Marta
Pacheco
a,
Beatriz
Jurado-Sánchez
*ab and
Alberto
Escarpa
*ab
aDepartment of Analytical Chemistry, Physical Chemistry and Chemical Engineering, University of Alcala, E-28807, Madrid, Spain. E-mail: alberto.escarpa@uah.es; beatriz.jurado@uah.es
bChemical Research Institute “Andrés M. Del Rio”, University of Alcala, E-28807, Madrid, Spain
First published on 1st October 2018
Catalytic Janus micromotors encapsulating Cd2+ or citrate are used here as mobile microreactors for “on the fly” CdS quantum dot and gold nanoparticle synthesis. Micromotor navigation in microliter “reagent solutions” results in the generation of the corresponding nanoparticles inside the micromotor body with high yield and negligible waste generation. Nanoparticle generation can be attributed to convective diffusion of reagents into the moving reactor body. “On-demand” modulation of nanoparticle size and catalytic activities can be achieved by judicious control of the motion behavior of the microreactor. The use of confined reagents in connection with such enhanced movement allows for efficient operation in very low (less than 800 μL) volumes. The new microreactors developed here hold considerable promise for reactions in aqueous environments for novel synthetic schemes in different sites along with multiplexed capabilities for a myriad of catalytic reactions.
Self-propelled micromotors represent another example of small devices capable of performing complex tasks in solution.8 Such moving particles can induce efficient fluid mixing and carry active components (“reagents”) in their structure, thus being extremely useful for accelerating chemical operations.9 Such capabilities have been exploited in a myriad of environmental,10 biomedical,11 energy,12 and analytical applications.13 Value-added product mediated synthesis (vanillyl alcohol) using sodium borohydride propelled graphene based micromotors has also been described.14 Wang's group reported the use of micromotors for fabrication of micro- and nano-structures. In a first approach, glucose oxidase modified Au/Ag/Ni flexible nanowires were used for generating 3D Au microstructures with high topological features (e.g., helical shape) on Au patterned substrates.15 Later on, metallic nanowires and Janus sphere motors were used as mobile nanomasks and nanolenses to manipulate light beams for generating controlled patterns on a surface in a lithographic like process.16 Yet, the application of micromotors as microreactors in ultra-miniaturized synthesis schemes remains unexplored. Herein we report on a new application of Janus micromotors as mobile microreactors for nanoparticle synthesis. The concept, which is illustrated in Fig. 1, relies on cadmium acetate (Cd2+) or citrate loaded Janus micromotors for the synthesis of CdS quantum dots and gold nanoparticles (AuNPs), respectively. Micromotor navigation in microliter “reagent solutions” (sulfur ions and adenosine 5′-triphosphate (ATP) or chloroauric acid (HAuCl4), respectively) results in the generation of the corresponding nanoparticles inside the micromotor body with high yield and negligible waste generation. Compared with previous studies on micromotors, synthesis can be performed without the need for any enzyme, patterned surfaces or light sources.
The strategy described here is inspired by our recent work on the use of oil-in-water prepared Janus micromotors encapsulating graphene quantum dots for endotoxin detection.17 In this work we adopt a similar bottom-up approach to synthesize our moving microreactors, which contain a huge loading of Cd2+ or citrate precursors, PtNPs for autonomous propulsion and Fe3O4 NPs for “on-demand” transport in small settings. Convective diffusion of sulfur ions and ATP or Au3+ into the micromotor body triggers the reaction with the precursors facilitating the generation of the nanoparticles (see Fig. 1). To gain further insights into the mechanism behind such nanoparticle generation, we evaluated the effect of different “microreactor” configurations using Cd2+ loaded micromotors and S2− solutions and vice versa. Similarly, for AuNP synthesis, citrate loaded microreactors in Au3+ reagent solutions were used, and vice versa. From the results of such experiments, and as will be further described, nanoparticle generation can be attributed to convective reagent diffusion into the moving reactor body. We will also illustrate the “on-demand” modulation of the synthesis conditions in the overall reaction yield and in the catalytic activity of the as-prepared nanoparticles. To the best of our knowledge, this is the first time that self-propelled micromotors have been applied as mobile microreactors in chemistry-based synthesis schemes.
Fig. 2 (A) Schematic of the Janus character of the PCL-PtNPs-Fe3O4 NP microreactor and (B) optical microscopy image of the micromotor. The asymmetric character is marked with a white circle. (C) Scanning electron microscopy (SEM) and energy-dispersive X-ray spectroscopy (EDX) images showing the asymmetric distribution of the catalytic patch in the microreactors. (D) Time-lapse images (taken from ESI Video 1†) showing the propulsion of the microreactor in helical (left) and circular–linear circular (right) trajectories in peroxide solutions and the control of its direction using an external magnetic field. Scale bars, 20 μm. |
Fig. 3 illustrates the synthesis of CdS quantum dots using our Janus microreactors. Two different configurations were explored, one using cadmium acetate dihydrate loaded microreactors (3 × 103 micromotors μL−1) in hydrogen peroxide, ATP and Na2S solutions and the other using the same amount of Na2S loaded microreactors in hydrogen peroxide, ATP and Cd2+ solutions. After 15 min, Cd2+ microreactors display a strong fluorescent emission at 482 nm after excitation at 340 nm, which was attributed to the generation of the CdS quantum dots. In contrast, no apparent fluorescent emission is noted for S2− loaded microreactors, even after 60 min of navigation in the solutions. From these result, we hypothesized that nanoparticle generation can be attributed to a convective diffusion process into the microparticles.18 In Cd2+ microreactors, the overall positive charge inside the microreactor body (along with the induced movement) induces the diffusion of oppositely charged ions (S2− and ATP) and the corresponding CdS QD generation. ESI Video 2† illustrates the efficient navigation of the micromotor and the strong fluorescent emission attributed to CdS generation. In contrast, microreactors loaded with Cd2+ but navigating in solutions in the absence of S2− do not display fluorescent emission (see the video) even after 30 min of navigation. The synthesis mechanism relies on the use of ATP as a capping ligand, which represents a powerful mean for rationally controlling CdS QD properties. This capping ligand prevents irreversible aggregation by stabilizing the colloid through entropic repulsion, increasing the water solubility.19 The low total solution volume (500 μL), which is 4 to 240 times lower than that used in traditional formats,19a,c,20 meets the demands of green chemistry principles and holds considerable promise for its use in small settings were mixing constraints can hamper the overall process. Surprisingly, in S2− microreactors, no apparent quantum dot generation is observed. The reason lies in the strong affinity of Cd2+ for ATP molecules. Indeed, strong electrostatic interactions between the positive Cd2+ ions and the negatively charged oxygen atoms in the phosphate backbones along with the coordination between Cd2+ and NH2 groups19b in ATP result in the generation of a neutral adduct, preventing its diffusion into the microreactor body.
The crucial role of the enhanced fluid mixing generated by the “moving” microreactor toward accelerating the reaction kinetics is illustrated in the time-dependent fluorescence graphics of Fig. 3A. As can be seen, for moving micromotors (a) fluorescence intensity increases rapidly with time up to 5 min of navigation, then reaching a plateau. Please also note that the slope of the graphic in (a) is almost two times higher than the one in (b), indicating the higher yield of CdS. The fluorescence intensity is two times higher than that obtained under magnetic stirring (b), which also reveals a lower yield of CdS quantum dots, further indicating the superior fluid mixing imparted by the micromotors in reduced volumes. For comparison, Fe microreactors in peroxide solutions (c) and static micromotors (d) did not show any apparent increase in the fluorescence intensity, which reveals that the presence of peroxide does not accelerate the synthesis. These results were obtained after analyzing a total of 100 individual micromotor-based reactors, yielding similar fluorescence intensities in all cases. Under the optimized conditions, the as-synthesized CdS quantum dots were further characterized. As can be seen in Fig. 3B, elemental mapping shows a uniform distribution of Cd, S and P in the microreactor body, corresponding to the CdS quantum dots. Also, it can be seen from the fluorescence spectra of Fig. 3C that the CdS quantum dots display a strong fluorescent emission at 482 nm after excitation at 340 nm, which is similar to that reported in other studies for its synthesis.19a UV/VIS spectroscopy was used to determine the direct optical band gap according to the Tauc relation,21 with the bandgap calculated to be 3.8 eV, yielding a particle size of over 3.6 nm (see the ESI†). The particle size was further confirmed from the HRTEM images of Fig. 3D. Particle analysis of over 50 CdS QDs recorded by HRTEM reveals a mean particle size of 3.6 ± 0.5 nm. Also, the EDX images of Fig. S1† indicate the presence of Cd2+ and S2− in the particles.
Another practical utility of the CdS microreactors is illustrated in Fig. 4. The fluorescence intensity dependence on ATP concentration can be exploited for detection of this important analyte in small settings/ultra-miniaturized environments where common agitation means are not available, revealing its role as a useful microsensor with plenty of capabilities. The maximum signal was obtained after 5 min of microsensor navigation, which was then selected as optimal. Thus, as shown in Fig. 4B, the plot of fluorescence intensity vs. ATP concentration displays a linear dependence up to 1 mM concentration and then remains constant. The slight decrease in fluorescence after 15 min was attributed to the aggregation of the CdS quantum dots over time, which can also be partly observed in the HRTEM images of Fig. 3D. Yet, at the optimal ATP concentration, very low aggregation is noted. This strategy offers a convenient way for future sensing profile schemes in different media. Additional efforts in our lab have been aimed at characterizing the CdS quantum dots synthesized under different conditions and extending the concept to synthesize other types of quantum dots, gaining better control of the whole process. On the other hand, the magnetic Fe3O4 nanoparticles in our microreactor body can be used to selectively transport for controlled “on-demand” release in a pre-determined area, thus opening new and exciting applications in fields such as microfluidics.
Fig. 4 (A) Influence of ATP concentration on the fluorescence intensity of CdS microreactors. (B) ATP detection using CdS microreactors. Scale bars, 20 μm. |
The utility of micromotors acting as highly efficient microreactors was also illustrated for “on-demand” gold nanoparticle synthesis. To this end, 200 μL of a solution containing sodium citrate loaded microreactors (optimal value, 4 × 103 micromotors μL−1) was re-dispersed in 200 μL of gold(III) chloride trihydrate containing 400 μL of H2O (for static or magnetic stirring control experiments) or 30% H2O2 (for bubble propulsion and Fe microreactor control experiments). Similarly, 200 μL of a solution containing gold(III) chloride trihydrate (optimal value, 4 × 103 micromotors μL−1) microreactors was re-dispersed in 200 μL of citrate solution containing 400 μL of the appropriate chemicals. Both microreactors display efficient propulsion in these solutions at a speed of 25 ± 5 μm s−1 in the presence and in the absence of a surfactant (see ESI Video 3†). In both configurations, and as can be seen in Fig. 5A, efficient AuNP generation was observed. Yet, for citrate microreactors, fast AuNP generation (which started after 15 min of microreactor navigation) was noted, which can also be visualized by the deep-blue colors of the photograph of the corresponding solutions. This strategy is competitive with conventional approaches. In contrast, 5 h was needed for Au3+ microreactors. The slight negative charge of the microreactor surface – due to its preparation in a negative surfactant medium – prevented to some extent the diffusion of negative ions in the microreactor, resulting in slow kinetics.22 To demonstrate the quality of the synthesized AuNPs as proof that our approach is viable, we have explored the catalytic reduction of 4-nitrophenol5,23 using these AuNPs after degrading the micromotor body with lipase (see the Experimental section and Fig. S2 in the ESI† for additional control experiments). The experiments clearly demonstrate that these AuNPs have the expected catalytic properties. From the results plotted in Fig. 5B, nearly 100% degradation of 4-nitrophenol was obtained after the “moving micromotors” experiment (bubble), as compared with magnetically stirred micromotors and static conditions. Such results indicate a higher reaction yield and catalytic activity of the AuNPs associated with the enhanced fluid mixing of the moving microreactors. Additional control experiments using Fe microreactors reveal negligible nanoparticle generation, indicating that peroxide alone is not enough to induce nanoparticle synthesis inside the micromotor.
SEM and HRTEM characterization reveals a uniform distribution of Au in its body, with a variable distribution with most of the particles displaying an average size of 20 nm (Fig. 5E, for more details see also the Experimental section). To further demonstrate the advantages of our micromotor/microreactor, we investigate nanoparticle formation in bulk solution by mixing 5 mM gold(III) chloride trihydrate, 3% sodium citrate and 15% hydrogen peroxide (total volume, 800 μL) in the absence of microreactors. Gold nanoparticle formation is observed after 5 min of addition; yet, after 30 min particles tend to aggregate and become unstable (see Fig. S3†). In addition, the 4-nitrophenol test revealed the poor catalytic activity of the as-prepared nanoparticles, with no degradation of the compound (not shown). On the other hand, gold nanoparticles remain stable when synthesized using our micromotor approach, which reveals an additional advantage of our procedure over batch synthesis in the presence of high concentrations of H2O2. Please note here that in experiments conducted with Fe microreactors, no apparent gold nanoparticle formation was observed. This further reveals the microreactor enhanced fluid mixing effect associated with the fast nanoparticle generation.
Interestingly, the reaction rate and catalytic activity of the resulting AuNPs can be modulated by the judicious control of the mobile microreactor motion behavior. For example, the addition of a surfactant to the mixture results in the generation of AuNPs with no apparent catalytic activity as illustrated in Fig. 6A. This can be attributed to the passivation of their surface with the surfactant.24 Further experiments to evaluate the effect of the surrounding media (propelling environment) reveal that AuNPs synthesized with the mobile microreactors at room temperature (25 °C, Fig. 6C and D) display higher catalytic activity than those synthesized with microreactors navigating in water at 100 °C (Fig. 6B). With this data we evaluate the catalytic performance of the catalytic nanoparticles for the reduction of 4-nitrophenol according to the Langmuir–Hinshelwood model. The apparent rate constant (Kapp) was determined from the slope of the linear correlation of ln(At/A0) with time, where At and A0 denotes the absorbance at time t and at the beginning, respectively (see Fig. S4 in the ESI†).25
The reduction of 4-nitrophenol catalyzed by AuNPs synthesized with Au3+ motors followed pseudo-first order kinetics, with apparent rate constants of 0.0004 and 0.0035 s−1 for the experiments conducted at 100 °C and room temperature, respectively. This corresponds to a particle size of about 100 and 20 nm, respectively. For citrate and Au motors (synthesized at 25 °C) similar apparent rate constants were noted for the synthesized nanoparticles. As can be seen, Kapp decreases as the particle size increases, which provides a convenient means to tailor the morphology and requirements of such nanoparticles for an intended application.
Future applications of gold microreactors can be directed to the evaluation of the antioxidant capacity of phenolic compounds and other antioxidants in food26 or to surface enhanced Raman scattering (SERS) sensing schemes for the detection of important analytes. In the latter case, the confinement and aggregation of AuNPs inside the microreactors hold considerable promise to create hot spots for enhanced detection.27 In this work, to prove the synthesis capabilities of our microreactors, we replace citrate with ascorbic acid, which is an essential antioxidant in food and is also involved in cellular functions. Thus, the assessment of such analytes in intracellular and extracellular environments is relevant for disease diagnosis or to ensure food quality. The concept is shown in Fig. 7. We mix the micromotors (loaded with Au3+) with increasing concentrations of ascorbic acid in water and diluted serum samples. As can be seen, after micromotor navigation (24 h) a slight color change is observed in this solution, which is attributed to gold nanoparticle formation following the mechanism depicted in Fig. 7A. To further support such a hypothesis, we treated the motor with lipase and determined the catalytic activity of the as-prepared nanoparticles through the reduction of 4-nitrophenol. As can be seen in Fig. 7B and C, the 4-nitrophenol degradation rate increases along with the concentration of ascorbic acid, indicating a higher yield of nanoparticles at increased concentrations. Such results hold considerable promise for the future application of the micromotor to monitor intracellular events involving ascorbic acid. The concept can also be extended to evaluate the antioxidant capacity of food based on the microreactor triggered gold nanoparticle generation as well as to synthesize tailored AuNPs using natural sources with different properties.
For AuNP synthesis, 200 μL of a solution containing a known amount of gold(III) chloride trihydrate loaded microreactors (4 × 103 micromotors μL−1) was redispersed in 200 μL of 3% sodium citrate (in H2O) or 0–2 M ascorbic acid (in H2O or human serum diluted 1:2). For reverse micromotor configuration, 200 μL of a solution containing a known amount of citrate loaded microreactors was mixed with 200 μL of Au3+ (5 mM). To these solutions were added 400 μL of H2O (for static or magnetic stirring control experiments) or H2O2 (final concentration in the mixture, 15%).
The mixture was retained in the centrifuge tube for 24 h at 25 °C to complete the reaction. This method was compared with the classic synthesis of gold nanoparticles that consists in a reduction chemistry of gold(III) chloride trihydrate with sodium citrate at 100 °C (reaction time, 30 min). Experiments with solutions containing surfactant (sodium cholate, 5%) were performed in a similar fashion. The generation of gold nanoparticles and their catalytic activity were monitored via catalytic reduction of 4-nitrophenol. To this end, 125 μL of aqueous NaBH4 solution (100 mM) was added to 1.5 mL of the 4-nitrophenol solution (100 μM) in a quartz cuvette. 1 mL of gold nanoparticles released from the microreactors after their enzymatic degradation was then added to the mixture. To monitor the reaction progress, the mixture was measured at regular intervals of time (5 min) for 30 minutes with UV-VIS spectrophotometry. The average size of gold nanoparticles was determined by analysing over 150 particles from the TEM images using ImageJ software developed by the National Institutes of Health.
Please note that in both cases we carried out experiments to study the influence of peroxide concentration (over the range of 5 to 20%) on CdS and AuNP formation. Similar results were observed along the entire range; thus peroxide does not have any influence on nanoparticle generation. To adjust the optimal concentration of precursors in the final mixture and minimize the use of reagents and subsequent waste, we adjust the amount of peroxide in each set of experiments.
Footnote |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available: Supporting videos and figures. See DOI: 10.1039/c8sc03681k |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2018 |