Yiding Maa,
Yingzhe Liub,
Tao Yubc,
Weipeng Laib,
Zhongxue Ge*b and
Zhenyi Jiang*d
aXi'an Modern Chemistry Research Institution, Xi'an 710065, China. E-mail: yiding@mail.ustc.edu.cn
bXi'an Modern Chemistry Research Institution, Xi'an 710065, China
cSchool of Chemistry and Chemical Engineering, Southeast University, Nanjing, China
dSchool of Physics Northwest University, Xi'an, China
First published on 22nd January 2019
A comprehensive study of the effect of the structure of pendant chains on the energetic and mechanical properties of nitramino oxetane polymers has been conducted. Enthalpy of formation (EOF), density, glass transition temperature, and elastic moduli were calculated via quantum mechanics and molecular dynamic simulations. It is shown in this study that –CH2 groups are unfavorable for EOFs, densities, and elastic moduli of the polymers, whereas –NCH3NO2 groups are favorable for these parameters. The glass transition temperature (Tg) shows non-monotonic features with increasing –CH2 groups; it reaches a minimum value when the pendant chains consist of 1 or 2 –CH2 groups. Moreover, the location of the pendant chains can strongly affect Tg of the polymers. Our study suggests that the asymmetric structure, distantly located pendant chains and appropriate length of the pendant chains can effectively reduce Tg of the polymers with negligible compromise to other properties.
A feasible method of designing an energetic polymeric binder is to “decorate” the polymer chain with energetic groups, such as azido or nitramino groups, on the side chains. Some energetic polymeric binders have been synthesized and applied in recent years.13–15 Among these, nitramino oxetane polymers are potential candidates as next-generation energetic binders since the nitramine groups provide good amount of energy and good compatibility with widely used energetic additives in propellants and explosives, whereas the oxetane backbone provides flexibility and good mechanical properties to the polymer.
Due to safety concerns and limitations of experimental techniques, so far, only a few studies have been reported on nitramino oxetane polymers. Poly(3-methylnitramino methyl-3-methyl oxetane) (PMNAMMO) and poly(bis-(3-methyl nitramino-methyl)oxetane) (PBMNAMO) were first synthesized by Manser;15 the structural and decomposition features of PMNAMMO and PBMNAMO were measured.16,17 These polymers are considered to be suitable ingredients of energetic binders in rocket propellants,18 aluminized explosives,19 energetic elastomers,20 and gas-generating materials.21 In practical applications, researchers and engineers often pay attention to the enthalpy of formation (EOF),22 glass transition temperature (Tg),23 and mechanical properties24 of the polymeric binders. However, to date, only PMNAMMO and PBMNAMO have been synthesized and reported in experiments with theoretical values of their enthalpies of formation, whereas few tests are reported about their mechanical properties and glass transition temperatures. EOF represents the energy contained in the polymeric binder, Tg is the temperature range of applications of the polymeric binders, where they act as elastic rubbers rather than fragile solids, and the mechanical properties of the polymeric binders are significant in the application of energetic materials. For the application of nitramino oxetane polymers, these properties should be comprehensively investigated. Moreover, for effectively seeking new and applicable energetic binders, we require a systematic investigation of the structure–property relationship of nitramino oxetane polymers. It is known that the structure of pendant chains can remarkably affect the properties of the polymers. The length and the location of the pendant chains are closely related to the flexibility and entanglement of the polymers; also, the substituent group on the pendant chains can affect the polarity and other properties of the polymer. For example, PBMNAMO has an additional methylnitramino group compared to PMNAMMO; therefore, it is considered to be more energetic than PMNAMMO. Due to the symmetrical structure of PBMNAMO, it is assumed to be easy to crystallize and less flexible, which makes it a potential candidate for the “hard segment” of thermoplastic elastomers.25
Computer simulations have been testified to be effective and reliable in the prediction of properties of materials;26–38 means such as quantum mechanics26–28 and molecular dynamics29–38 allow high-flux designing and screening of new materials at lower costs compared to one-by-one experimentation. Dorofeeva27 calculated the enthalpy of formation of hexanitrohexaazaisowurtzitane (CL-20) using the quantum mechanics method; the results showed good consistency with those of the experiments. The mechanical and thermal properties of polymers can be predicted by molecular dynamic simulations.31 In this study, we combine quantum mechanics and molecular dynamic methods to study both the energetic and mechanical properties of nitramino oxetane polymers. A comprehensive investigation of the effect of pendant chains on the properties of the polymers has been conducted.
Fig. 1 The naming of nitramino oxetanes; “N” and “H” represent the terminating groups of each pendant chain, and the number before them shows the length of the alkyl chains. |
According to Fox–Flory's free volume theory, there is a turning point around Tg where the specific volume of polymers decreases more rapidly with decreasing temperature. Thus, as shown in Fig. 2, we investigated the temperature dependence of the specific volume of the polymers in the range of 400–100 K, and Tg was determined by the changing point of the specific volume–temperature plot. To determine the cooling rate, we conducted simulations at the cooling rates of 15 K/200 ps and 10 K/200 ps; the results (Fig. 2) showed that the Tg values in these cooling rates are very close. Therefore, considering the accuracy and the cost of computations, we chose 15 K/200 ps as the cooling rate for the systems in our study. The uncertainty of Tg data in our study was about ±15 K (5%).
Mechanical properties are characterized by the elastic moduli and Poisson's ratio. The parameters are calculated on the basis of the Hooke's law (eqn (1) and (2)) by applying 0.5% deformation to the systems under 298 K and atmospheric pressure. The elastic moduli are calculated according to eqn (3) [Cij] is the elastic coefficient matrix containing 36 elements, and Lame coefficients (λ and μ) were introduced (C12 = λ, C11–C12 = 2μ).
σi = Cijεj, i, j = 1,…6 | (1) |
(2) |
(3) |
On the other hand, Tg of the polymers shows a non-monotonic feature when the pendant chains grow longer: Tg decreases at first, reaches a minimum value when the pendant chains contain 1–2 alkyl groups, and then increases with further increase in the length of the pendant chains. According to the free volume theory, the free volume of the system increases with the introduction of additional –CH2 groups, which benefits the flexibility of the polymers, and Tg tends to decrease. At the same time, the size of the pendant chains increases and the rotation barriers of the main chains of the polymers rise due to the steric hindrance between the pendant chains and other segments of the polymers. When the pendant chains are short, the introduction of extra free volume is the dominant effect in the flexibility of the polymers. Thus Tg decreases with increasing length of the pendant chains; with longer pendant chains, the steric hindrance is dominant, the polymers become less flexible and therefore, Tg increases. This suggestion is also supported by the comparison of the isomers, for example, 3N0H, 2N1H, 1N2H and 0N3H. When the –CH2 groups are displaced in two shorter side chains rather than in a single pendant chain, the free spaces in the systems are almost the same, whereas the steric hindrance of the free rotation of the polymer main chain is lower; hence, lower Tg is obtained. Please note that the polymers of symmetrical structures, i.e., 0N0N, 1N1N, 2N2N, and 3N3N do not obey such a trend; they have significantly higher Tg than the polymers having more or less –CH2 groups and have higher Tg than their isomers. The symmetric polymers are easy to crystallize; the chains in the crystalline region are folded and regularly arranged so that the chain segments can only move freely at higher temperatures. This is consistent with the difference between PBAMO and PAMMO;43,44 PBAMO is easy to crystallize and PAMMO is a flexible polymer, and the Tg values of two polymers are 246 K and 238 K, respectively.
The mechanical properties were characterized by the Young's modulus (E), bulk modulus (K), shear modulus (G), and Poisson's ratio, which indicate the capacity of tensile elasticity, incompressibility, rigidity, and the lateral deformation of the materials, respectively. The results are displayed in Fig. 4, and the uncertainty of the data of polymer mechanical properties is less than 5%. The Poisson's ratios of all the designed polymers are about 0.3, indicating good plastic properties.
It is shown that E, K, and G decrease monotonously with increasing number of –CH2 groups. The rubbery features of polymeric binders originate from their long and entangled main chains. When the pendant chains grow longer, the fraction of the main chains becomes lower and the entanglement of the chains becomes weaker with additional free volume, thus lowering the moduli.
Fig. 4 also shows that polymers with –NCH3NO2 groups exhibit significantly higher moduli. The polarity of –NCH3NO2 groups may account for this result since the polymers are polarized by more –NCH3NO2 groups and the electrostatic interactions between the molecules are stronger, thus making the materials more resistant to elastic deformations. Combining the result in Fig. 4 and the data of Tg, we can see that PBMNAMO has higher elastic moduli, higher Tg and tendency to crystallize, indicating that PBMNAMO is a suitable choice for the “hard segment” of thermoplastic elastomers. On the other hand, PMNAMMO has better flexibility and is suitable for the “soft segment” of thermoplastic elastomers. In practice, PBMNAMO and PMNAMMO are used as described above.20
As is well-known, the density of the energetic binder is an important parameter since it is closely related to the density and solid content of solid propellants and explosives; thus, high energy density can be achieved by applying the binder with high density. The uncertainty of the calculated densities is about 7%. As shown in Table 1, irrespective of termination with nitramine groups, when the number of alkyl groups increases, the densities of the polymers decrease. When the pendant chains grow longer, additional degrees of freedom are introduced into the system and the free volume between polymer chains increases; therefore, the densities of the polymers decrease due to volume exclusion effects. Interestingly, the densities of the isomers, such as 3N0H, 2N1H, 1N2H, and 0N3H, are almost the same considering the uncertainty of the calculation, suggesting that the densities of the polymers are more sensitive to the number of alkyl groups rather than their location. Moreover, the densities of the polymers containing more nitramine groups are higher because the intermolecular interactions increase with the number of nitramine groups due to increasing polarity.
Polymer | ρ (g cm−3) | ΔHf (kJ mol−1) | Q (kJ mol−1) |
---|---|---|---|
0N0H | 1.27 | −90.5 | 634.9 |
0N1H | 1.22 | −115.1 | 610.1 |
0N2H | 1.19 | −120.6 | 603.9 |
0N3H | 1.15 | −134.0 | 591.5 |
1N0H | 1.22 | −132.0 | 593.3 |
1N1H | 1.18 | −147.1 | 578.4 |
1N2H | 1.15 | −152.7 | 572.4 |
1N3H | 1.12 | −165.5 | 559.6 |
2N0H | 1.18 | −146.3 | 581.0 |
2N1H | 1.14 | −157.0 | 568.2 |
2N2H | 1.12 | −164.4 | 560.5 |
2N3H | 1.09 | −173.6 | 551.5 |
3N0H | 1.14 | −159.2 | 566.4 |
3N1H | 1.12 | −174.3 | 553.4 |
3N2H | 1.09 | −178.1 | 545.3 |
3N3H | 1.07 | −190.4 | 535.1 |
0N0N | 1.66 | −9.1 | 1200.1 |
0N1N | 1.37 | −52.8 | 1156.4 |
0N2N | 1.30 | −70.6 | 1138.6 |
0N3N | 1.27 | −87.8 | 1121.4 |
1N1N | 1.31 | −94.6 | 1114.3 |
1N2N | 1.26 | −115.6 | 1093.6 |
1N3N | 1.23 | −128.1 | 1081.2 |
2N2N | 1.22 | −120.7 | 1088.5 |
2N3N | 1.19 | −141.3 | 1068 |
3N3N | 1.16 | −154.1 | 1055 |
The energetic features distinguish the energetic binders from traditional binders, providing the propellants and explosives with higher energy density and better performances. Here, we chose EOF and heat of detonation as representative parameters of the energetic features. As shown in Table 1, EOFs of the polymers decrease monotonously when the number of –CH2 groups increase, and the heats of detonation of the polymers decrease with additional –CH2 groups accordingly, indicating that the –CH2 group is unfavorable for the energy of the polymers. On the other hand, the –NCH3NO2 group positively contributes about 40 kJ mol−1 to EOFs of the polymers, which does not seem significant; however, it also contributes about 540 kJ mol−1 to the heat of detonation of the polymers, which indicates that the –NCH3NO2 groups are the main source of energy of the polymers.
The location of the pendant chains is another important factor affecting the properties of polymeric binders; they occupy a large space in the system and can be decisive in the flexibility of the polymers. We designed isomers of PBMNAMO by altering the location of two pendant chains (P11–P13, Fig. 5), and we investigated their energetic and mechanical properties, as shown in Table 2. As can be easily understood, the free volume and the energy contributions induced by the pendant chains are almost the same in all the isomers; thus, the densities and EOFs are not significantly affected, as is shown by the data in Table 2. The flexibility of the polymers can be strongly affected due to the difference in the rotation barriers of the main chains of the isomers: the pendant chains in P13 are most distantly located from each other, and the rotation of the main chain is negligibly affected by them; the pendant chains of PBMNAMO and P11 are grafted from the α- and β-carbons of the oxygen atom, respectively. When the main chains of the polymers rotate, the two pendant chains make no contact with each other, but the rotation barriers rise because of the large occupied space of the α- and β-carbons. Hence, PBMNAMO and P11 have similar and higher Tg values. The rotation energies of α- and β-carbon bonds of the isomers are shown in Fig. 6; the energy barriers are 26.5 kJ mol−1, 83.7 kJ mol−1, 19.9 kJ mol−1, and 47.4 kJ mol−1 for P11, P12, P13, and PBMNAMO, respectively. The pendant chains of P13 strongly hinder the rotation of the bonds of α- and β-carbons due to volume exclusion effects, and Tg of P13 is significantly higher than that of other isomers. On the other hand, the elastic moduli of more flexible polymers are lower. We can see that the Tg values of the polymers can be lowered by 14 K by modifying the sites where the pendant chains are located, with negligible compromise of the mechanical properties while maintaining the energy density of the binder.
Polymer | ρ (g cm−3) | ΔHf (kJ mol−1) | Tg (K) | E (GPa) | K (GPa) | G (GPa) | γ |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
PBMNAMO | 1.29 | −94.6 | 274 | 4.01 | 2.98 | 1.56 | 0.28 |
P11 | 1.28 | −92.2 | 274 | 3.91 | 2.86 | 1.48 | 0.28 |
P12 | 1.29 | −96.3 | 307 | 4.47 | 3.17 | 1.72 | 0.27 |
P13 | 1.28 | −95.5 | 260 | 2.75 | 2.67 | 1.28 | 0.32 |
(1) Tg of the polymers against the number of –CH2 groups showed a non-monotonic trend, having a minimum value when the length of the pendant chains contained 1–2 –CH2 groups and the –CH2 groups were equally displaced in two pendant chains.
(2) The introduction of –CH2 groups is not favorable to the densities, EOFs, and elastic moduli of the polymers, whereas the –NCH3NO2 group is the main contributor to EOFs and increases the densities and elastic moduli of the polymers.
(3) Tg of polymers can be significantly lowered by modifying the grafting sites of the pendant chains while maintaining energy density.
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2019 |