Tsai-Wei
Chuo
,
Jyun-Ting
Hou
and
Ying-Ling
Liu
*
Department of Chemical Engineering, National Tsing Hua University, 300044 Hsinchu, Taiwan. E-mail: liuyl@mx.nthu.edu.tw; Fax: +886-3-5715408; Tel: +886-3-5711450
First published on 4th May 2021
Dynamic covalent bonds, particularly the ones exhibiting bond-breaking and bond-regeneration under ambient conditions, are attractive for the design and application of smart materials. This study demonstrates that the Meldrum's acid-based ketene chemistry is an effective approach to build up dynamic N-hindered amide bonds effectively workable at ambient conditions and under sunlight. The corresponding polyamides have been applied for sunlight-driven and self-repairing polymeric materials, and anticorrosion coatings. In addition to exhibiting sunlight-driven and self-repairing features on scratched surfaces, a high anticorrosion recovery of about 97% has been recorded. A smart anticorrosion coating requiring less maintenance is demonstrated.
Repairable polymers, being effectively workable under sunlight irradiation and/or at around ambient conditions, are attractive to integrate the autonomous and intrinsic self-healing features in the polymers. The repairing action could be achieved under a natural environment without additional stimuli and trigger factors. Self-healing polymers under an ambient environment, which employ dynamic-covalent diarylbibenzofuranone bonds13,14 and boronic esters,15,16 have been reported. On the other hand, the sensitivity of the dynamic covalent bonds towards sunlight irradiation could be enhanced by decreasing the bond strengths of the UV-responsive linkages. One approach is the introduction of an electron-donating group, which could effectively lower the disulfide bond dissociation energy. One example is the disulfide-bond-based sunlight-driven self-healing polymers.17 Similar strategies have been applied to thermal-responsive dynamic bonds. The incorporation of bulky substituents to urea bonds could significantly lower the bond dissociation energy of the hindered urea linkage, consequently making the urea bond dynamic and suitable for building up reversible and self-healing polymers.18,19 Although sterically hindered amide bonds also exhibit similar features,20 the preparation and application of dynamic-hindered amide bonds is somewhat restricted.21 Unlike hindered urea linkages, which could be formed with a hindered amine and an isocyanate groups,18 the formation of hindered amide bonds employs highly reactive ketene groups reacting with a hindered amine. Due to the high reactivity and poorly-controlled characteristic of the ketene groups, the developments of dynamic amide bond-based polymers are critically limited.
Meldrum's acid (MA) groups could convert to ketene groups via a thermolysis reaction with the evolution of CO2 and acetone.22 The MA-mediated ketene chemistry provides an effective and controllable approach of employing ketene groups in polymer synthesis and functionalization.23–26 In this study, we explored the first example of self-repairing polymers based on the dynamic N-hindered amide linkages through the MA-mediated ketene chemistry. The polyamides show sunlight-driven self-repairing property and are effective additives for introducing self-repairing features to anticorrosion coatings. The resulting coating shows a 97% recovery of anticorrosion efficiency under sunlight and ambient environment.
The 3 crosslinked samples were cut using a knife. The cut samples were applied to self-repairing tests (Fig. 1). The cut CR-PDMS sample did not demonstrate any repairing ability under the operation condition (80 °C for 24 h). In contrast, the cut pieces of CR-PAm-I and CR-PAm-II could recombine together to exhibit efficient self-repairing features. CR-PAm-I demonstrates a better self-repairing ability compared to CR-PAm-II, although CR-PAm-II has bulky substituents attached to the dynamic amide linkages. This result might be attributed to the relatively high electron-donating ability of the t-butyl groups of CR-PAm-II, compared to the i-propyl groups of CR-PAm-I. The electron-donating effects would strengthen the C–N bonds of the amide linkages of CR-PAm-II. The self-repairing tests on CR-PAm-I have been carried out under numerous conditions. The relatively high self-repairing efficiency was found at 80 °C due to the relatively high mobility of the decrosslinked polymer chains at high temperatures. Moreover, the self-repairing ability of CR-PAm-I under ambient conditions (under sunlight at daytime and at room temperature (about 25 °C) at night) is noteworthy. The sunlight-driven self-repairing ability of CR-PAm-I is further examined with an Instron (Fig. 2). The sunlight-driven repaired sample shows a strength of about 0.028 MPa, which is about 31% of the value recorded on the original sample. Since the CR-PAm-I sample was fully cut into 2 pieces, which were then recombined into one piece at a simple contact mode under the self-repairing condition, the resistance to the applied stress of the repaired sample is high enough to support the self-repairing ability. As the repaired sample obtained at 25 °C for 24 h (without sunlight treatment) only shows a strength of about 0.011 MPa, the sunlight treatment brings a positive effect on the promotion of the self-repairing efficiency of the CR-PAm-I sample. The sunlight-driven and self-repairing ability of CR-PAm-I is demonstrated. CR-PAm-I could be the first example of sunlight-driven and self-repairing polyamides since most reported cases are disulfide-based polymers.17,29,30
Fig. 1 Photographs showing the self-repairing tests on the crosslinked polyamide samples under different conditions. The tests on the crosslinked PDMS is included for a comparison. |
Fig. 2 Stress–strain curves of CR-PAm-I samples in self-repairing tests. The original sample was cut into 2 pieces and then merged again under the repairing conditions shown in the plot. |
The reversible reaction of the hindered amide groups, from the reaction between a secondary amine with bulky substituents and a ketene group, has been examined with a model reaction between a methylated MA compound (MAM) and diamine I. The reaction has been traced via NMR (Fig. 3). After being heated at 140 °C for 3 min, the occurrence of the MA thermolysis reaction is characterized by the evolution of acetone22 showing the resonance peak at δ = 2.16 ppm and the C3-ketene group at δ = 1.21 ppm. The reaction of diamine I and the ketene group forms the corresponding hindered amide groups, showing resonance peaks at δ = 1.41 ppm ((C3)2CH–N), δ = 3.05 ppm (–C2–N–C(O)), and δ = 3.42 ppm ((CH3)2C–N). The obtained amide sample was then heated at 45 °C. In the corresponding 1H NMR spectrum, the intensities of the resonance peaks associated with the hindered amide groups (δ = 3.05 ppm and δ = 3.42) decrease significantly. The increase in the intensities of peaks at δ = 1.07 ppm, δ = 2.55 ppm, and δ = 2.66 ppm indicates the regeneration of the isopropyl group-substituted secondary amine. The interchange reaction between the amide and amine groups has been further examined with 13C NMR. The amide group ((O)–N) exhibits a resonance peak at about δ = 167 ppm. This peak disappears for the sample being heated at 45 °C, indicating the occurrence of the scissoring reaction of amide bonds.
The reversible feature of the above-mentioned reaction has also been examined through tracing the reaction between PDMS-MA and diamine I via FTIR spectroscopy (Fig. 4). PDMS-MA was heated at 270 °C for 5 min to demonstrate the formation of ketene groups at 2100 cm−1.22 After being mixed with diamine I, the peak intensity of ketene groups decreases gradually. Moroever, the amide absorption peak at 1650 cm−1 is observed. The changes in the amide group absorption with the increase in temperature have been recorded. The absorption intensity of the hindered amide groups decreases and that of the secondary amine absorption increases significantly in the spectra recorded at about 35 to 45 °C, indicating the occurrence of the amide bond dissociation reaction. The amide absorption regains its intensity while the sample is being cooled to low temperatures (about 20 °C). The absorption intensity decreases again in the second heating run. The results support the reversibility of the amide bond dissociation and reformation in the heating–cooling processes.
The results discussed above support to (i) MA-possessing polymers are potential precursors for the preparation of crosslinked polymers possessing dynamic amide bonds and (ii) the corresponding dynamic amide are effective for building up self-repairing polymers workable under ambient conditions. One of the potential applications of the as-prepared material has been examined as sunlight-driven and self-repairing car paint.28 A commercial product of scratch-repairing car paint is utilized as the matrix with various amounts of CR-PAm-I.31 The self-repairing car paint samples are coded as SR_CP-X, where X denotes the weight fraction of CR-PAm-I of the sample. SR_CP-X samples have been coated on cold-rolled stainless steel (CRS) pieces for self-repairing and anticorrosion tests. The sample surfaces were cut with a knife and then applied to 2 different self-repairing processes. One is at 25 °C for 24 h without being exposed to sunlight, and the other is under sunlight (outdoor temperature is about 25–30 °C) for 10 h and then at 25 °C in dark for another 14 h. The results are collected in Fig. 5. The pristine car paint does not exhibit self-repairing property under both treatment conditions, as there are no obvious changes on the cut print after the treatment. For SR_CP-20 and SR_CP-40, the samples do not exhibit quick self-repairing feature at 25 °C for 24 h due to their low CR-PAm-I contents. Nevertheless, the samples under the sunlight treatment show certain extents of recovery of the cut prints. The sunlight treatment could enhance the self-repairing efficiency due to the increased temperatures of the samples under sunlight. The samples of SR_CP-60 exhibit a good self-repairing property. Nevertheless, the self-repairing performance of the pure CR-PAm-I sample (SR_CP-100) is not as high as SR_CP-60, particularly for the sample without sunlight treatment, due to the fact that the highly crosslinked structure of SR_CP-100 needs a relatively long time for chain motion and morphological repairing.
Fig. 5 SEM micrographs showing the self-repairing behaviors of the SR_CP-X samples (CR-PAm-I modified car paints). |
PAm-I has been used as an agent to impart self-repairing properties to a commercial product of car paint. The self-repairing property of the modified car paints (SR_CP-X samples coated on CRS pieces) have been evaluated with their anticorrosion performance with experimental data from both of the Tafel plots (corrosion rate (CR) and protection efficiency (PE)) and Bode plots.32 The anticorrosion performance could be identified with the peak values of the current in Tafel plots (Fig. 6). The neat car paint has a high anticorrosion performance with a protection efficiency of about 99.92% (Table 1). The addition of CR-PAm-I to the car paint results in a slight decrease in the protection efficiency to 99.6% due to the fact that the structure design of CR-PAm-I is not mainly for the anticorroison aspect. In further studies, the incorporation of the electroactive feature32 to CR-PAm-I might effectively address this issue. On the other hand, the neat car paint does not exhibit repairable features. Once some pinholes formed with the coating, corrosion might take place starting at the pinholes and then spread over the steel beneath the coating. Corrosion would take place readily even though the coating has a high protection efficiency. Since the neat car paint does not exhibit any self-repairing ability on the recovery of the anticorrosion property from the corresponding cut sample, the addition of CR-PAm-I to the car paint successfully introduces self-healing ability and anticorrosion recovery to the employed car paint. SR_CP-100 exhibits a certain anticorrosion ability with a CR of 4.7 μm year−1, which is not as good as that of the neat car paint and could be attributed to the relatively poor adhesion strength towards the CRS surface. Although the self-healing efficiency increases with an increase in the dynamic amide bond contents, the anticorrosion efficiency would decrease with the increase in the CR-PAm-I contents. Hence, SR_CP-20 (with 20 wt% of CR-PAm-I) is the optimum sample with a balance between the self-healing ability and anticorrosion efficiency. The partial recovery of the anticorrosion properties of SR_CP-20 is noteworthy. From the data shown in Table 1, the neat car paint shows a high efficiency of anticorrosion with a CR of 0.21 μm year−1 (the CR value recorded on naked CRS: 264 μm year−1) and a PE of 99.92%. The best result has been found with the SR_CP-20 sample. SR_CP-20 shows a CR and PE of 1.0 μm year−1 and 99.60%, respectively, indicating that an addition of 20 wt% of CR-PAm-I might slightly reduce the anticorrosion performance of the used car paint. Nevertheless, the anticorrosion efficiency of SR_CP-20 is still high for practical application. Moreover, applying a knife cut to the SR_CP-20-coated CRS sample significantly reduces its anticorrosion performance with an increase in the CR value to 38 μm year−1 and a reduced PE value of 85.5%. Unlike the neat car paint sample, the cut CR_CP-20 sample could be repaired under the treatment process mentioned above. After being repaired, a recovery of anticorrosion performance has been observed with a CR and PE of 2.0 μm year−1 and 99.24%, respectively. In terms of both CR and PE, a high anticorrosion performance recovery of about 97% is obtained. The results demonstrate the successful development of sunlight-driven self-repairing anticorrosion paints.
Fig. 6 Tafel plots of (a) neat SR_CP-0 (neat car paint) and (b) SR_CP-20 recorded in the self-repairing process. |
Sample | Corrosion rate (μm year−1) | Protection efficiency (%) | Resistance at 0.1 Hz (Ω) |
---|---|---|---|
Naked CRS | 264 | — | 430 |
SR_CP-0 | 0.21 | 99.92 | 391900 |
SR_CP-0, cut | 54 | 79.28 | 948 |
SR_CP-0, repaired | 13.7 | 47.92 | 670 |
SR_CP-20 | 1.0 | 99.60 | 117700 |
SR_CP-20, cut | 38 | 85.50 | 2588 |
SR_CP-20, repaired | 2.0 | 99.24 | 31460 |
The anticorrosion properties of the as-prepared samples have also been evaluated via electrochemical impedance spectroscopy (EIS).32 The resistance at low frequency (Zo at 0.1 Hz) read from the Bode plots could be utilized as an index for the anticorrosion performance (Fig. 7). Compared to the Zo value (430 Ω) of the naked CRS sample, the high Zo value (391900 Ω) of SR_CP-0 suggests the high anticorrosion performance of the pure car paint. The original car paint could not regain the anticorrosion property after being cut. On the other hand, although the Zo value (117700 Ω) of SR_CP-20 is not as high as the neat car paint, the addition of 20% of CR-PAm-I to the car paint could bring the self-repairing feature and anticorrosion recovery ability to the car paint, as a regain of the Zo value from 2588 Ω to 31460 Ω is observed. A sunlight-driven and self-repairing paint and anticorrosion coating needing very less maintenance has been demonstrated.
Fig. 7 Bode plots of (a) neat SR_CP-0 (neat car paint) and (b) SR_CP-20 recorded in the self-repairing process. |
The surface temperatures of cars parked outdoor on a sunny day in April in Taiwan (atmosphere temperature: 31 °C at 13:00) have been recorded. The temperatures recorded on a white car and a black car are 47 °C and 70 °C, respectively. The temperatures are high enough to trigger the self-repairing processes of CR-PAm-I. It is concluded that the CR-PAm-I could perform its function of sunlight-driven repairable coating under ambient conditions.
CR (mm year−1) = (0.13 × Icorr × (equivalent wt of CRS))/((area of CRS) × (density of CRS)) | (1) |
PE (%) = (Icorr − Icorr(CRS))/Icorr × 100% | (2) |
A Metrohm Autolab FRA2 electrochemical impedance spectroscopy (EIS) instrument was employed for the EIS measurements. An SCE and a carbon rode were utilized as the reference electrode and the counter electrode, respectively. A 3.5 wt% NaCl(aq) was applied as the electrolyte.
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2021 |