Jing
Bai
,
Dingyao
Liu
,
Xinyu
Tian
and
Shiming
Zhang
*
Department of Electrical and Electronic Engineering, The University of Hong Kong, Hong Kong SAR, China. E-mail: szhang@eee.hku.hk
First published on 18th July 2022
Organic bioelectronics has gone wild over the past few decades. As flagship devices, organic electrochemical transistors (OECTs) provide a new choice for next-generation bioelectronic devices because of their excellent water stability and ability to convert small ionic signals to stronger electronic signals (iontronic amplifiers) at extremely low voltage. However, device failure occurs when OECTs are introduced at tissue-electronic interfaces due to the mechanical mismatch between the stretchable tissues and the non-stretchable devices. Tissue-like OECTs aim to make a paradigm shift to unlock the potential of OECTs for applications at soft bioelectronic interfaces by acquiring the mechanical stretchable and healable properties of soft tissues. The stretchability allows OECTs to conform better with soft tissues under motion or deformation, while the self-healing ability permits fast recovery of the electronic functionality after accidental damage. In this article, we highlight the recent trends in developing tissue-like OECTs. Challenges in materials, devices, fabrications, and applications are summarized. Finally, we present our view on how tissue-like OECTs can serve as a new building block to impact exciting new areas, including wearables and implantable medical devices, e-skin, soft robotics, and soft neuroelectronics.
When used for recording health-related signals in vivo, such as deep brain activities, bioelectronic devices are expected to have the following merits to promote their use in practical situations: (i) good biocompatibility to minimize the foreign body reaction. Organic electronics stand out here because they are naturally similar to human tissues.2 This advantage gives rise to the field of organic bioelectronics;2 (ii) high stability in body fluids. While very few organic bioelectronic materials can meet this need, PEDOT:PSS (poly(3,4-ethylenedioxythiophene) polystyrene sulfonate) is an exception;3 and (iii) high signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) to lower the limit of detection. In this regard, transistor transducers are used to amplify the signal in situ.4
The combination of the above three merits points to a fast-rising bioelectronic device, the organic electrochemical transistors (OECTs).5,6 In OECTs, the ionic electrolyte replaces the dielectric layer that is used in common field-effect transistors (FETs) (Fig. 1). The use of an electrolyte as the gating media lowers the operation voltage to less than 1 V due to the large capacitance of the electrical double layer formed at the interface between the electrolyte and a solid conductor. The low operation voltage permits its use inside the human body. It is called an electrochemical transistor, not a FET, because the current modulation is achieved by the electrochemical reaction of the channel. In the case of PEDOT:PSS-based OECTs, the conductivity of the PEDOT:PSS thin film channel can be manipulated through a reversible doping/de-doping process.
OECTs have distinct advantages over other biotransistors.7–9 First, both the oxidized state and reduced state of the PEDOT:PSS-based OECTs are stable in harsh environments, such as in water or at high temperatures. Second, the freely movable ions in the electrolyte can penetrate into the bulk of the channel. This step leads to a higher sensitivity (transconductance) over FETs because the bulk modulation allows the gate to control the conductance state of polymers along the whole channel thickness (volumetric doping), while a FET only allows surface doping.10 Third, the nature of electrophysiological signals of a living creature is an ionic activity, such as action potential, which is analogous to the operation of OECTs.
In addition to the above properties, the fabrication of OECTs is compatible with facile low-temperature printing techniques, making them competitive for large-scale production at a relatively low cost compared to conventional fabrication approaches. Altogether, these merits make OECTs a highly endorsed technology for bioelectronic applications such as biosensing circuits and emerging neuromorphic hardware.
Despite the success of OECTs in the past decade, an additional issue arises when they are introduced to the device/tissue interface: the inherent mechanical mismatch between the device and the tissue causes stability issues.11–13 For example, motion-induced displacement and delamination impair the stability and reliability of signaling and may damage the surrounding tissues.
Tissue-like OECTs aim to develop soft, stretchable and healable OECTs to improve their interfacing with tissues (Fig. 1). Stretchable OECTs could minimize the mechanical mismatch toward improved signaling reliability during movement. Self-healing properties could increase the lifetime of the devices when suffering from accidental damages. Because of their potential applications in wearable and implantable medical devices, soft robotics, and soft neuroelectronics, tissue-like OECTs have taken shape in the past few years.
The major difference between tissue-like OECTs and conventional OECTs is the acquisition of additional mechanical properties of soft tissues. It includes the replacement of rigid materials with new low-modulus materials systems for device assembling, the design and fabrication strategies for higher stretchability, and the molecular-level design strategies for stretchability and healability. The ultimate tissue-like OECTs are expected to integrate materials of low modulus, high stretchability and reversible healability in one device, while maintaining high electrical performance and stability comparable to a rigid device. For material selection, in addition to low modulus, high stretchability, and molecular-level designed healability, biocompatibility and water-stability are also critically needed for practical body-centric wearable and implantable applications.
Fig. 2 Stretchable OECTs: (a) Optical images of a stretchable OECT. Adapted with permission from ref. 22 copyright 2019 Wiley-VCH; (b) stretchable OECT microelectrodes arrays (10 × 10) with channel length down to 5 μm. Adapted with permission from ref. 14 copyright 2017 American Chemical Society; (c) strain test of the stretchable system. Adapted with permission from ref. 32 copyright 2019 Wiley-VCH; (d) stretchable OECT e-skin. Adapted with permission from ref. 33 copyright 2019 Wiley-VCH. |
The first fully stretchable tissue-like OECTs were demonstrated with the buckling method.15 A stretchable solid-state tough hydrogel was brought from other disciplines to endow the device with full stretchability.19 The adhesion between the hydrogel and the substrate was investigated to prevent delamination under strain. Orthogonal photolithography and parylene transfer-patterning manufacturing technologies were combined as the manufacturing strategy to enable the assembling of stretchable OECT microarrays with a channel length less than 10 μm. Afterward, alternative strategies were used to fabricate structurally stretchable OECTs, including the use of laser ablation to pattern metallic interconnections with stretchable serpentine structures20 and the creation of a stretchable honeycomb grid on ultrathin parylene substrates.21 Significantly, in vivo experiments of the latter one proved that, when used for monitoring the electrocardiogram (ECG) signals on the heart surface of rats, stretchable OECTs boosted the SNR to 52 dB because their high conformability helped suppress motion artifacts.21 These results are exciting as they experimentally confirmed that OECT technology does outperform other competitive bioelectronic technologies in obtaining a high SNR, not only under static conditions (52.7 dB)22 but also under moving conditions (52 dB) if a stretchable device can be used.21
While structurally stretchable OECTs are relatively easier to realize, there are potential limitations for practical applications because of the fragility of the artificially constructed stretchable structures. This problem drives the development of more tissue-like intrinsically stretchable OECTs.23,24 For intrinsically stretchable OECTs, the stretchability comes from the inherent mechanical properties of the materials rather than device structures.25 Even though intrinsic stretchability is a natural advantage of organic bioelectronics over other bioelectronic technologies, it remains challenging to assemble an intrinsically stretchable OECT, mainly because of the lack of mature materials systems that can show both suitable electrical properties and intrinsic stretchability, which are considered mutually exclusive.
The first intrinsically stretchable OECTs were demonstrated in 201923 (Fig. 2a). This is made possible by the strategical selection of suitable intrinsically stretchable materials to serve as metallic electrodes, semiconducting channels, hydrogel electrolytes, and insulating layers, respectively. Special efforts were dedicated to processing materials for better intrinsic stretchability. For the PEDOT:PSS channel, it is found that thinner films and lower baking temperature are essential to maximizing intrinsic stretchability on elastomers.23 For the metallic electrodes, reducing the thickness could help gain the intrinsic stretchability on an elastomer through the formation of microcracks.26 The resultant intrinsically stretchable OECTs maintained stable electrical performance under 30% strain (the maximum value the skin can be stretched to).
The demonstration of intrinsically stretchable OECTs further promotes the use of OECTs for soft bioelectronic applications. For example, it was later demonstrated that intrinsically stretchable OECTs can be used to make stretchable neuromorphic transistors to mimic the synaptic function of a neuron.24 Recently, the performance bottleneck of intrinsically stretchable OECTs has been successfully overcome. The first intrinsically stretchable PEDOT:PSS OECT with rigid-device-benchmarkable performance was developed by using low-oxygen permeable elastomers as substrates to improve the de-doping efficiency of PEDOT:PSS thin films.27 Intrinsically stretchable OECTs hold the potential to serve as a fundamental building block for developing e-skins, artificial neurons, and chip-level soft neuroelectronic systems, which may provide artificial intelligence for future soft robotics.
It is observed that PEDOT:PSS thin films (as thin as 1 μm) damaged with a sharp blade can be electrically healed by simply wetting the damaged area with a water droplet29 (Fig. 3). The process is rapid, with a response time of 150 ms. Significantly, after being wetted, the films are transformed into autonomic self-healing materials without the need for external stimulation. This observation reveals the self-healing properties of PEDOT:PSS thin films which was later used to develop various self-healing organic bioelectronic devices.29–33
Fig. 3 Self-healable OECTs: (a) optical images of the PEDOT: PSS channel before and after water-enabled healing; (b) the healing process restored the conductance of the film and switched on the light-emitting diode; (c) schematic of the water-enabled healing process; (d) real-time current measurement of the wetted PEDOT:PSS thin film upon cutting with razor blades; (e) demonstration of self-healable OECTs where the wetted PEDOT:PSS film was used as the channel. The transfer curve remained identical after damage. Adapted with permission from ref. 27 copyright 2017 Wiley-VCH. |
The first self-healing OECTs were demonstrated by using the wet PEDOT:PSS film as the channel material.29 The OECTs autonomically restored their electrical performance after cutting the channel with a razor blade. This work proves that autonomous self-healing ability is achievable in a thin-film semiconductor device (less than 1 μm of thickness). The ability to obtain the self-healing ability in OECTs of smaller film thicknesses has several advantages. For example, there is no need to sacrifice the electrical performance such as the response time and on/off ratio, which happens in devices with greater channel thicknesses.
All-solid-state self-healable OECTs were later demonstrated by processing the PEDOT:PSS channel with a surfactant.32 The device showed a high on/off ratio of above 1000, a high transconductance of 54 mS, and a fast response time of less than 10 ms, promoting their use for practical bioelectronic applications.
The self-healing ability and the stretchability were later combined in an injectable PEDOT:PSS hydrogel fiber.34 These ultrathin fibers were fabricated through a syringe-extrusion method. The fiber is capable of being used as the channel material for OECTs. The freeze-drying method was used to induce a porous microscopic structure in the fiber to facilitate ion penetration into the channel for facile doping/de-doping. The wetted fiber is capable of being stretchable up to 20% of its initial length with healability due to the dynamic hydrogen bonding.
Fig. 4 Applications of tissue-like OECTs: (a) a coin-sized wearable analytical unit (PERfECT platform) for wireless characterization of OECTs and similar low-voltage transistors. Adapted with permission from ref. 36 copyright 2022 American Chemical Society; (b) tissue-like stretchable OECTs for pressure sensor and e-skin applications. Adapted with permission from ref. 34 copyright 2021 Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers; (c) demonstration of tissue-like OECTs for soft neuroelectronic applications. Adapted with permission from ref. 36 copyright 2022 American Chemical Society. |
To make a truly wearable system, a compact and wireless OECT readout unit is indispensable. For practical use, the size should be compatible with a smartwatch so that they can find more applications. The challenge in developing such a unit is how to maintain high accuracy during system miniaturization. This conflict was not solved until the recent development of a wireless OECT readout unit, namely “personalized electronic reader for electronic and chemical transistors (PERfECT)”38 (Fig. 4a). The coin-sized PERfECT chip has a high resolution of current reading (1 nA), high sampling rates (200 KSPS), and can characterize the overall performance of low voltage transistors including OECTs. PERfECT can measure 32 OECTs simultaneously and has been commercialized by SESIC Co., Ltd.38 Wireless and truly wearable systems have been demonstrated with stretchable OECTs for the detection of glucose concentrations.
For e-skin applications, conformability is currently a major concern. The elastic bending energy (EE) can be used to evaluate the conformability of tissue-like OECTs on a soft substrate, which is described by the Elasto-capillarity model shown as following equations:49
(1) |
(2) |
Decreasing the thickness is straightforward, but the decrease of the modulus is limited by the use of the conducting polymer (e.g., PEDOT:PSS) which has a higher modulus. One way to decrease the modulus of the conducting polymer is to blend it with softer stretchability enhancers. The other way is to use low-modulus substrates, while maintaining a high stretchability of PEDOT:PSS OECTs by strain engineering.
Tissue-like OECTs focusing on e-skin applications are expected to obtain a stretchability of at least 30% (maximum value of skin deformation).13,23 Higher stretchability (i.e., >30%) should not be overemphasized as it is likely not required for most practical applications. Another concern is the skin irritation issue, which raises the demand for biocompatibility and breathability. In addition, transparency, water-stability, and self-adhesive properties are also needed in specific application scenarios.
For tissue-like OECT research, it is essential to form a balanced research team with interdisciplinary backgrounds including semiconductor devices, electrochemistry, soft and healable electronic materials, advanced manufacturing, and mechanics (Fig. 6). Besides, electronic engineers and software engineers are indispensable to enabling their integration for translational applications. Communication between disciplines can be challenging at the beginning. However, once the code is decrypted, the high synergy of an interdisciplinary team will be a powerful engine to address specific challenges by decoding it into languages that all can understand.
Fig. 6 The transdisciplinary approaches toward tissue-like OECTs. Synergetic engineering efforts are required, including semiconductor device physics, electrochemistry, stretchable and healable materials,52,53 advanced manufacturing, and device mechanics. Specific investigations are needed to balance the electrical performance, electrochemical performance, mechanical performance, cyclic stability, water stability and lifetime. |
While pushing the paradigm shift from flexible/fragile to stretchable/healable is encouraging, many challenges exist, ranging from materials, interfaces, device performance, manufacturing, and prototyping for practical applications. Some examples are: (i) intrinsic stretchability needs to be obtained for all units without sacrificing too much of electrical properties; (ii) it is challenging to realize scalable manufacturing of tissue-like soft OECTs with conventional microfabrication technologies. This conflict can be mitigated by using printing technologies to process and pattern those soft materials on a case-by-case basis;51 (iii) poor adhesion between layers of soft bioelectronic devices deteriorates the device's performance and stability. Interface engineering is a must to stabilize the system, and customizable design should be available to expand their applications for personalized uses. Besides, non-living electrodes and the limited biomimetic functions of tissue-like OECTs prevent their diverse applications. Therefore, living, biocompatible electrodes and more artificially constructed bionic features still need to be developed.
Despite these challenges, we believe tissue-like OECTs have a bright future because of the rise of soft implantables, soft wearables, and soft robotics. Tissue-like OECTs could be a key supplement to the toolbox of current soft bioelectronic technologies. Beyond these exciting areas, the study of tissue-like OECTs itself is important to extend our understanding and knowledge on this technology, such as their maximum mechanical potential.
Finally, we wish to pass some remarks to newcomers. Tissue-like OECTs is a highly transdisciplinary topic (Fig. 6). While it is easy to demonstrate a device, it is a long journey before one can truly advance the boundary because of those challenges mentioned above. Before starting, it is suggested to conduct a detailed study on the fundamentals of OECTs first, followed by chasing the frontline of soft semiconductors (conducting polymers), soft electrolytes (ion-gels, hydrogels), soft conductors, and design and fabrication strategies for stretchable electronics. Once you are truly engaged in a topic that is cutting the edge, you will gradually enjoy the fulfillment of each day's progress. This should be the same for all scientific research.
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2022 |