Niklas
Reinfandt§
,
Adrian
Hauser§
,
Luca
Münzfeld
and
Peter W.
Roesky
*
Institute of Inorganic Chemistry, Karlsruhe Institute of Technology (KIT), Engesserstr. 15, D-76131 Karlsruhe, Germany. E-mail: roesky@kit.edu
First published on 4th February 2022
A convenient pathway to new molecular organo-lanthanide-polyarsenides in general and to a f-element complex with the largest polyarsenide ligand in detail is reported. For this purpose, the activation of the solid state material As0nano (nanoscale gray arsenic) by the multi electron reducing agents [K(18-crown-6)][(Ln+II)2(μ-η6:η6-C6H6)] (Ln = La, Ce, Cp′′ = 1,3-bis(trimethylsilyl)cyclopentadienyl anion) and [K(18-crown-6)]2[(Ln+II)2(μ-η6:η6-C6H6)] (Ln = Ce, Nd) is shown. These non-classical divalent lanthanide compounds were used as three and four electron reducing agents where the product formation can be directed by variation of the applied reactant. The obtained Zintl anions As33−, As73−, and As144− were previously not accessible in molecular 4f-element chemistry. Additionally, the corresponding compounds with As144−-moieties represent the largest organo-lanthanide-polyarsenides known to date.
In general, molecular arsenic Zintl ions of the lanthanides were only reported for Sm. In all these reactions the SET pathway from Sm(II) to Sm(III) was applied for the synthesis.29 Considering potential applications (lanthanide pnictide compounds have been discussed as potential thermoelectrical devices, transparent electrical contacts or solar cells)30–32 and in terms of possible optical and magnetic properties, this restriction to samarium compounds within 4f-element chemistry is a strong limitation.
Herein, we report a new pathway towards organo-f-element arsenic Zintl ions beyond Sm by combining the solid-state material As0nano with the high redox potentials of various molecular non-classical divalent lanthanide compounds. For this purpose, the non-classical divalent lanthanide three electron reducing agents ([K(18-crown-6)][(Ln)2(μ-η6:η6-C6H6)], Ln = La, Ce) (A) and four electron reducing agents ([K(18-crown-6)]2[(Ln)2(μ-η6:η6-C6H6)], Ln = Ce, Nd) (B) were employed (Fig. 1).33–35
Fig. 1 Three- (A(La), A(Ce)) and four- (B(Ce), B(Nd)) electron reducing agents, featuring non-classical divalent lanthanides ([Si] = SiMe3).33,34 |
Fig. 2 Molecular structure of 2 in the solid state. Solvent molecules, and hydrogen atoms are omitted for clarity. For bond lengths and angles see ESI (Fig. S9‡). |
It should be kept in mind that the solid-state material As0nano is gray arsenic, which features a polymeric structure. Thus, the selective formation of the As73− cages is a complicated process, which requires several steps of bond breaking and bond formation.
Since compound 1 and 2 exhibit the same structural motif, only the molecular solid-state structure of compound 2 is discussed in detail here. The As–As bond lengths within the As73− unit are longest on average for the uncharged basal arsenic atoms As5, As6 and As7 (As5–As6 2.4654(5), As5–As7 2.4717(5), As6–As7 2.4805(5) Å). Compared to these, the bonds towards the charged arsenic atoms tend to be shortened, with those towards the apical and uncharged As1 being in average slightly longer than those towards the As5–As6–As7 plane (As1–As2 2.4101(5), As1–As3 2.4129(5), As1–As4 2.4777(5) Å vs. As2–As5 2.3877(5), As3–As6 2.3845(5), As4–As7 2.4010(5) Å). In contrast to symmetrically coordinated As73− units, e.g., [(Li{dme})3As7] or K3As7,37,38 there are slight deviations in the bonding parameters from a symmetrical setup in the As73− core of compounds 1 and 2 due to the asymmetrical coordination with the various cationic fragments. The observed Ce–As bond lengths (Ce1–As2 3.0460(4), Ce1–As4 3.1053(4), Ce2–As3 3.0412(4), Ce2–As4 3.0897(4) Å) match with previous observations.33 The K–As distances are relatively long at ∼3.76 Å, which suggests weak coordination by the [K(18-crown-6)]+ fragment. Nevertheless, they are in a range observed for other potassium polyarsenides (e.g. 3.19–3.84 Å in [K(2.2.2-cryptand)]2(KAs7)).39,40
After the successful application of the 3-electron reducing agents A(La) and A(Ce) in the activation of nanoscale arsenic, we felt challenged to treat As0nano with 4-electron reducing agents in the reduction process. For comparison, we reacted the closely related compounds B(Ce) and B(Nd) with As0nano. This allows to maintain the same steric influence of the reducing agents to have an unobstructed view of the influence of the different reduction processes (three vs. four electrons). The reaction of both with As0nano at room temperature resulted in a mixture of different products in the subsequent crystallization. However, by changing the reaction conditions upon usage of B(Nd) (excess of As0nano and prolonged heating) it was possible to isolate [{K(18-crown-6)}2(Nd)2(μ4-η2:η2:η2:η2-As14)] (3) exclusively but in low yields of 7% (Scheme 2).
Compound 3 represents the largest organo-lanthanide-polyarsenide known to date. The central As144− unit formally consists of two covalently linked As72− units (Fig. 3).
Fig. 3 Molecular structure of 3 in the solid state. Solvent molecules and hydrogen atoms are omitted for clarity. Only one part of the positional disordered [K(18-crown-6)]+ is depicted. For both parts, bond lengths and angles see ESI (Fig. S10‡). |
Considering that As72− radicals are a known species,41 the formation of 3 can be explained via the radical recombination of two As72− units. The newly formed As–As bond, linking the two As72− units, of 2.4522(14) Å is in the range of a single bond (e.g. ca. 2.44 Å in carbene-stabilized diarene)42 and comparable to the bonds between the basal arsenic atoms As5, As6, and As7 (2.4516(10)–2.4580(11) Å). Analogous to the previously obtained As73− units, the As–As bonds involving the charged equatorial arsenic atoms As2 and As4 are the shortest. However, in contrast to the nortricyclene structures of 1 and 2, the [K(18-crown-6)]+ fragments are not coordinated by the equatorial and charged As atoms but by the basal ones, presumably for steric reasons. Additionally, they are disordered over two positions each (see Fig. S8‡). The cations are coordinated by the two respective charged equatorial arsenic atoms (Nd–As2 3.0506(7) Å, Nd–As4 3.0673(7) Å), with bond lengths comparable to the literature.33 In general, As144− Zintl anions are uncommon. There is one iron species, [K(dme)2]2[(Cp*Fe)2(μ,η2:2:2:2-As14)], which formally consists of two As7-norbonadiene motifs connected by means of an additional As–As bond.43 This is in contrast to 3, where two covalently linked As7-nortricyclene units form the As144− scaffold. The central motif of 3 is just reported from the solid state compound [Rb(18-crown-6)]4As14·6 NH3 and not known in molecular f-element chemistry.44
As an interim conclusion, we note that the formation and isolation of the As73− and As144− species by activation of nanoscale gray arsenic depends on the reducing agent used (3 vs. 4 electron reducing agents) and the reaction conditions. Moreover, the formation of the As73− and As144− species requires several steps of bond breaking and bond formation of gray arsenic. Thus, the formation of the well-characterized species 1–3 in one step seems to be unlikely. This can be seen by either using B(Ce) as a reducing reagent or by carrying out the reaction with B(Nd) at room temperature (note: 3 was formed at elevated temperature). In both cases mixtures of products were obtained. These could not be fully characterized as their separation failed due to similar solubility and identical appearance. However, their formation allows further insights into the complicated reduction process of As0nano as a solid-state material. Therefore, the hereby obtained compounds should be briefly discussed in the following section.
The activation of As0nano with B(Ce) at room temperature resulted in two different products (Scheme 3). In addition to crystals of compound 2, which was already obtained when A(Ce) was used, crystals of the As144− species [{K(18-crown-6)}2(Ce)2(μ4-η2:η2:η2-As14)] (4) (Fig. 4) were isolated, representing the Ce analogue of 3. As observed for 3, the newly formed As–As bond of 2.4468(13) Å is in the range of the bonds of the also uncharged basal arsenic atoms As5, As6, and As7 (2.4490(10)–2.4661(9) Å).
Fig. 4 Molecular structure of 4 in the solid state. Solvent molecules and hydrogen atoms are omitted for clarity. Only one part of the positional disordered [K(18-crown-6)]+ is depicted. For both parts, bond lengths and angles see ESI (Fig. S11‡). |
All other bond lengths are in accordance with 3 as well. The cations also coordinate to the two respective charged equatorial arsenic atoms (Ce–As2 3.0598(8) Å, Ce–As4 3.0417(7) Å), with bond lengths comparable to the corresponding bonds in 2. Analogous to 3, the [K(18-crown-6)]+ fragments are disordered over two positions (Fig. S11‡).
In contrast to B(Ce), the use of the 4-electron Nd reducing agent B(Nd) at room temperature resulted in mixture of even more products upon crystallization (Scheme 4). As result, four different species were formed under these conditions, indicating an influence of the different used lanthanides and their reactivity on the reaction. The obtained products are the As33− species [K(18-crown-6)][(Nd)2(μ-η3:η3-As3)] (5), two compounds with an As73− motif [{K(18-crown-6)}(Nd)2(μ3-η2:η2:η2-As7)] (6) and [{K(18-crown-6)}2(Nd)(μ3-η2:η2:η2-As7)] (7) as well as the isolable As144−-compound (3).
Within the mixture obtained at room temperature, [K(18-crown-6)][(Nd)2(μ-η3:η3-As3)] (5) (Fig. 5) features the smallest of the organo-lanthanide-polyarsenides obtained here (As33− unit) and – similar to [(Sm)2(μ-η2:η2-As2)] from the activation of As0nano by SET – may be regarded as an intermediate in the formation of the larger polyarsenides.26 The fragments are slightly offset from each other and both η3-coordinated by the central As33− moiety, which in turn forms an equilateral triangle. The Nd–As bond lengths range from 2.9311(7) to 3.0481(7) Å and are thus comparable to the shortest Nd–As distance in [K(18-crown-6)][Nd(μ-η4:η4-As5)FeCp*] (2.9258(4) Å).33 The As–As distances (2.4198(7)–2.4388(8) Å), all of approximately equal length, are in the range of single bonds.42 Additionally, they are comparable to As33− units in solid state compounds (2.43–2.47 Å in CsAs).38 While an example of an uranium complex with such an As33− unit is reported for the actinides,45 this has not been accessible for the lanthanides so far.
Fig. 5 Molecular structure of 5 in the solid state. Solvent molecules, counter cation [K(18-crown-6)]+ and hydrogen atoms are omitted for clarity. For bond lengths and angles see ESI (Fig. S12‡). |
In addition, two different compounds with an As73− structural motif were also found in the mixture (Fig. 6). Here, [{K(18-crown-6)}(Nd)2(μ3-η2:η2:η2-As7)] (6) represents the Nd analogue to 2. The observed bond lengths are all comparable to the latter. In contrast, [{K(18-crown-6)}2(Nd)(μ3-η2:η2:η2-As7)] (7) shows an altered composition, since the charge balance takes place by means of a fragment and two [K(18-crown-6)]+ units (vice versa for 1, 2, and 6). All bond lengths are within the previously observed ranges.
Fig. 6 Molecular structures of 6 (top) and 7 (bottom) in the solid state. Solvent molecules and hydrogen atoms are omitted for clarity. For bond lengths and angles see ESI (Fig. S13 and S14‡). |
Finally, the last compound that can be obtained in the mixture is the already described As144− compound 3. As mentioned above, this compound could also be obtained in pure form in the presence of an excess of As0nano and by prolonged heating (Scheme 2).
On the one hand, the clean formation of an As73− Zintl anion with a nortricyclic structure in 1 and 2 is observed by using the 3-electron reducing agents A(La) and A(Ce). Although lanthanide compounds with As73− Zintl anions have already been reported, the nortricyclane structural motif was previously unknown in this chemistry. On the other hand, the formation the As144− Zintl species 3 as sole isolable product is seen by applying the 4-electon reducing agents B(Nd) at elevated temperature. Compound 3 represents the largest known organo-lanthanide-polyarsenides to date. In between these boundaries, mixtures of various compounds with a polyarsenide as central motif were obtained. These results show that the formation of sophisticated structures directly out of nanoscale gray arsenic, which is a kind of polymer, is a complex process with various intermediates. Only careful tuning of the reaction conditions and the use of an optimized reducing reagent leads to isolable and unprecedented products.
Footnotes |
† Dedicated to Prof. Peter C. Junk on the occasion of his 60th birthday. |
‡ Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available: Full experimental procedures, spectra, and analytical data is provided. CCDC 2094692–2094698. For ESI and crystallographic data in CIF or other electronic format see DOI: 10.1039/d1sc05797a |
§ These authors contributed equally to this work. |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2022 |