Ulrike
Reisacher
a,
Damian
Ploschik
a,
Franziska
Rönicke
a,
Gergely B.
Cserép
b,
Péter
Kele
b and
Hans-Achim
Wagenknecht
*a
aInstitute of Organic Chemistry, Karlsruhe Institute of Technology (KIT), Fritz-Haber-Weg 6, 76131 Karlsruhe, Germany. E-mail: Wagenknecht@kit.edu
bChemical Biology Research Group, Institute of Organic Chemistry, Research Centre for Natural Sciences, Hungarian Academy of Sciences, Magyar tudósok krt. 2, H-1117 Budapest, Hungary
First published on 4th March 2019
Two different and small functions for inverse electron demand Diels–Alder reactions were applied for dual labeling of DNA: the 1,2,4-triazine was attached to the 5-position of 2′-deoxyuridine triphosphate, and the 1-methylcyclopropene to the 7-position of 7-deaza-2′-deoxyadenosine triphosphate. These two modified nucleotides were sequence-selectively incorporated into oligonucleotides by DNA polymerases. These products were labeled by two different fluorescent dyes using postsynthetic reactions that are not only bioorthogonal in general, but also mutually orthogonal.
Dual bioorthogonality is particularly challenging but desired for dual molecular imaging using energy transfer systems. In principle, it may be achieved by combining an iEDDA reaction with a strain-promoted azide–alkyne cycloaddition. Cyclooctynes, however, are prone to react both by iEDDA and strain-promoted azide–alkyne cycloaddition, the latter being the slower one, which can be solved for proteins by firstly adding the azide and secondly the tetrazine label.37 The combination of methylcyclopropene as iEDDA dienophile and dibenzocyclooctyne as the dipolarophile for the azide–alkyne cycloaddition finally yielded a copper-free, mutually orthogonal strategy for proteins.38 Similar dual labeling methods were developed for proteins,39 also for carbohydrates,40 but only rarely for nucleic acids.41,42 So far, the applied combinations of reactions for nucleic acids include the Cu(I)-catalyzed cycloaddition, as described above, or sequentially by different ethynyl protecting groups,43 or, for instance, with thiol-ene44,45 or hydrazine46 bioconjugation chemistries.
Herein, we show that two bioorthogonally reactive groups, 1-methylcyclopropenes and 1,2,4-triazines can be combined for dual and copper-free labeling of DNA. The 1,2,4-triazine was attached to the 5-position of 2′-deoxyuridine triphosphate 1, and the 1-methylcyclopropene to the 7-position of 7-deaza-2′-deoxyadenosine triphosphate 2.33 This allows sequence selective incorporation of two differently modified nucleotides by DNA polymerases. The primer extension product can subsequently be labeled by two iEDDA reactions which are not only bioorthogonal in general, but also orthogonal to each other.
For further investigations of the subsequent postsynthetic labeling the Vent (exo-) polymerase was chosen for the elongation of P1/T2, whereby an elongation time of 30 min at 37 °C was sufficient in order to yield the full length product. The fully elongated oligonucleotide was desalinated, lyophilized, resolved and then labeled in the presence of excess (1000 equiv.) of the BCN-modified rhodamine dye 3. The presence of a new band with a significantly slower gel mobility indicates the successful conjugation between the triazine moiety at the oligonucleotide and dye 3. This conjugate is evidenced by the additional red fluorescence that is specific for the rhodamine dye. Within 5 min, a labeling yield of approximately 70% was obtained, which could be further increased to a maximum of about 80% after 45 min. The labeled primer extension product was additionally verified by the reaction of 1 with BCN-rhodamine 3 (for MALDI-TOF MS of this conjugate see Fig. S12†) and subsequent primer extension with this conjugate triphosphate (similar to literature48) yielding an identical gel shift (see Fig. S5†).
To demonstrate that both modified nucleotides 1 and 2 that carry the two different reactive groups can be incorporated into one DNA strand in a sequence-specific manner, we performed primer extension with T2 using a dNTP mixture of 1, 2 and the unmodified dCTP and dGTP (Fig. 2A). It is important to note here that the sequence of T2 was designed such that there is only a single incorporation site for each of the both modified nucleotides. Since the Vent (exo-) polymerase was efficient for the incorporation of the single modifications it was used for the dual incorporation, too. As it was already known from previous experiments that a desalination step between the enzymatic synthesis and the labeling reaction results in better yields, it was applied for the following experiments, too. The PAGE analysis (Fig. 2B, left column) after primer extension shows only the fully extended 35 nt products before the dye was added. The comparison with the unmodified primer extension product which was obtained with all four unmodified dNTPs shows again a slightly different gel mobility indicating the successful incorporation of the two reactive groups as oligonucleotide modifications. The successful single and dual postsynthetic labeling of the 1-methylcyclopropene and the 1,2,4-triazine functions as reactive groups in the primer extension products was evidenced by careful PAGE analysis. If the primer extension product was only subject to single labeling with either the BCN-rhodamine dye 3 or the tetrazine-TAMRA dye 4, new gel bands appeared with slower mobility in the green fluorescence channel of the 5′-fluorescein label and the additional rhodamine fluorescence in the red channel. The red-labeled primer extension product was additionally verified by the reaction of 2 with tetrazine-TAMRA 4 (for MALDI-TOF MS of this conjugate see Fig. S13†) and subsequent primer extension with this conjugate triphosphate yielding an identical gel shift (see Fig. S5†). An additional gel shift is observed when the primer extension product was labeled with both reagents, 3 and 4. It is important to note that the order in which the dyes were added to the modified oligonucleotide played an important role. When the conjugation of the cyclopropene moiety with the tetrazine-modified dye 4 was performed first, the BCN-modified dye 3 obviously formed an additional undesired side product according to PAGE analysis (see Fig. S3†) yielding three different labeling products in total. We propose a Diels–Alder reaction between the pyrazoline (product between 1-methylcyclopropene and tetrazine functions) and the BCN function of 3 to a “double-click” product (see Fig. S3†). This side product was additionally verified on the nucleotide triphosphate level by the reaction of 2 with both BCN-rhodamine 3 and tetrazine-TAMRA 4 (for MALDI-TOF MS of this conjugate see Fig. S14†). However, primer extension with this doubly labeled nucleotide triphosphate was not successfully probably due to high steric demand. To avoid this side reaction, the labeling reaction between the triazine-modified oligonucleotides and BCN-dye 3 was firstly carried out and the excess of the dye was removed by an additional desalting step prior to the second labeling by tetrazine-dye 4.
To show that the described handling does not affect the efficiency of each labeling step nor does it interfere with the specificity of the given bioorthogonal reactions control experiments were done using elongation products of P1/T2 with only one of the modified triphosphates. When only 1 was incorporated (Fig. 2B, middle column) an additional gel band compared to the full-length product is visible both in the green and red channel upon reaction with 3 indicating a successful bioconjugation as expected. However, no additional product was found after subsequent incubation with 4, since the combination of a tetrazine with a triazine moiety is not reactive. When both dyes, 3 and 4, were present, there is still only one labeling product visible on the gel. These results show that the additional tetrazine-dye 4 does not interfere with the bioconjugation between the triazine and the BCN-dye 3. A similar result was obtained in control experiments when only 2 was incorporated into oligonucleotides (Fig. 2B, right column), and efficient single labeling was obtained with tetrazine-dye 4. Addition of BCN-dye 3 did not alter this reactivity. These results support the mutual orthogonality of the 1-methylcyclopropene and triazine functions in bioorthogonal modification chemistry.
However, since rhodamine and TAMRA have very similar fluorescence properties it is not possible to differentiate between those two labels by the red fluorescence channel of PAGE analysis. To overcome this problem, the tetrazine-modified BODIPY 5 was used as reaction partner for the cyclopropene moiety. However, the BODIPY dye as bioorthogonal marker has again very similar fluorescence properties as the 5′-fluorescein label in the green fluorescence channel. Therefore, primer P2 carrying a Cy5 label was applied (Fig. 3A) that emits in the far red channel. With those three differently emitting dyes dual labeling experiments were performed, similar to those described above. The PAGE analysis (Fig. 3B) shows the fully extended P2 by only unmodified dNTPs in the far red fluorescent channel of the Cy5 label, imaged in blue color to differentiate from the red rhodamine channel. Again, a shift in the gel mobility of the full length product is visible when both modifications (1 and 2) were incorporated. When the primer extension product was incubated with either 3 or 5 separately, only one new gel band with slower mobility is visible showing the respective labeling products: the conjugate with BCN-rhodamine 3 is evidenced by the additional rhodamine fluorescence in the red channel, whereas the product with tetrazine-BODIPY 5 is visible by the additional BODIPY fluorescence in the green channel. The latter green-labeled primer extension product was additionally verified by the reaction of 2 with tetrazine-BODIPY 5 (for MALDI-TOF MS of this conjugate see Fig. S15†) and subsequent primer extension with this conjugate triphosphate yielding an identical gel shift (see Fig. S5†). Orthogonal labeling experiments with both dyes were carried out as described above. Thereby, two additional bands with slower gel mobility appeared in the far red channel (imaged in blue color), whereby the upper band shows a higher intensity. The lower band shows a fluorescence in the red and green channel, indicating a mixture of singly labeled primer extension products by either 3 or 5. The upper band shows a clear fluorescence in the red channel indicating the presence of the rhodamine dye, but no fluorescence in the green channel. With respect to the clear evidence from the previous primer extension experiments with the two different red-emitting dyes 3 and 4 by the same excitation wavelength (presented in Fig. 2) we assume an energy transfer between the dyes of 3 and 5. In fact, when the gel is excited at 470 nm within the selective absorption range of BODIPY and emission is recorded using an emission filter at 605 nm (outside the emission range of BODIPY but inside the emission range of rhodamine) a fluorescence signal matching the upper band is visible. As a result of this control excitation, this band can be assigned to the doubly labeled primer extension product of P2. This explains also the absence of a signal in the green channel for this product by an obviously efficient energy transfer between BODIPY and rhodamine. Since both reactive groups, the triazine and the 1-methylcyclopropene, undergo bioorthogonal labeling with the respective dye in high yields, mostly the double labeled product and no unlabeled oligonucleotide was obtained. For control experiments with single incorporations of either 1 or 2 see Fig. S4.† The observed energy transfer between the two labels is an interesting aspect for applications in molecular imaging of living cells. Hence, we characterized this energy transfer additionally by steady-state in vitro fluorescence measurements (see Fig. S16 and S17†).
Fig. 3 (A) Schematic illustration of a dual labeling approach using Cy5-labeled Primer P2, BCN-rhodamine 3 for conjugation with the triazine moiety and tetrazine-modified BODIPY 5 for orthogonal conjugation with the cyclopropene component. (B) PAGE analysis of labeling reactions using elongated P2 (Vent (exo-), 37 °C, 30 min with a triphosphate mixture containing 1, 2, dCTP and dGTP) and the fluorescent dyes 3 (30 min incubation) and 5 (15 min incubation). “dNTP” shows the full-length product when only natural triphosphates are used (I) Cy5 λexc = 630 nm, λem = 700 nm; (II) rhodamine λexc = 540 nm, λem = 605 nm; (III) BODIPY λexc = 470 nm, λem = 535 nm; (IV) BODIPY λexc = 470 nm, λem = 605 nm. Overlays of the individual images are shown on the right side, whereby a mixed color occurs whenever different signals are present: cyan for Cy5 (blue) + BODIPY (green); magenta for Cy5 (blue) + rhodamine (red). For control experiments with only one of the two modified triphosphates, see ESI.† |
The DNA primer extension product of P2/T2 labeled with both BCN-rhodamine 3 and tetrazine-BODIPY 5 were applied in cell biology. HeLa cells were transfected by this DNA construct using Screenfect® agent. The cell images 24 h after transfection (Fig. 4) showed not only the BODIPY fluorescence when excited at 488 nm in the green emission channel (502–522 nm) but also the rhodamine fluorescence in the red emission channel (560–580 nm) (lane I). Control experiments with DNA primer extension products that were either labeled with BCN-rhodamine 3 or tetrazine-BODIPY 5 revealed only the corresponding single fluorescence in the respective emission channels (lanes II and III). This clearly shows that the energy transfer which was indicated by the gels (Fig. 3) is also observable inside cells. This supports the application of our double iEDDA modification chemistry for nucleic acid probes in molecular imaging.
Fig. 4 Images of HeLa cells 24 h after transfection with DNA primer extension products of P2/T2 (see ESI† page 25) labeled with both tetrazine-BODIPY 5 and BCN-rhodamine 3 (lane I), labeled only with 3 (lane II), and labeled only with 5 (lane III). Excitation and emission wavelengths are given as headings. |
Footnote |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available: Synthesis of 1, images of NMR and mass spectra, images of PAGE analyses after primer extension. See DOI: 10.1039/c8sc05588b |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2019 |