Muhammad
Iqbal
abc,
Yusuf Valentino
Kaneti
*a,
Kenji
Kashimura
d,
Masahiro
Yoshino
d,
Bo
Jiang
a,
Cuiling
Li
a,
Brian
Yuliarto
b,
Yoshio
Bando
aef,
Yoshiyuki
Sugahara
c and
Yusuke
Yamauchi
*gh
aInternational Research Center for Materials Nanoarchitectonics (WPI-MANA), National Institute for Materials Science (NIMS), 1-1 Namiki, Tsukuba, Ibaraki 305-0044, Japan. E-mail: KANETI.Valentino@nims.go.jp
bDepartment of Engineering Physics and Research Center for Nanoscience and Nanotechnology, Institute of Technology Bandung, Bandung 40132, Indonesia
cDepartment of Nanoscience and Nanoengineering, Faculty of Science and Engineering, Waseda University, 3-4-1 Okubo, Shinjuku, Tokyo 169-8555, Japan
dR&D Division, Yoshino Denka Kogyo Inc., Saitama 342-0008, Japan
eInstitute of Molecular Plus, Tianjin University, Tianjin 300072, P. R. China
fAustralian Institute for Innovative Materials (AIIM), The University of Wollongong, North Wollongong, NSW 2500, Australia
gSchool of Chemical Engineering and Australian Institute for Bioengineering and Nanotechnology (AIBN), The University of Queensland, Brisbane, QLD 4072, Australia. E-mail: y.yamauchi@uq.edu.au
hDepartment of Plant & Environmental New Resources, Kyung Hee University, 1732 Deogyeong-daero, Giheung-gu, Yongin-si, Gyeonggi-do 446-701, South Korea
First published on 26th February 2019
Mesoporous metallic films have shown enhanced catalytic performance for numerous electrocatalytic applications, such as electrooxidation of liquid fuels (ethanol, methanol, etc.) and biomolecules (glucose, maltose, etc.). Previously, our group has demonstrated the feasible fabrication of mesoporous Pd thin films using low-molecular-weight surfactants as templates (e.g. C. Li, B. Jiang, N. Miyamoto, J. H. Kim, V. Malgras and Y. Yamauchi, J. Am. Chem. Soc. 2015, 137, 11558–11561). However, the resulting pore size is typically limited to 2–10 nm, which may be disadvantageous for practical applications. This work demonstrates a breakthrough in the fabrication of mesoporous palladium (Pd) films with larger and tunable pore sizes from 14 to 41 nm using polymeric micelle-assisted electrochemical deposition. The average pore size of the resulting mesoporous Pd films can be conveniently tuned by employing block copolymers (PS-b-PEO) with different molecular weights. Mesoporous Pd films with larger average pore sizes exhibit higher mass activities for the ethanol oxidation reaction (EOR) than those with smaller average pore sizes along with superior electrocatalytic stability compared to commercially available Pd catalyst. It is anticipated that the proposed soft-templated approach can be extended to the preparation of other mesoporous metallic films for various electrocatalytic applications.
Conceptual insightsThe preparation of traditional mesoporous metallic films generally relies on hard-templating methods. The direct deposition of mesoporous films with metallic frameworks via soft-templating methods is limited to small pores, which are unsuitable for practical applications. Polymeric micelles with large molecular weights can provide mesoporous metallic films with larger open pores. The important factors in the polymeric micelle-assisted electrodeposition of mesoporous metallic films are the appropriate interactions between the metal ion complexes and the outer shell of the micelles in aqueous electrolyte solutions and the appropriate applied deposition potential. Mesoporous metallic films with larger pores possess higher mass-normalized electrochemically active surface areas (ECSAs) compared to those with non-porous metallic films and commercial metallic catalyst. Moreover, the films with larger pores can allow the guest molecules to access the inner region and the products to go out to the outer region more efficiently. In addition, their larger open pores offer more abundant accessible active sites and their unique 3D structure provides better stability against deformation during the electrocatalytic reaction. |
Among noble metals, platinum (Pt) is known as the most catalytically active element. However, its rarity in nature has limited its wider application, and hence many researchers are now seeking to reduce its consumption or to replace it altogether with cheaper materials. As the second most catalytically active element, palladium (Pd) is more abundant and possesses a similar structure to Pt. As such, it has great potential to replace (substitute) completely or partially Pt in various catalytic reactions.16–18 In fact, previous reports have demonstrated the excellent catalytic activity of Pd toward the oxidation of hydrogen or liquid fuels as well as its high selectivity toward the hydrogenation of acetylene.19,20
In recent years, several studies have been reported on the preparation of mesoporous metals by using polymeric micelles assembly. Both mesoporous Pd particles and films have also been reported; however, the pore size was limited to 2–10 nm.21–24 In these studies, cationic and non-ionic surfactants with relatively short chain lengths were used to prepare mesoporous metals. Block copolymers with large chain lengths (high molecular weights) can form larger micelles in solution with diameters ≥10 nm. The selection of a suitable hydrophobic moiety for the block copolymer is critical for ensuring stable interactions between the block copolymer and the Pd ion complexes in water, which in turn will assist the formation of mesoporous Pd films with larger mesopores.
Herein, we report the facile preparation of mesoporous Pd films with controllable large pores using polymeric micelle-assisted electrochemical deposition. The pore size tuning was achieved by utilizing block copolymers with different molecular weights. The electrolyte solution consisted of a Pd precursor and micelles dissolved in a mixture of tetrahydrofuran (THF), ethanol, hydrochloric acid, and water. In this reaction system, THF played an important role in promoting the dissolution of the block copolymer into free unimers in the solution. Subsequent additions of ethanol and water induced the micellization of the block copolymer. The mesoporous Pd films deposited from electrolyte solutions containing PS(5000)-b-PEO(2200), PS(18000)-b-PEO(7500), and PS(63000)-b-PEO(26000) were denoted as meso Pd-2.2, meso Pd-7.5, and meso Pd-26, respectively (the molecular weight for each block is shown in parentheses). To probe the electrocatalytic performance of the as-prepared mesoporous Pd films, ethanol oxidation was selected as the model reaction. The electrocatalytic tests revealed that the as-obtained mesoporous Pd films displayed high electrocatalytic performance for ethanol oxidation, owing to their large surface-active area, open accessible pores, and stable mesoporous structure.
Previously, it was suggested that the incorporation of metal precursors into the micellar solution would not destroy the structure of the micelles.24 The metal precursor would be transformed into water-coordinated metal ion complexes in the micellar solution. UV-vis spectroscopy was employed to observe the interactions between water-coordinated metal ion complexes with the shells of the micelles (Fig. 1a). Initially, a UV-vis spectrum was recorded from the PdCl2 aqueous solution. The absorption peak centered at around 425 nm with a tail on the low energy side is assigned to the d–d transition in the Pd(II) complexes (inset in Fig. 1a). The spectrum indicates the presence of [PdCl4−x(H2O)x](−2+x) (where x varies from 0 to 4) complex species formed by the ligand exchange reaction between coordinated Cl− ions and water molecules in aqueous media.26,27 The charge on the complexes, accordingly, changes from 2− to 2+ with the increase in the number of water molecules (from 0 to 4) entering the coordination sphere of Pd2+ ions.28 The hyperchromic effect is observed in the UV-vis spectrum of the solution containing micelles and PdCl2. The spectrum is shifted upward without any position changes in the absorption peaks (Fig. 1a). The observed hyperchromic effect can be attributed to the existence of interactions between water-coordinated Pd ions and the shells of the micelles. Such interactions have been thought to occur through hydrogen bonding.29
In this work, mesoporous Pd films with different pore sizes were obtained by applying a deposition potential to conductive substrates (working electrodes), as shown in Scheme 1. The deposition potential applied to the Pd films was determined by carefully carrying out negative scan linear sweep voltammetry (LSV) at a slow scan rate from electrolyte solutions containing polymers with different molecular weights (Fig. 1b). The LSV curves confirm the reduction potential of Pd(II) into Pd(0). The plateau region of these LSV plots is observed at around 0.0 V (vs. Ag/AgCl), and hence, this potential was selected as the applied potential for the deposition of mesoporous Pd films. Previously, it was suggested that at a higher applied deposition potential (more positive), the reduction rate of metal ions became slower, which repelled the micelles.30 In contrast, at a lower applied deposition potential (more negative), the reduction rate became faster, which broke down the structure of the micelles.24,31
As discussed earlier, the water-coordinated metal ion complexes are thought to interact with the shells of the micelles through hydrogen bonding. The formation mechanism of the mesoporous Pd films can be described as follows. When an electrical current generated using a potentiostat (using the amperometric i–t technique) is passed through the working electrode, it attracts the metal ion complexes and the micelles to the working electrode. The charge of the metal ion complexes changes from −2 to +2, which is important for their assembly and interactions with the micelle domains. As a result, the negatively charged Cl−-rich metal complexes become attracted to the positively charged water-rich complexes through electrostatic interactions, thus increasing the amount of Pd(II) species in and around the micelles during the electrodeposition of Pd(0). The electrical current enables the reduction of Pd(II) ions to the Pd(0) metal. The number of reduced Pd ions (the deposited Pd) is associated with the charge passing through the working electrode to the electrolyte solution. Subsequently, the Pd metal constructs the pore walls which envelop the micelles as the electrical current passes through the working electrode. The complete removal of the polymeric templates is performed by immersing the deposited films in THF and Pd metallic framework films with mesoporous structures are generated on the substrate (Scheme 1).
The morphologies of the as-prepared films were characterized by SEM (Fig. 2). Both top-view and cross-sectional observations reveal the continuous formation of spherical pores throughout the entire films arranged in a cage-type manner (Fig. 2a1–c1 and a2–c2). Moreover, from the top-view SEM images, the average pore sizes of meso Pd-2.2, meso Pd-7.5, and meso Pd-26 are measured to be 14, 25, and 41 nm, respectively, as statistically calculated from more than 100 pores (Fig. 2a3–c3). Furthermore, the contrast difference in the high-angle annular dark-field scanning TEM (HAADF-STEM) images indicates the porous nature of these films, in which the pores are constructed from the surface of the substrate to the top surface of the films, thereby suggesting the interconnected nature of the pore walls (Fig. 3). The high-resolution TEM (HR-TEM) images depicted in Fig. 4a1–c1 clearly reveal the existence of mesopores in each film, as indicated by the yellow circles. In contrast, no porous structure is observed in the Pd film deposited in the absence of polymeric micelles under similar electrodeposition conditions (Fig. S3, ESI†). This observation suggests that the spherical micelles present in the electrolyte solution play an important role in the formation of mesoporous Pd films.
Thin film XRD was utilized to examine the crystal phase of these films (Fig. 5a). The diffraction patterns of the films with different pore sizes show diffraction peaks located at 40.18°, 46.72°, 68.16°, 82.18° and 86.82°, assigned to the (111), (200), (220), (311) and (222) diffraction planes of Pd with a face-centered cubic (fcc) structure, respectively (JCPDS Card No. 05-0681). Low-angle XRD is a useful technique for characterizing the d-spacing of well-ordered materials. For ordered mesoporous materials, the d-spacing which resulted from low-angle XRD measurements is commonly ascribed to the average distance between adjacent pores. Fig. 5b shows the low-angle XRD diffraction patterns recorded for meso Pd-2.2, meso Pd-7.5, and meso Pd-26. All the diffraction patterns exhibit peaks centered at 0.44°, 0.28°, and 0.15° for meso Pd-2.2, meso Pd-7.5, and meso Pd-26, respectively. The average pore-to-pore distances are estimated to be around 20.1, 31.6, and 58.9 nm for meso Pd-2.2, meso Pd-7.5, and meso Pd-26, respectively. These values are in good agreement with the average pore size and pore wall thickness estimated from the TEM and SEM images, respectively.
The crystallite sizes of meso Pd-2.2, meso Pd-7.5, and meso Pd-26 are estimated using the Scherrer equation to be 5.78, 5.99, and 6.29 nm, respectively, which roughly match the values estimated from the TEM images. The lattice spacing of the three-representative mesoporous Pd films were observed by HR-TEM, as depicted in Fig. 4a2–c2. Typical lattice fringes with a constant d-spacing of 0.224 nm, corresponding to the (111) lattice plane of the fcc Pd crystal, are observed, which is in good agreement with the XRD observation (Fig. 5a). Fig. 5c displays the XPS survey spectra recorded for the meso Pd-2.2, meso Pd-7.5, and meso Pd-26 films. The high-resolution Pd 3d spectrum clearly shows the presence of a doublet with peaks at 336 eV and 341 eV, indexed to metallic Pd 3d5/2 and Pd 3d3/2, respectively (Fig. 5d). However, the absence of the PdO peak in these films indicates that they are composed of pure metallic Pd.
Based on the estimated average pore-to-pore distance and the pore wall thickness, we modeled the pore arrangement in 1000000 nm3 (100 nm × 100 nm × 100 nm) and further estimated the surface area ratio of the pore/void region for the mesoporous films with three different pore sizes (Fig. S4, ESI†). By assuming that the volumetric dimensions of the deposited layer among the three films are identical, the ratio of the Pd surface areas of meso Pd-2.2, meso Pd-7.5, and meso Pd-26 is approximated to be 4:3:2.
An electrochemical approach was employed to estimate the electrochemical active surface area (ECSA) of each mesoporous Pd film by carrying out cyclic voltammetry (CV) in 0.5 M H2SO4 electrolyte from −0.2 to +1.2 V (vs. Ag/AgCl) at a scan rate of 50 mV s−1 (Fig. 6a). The CV curves show the typical hydrogen and oxygen adsorption/desorption features. The ECSA was estimated by calculating the oxide reduction charge assuming that the conversion factor for an oxide monolayer reduction was 420 μC cm−2 on the surface of Pd.32 The ECSA values are 41.49, 32.27, and 21.75 cm2 for the meso Pd-2.2, meso Pd-7.5, and meso Pd-26 films with the very similar film thickness (∼500 nm), respectively, and these values closely match the surface area ratio of the films with three different average pore sizes estimated from the model (Fig. S4, ESI†). Clearly, meso Pd-2.2 has the largest ECSA since its pore size is relatively smaller than those of meso Pd-7.5 and meso Pd-26, implying that larger mesopores lead to smaller ECSA. When the ECSA is normalized with the respective deposited Pd mass, the mass-normalized ECSA for meso Pd-26 is larger (90.61 m2 g−1) than those of meso Pd-2.2 (40.28 m2 g−1) and meso Pd-7.5 (33.92 m2 g−1). Furthermore, the mass-normalized ECSA values of the mesoporous Pd films are obviously higher than those of the non-porous Pd film (11.38 m2 g−1) and commercially available Pd black, abbreviated as PdB (14.52 m2 g−1). The ECSA of meso Pd-26 linearly increases with the increase of film thickness (Fig. 6b, black line). Even when the ECSA values of the meso Pd-26 films with various thicknesses are divided by their respective geometric volumes, the volume-normalized ECSA values are relatively similar (Fig. 6b, blue line), suggesting that the large surface area derived from the mesoporous structure is fully accessible.
Electrooxidation of small organic molecules by noble metal catalysts is an important reaction in electrochemical energy conversion devices, such as direct alcohol fuel cells.33 The anodes on such devices typically require highly active and stable catalysts to ensure their good performance and durability to poisoning reaction intermediate products, such as carbon monoxide (CO), as well as deformation of the surface morphology.34 In this work, we carried out electrocatalytic tests of the meso Pd-2.2, meso Pd-7.5, and meso Pd-26 films toward the ethanol oxidation reaction (EOR) as the model reaction. For performance comparison, the non-porous Pd film and commercial PdB were also tested for the electrocatalytic EOR. The CV curves were recorded in 1.0 M KOH containing 1.0 M C2H5OH at a scan rate of 50 mV s−1 in the potential window of −0.8 V to +0.3 V (vs. SCE). All the mass-normalized CV curves clearly show the characteristics of the EOR in the forward and backward scans (Fig. 6c). The peak current density (mass-activity) of the meso Pd-26 film in positive sweep (1.82 A mg−1_Pd) is larger than those of the non-porous Pd film (0.32 A mg−1_Pd), PdB (0.52 A mg−1_Pd), and other mesoporous Pd films (meso Pd-2.2 and meso Pd-7.5). In addition, the ECSA-normalized CV curves show that the mesoporous Pd films show very high specific activity, compared to the non-porous Pd film and PdB. In spite of the different average pore sizes, the specific activities for all the mesoporous Pd films are almost similar (Fig. 6d). This implies that the stepped and kinked atomic arrangements of the mesoporous structures can significantly enhance the electrocatalytic activity of the catalyst.35
These results suggest that the large and open pores exhibited by the meso Pd-26 film are beneficial for providing better mass transport for the reactants and products from and to the electrolyte. To prove this, we have carried out additional CV measurements at various scan rates (Fig. S5a–c, ESI†). The diffusion efficiency of guest molecule species inside the mesopores can be determined by plotting the forward oxidation peak current densities versus the square root of the scan rates obtained from the CVs of the mesoporous Pd films with the three different average pore sizes.36 The slope value for the meso Pd-26 film is larger than those for the meso Pd-2.2 and meso Pd-7.5 films (Fig. S5d, ESI†), indicating that the diffusivity of ethanol molecules inside larger mesopores is higher than that inside smaller mesopores.37 To assess their stability, a chronoamperometry test was carried out in 1 M KOH containing 1.0 M C2H5OH at a constant potential of −0.1 V (vs. SCE) for 1500 s (Fig. S6a, ESI†). The current density of meso Pd-26 remains higher than those of the non-porous Pd film and PdB even after a long run of the stability test. The superior stability of meso Pd-26 can be attributed to its mesoporous architectures, which are beneficial for preventing aggregation or morphological deformation (Fig. S6b and c, ESI†).38
Footnote |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available. See DOI: 10.1039/c8nh00507a |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2019 |