Shan Li*a,
Yubei Zhanga,
Tong Zhaob,
Weijian Hanb,
Wenyan Duana,
Li Wanga,
Rui Dou*a and
Gong Wang*a
aCAS Key Laboratory of Space Manufacturing Technology, Technology and Engineering Center for Space Utilization, Chinese Academy of Sciences, Beijing, 100094, P. R. China. E-mail: wanggong@csu.ac.cn; ruidou@csu.ac.cn
bLaboratory of Advanced Polymer Materials, Institute of Chemistry, Chinese Academy of Sciences, Beijing 100190, P. R. China
First published on 5th February 2020
The application of advanced ceramic materials is limited by their brittleness and complicated manufacturing methods. Three-dimensional (3D) printing has emerged as a new method for the fabrication of complex-shaped ceramics. Herein, a type of printable slurry composed of SiBCN preceramic polymers and high-volume fractions of Si3N4 whiskers (up to 60 wt% of polymer) was prepared, and subsequently printed via digital light processing (DLP) technology. We successfully manufactured complex-structured ceramic composites and achieved high bending strength (∼180 MPa). The linear shrinkage and mass loss of the ceramic material were both significantly reduced after the introduction of whiskers. The properties and structure of the printed parts pyrolyzed at different temperatures were compared, and the relationship between the microstructure and mechanical properties discussed.
PDCs have been recognized widely as powerful tools for producing advanced ceramics. Their main advantage over conventional powder-synthetic procedures is the possibility of adopting a plastic-forming method to generate components with complex shapes that are subsequently transformed into the desired ceramic parts by heat treatment.17,18 Intensive research has been conducted on the 3D printing of PDCs.5,14–16,19,20 However, the liner shrinkage is relatively high (>25%), which may lead to collapse or some defects of the component.
The key problem is the control of shrinkage and structural integrity of the printed parts during the polymer-to-ceramic transformation. Introduction of inert fillers is an efficient way to reduce the shrinkage and porosity of the PDC21 by diluting the percentage of polymer. Moreover, the use of fillers permits the manufacturing of ceramics with improved mechanical or functional properties.21–23 Various fillers have been shown to be effective in strengthening PDCs, including carbon nanotubes, ceramic fibers, or graphene.14,24,25
SiBCN ceramics are a popular class of new ceramic materials with high thermal and phase stability.26–29 Polyborosilazane (PBSZ), the precursor of SiBCN, is a liquid polymer with a high ceramic yield. In our previous work,30 we modified PBSZ to render it photocurable (designated as “UV-PBSZ”). To decrease shrinkage of the printed parts during pyrolysis and improve the mechanical properties of the ceramic components, we assumed we introduced whiskers into UV-PBSZ. Whiskers of Si3N4 and SiC are fillers used commonly to improve the mechanical properties of the ceramic matrix,31–33 whereas SiC whiskers affect DLP printing severely.14 Herein, we manufactured Si3N4 whisker-filled SiBCN ceramic composite components with a complex shape and high resolution by DLP 3D-printing technology. Following pyrolysis, shrinkage of the component was much lower than that of the base preceramic polymer. A high bending strength of the printed ceramic composites was achieved, and the effects of the structure on the mechanical properties were discussed.
During printing, the photo-polymerization reaction was triggered; the crosslinking of the photosensitive groups in UV-PBSZ generated a polymer network that acted as a framework entrapping the Si3N4 whiskers. Introduction of the fillers might affect the photocuring process. Fig. 1 shows the curing depth of the slurry containing different amount of Si3N4 whiskers: the curing depth decreased significantly after introduction of the Si3N4 whiskers. With an increase in Si3N4w contents, the curing depth decreased further; when the Si3N4 loading was 60%, the curing depth was only 90 μm under a relatively high UV dose (528 mW S cm−2). With the increase of the UV dose, the curing depth of the base UV-PBSZ increased sharply, whereas that of the slurry increased slightly, suggesting that the whiskers would severely affect UV curing even under a higher UV dose. When the Si3N4 loading increased further, it was very hard to print.
For maximum reduction in the shrinkage of the 3D printing of PDCs, we used a printable slurry with maximum loading (60%). The slurry was fabricated with a layer thickness of 50 μm and exposure dose of 528 mW S cm−2. The material system remained printable even at high loading of Si3N4 whiskers (60 wt%), which was attributed to the high UV sensitivity of the preceramic polymer and the adjustable wide-range exposure dose of the printer.
Ceramic composite components were printed and sintered (Fig. 2). The printed green body had fine and complicated features with a smooth surface, suggesting a high resolution of the DLP-printing technology. After sintering, the shape of the components was well preserved without visible deformation or macro-cracks due to the low liner shrinkage of the component. Obtaining solid block structures through PDC routes are difficult due to the cracking problem of PDCs during pyrolysis. Furthermore, investigation of mechanical properties of PDCs has been hindered due to limitations in fabrication of suitable bulk test specimens.
Fig. 2 Optical images of (a and d) printed parts and (b, c, e and f) the corresponding sintered parts: (b and e) top view and (c and f) orthogonal image. |
The shrinkage and residual weight of the composites sintered at different temperatures are provided in Table 1. The linear shrinkage of pure UV-PBSZ was ∼30%, whereas that of the composite was ∼20%, suggesting that introduction of Si3N4 whiskers could significantly reduce the linear shrinkage of the printed parts during sintering, and maintain the stability of the structures. With an increase in pyrolysis temperature, the shrinkage of all three axes increased slightly. For example, the linear shrinkage of the x/y axes was 18.1%, 18.5% and 18.7% for samples pyrolyzed at 900 °C, 1200 °C and 1400 °C, respectively. The shrinkage in the three axes was different, with the x/y axes having lower and the z axis having the larger shrinkage (likely due to the z axis being the printing direction and the interlayer lamination becoming denser after sintering). Compared with the base resin UV-PBSZ, the residual weight of the composite also improved significantly, from 58.1% for UV-PBSZ to 72.2% for composite1200. With an increase in sintering temperature, the residual weight also decreased slightly, from 74.8% for composite900 to 70.4% for composite1400. The density of the composite was measured according to the Archimedes principle. The density of the base resin was ∼1.85 g cm−3, whereas the density of the composite was ∼2.1 g cm−3. The slight increase in the density may have been caused by the high content of Si3N4 whiskers in the composite. The density of the composite sintered at different temperatures was essentially identical.
Material | x/y | z | Residual weight (%) | Density (g cm−3) |
---|---|---|---|---|
SiBCN1200 (ref. 30) | 28.0 ± 0.1 | 30.9 ± 0.2 | 58.1 ± 0.1 | 1.85 ± 0.05 |
Composite900 | 18.1 ± 0.1 | 21.3 ± 0.1 | 74.8 ± 0.1 | 2.15 ± 0.05 |
Composite1200 | 18.5 ± 0.1 | 22.5 ± 0.1 | 72.2 ± 0.1 | 2.10 ± 0.05 |
Composite1400 | 18.7 ± 0.1 | 22.6 ± 0.1 | 70.4 ± 0.1 | 2.15 ± 0.05 |
The weight changes of the printed UV-PBSZ and composites during high-temperature sintering were assessed by TGA (Fig. 3). The weight loss of both systems occurred mainly in two steps. The first step was between room temperature to 300 °C, and the second step from 400 to 700 °C. The temperature at which maximum decomposition occurred was ∼450 °C, at which point the organic moiety in the material system could be decomposed. Above 800 °C, the weight change was milder, indicating that the polymer-to-ceramic conversion was almost complete. The thermal stability of the printed composite was higher than that of printed UV-PBSZ due to the dilution effect of the filled inert whiskers in the composite. The residual weight of the base resin and composite at 1000 °C was ∼58% and ∼68%, respectively, which suggested a much higher residual weight in the composite.
XRD spectroscopy was conducted to investigate the crystallization behavior of the ceramic material sintered at different temperatures (Fig. 4). After pyrolysis at 900 °C, the main composition was Si3N4 with peaks at 2θ = 13°, 23°, 27°, 33°, 37°, 41°, 51°, 71° and 73°. With an increase in the pyrolysis temperature, the signals of graphitic carbon at around 2θ = 26° became more obvious. The reflections of β-SiC, which were located at 2θ = 36°, 60° and 72°, were covered by the signals of Si3N4, and distinguishing them was difficult. Compared with the structure of the base resin (SiBCN 1400) that remained amorphous until 1400 °C, the crystallization resistance of the composite decreased due to the high amounts of Si3N4 whiskers in the material system.
Transmission electron microscopy (TEM) was used to investigate further the microstructure of the composite sintered at different temperatures (Fig. 5). For composite900, TEM showed Si3N4 crystallites and the amorphous matrix. After sintering at 1200 °C, turbostratic carbon features were formed along the Si3N4 crystallites, but major changes in the overall microstructure of the sample were not observed, and these data were consistent with the results of XRD spectroscopy. At a higher temperature (1400 °C), coarsening of the crystallites was observed, and the turbostratic carbon transformed into ordered graphite of thickness 4–10 nm, which was also observed in the XRD spectrum.
Si3N4 crystallites may promote matrix crystallization. Pure PDCs can retain an amorphous structure until a much higher temperature (1500 °C) through a diffusion barrier (turbostratic BNCx) limiting the size of the crystal domains. After introduction of Si3N4 crystallites, the amorphous interconnecting network of the matrix shows local disruption, and then initiation of crystallization begins, resulting in the loss of stability at high temperatures.
The microstructure of samples sintered at different temperatures was investigated by SEM (Fig. 6). The white dots and particles (marked by red circles) on the surface of composite900 (Fig. 6a) were determined to be Si3N4 whiskers. Composite1200 (Fig. 6b) showed a similar morphology to that of comosite900. At a higher temperature (1400 °C), the surface of the sample became rough, and more whiskers were exposed on the surface (Fig. 6c). During pyrolysis, the preceramic polymer pyrolyzed, resulting in linear shrinkage of the matrix parts, whereas the Si3N4 whiskers retained their dimensions and protruded from the surface. After sintering at 1400 °C, further decomposition of the PDC matrix led to many more exposed whiskers without the matrix binder.
Fig. 6 (a–c) Surface and (d–f) cross-sectional SEM images of the sintered parts at (a and d) 900 °C, (b and e) 1200 °C, and (c and f) 1400 °C. |
The cross-sectional images (Fig. 6d–f) of the composites pyrolyzed at different temperatures showed a similar morphology. There was no interlayer gap between the printing layers, which suggested good interlayer bonding. Undulations were found on the cross-sectional surface of the printed part, which was caused by the layer-by-layer printing process. In the higher-magnification images (upper-right corner of the figure), whiskers were dispersed uniformly within the matrix.
The mechanical properties of the ceramic composites were evaluated (Table 2). The bending strength of the composite reached 183 MPa upon sintering at 1200 °C. For the base SiBCN ceramic, the bending strength was too low to be measured for the samples sintered at all temperatures. Therefore, the Si3N4 whiskers helped to improve the mechanical properties of the PDC. The flexure strength of composite1200 (183 MPa) was higher than the reported values (57.3 MPa) of PDCs fabricated by DLP-printing technology, and is also at the same level with PDCs processed through other methods.34–37 A nanoindentation test was undertaken to calculate the hardness and modulus. Composite1200 showed higher hardness (3.4 GPa) and modulus (54.1 GPa) than composite900 and composite1400. The monolithic SiBCN ceramic showed the highest hardness of 7.8 GPa and modulus of 54.7 GPa. The mechanism of the different mechanical properties was analyzed by a microstructure study.
Material | Method | Flexural strength (MPa) | Hardness (GPa) | Modulus (GPa) |
---|---|---|---|---|
Cf/SiOC36 | PIP | 253.3 | 33.3 | |
SiC37 | PIP | 85 ± 5 | 30 | 218 |
SiCN35 | Cold isostatic pressing | 118 | 6.1 | 105 |
SiCN4 | DLP printing | 57.3 ± 8.7 | ||
SiBCN1200 (ref. 30) | DLP printing | 7.8 ± 0.3 | 54.7 ± 0.3 | |
Composite900 | DLP printing | 128 ± 15 | 28.4 ± 0.2 | |
Composite1200 | DLP printing | 183 ± 13 | 3.4 ± 0.2 | 54.1 ± 0.3 |
Composite1400 | DLP printing | 68 ± 18 |
The fracture surface of the tested samples sintered at different temperatures was investigated by SEM (Fig. 7). The fracture surface of the printed monolithic SiBCN ceramic material was smooth, suggesting that the material was brittle. Conversely, the fracture surface of the composite was uneven, indicating a ductility fracture. Composite900 showed micro-cracks in the fracture surface due to the brittle features of the incomplete ceramic transformation of the precursor matrix (arrows in Fig. 7d). For composite1200 (Fig. 7f), micro-cracks were not observed, and the whiskers merged within the ceramic matrix and were closely connected. Subsequent sintering at 1400 °C let to formation of many cracks in the fracture surface (Fig. 7h), and the reason is explicable.
When the pyrolysis temperature was low (900 °C), the preceramic polymer did not convert to a ceramic completely, exhibiting a low strength, and the matrix tended to form cracks during mechanical testing. For composite1400, the microstructure of the PDC matrix began to coarsen, and the crystals became larger (Fig. 5c), resulting in the loss of thermal stability. The PDC matrix decomposed slightly (Fig. 6c), with whiskers being exposed on the surface. Cracks were formed due to decomposition of the PDC matrix (Fig. 7h), which acted as defects in the sample, leading to a sharp decrease in mechanical properties. In composite1200, the perfect fracture surface without microcracks and better boundary connection between whiskers and the ceramic matrix than that in other composites contributed to the excellent mechanical properties.31 Whiskers can act as the reinforced phase in the composite, thereby enhancing the strength of the ceramic material.
DLP 3D-printing technology has shown great potential in shape-forming of ceramic composites with complex structures. SiBCN/Si3N4w composites with specially designed complex structures and improved mechanical properties can be fabricated more efficiently and readily, which can act as a thermal-barrier layer in hypersonic aircraft wings. Our method proposed is also applicable for the manufacture of other ceramic composites.
Footnote |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available. See DOI: 10.1039/c9ra09598e |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2020 |