Pengfei Zhaiab,
Chengying Shia,
Shengxiang Zhao*b,
Wenbin Liua,
Wenxin Wangc and
Lina Yaob
aXi'an High-tech Research Institute, Xi'an 710025, People's Republic of China. E-mail: zhaipengfei104@163.com; shichengying104@163.com
bXi'an Modern Chemistry Research Institute, Xi'an 710065, People's Republic of China. E-mail: xamcri@126.com
cSichuan Honghua Industrial Co., Ltd., Chengdu 611130, People's Republic of China
First published on 4th May 2021
(H2dabco)[NH4(ClO4)3] (DAP, dabco = 1,4-diazabicyclo[2.2.2]octane) is a recently synthesized ammonium perchlorate-based molecular perovskite energetic material. The high-symmetry perovskite configuration assembles the oxidant ClO4− and fuel H2dabco2+ into a compact cubic crystal, realizing a high energy-releasing efficiency. In this study, the thermal decomposition of DAP has been investigated by thermogravimetric analysis (TG) and differential scanning calorimetry (DSC) coupled with Fourier transform infrared (FTIR) spectroscopy and mass spectroscopy (MS). The TG-DSC profiles show that DAP has an intense one-stage heat release process with a weight loss of 94.7%. The evolved gas products are identified as H2O, CO2, CO, HCl, HCN, NH3, HNCO by FTIR spectrum, in which the infrared characteristic peak at 2283 and 2250 cm−1 is clarified not from N2O and assigned to HNCO. The principal products are H2O and CO2 together with significant amounts of HCl, HCN, NH3 in MS, while few nitrogen oxides and O2 are detected. The experimental results show that organic components have been the prominent media for the degradation of ClO4−. To refine the mechanism observed in experiment, ab initio molecular dynamics simulations are carried out to reveal the atomistic reaction mechanisms. The decomposition of DAP starts with proton transfer from NH4+ and H2dabco2+ to ClO4−. The deprotonated carbon skeleton is preferable to NH3 in capturing O atoms, realizing a faster consumption of O atoms. Amounts of H atoms enter the environment being active free radicals, realizing an efficient autocatalytic chain propagation of degradation of ClO4−. The atomistic thermal decomposition reaction mechanism of DAP uncovers the role of organic components in promoting the degradation of ClO4−, which will help improve the synthesis strategy of molecular perovskite energetic materials with improved performance.
Another method is crystal engineering, which assembles AP molecules with appropriate ligand molecules at the molecular level to obtain the desired improvement. Cocrystal is a new crystal formed by combining two or more known neutral molecules at a certain stoichiometric ratio through non-bonding interaction.4 Three cocrystals of AP and crown ethers – AP/18-crown-6, AP/benzo-18-crown-6 and AP/dibenzo-18-crown-6, have been synthesized.5 The last two cocrystals have a single obvious exothermic process at a lower temperature, with heat release increased to 1304.2 J g−1 and 1488.4 J g−1. Looking into the spatial configuration, the large and stretched ring skeletons of crown ethers are packed disorderly and thus the space of crystal is filled with many free volumes. Consequently, the crystal density is decreased far below that of AP and so is the corresponding energy density. Therefore, although the heat release of the cocrystal is increased relative to AP, which can be attributed to the catalytic effect of organic component and its exothermic combustion, the low crystal density limits the heat release to a low level.
Different from the direct “mixing” of cocrystal, molecular perovskites assemble molecules by introducing organic molecular unit into the perovskite architecture.6 (H2dabco)[NH4(ClO4)3] (DAP, dabco = 1,4-diazabicyclo[2.2.2]octane) introduces organic cation H2dabco2+ as A component, with NH4+ cation as B component and ClO4− anion as X component, to assemble a high symmetry ternary perovskite ABX3 structure,7,8 which realize a homogeneous mixing of fuel and oxidant at the molecular level.9 The organic component H2dabco2+ cation also has a ring skeleton but small and compact. And the electrostatic interaction between cation and anion is stronger than neutral molecules. Thus, the compact cubic crystal has a density close to AP, far above that of cocrystal. Furthermore, DAP is easier to be modified by replacing A, B or X component.10,11 Compared with AP, DAP has a lower thermal decomposition temperature and a single intense exothermic process, and its heat release has reached the level of nano-additives of carbon materials (>3000J g−1).12,13 These lay a good foundation for the further modification and application of DAP.14,15
The catalytic performance of nano-additives depends on the effective contact area and the number of active sites with AP. Simply mixing their nanoparticles or making them porous nanocomposites, in essence, is physically mixed and subject to the strength of interaction and the uniformity of dispersion. The cocrystals of AP and crown ethers suffer from low crystal density, so more types of cocrystal need to be synthesized with more suitable ligand molecules. DAP seemingly integrate the advantages of all above methods. More importantly, it is evident that the organic components play a key role in the thermal decomposition of AP, which need to be further revealed by studying the thermal decomposition mechanism of DAP.
The structure changes of DAP have been studied by in situ FTIR in heating process.13 The cage skeleton constructed by NH4+ and ClO4− ions decomposes before the organic moiety and determines the decomposition process. The combustion flames photographed with high speed photography and the gas release process recorded by TG-FTIR show a fierce one-stage energy-releasing effect of DAP.12 However, the chemical reactions during the decomposition process of DAP still remain unclear. The infrared characteristic peaks of gas products in the FTIR spectra show significant changes compared with AP.12 But the gas composition has not been identified, nor has the reason been given for these changes. To examine the thermal decomposition reaction process of DAP, thermogravimetric analysis and differential scanning calorimetry coupled with Fourier transform infrared spectroscopy and mass spectroscopy (TG-DSC-FTIR-MS) experiments and ab initio molecular dynamics simulations are carried out to identify the evolved gas products. The concentration–time profile of gas products gives clues about the elementary reactions,16 while the ab initio molecular dynamics simulations trace the breaking and formation of bond on atomic scale.17–19 Theoretical calculations can well make up for the insufficiency of macroscopic experiments on the exploration of microscopic mechanism, while the corresponding results of macroscopic experiments verify the reliability of theoretical calculations.
For comparison, the decomposition of AP is also simulated. The lattice parameters of AP (CCDC No. 725655) determined by Kumar et al.33 are used to construct the crystal model. Since the AP unit cell contains only 40 atoms, a 2 × 1 × 1 supercell constructed from the optimized unit cell is used for the sing le Gamma point ab initio molecular dynamics simulation, while all other parameter settings are consistent with that of DAP.
Fig. 2 PXRD of crystal model and prepared samples for DAP (red line for crystal model, black line for prepared samples). |
Fig. 3 Weight loss and heat release for DAP decomposed at the heating rate of 10 °C min−1 (black line for TG, red line for DSC). |
The infrared characteristic peaks in the FTIR spectrum correspond to certain characteristic vibrations of gas molecules which are fingerprints to identify the chemical species of gas products. By comparing the infrared characteristic peaks of gas products of DAP at 381.8 °C (Fig. S1(b)†) with the standard gas infrared data provided in HITRAN2016 molecular spectroscopic database (Fig. S1(a)†),37 the gas components can be clearly identified to include CO2, CO, H2O, HCl, HCN, NH3. It should be noted that high temperature will broaden the infrared characteristic peaks of some gases, but the central locations are almost unchanged (Fig. S2†). Since the temperature of FTIR gas cell is only maintained at 210 °C, for the infrared characteristic peaks not overlapped, the temperature-induced uncertainty can be ignored. More difficult is the identification of HNCO and N2O, which are the key to understanding the thermal decomposition mechanism of DAP. N2O is a symbolic gas product for AP and has the strongest infrared characteristic peak at 2239 and 2204 cm−1 (Fig. S3†). For DAP, the infrared characteristic peak at 2283 and 2250 cm−1 (Fig. S1(b)†) is also the strongest and has a similar profile with that of N2O. Considering that DAP contains the same component with AP, it is easy to jump to conclusions and identify it as N2O. However, the latter has an obvious shift to high wavenumber region, which is more consistent with that of HNCO. At the same time, the second characteristic peak of N2O at 1303 and 1269 cm−1 is absent, while that of HNCO appears at 3525 cm−1. Furthermore, the infrared characteristic peaks of CO2 and HNCO are partially overlapped in the range of 2200–2400 cm−1, which is consistent with the FTIR spectrum in.16,38,39 The infrared characteristic peaks of CO2 and N2O are clearly not overlapped even under high temperature (Fig. S4†), which is consistent with the FTIR spectrum in.16,39 Therefore, the infrared characteristic peak at 2283 and 2250 cm−1 is assigned to HNCO. The gas products in the thermal decomposition process of DAP include CO2, CO, H2O, HCl, HCN, NH3, HNCO (Fig. 4).
Fig. 4 Evolution of gas products from FTIR spectrum for DAP decomposed at the heating rate of 10 °C min−1. |
The concentration–time profiles obtained from mass spectrum show the evolution of product fragments. In Fig. 5, the product fragments all concentrate at 381.8 °C, indicating a fierce thermal decomposition of DAP. It should be noted that the relative abundance of O2 (m/z = 32) shows a negative increase at 381.8 °C. O2 is a common gas product in the thermal decomposition process of AP.40 The rupture of Cl–O bond will produce many oxygen free radicals like O, O2 and O3. Their strong oxidation activity can oxidize NH3 into various nitrogen oxides, which is a representation of oxidizing ability of AP. The negative increase of O2 here indicates that there is no O2 newly generated, but the O2 from background gases is consumed by certain gas products. Considering that there is no fragments peak of CO (m/z = 28) in the mass spectrum, but the infrared characteristic peaks of CO do appear in the FTIR spectrum, it can be speculated that CO has been oxidized by O2 in mass spectrometer. On the other hand, the absence of O2 indicates that there may be few higher-order oxygen radicals generated in the thermal decomposition process of DAP. The single O radicals generated first from the rupture of Cl–O bond are quickly consumed, so there is no enough time for them to gather to higher-order oxygen radicals.
Fig. 5 Evolution of product fragments from MS for DAP decomposed at the heating rate of 10 °C min−1. |
The chemical species of product fragments at 381.8 °C are deduced from the mass-to-charge ratio (Table 2). Combined with FTIR spectrum, CO2, H2O, HCl, HCN, NH3 are confirmed to sole principal species, but there are no mass-to-charge ratios correspond to CO and HNCO. The absence of CO has been explained above. One possible reason for the absence of HNCO is that HNCO has been ionized to H2NCO+ (m/z = 44) by adding H+, who will be covered by the fragments peak of CO2, since there are many fragments of H+ in the mass spectrometer. In the molecular dynamics simulation, HNCO eventually exists in the form of HNCO H2NCO, indicating that it is easy for HNCO to capture another H. But high-precision mass spectrometry experiments are needed to confirm this. The relative abundance of primary product fragments is shown in Fig. 6. H2O has the largest abundance more than twice the second largest one of CO2, indicating a large amount of O atoms decomposed from ClO4− have been captured by H atoms. In the decomposition of AP, H2O is also aprincipal product.40 The decomposition of AP starts with the proton transfer from NH4+ to ClO4− and HClO4 is degraded from high-order oxychloride or oxyacid to low-order ones, in which H atoms play an important role in the autocatalytic chain propagation.41 Since the cage skeleton constructed by NH4+ and ClO4− ions determines the decomposition process of DAP,13 it can be speculated that the decomposition also start with the proton transfer from NH4+ to ClO4−. The presence of HClO and HClO2 indicates that the degradation of HClO4 is also an autocatalytic chain propagation from high-order oxychloride or oxyacid to low-order ones. More abundant H2O origins from the organic components and higher proportion of ClO4−. N2O has been identified not included in the gas products by FTIR spectrum. Although there are fragments peaks with m/z = 30 and 46, which possibly belong to NO and NO2 respectively, their abundance is too small. Therefore, nitrogen oxides, which are the main oxygen-consuming products in the decomposition of AP,34,35 have been replaced by carbon oxides. NH3, HCN and HCl have close and significant relative abundance. NH3 comes from the deprotonated NH4+. HCl is a symbolic product for the degradation of ClO4−. And HCN comes from the polyazine unit in the carbon-nitrogen heterocycle of H2dabco2+, which is a common decomposition product of carbon-nitrogen heterocyclic molecules like RDX, HMX and CL-20.16,42 HNCO often accompanies with HCN, which is derived from the amide unit after the carbon skeleton is oxidized by O atoms. Another important gas product generated from the decomposition of carbon-nitrogen heterocycle is CH2O. But it cannot be identified in the FTIR spectrum. The relative abundance of fragments with m/z = 30 is also much smaller than that of CO2. This indicates that H2dabco2+ may lose H atoms first before the ring skeleton breaks or is oxidized by O atoms. So H2dabco2+ is more stable than its precursor of dabco under the confinement of cage skeleton.
m/z | Ion current/×10−10 A | Species | m/z | Ion current/×10−10 A | Species |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
1 | 1.011 | H | 30 | 0.143 | NO, CH2O |
2 | 0.337 | H2 | 36 | 1.202 | HCl |
12 | 0.256 | C | 37 | 0.210 | 37Cl |
15 | 0.070 | NH, CH3 | 44 | 2.091 | CO2, N2O |
16 | 0.408 | O, NH2, CH4 | 45 | 0.07 | HCO2, HN2O |
17 | 1.359 | OH, NH3 | 46 | 0.021 | NO2 |
18 | 5.493 | H2O, NH4 | 52 | 0.083 | HClO |
25 | 0.036 | C2H | 68 | 0.003 | HClO2 |
26 | 0.492 | CN | |||
27 | 1.206 | HCN |
In the thermal decomposition process of ClO4−, the highly reactive transient radicals ClOx (x = 1–3) can only survive for a very short time and few of them can escape in the form of gas. Therefore, they can hardly be detected by FTIR and quadrupole electron impact MS (the MS used in the paper).
In the paper,36 the author summarized the detection results of various FTIR and MS methods on the thermal decomposition products of AP. Only the state-of-the-art single vacuum ultraviolet (VUV) photoionization coupled with reflectron time-of-flight mass spectrometry (PI-ReTOF-MS) can detect all ClOx (x = 1–3) radicals, though the intensity of signal is much weaker than that of primary gas products. The FTIR and quadrupole electron impact MS can hardly detect the ClOx (x = 1–3) radicals.
In the following simulations, the reason why ClOx (x = 1–3) seem to have good half-lives is that they are transformed continuously from ClO4−. When ClO4− is degraded completely, ClOx (x = 1–3) disappear almost at the same time. Therefore, a single ClOx can only survive for a very short time. Only HClO exists for a certain time after all ClOx (x = 1–4) and HClOx (x = 2–4) disappear, so it has a relatively good half-life. This is why for the only two HClOx detected by MS, the intensity of signal of HClO is much stronger than that of HClO2, but is still much weaker than that of primary gas products. This is consistent with detection results of AP, in which only HClO can be detected even with PI-ReTOF-MS.
Fig. 7 Evolution of key chemical species (a), free radicals and potential energy (b) for DAP decomposed at 3000 K. |
Fig. 8 Evolution of key chemical species (a), free radicals and potential energy (b) for AP decomposed at 3000 K. |
Footnote |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available. See DOI: 10.1039/d0ra10559g |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2021 |