used to fabricate superhydrophobic surfaces on various substrates, such as metal plates,25 woods,26 glass,19,22 meshes,27,28 fabrics,29,30 polymer films,31 etc. By applying a suspension of nanoparticles in PDMS solution, superhydrophobic surfaces coated with PDMS/SiO2 nanocomposites have been realized with facile and economic methods, such as spin coating,32 spray coating,19,31 dip-coating,27,29 etc. Among them, dip-coating was appropriate for large scale fabrications. For the lack of strong interactions between PDMS and SiO2 particles, serious aggregations of nanoparticles and even cracks could be observed especially at high SiO2 contents,19 and the durability of superhydrophobic surfaces to mechanical wear and tear was usually weak. To improve particle dispersion and increase their compatibility with polymer matrices, surface modification of particles was usually adopted.24,30
Polyvinylidene fluoride (PVDF) also has a low free energy. Because of its excellent heat resistance, weatherability, and chemical resistance, PVDF received extensive attentions. For the preparation of superhydrophobic surfaces, PVDF usually need to be dissolved into solvents and superhydrophobic films could be fabricated by inert solvent-induced phase-inversion techniques.33,34 PVDF based coating techniques were also developed with the incorporation of nanoparticles.35,36 One of the disadvantages of PVDF based coatings is that they have poor adhesion with most substrates. Therefore, pre-treatment of the surfaces is required.35 As we know, there is no report about using commercial PVDF powder particles directly to construct superhydrophobic surfaces.
In this paper, PDMS, SiO2 nanoparticles, and PVDF microparticles were used to construct the superhydrophobic surface on the copper mesh through a simple one-step dip-coating method. The cross-linked PDMS acts as the adhesive agent, SiO2 nanoparticles and PVDF microparticles were adopted to construct the surface roughness. A coupling agent 3-aminopropyltriethoxysilane (KH-550) was used to improve the interactions between particles and PDMS. The prepared coatings were well characterized by using field emission scanning electron microscopy (FESEM), Fourier transform infrared spectroscopy (FTIR), X-ray photo-electron spectroscopy (XPS), and energy dispersive spectroscopy (EDS). It is found that the nanoparticle agglomeration was reduced by introducing PVDF microparticles and KH-550. The as-prepared superhydrophobic mesh displayed excellent self-cleaning properties, good resistance to acid and base attack, and desirable mechanical stability against sandpaper abrasion damage and adhesive tape tear. The applications of the coated mesh for water droplet manipulation and oil collection were also illustrated. The method is facile and economic, and is suitable for the large-scale industrial fabrications.
For the sake of comparison, the PDMS/SiO2/KH-550, PDMS/SiO2/PVDF and PDMS/SiO2 coated meshes were also prepared similarly to the above described process, but lack of PVDF, KH-550, or both of them in the dipping solutions respectively.
To verify the presence of PVDF on the copper mesh, the surface components of PDMS/SiO2 and PDMS/SiO2/PVDF meshes were scratched down, and the FTIR spectra of the two samples as well as the pure PVDF powder were measured and shown in Fig. 1. Appearance of the peak between 3300 cm−1 and 3700 cm−1 is due to the –OH stretching vibration. The peaks at around 2964 cm−1, 1261.2 cm−1 and 802.2 cm−1 are the asymmetric –CH3 stretching, symmetric –CH3 deformation and –CH3 rocking in Si–CH3 of PDMS, respectively. A broad, multi-component peak ranging from 930 cm−1 to 1200 cm−1 is corresponding to the asymmetric Si–O–Si stretching vibration absorption25,40,41 (Fig. 1a). Compared with the PDMS/SiO2 sample, the absorption bands at around 761.2, 615.6, 535.6, 409.8 cm−1, which can be assigned to the crystal vibration absorption peaks of PVDF,42 could be clearly seen in the spectra of the PDMS/SiO2/PVDF sample (Fig. 1b). The weak PVDF crystal absorption peaks in the PDMS/SiO2/PVDF sample are due to the presence of the SiO2 nanoparticles on the surfaces of the PVDF microparticles as disclosed in the following XPS and EDS measurements. Therefore, it is reasonable to infer that the mesh surface was effectively modified by SiO2 nanoparticles and PVDF microparticles.
The optical images of the prepared meshes were shown in Fig. 2. The surface of the dried PDMS/SiO2 mesh displays many tiny cracks on it (Fig. 2a). The toluene evaporation induced the internal flow during the drying process, and the cross-linked PDMS network had relatively high viscosity, thus the light nanoparticles were prone to forming aggregations and attaching onto the substrate.22 This led to the formation of cracks on the surface, especially at high SiO2 content.19 When PVDF powder was added into the solution, the cracks were more obvious (Fig. 2b) because of the incompatibility of PVDF and PDMS. Fig. 2a and b also indicated that both SiO2 and PVDF particles have weak interactions with PDMS and the copper mesh. After adding KH-550 into the dipping solution, the formed PDMS/SiO2/KH-550 and PDMS/SiO2/PVDF/KH-550 meshes were neat and smooth, and no cracks were found by naked eyes on the surfaces (Fig. 2c and d). Obviously, KH-550 plays an important role in improving the dispersion of SiO2 and PVDF particles in PDMS.
Fig. 2 Optical images of superhydrophobic meshes: (a) PDMS/SiO2, (b) PDMS/SiO2/PVDF, (c) PDMS/SiO2/KH-550, and (d) PDMS/SiO2/PVDF/KH-550. The insets are corresponding CAs, respectively. |
When PVDF powder was added, the CA increased from 153.6° ± 3.6° of the PDMS/SiO2 mesh to 157.8° ± 2.3° of the PDMS/SiO2/PVDF mesh (Fig. 2a and b), and the SA slightly decreased from 3.9° ± 1.0° to 3.4° ± 1.6° correspondingly. Both the low surface energy of PVDF and the improved roughness contributed to it. The addition of KH-550 further optimized the superhydrophobicity of the meshes, and the CAs and SAs were 156.9° ± 2.9° and 3.4° ± 1.4° for the PDMS/SiO2/KH-550 sample (Fig. 2c), and 160.1° ± 2.1° and 2.5° ± 0.6° for the PDMS/SiO2/PVDF/KH-550 mesh (Fig. 2d), respectively. Thus, the uniform distribution of the particles is beneficial to form a superhydrophobic surface.
It is found that amines could form hydrogen bonds with PVDF.43 Amines also enter into strong interactions with SiO2 nanoparticles by three kinds of interactions (Fig. 3b): amine groups form hydrogen bonds with silanol groups (hydrogen bonding interactions), amines accept protons from isolated silanol groups (Brönsted interactions), and amines coordinate to SiO2 nanoparticles (IV) when coordinative defect points are present on the surfaces (Lewis interactions).37 Therefore, amine groups of KH-550 could react with SiO2 and PVDF particles. The oxyethyl groups of KH-550, on the other end, would be hydrolyzed by absorbing water vapour in air, and the formed silanol groups could react with the hydroxyl groups of PDMS or form hydrogen bonds to PVDF. Therefore, KH-550 acts as the bridge-linker to bind SiO2 nanoparticles, PVDF microparticles and PDMS. The multiple interactions among them were shown in Fig. 3a as a schematic chemical reaction process. The increased interactions among SiO2, PVDF and PDMS led to the formation of well-distributions of particles on the sample surfaces.
Fig. 3 (a) The KH-550 acts as the bridge-linker to bind SiO2, PVDF and PDMS. (b) Possible interactions between an amine and the surface of SiO2 nanoparticles.37 |
The SEM images of PDMS/SiO2/KH-550 and PDMS/SiO2/PVDF/KH-550 meshes were shown in Fig. 4. Compared with the surface of the PDMS/SiO2/KH-550 mesh, granular bulges with the diameters from 1 to 15 μm could be clearly seen on the PDMS/SiO2/PVDF/KH-550 mesh (Fig. 4c), which indicated the PVDF microparticles were successfully coated on the mesh surface. The agglomerations of SiO2 nanoparticles were obviously seen on the surface of PDMS/SiO2/KH-550 mesh in the high magnification SEM image (Fig. 4b), while nanoparticles were distributed more homogenously on the surface of the PDMS/SiO2/PVDF/KH-550 mesh (Fig. 4d). These results indicated the microparticles, because of the much larger sizes and weights, would further prevent nanoparticles from forming agglomerations. The EDS elemental maps showed the uniform distribution of C, O and Si on the surface of PDMS/SiO2/PVDF/KH-550 mesh (Fig. 5), while F was only observed on PVDF microparticles (Fig. 5, S2 and Table S1†). Because of the low content of KH-550, the N element was not detected by the EDS measurement. The Si element was also found on the surface of PVDF particles (Fig. S2†), which indicates SiO2 adsorbed on the surfaces of PVDF microparticles.
Fig. 4 SEM images of the coated surface. (a) and (b) are PDMS/SiO2/KH-550 mesh, (c) and (d) are PDMS/SiO2/PVDF/KH-550 mesh at different magnifications. |
Fig. 5 (a) SEM image and (b–f) EDS C, O, Si, F and N elemental maps of the PDMS/SiO2/PVDF/KH-550 mesh. |
XPS studies were further carried out to get the chemical compositions of the outmost layers (Fig. 6 and Table 1). The C1s (285 eV), O1s (532 eV), Si2s (155 eV) and Si2p (103 eV) peaks can be seen clearly in the spectra of all samples. After introduction of PVDF, KH-550, or both of them, however, no clear peaks associated with the F and N elements could be found in the spectra. The elemental XPS spectra for F and N were further measured by using a pass energy of 20 eV (Fig. S3†). Only a very small F1s peak around 688 eV was observed in PDMS/SiO2/PVDF, and almost no fluorine element could be detected on the surface of PDMS/SiO2/PVDF/KH-550 mesh (Fig. S3a†). The results indicated the SiO2 nanoparticles and PDMS covered the surface of PVDF microparticles during the drying process. Also, a very weak N1s peak at 400 eV, which is attributed to nitrogen moieties with covalent N–H bonds in KH-550, could be seen in PDMS/SiO2/KH-550 and PDMS/SiO2/PVDF/KH-550 samples (Fig. S3b†). The weak intensity is because of the low contents of KH-550 in them. Also, SiO2 nanoparticles and PDMS are prone to moving to the surfaces to decrease the surface energy of the coatings, which further reduce the contents of N elements on the surfaces. After adding KH-550, the content of C element increases and that of the O element decreases (Table 1), indicating that PDMS migrated to the coating surfaces. Therefore, the interaction between PDMS and particles became stronger.
Fig. 6 XPS survey spectra of (a) PDMS/SiO2, (b) PDMS/SiO2/PVDF, (c) PDMS/SiO2/KH-550 and (d) PDMS/SiO2/PVDF/KH-550 mesh. |
Mesh | Compositions (at%) | ||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|
C | Si | O | N | F | |
PDMS/SiO2 | 23.97 | 32.41 | 43.62 | — | — |
PDMS/SiO2/PVDF | 21.59 | 35.77 | 42.42 | — | 0.22 |
PDMS/SiO2/KH550 | 32.2 | 30.96 | 36.11 | 0.73 | — |
PDMS/SiO2/PVDF/KH550 | 28.11 | 31.6 | 39.5 | 0.47 | 0.31 |
The PDMS/SiO2/PVDF/KH-550 mesh was chosen for further studies due to its outstanding superhydrophobicity. The optical images of water droplets (dyed by dark-blue ink) and oil droplets (dyed by Sudan red) on the pristine copper mesh and the superhydrophobic mesh were shown in Fig. 7a. Because of the porous structure, the pristine copper mesh is hydrophobic and has a CA around 120°. In comparison, the water droplet almost keeps a spherical shape on the surface of the modified mesh. The CA of oil droplet on the surface of the pristine mesh is small, while the oil droplet quickly spreads on the modified mesh, indicating the PDMS/SiO2/PVDF/KH-550 mesh is superoleophilic. A jet of water easily bounces off the superhydrophobic mesh due to the trapped air between the water and mesh (Fig. 7b and Movie S1†). Moreover, the superhydrophobic mesh appears bright silver with a mirror-like phenomenon when it was pressed into water, further proving the air cushion between water and the superhydrophobic mesh (Fig. 7d).
The variations of SAs along with different pH levels are also illustrated in Fig. 9. The SA increased with the immersion time, and the water droplets could roll off the coatings if the meshes were in neutral or alkaline solutions for 8 days. After 10 day immersion, the droplets were stuck on the coatings occasionally, which means the transition from the Cassie–Baxter state to the Wenzel state.38 It was reported that the variation of hydrophobic performance after the water immersion is attributed to a weakening of the Si–CH3 bond strength.3 The results indicated the meshes have good resistance to neutral and alkaline aqueous solutions.
For acidic treatments, though the CAs decreased gradually, the SAs were more sensitive to the damage of superhydrophobic surfaces.38,44 The droplets became adhesive to the meshes when they were immersed in the solutions of pH 5, 3, 1 for more than 6, 4 and 3 days, respectively. This is because the acid would attack the amine groups and the multiple interactions among SiO2, PVDF and PMDS were gradually eliminated. Acid also reacted with the exposed copper wires. Consequently, a portion of the nanostructured area started to get damaged, resulting in increasing SAs. Such results indicated that the mesh has medium-good stability against acidic solutions.
The mechanical stability of the coating was assessed by the repeated tear tests with adhesive tapes.38,39 In this test, an adhesive tape was pasted onto the coated mesh, pressed with thumb, and then peeled off.39 As shown in Fig. 10a, the PDMS/SiO2 coating was easily peeled off, demonstrating the coating stability was poor. In comparison, CAs and SAs changed slowly with the increase of the tear cycles. After repetition for 35 cycles, the PDMS/SiO2/PVDF/KH-550 mesh remained superhydrophobic and the water droplets rolled off the tilted coating successfully (Fig. 10b and c). Thus the PDMS/SiO2/PVDF/KH-550 coating is firmly attached to the copper mesh. The results implied that KH-550 improved the adhesion strength of the coatings. The effect of KH-550 content on the adhesion strength was also tested. When KH-550 is 0.5 wt%, adhesion strength of the prepared mesh is less than that containing 1 wt% KH-550. This result is because of the less bonding strength between particles and PDMS matrix. When KH-550 is 1.5 wt%, the decreased tear stability may be caused by the more PDMS on the coating surface, which would reduce the roughness of the surface. The increased KH-550 content would induce more –NH2 groups on the surface, which also decreased the superhydrophobicity of the surface.
The sandpaper abrasion tests5,39 were also carried out on the PDMS/SiO2/PVDF/KH-550 mesh. The mesh weighing 100 g was placed face-down to sandpaper (1500 meshes) and moved transversely and longitudinally for 10 cm respectively along the guided line as shown in Fig. 11a–d. This process is defined as one abrasion cycle. The water CAs and SAs after every five abrasion cycles are shown in Fig. 11e. When 1 wt% KH-550 was contained, the water CA decreased gradually to 151.6° and SA became larger than 10° after 30 cycles. But water droplets still could roll off the 14° tilted mesh after 35 cycles, which means that the water droplets are also in the Cassie–Baxter state. Therefore, the mesh has robust resistance to mechanical abrasions. The KH-550 content also influences the abrasion mechanical properties of the meshes, which was consistent with the results in the above tear test.
Fig. 11 Sandpaper abrasion tests. (a–d) One cycle of the sandpaper abrasion test. (e) Water CAs and SAs of PDMS/SiO2/PVDF/KH-550 mesh after repeated abrasion tests. |
Surface modification of particles was often adopted to improve particle dispersion and increase their compatibility with polymer matrix. Recently, PDMS-coated silica nanoparticles prepared by a thermal vapor deposition method were used to provide a superhydrophobic characteristic to fabrics and meshes.28 The prepared PDMS-coated SiO2/PDMS steel mesh showed negligible changes of CAs when it was exposed to acidic and basic environments for 40 min. And the superhydrophobic property was maintained when the mesh was impacted by 100 g of sands with velocity about 0.22 m s−1. In comparison, more strong tolerance to chemical corrosions was observed in this study and excellent mechanical stability was also exhibited. The results is due to the multiple bridge-link interactions provided by the KH-550 couple agent. In a recent experimental report, improved mechanical properties and good adhesion of the PVDF/SiO2 composites coating on the glass substrate were also found when the substrate was pre-treated with KH-550 molecules.35 It was also reported that the additional cross-linking points provided by silane agents could improve the mechanical properties of superhydrophobic coatings considerably.38 These results are consistent well with our findings. The hydrophobic SiO2 nanoparticles, PVDF powder, PDMS and KH-550 were all commercially available and inexpensive, therefore can be utilized in real industrial applications.
With the above device, microdroplet-based microreactions can be achieved conveniently (Fig. 13). A drop of 5 μL magnesium sulfate (1 M) and a drop of 5 μL sodium hydroxide (2 M) were transported to the superhydrophobic mesh, then the drop of magnesium sulfate was grabbed and put to the sodium hydroxide droplet, the white precipitate of magnesium hydroxide occurred later (Fig. 13b), demonstrating the potential strategy for the quantitative microdroplets reaction.
To demonstrate the ability of oil spill cleanup, xylene dyed with red oil (2.0 g) was used as a model oil spill, and the superhydrophobic mesh boat was put on the oil spill. As shown in Fig. 15, the oil permeated and entered into the boat, and after 5 min, almost all the oil was automatically collected by the mini boat. During the whole process, no external force was needed. About 1.83 g of xylene was collected, which includes 0.17 g xylene absorbed by the mesh and 1.66 g xylene in the boat. The oil recovery was approximated as 91.5%. The collection process is self-driven, and no additional energy is required, displaying an energy-saving and efficient application for oil collection. And if a vacuum pump could be equipped with the boat, the collection could be continuous, unmanned and highly efficient.
Footnote |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available. See DOI: 10.1039/c8ra03262a |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2018 |