Kanika
Bharti
,
Md Azimuddin
Sk
and
Kalyan K.
Sadhu
*
Department of Chemistry, Indian Institute of Technology Roorkee, Roorkee 247667, Uttarakhand, India. E-mail: sadhu@cy.iitr.ac.in
First published on 20th June 2023
Manganese powder with a suitable potential (, −1.19 V) has never been investigated for the reduction of Au3+ (, 1.00 V). In this study, we have utilized and low pH dependent for the polyethylene glycol stabilized gold nanoprism synthesis by reducing AuCl−4 in the presence of thiol terminated polyethylene glycol as the stabilizing agent. The synthetic methodology for gold nanoprisms has been optimized by pH and Cl− ion combination. Time dependent absorbance studies have been conducted to demonstrate the role of various reaction parameters such as the stabilizing agent, HCl concentration, temperature, and Mn metal. The synthesized gold nanoprism has been further utilized as a seed for nucleic acid and selected amino acid mediated edge and surface growth, respectively.
Seed mediated growth of gold nanoprisms has drawn significant attention due to their implication in biomedical applications.17 In this study, kinetically controlled growth has been found to be important. A very recent study has also focused on the Au56 nanocluster of a seed sized gold nanoprism.18 To date synthesis of nanoprisms without seeds remains challenging due to the parallel formation of rough gold nanoparticles.
Selective growth along the face, edge and corners was observed by controlling the reduction potential of the reducing agent and tuning the concentration of the reducing agent and stabilising agent.19 Efforts have been made to understand the synthesis mechanism of established traditional methods, overcome their limitations and modify the synthesis methodologies in order to improve the yield.20 Seed mediated21 and seedless synthetic methodologies22 are known for the synthesis of gold nanoprisms.
The growth mechanism of anisotropic nanoparticles has been influenced by reduction potential, which is indirectly governed by variations in seed concentration, pH, halide concentration, reducing agent, and surface passivating stabilizing agents.23 In our previous reports with Fe and Zn, seed-mediated syntheses produced gold-iron oxide24 or gold-zinc oxide nanocomposites.25 In this study, we aimed to synthesize nanoparticles without the incorporation of the reducing metal in the final nano-structure. Here, we have utilized a seed free methodology for the gold nanostructure synthesis. In order to achieve this, we have explored three half reactions for gold nanoparticle synthesis using Mn metal (eqn (1) and (2) and Scheme 1). Thiol modified PEG can reduce Au3+via thiol reduction and act as a stabilizing agent for the nanoparticle. Kinetically optimized condition produces gold nanoprisms as the major product by varying three reagents Mn metal, thiol containing polyethylene glycol (PEG) and pH of the solution for controlling Mn metal and Mn2+ in solution.
Without HCl, 3Mn + 2Au3+ = 3Mn2+ + 2Au | (1) |
With HCl, 3Mn2+ + 6H2O + 2Au3+ = 3MnO2↓ + 12H+ + 2Au | (2) |
Addition of 2.0 equivalents of Mn metal in the presence of PEG without any HCl generates a stable peak at 575 nm due to the formation of gold nanoparticles (Fig. S4, ESI†). The intensity of the absorption peak has not been affected much by varying the PEG or Mn concentration in the solution. The pH independent Mn/Mn2+ couple along with PEG is responsible for the reduction of Au3+ to Au0 in the absence of HCl (eqn (1)). In order to inspect pH dependent behavior of redox reaction between Mn and Au(III),24 this has been added to the solution. Addition of 10 equivalents of HCl (Au:HCl = 1:10) to the reaction mixture shows the generation of effervescence as expected due to liberation of hydrogen gas after reaction with Mn metal (Scheme 1). The control reaction with separate treatment of hydrogen gas to the mixture of Au3+ and PEG does not show any SPR peak even after 1 h.
The SPR peak intensity at 536 increases significantly within 10 min (Fig. S5, ESI†). The time dependent studies for PEG reduction only and combination of all the three reagents PEG, Mn and HCl show the faster rate of SPR peak formation in the second case (Fig. S6, ESI†). Interestingly, an additional broad peak has been observed in the NIR range. Monitoring the reaction for 6 h shows clear declining nature of both the peaks in the visible and NIR regions (Fig. S7, ESI†). The additional broad peak in the NIR range is a characteristic peak of gold nanoprisms due to in-plane dipole mode and the peak position depends on the prism thickness, edge length and dielectric environment.28,29 Kitaev et al. have reported gold nanoprisms with a tuneable shift of the same absorption peak within the visible to NIR range based on thiol- and halide-mediated reduction with hydrogen peroxide.30
The reduction of Au3+ in the presence of Mn, HCl and PEG-SH develops dual absorption peaks, which are stable even after stirring the reaction mixture for 3 h (Fig. S5, ESI†). No SPR peak has been developed under the same reaction conditions in the absence of HCl and PEG as the stabilizing agent. In order to check the efficiency of the reduction in basic medium, we have also performed the reaction in the presence of NaOH. Absorbance spectra show a single SPR peak at 530 nm and the transmission electron microscopic (TEM) image after filtration confirms the formation of spherical gold nanoparticles at higher pH (Fig. S8 and S9, ESI†). In order to obtain a stable gold nanostructure with the maximum possible yield from the Mn metal-based reduction, concentrations of three reagents Mn, PEG and HCl have been further optimized.
In order to monitor the nanoparticle architecture in the presence of 10 equivalents of HCl, TEM images have been taken from the filtrate after 6 h of the reaction (Fig. S10, ESI†). TEM analysis confirms the polycrystalline behaviour of both larger spherical gold nanoparticles of 24.0 ± 1.4 nm diameter and smaller spherical gold nanoparticles of 10.9 ± 0.3 nm with fringe patterns (Fig. S11 and S12, ESI†).31 Increasing the HCl concentration from 14 to 32 equivalents, the SPR and NIR peaks have been found to be stable for long days. The pH working range for these stable peaks varies within 1.50 to 2.85, where the Mn2+/MnO2 redox couple shows a reduction potential of 0.8 to 0.9 V.26,32
TEM images in the presence of different concentrations of HCl confirm both the formation of spherical gold nanoparticles and their aggregation and nanoprisms (Fig. 1 and S13–S15, ESI†). These TEM images suggest that two parallel reactions have proceeded continuously within the solution. In one path spherical gold nanoparticles form with a SPR peak and their aggregation generates the NIR peak. On the other hand, a parallel process leads to the formation of 2D gold nanoprisms having dual absorption peaks. The height of gold nanoprisms has been confirmed from atomic force microscopic (AFM) images and found to be ∼10 nm (Fig. 1e and f), which is significantly lower than the edge dimension of the gold nanoprism. These two reaction pathways have been monitored through changes in absorption intensities at 536 nm and 850 nm for 3 h. The 536 nm absorption has originated from the spherical gold nanoparticles and gold nanoprisms, whereas the 850 nm absorption is attributed to gold nanoprisms and aggregation of spherical gold nanoparticles. Similar absorbance spectra with dual peaks have been reported by Kitaev et al. for the thiol mediated reduction synthetic approach.30 The 850 nm absorbance in the NIR range is a characteristic peak for gold nanoprisms due to in-plane dipole mode29 or aggregation of gold nanoparticles.33 These kinetic data for 3 h have been followed as a combination of two factors of the well explored KJMA model34–37 and fitted as per eqn (1).
A = C1 (1 − ek1tn1) + C2 (1 − ek2tn2) | (3) |
A = C1 (1 − ek1t2) + C2 (1 − ek2t) | (4) |
HCl concentration dependent kinetics fitting (Fig. 2) with eqn (2) shows almost constant k1 values for 536 nm data (Table 1) within 14–26 equivalents of HCl. However, a significant enhancement of k1 values has been observed by increasing the HCl concentration to 29 equivalents. In the case of 850 nm kinetics, the k1 value decreases within 14–26 equivalents of HCl and has significantly enhanced at 29 equivalents HCl. On the contrary, k2 values are of a similar order for both 536 nm and 850 nm in the presence of 14–29 equivalents of HCl. Comparing these kinetic data with TEM images, it is clear that n1 = 2 deals with the spherical gold nanoparticles and n1 = 1 is associated with gold nanoprism formation. The k1 parameter for 850 nm decreases with the decreasing trend of aggregation of spherical gold nanoparticles in TEM. On the other hand, the k2 parameter decreases when a smaller number of nanoprisms have been observed in TEM. A recent review on the KJMA model34 suggests that the nanoprism formation in our case has been guided through diffusion-controlled growth without having any nucleation. Increasing the concentration of protons from 10 equivalents to 32 equivalents results in protonation of oxygen atoms in PEG, which is responsible for the continuous increase of ζ potential (Fig. S17, ESI†).
Fig. 2 Fitting of time dependent absorbance data at (a) 536 nm and (b) 850 nm in the presence of varying HCl concentration using eqn (2). |
Equiv. of HCl | 536 nm | 850 nm | ||
---|---|---|---|---|
Spherical nanoparticle formation | Nanoprism formation | Aggregation of spherical nanoparticle | Nanoprism formation | |
k 1 (h−2) | k 2 (h−1) | k 1 (h−2) | k 2 (h−1) | |
14 | 0.14 | 3.89 | 1.11 | 6.67 |
20 | 0.58 | 7.19 | 0.72 | 7.34 |
26 | 0.51 | 5.95 | 0.16 | 6.51 |
29 | 23.31 | 6.29 | 35.97 | 6.82 |
In order to obtain nanoprisms as the predominant product the reaction with 26 equivalents of HCl has been filtered after 30 min, where kinetic data changes its pattern. However, spherical gold nanoparticle formation cannot be avoided in this condition (Fig. 1a). The gold nanoprism and few planar twinned prisms have been collected as the predominant product (Fig. 1b and S18, S19, ESI†) after few rounds of washing. The high-resolution TEM (HRTEM) for gold nanoprisms confirms the curvature around the tips and presence of fringe lines with 0.28 nm interplanar distance (Fig. 1c and d). Lowering down the temperature from 35 °C to 10 °C, the k2 value significantly decreases and the k1 value remains almost constant (Fig. S20 and Table S2, ESI†). This trend is confirmed via TEM imaging study, where mostly spherical gold nanoparticles have been formed at 10 °C (Fig. S21, ESI†).
Initial slope calculations from 10 min reactions show a decreasing trend of rate with increasing HCl concentration (Fig. S22, ESI†) due to pH dependent non-elementary reaction38 for nanoparticle formation. In order to check the end product of Mn in the reaction, the solution and insoluble precipitate have been analysed carefully. The point and area wise elemental mapping of gold nanoprisms in TEM confirms no significant incorporation of Mn in the solution (Fig. 3a–e) after filtration. XPS analysis of the insoluble product confirms the peaks at 641.9 eV and 653.7 eV for Mn 2p3/2 and 2p1/2, respectively, due to Mn4+ oxidation state (Fig. 3f).39 Survey scan of XPS confirms the presence of MnO2 and trace amount of PEG in the precipitate (Fig. S23, ESI†).
Fig. 3 (a–c) Area wise mapping and (d and e) point wise EDX for Au and Mn in gold nanoprisms; (f) XPS data for Mn obtained from the residue after 3 h of reaction. Scale bar: (a–c) 100 nm. |
Addition of HCl not only makes the solution acidic, but also introduces more chloride ions in the solution. The pH has been reported to control the crystallographic orientation and growth.40 At lower pH, growth is predominating over nucleation. However, at very low pH reduction of Au3+ to Au0 has been inhibited.41 In our case, anisotropic gold nanoparticles have been formed in the acidic medium after the growth of the nucleated particle with time. In addition to controlling the pH of the solution by HCl, Cl− ion plays an important role through Au+-halide complexes.42 The Mn based reductions have been checked with other acids, such as HNO3, H2SO4 and HBr. In the presence of 26 mM HNO3 and H2SO4 the formation of isotropic gold nanoparticles as major products is confirmed in TEM images (Fig. S24 and S25, ESI†). Cl− ion from HAuCl4 in all these cases is responsible for few gold nanoprism formation. In the presence of 11 mM or higher HBr, the SPR peak has been destabilized (Fig. S26, ESI†). At 8 mM HBr concentration, both the spherical and prism shaped nanoparticles are observed after the synthesis (Fig. S27, ESI†). This study confirms the role of halide ions in the synthesis of anisotropic nanoparticles, similar to another report.43
In order to have better understanding of the growth mechanism, HRTEM images have been monitored at different time intervals. The TEM image after performing the reaction for 10 minutes shows the aggregated gold nanoparticles (Fig. 4a). Only a few nanoprisms have been observed at the same TEM grid. Aggregation and coalescence driven growth pathway44 have been clearly reflected in the TEM image (Fig. 4b). HRTEM analysis suggests oriented attachment along (200) crystallographic planes (Fig. 4c) as observed in another study by us.45 The growth takes place by assembling and merging46 and finally transforming into gold nanoprisms after continuing the reaction for 30 minutes (Scheme 2). The HRTEM of gold nanoprisms shows the presence of the (111) plane along the edges and the (200) plane along the surface (Fig. 4d and 5a).
Scheme 2 Mechanism of gold nanoprism synthesis from Mn based reduction in the presence of PEG and HCl. |
The equivalent of PEG has been optimized by monitoring 536 nm and 850 nm absorbance in the presence of 0.5–1.2 equivalents of PEG with respect to Au3+ amount in the reaction mixture (Fig. S28, ESI†). Similar to the HCl variation, k1 and k2 values at both the wavelengths have been compared (Table S3, ESI†) and 0.6 equivalents of PEG has been optimized for nanoprism formation. HRTEM analysis of nanoprisms shows hexagonal close packed hcp (2H) unit cells with AB–AB type packing (Fig. 5).47–49 The SAED pattern (Fig. 5b) has been found to be similar to experimental data observed for a cubic Au cell and a hexagonal cell.49 The twinned structure provides a different SAED pattern due to its different crystal orientation. The interplanar distance for this packing has been found to be 0.14 nm, which arises due to (02) planes.50 SAED patterns confirm the presence of the twinned structure.51,52 In the presence of 1.2 equivalents of PEG, the number of nanoprisms has significantly dropped down and small nanoclusters have been observed around the corner of the nanoprisms (Fig. S29, ESI†).
An earlier report suggests that there is a strong influence of pH as well as halide on the nanoprism morphology.53 We have also observed that the optimized amount of HCl concentration is required to balance the pH and halide concentration for the maximum yield of nanoprisms. XRD analysis (Fig S30, ESI†) of the gold nanoprism obtained by varying HCl concentration shows similar planes (111), (002), (022), (311), and (222) corresponding to the fcc structure. Similar to the observed HAADF data (Fig. 5d), we have also observed (002 h) and (101 h) planes corresponding to the hcp structure reported47 for gold nanoparticles.
Similar to HCl variation, the initial rate of the reaction decreases with increasing concentration of PEG (Fig. S31, ESI†). Changing PEG (Mn = 2000) with other sulphur containing ligands such as terminated thiol in polystyrene, lipoic acid, oxidized and reduced glutathione, 3-mercaptopropanoic acid, 6-mercaptoheptanoic acid and other PEG (Mn = 800 and 6000) shows the generation of prominent SPR peaks in few cases. However, the characteristic dual peaks due to nanoprisms are missing for these ligands (Fig. S32, ESI†).
In order to check the role of Mn, Au:Mn has been varied from 1:1.5 to 1:20. A minimum of 1.5 equivalents of Mn has been introduced for reducing Au3+ to Au0. To overcome the poor stability of dual peaks by reduction with 1.5 equivalents of Mn, 2 equivalents of Mn metal has been added. A further increase up to 20 equivalents only increases the amount of spherical gold nanoparticles in the solution (Fig. S33–S35, ESI†). More interestingly, unlike with HCl or PEG variations, the initial rate of SPR peak formation does not vary by increasing Mn metal concentration (Fig. S36, ESI†).
Rough surface gold nanotriangles with abundant hotspots on their surface show better SER performance as compared to gold nanotriangles with a smooth surface.54 We have planned to utilize the nanoprism as a seed for further growth reaction with a standard reducing agent, such as hydroxyl amine. The growth reactions of gold nanoprisms were carried out in the presence of nucleic acids and amino acids with positively charged side chains. In contrast to the preferred ligand binding at the tip of the nanoprism,55 our studies show that growth of gold nanoprisms takes place around the edges or flat surface in the presence of an amine modified single strand nucleic acid sequence (NH2-(CH2)6-ACATCAGT) or amino acids (His, Lys and Arg) with positively charged side chains, respectively (Fig. 6a–d). After the growth reactions, only His shows almost no shift of visible and NIR peaks except enhanced absorbance (Fig. S37–S40, ESI†). The TEM image for His after growth shows formation of longer particles on the prism surface. This overall unique growth pattern in the case of His has been selectively reflected in Raman spectroscopy (Fig. 6e) for the characteristic τ tautomer and π tautomer with a hydrated or dehydrated amide around 1650 cm−1.56
In order to find out the mechanism of different growth reactions at the edge and face, we have carried out the ζ-potential measurement of the purified gold nanoprism. In order to avoid the repulsion, the edge of the negatively charged gold nanoprism (ζ-potential −28.2 mV) having less surface area of the (111) plane has been targeted by the negatively charged nucleic acids during incubation (Scheme 3). On the other hand, the face of the nanoprism with more surface area of the (200) plane has been targeted with amino acids having positively charged side chains (Scheme 3).
Scheme 3 Nanoprism edge and face growth mechanism for nucleic acid and amino acids with positive charge, respectively. |
Footnote |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available: Supporting figures and tables. See DOI: https://doi.org/10.1039/d3na00292f |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2023 |