Ji-Sun
Kim
a,
Jun-Ho
Byeon
a,
Sungmin
Kang
bc and
Jin-Yeol
Kim
*a
aSchool of Advanced Materials Engineering, Kookmin University, Seoul 136-702, Korea. E-mail: jinyeol@kookmin.ac.kr; Tel: +82-2-910-4663
bAdvanced Technology Research Department, LG Japan Lab Inc., 413-14, Higashi Shinagawa, Shinagawa-ku, Tokyo 140-0002, Japan
cInstitute of Innovative Research Laboratory for Future Interdisciplinary Research, Tokyo Institute of Technology, Yokohama 226-8503, Japan
First published on 15th November 2022
Core–shell-shaped nanoparticles (CSS-NPs) with polyaniline emeraldine salts (PANi) in the core and hydroxypropyl methylcellulose (HPMC) and heptadecafluorooctanesulfonic acid (C8F) shells, i.e., C8F-doped PANi@HPMC CSS-NPs, were synthesized as a gaseous acetone sensing material with high sensitivity and humidity stability. The HPMC was chemically combined on the positively charged PANi NPs' outer surface, allowing it to efficiently detect acetone gas at concentrations as low as 50 ppb at 25 °C. To impart humidity stability, C8F was employed as a hydrophobic dopant, and a valid signal could be reliably detected even in the range of 0–80% relative humidity. The sensing material's structural analysis was conducted using scanning electron microscopy, transmission electron microscopy, energy-dispersive X-ray spectroscopy, and infrared spectroscopy, and in particular, the reaction mechanism with acetone gas was detected through a spectroscopic method. Thus, these findings illustrate the potential as a novel sensing material to detect acetone gas at a trace level of less than 1 ppm in human respiratory gas.
To address the above problems, we developed core–shell-shaped nanoparticles (CSS-NPs) comprising PANi in the core and hydroxypropyl methylcellulose (HPMC) and heptadecafluorooctane sulfonic acid (C8F) shells, i.e., C8F-doped PANi@HPMC CSS-NPs, specifically employed as an acetone gas sensing material. PANi is a p-type semiconductor with selectivity to specific organic components that have the structure of emeraldine salts. Structurally, it is a positively charged conductive polymer particle with a spherical surface surrounded by HPMC molecules that are sensitive to acetone gas. Particularly, because of its hydrophobic properties, C8F is placed on the surface of PANi nanoparticles and not only influences the electrical resistance value but also functions as a dopant to minimize the resistance change due to humidity. It has the benefits of high sensitivity, moisture stability, and low-temperature detection.11–15,19 Recently, Zhang et al.15 reported an acetone sensor made of a ZnO/S–N graphite QD/PANi composite with an enhanced response of the 500 ppb level at 25 °C.
In this research, we developed C8F-doped PANi@HPMC CSS-NPs using micelle templating in an emulsion polymerization approach. HPMC was employed as a polymer surfactant to generate spherical micelles; some of them were connected to the PANI's NH group backbone through electrostatic interaction during polymerization and finally formed as a capping layer on the spherical PANI's surface. Because of its hydrophobic properties, C8F is placed on the surface of conductive PANi NPs and functions as a dopant to not only enhance electrical conductivity but also minimize resistance changes due to moisture. Furthermore, Fig. 1 depicts the schematic and chemical structures of CSS-NPs made of C8F-doped PANi capped with HPMC. Thus, the C8F-doped PANi@HPMC CSS-NP sensor in this research efficiently detected acetone gas at concentrations as low as 50 ppb even at ambient temperature and could detect a consistent signal at a relative humidity (RH) ranging from 0–80%. It is thought that a human respiratory gas test could be useful for medical diagnosis.
Morphological structures revealed that CSS-NPs were well produced from the scanning electron microscopy (SEM) images of PANi@HPMC CSS-NPs without C8F and C8F-doped PANi@HPMC CSS-NPs, respectively, as demonstrated in Fig. 2. Particularly, the figure placed into the SEM image of Fig. 2(II) illustrates a transmission electron microscopy (TEM) image of one specific particle. As demonstrated in the figure, CSS-NPs consist entirely of monodisperse spherical nanoparticles with average diameters of 200 and 280 nm. HPMC employed to produce micelles and C8F employed as a hydrophobic dopant were produced with a thickness of about 40 nm on the shell of PANi particles during polymerization. In the PANi particles synthesized without C8F, only a 2–3 nm thin HPMC layer exists, as demonstrated in Fig. 2(I). Here a thin C8F layer containing fluorine (F) atoms sufficiently covered the PANi nanoparticles' entire surface. Energy-dispersive X-ray spectroscopy (EDS) spectra were employed to examine the component content of nanoparticles, as demonstrated in Fig. 2(II-b). The mass percentage of fluorine atoms on the C8F-doped PANi@HPMC CSS-NPs was estimated and compared with the content of other components. The mass percentage of F atoms was found to be 11.69% for C8F-doped PANi@HPMC CSS-NPs. Obviously, in the spectrum of PANi@HPMC CSS-NPs without C8F in Fig. 2(I-b), it was seen that F atoms were not present at all. FT-IR spectroscopic analysis was performed to characterize C8F-doped PANi@HPMC CSS-NPs, as demonstrated in Fig. 3(I-a). For a comparative analysis, Fig. 3(I-b) and (I-c) also illustrate the IR transmission spectrum of pure HPMC molecules in the outer shell and PANi particles alone in the core, respectively.
On the IR spectrum of the obtained C8F-doped PANi@HPMC CSS-NPs, the peaks at 1570, 1497, 1303, 1124, and 805 cm−1 are attributed to the C–C stretching of a quinoid ring, CC stretching of a benzene ring, C–N stretching of an aromatic ring, stretching of a charged C–NH+ group, and C–H out of plane in the 1,4-distributed benzene ring, respectively.22,23 The characteristic peaks seen at 1065 cm−1 are attributed to the CO group present in the HPMC shell on the PANi CSS-NPs’ surface. Here, it was verified that the intensity of this 1065 cm−1 peak increased with increasing HPMC shell thickness.
The reaction mechanism when C3H6O gas was injected into C8F-doped PANi@HPMC CSS-NPs was explained using spectroscopic analysis. In relation, Fig. 3(II) demonstrates the observation of changes in the IR absorption peak when C3H6O gas is adsorbed onto C8F-doped PANi@HPMC CSS-NPs. As demonstrated in the figure, when a certain amount of C3H6O gas is adsorbed, it was seen that the 1124 cm−1 stretching band's intensity caused by the positively charged C–NH+ group in the PANi backbone increased substantially. These findings also tended to recover reversibly, when the C3H6O gas was withdrawn.
The NH+ group of the PANi backbone interacts with the CO group of the C3H6O molecule through charge–charge coupling. Alternately, it can be thought of as a connection between the NH group of PANi and the oxygen atom of C3H6O by a weak hydrogen bond.
Fig. 4 illustrates the C8F-doped PANi@HPMC CSS-NP's UV/vis absorption spectrum and the spectrum when exposed to C3H6O gas, respectively. As demonstrated in the figure, an absorption peak attributed to the positively charged excitons contained in the PANi chain was detected at 820 nm. At this time, the bandgap energy associated with the π–π* transition was computed to be 1.51 eV. However, these absorption wavelengths moved to 805 nm (bandgap energy: 1.54 eV) with exposure to C3H6O gas, and the absorption intensity also substantially decreased. This is because acetone gas is chemically bound to the PANi molecule by charge–charge interaction, and some of the positively charged excitons of the positively charged PANI move toward the oxygen atom of the acetone molecule, reducing the number of excitons in the PANi chain. Thus, the PANi chain's electrical resistance (Ω cm) tends to increase. The PANi chain's band gap energy (Eg) also increased as the amount of acetone increased.
Acetone gas is found in trace amounts of less than 1 ppm in human exhaled gas, is linked to metabolism, and has been used as a medical biomarker for diabetes.24–27 Thus, it is a crucial requirement for tracing tens of ppb of acetone gas released during respiration. Humidity is present in both the ambient environment and exhalation, and the humidity dependence of respiratory gas sensing characteristics is a significant obstacle for real time applications. Thus, for practical applications including the point of care, the acetone sensor's high ppb level responsiveness and resistance to humidity remain critical tasks. Here, we manufactured an acetone gas sensor by drop-casting a C8F-doped PANi@HPMC CSS-NP ink solution onto a sensor substrate with a pair of gold electrodes (test cell: with a pair of integrated gold electrodes for a sensor electrode on a flexible substrate), as demonstrated in the sensor array diagram in Fig. 5. Particularly, C8F is placed on the surface of conductive PANi NPs as demonstrated in the figure and it not only works as a dopant but also has repulsive properties against water molecules due to its hydrophobic properties. Based on the study findings of Fujii et al.,28 it has been reported that C8F imparts hydrophobic properties when attached as a dopant on the surface of a conductive polymer including PPy. However, as demonstrated in the figure, the pure PANi@HPMC NP sensing material can detect the signal that the electrical resistance increases in proportion to the gas concentration with the C3H6O gas injection. Thus, with the adsorption of C3H6O gas, the charge density in the backbone of PANi decreases. At this time, C3H6O was thought to serve as a reducing agent to increase the resistance of PANi as a p-type semiconductor. The layer-structured films made of the as-prepared C8F-doped PANi@HPMC CSS-NPs demonstrate an electrical conductivity of 0.93 S cm−1 and largely enhanced humidity and temperature stability. At this time, the concentration of the C8F dopant was 4 × 10−4 wt% compared to PANi. However, the electrical resistance of PANi-based sensors influences the conductivity as the transfer of charged carriers within the PANi polymer chain and their resistance are changed by the adsorption of gas species.
When these chemical sensors are exposed to a certain gas, the sensor's resistance varies in proportion to the concentration of the adsorbed gas and measuring this is a fundamental principle. The PANi chain's electrical resistance increased as the amount of acetone increased. As demonstrated in Fig. 5, the sensing layer detected a signal indicating that the electrical resistance (R) increased in the positive direction along with the injection of acetone. However, the detection impact tended to decrease proportionally as the C8F concentration increased, and the detected sensor's response and recovery time to acetone gas were simultaneously observed to be 750 s and 500 s, respectively. The sensor's response and recovery time are defined as the time taken for the sensor to reach the 90% saturation response value and the time taken for recovery to 10%, respectively. At this time, while the response and recovery cycling tests were repeated up to 100 times, the change in sensitivity was observed to be less than 5%.
Fig. 6 illustrates the sensor array's response characteristics to C3H6O gas injection. We showed the continuous dynamic response of C8F-undoped-PANi@HPMC CSS-NP [(a) in Fig. 6] and C8F-doped-PANi@HPMC CSS-NP [(b) in Fig. 6] sensors to different concentrations of C3H6O gas ranging from 0.05 to 5 ppm at 25 °C and 0% RH, respectively. The response is characterized by a change in ΔR/Ri × 100 (responsiveness, S%) when injected with different concentrations of acetone, where Ri represents the initial current resistance, and ΔR represents the difference between Ri and R evaluated after exposure to acetone gas. As illustrated in the figure, the effective response was shown at each concentration (0.05, 0.1, 1, 2, 3, 4, and 5 ppm, respectively), and as the gas concentration increased, the relative responsiveness tended to increase in proportion. Particularly, as illustrated in Fig. 6(I), very prominent signals were observed even at trace gas concentrations of 50 ppb. In either case, the S was observed to have a linear characteristic toward increasing the resistance as the injection gas's concentration increased, as shown in Fig. 7(I). Then, the acetone gas sensor's sensitivity (ppm−1) can be defined as the slope of the response S against the concentration of acetone. The C8F-doped-PANi@HPMC CSS-NP sensor showed at least three times lower response to C3H6O gas compared to the C8F-undoped-PANi@HPMC CSS-NP sensor. This result can be explained by the fact that in the case of PANi doped with C8F, the reaction pathway with PANi was less activated since large-sized hydrophobic C8F molecules prevented C3H6O molecules' adsorption. Obtaining a reliable response to acetone at tens of ppb levels remains a crucial topic for biosensor applications that use exhalation.29
Almost all CCP-based sensors, including metal-oxide sensors, are easily influenced or do not respond under high-RH conditions. Thus, the sensing material's stability to the temperature and humidity environment functions as a major factor in evaluating the sensor's performance. In this sense, we observed the rate of changes in responsiveness (S%) at 2 ppm C3H6O concentration, according to the changes in RH% (constant to T = 25 °C) conditions, as illustrated in Fig. 7(II). In the case of the C8F-undoped PANi@HPMC CSS-NP sensor, as illustrated in Fig. 7(II-a), the S value under humidity conditions was significantly reduced to over one-twentieth of that under dry conditions. Furthermore, in the case of humidity conditions, the S value was stabilized at a low level or tended to increase slightly with the increase in humidity. Generally, PANi-based sensors have very high reactivity with water molecules, and when water comes into contact with the PANi backbone, the current resistance of PANI is substantially lowered. Thus, when several % of water molecules react in the C8F-undoped PANi@HPMC CSS-NP sensor, the sensor's current resistance (R) due to the reaction with acetone is offset and decreased due to their influence. However, in the case of the C8F-doped PANi@HPMC CSS-NP sensor (Fig. 7(II-b)), the S value under humidity conditions showed a relatively small decrease of 25–30% compared with dry conditions. Additionally, it demonstrated a tendency to increase proportionally with an increase in humidity. However, the resistance of the C8F-doped PANi@HPMC CSS-NP sensor was relatively less affected by humidity.
Furthermore, the S value slightly increases as the humidity increases because, under high-RH conditions, H2O molecules form small water droplets by self-binding, and these water droplets act to weaken the reactivity with the PANI backbone. According to previous reports,31,32 when gaseous C3H6O molecules come into contact with the small water droplet, there is a strong attractive force between the oxygen atom of C3H6O and the hydrogen atom of the water's OH group, so that acetone gas can be easily absorbed by the water droplet. This was also explained to be more affected by low-temperature conditions.
Selectivity is another crucial parameter of gas sensors used in practice. To observe selectivity, our study further tested various organic gases such as ethanol, chloroform, xylene, toluene, hydrogen, and carbon dioxide. The concentrations of all gases employed for observation were 5 ppm (1% in CO2) and were measured at room temperature and under dry conditions. As illustrated in the comparative plot in Fig. 8, the C8F-doped PANi@HPMC CSS-NP sensor showed superior responsiveness (S = 2.8 at 5 ppm) for acetone, indicating very low responses. Furthermore, highly polar molecules such as acetone, ethanol, hydrogen, and carbon dioxide showed response characteristics that increased the electrical resistance of the PANi backbone. However, gases such as chloroform, xylene, and toluene showed negative responsiveness due to a decrease in electrical resistance in molecules with low polarity. Thus, in the case of the PANi-based sensor in this study, the change in electrical resistance was detected differently depending on the polarity of the gas component in contact. That is, highly polar molecules such as acetone, ethanol, hydrogen, and carbon dioxide show a response characteristic that increases the PANi backbone's electrical resistance. However, gases such as chloroform, xylene, and toluene show negative responsiveness due to a decrease in electrical resistance in molecules with low polarity.
Fig. 8 Comparison of response to several analytes at 5 ppm (acetone, ethanol, chloroform, xylene, toluene, hydrogen, and carbon dioxide). |
Fig. 5 and 6 show the sensor's response and recovery curve. The reversibility of the response characteristics was also confirmed. When exposed to acetone at a concentration of less than 1 ppm, the sensor response was stable, and after that, a stable signal was confirmed even after 100 cycles of testing. This study's results show that the sensor's characteristics such as sensitivity, selectivity, humidity stability, repeatability and room temperature sensing are notable features. This work could yield good results of the comparative advantage compared with other PANi-based sensors reported in the literature,13–15,20,30 which sense at room temperature. As shown in the comparative data in Table 1, it was evaluated that the sensitivity (ppm−1) and detection limit (ppm) were very advanced.
Sensing materials | Sensitivity (ppm−1) | Detection limit (ppm) | Operating temp. (°C) | Type | Ref |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Core-shell-shaped PANi@HPMC NPs | 4.2 | 0.05 | RT | P-type | This work |
Core-shell-shaped C8F-doped PANi@HPMC NPs | 1.0 | 0.05 | RT | P-type | This work |
PANi/Au/Al2O3 | 0.055 | 30 | RT | P-type | 20 |
PANi/TiO2 | 0.0035 | 20 | RT | N-type | 30 |
PANi fabrics | 0.55 | — | RT | P-type | 13 |
PANi/Au/porous electrode | 0.0039 | 23 | RT | N-type | 14 |
ZnQ/S–N: graphite QD/PANi | 4 | 0.5 | RT | N-type | 15 |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2022 |