Steaphan Mark
Wallace
*ab,
Wipakorn
Jevasuwan
a and
Naoki
Fukata
*ab
aInternational Center for Materials Nanoarchitectonics, National Institute for Materials Science, Tsukuba, 305-0044, Japan. E-mail: FUKATA.Naoki@nims.go.jp; Steaphan.wallace@gmail.com
bGraduate School of Pure and Applied Sciences, University of Tsukuba, Tsukuba, 305-8573, Japan
First published on 16th October 2020
Sub-micron sized metal particles were formed through the annealing of sputtered metal thin films on silicon nanowires (SiNWs). During high-temperature annealing, the cylindrical SiNW structures induce the solid-state dewetting behavior to consistently move up the SiNW sides and form partial-spherical particles with uniform sizes on the nanowire tops. By adjusting the size parameters of the SiNW substrate and the metal thin film, the particles can be adjusted in size and layout along an array. This contrasts with the random dewetted particles seen on planar surfaces, and known movement towards pitted nanostructures. Ag, Au, Cu, and Ni have shown equivalent particle formation behavior and some alloying is also shown to be possible. These results open a path for a well-controlled and consistent method of metal particle formation at the nano to micro-scale and offer some insight on metal particle dewetting mechanisms. Suggested applications for the resulting regular particle grids include plasmonic sensors such as SERS.
For the purpose of controlling metal particles on a substrate surface, there has been a swell of interest in metal thin film dewetting and particle migration behavior.12–15 It is known that solid-state dewetting of metal thin films occurs at temperatures much lower than the metal's bulk melting temperature, which depends greatly on the metal thin film thickness.16 At high temperature, metal thin films will quickly dewet from passive surfaces and contract in order to reduce the film's surface energy, exposing the underlying surface.17 If the thin film is sufficiently thin and annealed long enough, the film may cross the percolation threshold to form isolated island particles.18 These particles will sometimes migrate randomly on the surface and merge with other particles, resulting in randomly sized and placed particles on a flat surface.19,20 However, if the surface has been shaped, the dewetting and migration of the metal can be altered according to the effect that the substrate has on the surface energy of the particle.21,22 These effects can be used for engineering the formation and placement of metal particles on the target surface for application. For instance, the nano-pit method of fabrication relies on the dewetting tendency to move away from convex surfaces and towards concave surfaces which cradle the particles.23,24 Uniform particle grids have already been produced in this way but this technique limits the substrate to shallow pits which can be easily disrupted by different deposition thicknesses. Detailing of alternate solid-state dewetting tendencies is needed for expanding the field and for the inclusion of other substrate structures.
Through our group's work with silicon nanowires (SiNWs),25–27 it was observed that metal thin films will easily form particles on the top of cylindrical nanowires. This was suspected to be due to the SiNW surface geometry's effect on the metal thin film surface energy. It was hypothesized that adjusting the SiNW parameters would lead to a high degree of control over the formation of metal particles on the nanowire tops. Though metal particles on nanowire structures are commonly grown in the reverse process,28,29 by depositing particles on a flat surface and then etching or growing the nanowires underneath, control and consistency of the particle/nanowire placement and size is difficult and the type of metal particle is limited by the growth or etching reactions. In contrast, the particle grown from SiNW technique seen here is unique in its solid-state dewetting process, its resulting quality, and its capability to use many metals. We sought to better understand this process and conducted an examination of the conditions at which different metals will form particles on top of SiNWs. The resultant particles were then characterized for their structural properties.
Many metals will react with silicon at high temperature, so a passivating layer was used to separate the metal from the Si substrate. For this purpose, a thin layer of SiO2 was added by thermal oxidation of the sample at 975 °C. The oxidized substrates were cleaned and Ag thin films were deposited onto the substrate by sputtering while rotating the sample. A typical film thickness equivalent to 200 nm when deposited on a planar perpendicular surface (and therefore denoted as 200 nmplanar in this report) was deposited onto the SiNWs. The actual thickness of the thin film differs on the different parts of the SiNW substrate surface. To test the process for other metals and alloys, other samples were deposited with Ni, Au, and Cu instead of, or in combination with, Ag.
The samples were then annealed in a hot-walled quartz tube furnace in an inert atmosphere of 50 sccm Argon at 300 torr at various temperatures and times as explained in the results section. A magnetic transfer rod was used to quickly move the samples between the hot zone and cool zones of the furnace to precisely control the annealing time.
After cooling, the samples were mechanically severed and the cross-sections were characterized by scanning electron microscopy (SEM) to observe their structure and the chemical compositions were recorded by an attached energy-dispersive X-ray spectrometer (EDS). The horizontal particle diameter of some samples was determined by image analysis software for >140 particles. Crystallographic data was gathered using a PANalytical X'Pert thin film X-ray diffractometer (XRD) using Cu Kα radiation and a 5° grazing incidence angle.
In this experiment, the cylindrical SiNWs on a flat floor as seen in Fig. 1(e) were used to guide the dewetting process. When the 200 nmplanar Ag metal is sputtered onto the sample while rotated it takes on the shape seen in Fig. 1(f). Due to the nature of the sputtering, the deposition is thicker on top and thinner on the sides of the SiNW. The thickness decreases slightly going down the length of the SiNW and is thinnest near the base but is continuous over the entire SiNW sample. These results appear to be important for initiating dewetting. As the thin film on the sides is thinner, they will dewet quicker than the films on the floor and tops of the SiNWs. The thinnest section near the base facilitates hole nucleation and pinches off the film from the floor. Despite being above the percolation threshold for the equivalent planar film, the film on the SiNW becomes isolated and is similar in mass to the films isolated on the other SiNWs. Once isolated, the metal will migrate upwards to the top as imaged in Fig. 1(g) and illustrated in Fig. 1(h). This upward movement is thought to be a combination of symmetrical contraction towards the thicker and less mobile mass of metal on the top of the SiNW, and a tendency to move away from the curved surface and corners of the SiNW sides. Once the particle has formed on top of the SiNW, the corners will keep the particle pinned to the SiNW top instead of migrating back down. After cooling, the particles become strongly attached to the SiNWs. The effect of gravity is negligible as the same results occur whether the SiNWs point either upwards or downwards during annealing (Fig. S1†). With the proper conditions, this effect should produce particles on nearly every SiNW over the entire sample area. Meanwhile, the material on the floor between the NWs will remain as a thin film if the temperature is below the dewetting point for its particular thickness.
XRD data obtained from the Ag surface (both the particles and underlying Ag) of an annealed sample is shown in Fig. 2(b). A multi-crystalline Ag crystal structure can be seen both before and after annealing with similar peak ratios. More intense and narrow peaks can be seen after annealing due to the increase in crystal grain size compared to the sputtered structure. The annealing also causes only a very slight rightward shift probably due to a small change in residual stress.34
Fig. 2 (a) Wide view SEM image of consistent Ag particle formation on NWs over a wide area. (b) XRD spectrum of the surface of the same sample showing Ag crystal peaks before and after annealing. |
One important attribute of the sputtering deposition is the continuous coating that is formed. Because the direction of incoming metal is at an angle in a typical sputtering machine, the sample is rotated. If the deposition angle is held at a single direction as in Fig. 3(a) or perpendicular to the sample (Fig. S2†), then the thin film will appear with pores in the film on the side of the SiNW. When annealing, dewetting will initiate at these pores and will lead to small particles on the SiNW sides which will not migrate upward, seen in Fig. 3(b).
To initiate dewetting at a certain thin film thickness, a sufficiently high temperature is needed which corresponds with that thickness. The association between thin film thickness and dewetting temperature for various metals on flat surfaces can be found in other reports.35,36 In the nanowire substrate case, at a temperature slightly below dewetting temperature, grain growth and some hole nucleation may occur but the metal will not form particles, as seen in Fig. 3(c). At temperatures much higher than the dewetting temperature of the entire metal film, the entire film experiences strong dewetting. This will cause hole nucleation between SiNWs and more metal to migrate off the SiNWs, leading to small irregular particles as seen in Fig. 3(d). Overly high temperatures also make it more likely for large particles to touch and merge on the SiNWs or to damage the underlying substrate (Fig. S3†). Consequently, it appears that an annealing temperature above the dewetting temperature of the film on the SiNW sides but below the dewetting temperature of the film on the SiNW top should be used as this will cause the film to consistently dewet off the sides and into stationary particles on top. This temperature will depend on the type of metal and the film thickness found on the different sections of the nanowire. For this experiment, 200 nmplanar of Ag could form proper particles when annealed at 800 °C for 30 seconds or more. Lower temperatures can potentially be used with longer annealing times.
Adjusting the metal deposition thickness had a complex effect on the particle quality. On a planar surface, a thicker film will simply increase the necessary dewetting temperature and form either larger particles or percolated films compared to thinner films. On the SiNW surface, changing the deposition thickness has the added effect of changing the distance from the top of the film on the floor to the top of the SiNW, illustrated in Fig. 3(g). This will change the pinch-off point and therefore the amount of material that will migrate up the SiNWs. At low deposition thicknesses, the deposited film may not be continuous and particles will form on the SiNW walls while the film on the floor dewets into particles as well, such as the 50 nmplanar thick film in Fig. 3(e). At high deposition thicknesses relative to the SiNW height, the film on the floor approaches the SiNW tops and the resulting particles will be small and more random such as the 300 nmplanar thick film in Fig. 3(f). As a result, finding the right deposition thickness relative to the nanowire dimensions is necessary for well-formed particles.
Metal particles could be successfully formed on a variety of sizes of SiNWs. To test the effect of SiNW height, 200 nmplanar Ag was deposited on samples with three different SiNW heights and annealed at the same conditions. The nanowire height was adjusted by using different plasma etching times in the nanoimprint lithography process. Increasing the height of the SiNW while keeping the deposition thickness constant was seen to increase the amount of metal that will travel upward and therefore the size of the particle. Arbitrary heights of 540 nm, 650 nm, and 810 nm caused an increase of the average horizontal particle diameters of 315 nm, 400 nm, and 425 nm respectively which can be seen in the SEM images and particle size distributions of Fig. 4(a–c). This is likely due to the increase of the distance between the floor film and the SiNW top, and an increase of the ratio of the deposited metal on the SiNW sides compared to the floor, depicted in Fig. 4(f). This also reduces the thickness of the metal on the floor, which will also dewet if it approaches thicknesses similar or lower than that on the SiNW walls.
Alternatively, to test the effect of SiNW diameter, 200 nmplanar Ag was deposited on SiNWs of different diameters and annealed at the same conditions. Nanowire diameter can be adjusted by the lithography process, or by increasing or decreasing the oxide layer. Changing the SiNW diameter also changed the particle size. 200 nm and 275 nm diameter SiNWs were formed by adjusting the oxide layer and resulted in particles with average horizontal metal particle diameters of 300 nm and 420 nm respectively, seen in Fig. 4(d and e). This is likely due to the amount of metal material deposited on the SiNW tops, depicted in Fig. 4(f).
Although changing the SiNW height and diameter individually could change the size of the metal particles, there are limits on the extent of this process. As already seen in Fig. 3(e), if the volume of metal on top of the SiNW is too small, without reducing the diameter of the SiNW, the metal particle may flatten. And, as seen in Fig. 4(c), if the particle is too massive and the diameter of the SiNW is not wide enough to support the particle's normal wetting surface area then the particle will sag over the SiNW edge, reducing uniformity of the sample. Therefore, large changes in particle size should be made by adjusting both the SiNW height and diameter together.
Alloyed nanoparticles are of particular interest because they can combine the properties of individual elements or allow for complex structures.37 To investigate the potential of alloying using this method, Ag and Au were deposited one after the other on SiNW arrays. One sample had 100 nmplanar Au on 100 nmplanar Ag and the second sample had 50 nmplanar Ag on 100 nmplanar Au. Both samples were annealed at 750 °C for 2.5 minutes. SEM-EDS mapping of individual particles showed an even distribution of Au and Ag, such as in Fig. 5(e). EDS spectra from single points showed the calculated atomic ratio of Au:Ag to be 49:51 for the first sample and 65:35 for the second sample, close to that expected by the deposition thickness. XRD data in Fig. 5(g) shows strong single peaks aligning at the overlapping Ag and Au peaks both before and after annealing along with a decrease in peak width and possible slight rightward peak shift after annealing as also seen in the pure Ag sample. Together, the EDS and XRD data suggest that a good level of controllability can be achieved for forming solid solution alloy metal particles by this method. 50 nmplanar Ag on 200 nmplanar Cu was also tested as these metals do not form a solid solution by annealing. Spherical particles with different textured regions could be seen in SEM. SEM-EDS mapping in Fig. 5(f) and single-point spectra at different locations on the particle suggest that the different regions vary in Ag:Cu composition. XRD from the sample after sputtering reveals peaks aligning well to both Ag and Cu standard peaks. However, after annealing, the Ag peaks shift rightward (from compression) and the Cu peaks shift leftward (from tension). This is likely an adjustment due to the difference in the lattice parameters of the two metals and a sign that there has been alloying of the metals.38
Possible applications for the particles include plasmonic sensors or other devices that can utilize the high degree of ordering along a plane. With further refinement and a decrease in the particle dimensions using the methods outlined above, hot-spot engineered Surface-Enhanced Raman Spectroscopy (SERS) grids for trace molecular analysis should be possible.39–42 The advantages of this process would include improved reproducibility and stability over large substrate areas by utilizing the top-down control of nanoimprint lithography for particle formation. Another possibility is to use the NWs in order to form tip-enhanced Raman spectroscopy (TERS) probes, as the particles are firmly attached to the SiNWs.43 In either case, the Ag/Au alloy particles can be useful because of the combined high plasmonic properties of Ag and the protection from oxidation that Au provides.44
The dewetting behavior outlined in this report adds to the available techniques of using nanostructured surfaces to promote metal solid-state dewetting in a desired direction to control the formation and location of metal islands into particles. The process can likely be extended to other metals, substrates, and nanostructures besides SiNWs. The flexibility of the nanoimprint lithography process and availability of other lithographic methods can provide other possible layouts and applications that can be guided by the results presented in this report. We think that this can serve as a versatile nanofabrication technique for making complex structures which combine metal particles and nanostructured substrates.
Footnote |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available. See DOI: 10.1039/d0na00567c |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2020 |