K. S.
Savitha
b,
M.
Senthil Kumar
a and
R. L.
Jagadish
*b
aAlumnus, Department of Chemistry, Indian Institute of Technology Madras, Chennai, India. E-mail: senthiliit@gmail.com
bDepartment of Polymer Science Sir M. Visvesvaraya Postgraduate Centre Tubinakere, Mandya, India. E-mail: rljagadish@yahoo.com
First published on 26th August 2022
Poly(butylene succinate) (PBS) is considered to be a potential bio-alternative for petroleum-based polymers due to its environmentally benign nature and biodegradability. Despite its various advantages, its low thermal stability and lack of high molecular weight required for industrial applications restrict its implementation on a commercial scale. The synthesis of high molecular weight PBS remains a challenging task due to the hydrolytic instability of the catalyst as well as the thermal sensitivity of PBS. Herein, we report a Lewis acidic ionic liquid (LAIL) as a novel, mild, efficient and hydrolytically stable catalyst system for the synthesis of high molecular weight PBS. Further, the thermal stability of the PBS synthesized using the novel catalyst is found to be higher than the corresponding polymer synthesized using a conventional catalyst.
However, its high cost coupled with a lack of high molecular weight required for industrial application restricts its commercialization.7 Extensive research is being carried out to broaden the application of PBS by improving its mechanical and thermal properties via chemical and physical methods.8 Generally, the synthesis of PBS involves two steps: esterification or trans-esterification followed by polycondensation reactions, which are carried out at high temperatures, usually 230–250 °C under vacuum (Scheme 1).9 Significant efforts have already been made towards the development of mild and efficient catalysts in synthesizing high molecular weight PBS. As a result, various catalyst systems have been reported in the literature for the synthesis of PBS.8
However, among the various catalysts explored, titanium-based catalysts exhibit better catalytic activity than other Lewis acid catalysts. Thus, titanium alkoxides (titanium tetrabutoxide (TBT) and titanium tetraisopropoxide (TTIP)) are the most widely used catalyst for the synthesis of PBS as well as its copolymers, and the order of efficiency is found to be Ti » Zr ∼ Sn > Hf > Sb > Bi.9 However, titanium-based catalysts are more sensitive to moisture/water, and hence the addition of catalyst during the polycondensation step exhibited higher activity than adding the catalyst during the esterification step. This clearly indicates the sensitivity of titanium-based catalysts towards water, the by-product formed during the reaction.9a
Moreover, PBS is thermally sensitive and the high temperature required for the polycondensation reaction restricts the synthesis of high molecular weight PBS, as it undergoes various side reactions including degradation.10 Thus, the synthesis of high molecular weight PBS from dicarboxylic acids and diols remains a challenging task due to the thermal sensitivity of PBS and hydrolytic instability of the catalyst. Thus, the development of efficient and hydrolytically stable catalysts for the synthesis of high molecular weight PBS is much sought after. Herein, we report a novel mild, efficient and hydrolytically stable (Lewis acidic ionic liquid) catalyst system for the synthesis of high molecular weight PBS.
Thus, ionic liquids based on Sn and Zn were prepared using choline chloride and BMIMCl (1-Butyl-3-methylimidazolium chloride) by following a reported procedure.12 The synthesized catalyst was examined for its catalytic efficiency with respect to conventional catalyst such as titanium tetrabutoxide, titanium tetraisopropoxide, stannous chloride etc., and the results are summarized in Table 1 (entry 1–12). The reported method was optimized and using the optimized synthetic method, PBS with Mn, Mw and PDI values of about 1.84 × 104 g mol−1, 4.68 × 104 g mol−1 and 2.53, respectively, were synthesized.9a Further, the optimized reaction condition was used to screen the efficiency of other catalyst systems (using 0.02 mol%) for the synthesis of PBS (Table 1).13
S. No. | Catalysta | Temp. (°C) (Time) | M n (g mol−1) | M w (g mol−1) | PDI | T m (°C) | T c (°C) | T d (°C) |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
a 0.02 mol% catalyst was used for the reaction; Td: onset degradation temperature. | ||||||||
1 | Ti(OBu)4 | 230 (6.5 h) | 18536 | 46870 | 2.53 | 77 | 112 | 368 |
2 | Ti(OiPr)4 | 230 (6.5 h) | 14855 | 41354 | 2.78 | 73 | 110 | 365 |
3 | SnCl2 | 230 (6 h) | 18427 | 50868 | 2.76 | 77 | 114 | 370 |
4 | ZnCl2 | 230 (8 h) | 10226 | 32226 | 3.15 | 70 | 112 | 360 |
5 | ChCl:SnCl2 (1:1) | 230 (7 h) | 21874 | 57957 | 2.65 | 78 | 115 | 379 |
6 | ChCl:ZnCl2 (1:1) | 230 (7 h) | 19289 | 41483 | 2.15 | 74.8 | 112.7 | 358 |
7 | BMIM:SnCl2 (1:1) | 230 (7 h) | 15923 | 38160 | 2.41 | 72.6 | 112.6 | 362 |
8 | BMIM:ZnCl2 (1:1) | 230 (7 h) | 9654 | 27058 | 2.81 | 71.4 | 110.81 | 354 |
9 | BMIMCl | 230 (7 h) | 2286 | 10740 | 4.70 | — | — | — |
10 | ChCl | 230 (7 h) | 7758 | 18278 | 2.36 | — | — | — |
11 | [BMIM][HSO4] | 230 (7 h) | 3065 | 7271 | 2.37 | — | — | — |
12 | PMA | 230 (7 h) | 1113 | 1884 | 1.69 | — | — | — |
Interestingly, the ionic liquid prepared using choline chloride and SnCl2 exhibited better catalytic activity than the conventional catalysts (Table 1, entry 5). However, the ionic liquid prepared using zinc chloride exhibited moderate activity (Table 1, entry 6 and 8). From the experimental results, it is very clear that choline chloride-based ionic liquids are found to be more efficient in producing relatively high molecular weight PBS than the corresponding BMIMCl-based ionic liquids (Table 1, entry 5–8). Further, the reaction of succinic acid and butanediol in the presence of BMIMCl, ChCl, [BMIM][HSO4] and phosphomolybdic acid (PMA) resulted in the isolation of polymers with low molecular weight (Table 1, entry 9–12).
Furthermore, the influence of Lewis acid concentration in the ionic liquids was investigated and the results are summarized in Table 2. Since ChCl-based Lewis acidic ionic liquids exhibited better catalytic activity than the corresponding BMIMCl-based ionic liquids, a systematic investigation was carried out to understand the influence of temperature and the concentration of metal halides in ChCl-based Lewis acidic ionic liquids. An increase in the concentration of metal halides in the ChCl-based ionic liquids resulted in increased catalytic activity by reducing the reaction time required for the reaction (Table 2, entry 3); however, further increase in the concentration of Lewis acid in the catalyst system resulted in the lowering of the thermal stability of the polymer (Table 2, entry 9). Interestingly, the choline chloride-based Lewis acidic ionic liquid catalyst system was found to produce high molecular weight PBS even at low temperatures (200 °C) (Table 2, entry 6).
S. No. | Catalysta | Temp. (°C) (Time) | M n (g mol−1) | M w (g mol−1) | PDI | T m (°C) | T c (°C) | T d (°C) |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
a 0.02 mol% catalyst was used for the reaction. | ||||||||
1 | BMIM:SnCl2 (1:2) | 230 (7 h) | 18057 | 42907 | 2.38 | 75 | 112 | 368 |
2 | BMIM:ZnCl2 (1:2) | 230 (7 h) | 12365 | 31623 | 2.56 | 74.6 | 111 | 362 |
3 | ChCl:SnCl2 (1:2) | 230 (6 h) | 31988 | 72624 | 2.27 | 77 | 115 | 383 |
4 | ChCl:ZnCl2 (1:2) | 230 (7 h) | 14902 | 41472 | 2.78 | 75 | 113 | 364 |
5 | ChCl:SnCl2 (1:1) | 200 (8 h) | 21840 | 56826 | 2.60 | 77 | 114 | 378 |
6 | ChCl:SnCl2 (1:2) | 200 (7 h) | 21609 | 73031 | 3.38 | 76 | 115 | 389 |
7 | ChCl:ZnCl2 (1:1) | 200 (8.5 h) | 12365 | 31623 | 2.56 | 75 | 112 | 354 |
8 | ChCl:ZnCl2 (1:2) | 200 (7.5 h) | 15823 | 37960 | 2.39 | 75 | 111 | 358 |
9 | ChCl:SnCl2 (1:3) | 230 (5 h) | 21902 | 72990 | 3.33 | 77 | 114 | 368 |
To understand the hydrolytic stability of the ChCl-based Lewis acidic ionic liquid catalyst system, PBS synthesis was carried out by adding the catalyst before and after the esterification reaction (Table 3, entry 1–6). Interestingly, no significant changes in catalytic activity were observed for the newly synthesized ChCl:SnCl2 catalyst system, which clearly indicates the hydrolytic stability of the catalyst. Whereas, conventional titanium based catalyst exhibited reduced catalytic activity by adding the catalyst before esterification reaction, which clearly elucidates the hydrolytic instability of the catalyst system during PBS synthesis (Table 3, entry 1 & 4). Further, thermal stability of the PBS produced using stannous chloride-based ionic liquids was found to be higher than that of the corresponding polymer produced using the zinc-based ionic liquids and titanium-based catalysts (Tables 1 and 2).
S. No. | Catalyste | Time | M n (g mol−1) | M w (g mol−1) | PDI | T m (°C) | T c (°C) | T d (°C) |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
a Catalyst added during the esterification step.13a b Catalyst added during the polycondensation step.13b c Temperature of the polycondensation reaction: 230 °C. d Temperature of the polycondensation reaction: 200 °C. e 0.02 mol% ppm catalyst used for the reaction. | ||||||||
1a | Ti(OBu)4 | 7c | 18536 | 46870 | 2.53 | 77 | 112 | 362 |
2a | ChCl:SnCl2 (1:1) | 7c | 21874 | 57957 | 2.65 | 77.6 | 115 | 379 |
3a | ChCl:SnCl2 (1:2) | 6d | 31988 | 72624 | 2.27 | 77 | 115 | 389 |
4b | Ti(OBu)4 | 5c | 19074 | 50271 | 2.64 | 81 | 114 | 366 |
5b | ChCl:SnCl2 (1:1) | 7c | 21732 | 57272 | 2.64 | 78 | 115 | 382 |
6b | ChCl:SnCl2 (1:2) | 6d | 31448 | 73104 | 2.32 | 78 | 115 | 394 |
It is reported in the literature, that the residual catalyst present in the final polymer results in the degradation of the corresponding polymer at higher temperatures.9a Trace metal analysis clearly indicates that the metal catalyst present in the final polymer (PBS) produced using Lewis acidic ionic liquids is very low when compared to the polymer produced using the corresponding metal chloride catalysts (Table 4). The removal of catalyst is found to be more effective in the case of polymerizations carried out using Lewis acidic ionic liquids compared to those with conventional metal chloride catalysts. Moreover, this resulted in the increased thermal stability of the final polymer produced using Lewis acidic ionic liquids (Table 4).
S. No | Catalyst used for polymerization | Metal content in the final polymer (ppm) |
---|---|---|
1 | Ti(OBu)4 | 225 |
2 | SnCl2 | 212 |
3 | ZnCl2 | 230 |
4 | ChCl:SnCl2 (1:2) | 96 |
5 | ChCl:ZnCl2 (1:2) | 108 |
Finally, from the thermal studies, it is evident that all the synthesized ionic liquid catalysts are more stable at 250 °C (temperature required for polycondensation reaction) (Table 5, entry 1–6). Even choline chloride is found to be stable at 250 °C (Table 5, entry 1). However, the stability of BMIMCl was found to be very low (61%) at 250 °C (Table 5, entry 2). Interestingly, the corresponding ionic liquids synthesized using BMIMCl are found to be more stable at 250 °C (Table 5, entry 5 and 6). This increased stability of the BMIMCl-based Lewis acidic ionic liquids is believed to be due to the self-association of quaternary ammonium salts (QASs) (hydrogen bond acceptor) and metal halides (hydrogen bond donor) to form complexes, which leads to an increase in the thermal and chemical stability of the ionic liquids.
(a) General method for the synthesis of PBS (catalyst addition during esterification reaction):
In a clean three neck RB flask fitted with distillation assembly, succinic acid (20 g, 0.17 mol) and butane diol (16 g, 0.18 mol) was taken and stirred for 10 mins. Into this catalyst (0.02 mol%) was added and the resultant mixture was heated to 175 °C till the completion of the esterification reaction (water collected approximately 5.6 mL). After completion of the esterification reaction, polycondensation was carried out at 230 °C under vacuum (10 mmHg) to give the corresponding polymer. After completion of the polycondensation reaction, reaction mixture was cooled (80 °C) and then poured into water. The solid thus obtained was filtered, washed with acetone and dried under nitrogen to give the corresponding PBS in good yield (88%). IR (neat):1714, 1157 cm−1; 1H NMR (400 MHz, CDCl3): δ 1.71 (m, 4H), 2.63 (m, 4H), 4.24 (m, 4H); 13C NMR (100 MHz, CDCl3): δ 172.3, 64.2, 29.0, 25.2.
(b) General method for the synthesis of PBS (catalyst addition during polycondensation reaction):
In a clean three neck RB flask fitted with distillation assembly, succinic acid (20 g, 0.17 mol) and butane diol (16 g, 0.18 mol) was taken and heated to 175 °C till the completion of the esterification reaction (water collected approximately 5.6 mL). After completion of the esterification reaction, catalyst (0.02 mol%) was added and the polycondensation reaction was carried out at 230 °C under vacuum (10 mmHg) to give the corresponding polymer. After completion of the polycondensation reaction, reaction mixture was cooled (80 °C) and then poured into water. The solid thus obtained was filtered, washed with acetone and dried under nitrogen to give the corresponding PBS in good yield (92%)
.Footnote |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available. See DOI: https://doi.org/10.1039/d2ma00757f |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2022 |