Yue Hu,
Zhihuan Weng*,
Yu Qi,
Jinyan Wang,
Shouhai Zhang,
Cheng Liu,
Lishuai Zong and
Xigao Jian
State Key Laboratory of Fine Chemicals, Liaoning High Performance Resin Engineering Research Center, Department of Polymer Science & Materials, Dalian University of Technology, Dalian 116024, China. E-mail: zweng@dlut.edu.cn
First published on 24th September 2018
Major problems currently limiting the widespread application of phthalonitrile resins are the high precursor melting point and volatility of the curing agent. Herein, a novel self-curing triphenol A-based phthalonitrile resin precursor (TPPA-Ph) was successfully synthesized by reacting α,α,α′-tris(4-hydroxyphenyl)-1-ethyl-4-isopropylbenzene (TPPA) with 4-nitrophthalonitrile (NPh) via nucleophilic substitution. The presence of residual phenolic hydroxyl groups in the TPPA-Ph precursor promoted the curing reaction of phthalonitrile resin in the absence of an additional curing reagent. Self-cured TPPA-Ph resins exhibited relatively low melting points (less than 100 °C), high thermal stability, and a wide processing window (116 °C). Furthermore, the TPPA-Ph precursors contained phenolic hydroxyl and cyano groups that can be used as flexibilizers and curing agents to optimize other phthalonitrile resins. Resorcinol-based phthalonitrile resin (DPPH) cured with various amounts of TPPA-Ph possessed excellent thermal and thermo-oxidative stability with a 5% weight loss temperature exceeding 530 °C, Tgs above 380 °C, and a wide processing window and time. Therefore, as a novel precursor and curing agent for phthalonitrile resins, the triphenol A-based phthalonitrile resin is an ideal resin matrix for high-performance composites with broad application prospects in aerospace, shipping, machinery, and other high-tech fields.
The Keller research group has been researching phthalonitrile resin since 1980, resulting in great progress. A series of simple bisphenol-based phthalonitriles10 have been designed and synthesized. However, the curing rate of the phthalonitrile monomer is very slow, taking nearly one hundred hours to produce a significant gel at 280 °C. Subsequently, Keller and coworkers found that mixing phthalonitrile monomers and aromatic amines effectively promoted the curing of phthalonitrile monomers, with the curing rate related to the alkalinity of the aromatic amines.11 Curing additives that can catalyze the production of high-performance phthalonitrile resin include strong organic acids,12 organic amines,13 organic acid/amine salts,14 metals,15 and metal salts.16 Currently, aromatic diamines, such as 1,3-bis(3-aminophenoxy)benzene (m-APB), diamino diphenyl sulfone (DDS), and 1,3-bis(3,4-dicyanophenoxy)benzene (BDB), are commonly used as curing agents for phthalonitrile resins. Although the amount of aromatic diamine curing agent added can adjust the rate of phthalonitrile curing, the aromatic amines17 are easily decomposed. Adding too much curing agent produces voids in the material during high-temperature treatment, which affects the mechanical properties of the material. To resolve this problem, a stable curing agent is needed to prevent volatilization during high-temperature curing and, therefore, improve the mechanical performance of phthalonitrile resin.
Meanwhile, another problem of phthalonitrile resin is the high melting point of the phthalonitrile monomer, which is caused by its larger molecular rigidity (usually greater than 200 °C).18–21 For example, bisphenol A-based phthalonitrile has a melting point of 195 °C, while the melting point of biphenyldiol-based phthalonitrile is 235 °C.17 However, phthalonitrile resin curing can be conducted after the phthalonitrile monomer has been melted. Therefore, the processing temperature window from the melting point to the gel point is too narrow, making it difficult to process and mold the phthalonitrile resin. Therefore, the synthesis of a phthalonitrile monomer with a low melting point is key to the development of phthalonitrile resin.
In brief, the major problems currently limiting the widespread application and development of phthalonitrile resin are the high precursor melting point, curing agent volatility, high curing temperatures, and long curing times.22,23 Therefore, research into new resin precursors and novel curing agents can effectively solve these issues.24–26 In our laboratory, we have demonstrated introducing phthalazinone groups into phthalonitrile resins enhances their thermal stability.27 Meanwhile, the new curing agent has been screened to improve the phthalonitrile resin processing properties.28,29
Herein, a new type of multifunctional phthalonitrile resin (TPPA-Ph) containing a triphenol A structure was prepared using α,α,α′-tris(4-hydroxyphenyl)-1-ethyl-4-isopropylbenzene (TPPA) as a feedstock in a one-pot reaction. Using TPPA as a monomer was advantageous for the construction of phthalonitrile resins. Firstly, TPPA-based phthalonitrile precursor TPPA-Ph has a relatively low melting point due to the TPPA monomer containing an alkyl flexible center and isopropyl benzene flexible group. Secondly, by regulating the reaction point, the phthalonitrile resin system retains a certain amount of phenolic hydroxyl groups after the reaction, which can activate phthalonitrile resin self-curing without an additional curing agent. Therefore, the formation of voids due to the addition of external curing agent is avoided, resulting in an excellent phthalonitrile resin. Thirdly, phenolic hydroxyl groups in the precursor can also be used as a flexibilizer to optimize other phthalonitrile resins, which improves the processing performance of phthalonitrile resin. The cure kinetics, and thermal and dynamic mechanical properties, were also investigated.
DPPH and TPPA-Ph (mass ratios of 10%, 20%, 25%, and 30%) were ground evenly and stirred in a reaction vessel at 180 °C until melting. The mixtures were then cured at 200 °C for 2 h, 250 °C for 2 h, 300 °C for 2 h, 350 °C for 2 h, 375 °C for 2 h, and 400 °C for 2 h in a muffle furnace. As a reference, 5% (mass ratio) DDS was mixed with DPPH and cured under identical conditions.
(1) |
The temperature-dependent function can be easily determined using the Arrhenius equation:30
(2) |
The frequently applied methods of determining Eα are the Kissinger, Ozawa, and Friedman methods for non-isothermal reactions. Using the Starink method is recommended due to higher accuracy of Eα according to the ICTAC kinetic project.32
(3) |
TPPA-Ph | TPPA-Ph-N1 (%) | TPPA-Ph-N2 (%) | TPPA-Ph-N3 (%) |
---|---|---|---|
P1 | 0.0 | 9.8 | 90.2 |
P2 | 11.6 | 42.3 | 46.1 |
P3 | 28.0 | 29.5 | 42.5 |
P4 | 44.0 | 43.1 | 12.9 |
The presence of residual phenolic hydroxyl groups in TPPA-Ph promoted curing of the phthalonitrile resin. The phenolic hydroxyl content, structure, and distribution of the TPPA-Ph precursors were determined using HPLC and HPLC-MS (Fig. 1S†). These results indicated that five compounds were present in total, whose structures were classified as TPPA-Ph-N1–3, and a total of three types according to the different phenolic hydroxyl contents. There were two mono-substituted compounds (TPPA-Ph-N1-A and TPPA-Ph-N1-B), two bis-substituted compounds (TPPA-Ph-N2-A and TPPA-Ph-N2-B) and one tri-substituted compound (TPPA-Ph-N3) in the TPPA-Ph precursor systems. Different distributions of the TPPA-Ph precursor systems were synthesized by changing the reaction parameters, such as reactant proportion and reaction temperature (Table 1). Increasing the molar ratio of NPh to TPPA and the reaction temperature led to a decrease in the proportion of mono-substituted compounds (TPPA-Ph-1; from 44.0% to 0.0%), while the proportion of the tri-substituted compound (TPPA-Ph-3) was increased from 12.9% to 90.2%. Using a TPPA:K2CO3:NPh molar ratio of 1:1.5:1.05 and a temperature of 25 °C, the TPPA-Ph precursor system contained 44.0% of the mono-substituted compounds (TPPA-Ph-N1) and 43.1% of the bis-substituted compounds (TPPA-Ph-N2), which afforded the majority of phenolic hydroxyl groups that act as curing centers to facilitate TPPA-based phthalonitrile resin curing.
Fig. 3 DSC curing kinetics curves for self-curing TPPA-Ph (P4) under a nitrogen atmosphere at various heating rates. |
The self-curing reactions of TPPA-Ph precursors were conducted under temperature-programmed conditions (200 °C for 2 h, 250 °C for 2 h, 350 °C for 2 h, and 400 °C for 2 h). The thermal stabilities of the resulting TPPA-Ph resins were investigated using TGA analysis over the temperature range 30–800 °C at a heating rate of 10 °C min−1 under a nitrogen atmosphere. The data, including the temperature at 5% mass loss (Td5%) and the char yields at 800 °C, are summarized in Table 2. As shown in Fig. 4, the self-cured TPPA-Ph (P1) resin had the highest 5% weight loss temperature (Td5%) of 506.1 °C, exhibiting a char retention of 81.2% after heating to 800 °C under a nitrogen atmosphere. Cured TPPA-Ph resins with different distributions had distinct thermal stabilities, with a decrease in phenolic hydroxyl content in TPPA-Ph precursors resulting in an increase in Td5% (see Table 2). Although the presence of residual phenolic hydroxyl groups in TPPA-Ph precursors can promote resin curing, a higher molar ratio of residual phenolic hydroxyl groups to cyano groups will reduce the crosslinking density and thermal stability of the phthalonitrile resin. This suggested that the curing rate and thermal properties of self-cured TPPA-Ph resins can be easily controlled by adjusting the phenolic hydroxyl content in the TPPA-Ph precursors.
TPPA-Ph | Molar ratio of residual OH/CN | Td5% (°C) | Char yield at 800 °C (%) |
---|---|---|---|
P1 | 0.03 | 506.1 | 81.2 |
P2 | 0.22 | 505.7 | 76.8 |
P3 | 0.35 | 500.3 | 78.1 |
P4 | 0.55 | 490.6 | 78.5 |
The rheological properties of TPPA-Ph (P2) without an additional curing reagent were also investigated. As shown in Fig. 5, the TPPA-Ph (P2) precursor showed a rapid decrease in viscosity at around 100 °C. When the temperature was raised to 140 °C, the viscosity dropped to 50 Pa S, which is considered in the machinable range. The viscosity was stable in the range 1–0.1 Pa S with increasing temperature, while the minimum viscosity was 1.615 Pa S, which confirmed that the melt of TPPA-Ph resin has satisfactory fluidity. The viscosity levels increased gradually above 256 °C, meaning that the processing temperature window was 116 °C. Therefore, TPPA-Ph resins have a wide processing window and excellent processing fluidity.
The thermal and thermo-oxidative properties of the DPPH resins cured with TPPA-Ph (P4) were evaluated using TGA over the temperature range 30–800 °C at heating rates of 10 °C min−1, as shown in Fig. 7, and the key data are shown in Table 3. In general, the DPPH resins cured with various contents of TPPA-Ph (P4) possessed excellent thermotolerance, with the temperatures corresponding to 5% weight loss all exceeding 528 °C under either nitrogen or air atmospheres, while char yields were all above 76% when heated to 800 °C under a nitrogen atmosphere. Although the TPPA-Ph (P4) content was 10%, the 5% and 10% weight loss temperatures were the highest in any atmosphere, and were also higher than those of DPPH cured with 5% DDS as reference.
Fig. 7 TGA traces of DPPH resins cured with DDS and different TPPA-Ph contents under (a) nitrogen and (b) air atmospheres. |
Curing agent | In N2 | In air | ||
---|---|---|---|---|
Td5% (°C) | Char yield at 800 °C (%) | Td5%(°C) | Char yield at 800 °C (%) | |
5%DDS | 530.9 | 77.4 | 534.4 | 45.3 |
10%TPPA-Ph | 547.0 | 76.3 | 537.3 | 55.5 |
20%TPPA-Ph | 528.8 | 78.4 | 537.2 | 46.6 |
25%TPPA-Ph | 538.0 | 77.8 | 534.6 | 47.5 |
30%TPPA-Ph | 532.3 | 77.3 | 531.2 | 22.8 |
The influence of long-term oxidative aging at high temperature under an air atmosphere is also an important consideration for phthalonitrile resin use. The conditions were simulated by subjecting DPPH resins cured with TPPA-Ph (P4) to stepwise heating at a series of temperatures between 200 and 375 °C at 8 h intervals under air. Fig. 8 shows the percentage residual mass after weight loss at various temperatures. A cumulative weight loss of 1.68–3.84% was observed for a TPPA-Ph (P4) content range of 10–30%. This performance was similar to that of the resin with DDS as curing agent. Based on the above results, the DPPH resins cured with TPPA-Ph (P4) showed outstanding thermal stability and thermo-oxidative stability.
Fig. 8 Long-term oxidative aging plots of DPPH phthalonitrile resins cured with DDS and different TPPA-Ph (P4) contents. |
Rheological behavior plays an important role in confirming the processability of resins. The processing window and time required for curing were further investigated by examining the complex viscosity (η*) of DPPH resins cured with TPPA-Ph (P4) as a function of temperature from 160 °C to 370 °C. As shown in Fig. 9a, the viscosity of the resins was influenced by the TPPA-Ph (P4) content, with TPPA-Ph (P4) contents of 10%, 20%, 25%, and 30% showing rapid complex viscosity increases at 330 °C, 290 °C, 270 °C, and 260 °C, respectively. At temperatures above 175 °C, a minimum melt complex viscosity of around 0.2 Pa S was observed for all DPPH resins. The low melt viscosity of the resins at higher temperatures was evidence of their superb melt fluidity and stability. However, for the DDS curing system, the lowest viscosity was around 0.08 Pa S at 191 °C, and the curing window was narrower than that of the TPPA-Ph system. In Fig. 9b, complex viscosity measurements as a function of time for DPPH resins with different TPPA-Ph (P4) contents were performed at 250 °C, respectively. The processing window and time of the DPPH resins could be adjusted by the TPPA-Ph (P4) content. Based on the above results, the DPPH resins with TPPA-Ph (P4) showed good processability with low complex viscosity and a wide processing window at moderate temperatures.
Fig. 9 Complex viscosity (η*) as a function of (a) temperature and (b) time for cured DPPH phthalonitrile resins with DDS and different TPPA-Ph (P4) contents. |
The dynamic mechanical properties are another fundamental feature that determines the upper limit of the application temperature in developing high-performance phthalonitrile resin. The dynamic mechanical properties of DPPH resins cured with TPPA-Ph (P4) were investigated to evaluate changes in the resin modulus as a function of temperature and to determine the glass transition temperature of DPPH resins. The dynamic mechanical behavior of resins, including storage modulus (G′) and damping factor (tanδ) at a fixed frequency of 1 Hz in single cantilever mode, are shown in Fig. 10. All cured resins exhibited a high storage modulus of more than 3.0 GPa at 50 °C, which decreased as the temperature gradually increased. This high modulus should be due to heteroaromatic structures and the high degree of crosslinking. Furthermore, the declining modulus with increasing temperature was attributed to stress relaxation of the cured resins. The tand vs. temperature curves for DPPH cured resins are shown in Fig. 10b, showing that the tanδ values were below 0.03 when heated to 380 °C with no obvious relaxation transition, suggesting that the glass transition temperature of DPPH resins were all above 380 °C within the testing range. Some small transitions were ascribed to secondary relaxation of the phthalonitrile structures. As determined above, DPPH resins cured with various TPPA-Ph (P4) contents possessed excellent thermal stability. For DPPH cured with DDS, no Tg was detected within the tested temperature range and the storage modulus was much higher than that using the TPPA-Ph system due to the rigid structure of DDS.
Fig. 10 Dynamic mechanical properties of DPPH resins cured with DDS and different contents of TPPA-Ph (P4): (a) storage modulus vs. temperature; (b) tanδ vs. temperature. |
Another important factor in the use of resins under real conditions is water absorption caused by the cyano and phenolic hydroxyl groups. The water absorption was investigated by immersing the DPPH resins cured with TPPA-Ph (P4) in boiling deionized water for 100 h. Data, including the weight increase at 100 h, are summarized in Fig. 11. However, the water absorption of all resins with different TPPA-Ph (P4) contents was less than 4%, which was lower than that of the DDS curing system, guaranteeing the effective use of DPPH resin in practical production.
Fig. 11 Moisture absorption curves for DPPH phthalonitrile resins cured with DDS and different TPPA-Ph (P4) contents. |
Footnote |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available. See DOI: 10.1039/c8ra06926c |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2018 |