Andreas
Rehpenn
,
Alexandra
Walter
and
Golo
Storch
*
School of Natural Sciences and Catalysis Research Center (CRC), Technical University of Munich (TUM), Lichtenbergstr. 4, 85747 Garching, Germany. E-mail: golo.storch@tum.de
First published on 14th November 2022
In nature, the isoalloxazine heterocycle of flavin cofactors undergoes reversible covalent bond formation with a variety of different reaction partners. These intermediates play a crucial role inter alia as the signalling states and in selective catalysis reactions. In the organic laboratory, covalent adducts with a new carbon–carbon bond have been observed with photochemically excited flavins but have, so far, only been regarded as dead-end side products. We have identified a series of molecular flavins that form adducts resulting in a new C–C bond at the C4a-position through allylic C–H activation and dehydroamino acid oxidation. Typically, these reactions are of radical nature and a stepwise pathway is assumed. We could demonstrate that these adducts are no dead-end and that the labile C–C bond can be cleaved by adding the persistent radical TEMPO leading to flavin regeneration and alkoxyamine-functionalised substrates. Our method allows for the catalytic oxidation of dehydroamino acids (16 examples) and we show that the acylimine products serve as versatile starting points for diversification. The present results are envisioned to stimulate the design of further catalytic reactions involving intermediates at the flavin C4a-position and their reactivity towards metal complexes or other persistent organic radicals. Our method for dehydrobutyrine derivatisation is orthogonal to the currently used methods (i.e., nucleophilic attack or radical addition) and offers new perspectives for peptide natural product diversification.
Both the formation of covalent C–C adducts at the C4a-position and presumably also their reaction with O2 are typically radical pathways. We wondered whether the formal homolysis step would allow using flavin C–C adducts as a reservoir for carbon-centred substrate radicals. Following this rationale, the adducts should also react with other radical species besides O2 and we were particularly interested in the reaction with the persistent radical TEMPO. On the substrate side, we focused on the activation of allylic C–H positions in olefins and the oxidation of dehydroamino acids. Radical addition reactions of the latter substrates are a perfect tool for the diversification of peptide natural products,8 which are of high pharmaceutical relevance.9 The typical protocol relies on radical generation and addition to a dehydroamino acid's β-position.10 An iridium-mediated generation of heteroatom-stabilized radicals from dimethylanilines and their subsequent addition to a short peptide 8 yielding conjugate 9 serves as a representative example here (Fig. 2A).11 The orthogonal approach, which relies on the oxidation of a dehydroamino acid and its subsequent intermolecular reaction is, however, much less explored. This reactivity was found in PCET-type12 oxidation of dehydrophenylalanine 10 (BDFE = 456 kJ mol−1) with Ag2O to an intermediate radical 11, which reacts with TEMPO at the β-position yielding alkoxyamine product 12 (Fig. 2B).13 Related TEMPO-functionalisation of peptides has also been accomplished by dechalcogenation.14
We wondered whether such functionalisation of dehydroamino acids could be performed catalytically with molecular flavins.15 While their use as photo-oxidants is well-established,16 we were in particular interested in using covalent intermediates at the flavin's C4a-position as stabilised substrate radicals (Fig. 2C).
Fig. 3 Flavin catalyst synthesis. For reaction conditions and yields of diamines 13, see the ESI.† Flavin synthesis: 2.5 equiv. N-butyl barbituric acid, 3 mol% RuCl3·(H2O)3, 5.0 equiv. tBuOOH (CH2Cl2/H2O), r.t., 22 h; then 1.0 equiv. B2O3 (AcOH), r.t., o/n. Yields for this two-step procedure: 59% (14), 42% (15), and 33% (16). PMHS: poly(methylhydrosiloxane). |
Following our design principle, we directly started with ester-modified flavin 14 and interrogated the photochemical allylic activation of cycloheptadiene (BDE for allylic C–H bond is 347.3 kJ mol−1)19 as a model substrate. Indeed, when irradiating a solution of flavin and diene in CD2Cl2 under inert conditions in a J Young NMR tube, we observed the clean formation of covalent adduct 19 (as a set of two diastereomers), which has a newly established C–C bond at the C4a-position (Fig. 4A). This compound was characterized by 2D-NMR and HR-ESI (see ESI† for details). Upon contact with air, quinoid flavin 14 was regenerated. We then studied whether the new C–C bond is weak enough to be cleaved upon the addition of a persistent radical and treated adduct 19 with TEMPO under inert conditions (Fig. 4B). Again, we observed the formation of quinoid flavin 14 but we could also detect the stoichiometric release of alkoxyamine-functionalised diene 20 in the NMR tube (Fig. 4C).
From a synthetic standpoint, the formation of alkoxyamine 20 reminded us of the known reactivity of alkenes towards nitroxyl radicals20 and oxoammonium cations,21 which is typically very low with disubstituted olefins. We wondered, whether our flavin activation method might offer a way to catalyse these reactions and found that a flavin-mediated method with TEMPO as a reactant and oxidant indeed leads to product formation (Table 1, entry #1). When using Bobbitt's salt (21) instead of TEMPO, only one equivalent of the reagent is required since the oxoammonium salt not only acts as an oxidant (Emp [nitroxo+/nitroxyl˙] = +0.65 V vs. Ag/AgCl (+0.61 V vs. SCE)),22 but also liberates the persistent radical reaction partner. Potassium phosphate is added as a base to trap the released fluoroboric acid (entry #2). The parent flavin RFTA(Me) performed worse (entry #3) and all control experiments verified that a photochemically excited flavin is required (entries #4 and #5).
Entry | Catalyst | Change of conditions | Yielda,b |
---|---|---|---|
a Determined by NMR vs. internal standard. b n.d. = no product formation was detected. c TEMPO (without a base) was used instead of Bobbitt's salt 21 leading to product 20. d Isolated yield. e (−)-N-3-Methyl riboflavin tetraacetate. | |||
#1 | 14 | TEMPO instead of 21 | 27%c |
#2 | 14 | — | 42% (37%)d |
#3 | RFTA(Me)e | — | 17% |
#4 | 14 | No irradiation | n.d./n.d.c |
#5 | None | — | n.d./n.d.c |
With these encouraging results in hand, we investigated whether flavin catalysis would also allow the oxidative TEMPO-functionalisation of more complex substrates such as dehydroamino acids (c.f.Fig. 2). We chose dehydrobutyrine 23 as a model substrate and indeed, the formation of acylimine 24 was achieved.
Here, the use of TEMPO (3.0 equiv.) was found to result in better yields when compared to Bobbitt's salt 21 (Table 2, entries #1 and #2). The carboxamide flavin 15, C7-substituted ester 16, and parent flavin 17 all resulted in lower yields (entries #3–#5). Since catalysis product 24 is sensitive towards hydrolysis, the addition of water (10 equiv.) to the reaction mixture resulted in only a trace amount of product (entry #6). The control reactions (entries #7 and #8) confirmed that the reaction is driven by a photochemically excited flavin catalyst.
Entry | Catalyst | Change of conditions | Yielda,b |
---|---|---|---|
a Determined by NMR vs. internal standard. b n.d. = no product formation was detected. c Acylimine 24 slowly hydrolyses during purification by column chromatography and a significantly reduced isolated yield (14%) was obtained. d Reagent 21 (1.0 equiv. together with K3PO4 as a base) was used instead of TEMPO leading to product 24NHAc with an acetamide substituent in the piperidine's 4-position. | |||
#1 | 14 | — | 60%c |
#2 | 14 | 21 instead of TEMPO | 6%d |
#3 | 15 | — | 15% |
#4 | 16 | — | 35% |
#5 | 17 | — | 43% |
#6 | 14 | With 10 equiv. H2O | <5% |
#7 | 14 | No irradiation | n.d./n.d.d |
#8 | None | — | n.d./n.d.d |
We were intrigued by the improved activity of ester-modified flavin 14 and went on to study similarities and differences when compared to RFTA(Me). Both quinoid flavins show relatively similar spectroscopic properties (Fig. 5A, see ESI† for details): λabsmax = 442 nm, E(S0 ← S1) = 246 kJ mol−1 (EtOH, r.t.), and E(S0 ← T1) = 205 kJ mol−1 (EtOH, 77 K) (14) vs. λabsmax = 448 nm, E(S0 ← S1) = 244 kJ mol−1 (EtOH, r.t.), and E(S0 ← T1) = 205 kJ mol−1 (EtOH, 77 K) (RFTA(Me)). Cyclic voltammetry, however, revealed characteristic differences: The N3-alkylated flavin RFTA(Me) shows a simple cyclic voltammogram with a reversible reduction process (E1/2 = −0.86 V vs. SCE, see ESI† for details).23 Under analogous conditions, flavin 14 shows two separate oxidation waves (waves 2 and 3) and a half-wave potential of E1/2 = −0.72 V vs. SCE for the reversible reduction. We rationalise this observation by a significantly faster protonation of the immediately formed anion 14˙− to the neutral radical 18, which is reasonable based on the favoured intramolecular hydrogen bonding. This neutral semiquinone 18 is easier to reduce than quinoid flavin 14 and, therefore, it is converted to hydroquinoid 18− in wave 1. Reoxidation of 14˙− (wave 2) and 18− (wave 3) then occur separately. In order to prove this hypothesis, we accelerated the protonation step by measuring cyclic voltammograms in the presence of acetic acid.24 Indeed, this resulted in the detection of only one oxidation wave, which corresponds to the oxidation of 18− (Fig. 5B, see ESI† for details).
The flavin-catalysed method was successfully applied to the oxidative modification of a variety of dehydroamino acid substrates (Fig. 6), which also do not show any uncatalysed reactivity under our conditions with either TEMPO or Bobbitt's salt (see ESI† for attempted conversion of a dehydrobutyrine substrate to acylimine 25). Owing to the decreased electrophilicity of the acylimine amides compared to ester-derived product 24, the former are significantly less reactive towards water hydrolysis and their isolation is straightforward. Similar results were observed when increasing the size of the alkyl chain on the substrate's C–C double bond or the amide (products 25–28). The acylamides 29–31 from amides consisting of two amino acid residues were also successfully formed. We found that our method is not limited to benzamide substrates and the readily available Boc- and Cbz-protected products 32–34 were obtained in reasonable yields as well. Aromatic amino acid side chains such as phenylalanine (35) or protected histidine (36) and tyrosine (37) are also tolerated. Dehydroamino acid amides are significantly more reactive compared to the analogous esters, which allowed the selective formation of acylimine 25 with only negligible amounts of ester 38 in a competition experiment. The same preference was observed in an intramolecular setting, where mono-functionalised acylimine 39 was the only species we observed when using a substrate with two dehydrobutyrine residues.
We subsequently interrogated the mechanism of dehydroamino acid activation. Consistent with initial radical formation at the amide nitrogen position yielding an N-centered radical, we did not observe any conversion of N-methylated substrate (E)-41 under standard catalysis conditions (see ESI†). When irradiating this amino acid substrate together with flavin 14 in a J Young NMR tube under the exclusion of air, we confirmed that neither E/Z-isomerisation25 nor substrate conversion takes place (Fig. 7). This also holds true for the isomeric (Z)-41, which was also not converted under these conditions. In contrast, oxidation of both (E)- and (Z)-40 results in radical formation at the dehydroamino acid's β-position. When we conducted such experiments in J Young NMR tubes with the exclusion of air and without TEMPO, we observed the formation of covalent flavin adducts within minutes and confirmed this by HR-ESI measurements. Careful inspection of 2D-NMR spectra and NOE-contacts corroborated our assignment of a covalent C–C adduct at the C4a-position (see ESI† for details). Flavin adduct 42 is formed as an almost equal mixture of two diastereomers. When adduct 42 is irradiated in the presence of TEMPO, quinoid flavin 14 is regenerated and acylimine 25 is released.
Fig. 7 Irradiation experiments with dehydrobutyrine substrates 40 and 41 in J Young NMR tubes under the exclusion of air. |
Acylimines are easily reduced to the corresponding amides by sodium borohydride, which leaves the TEMPO-functionalisation unaltered (Fig. 8A). Also, the relatively weak C–O bond in TEMPO-containing organic products allows subsequent transformations,26,27 and we demonstrated the oxidation of alkoxyamine 43 to ketone 44 by mCPBA. All of the obtained acylimine products resemble reactive electrophiles and, therefore, offer the possibility for one-pot reactions leading to diversified amino acid products. Acylimine 28 was found to be unstable during chromatography with silica gel, but when subjected to a one-pot malonate addition sequence,28 the formation of stable pyrrolidine-2,5-dione 45 was observed (Fig. 8B). We confirmed the relative stereochemistry in the five-membered ring by NOE-contacts. There are also literature protocols for the reduction of acylimines to the corresponding amides.29 As a representative example for transforming the weak C–O bond in the alkoxyamine products, we performed a one-pot three-step sequence starting from dehydrobutyrine 23 with subsequent malonate addition and mCPBA oxidation to ketone 46 (Fig. 8C). These examples shall demonstrate that flavin catalysis is a powerful tool for the functionalisation of dehydroamino acid derivatives.
Footnote |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available. See DOI: https://doi.org/10.1039/d2sc04341f |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2022 |