Ningze Zhuoabc,
Na Zhangbc,
Peng Chen*a and
Haibo Wang*bc
aSchool of Electronic Science and Engineering, Nanjing University, Nanjing 210093, China. E-mail: pchen@nju.edu.cn
bInstitute of Optoelectronic Materials of Light Industry, Nanjing 210015, China. E-mail: wanghaibo88@163.com
cResearch Institute of Electric Light Source Materials, Nanjing Tech University, Nanjing 210015, China
First published on 9th September 2019
Red phosphor thin films (PTFs) with different MgO nanoparticle concentrations for near-ultraviolet (NUV) LEDs were prepared based on their strong scattering effect; red LEDs and laminated white LEDs were packaged further. SEM and XRD showed that CaAlSiN3:Eu2+ (CASN) and MgO nanoparticles were uniformly distributed in silicone resin and their crystal structure remained unchanged. The phosphor conversion efficiency (PCE) had a maximum value of 83.15% when the MgO nanoparticle concentration was 15 wt%. An increase of concentration can improve the spatial distribution uniformity of photonics for 410 nm, 627 nm and 660 nm. Fluorescence lifetime showed that the value is positively correlated with concentration change. The packaged red LED luminous flux reaches a maximum of 20.337 lm at a concentration of 15 wt%. The laminated white LED showed that the MgO nanoparticle concentration can be used to adjust the correlated color temperature (CCT) from 4322 K to 1987 K. Under similar CCT, the red phosphor concentration is only 1.83 wt%, the dosage is reduced by 56.12%, and the corresponding luminous efficiency of radiation (LER) and luminous efficiency (LE) are 296.03 lm W−1 and 73.72 lm W−1 respectively. The increase was 11.42%, the decrease was 10.14%, the color rendering index (CRI) increased from 90.6 to 91.8, and CCT uniformity increased from 82.04% to 89.27% with an increase of 8.81%. Research shows that MgO nanoparticles have potential application value in the preparation of high-quality white LEDs.
As phosphor conversion materials,12–14 PTFs can convert the absorbed photons into an emission spectrum with specific energy distribution. With wide application range, in the display field,15,16 PTFs can effectively improve color uniformity and light extraction efficiency of fluorescent screens; in the field of photovoltaics,17,18 they can effectively improve utilization efficiency of solar energy; in the field of solid-state lighting,19,20 also known as remote phosphors, they have the advantages of improving uniformity and photo-thermal stability.21–23 Researchers have used a variety of methods to further optimize the performance of PTF-based white LEDs, such as surface plasmons,24 gradient index design,25 graphical processing,26–29 free-form surface design,30 polarization effect31 and so on. Kwon24 enhanced luminescence properties by combining a waveguiding ZnO-based nanostructure with plasmonic Au nanoparticles of PTFs, and improved the LE of white LEDs by 18%. Xu25 prepared phosphor in glass with gradient refractive index structure by screen printing, breaking the total reflection effect in the process of photon propagation, and the LE was improved by 7.81%. Kim26 used the nano-texture technology of glass substrate to obtain PTFs with patterned structure, improving the efficiency by 16%, and the simulated result showed that a large amount of light was scattered from the patterned structure. Li30 improved the uniformity of PTFs by 26.2% through the design of a double free-form surface. In addition to the above methods, nanoparticles have a great advantage in improving white LED light color performance due to their strong scattering effect.32–36 Tang32 introduced inorganic ZnO scattering particles through quantum dots, the dispensing method achieving a 3.37% improvement in QD-LED efficiency. The CCT difference from 862 K to 712 K is reduced from −70° to 70°. Chen33 reported the use of ZrO2 nanoparticles; the luminous flux is increased by 12% at a concentration of 1 wt% and the CCT difference is reduced from 522 K to 7 K when the concentration is increased to 10%.
The aforementioned studies are mostly limited to blue LED chips, and a single type of PTF or phosphor. Different from the above research, in this paper, red PTFs with MgO nanoparticles for laminated NUV white LEDs are used as the research object, systematically exploring the regularity of microstructure, reflectivity and transmittance, PCE, fluorescence lifetime of PTFs, LE and CCT uniformity of packaged red LED and laminated white light LED. It is found that the scattering effect of MgO nanoparticles can effectively improve the PCEs of PTFs and luminous flux of red LEDs. In the application of laminated white LEDs, the CCT regulation can be controlled by the adjustment of MgO nanoparticle concentration; the incorporation of MgO nanoparticles can effectively improve the CCT uniformity, and save a large amount of red phosphor, which has the obvious advantage of reducing the production cost.
Fig. 2 (a) PTFs with different CSAN and MgO nanoparticle concentrations. (b) Micrograph of PTF with CASN (4.17 wt%) and MgO nanoparticles (15.0 wt%). |
Fig. 3 shows XRD patterns of red PTFs of different CSAN and MgO nanoparticle concentrations. The MgO nanoparticle crystal form used belongs to periclase, corresponding to a cubic system, and the space group is Fmm. The pattern is matched with standard card PDF#77-2179. It can be seen from the figure that as the concentration increases, the positions of the diffraction peaks for the CASN and MgO nanoparticles remain unchanged, indicating that the crystal structures have not changed during the incorporation of MgO nanoparticles and the process of PTF formation.
Fig. 4 shows the optical parameters of PTFs obtained by double-integral sphere. The lasers used are a 410 nm NUV laser and a 660 nm red laser. 410 nm is close to the NUV LED chip peak (415 nm) to measure the reflectance and transmittance of phosphor emission light. For the PCE of PTFs, the specific formula is as in eqn (1).37 660 nm is used to measure the optical properties of PTFs for long-wavelength red light outside the excitation spectrum. It can be seen from Fig. 4(a) that as the MgO nanoparticle concentration increases, the reflectance at 660 nm increases and the transmittances decrease. Since the CASN excitation spectrum has no absorption effect at 660 nm, the decrease is related to the scattering loss of the PTF. In Fig. 4(b) and (c), as the MgO nanoparticle concentration increases, the reflectance at 410 nm increases, the intensities of the reflected phosphor emission light increase first and then decrease, the transmittances at 410 nm decrease, and the transmitted light of phosphor gradually increases. In saturation, the PCEs in Fig. 4(d) first rise and then fall, which has the highest value of 83.15% at a concentration of 15.0 wt%. The relevant change mechanism can be explained by Fig. 8.
(1) |
Fig. 4 Reflectance and transmittance of (a) 410 nm, (b) 627 nm, (c) 660 nm and (d) PCE of PTFs with different CSAN and MgO nanoparticle concentrations. |
Fig. 5(a–c) shows light scattering distribution of 410 nm LD, phosphor emission light at 627 nm and 660 nm LD by PTFs with different CSAN and MgO nanoparticle concentrations. Fig. 5(d) shows the scattering distribution characteristics of CASN and MgO nanoparticles to photons of 410 nm, 627 nm and 660 nm calculated based on Mie theory. Fig. 5(a) and (c) have similar trends, in the concentration range of 0.00 wt% to 10.0 wt%, and there is a peak in the range of ±10° of the scattered light intensity, that is, the main forward transmission is dominant at low concentration, but as the concentration increases, the scattered light intensity gradually becomes smooth, which is attributed to the scattering effect of the MgO nanoparticles. The intensity gradually increases in the range of 90–140° backscattering, which corresponds to the result of Fig. 4. Further, in combination with Fig. 5(d), it can be seen that the CASN also has scattering peaks in a small angle range. The phenomenon may be due to the particle size of up to 18.7 μm, for the propagating photons, which is similar to the lens. The light is concentrated in the range of the forward small angle. Due to the small particle size, the MgO nanoparticles have a diffraction effect on the photon propagation process, and strengths of forward and backward scattering are close. Fig. 5(b) is a light distribution diagram of phosphor emission light. There is also a peak phenomenon in the range of ±10°, the peak gradually disappears as the concentration increases, and before and after the critical angle of ±90°, the forward and backward intensities are close to each other, which indicates that the luminescence of phosphor is isotropic. The phosphor emission light intensity reaches the highest value at a concentration of 15 wt%.
Fig. 6 shows the fluorescence lifetimes of PTFs at MgO nanoparticle concentrations of 0.00 wt%, 15.0 wt%, and 30.0 wt%. After a certain substance is excited and then fluoresces, and then the excitation light is removed, the fluorescence lifetime is the time for the fluorescence intensity to gradually decrease to 1/e of the maximum intensity fluorescence I0. The time can be used as a reference for the existence of energy transfer phenomena inside the material. According to the test results, a single exponential function fitting is performed to obtain the corresponding fluorescence lifetimes which are 629.68 ns, 617.11 ns and 615.25 ns, respectively. It can be seen that as the concentration increases, the fluorescence lifetime decreases, which may be due to the scattering effect increased by MgO nanoparticle concentration. The probability of Eu2+ being excited increases, owing to an overlapping and self-absorption effect of excitation and emission spectra, and the energy transfer occurs in the luminescence center Eu2+–Eu2+, resulting in a shorter fluorescence lifetime.38,39
Fig. 6 Fluorescence lifetimes of PTFs at MgO nanoparticle concentrations of 0.00 wt%, 15.0 wt%, and 30.0 wt%. |
Fig. 7 is a graph showing the corresponding luminous flux and red/NUV ratios of red LEDs prepared according to Fig. 1 at different MgO nanoparticle concentrations. As can be seen from the figure, the overall variation of luminous flux is similar to that of Fig. 4(d), and there is a maximum value of 20.337 lm at 15.0 wt%. The red/NUV ratio maintains an upward tendency, which indicates that the red emission intensity is always greater than that of the NUV light.
Fig. 7 Luminous efficiency and red/NUV ratios of red LEDs prepared using PTFs with different MgO nanoparticle concentrations. |
The regularity of PTFs and red LEDs and mechanism in Fig. 4–7 can be explained by the schematic diagram of photon propagation in the PTFs shown in Fig. 8. The regions A, B, and C indicate the PTFs without MgO nanoparticles (0.00 wt%), and with concentrations of (1.67 wt%, 5.00 wt%, 10.0 wt%, 15.0 wt%) and (20.0 wt%, 25.0 wt%, 30.0 wt%) respectively. In region A, when MgO nanoparticles are not incorporated, NUV (Ray ①) can easily penetrate the PTF due to the low phosphor concentration, and the propagation mode is mainly the forward transmission, and the emission of the phosphor (Rays ③, ④) spreads in an isotropic manner. In region B, when MgO nanoparticles are doped, the direction of light propagation changes, and the absorption of NUV light and the forward transmission red emission light intensity increase significantly, mainly because the scattering effect of MgO nanoparticles improves the absorption probability of NUV light by the phosphor (Rays ⑧, ⑪) and red light forward transmission (Ray ⑩). The increase in the probability of NUV light retroreflection (Rays ⑥, ⑦) is due to the increase refractive index of PTFs,33,40 as shown by the formula (2)–(5), enhancing the probability of total reflection of NUV light at the air interface, as shown by the formula (6) and (7), so the overall performance is that the retroreflective intensity of NUV light is enhanced, and forward transmission intensity is reduced.
nPTF = χPhopshornPhopshor + χMgOnMgO + χSiliconnSilicon | (2) |
nPTF = C + χMgOnMgO | (3) |
Fig. 8 Schematic diagram of light propagation direction in PTF at different MgO nanoparticle concentrations. |
The relationship of χMgO with the MgO nanoparticle concentration cMgO satisfies the following:
(4) |
In the formula, N(r)MgO and ρMgO represent the concentration distribution function and the density of MgO nanoparticles which are constants, and the simultaneous eqn (3) and (4) are obtained:
(5) |
It can be seen that the refractive index of the PTF is positively correlated with the MgO nanoparticle concentration.
The propagation of light at the interface between the PTF and the air satisfies the law of total reflection:
nPTFsinα1 = nAirsinα2 | (6) |
(7) |
It is known that the refractive index of air is 1, so the combination formula (7) shows that as the MgO nanoparticle concentration increases, the critical angle of total reflection decreases, and the probability of total reflection increases.
In region C, when the amount of MgO nanoparticles incorporated reaches a certain value, MgO nanoparticles will form an agglomeration on the phosphor. On the one hand, the MgO cluster will generate multiple scattering (Ray ⑬) to the excitation light, and on the other hand, the phosphor emission light (Ray ⑮) will fall into the MgO cluster, and multiple scattering direct energy depletion will occur, resulting in a decrease in the total optical power of the red emission light. At the same time, according to the formulas (5) and (7), the PTF refractive index continues to increase, the reflection phenomenon on the interface is enhanced, and the retroreflective intensity of NUV light is gradually increased.
Fig. 9 and 10 show corresponding CCTs, LEs, CRI and spectral distribution curves of different MgO nanoparticle concentrations for laminated white LEDs prepared according to Fig. 1(b). It can be seen that the CCTs and LEs decrease with increasing concentration, and the light source apparent color in the illustration changed gradually from positive white to red, indicating that the control of white LED color can be achieved by changing the MgO nanoparticle concentration. The CRI is greater than 90 for the mass fraction of 0 wt% to 10 wt%, and its value becomes gradually lower than 90 with increasing MgO nanoparticle concentration and red phosphor emission light intensity. The spectral distribution curve in Fig. 10 can be used to explain this phenomenon. In the figure, the red light intensity first rises and then falls, with the largest value at 15.0 wt%. The light source color changed gradually from positive white to red because the increasing red light intensity is higher than the blue and green light amplitude. The change of luminous efficiency can be explained by formula (8). In the range of visual efficiency curve of the visible spectrum, as the concentration increases, the green light intensity gradually decreases, although the red light intensity gradually increases, but away from the maximum peak of 555 nm, so the luminous efficiency is gradually reduced according to the formula.
(8) |
Fig. 9 Trends of CCT, LE and CRI of laminated white LEDs under different MgO nanoparticle concentrations. |
Fig. 10 Spectral distribution curves of laminated white LEDs under different MgO nanoparticle concentrations. |
In order to more objectively evaluate the influence of MgO nanoparticles on laminated white LEDs, under similar color temperature conditions, we select an incorporated MgO nanoparticle concentration of 15 wt%, and adjust the red phosphor concentration to achieve white LED performance regulation. According to the experiment, references 1, 2, and 3 in Fig. 11 respectively represent CCT, LER, and LE values of laminated white LED prepared by red phosphor (4.17 wt%) without MgO nanoparticles incorporated. When the red phosphor concentration is 1.83 wt%, the CCT of white LED is 4243 K, which is 79 K different from the reference 4322 K. The corresponding LER and LE are 296.03 lm W−1 and 73.72 lm W−1 respectively. In the figure, the three indicators gradually decrease with the increase of red phosphor. This phenomenon can also be explained by the spectral distribution curve of Fig. 12, and its trend is similar to that of Fig. 9. In Fig. 12, as the red phosphor concentration increases, the red luminescence intensity increases, the green luminescence intensity decreases, so the corresponding CCT and LE decrease, while the LER is higher than that of the reference light source before the concentration of 3.33 wt%, which indicates that the relative green emission ratio that promotes the luminous flux before this concentration is relatively high. After this concentration, since the red phosphor concentration is too high, NUV light is greatly absorbed and converted into red light, causing a decrease in the relative amount of NUV intensity for exciting green phosphor. It can be seen from the figure that under similar CCT conditions, the red phosphor amount is reduced from 4.17 wt% to 1.83 wt%, and the saving amount reaches 56.12%. At this time, LER and LE are 296.03 lm W−1 and 73.72 lm W−1 respectively. Compared with the reference value, the increase was 11.42%, the decrease was 10.14%, and the CRI increased from 90.6 to 91.8.
(9) |
Fig. 12 Spectral distribution curves of laminated white LEDs under different red phosphor concentrations. |
Fig. 13 and 14 respectively show the light distribution curve and CCT uniformity of laminated white LEDs corresponding to MgO nanoparticle concentration of 0.00 wt% (none incorporated) and 15.0 wt% (incorporated). It can be seen from Fig. 13 that the distribution of the two light sources is still of Lambertian type (that is, the luminous intensity has a cosine distribution as a function of angle). In Fig. 14, in the range of −75° to 75°, the CCT range of none incorporated is 843 K, the CCT uniformity is 82.04%; the CCT range of doped type is 474 K, the CCT uniformity is 89.27%, showing 8.81% increases.
Fig. 13 Light distribution curve of laminated white LEDs corresponding to MgO nanoparticle concentration of 0.00 wt% (none incorporated) and 15.0 wt% (incorporated). |
Fig. 14 CCT uniformity of laminated white LEDs corresponding to MgO nanoparticle concentration of 0.00 wt% (none incorporated) and 15.0 wt% (incorporated). |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2019 |