Taylor
Wright
a,
Yael
Petel
a,
Carson O.
Zellman
b,
Ethan R.
Sauvé
a,
Zachary M.
Hudson
a,
Carl A.
Michal
ac and
Michael O.
Wolf
*a
aDepartment of Chemistry, University of British Columbia, Vancouver, BC, Canada V6T 1Z1. E-mail: mwolf@chem.ubc.ca
bDepartment of Chemistry, Simon Fraser University, 8888 University Drive, Burnaby, BC, Canada V5A 1S6
cDepartment of Physics and Astronomy, University of British Columbia, Vancouver, BC, Canada V6T 1Z1
First published on 28th February 2020
Bulk crystallization in flexible polymeric systems is difficult to control due to the random orientation of the chains. Here we report a photo cross-linking strategy that results in simultaneous cross-linking and crystallization of polysiloxane chains into millimeter sized leaf-like polycrystalline structures. Polymers containing pendant anthracene groups are prepared and undergo [4+4] photocycloaddition under 365 nm irradiation at room temperature. The growth and morphology of the crystalline structures is studied using polarized optical microscopy (POM) and atomic force microscopy and is found to progress through three unique stages of nucleation, growth, and constriction. The mobility of the individual chains is probed using pulsed-field gradient (PFG) NMR to provide insights into the diffusion processes that may govern chain transport to the growing crystal fronts. The room temperature crystallization of this conventionally amorphous polymer system may allow for a new level of morphological control for silicone materials.
Macroscopic crystallization of cross-linked polymers is much less common, owing partially to the low solubility of crosslinked materials making polymer crystal growth from dissolved solutions difficult. One method for the preparation of cross-linked polymer crystals is the concurrent polymerization and crystallization of small molecules into covalent-organic frameworks.14–16 This technique requires rigid linkers that promote regioregularity between cross-linking nodes. Others have explored the photochemical polymerization of anthracene-containing molecules to produce 2D polymer crystals, beginning with monomer single crystals or interfacial thin films that can be cross-linked into crystalline sheets.17–19
While crystallization in many commercial polymers has been extensively probed, poly(dimethylsiloxane) (PDMS) crystallization is much less reported. PDMS has been widely explored for use in microfluidics, flexible conductors, and biocompatible materials.20–22 Low cost, low toxicity, and elastomeric behaviour make PDMS an attractive material for soft-polymer applications. However, the high degree of flexibility and resulting low glass transition temperature (Tg) of linear PDMS requires temperatures below −70 °C for crystallization to occur and be stable.23,24 This temperature limitation severely limits the study of crystalline siloxane's properties. Cross-linking can raise the crystallization temperature, but gives materials with only semi-crystalline regions without discrete crystal formation.25,26 No room temperature stable polymer crystals of PDMS have been reported, likely owing to the highly amorphous nature of the flexible backbone.
Here, we use anthracene photodimerization to cross-link a linear PDMS polymer liquid, resulting in the crystallization of approximately 1 mm diameter polycrystalline structures in less than one hour of low intensity 365 nm irradiation. This is the first example of room temperature crystallization of highly amorphous PDMS to our knowledge. The use of photo-driven cross-linking allows for the growth of structures to be controlled by varying the duration or intensity of irradiation. The amount of anthracene on the polymer backbone has a large influence on the resulting crystal size and morphology, however in all cases the anthracene units represent less than 4% of the total number of repeat units in the flexible polymer backbone. This strategy of driving crystallization through rigid photo crosslinking nodes represents a significant departure from previously reported anthracene polymer crystals where numerous rigid repeat units in the backbone were employed to provide the order necessary for crystallization. This strategy may allow for new types of soft, elastomeric polymer crystals that can be studied and handled at room temperature.
A simple viscosity experiment was performed on a bulk sample, inverting a sealed vial of the polymer before and after irradiation. A decrease in creep distance was observed as a function of irradiation time, resulting in a solid sample (no observable movement after inversion) after 120 minutes of irradiation (Fig. S5†). No changes were observed in the FT-IR spectrum of bulk samples or thin films after irradiation, indicating that the vinylogous urethane bonds were not disrupted (Fig. S6†). Vibrational changes in the anthracene moiety are masked by the position and intensity of the stretching frequencies of the PDMS backbone.
Each spherulitic structure is observed to nucleate from an individual spherical structure, with clearly delineated arms from which a fine structure grows. Images resemble the leaves of a redwood tree, and as such a seed and leaf model analogy is applied (Fig. 1e). Leaves are observed to grow into contact with neighbouring leaves but joining or overlap of two structures was not observed (Fig. S8†). Isotropic irradiation of bulk samples in a vial produced crystal structures of a similar maximum diameter but lacking the branching and leaf structure, indicating different crystal growth dynamics (Fig. S9†).
Differential scanning calorimetry of P7 films after irradiation did not show any significant thermal transitions from −80 to 150 °C, with no changes to endotherms on repeated runs (Fig. S10†). The Tg is expected to be <−120 °C, and Tm values for semi-crystalline cross-linked PDMS have been reported in the region of 25–100 °C.25,26 Crystalline spherulite formation of linear PDMS has been reported at temperatures below −90 °C but not for samples at room temperature.23,24 Heating samples to higher temperatures was not explored as the amine functionalities of PDMS-NH2 are not thermally stable above 150 °C. No visual change was observed for crystallized samples after four weeks at room temperature under ambient laboratory conditions. A crystallized film of P7 was brought to 100 °C for one hour, resulting in a change from the observed leaf structures to long needle-shaped crystals (Fig. S11 and S12†). PXRD measurements of the needle-containing film showed a new sharp peak at 11.7° (Fig. S13†).
Polymers were prepared with three different molar ratios of AnAc to PDMS-NH2 (Fig. 1a) and the compositional effect on crystal growth studied. P3 produced seed structures within 15 minutes of irradiation, and upon further irradiation stunted leaf structures were observed with a maximum cross-sectional size of approximately 110 μm (Fig. 2). P25 showed macroscopic buckling of the thin-film surface after ten minutes of irradiation, with no crystallization seen in the deformed regions (Fig. S14†). At the film edges where buckling was less pronounced, crystals of a maximum cross-sectional size of approximately 210 μm were observed (Fig. 2). These crystals exhibit a less spherical growth and lessened fine structure near the leaf tips compared with P7, and a much wider variance in average size.
Irradiation of P25 beyond ten minutes did not result in further crystallization. The small growth of P3 is attributed to insufficient anthracene units per polymer, resulting in crystal surfaces not capable of nucleating further growth. Buckling in P25 suggests that cross-linking is too rapid for the growth of well-defined leaf structures to occur, attributed to the higher concentration of anthracene groups. Despite the large dependence of crystallization on anthracene content, for the three tested samples anthracene-containing subunits on the polymer represented only between 0.5–4% of the total number of repeat units per polymer chain. Polarized optical microscopy (POM) of P7 shows a distinct birefringence pattern that persists across the non-contiguous branches of the same leaf (Fig. 1f). These POM results are consistent with birefringence in PLLA/PVP composites that is proposed to arise from sudden discontinuous branching and not from a helical twist of the growing crystal.35 Growth in these cases proceeds until a defect or breakage in the crystalline structure results in new branches extending from the original portion. Analysis of the POM images of P7 shows a branching angle of 45° between the orange and blue regions along a single leaf direction (Fig. S15†). The seed structures do not exhibit the same crystallization pattern under the same imaging conditions (Fig. S16†). No polarization effects were observed in the P7 oil before irradiation.
PXRD measurements of P7 were performed before and after crystallization, as well as on PDMS-NH2. All samples show the same two broad diffraction peaks centered at 12° and 22° that align with the features in the WAXS spectrum (Fig. S21†). Liquid crystal mesogens containing PDMS portions have been reported, demonstrating the ability of PDMS chains to participate in self-assembly when guided by rigid, aromatic moieties.37,44 In our system, we propose that interactions between anthracene dimer crosslinking nodes produces ordering that is not present when crosslinking is done using flexible moieties, however the high weight percentage of amorphous PDMS prevents complete ordering here (Fig. S22†). For similar sheaf-like lamellar structures prepared using two-component polymer blends, X-ray diffraction peaks are more prominent for blends featuring a higher proportion of the crystallizing polymer versus the amorphous polymer.45–47 Blends featuring a high proportion of amorphous component have been reported that exhibit only diffuse diffraction while still assembling into macroscopic structures.48 Combined with the X-ray scattering measurements, this demonstrates that the birefringent structures are only weakly crystalline, exhibiting long-range ordering necessary for the observed POM results, but lacking extensive short-range crystalline order (Fig. S22†). We attribute the weak crystallinity to the high proportion of amorphous component (PDMS moieties far from an anthracene cross-linking point) that inhibits short-range ordering as well as dominating the PXRD spectra with the two diffuse peaks.
Imaging only the edges of a leaf structure shows that the leaves grow up and out from the center, with a height difference of 11 μm for the observed region (Fig. S23†). This demonstrates that the leaves grow upwards towards the source of illumination from an embedded seed and suggests that only seeds near the middle of the film are capable of nucleating to produce the large leaf structures.
Anthracene dimerization is expected to stop once cross-linking sufficiently inhibits polymer motion, preventing anthracene molecules from adopting the correct orientation for photocycloaddition. Samples remain emissive after irradiation as approximately 25% of the anthracene is not dimerized (Fig. S24†). Fluorescence microscopy imaging to examine the distribution of non-dimerized anthracene in the samples (Fig. S25†), demonstrates that both seeds and leaves are clearly distinguishable from the background. This demonstrates the presence of non-dimerized anthracene molecules in the crystalline structures, possibly due to anthracene molecules becoming confined in the growing structure, preventing their photoreaction (Fig. S26†). A direct comparison between emission intensities in the bulk and crystalline regions is not possible due to the changes in absorbance and quantum yield between single crystal, powder, and dissolved anthracene samples.49
Confocal imaging suggests that the leaf structures grow upwards from seed structures embedded in the interior of the film. However, photoreaction is expected to occur first near the surface of the film where the light intensity is the greatest. Diffusion of polymer chains against a photo-induced cross-linking gradient has been previously reported for the preparation of heterogeneously swollen films.50,51 Diffusion in our samples was studied using pulsed field gradient (PFG) 1H NMR spectroscopy.52,53 The translational diffusion coefficient (Dt) and rotational time play important roles in crystallization events, governing the rates of mass transport and reorientation to the growing crystal facets respectively.54,55 Measurements were performed on liquid samples before irradiation and solid samples after irradiation as a function of anthracene content, probing the methyl protons on the PDMS backbone (Fig. 4, 5a and Table S2†). The relative rotational times were estimated from the T1/T2 ratio.56,57
Fig. 4 PFG 1H NMR diffusion measurements. Gaussian fits to the Stejskal–Tanner diffusion equation52 with an additive constant to account for slowly diffusing species are shown for liquid P7 (top) and irradiated solid P7 (bottom). |
A decrease in Dt of nearly two orders of magnitude accompanied the addition of 3 equivalents of AnAc to the liquid polymer, with insignificant decreases upon addition of further molar equivalents (Fig. 5a). This suggests an aggregated state arising from the pendant anthracenes that is not impacted by further anthracene addition. The relative rotational times increase linearly with increasing AnAc equivalents. However, the increase in rotational times was less than an order of magnitude between P3 and P25. As such, diffusional limitations are not expected to play a major role in the larger degree of crystallization of P7 relative to P3 and P25. Given the morphology of the irradiated samples observed optically these findings are not surprising, as the mobility of the polymer likely depends on the proximity to crystallized structures. These measurements represent only the mobile components of the samples because the short T2 values of the crystalline components result in their suppression due to the filtering effects of the PFG pulse sequence.
The maximum translational diffusion lengths (assuming linear displacement) were plotted from Dt for PDMS-NH2 and P7 (before irradiation) as a function of time (Fig. 5b). P3 and P25 were omitted from this plot as the similar diffusion speeds to P7 results in a nearly identical profile. Crystallization of seeds in P7 is observed to begin within approximately 15 minutes of irradiation, while leaf growth began within 30 minutes.
From the data in Fig. 5b, it may be seen that an individual polymer chain is predicted to diffuse a maximum of 39 μm (15 minutes) and 55 μm (30 minutes). Confocal microscopy showed focal planes separated by approximately 40 μm between the layers of seeds and growing crystal leaf. As samples are irradiated from above, cross-linking and a reduction in motion should begin at the surface and propagate downward as irradiation continues. However, the leaves are observed to nucleate from seeds in the interior of the film and grow into a region that should already be cross-linked and thus unable to undergo reorientation for growth of the leaf structures. Based on the data in Fig. 5, it is reasonable to propose that diffusion from lower, non-cross-linked regions up to the growing crystalline front may be ongoing during irradiation, driven by the cross-linking gradient.
Atomic force microscopy (AFM) of crystallized P7 was performed in both non-contact mode and fast-force mapping contact mode to probe the surface topology and Young's modulus of the resulting films (Fig. 6a and b). The leaf structures are observable using AFM with feature heights of up to 1.3 μm relative to the surrounding flat film. Similarly shaped polymer lamellae typically exhibit a sheaf thickness on the order of tens of nanometers.58 Crystallization of the leaves must proceed prior to a bulk reduction in volume causing the film to constrict, forcing the tips of the crystal leaves to protrude from the film (Fig. 3b).
Force mapping of the same exposed leaf structure shows a uniform Young's modulus of approximately 100 MPa across the crystals, an increase of nearly 10 times over the bulk material (Fig. S28†). This value is comparable to the reported modulus determined using AFM for ozone cross-linked PDMS, and shows a nearly 100 times increase over the modulus for bulk measurements of PDMS-NH2 cross-linked with flexible linkers.30,59 The modulus for organic crystals determined by AFM is typically between 5–10 GPa, orders of magnitude higher than those found for the leaf structures, supporting the incorporation of the PDMS units into the observed structures.60–62 The large contrast in bulk and crystal modulus may allow the leaves to act as structural reinforcement amongst the elastomeric bulk if this chemistry can be expanded to thicker, more mechanically robust samples.
Footnote |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available. See DOI: 10.1039/c9sc06235a |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2020 |