Mara
Di Filippo
a,
Cristina
Trujillo
b,
Goar
Sánchez-Sanz
ac,
Andrei S.
Batsanov
d and
Marcus
Baumann
*a
aSchool of Chemistry, University College Dublin, Science Centre South, D04 N2E2, Dublin, Ireland. E-mail: marcus.baumann@ucd.ie
bTrinity Biomedical Sciences Institute, School of Chemistry, The University of Dublin, Trinity College, Dublin, Ireland
cIrish Centre for High-End Computing (ICHEC), Grand Canal Quay, Dublin 2, D02 HP83, Ireland
dDepartment of Chemistry, Durham University, DH1 3LE, South Road, Durham, UK
First published on 5th July 2021
Herein we report the discovery of a new photochemical cascade process through a flow-based strategy for intercepting diradicals generated from simple alkenes. This continuous process delivers a series of unprecedented polycyclic reaction products. Exploring the scope of this novel process revealed that this approach is general and affords a variety of structurally complex reaction products in high yields (up to 81%), short reaction times (7 min) and high throughputs (up to 5.5 mmol h−1). A mechanistic rationale is presented that is supported by computations as well as isolation of key intermediates whose identity is confirmed by X-ray crystallography. The presented photochemical cascade process demonstrates the discovery of new chemical reactivity and complex chemical scaffolds by continuously generating and intercepting high-energy intermediates in a highly practical manner.
Importantly, this has enabled the application of photochemical processes not only in academia but also in industry8 to bring about the functionalisation of valuable building blocks through previously elusive methods. Key to this development is thereby not only the development of photocatalysis as a field, but also the availability of cheap and monochromatic light emitting diodes (LEDs) as attractive light sources,9 and lastly the advent of new reactor technology to provide ready-to-use and standardised set-ups in batch10 and continuous flow mode.11
Whilst the use of blue light (ca. 450 nm, ca. 64 kcal mol−1) is commonly favoured in photoredox applications due to the tolerance of highly functionalised substrates, UV light still plays an important role in photochemistry. This can be seen in [2 + 2]-photocycloaddition processes of readily available alkenes affording important cyclobutanes as well as various photochemical rearrangements.3 Modern high-power LEDs emitting in the UV-A region (310–400 nm, ca. 71–92 kcal mol−1) are particularly interesting in view of replacing classical medium-pressure mercury lamps that do not provide monochromatic light, generate significant amounts of heat, and often require filters to block undesired wavelengths that would result in side-product formation.
Recent work by Noël and co-workers demonstrated the power of photocatalysed HAT processes using UV-A emitting LEDs to bring about the effective C–H functionalisation of unreactive alkanes such as methane, ethane and propane in a continuous manner.12 Additional studies by Booker-Milburn,13 Cochran14 and others15 clearly showcase the value of flow-based photochemistry exploiting uniform and selective irradiation processes to generate diverse targets in a scalable and effective manner.
Our own laboratory recently exploited a high-power LED lamp (tuneable 50–100 W) emitting at 365 nm to realise the clean generation of a set of quinolines16 (Scheme 1, top). In this application the direct irradiation of chalcones triggered isomerisation of the alkene and subsequent cyclocondensation. The replacement of a traditional medium-pressure mercury lamp with this high-power UV-A LED thereby minimised side-product formation, which increased reaction yields by 10–25% and furthermore enabled the telescoped hydrogenation of the quinolines to furnish a set of tetrahydroquinolines including the antimalarial alkaloid galipinine.
To study the fate of these entities under standardised photochemical conditions a Vapourtec E-series flow reactor (10 mL FEP coil, 1/16′′ i.d.) was exploited in combination with a high-power LED lamp emitting light at a wavelength of 365 nm (see ESI† for full details). This reactor set-up was advantageous as the LED power can be regulated between 50–100 W, while the flow processing allows for short and uniform light pathlength, narrow residence time distribution and thus excellent reproducibility. Initial efforts exploited piperonal-derived substrate 4a possessing a maximum absorbance (λmax) at 375 nm which closely matched the emission of the LED light source. Using the described set-up, a solution of 4a (50 mM in MeCN) was processed through the LED reactor set-up operating at 100 W with a residence time of 20 minutes. Pleasingly, TLC analysis indicated full conversion of 4a and formation of a major new product. Optimisation of this flow process quickly indicated that clean formation of this new product can be achieved using only 70 W lamp power, in combination with a shorter residence time of 7 minutes at a concentration of 80 mM while regulating the reactor temperature to 25–30 °C (Table 1). These findings indicate that shorter residence times minimise over-irradiation (i.e. secondary photo-reactions) through improved spatiotemporal control in the flow reactor, which renders the desired product in higher yields.
This new product was subsequently purified by silica gel chromatography rendering a beige solid that was then studied by various spectroscopic techniques to establish its chemical structure. 1H-NMR spectroscopy highlighted that a single entity had been obtained whereby the presence of diastereotopic methylene protons indicated a chiral, albeit racemic structure. Most notably, a set of four resonances was observed up-field of the methylendioxybenzene unit (5.8–6.8 ppm, see Fig. 1).
These four resonances integrated for one proton each and were part of two separate alkenes. Furthermore, a doublet with a coupling constant of 2.3 Hz was observed at 3.6 ppm (1 H), as well as an AB quartet at 3.5 ppm (2 × 1 H). This unexpected finding, together with the absence of the enone protons, pointed towards a set of secondary transformations that involved not only the alkene and alkyne moieties, but also the phenyl ring adjacent to the carbonyl in 4a. Analysis of 13C-NMR data along with various 2D NMR data corroborated this analysis suggesting that an unexpected and likely unprecedented photochemical cascade had taken place that transformed a benzene ring into two separate alkene moieties. High-resolution mass spectrometry confirmed a formula of the base peak of C22H21O3 (M + H+) which is identical to that of the substrate. UV-Vis spectroscopy revealed a diminished maximum absorbance of 348 nm indicating a less conjugated system compared to the substrate (Δλmax = 27 nm). While IR spectroscopy additionally indicated the presence of functionalities consistent with a conjugated ketone (1674 cm−1) as well as alkenes and alkanes, it was not possible to unambiguously establish the connectivity of this new structure.
To resolve this situation, the synthesis of this new photoproduct was scaled in flow mode to provide larger quantities for crystallisation and subsequent X-ray diffraction analysis. Gratifyingly, operating the flow process under the previously established conditions for 1 h reproduced the outcome of the initial experiments and rendered a total of 1.85 g of this product after purification. This not only equates to a high productivity of 5.5 mmol h−1, but moreover demonstrates the straightforward scalability of continuous photochemical processes.18 Attempts to crystallise this material were soon met with success and led to identifying the molecular structure based on single crystal X-ray diffraction. Fig. 2 shows this structure,19 which confirmed the prior spectroscopic data and highlighted the formation of a new fused pentacyclic ring system (excluding the methylenedioxy ring).
Fig. 2 Molecular structure of photo-cascade product 7a (CCDC-2072295). |
The structure of this unique architecture is characterised by a cyclopentenone with fused cyclopentene and cyclobutene rings that are joint by a methine carbon and two adjacent quaternary carbon atoms (C6 and C7, Fig. 2). The cyclobutene ring and butyl chain display a cis relationship imparting a distinct three-dimensional shape to this structure. It is noted that this tricyclic subunit of 7a occurs in the natural product tricycloclavulone20 (8, Fig. 3), though published studies describing the construction of this scaffold unsurprisingly require significantly more steps compared to our new photochemical cascade.
Having demonstrated proof of principle for this new photochemical cascade we next wished to study the scope of this process. To this end we modified the scaffold of substrate 4 incorporating different appendages on both aryl moieties and the alkyne. Pleasingly the reaction tolerated different groups on the initial 2-iodo benzaldehyde unit, including 3,4-(methylene)dioxy, 3,4-dimethoxy and even unsubstituted systems (R1 = H, Fig. 4). A distinct blue-shift of the maximum absorbance (λmax) for substrates 4h–j to ca. 310 nm was observed, however a shoulder reaching as far as 360 nm appears to provide sufficient overlap with light emitted from the UV-LED. It was furthermore established that variations on the alkyne including phenyl and alkyl groups are well tolerated. However, placing a cyclopropyl ring next to the alkyne did not provide the desired product (7g), which is consistent with the involvement of nearby radicals.21 Lastly, introduction of substituents on the benzoyl moiety is possible providing the desired products (7d, 7j) with three contiguous quaternary centres. In all these cases the desired products were isolated in high chemical yields. It was furthermore established that the cascade products possess significantly lowered λmax values compared to the substrates (300–345 nm) which is consistent with the apparent loss of conjugation.
The next part of our study concerned probing the mechanism by which these unique photocascade products are generated. Specifically, this entailed the fate of the aryl ring that is transformed into the unusual bicyclo[3.2.0]hepta-2,6-diene scaffold. As we initially hypothesised that this ring system may have arisen from a cycloheptatriene by a photochemical 4π-electrocyclisation process, we attempted to experimentally find proof for this proposal. We therefore wished to again exploit the benefits of continuous flow processing allowing for fine tuning of reaction conditions based on superb spatiotemporal control.22
Therefore, the flow process was repeated for the photo-cascade of 4a, however, utilising conditions that would lead to incomplete conversion of the substrate. An experiment was thus run in which a more concentrated solution of 4a (100 mM MeCN) was processed with only 5 minute residence time at 50 W lamp power (Scheme 2).
Analysing the 1H-NMR spectrum of the crude product, we were pleased to identify a new species (13a, ca. 65%) besides the previous photo-cascade product (7a, ca. 35%). Purification by chromatography rendered this new product as a yellow solid (λmax = 383 nm) in 50% isolated yield. HR-MS analysis confirmed that it was an isomer of 7a (molecular formula: C22H20O3). In addition, the 1H-NMR spectrum of this compound clearly showed that the resonance for the methine proton at 3.6 ppm was absent, while a total of five olefinic resonances were visible (5.9–7.1 ppm; Fig. 5). COSY and NOESY experiments subsequently revealed that these five protons are part of the same spin system, which together with all other data suggested this species to be the cycloheptatriene intermediate 13a.
Fig. 5 Molecular structure (CCDC-2072296) and partial 1H-NMR spectrum of cycloheptatriene 13a (CDCl3, 500 MHz). |
The molecular structure of 13a was subsequently secured through single crystal X-ray diffraction analysis19 and confirmed both our initial hypothesis and structural assignment.
Considerable amounts of 13a (ca. 250 mg) were soon prepared allowing for a final test to prove its role as a late-stage intermediate. Pleasingly, subjecting a solution of 13a (80 mM MeCN) to the regular photoreaction conditions (70 W, 7 minutes residence time, Scheme 3) afforded 7a as sole product in 97% purity (by 1H-NMR).
To shed some light on the mechanistic pathway operational for this photo-cascade process we furthermore performed DFT calculations as implemented in Gaussian 16.23 Specifically, calculations at the M062X24/6-31+G(d,p)25 level of theory in a solvent model SMD (acetonitrile) at 298 K were used and subsequently refined for single point energies using M062X/6-311+G(d,p)25 (acetonitrile). These calculations suggest a first step in which the alkene π-bond initially undergoes homolysis to a diradical species (int2) that is intercepted by the alkyne through a 5-exo-dig cyclisation step (Fig. 6).26 The resulting intermediate (int3) undergoes H-atom translocation to render a fully substituted cyclic enone with an adjacent carbene (int4).27 This carbene species then adds across the adjacent benzene ring to render a norcaradiene ring system.28 These calculations show the possibility of both a concerted (in the singlet state) and stepwise (via switch to triplet intermediate) pathway for this process. Subsequent 6π-electrocyclisation occurs in a conrotatory sense under photochemical conditions to furnish cycloheptatriene 13a, which upon disrotatory 4π-electrocyclisation yields the scaffold of 7a.
Fig. 6 Free-energy profile for the studied reaction of substrate 4a; S and T refer to singlet and triplet states, respectively. |
As depicted in Fig. 6, the cycloheptatriene species (int6) is thermodynamically more stable than the final cascade product, which is in good agreement with observations that solutions of this material (e.g.13a) are stable for several weeks under laboratory conditions. However, the high-power UV-LED lamp provides enough energy to overcome this barrier towards the final products. Diminished absorbance of the photoproduct 7a is the likely cause for the observed irreversibility of the final step in this cascade rendering the mechanism as shown in Scheme 3.
Armed with this mechanistic understanding we embarked on a final extension to probe the effect of further substituents in the para position of the aryl enone fragment. Both electron donating (R = OMe) and electron-withdrawing (R = F, CN, CF3) groups were chosen to complement the previously studied cases (R = H, Me) where the substrates uniformly featured the piperonyl moiety as well as a propyl chain introduced with the alkyne. Using the para-fluoro substrate quickly established the formation of the anticipated polycyclic scaffold 7 (Fig. 7) in good yield. However, when trialling either the methoxy derivative, or the electron-deficient nitrile and trifluoromethyl variants, the corresponding cycloheptatriene products 13 were obtained as principal products. These materials were found to absorb light in the UV-A region which may lead to secondary photoreactions and likely accounts for the modest yields (see ESI† for details). The results imply that the electronic effect of the para substituent is not decisive in determining the reaction outcome. To understand these results, we turned again to computations at the same level of theory as before which highlighted the interplay between the energy barrier (13 → 7) as well as the relative stability of the ultimate product with regards to the cycloheptatriene species. In the case of the p-methoxy system (13l), a relatively low energy barrier together with the reversibility of this reaction favours the more stable 7-membered ring as the product. On the other hand, the energy barrier for both the trifluoromethyl and nitrile system is excessively high thus precluding the final step to occur efficiently. Conversely, in case of the para-substituent being a proton or methyl group (e.g.7a, 7d) the energy barrier is surmountable under the reaction conditions whilst a significantly lower absorbance of the product impedes the reverse reaction.
Fig. 7 Correlation between energy barrier and product formation (a yield for butyl side chain; b attainable in 50% yield, see Scheme 2). |
Footnote |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available. CCDC 2072295 and 2072296. For ESI and crystallographic data in CIF or other electronic format see DOI: 10.1039/d1sc02879k |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2021 |