Matthew J.
Evans
a,
Mathew D.
Anker
*a,
Claire L.
McMullin
*b and
Martyn P.
Coles
*a
aSchool of Chemical and Physical Sciences, Victoria University of Wellington, P. O. Box 600, Wellington, New Zealand. E-mail: martyn.coles@vuw.ac.nz
bDepartment of Chemistry, University of Bath, Bath, BA2 7AY, UK
First published on 12th May 2023
We report the reaction of the potassium aluminyl, K[Al(NON)] ([NON]2− = [O(SiMe2NDipp)2]2−, Dipp = 2,6-iPr2C6H3) with a series of isocyanide substrates (R-NC). In the case of tBu-NC, degradation of the isocyanide was observed generating an isomeric mixture of the corresponding aluminium cyanido-κC and -κN compounds, K[Al(NON)(H)(CN)]/K[Al(NON)(H)(NC)]. The reaction with 2,6-dimethylphenyl isocyanide (Dmp-NC), gave a C3-homologation product, which in addition to C–C bond formation showed dearomatisation of one of the aromatic substituents. In contrast, using adamantyl isocyanide Ad-NC allowed both the C2- and C3-homologation products to be isolated, allowing a degree of control to be exercised over the chain growth process. These data also show that the reaction proceeds through a stepwise addition, supported in this study by the synthesis of the mixed [(Ad-NC)2(Dmp-NC)]2− product. Computational analysis of the bonding within the homologised products confirm a high degree of multiple bond character in the exocyclic ketenimine units of the C2- and C3-products. In addition, the mechanism of chain growth was investigated, identifying different possible pathways leading to the observed products, and highlighting the importance of the potassium cation in formation of the initial C2-chain.
In addition to their stoichiometric incorporation into more complex molecules, the ability to homopolymerize isocyanides into high molecular weight materials is an established reaction.5 The resulting polyisocyanide materials consist of a saturated carbon backbone with a helical arrangement of pendant imine functionalities6 that incorporate the R-group present in the isocyanide monomer.7 Transition metals are widely used to promote these polymerizations and have traditionally been based on precious metals (e.g. Pd, Rh),8 although extension to base metals has attracted recent attention.9 The mechanism of chain-growth in these systems follows a sequential insertion of coordinated isocyanides into [M]–C bonds of the propagating iminoacyl intermediate (Scheme 1).10
The reductive coupling of isocyanides to low molecular weight oligomers may offer further insight into the mechanism of polymerization. However, molecular species that allow controlled insertion reactions leading to short chain homologues of isocyanides are relatively scarce.11 Early work with transition metal complexes demonstrated that controlled dimerisation of isocyanides primarily gave compounds containing C2-ethynediamine ligands (RHN–CC–NHR), typically achieved through a reductive coupling of two coordinated isocyanide ligands under acidic (Zn2+/H2O) conditions.12 More recently, the direct dimerization by low-valent transition metals13 and uranium,14 has been reported, whereas the formation of higher homologues is less common and is limited to examples of C3-,13e,15 C4-,16 and C6-products.16a
A resurgence of interest in the chemistry of (low-valent) s- and p-block complexes has established many examples of parallel reactivity to that of d- and f-block metal compounds.17 In the context of this study, main-group systems have been shown to access a range of C2- and C3-coupled isocyanide products exploiting the reducing abilities of the low-valent elements.18 The reductive dimerisation to form 1,2-diazabutadiene-2,3-diyl ligands, [RNC–CNR]2− (R = Ph, tBu, SiMe3, 2,6-Me2C6H3 = Dmp), has been noted in the presence of bimetallic dialanes (I, Fig. 1)19 and digallanes,20 as well as dimeric Mg(I)21 and Ge(I)22 compounds. A similar diimine product is obtained from the insertion of two molecules of tBuNC into an Al–C bond of AlCp′3 (II, Cp′ = [C5Me4H]−).23 In contrast, when the masked dialumene reagent [Al(Ar)]2(μ-C6H6) (Ar = 2,6-{(Me3Si)2CH}2-4-tBuC6H2) is reacted with tBuNC, the coupled product is best described as the ethynediamide ligand [tBuNCCNtBu]2−, which contains a linear NCCN unit that bridges two Al centres (III).24 We also note that, while the reaction of the bulky β-diketiminate aluminium compound Al(tBuBDIDipp) (tBuBDIDipp = [HC(CtBuNDipp)2]−, Dipp = 2,6-iPr2C6H3) with DippNC afforded reductively coupled dimers of the isocyanide, additional reactivity afforded products in which either an iPr group of the DippNC substrate (IV) or the tBuBDIDipp-ligand (V) was also activated.25 This area has recently evolved to include examples of linear- and cyclo-trimerized isocyanides (VI–VII), generated when the dialumane [(THF){L}Al–Al{L}(THF)]2 ({L} = [{DippNC(Me)}2]2−) is reacted with tBu-NC in the presence of sodium as an additional reducing agent.19c The crystallographically characterized products show that the linear C3-trimers exist as isomeric radical trianionic [(tBuNC)3]3˙− ligands, whilst the cyclic trimer forms an aromatic C3-ring in the [cyclo-(tBuNC)3]2− ligand.
Alkali metal aluminyls26 are a new class of anionic Al(I) complex that have been shown to activate a range of small molecules (e.g. H2,27 CO2,28 C2H4 (ref. 29)) and E–H bonds (E = C,27a,30 N,31 Si,31a,b,32 O,31b P31b). We have focussed our studies in this field on the [Al(NON)]− anion ([NON]2− = [O(SiMe2NDipp)2]2−), which has been isolated as the full series of alkali metal salts, Li–Cs.27b,30c,33 We have recently established that the contacted dimeric pair [K{Al(NON)}]2,33 and the monomeric ion pair, (NON)Al–K(TMEDA)2,34 will promote the homologation of CO to afford linear-[(CO)4]4− and -[(CO)5]5− ligands.35 Analogous CO homologation chemistry was observed using a related three-coordinate aluminyl anion.36 Although inherent difficulties associated with gas phase reactions involving CO prevented the acquisition of mechanistic details from experimental evidence, a quantum chemical study on the latter system showed that the key step in the formation of the C4-homologue [(CO)4]4− was the CC bond formation between two monometallic carbene units, each consisting of a bent coordinated ketene ligand.36 More detailed mechanistic analysis of the CO homologation sequence (from C1 → C2 → C3 → C4) promoted by bimetallic Al/TM (TM = Cr, Mo, W, Mn, Re, Co) systems concluded similar metallocarbene complexes of the transition metals for the C3- and C4-products.37
There have been no reports on reductive homocoupling of isocyanides initiated by aluminyl anions. In this contribution we report the reactivity of K[Al(NON)]‡ to a range of aromatic and aliphatic isocyanides resulting in the selective production of C1-, C2- or C3-homologated products. These studies are complimented by density functional theory (DFT) experiments to provide insight into the mechanism of C–C chain growth.
For the mixture of 1a and 1b, we tentatively assign the cyanido-κC isomer 1a as the major product, based on a more intense (broad) signal in the 13C {1H} NMR spectrum at δC 141.0 compared to the cyanido-κN isomer at δC 174.2 (Fig. S4†). 2D correlation experiments were used to identify the respective SiMe2 signals in the 1H NMR spectrum and the partial separation of these resonances were used to determine the relative ratio of isomers 1a and 1b as 4:1 (Fig. S2†). IR data collected on crystals of 1a/1b show a characteristic Al–H stretch at 1755 cm−1,27b with a weak absorption at 2119 cm−1 that is assigned to the CN stretching vibration of the cyanido-κC isomer, 1a. The corresponding νCN for the cyanido-κN derivative is predicted at 70–100 cm−1 lower than the Al–CN isomer,39 but was not observed.
To further our understanding of the Al–CN/Al–NC isomerisation, a sample in 1 prepared in situ was reacted with 1 equivalent of 222-cryptand, affording a mixture of [K(2.2.2)crypt][Al(NON)(H)(CN)] (1a-crypt) and [K(2.2.2)crypt][Al(NON)(H)(NC)] (1b-crypt). 1H NMR data show a similar splitting of the SiMe2 resonances with a ratio of 5:3 in favour of the cyanido-κC isomer (Fig. S8†). The AlNC resonance of 1b-crypt was observed at δC 179.3 in the 13C{1H} NMR spectrum, although the corresponding AlCN peak was not observed presumably due to broadening caused by the 27Al nucleus. The diagnostic absorptions in the IR spectrum of 1a-crypt/1b-crypt (νCN 2106 cm−1; νAl–H 1792 cm−1) are comparable to those in 1a/1b.
Single crystal X-ray diffraction data was collected on 1a/1b and the structure was modelled as (i) Al–CN (Fig. 2a), (ii) Al–NC and (iii) disordered Al–(C/N)(N/C). The most stable refinement was obtained with a disordered model, in which the cyanido-κC isomer 1a was the major contributor (80.4%), which correlates well with the spectroscopic data (Fig. 3). Residual electron density was present near the aluminium centre, consistent with a terminal hydride ligand thereby confirming the overall structure as K[Al(NON)(H)(CN/NC)]. The aluminium adopts a distorted tetrahedral geometry, with the K cation engaging in intramolecular π(arene) interactions to a Dipp substituent with additional K⋯C/N interactions to the cyanido group. Additional intermolecular K⋯π(arene) and K⋯H interactions generate a 1-D chain parallel to the b-axis of the unit cell (Fig. 2b). The Al–C/N bond distance of 2.000(2) Å in 1 is within the range of those reported for related aluminium compounds containing the “Al–CN/Al–NC” fragment (1.989(3) Å–2.047(3) Å),19c,38,40 with a short CN bond length (1.153(3) Å) consistent with a triple bond. Unfortunately, analysis of 1a-crypt/1b-crypt by X-ray crystallography revealed additional disorder in the position of the aluminium and in the backbone of the NON-ligand, preventing any additional useful information from being obtained (Fig. S11†).
Fig. 2 (a) Displacement ellipsoid plot (30%) of the asymmetric unit of K[Al(NON)(H)(CN)] (1a). (b) Section of the 1-D chain formed by intermolecular K⋯H and K⋯N/C interactions. |
Fig. 3 Summary of crystallographic data for the models of K[Al(NON)(H)(CN)] (1a) and K{Al(NON)(H)(NC)] (1b). |
Since the desired homologation reaction did not occur with tert-butyl isocyanide, we therefore extended the study to the reactions between K[Al(NON)] and 2,6-dimethylphenyl- (Dmp-) and 1-adamantyl- (Ad-) isocyanides. The addition of Dmp-NC to a yellow diethyl ether solution of K[Al(NON)] resulted in a colour change to dark purple (Scheme 3). The 1H NMR spectrum of crystals isolated from the reaction indicated the presence of more than one species in solution. An analytically pure sample of the major product (2) was prepared by washing the crystals with hexane and drying the sample under high vacuum. Attempts to characterize the by-products in the hexane wash were unsuccessful.
The 1H NMR spectrum of 2 revealed a highly asymmetric environment for the NON-ligand, best represented by the presence of four singlets between δH 0.38 and −0.15 for the SiMe2 groups. The Dmp-methyl groups appear as six singlets between δH 2.53 and 0.93 that integrate for 18H, consistent with the incorporation of three Dmp-NC molecules in the structure of 2. However, the presence of low field signals in the 1H NMR spectrum (δH 5.79, 1H; 5.71–5.62, 2H) and a loss of symmetry for one of the Dmp-rings in the 13C {1H} NMR spectrum (δC 156.3, 133.6, 123.5, 122.4, 122.3, 63.4) were reminiscent of data observed for a related germanium complex that underwent dearomatisation of an aromatic ring system to form a metallacycle.41 Repeating the reaction at low temperatures (−78 °C) or varying the number of equivalents of Dmp-NC (1–3 equivalents) had no effect on reaction product and all resulted in the isolation of 2.
Compound 2 was crystallized from Et2O as the bis-ether adduct, 2·Et2O.§ The solid-state structure confirms the formation of a C3-chain as part of a tricyclic ring system, formed by the reductive coupling of three molecules of Dmp-NC, in addition to dearomatisation of one of the pendent Dmp-groups (Fig. 4). The Al centre adopts a distorted tetrahedral geometry supported by the bidentate NON ligand and a four-membered AlC2N-chelate formed from the coupled isocyanides. The potassium cation coordinates to the nitrogen atoms of two of the isocyanide groups, with the two Et2O molecules completing the coordination sphere.
Within the [Dmp-NC]3 unit of 2·Et2O, the C29–C38 (1.4350(16) Å) and C29–C47 distances (1.4399(17) Å) are similar, and intermediate between the idealised bond lengths for C–C single (1.54 Å) and CC double (1.34 Å) bonds, suggesting delocalisation of electron density within the C3-chain. The C–N distances C38–N4 (1.3009(17) Å) and C47–N5 (1.3015(17) Å) confirm CN double bonds. These atoms form part of a larger planar unit that incorporates the ipso-carbon atoms C39 and C48, with the latter atom showing the maximum deviation from the mean plane of 0.0132(8) Å. The formation of a bond between an isocyanide Dmp-CN atom and an ortho-carbon of an adjacent Dmp-group generates a cyclohexa-1,3-diene ring, with a short N3–C30 bond of 1.3200(16) Å. The ring has a fold angle of 28.48(5)° to the previously defined plane, imposed by the sp3-hybridised C31 atom. Analogous dearomatisation of Dmp-groups have been observed during coupling reactions of Dmp-NC initiated by complexes of scandium42 and vanadium.13e,43
To avoid complications due to the presence of the arene-substituent, the reaction of K[Al(NON)] with Ad-NC was investigated. When performed in a 1:1 ratio, a complex mixture of products was identified by 1H NMR spectroscopy. It was reasoned however that the bulk of the adamantyl group might provide access to the C2-coupled product. Therefore, the reaction was repeated with two equivalents of Ad-NC at −78 °C, allowing the isolation of 3·Et2O in good yields.
The 1H NMR spectrum of 3·Et2O shows broad resonances typical for the Ad-group, which overlap with the NON-ligand signals. The SiMe2 resonances are split into four signals, indicating a low symmetry at the aluminium centre. A low field peak is observed in the 13C{1H} NMR spectrum at δC 196.1, assigned to the central ‘–CCN–’ carbon atom of a ketenimine group. The lack of signal for the other carbon of this unit is likely a consequence of bonding to the quadrupolar 27Al atom (I = 5/2). To determine the structure of 3·Et2O, crystals suitable for a single crystal X-ray diffraction experiment were obtained by the slow evaporation of a diethyl ether solution.
Compound 3·Et2O is monomeric in the solid state with a distorted tetrahedral Al centre defined by the NON-ligand, and an η2-C,N-bonded [{Ad-NC}2]2− group that forms an aluminaazacyclopropane ring (Fig. 5). The coordination sphere of the K cation is defined by π(arene) interactions with a Dipp substituent, with additional interactions to the C2N-chain and a molecule of diethyl ether. The C40–N4 distance of 1.4292(15) Å is longer the corresponding bonds in related AlCN-rings that contain delocalised (range: 1.358(2) Å–1.379(2) Å) or unsaturated (range: 1.239(11) Å–1.322(6) Å) C–N bonds derived from carbodiimides30f,44 or isocyanides,19a,24,45 respectively, confirming an aluminaazacyclopropane ring. The C29–C40 bond length (1.3081(18) Å) is much shorter than the corresponding C–C bonds in the C3-unit of 2·Et2O and is close to the value observed for an idealised double bond. Furthermore, the C29–N3 bond length (1.2693(17) Å) and the bond angle at C29 (157.12(13)°) suggest that the exocyclic C2N-unit is best described as a localised ‘CCN’ ketenimine, with consecutive double bonds. This structure for the dimerized isocyanide contrasts with the proposed intermediate carbene that forms from the dimerization of CO during the formation of the [(CO)4]4− ligand (Fig. 6). It is likely that the bulky R-groups enforce this structural difference, although the influence of the supporting ligands cannot be discounted. Additionally, the presence of the N-substituents will hinder dimerization and prevent formation of the analogous [(R-NC)4]4− ligand. We note a recent report that describes the reductive coupling of Dmp-NC by a low-valent uranium complex in the presence of Cp*2Co, which afforded [U{N(SiMe3)2}2(Dmp-NCCNDmp)]− anion containing a similar η2-N,C-ligand to that in 3·Et2O.14 Although described as an “acetylene diamide” complex, analysis of the bond lengths and angles by the authors concluded the same contiguous CC and CN double bond character as that observed in 3·Et2O.
Fig. 5 Displacement ellipsoid plot (30%) of 3·Et2O (H-atoms omitted, peripheral carbon atoms represented as spheres). Selected bond lengths (Å) and angles (°) presented in Fig. 7. |
Fig. 6 Calculated carbene intermediate in the formation of the [(CO)4]4− ligand, with the analogous dimerised isocyanide (not observed) and isomeric core of 3·Et2O. |
The bonding within 3·Et2O was examined using DFT (full details in ESI†). In agreement with the proposed structure based on X-ray diffraction data (Fig. 7a), relatively large values for the Wiberg bond indices (WBIs) at C29–C40 (1.83) and C29–N3 (1.73) confirm CC and CN double bond character within the ketenimine unit (Fig. 7b). The HOMO shows π-electron density across the CC bond with p-orbital characteristics at N4. The distal C29–N3 double bond is π* anti-bonding with respect to the CC bond, with one lobe aligned with the N3–C30 bond and the other showing (sp-hybridized) lone-pair character.
To develop our understanding of the C–C chain growth mechanism from C2- to C3-products, we exposed a solution of 3·Et2O to one equivalent of Dmp-NC or Ad-NC affording new products 4 and 5, which were isolated as the THF (4·THF) and toluene (5·toluene) adducts, respectively (Scheme 4). The resonances in the 1H and 13C{1H} NMR spectra of 4·THF are broad and heating the sample to 333 K only partially resolved the signals, suggesting a rigid structure with restricted rotational freedom in solution. No evidence of dearomatisation was observed in the solution state, even when heated to 333 K. Compound 5·toluene exhibits two low field resonances in the 13C{1H} NMR spectra (δC 226.6 {C3}, 212.6 {C1}, Scheme 4) consistent with an additional unsaturated carbon atom in a RNC1–C2(NR)C3NR chain. The low solubility and resulting broadening of the observed resonances for 4·THF means that only one signal is resolved, at δC 209.5, assigned to the C3-carbon atom. These data are consistent with the additional isocyanide inserting into the Al–C bond of 3·Et2O to form an unsaturated C3-chain.
Scheme 4 Chain growth of 3·Et2O upon addition of R-NC, affording 4·THF (R = Dmp) and 5·toluene (R = Ad). Carbon atom numbering in products according to NMR assignments. |
X-ray crystallographic studies of 4·THF (Fig. 8a) and 5·toluene (Fig. S25†) confirm the formation of the trimerized C3-chain (Table 1). The key components of the two derivatives are essentially the same. Structural features are therefore discussed for 4·THF with corresponding bond lengths and angles for 5·toluene given in parentheses.
4·THF | 5·Toluene | |
---|---|---|
Al–N4 | 1.9143(19) | 1.8658(15) |
Al–C51 | 2.063(2) | 2.1236(18) |
N3–C29 | 1.246(3) | 1.250(3) |
C29–C40 | 1.334(3) | 1.332(3) |
C40–C51 | 1.512(3) | 1.531(2) |
C40–N4 | 1.400(3) | 1.399(2) |
C51–N5 | 1.280(3) | 1.282(2) |
N4–Al–C51 | 71.36(8) | 71.34(7) |
C30–N3–C29 | 120.6(2) | 120.05(16) |
N3–C29–C40 | 162.2(3) | 163.75(19) |
C29–C40–N4 | 133.4(2) | 133.27(17) |
C29–C40–C51 | 120.74(19) | 120.48(16) |
N4–C40–C51 | 105.71(18) | 105.64(14) |
C40–N4–C41 | 119.50(18) | 121.22(14) |
C40–N4–Al | 96.13(13) | 98.53(11) |
C41–N4–Al | 144.36(14) | 140.21(12) |
C40–C51–N5 | 117.7(2) | 116.63(16) |
C40–C51–Al | 86.79(13) | 84.35(10) |
N5–C51–Al | 155.26(19) | 158.43(14) |
C51–N5–C52 | 123.6(2) | 122.94(16) |
The trimerized isocyanide group bonds to aluminium as a κ2-C,N-chelate, forming a four-membered aluminaazacyclobutane ring with an acute bite angle of 71.36(8)° (71.34(7)°) at aluminium. The solvated potassium atom is contacted by an unsaturated CN unit of the chain, with an additional contact to the terminal imine nitrogen, N5. The C–C and C–N bond lengths within the metallacycle indicate single bonds, while the exocyclic components of the C3-chain are consistent with a reduced bond order. For example, the C29–C40 bond length of 1.334(2) Å (1.332(3) Å) indicated double bond character, although we note that this is longer than the CC ketenimine bond in 3·Et2O. In addition, the C–N distance of 1.246(3) Å (1.250(3) Å) reflects multiple bond character, with the large angle of 162.2(3)° (163.75(19)°) consistent with this model. At the other end of the C3-chain, the C51–N5 bond length of 1.280(3) Å (1.282(2) Å) also indicates retention of an unsaturated bond in a terminal imine group.
DFT calculations performed on 4·THF and 5·toluene are consistent with the bonding model suggested from X-ray diffraction data. The WBIs confirm single and multiple C–C bond character within the C3-chain, with the C29–C40 bond order of ∼1.5 lower than the corresponding value in the dimer (1.83). The HOMOs of both compounds are similar (Fig. 8b and S26†) with key components the same as that calculated for 3·Et2O, consisting of CC π-bonding component that is π* anti-bonding with respect to the C29–N3 bond, and a non-hybridised p-orbital on N4. The exocyclic C51–N5 imine does not contribute to the HOMO.
The (R-NC)3 homologues in 4·THF and 5·toluene are unique examples of dianionic trimerized isocyanides, differing from the radical trianionic trimers [(tBuNC)3]3˙− noted in VI (Fig. 1).19c They are, however, structurally related to products formed during the trimerization of isocyanides at group 4 and 5 metals,43,46 although these transition metal promoted reactions proceed via an initial insertion of isocyanide into a M–H or M–C bond, resulting in carbon-substituted trimers (Fig. 9). Of relevance to this study, we note that the sequential addition of differently substituted isocyanides to the tantalum hydride complex Ta(ODipp)2(H)Cl2(PMe2Ph)2 (ref. 46d and f) or the titanium imido (κ3-N2Npy)Ti(NtBu)(py) (N2Npy = [(2-C5H4N)C(Me)(CH2NSiMe2)2]2−)46c afforded non-symmetrical keteneimine ligands, similar to the ligand observed in 5·toluene. This led to two proposed mechanisms for the transition metal promoted oligomerisation that differ in the position at which the second isocyanide bonds to the growing chain. Thus, either an intermediate N-bound aminoketeneimine group,46d or an imine-substituted iminoacyl intermediate46a is postulated, which are formed from a common η2-iminoacyl complex derived by insertion of R-NC into a M–H or M–C bond.
Fig. 9 Schematic diagrams of the different ligand classes generated from the trimerization of isocyanides at metal centres. |
We have examined the mechanism of isocyanide dimerisation and trimerisation by K[Al(NON)] leading to 3·Et2O, 4·THF and 5·toluene using DFT (BP86-D3BJ(PCMC7H8)/BS2//BP86/BS1). We note that comparisons with the transition metal systems described above must be treated with caution as the initial step of the reaction with aluminyls cannot generate the analogous iminoaacyl intermediate. Furthermore the possibility exists in the current study for R-CN coordination at multiple (Al and K) centres.‡
An assessment of the dimerisation of Ad-NC to afford 3·Et2O was conducted. Initial work examined whether the reaction is favoured at the contacted dimeric pair (CDP) [K{Al(NON)}]2 (A) or via an initial dissociation into monomeric ‘K[Al(NON)]’ units (Fig. S27†). Splitting the dimer has an energy cost of 14.5 kcal mol−1, with an increase to 17.2 kcal mol−1 when Ad-NC is coordinated to the aluminium of the resulting monomeric K[Al(NON)] unit. However, retaining the dimeric form gave lower energy pathways for the initial coordination of Ad-NC at either aluminium or potassium.¶
Introduction of three equivalents of isocyanide (at one aluminium of the CDP and both potassium atoms) generated structure E (ΔGtol = 7.8 kcal mol−1) that provided a pathway for C–C bond formation (Fig. 10). Intermediate F (ΔGtol = −2.1 kcal mol−1), where the new isocyanide substrate forms an aluminaazacyclopropane ring, is accessed via transition state TS(E–F) with an energetically accessible barrier of 4.5 kcal mol−1. From intermediate F, the disruption to Al⋯K interactions within the Al2K2-core (present in structures A–E) permits an onward trajectory with loss of “K[Al(NON)(Ad-NC)]” to form G (ΔGtol = 10.9 kcal mol−1). Intermediate G undergoes the critical C–C bond forming step via TS(G–H) to afford H (ΔGtol = −42.2 kcal mol−1), via potassium delivery of Ad-NC to a strained azaaluminacyclopropane. This step mirrors that calculated for the C1 → C2 growth in a mixed Al/Mn system, in which exogenous CO reacts with a strained oxaaluminacyclopropane ring the give the C–C coupled product.37c Compound H can coordinate Et2O to form 3·Et2O (ΔGtol = −46.6 kcal mol−1) that is notably more stable by 4.4 kcal mol−1.
Fig. 10 Computed free energy profile (BP86-D3BJ(PCM = C7H8)/BS2//BP86/BS1 in kcal mol−1) for the dimerisation of Ad-NC at [K{Al(NON)}]2 leading to formation of 3·Et2O. Note: charges and lone pairs on isocyanide groups omitted for clarity. See footnote ¶ and Fig. S28† for details of structures A–E. |
An alternative ‘ether assisted’ pathway for the C–C coupling step has also been identified as part of this study (Fig. S29†). The coordination of Et2O to the potassium cation of G before the C–C bond forming step lowers the energy by 3.0 kcal mol−1 to form G·Et2O (ΔGtol = 7.9 kcal mol−1). This pathway leads to the product 3·Et2Ovia TS(G·Et2O–3·Et2O), with a small energy barrier of 2.3 kcal mol−1. We note that this is lower than the corresponding barrier for the conversion of G → H (4.6 kcal mol−1). However, experimental observations note that a distinct colour change to bright yellow occurs upon mixing the reagents in the reaction solvent of toluene prior to the removal of this solvent and crystallization from Et2O. This suggests that under the conditions of the experiment, the pathway in Fig. 10 is most likely operating, although it does highlight the potentially important role that the solvent can play in this reaction.
Based on the crystal structures of 4·THF and 5·toluene and assuming there is no interconversion between tautomers or geometric isomers, the [(Ad-NC)2(Dmp-NC)]2− dianion can adopt three different structures that differ in the relative positions of the amido (am), imine (im) and ketenimine (ket) substituents (Fig. 11). The crystal structure of 4·THF adopts the {AdamAdketDmpim} form (Fig. 8a) and represents the least structural reorganisation when starting from 3·Et2O (which may be considered as the {AdamAdket} form of the dimer). Taking this into consideration, we examined the addition of a third equivalent of R-NC to the non-solvated species H as a route to 4 (R = Dmp) and 5 (R = Ad).
Fig. 11 Possible forms of the [(Ad-NC)2(Dmp-NC)]2− ligand that differ in the relative position of the amino, ketenimine and imine substituents (am = amido, ket = ketenimine, im = imine). |
Three energetically accessible pathways were identified for the addition of isocyanide to the C2-chain in H. The addition of Dmp-NC at the potassium affords J at ΔGtol = −40.0 kcal mol−1, while coordination at the aluminium forms a higher free energy structure I at −37.3 kcal mol−1 (Fig. 12) with a change in the coordination of the [AdNC]2 unit to the monodentate N-bound C2-chain. Onward reaction from I occurs via C–C coupling in TS(I–K) (ΔGtol = −34.1 kcal mol−1) with an overall barrier from H of 8.1 kcal mol−1. The transition state for the onward pathway from J was also identified, although occurs at a high free energy barrier (34.3 kcal mol−1) compared to the barrier for TS(I–K) of only 3.2 kcal mol−1. As noted for the formation of 2·Et2O, the coordination of solvent during the crystallisation process (in this case two THF molecules associating to the K+ cation), stabilises structure K by 5.9 kcal mol−1 to give 4·THF.
The third pathway (Fig. S30†) involves a reorganization of the coordinated C2-ligand of H to a four-membered AlNC2 metallacycle followed by coordination of Dmp-NC at potassium via K⋯π(arene) interactions to give intermediate L (ΔGtol = −33.8 kcal mol−1) and subsequent C–C bond formation with a barrier of 15.8 kcal mol−1. However, when Dmp-NC is introduced as the third isocyanide, this results in the {AdamDmpketAdim} form of the ligand coordinated to aluminium, M, which is inconsistent with the experimentally observed structure of 4·THF. Therefore, although the pathway cannot be ruled out as the possibility exists for interconversion of the different ligand forms, we consider it less likely compared with the other pathways identified that involve considerably less reorganization.
Examination of the corresponding pathways for the conversion of H to 5·toluene (i.e. the addition of Ad-NC to H) has also been conducted (Fig. S31†). The pathway with the lowest barrier mirrors that shown in Fig. 12, with an overall value of 6.0 kcal mol−1. In this case we note that the ΔGtol value of I′ (−36.2 kcal mol−1) is higher than TS(I′–K′) (−39.4 kcal mol−1) due to the presence of dispersion effects. The pathway with insertion of Ad-NC via potassium, TS(J′–K′), remains relatively high with a barrier from H of 31.6 kcal mol−1. Finally, we note that for the homologized (AdNC)3 product, only one isomer is possible (i.e. {AdamAdketAdim}), legitimizing the third pathway noted previously. However, the overall barrier for the formation of K′ from H through this route remains relatively high (28.2 kcal mol−1) compared with the lower energy pathway viaI′.
Footnotes |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available: Experimental procedures; NMR spectra; details of X-ray experiments and additional figures; computational details and xyz-coordinates from DFT calculations. CCDC 2247345–2247351. For ESI and crystallographic data in CIF or other electronic format see DOI: https://doi.org/10.1039/d3sc01387a |
‡ K[Al(NON)] is known to exist as the contacted dimeric pair [K{Al(NON)}]2 in the solid- and solution-states. |
§ Compound 2 has also been crystallographically characterised as the toluene solvate, 2·toluene. In this structure, the potassium is not solvated by Et2O and has intermolecular K⋯O contacts with the NON-ligand of a neighbouring molecule, forming a polymeric 1-D chain. The structure of 2·toluene is included in the supporting information for reference (Fig. S15). |
¶ See Fig. S28. Coordination of Ad-NC at aluminium affords B (ΔGtol = 1.1 kcal mol−1) and coordination at potassium generates B′ (ΔGtol = 0.7 kcal mol−1). An increase in the energy of B to ΔGtol = 4.5 kcal mol−1 was calculated when a second (non-coordinated) isocyanide was introduced, C. The transition-state for association of the second Ad-NC to a potassium cation of C, TS(C–D), was isolated at 3.8 kcal mol−1 to give adduct D (ΔGtol = 1.9 kcal mol−1). TS(C–D) is higher in ‘raw’ free energy than intermediate C by 0.67 kcal mol−1, however, when the full methodology of single point corrections is applied (most specifically dispersion) TS(C–D) has a relative free energy value that lies below C on the reaction surface by 0.7 kcal mol−1. Multiple attempts were made to identify a transition state corresponding to the dissociation of “K[Al(NON)]” from D. Unfortunately, this proved unsuccessful due to the flat nature of the reaction energy surface with the productive dissociation imaginary frequency not the only negative frequency located. |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2023 |