Xujiao
Ma
a,
Yajie
Yang
a,
Rongchen
Ma
a,
Yunfeng
Zhang
a,
Xiaoqin
Zou
a,
Shoujun
Zhu
b,
Xin
Ge
c,
Ye
Yuan
*a,
Wei
Zhang
*c and
Guangshan
Zhu
*a
aKey Laboratory of Polyoxometalate Science of Ministry of Education, Northeast Normal University, Changchun 130024, China. E-mail: yuany101@nenu.edu.cn; zhugs@nenu.edu.cn
bState Key Laboratory of Supramolecular Structure and Materials, College of Chemistry, Jilin University, Changchun 130012, China
cKey Laboratory of Automobile Materials MOE, School of Materials Science & Engineering, Electron Microscopy Center, International Center of Future Science, Jilin University, Changchun 130012, China. E-mail: weizhang@jlu.edu.cn
First published on 23rd September 2020
Despite their remarkable mechanical, optical, and electrical properties, inorganic particles and dynamic polymer assemblies encounter difficulties in their compatibility with regards to structural order and complexity. Here, covalent organic frameworks (COFs) constructed through reversible coupling reactions were exploited as dynamic porous polymers to prepare inorganic nanocrystal-polymer assemblies. Under an in situ growth process, carbon quantum dots (CDs) were gradually prepared in the COF cavity, with a narrow size distribution (2 ± 0.5 nm). The well-established assemblies achieve effective energy transfer from the inorganic to the organic part (efficiency > 80%), thus rendering a ∼130% increase in quantum yield compared with the pristine COF network. Notably, the hybrid material realizes a simple, selective, and sensitive diagnostic tool for urine copper, surpassing the detection limit of COF solid by 150 times. Beyond the scientific and fundamental interests, such hybrid assemblies are attractive from technological perspectives as well, for example, in energy storage, electronics, catalysis, and optics.
Covalent organic frameworks (COFs), based on the auto-assembly of aromatic units through the reversible character of polymerization reactions, are a type of dynamic porous polymer.13–16 Due to their designable building blocks and tunable porous structures, COFs have been considered to be functional organic equivalents of inorganic microporous solids for utilization in gas separation,17–19 ion enrichment,20 optoelectronics,21–23 catalysis,24–26 drug transport,27,28 and biosensing.29–32 Based on the reversible formation of covalent bonds, they combine error-correction capability and molecular robustness.14,33 Compared to supramolecular polymers connected by weak noncovalent bonds, the modularity of COF solids endows a well-defined molecular architecture for the integration of guest substances.34,35 Therefore, they have allowed us to explore the exciting applications in host–guest chemistry and nanocomposite fabrication.
Herein, a series of COF samples driven by dynamic imines were utilized as matrices to exploit the novel inorganic nanocrystal-dynamic porous polymer assemblies. Subsequent thermal treatment of sodium citrate precursor afforded the pore-determined CD nanoparticles, denoted as CD@COF samples. Based on the fluorescence resonance energy transfer (FRET) mechanism, the CD donors transfer their emission energy to the energy-absorbing hydrazone groups of the COF skeleton. Accordingly, the CD nanocrystal-doped COF assemblies with high energy transfer efficiency showed a high-fluorescence emission. Thanks to the full host–guest chemistry of the porous structure, Cu2+ ions were concentrated in the fluorescent COF architectures to realize highly sensitive and selective detection.
Experimentally, temperature plays a crucial role in the self-polymerization of the precursor (sodium citrate), which increases the fluorescence performance of CDs with the increase of temperature.41 However, most COF skeletons will decompose at 350 °C, according to thermogravimetric analysis. To establish inorganic particles and dynamic polymer assemblies with effective energy transfer, 200 °C, 250 °C and 300 °C were selected as the temperature to synthesize CD nanoparticles. Loading with the same amount of CD precursors, we found that the CDs synthesized at 300 °C had the strongest fluorescence intensity (Fig. S2†). Then, BCOF-1 constructed with 1,3,5-triformylbenzene and hydrazine hydrate were selected as the subject, through observing fluorescence intensity under different doping amounts to screen for the optimum content of CDs. Sodium citrate, with varied content for each batch, was soaked into BCOF-1 as the precursor. After being heated at 300 °C for 2 hours, CD-doped BCOF-1 samples were obtained and denoted as CD@BCOF-1-X, where X (X = 5/4, 5/8, 5/16, 5/32, and 5/64) represents the initial mass ratio of sodium citrate to COF powder (Table S1†).
Powder X-ray diffraction (PXRD) analysis proved that CD-doped BCOF-1 samples had the same ordered structure as their parent BCOF-1. A sharp diffraction peak at 6.97° corresponds to the (100) crystal plane, and relatively weak signals at 11.99, 13.83, and 18.35° are assigned to the (110), (200), and (120) crystal planes, respectively. The π–π stacking structure between COF layers results in a slightly wider diffraction peak at 26.9° corresponding to the (001) plane. It is indicated that the implanted CD particles do not affect the crystal structure of BCOF-1 (Fig. 2A and S3†). Scanning electron microscopy (SEM) images indicate a consistent cluster-like microscopic morphology of BCOF-1 and CD@BCOF-1-5/4 (Fig. S4†). According to transmission electron microscopy (TEM) images, CD@BCOF-1 usually exhibits clear lattices in a small area, and pores with a pitch of 0.8 nm were detected (Fig. 2B and S5†). Within the COF lattices, the 2–3 nm circled black dots are assigned to the CD particles (Fig. 2B), demonstrating the successful incorporation of carbon dots.42,43 Overall, it is fully proven that the CDs@COF hybrids ensure the orderly structure of the framework while achieving high CD-doped content for structural complexity.
In the Fourier transform infrared (FT-IR) spectroscopy, the appearance of CN stretching band at 1631 cm−1 demonstrates the formation of imine bonds in COF skeletons (Fig. S6†). With the increased doping amount of CD, there is a red shift for the CN vibration frequency caused by the hydrogen bonding interaction between CD and the COF skeleton. As for CD@BCOF-1-5/4, this change is particularly obvious for the CN band, to 1625 cm−1. The apparent carbonyl stretching vibration at 1695 cm−1 in the IR spectra for CD@BCOF-1-X confirms the successful assembly of CDs (Fig. S6†). The chemical states of the C and O atoms in the CD-doped COF materials were determined by X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy (XPS; Fig. S7†). The high-resolution C1s XPS spectrum for BCOF-1 was deconvoluted into two peaks, located at 284.7 (CC/C–C) and 288.4 eV (CN/CO). As for the C1s spectrum for CD@BCOF-1-5/4, distinct signals were assigned to the C–O (286.2 eV) and CN/CO (288.6 eV) groups in CDs and to CC/C–C (284.7 eV) bonds in BCOF-1 (Fig. 2D). There was a 0.2 eV shift of the CN/CO peak position that could be ascribed to the hydrogen bonding between the O–H groups in the CDs and CN/CO groups in the COF network (Fig. 2E). Meanwhile, the characteristic peak at 532.6 eV in the O1s spectrum is attributed to the CO group at the BCOF-1 skeletal terminal. The high-resolution O1s spectrum for CD@BCOF-1-5/4 is deconvoluted into five peaks. In addition to the CO peak provided by BCOF-1, the signals centered at 531.6, 532.9, 533.4, and 535.2 eV correspond to the O atoms in the CO, C–O, O–CO, and O–H groups of CDs, respectively (Fig. 2C). There is only one convolution peak in the N1s spectrum, assigned to the CN–N group. The hydrogen bonding between the O–H of CDs and CN–N of the COF framework causes the peak position to shift by 0.25 eV (from 400.0 to 399.75 eV) (Fig. 2F).
There is an additional evidence of the successful introduction of CDs via hydrogen bonds in the 13C solid-state nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) spectra. The distinct signals in the range of 134–124 ppm are assigned to the aromatic carbon atoms in the phenyl ring. The CN characteristic peak shifts from 160 ppm (COF) to the lower field (163 ppm) due to the deshielding effect of the CDs embedded in the COF framework (Fig. S8†). The electron cloud of the CN group in the COF network is pulled by the exposed hydroxyl groups of CDs, leading to the lower binding energy. It is worth mentioning that there is a red shift of the maximum emission wavelength from 635 nm for the original BCOF-1 to 650 nm for CD@BCOF-1-5/4 (Fig. 3A). This increased wavelength (15 nm) is attributed to the hydrogen bonding between CDs and the COF skeleton, which inhibits free rotation within the N–N fragment (Fig. S1†). This restriction of intramolecular rotations (RIR) leads to a reduction of the excited-state non-radiative transitions and induces an increase in the Stokes shift.44
Nitrogen adsorption experiments were performed at 77 K to study the porous nature of the CD-doped COF materials. CD@BCOFs exhibited a type IV isotherm similar to that of BCOF-1. As CD particles increasingly occupied COF channels, the mass per unit increased, and the Brunauer–Emmett–Teller (BET) surface area was reduced from 1222 m2 g−1 for BCOF-1 to 359 m2 g−1 for CD@BCOF-1-5/4 (Fig. S9†). Elemental analysis data showed that the weight of C and N elements in CD@BCOF-1 was significantly reduced compared to BCOF-1. It was calculated that the mass ratio of O element increased from 5.58% to 10.56%, proving the successful incorporation of CDs (Table S2†).
The FRET method refers to transfer of dipole-mediated energy from the donor to the acceptor, as the distance between them is less than 10 nm.45 Its manifestation is the overlapped spectra for the donor molecule in an emissive state (Em1) and the acceptor molecule in an excited state (Ex2) (Fig. 4A). The emission spectrum of CD particles ranged from 405 to 565 nm (centered at 490 nm); the excitation spectrum of BCOF-1 varied within the range of 345–505 nm (centered at 420 nm). There is a spectrum overlap from 405 to 505 nm between the CD-donor emission and the COF-acceptor excitation (Fig. 3B). CDs evidenced a restricted growth in the uniformly distributed binding sites in the framework. The successful coupling between CDs and BCOF-1 resulted in the efficient transfer of fluorescence energy from CDs to BCOF-1. These roles are critical for the successful assembly to endow an efficient FRET behavior.
As shown in Fig. 3C, the fluorescence intensities for the CD@BCOF-1-X materials are significantly increased at 650 nm, corresponding to an orange-red emission (excitation at 420 nm), with the increasing content of loaded CDs. This phenomenon indicates that the energy transfer between CDs and COF structures is gradually enhanced to achieve high fluorescence emission. Significantly, CD@BCOF-1-5/4 gains more than a 10-fold fluorescence intensity increase compared with the original BCOF-1 (Fig. 3A). The fluorescence quantum yield increases from 12% for BCOF-1 to 28% for CD@BCOF-1 (Fig. 4B).
In addition, the time-resolved photoluminescence (TRPL) spectra reveal that CD@BCOF-1 has a prolonged lifetime at the corresponding maximum excitation wavelengths (420 nm) (Fig. S11 and Table S3†). This result further demonstrates the effective energy transfer between CDs and COF structures.35 The time-resolved photoluminescence measurements show that the fluorescence lifetime of CDs is 4.248 ns (excitation at 380 nm). Under the same excitation (380 nm), the fluorescence lifetime for CD@BCOF-1-X decreases with the increase of doping amount of CDs (Fig. S12†).
Correspondingly, the calculated energy transfer (EnT) efficiency, opposite to the fluorescence lifetime, exhibits a linear increase as the doping amount of CDs in the CD@BCOFs increases (Fig. 3D).40,46 This observation provides conclusive evidence for an effective donor–acceptor FRET system. For CD@BCOF-1-5/4 with doping ratio of 5/4, the fluorescence lifetimes decreased to 0.506 ns and EnT efficiency increased to 88.08% (Fig. 3D), which resulted in the KEnT value of 1.74 × 109 S−1. As assessed from laser scanning confocal microscopy (LSCM), all the COF samples were brownish-yellow under sunlight. The solids had orange-red fluorescence under 365 nm of ultraviolet light irradiation, and the fluorescence emission intensities of CD@BCOF-1-5/4 were much stronger than the original BCOF-1 (Fig. 4D–G).
Because CD@BCOF-1-5/4 displayed the highest fluorescence intensity, it was named CD@BCOF-1 to aid in comparisons with the other CD-based COFs. In addition, the optimal content of 5/4 (sodium citrate to COF powder) was utilized to prepare the other CD-doped COF materials, denoted as CD@BCOF-2, CD@TCOF-1, CD@TCOF-2, and CD@TCOF-3 (Fig. 1). The FT-IR and XPS spectra indicate the presence of hydrogen-bonded CD particles in all COF networks. Compared with the FT-IR spectra for the initial monomers, the emerging CN stretching vibration demonstrates the occurrence of Schiff base reaction (Fig. S13†). After doping the CD particles into the COF architectures, red shifts were seen for the CN stretching vibration, from 1631 to 1625 cm−1 for CD@BCOF-1 and from 1656 to 1634 cm−1 for CD@TCOF-1, respectively. These variations suggest the CD particles are fixed in the framework through hydrogen bonding with CN groups (Fig. S6 and S13†). The lower binding energy (from 400.2 to 399.7 eV) belonging to the CN–N convolution peak in the N1s XPS spectra also proves the hydrogen bonding effect between CN groups and CDs in BCOF-1 and TCOF-1 (Fig. S17†). For BCOF-2, TCOF-2, and TCOF-3 with amide groups in the frameworks, there is a blue shift of CO stretching vibration in the FT-IR spectra after doping with CD nanocrystals. This change proves that the CDs are fixed on the carbonyl groups of COF skeletons through hydrogen bonds (Fig. S13†). In addition, CO (COFs) peaks in the O1s XPS spectra shift by 0.3, 0.25, and 0.5 eV in CD@BCOF-2, CD@TCOF-2, and CD@TCOF-3, respectively (Fig. S15†). These augmented binding energies confirm the existence of hydrogen bonds between CDs and CO groups in the COF networks. SEM and TEM images show a random distribution of CDs, and all CD@COFs exhibit excellent thermal stability (Fig. S18 and S19†). All of the characterizations for the CD@COF materials are listed in the ESI.†
Stability is an essential parameter for the practical application of inorganic nanocrystal-dynamic polymer assemblies. Therefore, the fluorescence intensities of CD@BCOF-1 and its supernatant were monitored after dispersion in water for 24 hours. It was found that scarcely any quantum dots overflowed from the COF solid. There was no variation of fluorescence intensity for CD@BCOF-1, confirming its high stability in an aqueous environment (Fig. S20†). In addition, the CD@COF samples could be stored at room temperature for three months without losing their fluorescent quality (Fig. S21†). The extraordinary stability of the CD@COF samples is attributed to the strong affinity (hydrogen bonding interaction) locking the distributed CD particles into the rigid structure, which prevents the collision-induced fluorescence self-quenching phenomenon.47
Similar to CD@BCOF-1, the emission spectrum for the donor CDs overlaps the excitation spectra for BCOF-2 and TCOF-1 (Fig. S22 and S23†). Therefore, a similar FRET phenomenon occurs for CD@BCOF-2 and CD@TCOF-1. They presented enhanced fluorescence intensities, from 8% (BCOF-2) to 12% (CD@BCOF-2) and from 12% (TCOF-1) to 18% (CD@TCOF-1), respectively (Fig. 4B). The time-resolved photoluminescence (TRPL) spectra for CD@BCOF-2 and CD@TCOF-1 indicated that the lifetime was prolonged due to the FRET energy transfer at the maximum excitation wavelength for BCOF-1 (λex = 420 nm) (Fig. S24†). At the maximum excitation wavelength for CDs (λex = 380 nm), the fluorescence lifetimes of CD@BCOF-2 and CD@TCOF-1 were reduced to 0.880 and 0.574 ns, respectively (Fig. S25 and Table S4†). The calculated EnT efficiency reached 79.28% and 86.49% for CD@BCOF-2 and CD@TCOF-1, respectively. Correspondingly, the KEnT values were 0.900 × 109 S−1 for CD@BCOF-2 and 1.506 × 109 S−1 for CD@TCOF-1, respectively. The energy transfer efficiency depends on the distance between the CD and COF materials.45 The different energy transfer efficiencies of CD@BCOF-1, CD@BCOF-2 and CD@TCOF-1 are caused by the different sizes provided by the COFs for CD particles. Hence, we observed significantly stronger fluorescence emission at 365 nm ultraviolet through LSCM photographs of CD@BCOF-2 and CD@TCOF-1 (Fig. S26†). All the conclusions indicated that BCOF-2 and TCOF-1 were able to be used as a platform to accommodate CD nanocrystals, and these assemblies successfully improved the fluorescence performance by means of FRET energy transfer.
In comparison, the excitation spectra for TCOF-2 and TCOF-3 overlapped the absorption spectrum for CD particles. Likewise, the emission spectrum for CDs partially overlapped the excitation spectra for TCOF-2 and TCOF-3. Subsequently, the excitation energy of COFs or CDs was absorbed by CD or COF species, respectively. This internal filter effect indicates a failure of the FRET mechanism for both CD-doped TCOF-2 and TCOF-3 systems, leading to the fluorescence quenching of the CD@COF materials (Fig. S27†).48 Significantly, CD@BCOF-1 exhibits an extraordinary solid-state fluorescence quantum yield that approaches the highest level of fluorescence materials, including TFPB-DHzDs,49 Eu3+/Tb3+@1,50 and Tf-DHzDPr.49 It is much higher than those of traditional porous materials, such as ZJU 28@DSM/AF,51 Mg-CP@CuI,52 and 10%Eu-SMOF-1 (Fig. 4C).53
Copper is a constituent element of human hemocyanin, which has an important influence on the functions of blood, brain, and other central nervous system components. Changes in copper homeostasis will mutate proteins and destroy the liver and nervous system; many diseases are related to the concentration of copper, for instance, Wilson's disease.54 Therefore, the sensitive detection of copper ions is critical for healthcare and environmental monitoring.47 As reported previously, COF architectures offer considerable host–guest chemistry for guest molecules. The N atoms from the adjacent COF layers will concentrate a large number of metal ions through coordination bonds.7,8 Taking advantage of the COF platform, CD@BCOF-1 with a strong emission was selected as a fluorescence detector (Fig. 5).
Solutions of CDs and CD@BCOF-1 with the same PL intensity (3 mL) were added to the same amounts of Cu2+ ions (30 μL, 0.1 mol L−1). CD@BCOF-1 displayed a specific quenching effect for Cu2+ ions (Fig. 5A). The quenched PL intensity (ΔI) of CD@BCOF-1 induced by Cu2+ ions was more obvious than that of CDs. Moreover, the peak position in the emission spectrum was not changed, but the fluorescence lifetime became shorter, indicating the dynamic quenching mode (Fig. S28†). The mechanism was caused by the transition of Cu2+ ions from the excited electronic state to d orbit state, resulting in the non-radiation quenching.
The CD@BCOF-1 sensing system has a comprehensive response range for copper ions. Fitting with eqn (3) in the ESI,† as the concentration changes within the range of 10−7 to 10−8 M, we can obtain the simulated spectral curve F0/F = 1.5003Q + 0.9985 (R2 = 0.998). At a signal-to-noise ratio of 3, the detection limit of the CD@BCOF-1 sensor is 6.60 × 10−9 mol L−1 (Fig. S29†). It is ca. 150 times more sensitive than the BCOF-1 sensor (detection limit of 9.92 × 10−7 mol L−1; Fig. S30†). This higher detection sensitivity is caused by the ordered channels, together with the vast accessible surface, which provides a platform for the full interaction between CD@BCOF-1 and enriched Cu2+ ions. At least 57% reduced fluorescence intensity is detected after CD@BCOF-1 was exposed to Cu2+ ions (10−3 mol L−1). Significantly, the quenching capability maintains its reduced state after 9 minutes of exposure (Fig. S31†).
The selective detection of Cu2+ ions against other interfering ions is necessary for practical application. Various metal ions common in the human body, including Ag+, K+, Ba2+, Ca2+, Co2+, Mg2+, Ni2+, Zn2+, Al3+, and Fe3+, were tested at a concentration of 10−3 mol L−1. As observed in Fig. S32,† there are no apparent changes in PL intensity in the presence of various interfering ions. In the presence of Cu2+ ions, the fluorescence of CD@BCOF-1 is immediately quenched, suggesting the high selectivity of CD@BCOF-1 for Cu2+ ions. Specifically, the fluorescence quenching appearance of the solid powder can be visually observed from LSCM images in the presence of 10−3 mol L−1 Cu2+ ions (Fig. 5B).
As a result of its precious stability, excellent selectivity, and high sensitivity, the CD@BCOF-1 fluorescence sensor was developed for the practical application of trace detection of Cu2+ ions. Wilson's disease can be diagnosed by testing for the presence of Cu2+ ions in urine, as the peak value for a healthy person is about 0.6 μmol L−1; urinary copper usually exceeds 1.6 μmol L−1 in patients with symptoms; children who take copper-discharge drugs will have concentrations above 25.0 μmol L−1.55 Therefore, three concentrations were configured based on actual human urine spiked with copper ions. After CD@BCOF-1 powder was dispersed on a filter paper, we observed that the paper sensor became orange-red under ultraviolet light (λex = 365 nm). However, the fluorescence intensity visibly changed in the 1.6 μmol L−1 copper ion solution; and it was nearly quenched in the presence of 25.0 μmol L−1 copper ion solution (Fig. 5C). This apparent change demonstrates that CD@BCOF-1 exhibits excellent sensing for copper ions at very low levels and is therefore a promising tool for medical diagnosis and treatment.
Footnote |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available. See DOI: 10.1039/d0sc04359a |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2020 |