Zaryab Tariqa,
Dure Najaf Iqbal
*a,
Muhammad Rizwana,
Muhammad Ahmadb,
Muhammad Faheemb and
Mahmood Ahmed
*b
aDepartment of Chemistry, The University of Lahore, Lahore, Pakistan. E-mail: dure_najaf80@yahoo.com
bDepartment of Chemistry, Division of Science and Technology, University of Education, Lahore 54770, Pakistan. E-mail: mahmoodresearchscholar@gmail.com; mahmood.ahmed@ue.edu.pk
First published on 18th August 2023
Hydrogels are three-dimensional polymer networks that are hydrophilic and capable of retaining a large amount of water. Hydrogels also can act as vehicles for the controlled delivery of active compounds. Bio-polymers are polymers that are derived from natural sources. Hydrogels prepared from biopolymers are considered non-toxic, biocompatible, biodegradable, and cost-effective. Therefore, bio-polymeric hydrogels are being extensively synthesized and used all over the world. Hydrogels based on biopolymers finds important applications in the agricultural field where they are used as soil conditioning agents as they can increase the water retention ability of soil and can act as a carrier of nutrients and other agrochemicals. Hydrogels are also used for the controlled delivery of fertilizer to plants. In this review, bio-polymeric hydrogels based on starch, chitosan, guar gum, gelatin, lignin, and alginate polymer have been discussed in terms of their synthesis method, swelling behavior, and possible agricultural application. The urgency to address water scarcity and the need for sustainable water management in agriculture necessitate the exploration and implementation of innovative solutions. By understanding the synthesis techniques and factors influencing the swelling behavior of these hydrogels, we can unlock their full potential in fostering sustainable agriculture and mitigating the challenges posed by an ever-changing environment.
The urgency for conducting this review arises from the growing imperative to improve water utilization efficiency within the agricultural sector. Conventional irrigation methods frequently result in the inefficient utilization of water resources, the occurrence of runoff, and the deterioration of soil quality, hence exacerbating environmental issues. This study seeks to offer valuable insights to academics, policymakers, and practitioners in the agricultural sector by conducting a comprehensive assessment of synthesis methods and examining the factors that impact the degree of swelling in hydrogels based on biopolymers.
This review aims to provide insight into the various applications of hydrogels derived from biopolymers in the field of agriculture. Hydrogels possess the capacity to significantly transform agricultural methodologies, ranging from the regulation of soil moisture levels to the controlled discharge of nutrients and agrochemicals. The hydrogels possess characteristics that are in line with the worldwide endeavors to establish a more environmentally friendly and sustainable agriculture industry. Insufficient research has been conducted to thoroughly examine the complex interactions between biopolymer-based hydrogels and various plant species. The investigation of the impact of hydrogels on plant development, nutrient absorption, and total crop productivity under different environmental circumstances is a significant area of research that requires further exploration. Although a wide range of hydrogel formulations have been produced, there is still no consensus in the research community about the optimal biopolymer type, concentration, and application method for various agricultural practices and crop kinds. The comprehensive understanding of the long-term effects of employing biopolymer-based hydrogels on soil characteristics and the broader ecosystem remains incomplete. Conducting research that investigates the potential impacts on soil microbiology, soil structure, and ecological equilibrium is of utmost importance. The majority of studies pertaining to hydrogels derived from biopolymers are typically carried out at the laboratory level. It is imperative to undertake an examination of the obstacles and potential adjustments necessary for the proper implementation of large-scale operations in the field. This examination should encompass considerations of cost-effectiveness and logistical aspects.
Starch, chitosan, guar gum, alginate, gelatin, and lignin are some of the examples of biopolymers8 are presented in Table 1.
Sr. no. | Bio-polymers | Source |
---|---|---|
1 | Starch | Cereals, grains, and potatoes |
2 | Chitosan | Shells of crustacean |
3 | Guar gum | Guar seeds (Cyamopsis tetragonoloba plant seeds) |
4 | Alginate | Brown algae |
5 | Gelatin | Hydrolysis of collagen (derived from the connective tissues of animals) |
6 | Lignin | Support tissues of most plants |
Polymer | Synthesis method and cross-linker used | Swelling degree (SD)/water absorption | Agricultural application | Reference |
---|---|---|---|---|
Native cassava starch & polyacrylonitrile | Alkaline hydrolysis (macro-alkoxide initiated cross-linking) | 682 g g−1 in distilled water (maximum SD) | Water absorption facilitates plant growth | 11 |
Starch grafter with acrylic acid and 2-hydroxy ethyl methacrylate | Graft polymerization | 95 g g−1 at pH = 8 (maximum SD) | Controlled delivery materials (agrochemicals) | 12 |
Starch and carboxymethyl cellulose (CMC) | Radiation-induced polymerization (gamma irradiation) | 100–350 g g−1 in distilled water | Enhance the water absorption capacity of soil | 13 |
Potato starch (PS), waxy corn starch (WCS) | Chemical cross-linking (succinic anhydride-cross linker) | PS-260 g g−1 WCS-199 g g−1 (in distilled water) | Improves the water absorption capacity of the soil, improves the early growth of the plant | 14 |
PS- 18 g g−1, WCS-38 g g−1 (in saline solution-0.9% NaCl) | ||||
Starch nanoparticles | Radiation-induced polymerization | 256–365% in distilled water | Increase water holding ability of soil | 15 |
Gamma irradiation | ||||
Starch, poly(acrylic acid-co-acrylamide) and polyvinyl alcohol | Graft polymerization | 772–922 g g−1 in distilled water | 16 | |
Amylose & amylopectin (starch)/acrylamide | Graft polymerization (grafting by ultrasonic heating) | 1500–4500% in distilled water | Superabsorbent hydrogel for water retention in soil | 17 |
Starch | Chemical cross-linking (itaconic acid-cross linker) | 650 g g−1 in distilled water (maximum SD) | Increase the water retention ability of soil | 18 |
Starch and N,N-dimethylacrylamide | Redox polymerization (N,N-methylene-bis-acrylamide-cross linker) | 1115–2629% in distilled water | Water absorption, controlled release of urea/fertilizer | 19 |
Starch (composite with zeolite NPs) | Chemical cross-linking (N,N-methylene-bis-acrylamide-cross linker) | 900–1150 g g−1 in distilled water | Water retention, controlled release of zinc ion in soil | 20 |
Starch and chitosan | Glutaraldehyde, glyoxal | — | Controlled release of herbicides | 21 |
Starch, 2-acrylamido-2-methylpropansulfonic acid, and acrylamide | Radical initiated polymerization | 158.3 g g−1 in tap water | Enhance water absorption capacity, promote plant growth | 22 |
50 g g−1 in saline water | ||||
141.2 g g−1 in urea solution |
Fig. 5 Schematic presentation of amylose/amylopectin synergistic regulation of gel microstructure, reproduced from ref. 17, under the terms of the Creative Commons CC BY license, 2021. |
Results obtained by the analysis of these hydrogels (Table 2) indicated that an increase in the proportion of amylopectin results in the enhancement of the grafting ratio. The best absorption of water occurs when amylopectin is taken 70% proportion to amylose.17 A starch-based biodegradable superabsorbent hydrogel can be synthesized by chemically cross-linking the starch with itaconic acid. The prepared hydrogel exhibits a porous structure which led to its great water retention capability. Swelling kinetics of this hydrogel indicated that as the amount of cross-linker (itaconic acid) is increased, water absorption by the hydrogel occurs at a fast rate. In addition, starch–itaconic acid superabsorbent hydrogel shows very good degradability.18 Another environmentally friendly, starch-based hydrogels have been prepared by redox polymerization of starch and N,N-dimethylacrylamide method for controlled release of urea. Cross-linker used for this method is N,N-methylene-bis-acrylamide (MBA). These hydrogels showed great water absorption ability and have expressed different urea release behavior at different pH values (Table 2).19 Starch and zeolite-nanoparticle-based hydrogel can be prepared using an alkaline hydrolysis technique followed by a chemical cross-linking reaction, using MBA as a cross-linker and ammonium persulfate as an initiator. It has been observed that the amount of zeolite nano-particles in the hydrogel influences its water absorption capacity. Maximum water absorption by the hydrogel takes place when 10% of zeolite nano-particles are used. The release of Zn ion from starch–zeolite nano-composite hydrogel has also been investigated. It has been observed that the release of zinc ions from the composites increases as the amount of zeolite in composite hydrogel increases.20 Starch–chitosan hydrogels have potential applications in the agriculture field as a control release material for herbicides. These hydrogels have been synthesized by chemical cross-linking method, using glutaraldehyde and glyoxal as cross-linking agents.21 Another biodegradable and cost-effective hydrogel has been synthesized using starch (from rice-cooked wastewater), 2-acrylamido-2-methylpropansulfonic acid, and acrylamide. This hydrogel was found to have good swelling ability in water, urea, and saline solutions. In addition, this hydrogel proved to promote the growth of plant,22 as depicted in Fig. 6.
Fig. 6 Illustration of the plant (Capsicum frutescens) growth in both (a) control and (b) hydrogel (HGs)-mediated soils for 30 days, reproduced with permission from ref. 22 copyright, Elsevier, 2022. |
It could be concluded that starch-based hydrogel could be used as a potential candidate for agricultural application. The synthetic method of the starch-based hydrogels, their swelling behavior, and their potential applications in the agricultural field are given below (Table 2).
Fig. 7 Illustration of the steps involved in the coupling of cellulose and chitosan into the crosslinked backbone and successive graft polymerization of acrylic acid from this backbone, reproduced with permission from ref. 31 copyright, Elsevier, 2016. |
Another method for the formulation of CS-based hydrogel was proposed by the researchers. CS and starch were polymerized to each other using ionotropic gelation and neutralization techniques, and fertilizer release from the formulated hydrogel was observed. Fertilizer release by this hydrogel was 70–93% after 14 days of loading. These hydrogels are expected to be a good material for the controlled release of fertilizer and other agrochemicals.32 Superabsorbent hydrogels based on polyacrylamide (PAAm) and Na-alginate (Alg) or CS by γ-rays induced polymerization have also been proposed. This hydrogel was found to have great water absorption capacity. The gel content and water absorbency follow the order PAAm/Alg > PAAm/Alg/CS > PAAm/CS. The impact of this hydrogel on the growth of maize was determined. Results of this experiment showed that formulated hydrogel could increase the growth of maize plants to 1.5 times the untreated soil (Fig. 8). The response of plants towards different hydrogels used followed the order PAAm/Alg > PAAm/Alg/CS > PAAm/CS. The superabsorbent hydrogel could be used as a soil conditioning material.33
Fig. 8 Effect of swollen hydrogels on the growth of maize plants (B) growth of maize cob yield size. (a) Untreated soil (control), (b) soil treated with PAAm/Alg, (c) soil treated with PAAm/CS, and (d) soil treated with PAAm/Alg/CS, reproduced with permission from ref. 33, copyright, Elsevier, 2017. |
CS based superabsorbent hydrogel has also been synthesized by grafting CS with poly(acrylic acid-co-acrylamide) via the free radical graft co-polymerization method and then making its composite with ground basalt. For this purpose, MBA was used as a cross-linker. Hydrogel composite prepared by this method was found to exhibit good mechanical strength and water absorption capacity. These composite hydrogels were found to be more stable than the hydrogel (CS/poly(acrylic acid-co-acrylamide)). The impact of this hydrogel composite on the growth of eggplant was examined, which showed its positive impact on the growth of plants. It could be concluded that this hydrogel composite is an effective soil conditioning material.34 CS and PVA hydrogel formulated by freeze–thawing procedure proved to have good mechanical properties and water holding capacity. This hydrogel could have a positive effect on the germination of okra plants and allow the controlled release of fertilizer.35 CS based hydrogels have been prepared by mild oxidation and grafting technique. Investigation of swelling degree and water retention by both hydrogels showed that grafted hydrogel has more swelling ability than oxidized CS hydrogel. Moreover, urea release from these formulated hydrogels has also been estimated. These chitosan-based hydrogel can have potential applications in agricultural fields due to their water retention ability and ability to deliver fertilizer in a controlled way to the plants.36 CS and starch hydrogel macro-beads were developed by the dripping technique, using sodium tripolyphosphate as a cross-linker found to have their application in the delivery of growth-promoting bacteria for plants. Formulation of these macro-beads involved ionotropic gelation and neutralization process. These macro-beads have the potential to be used as bio-fertilizer.37 Superabsorbent hydrogel based on CS has been synthesized, and their water holding capacity was evaluated, which was found to be 1250 g g−1. The hydrogel was prepared by using the chemical cross-linking method, in which CS and urea were cross-linked together using citric acid as a cross-linker.38 A soil conditioning material (hydrogel) was formulated by cross-linking CS with salicylaldehyde (cross-linker). Urea fertilizer was also added to the reaction mixture to make its blended hydrogel. Formulated hydrogel proved to be very beneficial for plant growth as it could increase plant growth by 70% and can retain large amounts of water in soil.39 Hydrogel based on CS, PVA, and gelatin has been prepared and loaded with inulin to protect the chili plant from Phytophthora capsici. It was observed that this bio-degradable hydrogel has good water absorption capacity and could be used successfully for inulin release to protect chili plants from Phytophthora capsici, which is a plant pathogen.40 CS and starch hydrogel films have been prepared using citric acid and glycerol. For this purpose, titanium dioxide (TiO2) solution with calcium carbonate (CaCO3) was added to the reaction mixture. This hydrogel mulching is bio-degradable and can be used to promote the growth of invasive (short-cycled) plants. These films could also be used as an effective material to promote fertilizer-free plant growth.41 CS hydrogel beads have also been synthesized by blending them with starch via the ionotropic gelation method. These beads were found to have the ability for the controlled delivery of fertilizer. Fertilizer-loaded CS/starch hydrogel beads allow more than 70% of fertilizer release within 16 days.42 CS-co-polyacrylamide–TiO2 hydrogel developed by chemical crosslinking method using glutaraldehyde as a cross-linker can be effectively used as a soil conditioning material. The effect of this hydrogel on the growth of the soya bean plant was observed. Results of the experiment indicated that this hydrogel has positive effects on the growth of plant.43 Eco-friendly hydrogel based on CS and starch has been synthesized by cross-linking starch and CS with citric acid and has been found to exhibit good water holding capacity. It was observed that hydrogel with desirable characteristics could be obtained when starch and CS are used in equal proportion.44 The swelling properties of CS-based hydrogel, along with their synthetic method and agricultural applications, have been discussed below (Table 3).
Polymer | Synthesis method & cross-linker used | Swelling degree (SD)/water absorption | Agricultural application | Reference |
---|---|---|---|---|
Chitosan, poly(acrylic acid-co-acrylamide) | Spray coating followed by chemical cross-linking (N,N-methylene-bis-acrylamide-cross linker) | 40–70 g g−1 in distilled water | Enhance water retention, controlled release of fertilizer | 24 |
Chitosan | Chemical cross-linking (genipin-cross linker) | 112–145% in distilled water | Increased water uptake by the plant, controlled release of urea | 25 |
Chitosan | Chemical cross-linking (glyoxal-cross linker) | — | Slow release of agrochemicals (dicyandiamide/DCD) | 26 |
Chitosan, polyvinyl alcohol, acrylamide, and acrylic acid | Reverse suspension polymerization (chemical cross-linking) (glutaraldehyde and N,N-methylene-bis-acrylamide-cross linker) | 120–230 g g−1 in deionized water | Enhance water absorption capacity of the soil, controlled fertilizer release | 27 |
Chitosan | Chemical cross-linking (EDTA–urea-cross linker) | 238–570 g g−1 in distilled water | Water absorption, controlled release of urea and metal ions | 28 |
Chitosan and high acetyl gellan gum (HAGG) | Cross-linking via ionic bond formation | 219 g g−1 in pure water | Water retention, controlled release of fertilizer | 29 |
Chitosan, silk fibroin and gelatin | Blended hydrogel (no intermolecular interaction) | 5.32 parts per hundred of polymer | Slow release of urea | 30 |
Chitosan–cellulose and acrylic acid | Graft polymerization | 390 g g−1 in distilled water and 39.5 g g−1 in saline solution (0.9% NaCl) | Increase water absorption capacity of soil | 31 |
Controlled release of fertilizer | ||||
Chitosan and starch | Inotropic gelation technique | — | Controlled release of agrochemicals | 32 |
Chitosan, sodium alginate, and polyacrylamide | Radiation-induced polymerization (gamma-radiations) | 397 g g−1 in distilled water (maximum absorption) | Water retention, soil conditioning, increase plant growth | 33 |
Chitosan, poly(acrylic acid-co-acrylamide (ground basalt for making composite) | Graft free radical co-polymerization | ∼600 g g−1 at pH = 3 | Soil conditioning enhances plant growth and pH-sensitive water absorption | 34 |
Chitosan and polyvinyl alcohol | Freeze thawing method | 58.3% in distilled water (with 6 wt% chitosan) | Water retention, increased plant germination, and controlled release of fertilizer | 35 |
Chitosan | Graft polymerization and mild oxidation | ∼2500% in distilled water | Water regulation, controlled urea release | 36 |
Chitosan and starch | Ionotropic gelation and neutralization | 143–235% in distilled water | Water retention, bio-fertilizer | 37 |
Chitosan | Chemical cross-linking (citric acid-cross linker) | 1250 g g−1 in distilled water | Water absorption | 38 |
Chitosan | Chemical cross-linking salicylaldehyde-cross linker) | 154% in distilled water | Water absorption, controlled fertilizer release, enhanced plant growth | 39 |
Chitosan, gelatin and PVA | Chemical cross-linking | 10–12 times than its mass | Controlled delivery of agrochemical (inulin), water absorption | 40 |
Chitosan ad starch | Chemical cross-linking (glycerol & citric acid-cross linker) | — | Biodegradable mulch for invasive plants increases plant growth | 41 |
Chitosan and starch | Ionotropic gelation | 120–162% in distilled water | Controlled release of fertilizer, water absorption | 42 |
Chitosan-co-polyacrylamide–TiO2 | Chemical cross-linking (glutaraldehyde-cross linker) | 364.76% without TiO2 maximum swelling | Soil conditioner, plant growth promoter | 43 |
66.45–100% in distilled water | ||||
Chitosan and starch | Chemical cross-linking (citric acid-cross linker) | ∼120% (almost the same in distilled water, glucose solution, and urea) | Increase water absorption capacity of soil | 44 |
Guar gum based superabsorbent hydrogel has been synthesized by using graft co-polymerization technique. For this purpose, partially neutralized acrylic acid (NaAA) was grafted on guar gum using MBA as a cross-linker. Formulated hydrogels not only exhibit good water retention ability but are also very stable and eco-friendly.47 Another important hydrogel was prepared by using guar gum and acrylic acid using the graft co-polymerization method. In this experiment, hexamine was utilized as cross-linking agent. The hydrogel was pH sensitive and exhibited great swelling capacity and water absorption ability. Maximum absorption occurs at neutral pH. This hydrogel could be used as an excellent material for agricultural applications, especially in arid areas, for water retention.48 Guar gum based hydrogel formulated by grafting acrylamide on guar gum backbone could be used as a soil conditioning material. This hydrogel could enhance the water absorption capacity of soil for better growth of plants and have different water absorption in different mediums. However, the swelling ability of the hydrogel was found to be influenced by the amount of water, cross-linker concentration, and monomer-backbone ratio.49 Researchers have synthesized a guar gum based hydrogel composite by graft polymerization of guar gum with methyl methacrylate using boric acid as a cross-linker. Effect of pH and conc. of monomer, cross-linker, and guar gum on the water absorption capacity of the prepared hydrogel was instigated. The developed hydrogel was found to have very good water absorption ability and could be an effective tool for water retention in soil that face water deficiency.50 Another hydrogel was developed by grafting acrylic acid on guar gum using ethylene glycol di-methacrylic acid as a cross-linker (GG/AA/EGDMA). This hydrogel was found to have good porosity and water holding capacity. Moreover, this hydrogel is biodegradable, having a half-life of about 77 days. This hydrogel appeared to be a promising material for soil conditioning.51 Microwave radiations have also been used to synthesize guar gum based hydrogel by grafting guar gum with acrylic acid using a free-radical emulsifier. This technique is called free-emulsion graft polymerization. The hydrogel is thermally stable and biodegradable. The water absorption capacity of this hydrogel was quite good, and maximum swelling was observed at a pH of 5.0–7.4.52 Boron-loaded guar gum hydrogel has been formulated and investigated by the researchers for the controlled delivery of nutrients, particularly boron (Fig. 9). First, boron was loaded into guar gum, and then hydrogel was synthesized using ethylene-glycol-di-methacrylate (cross-linker) and benzoyl peroxide (initiator). It was observed that about 60% of the boron is released in 5 days.53
Fig. 9 Illustration of synthesis of boron-loaded guar gum hydrogel and boron release mechanism, reproduced with permission from ref. 53 copyright, John Wiley and Sons, 2022. |
A hydrogel synthesized by grafting methyl methacrylate on guar gum to evaluate its impact on the growth of sugar cane crops. It was found that this hydrogel can retain a large amount of water and hence can be used to increase sugar cane yield, especially under water stress conditions.54 An eco-friendly hydrogel composite based on guar gum has been formulated by using gamma irradiations. For this purpose, guar gum, polyacrylamide, pectin, and ZnO were cross-linked via gamma irradiation. The composite was observed to have good biodegradability and water holding capacity. Results indicated that the water absorption capacity of the prepared composite increased by increasing the concentration of ZnO. This composite hydrogel could be used as an effective soil conditioning material in the agriculture sector.55 Table 4 shows the synthetic method, water holding capacity, and potential applications of guar gum-based hydrogels used in agriculture.
Polymers | Synthesis method & cross-linker used | Swelling degree (SD)/water absorption | Agricultural application | Reference |
---|---|---|---|---|
Guar gum, partially neutralized acrylic acid | Graft co-polymerization (N,N′-methylenebisacrylamide-cross linker) | 1107 g g−1 in distilled water | Water retention, pH stability (pH = 4–11) | 47 |
88 g g−1 in saline solution (0.9 wt%) | ||||
Guar gum, acrylic acid | Graft co-polymerization (hexamine-cross linker) | 5307% (pH ∼7) maximum swelling | Water absorption, pH sensitive behavior | 48 |
Guar gum, acrylamide | Graft polymerization | ∼600 g g−1 in distilled water (maximum absorption) | Enhance the water absorption capacity of soil | 49 |
400–500 g g−1 in saline solution (maximum absorption) | ||||
Guar gum, methyl methacrylate | Graft polymerization (boric acid-cross-linker) | 3650% in distilled water | Excellent water absorption ability (soil conditioner) | 50 |
Guar gum, acrylic acid | Graft polymerization (ethylene glycol di-methacrylic acid-cross linker) | 806 g g−1 in distilled water | Soil conditioning material | 51 |
77 g g−1 in saline solution (0.9 wt% NaCl) | ||||
Guar gum, acrylic acid | Free-emulsion graft-polymerization | 120% at pH = 7 (distilled water) | Increase water absorption capacity of soil | 52 |
Guar gum (loaded with boron) | Graft polymerization (ethylene-glycol-di-methacrylate-cross linker) | 300–375 g g−1 (at pH = 9) | Controlled delivery of micronutrients, water retention | 53 |
80–120 g g−1 in distilled water | ||||
Guar gum, methyl methacrylate | Graft polymerization (polyethylene glycol-cross linker) | ∼110 g g−1 in distilled water | Soil conditioning material, enhances crop yield | 54 |
Guar gum, polyacrylamide, pectin | Radiation polymerization (gamma irradiation) | 600–1050 g g−1 in distilled water | Enhance water holding capacity of soil | 55 |
Gelatin based superabsorbent hydrogel composites have been synthesized by graft polymerization of acrylic acid on gelatin backbone using kaolin powder. In this experiment, MBA was utilized as a cross-linker. It was observed that the concentration of gelatin polymer, monomer, cross-linker, and kaolin influenced the water absorption capacity of the hydrogel. Results indicated that these hydrogel composites exhibit good swelling ability or water retention capacity. The swelling behavior of the hydrogel was sensitive to different values of pH.57 Gelatin based hydrogel has been used for the controlled delivery of fertilizer to the plants. One of the methods for the development of this type of hydrogel includes the crosslinking of gelatin loaded with ammonium nitrate (AN) using glutaraldehyde as cross-linking agent. The impact of the formulated hydrogel (gelatin/AN) on cucumber was investigated. The results indicated that gelatin/AN hydrogel could be used as a promising controlled-release fertilizer material for agricultural use.58 Gelatin hydrogel prepared from the co-polymerization of gelatin and agar agar with acrylic acid and methyl acrylate can be used as a satisfactory soil conditioning agent. This hydrogel can retain a large amount of water (Fig. 10a) and is biodegradable, non-toxic, and economical; thus, it could be used as an eco-friendly soil conditioning agent (Fig. 10b).59
Fig. 10 (a) Schematic presentation of water retention in the soil through agar agar/gelatin/methyl acrylate/acrylic acid (Agr/GE-co-MA/AA hydrogel) (b) demonstrates hydrogel used in the agriculture field for the function of plant water assimilation, reproduced from ref. 59 under the terms of the Creative Commons CC BY license, 2020. |
Alg and gelatin based hydrogel could be effectively used for the controlled release of urea fertilizer. Researchers have formulated urea loaded gelatin/Alg hydrogels by using calcium chloride as a cross-linker. The hydrogel was analyzed, and the results of the analysis showed that hydrogel with desirable characteristics was obtained when a 0.5:1 ratio of gelatin and Alg was used. This hydrogel allows the controlled release of urea (and other blended nutrients) in an environmentally friendly way.60 Modified gelatin hydrogel films loaded with urea and wood ash have been synthesized and investigated. Chemical cross-linking of gelatin with glutaraldehyde was done for this purpose. This hydrogel composite could be used as a cost-effective slow-release fertilizer for plants. The best release of urea (54.43%) from the formulated hydrogel films was observed when the ratio of urea to gelatin (U/G) = 2.22 g, wood ash to U/G ratio = 1.50 g, and glutaraldehyde was used in a concentration of 2.47 mL g−1. Moreover, this hydrogel composite has good water holding capacity and also shows a positive impact on the growth of plants.61 Gelatin based hydrogel was prepared by chemical cross-linking of gelatin and di-aldehyde xanthan gum. This hydrogel can be used as a control release fertilizer material when blended with the fertilizer (Fig. 11). The hydrogel not only acts as a carrier of fertilizer but can also hold a large amount of water to improve plant growth in water stress condition.62
Fig. 11 Schematic representation of the synthesis of gelatin (GT)-dialdehyde xanthan gum (DAXG) Schiff-base hydrogels (GD) as urea-controlled release fertilizers (CRFs) in agriculture, reproduced with permission from ref. 62 copyright, Elsevier, 2023. |
Chemical cross-linking of urea with polylactic acid and CS produced a hydrogel composite that exhibited excellent water holding ability. The blending of this composite hydrogel with urea ensures the slow release of nitrogen in the soil. Hence, this gelatin based hydrogel composite could be used as an efficient soil conditioning tool for agricultural purposes.63 Potential applications of gelatin-based hydrogels in agricultural fields, along with their synthetic method and water holding capacity, are given below (Table 5).
Polymers | Synthesis method & cross-linker used | Swelling degree (SD)/water absorption | Agricultural applications | References |
---|---|---|---|---|
Gelatin, acrylic acid, kaolin powder | Graft polymerization (methylenebisacrylamide-cross linker) | 85–90 g g−1 at pH = 8 | Enhance the water retention capacity of soil (pH-responsive behavior) | 57 |
55 g g−1 in NaCl solution (maximum) | ||||
Gelatin | Chemical cross-linking (glutaraldehyde-cross linker) | 218% in distilled water (maximum) | Controlled release of fertilizer enhances the water absorption capacity of soil | 58 |
Gelatin and agar | Chemical cross-linking | 636.1% in deionized water (maximum) | Excellent water holding capacity | 59 |
Gelatin, sodium alginate | Ionic gelation method (calcium chloride-cross linker) | 13.95 g g−1 in deionized water (maximum) | Controlled release of urea and other nutrients | 60 |
Gelatin | Chemical cross-linking (glutaraldehyde-cross linker) | 228–251% in deionized water | Controlled release of urea and other nutrients and fertilizer, water retention, enhanced plant growth | 61 |
Gelatin, di-aldehyde xanthan gum | Chemical cross-linking | — | Allow controlled release of fertilizers, improves water holding capacity of soil | 62 |
Gelatin, polylactic acid and chitosan | Chemical cross-linking | 4448% at 30 °C in deionized water | Excellent water retention ability allow the slow release of nitrogen and other useful nutrients | 63 |
Lignin based superabsorbent hydrogel has been prepared by mixing it with cellulose and then chemically cross-linking them with epichlorohydrin, which is a cross-linker. Swelling property and controlled release behavior of the hydrogel was instigated. Polyphenols were loaded into the hydrogel to examine their release pattern. It was observed that polyphenols released from the hydrogel depend upon the lignin content of the hydrogel matrix. Results showed that release of polyphenols increases by increasing the lignin content of the hydrogel. Maximum swelling was observed when cellulose and lignin were mixed in a proportion of 0.125 g and 0.375 g, respectively 65. Lignin based water absorbent hydrogel prepared by cross-linking lignin and poly(ethylene glycol) diglycidyl ether in an alkali solution. Formulated hydrogel exhibits good swelling ability and is biodegradable. The swelling behavior of the hydrogel was investigated in distilled water, CaCl2, and NaCl solutions. Maximum swelling of hydrogel was observed in distilled water. This hydrogel proved to be an effective material to be used for plants under water stress conditions.66 Another method proposed for the synthesis of lignin hydrogel includes the use of waste from the pulp and paper industry by a co-polymerization technique using acrylic acid and red liquor (industrial waste). This hydrogel was not only cost-effective but is also very environmentally friendly as it is biodegradable and reduces waste pollution. This hydrogel possesses the characteristics of water retention and slow release of material (if blended with the hydrogel). Hence it is a potential agent for agricultural application.67 Lignin and PVA hydrogel has been developed by using epichlorohydrin as a cross-linker which can be used as a water holding agent in agriculture. This hydrogel exhibits great water absorption capacity, which ranges from 92–456 g g−1. It was concluded that the swelling ability of hydrogel is enhanced if high molecular weight poly-vinyl alcohol is used. Thus, this lignin based hydrogel is a potential candidate for agricultural use.68 An agricultural hydrogel has been prepared using lignosulfonate (L), konjaku flour (KJ), and Alg. This hydrogel increases the water and nutrient holding capacity of soil as it prevents the nutrient from leaching. The impact of this hydrogel on the growth of tobacco plants was examined. The photosynthetic ability of tobacco plants was found to be enhanced by the application of this hydrogel in soil. Commercial acrylamide hydrogels and L/KJ/Alg hydrogels, as depicted in Fig. 12, may both lengthen the growth cycle of the tobacco plant by 2–4 days and 9–14 days, respectively, during periods of intense drought. It is evident that the water retained by acrylamide hydrogels cannot be utilized for plant growth, despite the fact that their water absorption is significantly more than that of L/KJ/Alg hydrogels.69
Fig. 12 Illustration of different treatments of tobacco growth after stopping water supply. M: L/KJ/Alg hydrogel treatment; S: acrylamide hydrogel, CK: untreated soil, reproduced with permission from ref. 69 copyright, Elsevier, 2019. |
Another important method for the development of agricultural hydrogel based on lignin was proposed by the researchers to increase the water retention ability of the silt loam soil. Alkali solution of lignin was cross-linked with poly(ethylene glycol) di-glycidyl ether. This hydrogel is a promising material to improve water retention of soil in drought conditions.70 Table 6 describes some of the important hydrogels based on lignin, their synthetic method, swelling behavior, and agricultural applications.
Polymers | Synthesis method & cross-linker used | Swelling degree (SD)/water absorption | Agricultural applications | References |
---|---|---|---|---|
Lignin and cellulose | Chemical cross-linking (epichlorohydrin-cross linker) | 3061% (maximum) in a water–ethanol mixture (ethanol:water = 1:19) | Controlled release of polyphenols (agrochemical) enhances the water absorption capacity of soil | 65 |
Lignin | Chemical cross-linking (using alkali) | 34 g g−1 in distilled water (maximum) | Increase the water retention ability of soil | 66 |
Lignin (waste from the paper and pulp industry) | Co-polymerization (chemical cross-linking using N,N-methylene-bis-acrylamide) | 280 g g−1 in deionized water (maximum) | Increase water holding ability of soil, slow release of agrochemicals | 67 |
Lignin, poly-vinyl alcohol | Chemical cross-linking (epichlorohydrin-cross linker) | 92–456 g g−1 in distilled water | Enhance the water absorption capacity of soil | 68 |
Lignosulfonate, konjaku flour, and sodium alginate | Chemical cross-linking in the liquid phase (anhydrous calcium chloride solution-cross linker) | 41.13 g g−1 in distilled water (maximum) | Improve the photosynthetic ability of plants (tobacco plant), water retention in soil | 69 |
Lignin (alkali lignin) | Chemical cross-linking (poly(ethylene glycol) di-glycidyl ether-cross linker) | 2013% in deionized water, 825% in 0.9% NaCl solution, and 1092% in tap water | Increase water retention capacity of soil | 70 |
Alginate based hydrogel has been synthesized by the chemical crosslinking of PVA and Alg using glutaraldehyde as cross-linking agent. It was observed that as the concentration of cross-linker (glutaraldehyde) increases, the swelling degree of this hydrogel decreases. The swelling behavior of this hydrogel was investigated in acidic and alkaline media. The results indicated that the swelling ability of hydrogel was enhanced with the increase in the amount of acid. The swelling rate of hydrogel examined in different salt solutions showed. The swelling rate of hydrogel reduces as the concentration of salt increases in the solution. This hydrogel could be used as an effective material for the retention of water in soil.73 A cost-effective method to prepare alginate based hydrogel beads by the ionic cross-linking of Alg using calcium chloride. These hydrogel beads exhibit pH-sensitive swelling behavior and could be used for enhancing the water holding capacity of the soil. The effect of cross-linking time, concentration of cross-linker, pH, and temperature on the swelling degree of beads was studied. Results showed that the swelling degree decreases as the cross-linking period of the hydrogel increases. Moreover, it was also observed that a change in temperature does not have a considerable impact on the swelling capacity of the hydrogel.74 To increase the water absorption capacity of the soil and control the delivery of nutrients to the plants, another important hydrogel has been synthesized. This hydrogel was formulated by the physical cross-linking of hydroxyl-propyl cellulose (HPC), carboxymethyl cellulose (CMC), and Alg by using aluminum sulfate (cross-linker). This hydrogel is a potential candidate to be used as a soil conditioning agent in agricultural sector.75 Alginate based hydrogel beads prepared by cross-linking Alg with calcium chloride could be effectively used as a substitute for synthetic hydrogel. These beads are non-toxic and biodegradable and can improve the water retention ability of soil. The water retention ability of soil is significantly influenced by the type of soil used for farming. However, the results of the experiment show that these hydrogel beads can be used by farmers to improve water retention in the soil, especially in water stress conditions (Fig. 13).76
Fig. 13 Illustration of effect of hydrogel substrate supplementation on lettuce plants subjected to drought for 7 days; C: substrate without hydrogel supplementation, 1% w/w or 5% w/w-supplemented substrates. CW: set of plants grown without hydrogel were continually watered along the experiment, reproduced with permission from ref. 76 copyright, Elsevier, 2020. |
Hydrogel developed by graft polymerization of phosphorylated alginate with polyacrylamide exhibits good water absorption ability and allows the controlled delivery of phosphorous to the plants. Phosphorylated alginate samples were prepared by the reaction of Alg and PVA with di-ammonium phosphate and mono-ammonium phosphate. Afterward, these phosphorylated alginate were grafted individually with polyacrylamide. Release of phosphorous from di-ammonium phosphate and mono-ammonium phosphate hydrogel sample was observed in 45 days which was 57% and 77%, respectively.77 Alginate based hydrogel beads have also been synthesized by using alginate derived from kelp industrial waste using calcium chloride as a cross-linker. These beads do not exhibit good water retention properties but also allow controlled release of fertilizer and useful nutrients. Moreover, these hydrogel beads help to control the pH of the soil as well.78 Some of the alginate-based hydrogels used in agriculture have been discussed in Table 7, along with the method of their synthesis and agricultural applications.
Polymers | Synthesis method & cross-linker used | Swelling degree (SD)/water absorption | Agricultural applications | References |
---|---|---|---|---|
Sodium alginate and polyvinyl alcohol | Chemical cross-linking (glutaraldehyde-cross linker) | 50–400% (in different salt solutions) | Enhance water retention capacity of soil | 73 |
Sodium alginate | Ionic cross-linking method (calcium chloride-cross linker) | >1000% (pH = 8, 30 °C) | Excellent material for increasing the water retention ability of soil | 74 |
Sodium alginate, HPC, and CMC | Physical cross-linking (ionic interaction) aluminum sulfate-cross linker | 1585% (maximum) | Slow release of fertilizer and nutrients and increase moisture holding capacity of soil | 75 |
Sodium alginate | Ionic cross-linking method (calcium chloride-cross linker) | >55 g g−1 in distilled water, >36 g g−1 in tap water | Improve moisture holding ability of soil | 76 |
Sodium alginate and polyacrylamide | Graft polymerization | 6–8 g g−1 in distilled water | Controlled release of phosphorous | 77 |
Alginate from kelp industrial waste | Ionic cross-linking method (calcium chloride-cross linker) | 0.6–1.8 g g−1 in deionized water | Improve water retention ability of soil, allow controlled release of fertilizers, and control pH of soil | 78 |
Fig. 14 The swelling mechanism of hydrogels, reproduced from ref. 1, copyright, Elsevier, 2020. |
The majority of hydrophilic hydrogels can be applied during planting or coated on the seed itself, and they are primarily used in agriculture as nutrient carriers and soil conditioners. Fig. 15 depicts the process leading to fertilizer carriers and soil conditioners. The preparation of soil conditioner should take into account the basic criteria, as shown in Fig. 15. When choosing a hydrogel as a soil conditioner, at least three factors must be taken into account such as superabsorbent, biodegradable, and chemically covalently cross-linked.1,80–82
Fig. 15 Aspects to choose the ideal hydrogel for use as a soil conditioner, reproduced from ref. 1, copyright, Elsevier, 2020. |
Water is trapped in the gaps between soil granules as it comes into touch with the land. When hydrogel is present, it uses osmosis to take water into its network as the soil becomes moist. The process of photosynthesis is carried out by chlorophyll, which converts water and carbon dioxide (CO2) into carbohydrates and oxygen. Plants with access to plenty of water have higher chlorophyll levels, which boost agricultural yield. Hydrogels have the effect of expanding the area available for air and water infiltration in the soil. This particular soil has the perfect texture for gardening. The hydrogel will quickly release water into the environment from its internal polymer network once the soil has dried. When required, the water is released from a hydrogel network and returned to the soil. The soil structure became stable as a result of soil–water interactions generated by swollen hydrogel.83,84 This is also observed with the nutrient and fertilizer leaching from agricultural soils. Hydrogel is used in fertilizer formulations to lessen fertilizer leaching. Because of the way fertilized hydrogel behaves, fertilizer can be kept in place and released gradually. As a result of less leaching, crop output increases, and fertilizer requirements decrease. Fertilizers loaded into hydrogel have been demonstrated to discharge at a rate that is half that of fertilizer applied in water alone.85–87 Fig. 16a shows hydrogel as a slow-release technique for water and dissolved fertilizers in soil. The diffusion mechanism, which starts with a deswelling process where water is diffused and carries fertilizer via the porous network to the outside, is typically how fertilizers are released into the environment.88–90
Fig. 16 (a) An illustration of the complete fertilizer release procedure from hydrogel (b) the impact of polysaccharide hydrogel on the soil texture for plant growth, reproduced from ref. 1, copyright, Elsevier, 2020. |
Ammonium (NH41+) and nitrate (NO31−) are nitrogen fertilizers that encourage the production of N2O, which contributes more to global warming than CO2 emissions. The current challenge is to maximize nitrogen retention while reducing methane (CH4) and N2O emission. The majority of the nutrients from dissolved fertilizers are retained by soil conditioner hydrogel, which also reduces the requirement for nutrients in agricultural soils, as well as nitrogen leaching and N2O emission.91–93 The pores of soil are mostly filled with water after irrigation or rainfall, and the water escapes downhill. Soil is ideal for aeration but cannot hold water. Polysaccharide hydrogel, a soil conditioner, aids in holding water, which creates ideal growing conditions for plant roots (Fig. 16b).
Fig. 17 demonstrates how tightly the hydrogel adheres to the roots, making it possible for the roots of the plant to access nutrients. Ions and nutrients are transported more quickly by soil conditioner polysaccharide hydrogel adaption of plant roots. The plasma membrane, made up of phospholipids, proteins, and steroid compounds, covers the surface of the root. Assisting in increasing the active transport of nutrients and water to plants by negatively charged clay surfaces with cationic functional groups (Al3+, Fe3+, and Ca2+), hydrogel increased the contact between soil particles and roots through a hydrogen bond or dipole–dipole interaction. Reduced crop output can result from fertilizers' and herbicides' detrimental effects on non-target plants. As a result, biodegradable polysaccharide hydrogel-based agrochemicals have been developed for use in safe and effective ways in agricultural settings. Various works on the subject of polysaccharides use them as elicitors, with chitosan being one of the most significant as a plant defense-booster.94,95
Fig. 17 The hydrogel adheres to the roots tightly and improves soil-root contact, reproduced from ref. 1, copyright, Elsevier, 2020. |
Polysaccharides, such as chitosan and chitin, have been shown to trigger plant defensive reactions against a variety of phytopathogens, including plant viruses and fungi. Currently, several experimental findings have demonstrated that chitosan helps prevent viral infections.96 The effects of the growth media and the absence of phytotoxicity of the polysaccharide hydrogel have been documented.97,98 It's crucial to evaluate the phytotoxicity of hydrogels to spot any growth inhibition. Root surface area and length increased in plants exposed to soil conditioner hydrogel. The rate of seed germination and seedling survival can be increased by seed coating.99,100 A slower release of nutrients into the soil is made possible by nano-fertilizers, which are soluble fertilizers that have been loaded or encapsulated by hydrogel nanoparticles. A biodegradable hydrogel that has been nano-fertilized quickly spreads into roots over time. The nanoparticle quickly diffused into the roots of the plants by symplastic and apoplastic routes before moving to the aerial sections of the plants, including the stems and leaves, via xylem tissue.101,102 It is desirable to wrap fertilizer with a clever biodegradable hydrogel to increase its efficacy. The fertilizer will perform better and be more sophisticated, for example, making itself available to roots and plants for a long time and encouraging effective root uptake control, which could be influenced by the soil's P, N, and K content, and allowing roots easy access to the fertilizer. The crop yield will rise, and the compaction will go.95,103
It is critical to take into account the following steps to reduce these potential environmental risks.
The potential dangers connected with hydrogels in the environment can be reduced while still reaping the benefits of their agricultural uses by addressing these environmental concerns and implementing proper usage and disposal methods.
Therefore, the purpose of this review is to assist academics, researchers, and industry experts in developing hydrogels based on biopolymers that have gained unique significance in agricultural applications (soil conditioners, fertilizer, and pesticide carriers).
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2023 |