Susana
Velasco-Lozano‡
a,
Silvia Alonso-de
Castro‡
b,
Carlos
Sanchez-Cano
abc,
Ana I.
Benítez-Mateos
a,
Fernando
López-Gallego
*ac and
Luca
Salassa
*bcd
aCenter for Cooperative Research in Biomaterials (CIC biomaGUNE), Basque Research and Technology Alliance (BRTA), Paseo de Miramon 182, San Sebastián, 20014, Spain. E-mail: flopez@cicbiomagune.es
bDonostia International Physics Center, Paseo Manuel de Lardizabal 4, Donostia, 20018, Spain. E-mail: lsalassa@dipc.org
cIkerbasque, Basque Foundation for Science, Bilbao, 48011, Spain
dPolimero eta Material Aurreratuak: Fisika, Kimika eta Teknologia, Kimika Fakultatea, Euskal Herriko Unibertsitatea UPV/EHU, Paseo Manuel de Lardizabal 3, Donostia, 20018, Spain
First published on 29th November 2021
Catalysis-based approaches for the activation of anticancer agents hold considerable promise. These principally rely on the use of metal catalysts capable of deprotecting inactive precursors of organic drugs or transforming key biomolecules available in the cellular environment. Nevertheless, the efficiency of most of the schemes described so far is rather low, limiting the benefits of catalytic amplification as strategy for controlling the therapeutic effects of anticancer compounds. In the work presented here, we show that flavin reactivity within a hydrogel matrix provides a viable solution for the efficient catalytic activation and delivery of cisplatin, a worldwide clinically-approved inorganic chemotherapy agent. This is achieved by ionically adsorbing a flavin catalyst and a Pt(IV) prodrug as substrate into porous amino-functionalized agarose beads. The hydrogel chassis supplies high local concentrations of electron donating groups/molecules in the surrounding of the catalyst, ultimately boosting substrate conversion rates (TOF >200 min−1) and enabling controlled liberation of the drug by light or chemical stimuli. Overall, this approach can afford platforms for the efficient delivery of platinum drugs as demonstrated herein by using a transdermal diffusion model simulating the human skin.
Despite proving the potential of catalysis-based approaches in medicine, the great majority of the schemes proposed so far display rather modest catalytic efficiencies, even in buffer solutions, as evidenced by low turnover numbers (TONs) and slow reaction kinetics.15 The latter aspect is especially overlooked by the scientific community working in this field, yet of key importance in the development of drug activation strategies. Apart from few exceptions,2,12,16,17 catalysts currently reported in the literature typically achieve substrate conversion rates in solution that are in the order of 0.1–10 h−1 (10−3 to 10−1 min−1). This undoes the benefits of catalytic amplification since catalysts with low turnover frequency (TOF) require long exposure periods and/or high loadings for transforming enough substrate (i.e. prodrug) to induce the desired therapeutic effects. In such a scenario, the catalyst intrinsic toxicity is critical15 and the choice of drugs with high-potency (sub-μM) becomes often mandatory, overall limiting the therapeutic scope of several catalysis-based strategies for prodrug activation.
Thus, catalysts with high TOFs are preferable for rapidly generating lethal doses of drug before both the prodrug and catalyst are metabolized and cleared by the treated tissue or organism. In that regard, our groups recently reported that flavins and selected flavoproteins photocatalytically convert Pt(IV) prodrug precursors into clinically-approved cisplatin and carboplatin with unanticipated efficiency, exhibiting TOFs as high as 25 min−1 and TONs up to 500.18,19 Reaction mechanism studies indicate that the active catalyst is the flavin hydroquinone species (doubly reduced flavin) whose generation is dramatically accelerated by photoirradiation in the presence of selected electron donors.18 Notably, these inorganic transformations catalyzed by innocuous biomolecules unconventionally use metal complexes as substrates20 and display bioorthogonal selectivity,19,21,22i.e. they occur in cell culture media avoiding interference from other chemical and biochemical entities.
Considering the exceptional anticancer activity of Pt chemotherapeutics and the tremendous research efforts devoted to design delivery platforms capable of reducing their off-target effects,23 we speculated that we could capitalize on the catalytic efficiency of these flavin-mediated reactions and devise convenient solutions for the administration of cisplatin and its derivatives. To such aim, we sought inspiration in Nature which confines biocatalysts (i.e. enzymes) and substrates (i.e. metabolites) inside organelles to control biosynthetic pathways and boost catalytic performance.24 Catalysts confined into supramolecular structures have proved very effective in favoring chemical reactions for different technological purposes.25 In biomedicine, enzymes and chemical catalysts entrapped into artificial envelops have afforded therapeutic weapons to target cancer.26,27 However, none of the state-of-the-art systems involve confinement of the catalyst and its corresponding prodrug substrate into an artificial chassis that can operate as drug depot. Besides, catalysis-based systems for prodrug activation have been so far designed to function under the very diluted conditions that they encounter during in vitro and in vivo studies. In such a scenario, catalysts hardly find substrate molecules to react with, ultimately displaying low catalytic efficiencies. In confined spaces this is not the case since high concentrations of substrate are available in the proximity of the catalyst, therefore maximizing reaction kinetics when rate laws are equal or higher than 1.
Hydrogels have been widely used as solid supports to immobilize different types of catalysts,28 including for therapy purposes.29 Furthermore, they are appealing materials for delivery, because of their excellent biocompatibility and high water content.30 These soft materials can be applied in surgical implants, locally injected or administered systematically via intravenous infusion,31 and used to fabricate therapeutic patches for intra- and transdermal release of pharmaceuticals.32 Binding of drugs to hydrogel polymer networks can be extremely diverse, ranging from covalent conjugation, electrostatic and hydrophobic interactions, as well as physical trapping. The nature of the interaction governs drug release properties.31
Stimuli responsive hydrogels are particularly promising because they introduce an additional level of control on the drug action. In the specific case of platinum-based anticancer agents, hydrogel polymers have generally been employed to release their Pt(II) and Pt(IV) cargos upon swelling and degradation of the gel.33,34 In such systems, Pt complexes are loaded by host guest chemistry or by conjugating prodrugs with polymer monomer units. Recent studies showed that release of active platinum species from hydrogels can also be triggered by short-wavelength light.35
In this contribution, we demonstrate how loading of a Pt(IV) prodrug complex and a flavin catalyst onto agarose porous microbeads enables performing in situ the confined catalytically-driven generation and subsequent release of cisplatin in a stimuli responsive manner, by light and chemical activation. Catalysis has so far been employed in drug release to accelerate the degradation of hydrogels and thus control the delivery of active agents,36 rather than activating a confined prodrug. Our approach is different and may provide a general method to produce high local concentrations of Pt drugs in short bursts upon remote control. In the long run, this can afford viable strategies to develop topical medicaments and implantable devices37 that could overcome some of the issues associated with the systemic administration of Pt chemotherapeutic agents.
Thus, we loaded the Pt(IV) substrate and the flavin catalyst onto transparent AGM functionalized with diethylaminoethyl groups (pKa ≈ 9.5), exploiting non-covalent interactions between FMN, 1, and the microbead network (Fig. 1).
Fig. 1 Flavin-catalyzed generation of cisplatin from a Pt(IV) prodrug precursor inside diethylaminoethyl agarose microbeads (AGM). |
The immobilization is based on the electrostatic interactions established by the phosphate and succinates of FMN and 1, respectively, and the positively charged tertiary amino groups of AGM. The association/dissociation equilibrium that rules these ionic interactions also enables the flavin to diffuse within the bead pores and act over the electrostatically anchored Pt(IV) complexes.42
Confinement of the photocatalyst and the metal substrate was achieved by sequential incubation of 1 mM 1 and 75 μM FMN solutions with AGM, under low ionic strength and neutral pH conditions (10 mM Tris–HCl at pH 7.6). After buffer washing, the resulting 1-FMN@AGMs could be loaded with concentrations up to 0.165 ± 0.06 and 4.70 ± 0.02 μmol g−1 of flavin and 1, respectively, as determined by UV Vis and UPLC-MS. When 1-FMN@AGMs were incubated with 1 M NaCl, 1 and FMN were majorly released from the matrix, demonstrating that both metal substrate and catalyst were ionically absorbed to the AGMs.
Fig. 2 Flavin-catalyzed photoactivation of 1-FMN@AGM and subsequent cisplatin release monitored by (a) 1H NMR and (b) UPLC-MS. Supernatant and solutions eluted with (pale yellow) and without (orange) 1 M NaCl were employed for UPLC-MS analysis to quantify the amount of cisplatin liberated by light-activated 1-FMN@AGM (5 min, 6 mW cm−2) or residual 1 trapped in the beads, respectively (ESI†). |
With that in mind, we observed by 1H NMR that 5 min of low-power light irradiation (6 mW cm−2) were indeed sufficient to catalytically convert 100% of immobilized 1 into its photoproducts and release free succinate upon addition of 1 M NaCl (Fig. 2a). UPLC-MS (Fig. 2b and S2†) confirmed the simultaneous generation and release of cisplatin (yet without the need of adding NaCl), demonstrating that the process took place entirely, since no presence of 1 could be detected in the supernatant after light-irradiation and upon incubation with salt (Fig. 2b). After 1 min of exposure to light, 1-FMN@AGM achieved a TOF of 20.1 ± 0.6 min−1, in agreement with results previously reported for reactions in diluted solution.18 Remarkably, we measured a 10-fold increase in TOF (244 ± 10 min−1) by reducing the catalyst loading from 0.165 to 0.008 μmol g−1 (Table S1†) which indicated that confined spaces are indeed advantageous for improving the efficiency of these catalytic transformations.
Control experiments showed that cisplatin release was not taking place in the dark or in the absence of FMN under light irradiation (Fig. 2b and S3–S6†). Moreover, when kept in the dark and washed with 1 M NaCl, 1-FMN@AGM liberated approximately 80% of 1 (Fig. 2b), confirming that light was required for the flavin to trigger the catalysis.
In order to demonstrate that 1-FMN@AGM was capable of delivering therapeutic doses of cisplatin in a short period, we photoirradiated for 5 min a solution containing the microbeads (≈3 μmol g−11) and supplied 5 and 10 μL aliquots of supernatant to in vitro cultures of MCF-7 cells (breast cancer). Under the tested conditions, the cisplatin delivered from irradiated 1-FMN@AGM induced over 80% reduction in cell viability, corresponding to full conversion of the non-toxic Pt(IV) precursor and administration of 25–50 μM cisplatin, depending on the supplied volume. On the contrary, light-irradiated 1@AGM and dark controls did not have any effect on cell proliferation, in line with their inability to generate and release the Pt(II) drug (Fig. S7†).
EDX (Energy-Dispersive X-ray) spectroscopy further confirmed the capacity of 1-FMN@AGM of photoreleasing cisplatin (Fig. 3b and S12†). EDX spectra collected for 1-FMN@AGM and controls clearly showed that a signal corresponding to Pt was present on the material surface after loading 1 in the dark but disappeared upon light irradiation.
To gain further insights, we performed catalysis experiments in solution using galactose, diethylaminoethanol and agarose as electron donors to identify which component of AGM was directly involved in the photoreaction. Among these co-reactants, only diethylaminoethanol was capable of promoting the catalytic conversion of the Pt(IV) substrate, albeit at lower rate than the confined system (Fig. S13†). The higher catalytic efficiency observed for 1-FMN@AGM with respect to free diethylaminoethanol further confirmed the key role played by the microbead chassis in providing a high local concentration of electron donating groups and substrate molecules in the surrounding of the entrapped FMN. Others already demonstrated that confinement improves the outcome of catalytic reaction giving access to pathways that are forbidden or kinetically unfavored in diluted solutions.45 In photocatalysis, confined spaces enhance photochemical processes by altering several key steps, such as light absorption, lifetime of excited species and formation of key redox intermediates.46
1H NMR results revealed that the anaerobic environment produced by GOX inside AGM prompted a 4-fold acceleration in the generation of cisplatin compared to aerobic conditions, upon the same light irradiation time (Fig. S14†). O2 competes with 1 as terminal electron acceptor in the oxidation of the catalytically-active FMN hydroquinone (FMNH−).18,19 Therefore, depletion of O2 inside irradiated 1-FMN-GOX@AGM resulted in a faster production of the Pt(II) drug. These insights suggest that the GOX capability to starve cells50 and concurrently deplete O2 can be of value for increasing cisplatin photogeneration and delivery to the glucose-rich extracellular environments of tumors.
Therefore, confinement of the reaction components enabled a proficient electron transport from NADH to the Pt(IV) substrate, which conversely is precluded in diluted solutions without the use light. A similar behavior was observed by Chen et al.52 using a zeolitic imidazolate framework where both FMN and NADH were co-immobilized. As in our design, such nanozyme architecture was able to convert ferric cytochrome C to the ferrous form, supporting that confinement of the catalyst and electron donor is crucial to transfer electrons to metal centers in an efficient manner under dark conditions.
In order to better understand the dynamics of the catalytic reaction inside the beads, we employed fluorescence microscopy to monitor at a single-particle level how NADH and FMN fluorescence signals of AGM evolved in the presence of 1 (Fig. 4b and c). Upon excitation at 365 nm, NADH is fluorescent (λem = 402–448 nm) only in its reduced form, whereas FMN (λexc = 470 nm) emits at 520 nm, becoming non-emissive once reduced to FMNH−.53 After NADH addition, we monitored the fluorescence within each bead during the first 10 min, observing a progressive increase of NADH emission. This process corresponded to the immobilization of NADH on 1-FMN@AGM beads. Simultaneously, FMN fluorescence decreased due to the generation of the catalytically active FMNH−. After this onset period, however, NADH-associated emission diminished rapidly because of its FMN-promoted efficient conversion to NAD+. Alongside, FMN fluorescence was restored consistently by the catalytic Pt(IV)-to-Pt(II) reduction triggered by FMNH− and the regeneration of the emissive FMN catalyst in its oxidized form. Control experiments (Fig. S19†) confirmed this scenario, demonstrating that AGM containing NADH only displayed slower fluorescence decay than in presence of the FMN-1 pair, likely due to simple photobleaching of the electron donor. Furthermore, FMN-loaded beads showed a constant emission profile with limited photodecomposition in the absence of NADH.
In our experiments (Fig. 5 and S20†), 1-FMN@AGM was formulated with different concentrations of polypropylene glycol (PPG, 50–100%), since previous work demonstrated that this macromolecule aided the percutaneous penetration of drugs through the skin of mammals.57 The obtained viscous solutions were first applied to the STRAT-M® membrane and then light-irradiated for 5 min to fully convert 1 into cisplatin. Immediately afterwards, we incubated the whole system at 298 K in Tris buffer for 18 h in the dark, allowing cisplatin to permeate through the STRAT-M® and reach an agarose film placed beneath it. Quantification of the cisplatin that diffused through the membrane and accumulated in the collecting compartment was achieved by ICP-MS. Under these experimental conditions, we observed that light-activated 1-FMN@AGM in PPG did show significantly higher levels of membrane permeation than controls in the dark or in the absence of FMN. According to ICP-MS data, photoirradiated 1-FMN@AGM delivered approximately 36 ± 17 nM cisplatin (0.5% of loaded 1), whereas the concentration of cisplatin was either non-detected or <10 nM in the case of 1@AGM under the same conditions. After lyophilization, the agarose film collecting the permeated cisplatin was administered to MCF-7 cell cultures, observing a small (10%) but significant cell viability reduction for light-activated 1-FMN@AGM only, in agreement with the dose-toxicity profile of cisplatin (Fig. S21†).
Our study shows at a proof-of-concept level that a device based on flavin catalysis towards Pt substrates has potential applications for the controlled transdermal delivery of cisplatin. Careful refinement of this strategy in terms of formulation can afford creams and ointments for the topic treatment of specific cancerous lesions of the skins. Nevertheless, the versality of these catalytic reactions enables extending our approach towards other applications, for example by employing diverse polymeric architectures and fine-tuning their functional chemical groups for anchoring different flavins (or flavoproteins) and Pt substrates. Overall, this can afford real catalytic therapies for the cure of several types of cancers with new modes of action and fewer side effects.
Footnotes |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available. See DOI: 10.1039/d1sc05151b |
‡ Contributed equally. |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2022 |