Mohammed
Sharique‡
a,
Bianca
Matsuo‡
a,
Albert
Granados‡
a,
Saegun
Kim
a,
Mahwish
Arshad
a,
Hyunjung
Oh
a,
Victoria E.
Wu
b,
Minxue
Huang
b,
Adam
Csakai
b,
Lisa A.
Marcaurelle
b and
Gary A.
Molander
*a
aRoy and Diana Vagelos Laboratories, Department of Chemistry, University of Pennsylvania, 231 South 34th Street, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania 19104-6323, USA. E-mail: gmolandr@sas.upenn.edu
bEncoded Library Technologies/NCE Molecular Discovery, R&D Medicinal Science and Technology, GSK, 200 Cambridge Park Drive, Cambridge, MA 02140, USA
First published on 14th September 2023
The emergence of DNA-encoded library (DEL) technology has provided a considerable advantage to the pharmaceutical industry in the pursuit of discovering novel therapeutic candidates for their drug development initiatives. This combinatorial technique not only offers a more economical, spatially efficient, and time-saving alternative to the existing ligand discovery methods, but also enables the exploration of additional chemical space by utilizing novel DNA-compatible synthetic transformations to leverage multifunctional building blocks from readily available substructures. In this report, a decarboxylative-based hydroalkylation of DNA-conjugated N-vinyl heterocycles enabled by single-electron transfer (SET) and subsequent hydrogen atom transfer through electron-donor/electron-acceptor (EDA) complex activation is detailed. The simplicity and robustness of this method permits inclusion of a broad array of alkyl radical precursors and DNA-tethered nitrogenous heterocyles to generate medicinally relevant substituted heterocycles with pendant functional groups. Moreover, a successful telescoped route provides the opportunity to access a broad range of intricate structural scaffolds by employing basic carboxylic acid feedstocks.
Conceptualized by Brenner and Lerner in 1992,15 DEL technology offers several advantages over other hit identification methods because of its ability to screen large libraries of compounds (>106 to 1012 discrete members) in a relatively short period of time, because the library of compounds can be screened against a biological target in a single step, rather than requiring the screening of individual compounds.16 This leads to significant time and cost savings, particularly in the early stages of drug discovery. Another advantage of DEL synthesis is its ability to identify hits with high binding affinity to a target protein. Thus, compounds in the library are covalently linked to a DNA barcode, which enables the screening of billions of compounds simultaneously. This allows the identification of compounds that bind specifically and tightly to the target protein, which can be important for the development of effective drugs.17
To generate structurally valuable DEL libraries, it is essential to explore and translate innovative synthetic transformations to this platform.
Compared to traditional synthetic reactions, DEL reactions are often viewed as unconventional because they involve simultaneously manipulating the small molecule building blocks while preserving the valuable DNA tags. As a result, these reactions present unique challenges and often require optimal tuning of reaction parameters. Additionally, the reaction must exhibit high chemo-selectivity, scalability, and versatility toward different functional groups.18 In this context, photoredox chemistry is an appealing and powerful synthetic tool for conducting DEL reactions. This is primarily because of its ability to operate under extremely mild conditions, faster reaction times, and compatibility with dilute aqueous media.19,20
Among various transformations developed in the realm of DEL-chemistry, C(sp3)–C(sp3) bond formation has garnered significant attention.19–22 In particular, photo-induced (hydro)alkylation reactions have proven to be valuable tools for incorporating pharmaceutically relevant alkyl scaffolds. These reactions utilize alkyl radicals derived from readily available radical precursors (RP) through photoinduced SET, which are subsequently reacted with DNA-tethered electrophilic Giese-type acceptors, making them an efficient way to introduce these scaffolds (Scheme 1A).23 Relying on this strategy, Flanagan and co-workers developed a decarboxylative alkylation approach to introduce stabilized α-amino- or α-oxy radicals onto DNA-tagged styrenes, acrylamides, and vinyl benzamides.24 Subsequently, the Liu (2021)25 and Lu (2021)26 research groups independently reported similar methods for adding α-amino radicals to on-DNA acylamides via the hydrogen atom transfer pathway in the presence of an iridium-based photocatalyst, yielding amino-alkylated products. However, these approaches are largely limited to stabilized alkyl radicals, with the exception of a 2020 report by Mendoza et al., where they employed a redox-active ester (RAE) to incorporate unstabilized alkyl radicals into on-DNA acrylates/acylamides through an EDA-complex route using NADH as an electron donor species.27
As part of a research program focused on creating innovative synthetic methods to broaden the chemical space in DEL, our laboratory has been particularly involved in developing (hydro)alkylation reactions on various functionalized DNA headpieces (HPs) using photoredox approaches. In 2019, we reported a defluorinative alkylation method that utilizes photoredox radical-polar crossover pathway to synthesize on-DNA gem-difluoroalkenes from trifluoromethylated alkenes.28 We also developed a metal-free hydroalkylation approach that was used to introduce alkyl groups on DNA trifluoromethylated styrene conjugates, enabling access to complex trifluoromethylated benzylic scaffolds via a decarboxylative EDA complex activation mechanism.29 Very recently, in 2022, our laboratory reported an organo-photocatalyzed method for incorporating medicinally relevant bicyclo[1.1.1]pentanes (BCPs), which are arene bioisosteres, into functionalized on-DNA styrenes via a photocatalyzed halogen transfer pathway.30
Although significant progress has been made in the field of on-DNA hydroalkylation, the existing methods are limited to a few types of Giese acceptors such as styrenes and acrylates/acrylamides, indicating the need to explore new chemical methods to broaden the hydroalkylation space. To complement these efforts, we became interested in pushing the boundaries of photochemical paradigms to access on-DNA N-alkylated heterocyclic scaffolds via hydroalkylation of N-vinyl heterocyclic precursors (Scheme 1B). Heterocycles play a vital role in medicinal chemistry research and are a fundamental component of numerous pharmaceutical drugs.31–33 In particular, N-alkylated heterocycles are found in essential medicinal drugs such as atorvastatin/Lipitor® (for treating hypercholesterolemia) as well as fezolamine34,35 and trazodone (both antidepressants) (Scheme 1C). This underscores the significance of developing new chemical reactions focused on N-containing heterocycles. Off-DNA examples have successfully adopted the strategy of photoactivation of EDA complexes of RAEs and Hantzsch ester (HE) in a metal-free setting to promote the Giese addition of alkyl radicals to activated olefins, as demonstrated initially by Shang36 and later by Allred and Overman.37
Therefore, we envisioned a metal-free protocol that leverages the electron-donor/electron-acceptor (EDA)38–41 activation pathway to generate alkyl radicals from redox active esters, which are subsequently added into the N-vinyl heterocyclic HPs in a Giese-addition manner followed by hydrogen atom transfer, allowing the synthesis of on-DNA N-alkylated heterocyclic products (Scheme 1D).
Although the proposed transformation seems promising, there were challenges to overcome. For instance, N-vinyl heterocycles are electron-rich systems, which can result in a polarity mismatch of reactivity with the alkyl radicals that are also electron-rich species. To the best of our knowledge, no report on this specific hydroalkylation of N-vinyl heterocycles has been disclosed either on- or off-DNA, which made this transformation particularly appealing to investigate.
Entry | Deviation from std conditions | % conversionb |
---|---|---|
a Reaction conditions: N-vinyl imidazole HP-1a (1.0 equiv., 25 nmol), RAE 2a (50 equiv., 1.25 μmol), Hantzsch ester (50 equiv., 1.25 μmol), 8:1 DMSO/H2O (0.55 mM), 20 min irradiation with Kessil lamps (λmax = 456 nm, 40 W). b Conversion to 3ab was determined by LC/MS (see ESI). | ||
1 | None | 95 |
2 | RAE (25 equiv.), HE (25 equiv.) | 42 |
3 | RAE (12 equiv.), HE (12 equiv.) | 18 |
4 | RAE (6 equiv.), HE (6 equiv.) | Trace |
5 | No HE | 0 |
6 | No light | 0 |
After establishing suitable conditions, the generality of the on-DNA hydroalkylation reaction was assessed (Table 2). Initially, the scope of redox-active esters was investigated by utilizing primary-, secondary-, and tertiary radical precursors and reacting them with DNA-tagged pyrazole HP-1b. Notably, the method is effective with primary radicals that are relatively unstable and feature complex functional groups. The methyl radical 3a exhibited favorable conversion (49%). Redox-active esters with phenyl- and phenacyl on the side chain generated the desired products in good conversions (3b–3c). The reaction showed good tolerance toward some other primary radicals as well, including Boc-protected amine 3d, the bulkier methyl adamantyl group 3e, and the thiyl radical 3f, all of which provided modest to good conversions.
a Conversion was determined by LC/MS analysis (see ESI). Reaction conditions: DNA-N-vinyl pyrazole HP-1b (1.0 equiv., 25 nmol), RAE 2 (50 equiv., 1.25 μmol), Hantzsch ester (50 equiv., 1.25 μmol), 8:1 DMSO/H2O (0.55 mM), 20 min irradiation with Kessil lamp (λmax = 456 nm, 40 W). |
---|
We then proceeded to investigate the feasibility of using secondary- and tertiary alkyl-substituted redox-active esters in the reaction. We examined a range of secondary radical precursors that contained protected nitrogen groups. Piperidine 3g, pyrrolidine 3h, and azetidine 3i, all of which were Boc-protected, showed mostly excellent conversions. Similarly, other substructures, such as pyrimidine-containing 3j and benzyl ester 3k, also displayed good reactivity. In addition, cyclohexyl 3l, difluorocyclohexyl 3m, and difluorocyclobutyl (3n) radicals all exhibited good conversion. Moreover, compounds containing both internal and external alkene functional groups (3o–3p) also displayed excellent tolerance to the reaction, expanding the potential to attach further building blocks, an important aspect in DEL synthesis. In addition, the developed conditions were found to be effective for α-amino 3q, α-oxy 3r, and sugar-containing radicals (3s–3t). However, the bis-benzylic radical 3u exhibited low conversion under the same conditions.
To expand the scope of the process, structurally diverse tertiary radicals were examined in the reaction. N-Boc-protected cyclobutyl- and cyclohexylamines (3v–3w) exhibited excellent conversion. 4-Methylpentene 3x and cyclopropylbenzene 3y were also accommodated. Additionally, gemfibrozil 3z, which is a lipid-regulating medication, demonstrated good compatibility and conversion in the reaction, furnishing the desired compound with 72% conversion.
Next, we sought to evaluate the scope of this transformation with various heterocyclic HPs using a set of primary-, secondary-, and tertiary redox-active esters (Table 3). HP-1a, which contains an imidazole moiety, exhibited moderate reactivity with primary radical 3aa, but excellent reactivity with secondary- and tertiary radicals (3ab–3ad). Surprisingly, 2-bromo-imidazole HP-1c, which contains a carbon–halogen bond that is prone to photochemical cleavage, also exhibited good tolerance in the reaction and provided good to excellent conversions with all three types of RAEs (3ae–3aj). The scope of the investigation was broadened to encompass additional important heterocycles, such as pyrazoles and pyrroles. These heterocycles have been extensively studied and utilized in the design and development of various therapeutic agents because of their wide range of biological activities, structural diversity, synthetic accessibility, and favourable drug-like properties.44 In this regard, 5-methyl pyrazole HP-1d and 5-methyl pyrrole HP-1e demonstrated a notable ability to undergo reaction under the experimental conditions. Specifically, 5-methyl pyrazole HP-1d demonstrated moderate conversions with un-activated radicals (3ak–3am), but excellent results with more stabilized radicals (3an–3ap). On the other hand, 5-methyl pyrrole HP-1e displayed only moderate conversions (below 60%) when reacted with various alkyl radicals (3aq–3av). Furthermore, two nitrogen-rich heterocycles, triazole HP-1f and benzotriazole HP-1g were incorporated, which are easily obtained through Click reactions and hold significance in drug discovery.45,46 These heterocycles also showed excellent compatibility in the reaction and exhibited good to excellent reactivity (3aw–3bh), showcasing the robustness and versatility of the developed method, which can accommodate numerous heterocyclic functional groups crucial for medicinal chemistry research.
a Conversion was determined by LC/MS analysis (see ESI). Reaction conditions: DNA-N-vinyl Het (1.0 equiv., 25 nmol), RAE 2 (50 equiv., 1.25 μmol), Hantzsch ester (50 equiv., 1.25 μmol), 8:1 DMSO/H2O (0.55 mM), 20 min irradiation with Kessil lamp (λmax = 456 nm, 40 W). |
---|
The structural diversity and commercial availability of carboxylic acids make them a desirable choice for multifunctional building blocks in DEL. To demonstrate the modularity of this approach, a one-pot photoinduced decarboxylative alkylation protocol was devised by forming aliphatic RAEs in situ using N-hydroxyphthalimide tetramethyluronium hexafluorophosphate (HITU), which is a stable solid that can be easily synthesized in large quantities.40 The carboxylic acid 4, DIPEA, and HITU were microdosed in DMSO under air, followed by 3 hours of activation time. The RAE 2a formed in situ was then directly subjected to the developed conditions with a solution of HE and the DNA headpiece HP-1b. Gratifyingly, the reaction attains 80% yield to provide product 3g, which is similar to the yield obtained when preformed RAE was used (81%) (Scheme 2).
Scheme 2 On-DNA photoinduced decarboxylative alkylation: in situ activation of RAEs with N-hydroxyphthalimide tetramethyluronium hexafluorophosphate (HITU). |
Footnotes |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available: Experimental and mechanistic studies details, as well as spectral data. See DOI: https://doi.org/10.1039/d3sc03731b |
‡ These authors contributed equally. |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2023 |