Mingyu Shang‡
a,
Yanfei Wei‡b,
Herong Zhou*a,
Tao Wua,
Ke Wanga,
Hongxiang Chenc,
Beisong Fangd and
Yang Zhaod
aState Key Laboratory of Refractories and Metallurgy, Wuhan University of Science and Technology, Wuhan, 430081, China. E-mail: zhouhr_9@163.com
bInstitute of Cultural Relics and Archaeology of Gansu, Lanzhou 730000, China
cHubei Key Laboratory of Coal Conversion and New Carbon Material, College of Chemical Engineering and Technology, Wuhan University of Science and Technology, Wuhan, 430081, China
dJingzhou Cultural Relics Protection Center, Jingzhou, 434000, China
First published on 24th November 2023
PEG2000 (polyethylene glycol, molecular weight: 2000) is commonly used for the dehydration and reinforcement of waterlogged wooden cultural relics, but its photo-aging degradation will seriously affect the long-term conservation of the wooden cultural relics. In this study, the photo-aging characteristics and mechanisms of PEG2000 under UV (ultraviolet) irradiations of three wavelengths were comprehensively investigated, and the surface morphology, crystal structure, and relative molecular weight of PEG2000 were systematically characterized. The results showed that PEG2000 showed a higher gloss loss rate, carbonyl index and crystallinity, and a wider molecular weight distribution with increasing aging time, especially under the irradiation of 313 nm ultraviolet light. The evolution of the PEG2000 from surface to interior during photoaging was elucidated by SEM (scanning electron microscopy) and FTIR (Fourier transform infrared spectroscopy), and it was determined that photodegradation not only occurs on the surface of PEG2000 but also gradually extends to the interior of the sample with the prolongation of irradiation time, resulting in the transformation of the basic component unit of spherical crystals in PEG2000 from fibrous crystals to spherical particles. Based on 1H-NMR (nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy), the photochemical reactions for the generation of degradation products were proposed, and it was found that the degradation occurred at the C–H and C–O–C bonds on the main chain, forming a large number of ester and ethoxy structures. The aging degree of PEG2000 was evaluated from the perspective of surface morphology and chemical structure by gloss and FTIR spectroscopy, and it was found that the combination of gloss loss rate and carbonyl index was more suitable to evaluate the aging degree of the sample. The relevant theoretical research will provide reliable guidance for the preservation of polyethylene glycol in waterlogged wooden cultural relics.
Many studies on the effects of environmental factors such as heat, oxygen, and humidity on the structure and performance of polyethylene glycol have been reported in the literature. Han et al.9 found that PEG6000 would be degraded by thermal oxygen in 80 °C air, and the main product was low molecular weight esters, whose degradation mechanism was random chain break of the main chain, while PEG6000 did not degrade in vacuum. Bilen et al.10 reported that a polyethylene glycol thin film gradually hydrogenated at 80% RH and changed from a semi-crystalline state to a physical gel state by using optical waveguide spectroscopy, resulting in a sharp decrease in surface refractive index and a sharp increase in thickness. At the same time, hydrogenation caused fewer ether oxygen atoms to form hydrogen bonds with water molecules, making the structure of PEG more stable than before.
Compared to thermal-oxidative aging induced by thermal energy, photo-oxidative aging is caused by chain initiation caused by ultraviolet radiant energy, which leads to a rapid photo-oxidation reaction from the beginning.11 At the same time, the chain growth process is shorter than the thermal-oxidation reaction, which means that light has an important influence on polymer aging.12,13 Mao et al. showed that the aging of polystyrene (PS) with UV irradiation under air, pure water, and seawater conditions was the most obvious in an air environment and produced a large number of oxygen-containing functional groups (CO, C–OH, O–CO). The photo-oxidation reaction was determined by FTIR and 2D-COS to occur on the C–H bond, which clarified the aging sequence of PS functional groups in air.14 Yang et al. reported that a photooxidative aging reaction of P(St-co-BA-co-MMA) latex film under UV irradiation occurred on the –CH– groups, which leads to the breakage of weak cross-linked chains in the film and the destruction of the connection between the microspheres, resulting in the decrease of the toughness of the latex film.15 Ouyang et al.16 showed that the oxygen-containing functional groups, carbonyl index, and crystallinity of polyvinyl chloride (PVC) increased with the increase of ultraviolet irradiation time, and the active sites and aging sequence of functional groups were determined based on Fourier transform infrared spectroscopy analyses. However, the degradation behavior of polyethylene glycol under ultraviolet irradiation and the mechanism of influence of different wavelengths of ultraviolet light on its properties and structure has not been reported in the literature.
Light exposure in the environment, especially ultraviolet light irradiation,17 can easily lead to the degradation of wooden cultural relics and their organic protection material, polyethylene glycol,18,19 resulting in changes in color,20 gloss, ductility, and strength,21 and losing the function of protective materials.22,23 Therefore, we used three different wavelengths of ultraviolet light to simulate the aging rate of PEG2000 under different environments (indoor, outdoor, and strong aging), evaluated the aging degree of samples comprehensively from the perspective of surface morphology and chemical structure using surface gloss loss rate and carbonyl index. During this process, the evolution of PEG2000 samples from the surface to the interior during photoaging was elucidated, and the photochemical reactions were proposed to produce degradation products of PEG2000. Based on the obtained photoaging characteristics and mechanisms of PEG2000, the aging stages were summarized. This study helps to understand the aging behavior of PEG2000 in the light environment and guides the use and long-term preservation of PEG in the protection of waterlogged wooden cultural relics.
Fig. 1 Photographs of PEG2000 irradiated with 340 nm UV light for different times: (a) 0 h, (b) 120 h, (c) 240 h, (d) 360 h, (e) 480 h, and (f) 600 h. |
In order to study the effect of ultraviolet light on the microstructure of PEG2000, scanning electron microscopy was used to observe the morphological changes on the surface and cross-section of the sample. Fig. 2 showed the morphological changes during the irradiation of 340 nm UV light for 600 h, and the morphological changes after 351 and 313 nm UV irradiation were shown in Fig. S2.† The pristine samples in Fig. 2a had a regular and smooth surface. After exposure to UV irradiation, the surface gradually became rough and developed cracks (Fig. 2d). Several published studies have also reported the phenomenon of polymer aging under UV irradiation.24–26 When the samples were aged to a certain extent, the surface crinkled (Fig. 2e), and bulge particles were produced (Fig. 2f). Under the irradiation of 351, 340, and 313 nm UV light, the surface cracks were observed on the surfaces at 600, 360, and 120 h, respectively. After 600 h of testing, there were only a few cracks on the surface of the sample irradiated by 351 nm ultraviolet light, irregular network texture, and a few raised particles on the surface of the sample irradiated by 340 nm, and large-scale cracks and dense raised particles on the surface of the sample irradiated by 313 nm.
Fig. 2 SEM images of PEG2000 irradiated with 340 nm UV light for different times: (a) 0 h, (b) 120 h, (c) 240 h, (d) 360 h, (e) 480 h, and (f) 600 h. |
Based on the macroscopic morphology shown in Fig. 1, it can be seen that the surface pits and cracks occurred at the same time. It can be deduced that the pits generated by aging on the surface are caused by cracking. With the increase of aging time, the crack number and aging degree increased, and the irregular pits gradually covered the whole surface. The bulge particles observed at the crack may be due to the precipitation of oligomers during the aging process.
Fig. 3 shows the microscopic morphology of the cross-section of the PEG2000 sample during 600 h of irradiation with 340 nm ultraviolet light. As shown in Fig. 3a, there were dense spherulites on the cross-section of the sample, with larger spherulite sizes ranging from 200 to 400 μm. The basic composition of spherulites is fibrous crystals, mainly growing radially (Fig. 3b). The red arrow in Fig. 3c shows the surface irradiated by 340 nm ultraviolet light. At 480 hours, the surface of the sample underwent slight melting due to degradation. Fig. 3d is the enlargement of the red circle in Fig. 3c. At this time, the fibrous crystals at the end of the spherulites inside the sample were transformed into spherical particles, and the growth direction was also changed from radial to irregular. When irradiated with 340 nm ultraviolet light for 600 h, the surface of the sample at the red arrow in Fig. 3e degraded and melted severely. At this point, it is observed from Fig. 3f that the density of spherical particles increases at the cross-section of the sample. In summary, the fibrous crystals of the spherulites inside the PEG2000 gradually transform into spherical particles in the later stage of photodegradation. With increased aging time, the number of spherical particles gradually increased and continuously precipitated onto the surface of the sample, resulting in the formation of protruding particles on the surface, as shown in Fig. 2f.
In order to study the changes in surface roughness of PEG2000 under ultraviolet light, the changes in surface glossiness of the sample were monitored (Fig. 4). The initial gloss of all samples was about 52°. After 600 h irradiation with 351, 340, and 313 nm ultraviolet light, the gloss of the sample surface decreased, and the gloss loss rate of the sample surface gloss reached 36.3%, 68.9%, and 84.5%, respectively. The rate of gloss reduction changed continuously during irradiation. After irradiation with 340 nm ultraviolet light, the rate of gloss reduction first increased and then decreased, reaching the maximum value at 360 h. After 351 and 313 nm UV irradiation, the rate of gloss reduction reached the maximum value at 600 and 120 h, respectively. The lower the wavelength of UV light, the greater the gloss loss rate. At the same time, the time point corresponding to the maximum value of the rate of gloss reduction was continuously shortening.
Fig. 4 The surface gloss of samples exposed to three UV irradiations for 600 h (the error bar represents the measured value of glossiness and its error range). |
The reason for the increase of the CO group may be due to the C–H bond breaking on the main chain under the action of UV irradiation, reacting with oxygen to form peroxyl radical (C–O). The peroxyl radical can absorb hydrogen atoms from the surrounding environment, thus forming hydroperoxide groups (COOH), and further decomposes into the CO group.31,32
In order to illustrate the changes in functional groups inside the PEG2000 sample under 340 nm ultraviolet light irradiation, we conducted infrared spectroscopy tests on the cross-section of the sample under three types of ultraviolet light irradiation for 360 hours. The results showed that after irradiation with ultraviolet light at 340 and 313 nm, the sample generated a stretching vibration peak of carbonyl group (CO) at wave number 1724 cm−1, while it was not shown at 351 nm (Fig. 7a). This indicated that 351 nm ultraviolet light did not affect the interior of the sample at 360 h, and the degradation of PEG2000 by 340 and 313 nm ultraviolet light had extended to the interior. From this, it can be seen that the photodegradation of PEG2000 not only occurs on the surface of the sample but also gradually extends from the surface to the interior over time. Fig. 7b showed the carbonyl index at the cross-section of the sample under three types of ultraviolet light irradiation for 360 h. Compared to 351 and 340 nm ultraviolet light, the relative intensity of the carbonyl index inside the sample was higher when irradiated with 313 nm ultraviolet light for 360 h, indicating that shorter wavelength ultraviolet light irradiation can accelerate the degradation process from surface to interior.
Fig. 8 MALDI-TOF spectra of pristine and aged PEG2000 treated for 600 h under different UV irradiations: (a) pristine, (b) 351 nm, (c)340 nm, and (c) 313 nm. |
Sample | Mn/Da | Mw/Da | PDI |
---|---|---|---|
Pristine | 1955 | 1990 | 1.01 |
351 nm | 1899 | 1941 | 1.02 |
340 nm | 1611 | 1779 | 1.10 |
313 nm | 1211 | 1478 | 1.22 |
The aged PEG2000 exhibited a higher gloss loss rate, particularly under 313 nm irradiation. The SEM image (Fig. 2) showed that the sample's surface gradually became rough and cracked during the aging process, and the surface was covered with irregular mesh texture at the later stage of aging. The gloss can be attributed to surface aspects of PEG2000, such as the roughness.34 Changes in surface aspects of samples, such as cracked surfaces or higher surface texture, increased the scattering of the reflected light, and lower gloss ratings were expected to be measured.35,36 It was also found that there was a maximum value for the rate of gloss reduction on the surface of the samples when exposed to UV irradiation. As the wavelength of ultraviolet light decreased, the time corresponding to the maximum value continued to shorten. Combined with the SEM image, it was found that the maximum value of the rate of gloss reduction was located at the time when surface cracking occurred. The surface cracking phenomenon was due to the degradation of PEG2000 under UV irradiation, and the cracks caused by the photochemical reaction required a certain accumulation of UV radiation energy. Generally, the higher the energy of ultraviolet light with shorter wavelengths, the shorter the time it takes to complete energy accumulation, resulting in a phenomenon of continuously shortening the time corresponding to the maximum value of the rate of gloss reduction.
The carbonyl index can reflect the aging degree of materials to a certain extent.37,38 Combining the changes in carbonyl index and gloss loss rate of PEG2000 samples during the three UV irradiations for 600 h (Fig. 11), it can be found that there is a good correlation between the two, especially in the 351 and 313 nm UV irradiation. As shown in Fig. 2, the sample is in a slight aging state from the induction period to the destruction period under the irradiation of 351 nm ultraviolet light, and the sample is in the middle and late aging stage from the destruction period to the drastic change period. This means that the variation of the sample morphology is relatively stable under the conditions of 351 and 313 nm ultraviolet light. Since the carbonyl index and gloss loss rate of the samples increased moderately during the 351 and 313 nm ultraviolet light for 600 h, this is consistent with their morphology changes, so there is a good correlation between the carbonyl index and the gloss loss rate. However, cracking and crinkling occurred on the surface of the samples during 360–480 h irradiation with 340 nm UV light, with a large degree of morphological change. The carbonyl index of samples in the range of 360–480 h increased slowly, from 0.11 to 0.15. As a result, the carbonyl index of the samples under the condition of 340 nm cannot reflect the aging degree of the samples well, so the correlation decrease phenomenon shown in area A appears. When the surface morphology of the PEG2000 sample changes drastically in a short period of time, the change in glossiness can better reflect the aging degree of the sample. In the initial stage of aging, when the transition from the induction period to the destruction period, since there is no obvious aging phenomenon on the surface of the sample, it may be more accurate to use the carbonyl index to reflect the aging degree. In summary, this experiment uses the combination of carbonyl index and gloss loss rate and can better evaluate the aging degree of PEG2000 samples after 351 and 313 nm UV irradiation from the perspective of surface morphology and chemical structure.
Fig. 11 Carbonyl index and gloss loss rate of PEG2000 under three UV irradiations (the error bar represents the error range of the gloss loss rate and carbonyl index). |
Based on 1H-NMR, the photochemical reactions for generating degradation products were proposed (Fig. 12). The degradation of PEG2000 occurred at both the C–H bond and ether bond (C–O–C) on the main chain. The C–H bond on the main chain of PEG2000 was broken under the action of ultraviolet light and reacted with oxygen to form a peroxyl radical (C–O). Peroxyl radical absorbed hydrogen atoms from the surrounding environment to form hydroperoxide (COOH) and then further decomposed into CO groups. At the same time, the “C–O” in the ether bond (C–O–C) was broken to form a radical under UV light, which absorbed the H in the ortho-carbon to form a methyl structure attached to the ester carbonyl group and the ester group structure was formed through the above change process (Fig. 12I).
As shown in Fig. 12II, PEG2000 degradation under UV light irradiation also occurred in another chain-breaking mode. The breakage of the PEG2000 molecular chain due to UV degradation was random, and the “O–C” in the ether bond was broken to form a radical, which ultimately formed the ethoxy groups by absorbing hydrogen atoms from the surrounding environment.
The above test results showed that polyethylene glycol was vulnerable to the influence of ultraviolet light in the environment, the loss of light and structural degradation, resulting in the change of its surface morphology and performance degradation, and then reduced or even loss the reinforcement protection of wooden cultural relics. Therefore, polyethylene glycol is used as a kind of protective material for the restoration of wooden cultural relics. In particular, it is necessary to pay great attention to the influence of ultraviolet light in the long-term preservation process of wooden cultural relics repaired by polyethylene glycol and try to preserve them in a very low or no ultraviolet light environment.
Footnotes |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available. See DOI: https://doi.org/10.1039/d3ra06407g |
‡ Co-first authors: Mingyu Shang, Yanfei Wei. |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2023 |