Lukas M.
Sigmund
a,
Eliane
Engels‡
a,
Nick
Richert‡
a and
Lutz
Greb
*b
aRuprecht-Karls-Universität Heidelberg, Anorganisch-Chemisches Institut, Im Neuenheimer Feld 270, Heidelberg 69120, Germany
bFreie Universität Berlin, Anorganische Chemie, Fabeckstraße 34-36, Berlin 14195, Germany. E-mail: lutz.greb@fu-berlin.de
First published on 7th September 2022
Forcing a priori tetracoordinate atoms into planar configuration represents a promising concept for enhanced reactivity of p-block element-based systems. Herein, the synthesis, characterization, and reactivity of calix[4]pyrrolato gallates, constituting square planar-coordinated gallium(III) atoms, are reported. Unusual structural constraint-induced Lewis acidity against neutral and anionic donors is disclosed by experiment and rationalized by computations. An energetically balanced dearomatization/rearomatization of a pyrrole unit enables fully reversible metal–ligand cooperative capture of CO2. While alcohols are found unreactive against the gallates, a rapid and selective OH-bond activation can be triggered upon protonation of the ligand. Secondary ligand–sphere modification adds a new avenue to structurally-constrained complexes that unites functional group tolerance with unconventional reactivity.
Planarization results in a distinct alteration of the electronic structure, namely rising the energy of the highest occupied molecular orbital (HOMO) and lowering the energy of the lowest unoccupied molecular orbital (LUMO) (Fig. 1B).19,20 These features equip the compounds with biphilic properties, ideal for element-ligand cooperative reactivity21–23 toward various functional groups (Fig. 1A).14,16,24–26 The potential of gallium–ligand cooperativity (GaLC) was so far exploited with binuclear Ga(II)-species toward unsaturated substrates such as alkynes,27,28 isocyanates,29 and others (Fig. 1C).23,30–33 A few examples of GaLC of mononuclear complexes with amidophenolato34 or deprotonated β-diketiminato35 ligands, as well as Berben's pyridine diimine-system18 are also known to the literature (Fig. 1C).
We herewith report on the synthesis, characterization, and reactivity of two calix[4]pyrrolato gallates(III) (Fig. 1D) and their GaLC reversible addition of CO2 and protic substrates. They represent the first examples of monoanions with square planar-coordinated gallium(III) atoms and showcase a new direction for reactivity modulation by secondary ligand–sphere modification.
Fig. 2 (a) Synthetic scheme for the preparation of the gallates [Me1]− and [Et1]− as their [PPh4]+ salts (DME: 1,2-dimethoxyethane). (b) Solid state molecular structures of [Me1]− and [Et1]− as determined by SCXRD analyses. The counter cations, cocrystallized solvent molecules, and the hydrogen atoms are not shown. Thermal displacement ellipsoids are presented at a probability level of 50%. Mean Ga–N distances [pm]: [Me1]−: 193.8(1), [Et1]−: 195.0(1). Mean cis-N–Ga–N angles [°]: [Me1]−: 90.0(1), [Et1]−: 90.0(1). Mean trans-N–Ga–N angles [°]: [Me1]−: 178.6(1), [Et1]−: 178.7(1). CCDC numbers: 2175982, 2175981. (c) Kohn–Sham frontier molecular orbital representations of [Me1]−. Hydrogen atoms are not shown for clarity. |
This structural arrangement was analyzed by various computational techniques (for all computational details see the ESI).† Structural optimization with density functional theory (DFT) confirmed the square planar structure as the energetic global minimum. Constrained structural optimization of [Me1]− with the valence angles around the gallium atom fixed to 109.5° gave a conformer 581 kJ mol−1 higher in energy as the fully relaxed structure (see Fig. S8 in the ESI).† In comparison, constraining the non-cyclic tetrapyrrolato gallate, which has an effectively tetrahedral ground state, to square planarity costs 166 kJ mol−1.20 This nicely illustrates the substantial support of the macrocyclic calix[4]pyrrolato ligand and its electronic properties (σ-accepting, π-donating)39 as being crucial for the experimental realization of this configuration.
The anion [Me1]− features an energetically low-lying LUMO (1.48 eV), having its largest coefficient (0.754 within a natural atomic orbital basis) for the 4pz orbital of the gallium atom (Fig. 2C). In contrast, the HOMO is entirely located in the ligand backbone (Fig. 2C). This agrees with the findings for the corresponding aluminum(III) and silicon(IV) compound and matches early theoretical work from the von Schleyer group.19 This electronic structure should impart the isolated gallates with biphilic character (vide infra). To probe the global Lewis acidity of [Me1]−, its solution phase (dichloromethane) fluoride ion affinity (FIAsolv) was computed. It amounts to 149 kJ mol−1 ([Et1]−: 132 kJ mol−1).40 This value is slightly reduced compared to the analogous aluminate (196 kJ mol−1), though still substantial given the anionic charge state of [Me1]−. For comparison, the FIAsolv value of the tetrahedral tetrapyrrolato gallate is 58 kJ mol−1 – corresponding to an increase in Ga–F bond strength of 90 kJ mol−1 mainly based on geometric effects!
Following these computational results [PPh4][Me1] was reacted with one equivalent of the fluoride ion donor tetrabutylammonium difluorotriphenylsilicate (TBAT) in acetonitrile at room temperature (Fig. 3A). Workup after 4 h afforded an orange solid in 80% yield. Its 1H NMR spectrum showed two doublets for the pyrrolic β-protons and four signals for the methyl groups. Intriguingly, the signal of the endo-methyl groups next to the fluoride is split into a doublet (3.1 Hz), indicating through-space fluorine-proton spin–spin coupling. This doublet splitting was also found for the signal of the carbon atom of the respective methyl groups (18.3 Hz). The 19F NMR spectrum contained a resonance at −146 ppm, significantly broadened due to this coupling.15 In total, this is consistent with the formation of the dianionic [Me1-F]2−, which was further confirmed by mass spectrometry. These results also agree with the calculated lower FIAsolv of fluorotriphenylsilane (85 kJ mol−1) in comparison to the value of [Me1]− (see above) and with the overall negative solution-phase Gibbs free reaction energy of −65 kJ mol−1 for the fluoride transfer reaction from difluorotriphenylsilicate to [Me1]− in acetonitrile. Additional experimental proof for the Lewis acidic reactivity of [Me1]− was found when [PPh4][Me1] was crystallized from tetrahydrofuran (THF) as solvent.
Fig. 3 Lewis acidic reactivity of [Me1]− as demonstrated (a) by the reaction of [PPh4][Me1] with tetrabutylammonium difluorotriphenylsilicate (TBAT) and (b) by the solid-state structures as determined by SCXRD analysis of [PPh4][Me1] crystallized from THF as solvent. Thermal displacement ellipsoids are shown at a probability level of 50%. Selected bond lengths [pm]: Ga–O: 202.30(8), mean Ga–N: 199.32(5). Selected bond angles [°]: mean cis-N–Ga–N angle: 89.21(2), mean trans-N–Ga–N angle: 166.5(1), mean O–Ga–NX (X = 1, 2, 3, 4) angle: 96.8(1). CCDC number: 2175983. |
One THF coordinating to the gallium atom was observed in the solid-state structure with a Ga–O distance of 202.3 pm (Fig. 2B). Interestingly, the computed solution-phase affinity toward THF is low for both gallates ([Me1]−: 0 kJ mol−1, [Et1]−: −4 kJ mol−1), allowing for THF removal during the workup of the synthesis of [PPh4][Me1] and [PPh4][Et1], respectively.
Having established the Lewis acidity of the gallates by computations and experiment, it was tested whether their properties arising from the square planar-coordinated Ga(III) atoms serve to facilitate reactions with other substrate molecules. The analogous calix[4]pyrrolato aluminate showed manifold reactivity with carbonyl-containing compounds (see Fig. 1A);25 so we reacted [PPh4][Me1] and [PPh4][Et1] with carbon dioxide.
After exposing both gallates dissolved in dichloromethane-d2 to 5 bar of CO2 at room temperature, the solutions turned intensively yellow within several hours. This color change indicates the dearomatization of one pyrrole moiety (marked with an asterisk in the following formulae). The 1H NMR spectra showed the clean emergence of a new C1 symmetric species, which was unambiguously identified as the gallium–ligand cooperative addition product of CO2 to [Me1]− and [Et1]−, respectively (Fig. 4, see the ESI for details).† Interestingly, the conversion to [R1*-CO2]− was found almost quantitative for the methyl case (96%), whereas a 2:1 ratio of starting material to addition product was observed for the ethyl gallate under the chosen reaction conditions. The Gibbs free activation energy for the addition reaction of CO2 to [Me1]− was calculated to ΔG‡r = 90 kJ mol−1, and the overall Gibbs free reaction energy to ΔGr = 6 kJ mol−1, which conforms with the experimental observations. Further, the computational simulations reproduced the decreased binding strength of CO2 to [Et1]− (ΔGr = 18 kJ mol−1). This may be rationalized by the slightly decreased Lewis acidity on the FIAsolv scale of the gallium atom in [Et1]− (see above) as well as by a larger stabilization of [Me1*-CO2]− in a dichloromethane solution as found by COSMO-RS41–43 calculations (see Chapter S11 in the ESI).†
In agreement with these thermoneutral computed values, the application of reduced pressure to solutions of [PPh4][R1*-CO2] over several hours at room temperature resulted in the quantitative removal of CO2 from the systems and in the selective reformation of [R1]− (see Fig. S1 and S2 in the ESI).† Element-ligand cooperative (ELC) binding of CO2 is a widely studied reaction with various transition metals44–50 and p-block elements51–59 and was also investigated in small molecule contexts other than ELC.35,60–66 To the best of our knowledge, the described reaction represents the first example for reversible CO2 fixation by a gallium(III) platform. This is achieved by the balanced energetics in dearomatization/rearomatization of one of the pyrrole rings of the calix[4]pyrrolato ligand.
We next turned our attention to protic substrates, namely alcohols, as their ready activation by the calix[4]pyrrolato aluminate was already noticed by our group.24 Upon reacting one equivalent of iPrOH with [PPh4][Me1] and [PPh4][Et1], respectively, no reaction occurred, contrasting the behavior of the corresponding aluminates, i.e., the formation of an oxygen–element bond with the proton being transferred to the 2-position of one of the pyrrole rings (Fig. 5B, left part). We reasoned that protonation of the ligand backbone might serve as a powerful strategy for second-sphere reactivity modulation in structurally constrained complexes. Such tactics are well-known in an alternative context,67 for example, applied by the Corey group in enantioselective Diels–Alder catalysis.68–70 To probe this hypothesis computationally, the α-pyrrole protonated, neutral [H-Me1*] was optimized by DFT and its electronic structure was examined. The HOMO is now concentrated almost exclusively in the pyrrole unit opposite the protonation site, which itself is hosting the LUMO (Fig. 5A). The LUMO+1 resembles the former LUMO (cf. Fig. 2C) with the dominant contribution of the 4pz orbital of the gallium atom. The calculated solution phase FIA of [H-Me1*], which was 149 kJ mol−1 for [Me1]−, is now boosted to 191 kJ mol−1, pointing to an augmented Lewis acidity.
Motivated by these computational results [PPh4][Me1] and [PPh4][Et1] were treated with bis(trifluoromethyl)sulfonimide (HNTf2) in dichloromethane-d2 as solvent. The 1H NMR spectra of the reaction mixtures showed an unselective product mixture. Computations disclosed a potential decomposition channel initiated after the formation of [H-Me1*] by the cleavage of the exopyrrolic C–C bond originating from the proton-bearing carbon atom of the dearomatized pyrrole ring (see Chapter S8 in the ESI for details).† However, a selective transformation was observed when THF-d8 was used as solvent. The 1H NMR data revealed the dearomatization of one of the pyrrole rings, besides a slightly broadened singlet resonance at 5.02 ppm, assigned to the new proton in the 2-position of the dearomatized pyrrole ring. Apparently, the Lewis basic properties of THF suppress the undesired pathway mentioned above. Indeed, remodeling the C–C bond cleavage transition state in the presence of an explicit THF molecule coordinating to Ga in [H-Me1*], resulted in a significant increase in Gibbs free activation energy of 64 kJ mol−1 (see the ESI for details).† When repeating the reaction with HNTf2 in a mixture of dichloromethane-d2 and diethyl ether (2:1 % vol), the same 1H NMR characteristics were found, supporting the Lewis base stabilization rationale.
Subsequently, the reaction with iPrOH was repeated with the in situ generated [H-Me1*]·Et2O in the dichloromethane/diethyl ether mixture. After stirring at room temperature for 1 min, removing the solvent, and extracting with n-pentane/diethyl ether (4:1 % vol), a pale-yellow solid was isolated in 72% yield. Its 1H NMR spectrum showed the formation of a symmetric species with two dearomatized pyrrole rings due to protonation at the 2-positions and an isopropyl group with shifted signals compared to free iPrOH. These features align with the formation of the neutral O–H bond addition product [HH-Me1**-OiPr] by gallium–ligand cooperativity (Fig. 5B, right part). Hence, whereas [Me1]− itself is not capable of splitting the O–H bond by GaLC, the protonated, neutral [H-Me1*]·Et2O instantaneously adds iPrOH. It confirms the hypothesis that the reactivity of [Me1]− can be enhanced by protonation of the ligand backbone.
Footnotes |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available. CCDC [2175981–2175983]. For ESI and crystallographic data in CIF or other electronic format see https://doi.org/10.1039/d2sc03054c |
‡ These authors contributed equally to this work. |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2022 |