Athira Jayasree
Subhash
a,
Gafar Babatunde
Bamigbade
a and
Mutamed
Ayyash
*ab
aDepartment of Food Science, College of Agriculture and Veterinary Medicine, United Arab Emirates University (UAEU), Al-Ain, UAE. E-mail: mutamed.ayyash@uaeu.ac.ae
bZayed Center for Health Sciences, United Arab Emirates University (UAEU), Al-Ain, UAE
First published on 9th January 2024
The date palm holds immense significance in the socio-economic fabric of the countries where it is extensively cultivated. The plant and its derivatives boast diverse nutritional and functional properties, contributing to a substantial global production surge. Despite various initiatives to convert date processing waste into value-added products, a significant proportion of waste persists in the form of date seeds, date pomace, and lost dates. The physicochemical and nutritional profiling of date seeds and pomace reveals functionalities that, if properly utilized, could transform them into economically viable, natural, and sustainable ingredients across various sectors. Although ample literature exists on date palms and their industrially relevant waste products, this review distinctly focuses on date seed and pomace as pivotal by-products of date processing. The objective is to furnish comprehensive and updated insights into the valorization of date seeds and pomace, emphasizing their applications in the food industry. This review also endeavors to illuminate approaches for minimizing the wastage of these industrial by-products and highlights the bioactive components inherent in them.
Sustainability spotlightThe manuscript provides a comprehensive exploration of sustainable practices in the food industry by focusing on the valorization of date by-products, specifically seeds and pomace. By addressing the physicochemical and nutritional profiling of these by-products, the review sheds light on their potential as economically viable, natural, and eco-friendly ingredients. The manuscript emphasizes strategies for minimizing waste, promoting sustainable utilization, and highlights bioactive components with potential health benefits. Through this work, we contribute valuable insights into sustainable technologies for food ingredients, processes, and packaging. |
The date palm (Phoenix dactylifera L.), a dioecious monocotyledonous tree belonging to the family Arecaceae and the subfamily Coryphoideae, encompasses approximately 200 genera and over 2500 species.6 Cultivated since ancient times, date palms have played pivotal roles in medicine, socioeconomics, ornamentation, environmental sustainability, and nutrition.7–9 Although historical records provide limited information on the origin of date palms, ancient Mesopotamia (now Southern Iraq) and the Nile Valley in Egypt are recognized as their sources. Domestication occurred from the Neolithic period through the Bronze Age, as evidenced by carbonized seed materials.10–13 Date palms originated in the Near East region in Mesopotamia around 4000 BC before becoming integral to the social and economic lives of arid and semi-arid regions, thriving in hot climates with minimal rainfall and low humidity.14 Geographically, Arabian countries and Iran are global leaders in date palm cultivation, accounting for about 70% of the global production.15–18 However, date palms have also spread to tropical, subtropical, temperate, and arid regions globally, including South America, South Africa, Southern Spain, West Asia, the Mediterranean coast of Africa, Pakistan, Mexico, Australia, India, and parts of the United States (California, Texas, and Arizona).6,19 With over 2000 global cultivars named according to their originating country,19,20 date palms offer more than just fruits. They provide ligneous midribs, stalks, and fibers from leaves and fronds used in manufacturing building materials, fuel, basketry, and packaging materials.21,22
Fig. 1 illustrates some of the global importance of cultivating date palms. Beyond the cultural and spiritual significance, especially in MENA, central and South Iraq, Upper Egypt, and Northern Sudan, date cultivation profoundly influences the economies of producing countries. The MENA region, characterized by hot and dry climates, remains a major producer, accounting for 67% of total date exports and 75% of global date production, with India being the top consumer of date fruits.5,23–26 In 2020, global date palm cultivation covered about 1.3 million hectares, producing approximately 9.5 million tons of date fruits.25 Asia reported the largest cultivated area at 62.43%, followed by Africa at 36.72%, while America and Europe each accounted for less than 1%. FAO statistics identified Egypt, Saudi Arabia, Iran, Algeria, the United Arab Emirates, Pakistan, and Sudan as the top seven date-producing countries.25 Recent trends indicate a steady increase in date palm production, attributed to documented nutritional and health values, along with innovations in cultivation and processing, leading to the introduction of new date-derived products.10 The global date fruit market is expected to witness significant growth between 2022 and 2030, driven by strategic initiatives by key producers.25
Date fruits are the cornerstone of date palm products from an economic perspective, being consumed as fresh or dried whole fruits or processed into various food products, such as jams, syrups, sugars, jellies, juice, and pastes.7,24,27 Physiologically, the date fruit is a one-seeded drupe enclosed in a fleshy pulp of pericarp, mesocarp, and endocarp,24 holding pivotal significance, particularly in MENA regions.1,28,29 In many Arabian and Islamic countries, date fruits serve as traditional snacks during hospitality events, often accompanied by dairy products and coffee, especially in Gulf countries.20 Moreover, the social and economic value of oasis residents in MENA countries is intertwined with date palms and fruits owing to their inherent nutritional, medicinal, environmental, and structural applications.20 Despite the global variety in date cultivars, characterized by differences in size, color, taste, and ripeness degree, they all undergo a maturation cycle encompassing five stages over seven months, with each stage named according to the originating country.15,30 The quality and nutritive value of date fruits are influenced by external and internal changes during maturation.31 The edibility of date fruits spans the last three stages due to reduced bitterness, increased sweetness, improved tenderness, and juiciness.10,24,32 It is noteworthy to reiterate that the chemical and functional contents of dates are affected by the different stages of growth (Table 1) evinced by the simultaneous reduction in fibers, vitamins, and minerals as sugar levels increase, resulting in a total decrease in weight.33,34 Additionally, phenolics and flavonoids have been reported to decrease as dates age, especially in Ajwa dates.35
S/N | Stage name | Maturity | Growth period (weeks) | Color | Texture | Taste | Moisture content (%) | Sugar content (%) | Edibility | Reference |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
1 | Hababouk | Young immature | 4–5 | White | Fluffy | — | 80–90 | — | No | Fernández-López et al. (2022),10 Hussain et al. (2020)32 |
2 | Kimri | Immature | 9–14 | Green | Turgid | Bitter | 75–85 | 20 | No | Krueger (2021),229 Martín-Sánchez et al. (2014)34 |
3 | Khalal | Mature | 6 | Yellow, pink, red, purple | Turgid | Slightly bitter | 40–60 | 50 | Yes | Golshan and Fooladi (2006),230 Martín-Sánchez et al. (2014)34 |
4 | Rutab | Mature | 2–4 | Yellow, brown, black | Soft | Sweet | 30 | 72–88 | Yes | Baliga et al. (2011),15 Krueger (2021)229 |
5 | Tamar (ripe and dried) | Mature | Black or brown | Hard | Sweet | 20–25 | 72–88 | Yes | Al Udhaib (2015),231 Krueger (2021)229 |
Dates not only serve as a cost-effective staple food source, contributing to food security in agrarian societies, but are also considered excellent sources of energy for growing populations.36 Consumption of dates contributes to overall health due to their richness in bio-nutrients, such as dietary fibers, proteins, carbohydrates, low fat, and minerals, with carbohydrates being the most abundant, averaging an estimated 50–89 g of total sugars per 100 g of date fruits.10,32,37 Furthermore, vitamins, such as thiamine, cobalamin, riboflavin, retinol, pyridoxine, and ascorbic acid, along with carotene, flavonoids, and anthocyanins that influence date color, have been identified in date fruits.1,6,19 The presence of bioactive compounds like antioxidants, phenols, sterols, anthocyanins, and carotenoids, enhances the functional and health properties of dates, making them beneficial for treating cardiovascular and stomach disorders.10,30,38–40 It is crucial to note that the composition and quantity of these micro and macro nutrients vary according to the cultivar, growth region, ripening stage, and climatic conditions.32,37,41
The date palm tree has garnered significant attention owing to its desirable fruits and high nutritional benefits.42 Traditionally, all parts of the date palm tree have found applications in medicine and food, playing a unique role in the diets of residents in date-producing countries. Date palm fruits have been utilized in traditional medicine as syrups for treating liver diseases and for pregnant women just before delivery. Consuming dates regularly is believed to protect individuals from chronic, infectious, and gastrointestinal diseases.43 Date fruits and associated products, such as date syrups, serve as raw materials for beverages, confectioneries, ice creams, and bakery products.44
The production of dates generates approximately 30% waste during harvesting from immature stages within the cluster. Second-class dates are also generated during picking, storing, or conditioning. Furthermore, the processing of date fruits into secondary products, such as confectionary dates, date paste, date fruit powder, vinegar, jam, chutney, date syrup, sugar, juice, and syrups, results in the generation of tons of waste in the form of fibrous date pomace (dibs) and seeds,45,46 along with by-products like date seed flour hydrolysate (DSFH), date seed flour (DSF), defatted date seed, fermented date fruit puree, and date seed oil.1 These by-products have industrial functional applications in food. Intriguingly, there is scientific evidence supporting the nutritional and bioactive properties of date fruits and their by-products, demonstrating antioxidant, antimutagenic, anti-inflammatory, anticancer, antimicrobial, and immunostimulant properties.42 The global acceptance of date fruit, coupled with the aforementioned activities, contributes to the substantial amount of waste generated from date production and processing. It has become essential for farmers and processors to enhance the valorization of these by-products into value-added products, leveraging their inherent nutritional and medicinal benefits while promoting a circular economy and sustainability. Despite the global acceptance of date consumption, the exploration of the food and medicinal applications of dates and their by-products has not been fully investigated. Hence, the aim of this present review is to elucidate recent information about the history and market value, as well as to explore and generate comprehensive current scientific reports on different biocomponents, phytonutrients, and phytochemicals present in date by-products, specifically the date seeds and pomace. The novelty of this review is further strengthened by illuminating and accentuating the applications of these by-products in food industries as potential food additives, nutraceuticals, or raw materials for functional foods against increasing health and food insecurities.
As one of the richest natural plant protein sources, date fruits have versatile applications in various food processes, serving as solubilizing, gelling, stabilizing, emulsifying, and foaming agents.48 Notably, almost every part of the date fruit is utilizable. Harvested dates are consumed directly in their natural stages, such as Khalal, Rutab, or Tamer.19 Additionally, low-grade or excess dates undergo direct processing or value addition for consumption, manifesting as date syrup, date juice, date extract, date powder, date paste, date fiber concentrate, date jam, vinegar, and some components that serve as animal feed.50 Despite numerous efforts to convert industrially relevant date processing waste into value-added products, a substantial amount of waste is generated in the form of date seeds, date pomace, and discarded dates.51Fig. 2 illustrates the by-products produced by the date processing industry.
Studies focusing on the nutritional profiling of date seeds have undertaken comparative analyses of different seed varieties, maturity stages, and geographical locations.56–58 Unfortunately, large quantities of date seeds are discarded by date industries, contributing to post-harvest waste annually.59 Notably, date seeds exhibit the potential to remain dormant for extended periods and can grow under favorable circumstances.60 Owing to their bioactive compounds and dietary fibers, date seeds emerge as suitable candidates as raw materials for fiber-based foods. They are rich in phytochemicals, such as phenolic acids, carotenoids, flavonoids, anthocyanins, and lignin.61–63
Date pits, whether in whole or roasted form, are well-known sources of various classes of phenolic compounds. A study by Ardekani et al. (2010)64 highlighted that date seeds exhibited an overall antioxidant activity of 37 mmol ferric per 100 g sample and an overall phenolic content of 3658 mg gallic acid equivalents per 100 g sample. Habib et al. (2014)65 reported the presence of families of phenolic compounds like phenolic acids, flavan-3-ols, flavones, flavonols, and hydroxycinnamic acids, in the UPLC chromatogram of date seeds. The concentration per 100 g of ellagic acid, benzoic acid, cinnamic acid, and pyrogallol, as identified in date seeds, ranges from 36% to 58%.53
Roasted date pits have demonstrated a maximum inhibiting effect against colon cancer cell lines possibly due to their phenolic profiling and antioxidant potential. Various studies have reported the role of dietary flavonoids in suppressing tumor cell proliferation.66–68 This suppression is achieved by (i) modulating reactive oxygen species (ROS) to scavenge enzyme activities; (ii) arresting the cell cycle; and (iii) inducing apoptosis, thereby suppressing cancer cell proliferation. A study by Akasha et al. (2016)48 identified storage proteins glycinin and b-conglycinin as the prominent date seed proteins out of the 300 proteins detected. The protein found in date seeds contains a higher concentration of sulfur-containing amino acids, such as methionine and cystine and negligible concentrations of tryptophan. This concentration and type of amino acid vary with different date cultivars and processing methods. For example, in roasted date seeds, the highest reported amino acids were glutamic acid, arginine, aspartic acid, and leucine, corresponding to 16.44, 8.13, 7.63, and 6.10 g/100 g proteins, respectively.69
Date pits were traditionally discarded during processing until recent times when their potential functionalities were explored. Powdered seeds have been used as caffeine-free coffee ingredients in the Arab world for decades. In recent times, date seeds have found applications in animal feed, enhancing animal growth by boosting hormone levels.70 Extensive studies are ongoing on the utilization of date seed by-products in foods owing to their physicochemical and nutritional properties. A positive trend in world date production is observed every year, emphasizing the importance of exploiting date pits containing numerous bioactive constituents for the benefit of mankind and as an extended income for this sector.55 As the major by-product of date processing industries, date seeds are utilized in different forms based on their nature of applications, such as defatted date seeds, date seed flour hydrolysate, dietary fiber concentrates from date seeds, and date seed oils.
Date seeds contain a comparatively higher proportion of dietary fibers, approximately 70%, compared to pulp. The major components of these dietary fibers are insoluble, with a lower proportion being soluble. The dietary fibers in date seeds primarily consist of cellulose and hemicellulose, mainly gluco and galacto-mannans.71 The composition of these fibers, along with their water and oil holding capacity and emulsifying abilities, has paved the way for their application in foods fortified with natural fibers.70
It is estimated that, on average, 3900 tons of date seed oil could be extracted from date pits annually.72 The superior quality of date seed oils is attributed to their lower acidity and peroxide values compared to refined vegetable oils, such as sunflower oil, indicating their lower oxidation potential. Furthermore, the oil derived from date seed extraction is rich in monounsaturated fatty acids and lipid-soluble antioxidants like phenols and phytosterols, which have the potential to lower the likelihood of various diseases.73
The oil extracted from date seeds contains more saturated fatty acids than unsaturated ones, with oleic and linoleic acids being the major mono-unsaturated fatty acids, and lauric, myristic, and palmitic acids being the major saturated fatty acids. The ratio of oleic to linoleic acids determines the quality of the extracted oil.69,74 Oleic acid is generally considered advantageous for health due to its low saturation level, trans-isomer content, and its ability to act against increasing LDL cholesterol levels. The physicochemical characteristics of the oil hint towards its oxidation and thermal stability, making it a suitable candidate for use as edible oil.72
The oxidative stability of seed oil is explained in terms of its higher average tocopherol content, observed in date seed oils compared to olive and peanut oils. The key mechanism governing this is the ability of date seeds to scavenge free radicals, thereby protecting cells from oxidative stress. Carotenoid, a phytochemical in the form of β-carotene, is present in date seeds and oil in major quantities. The quantity of carotenoid is considered an important parameter for assessing the oil quality, as this phytochemical directly correlates with the color of the oil.36,53 Given the annual global wastage of date seeds, the date seed oil resulting from extraction is a promising potential ingredient in the food, medical, pharmaceutical, and chemical sectors.
Date pomace is an excellent source of dietary fiber, protein, residual sugars, and fat, with the former around 45 g/100 g of dry weight, making it a potential polysaccharide source.82 It also contains microelements, such as manganese, calcium, iron, zinc, magnesium, and potassium, in the range of 10.9–625 mg kg−1, respectively, along with carotenoids.83,84 Dietary fiber in pomace comprises non-starch polysaccharides, such as arabinoxylans, cellulose, and other constituents like resistant starch, inulin, lignin, chitins, pectins, beta-glucans, and oligosaccharides. The antioxidant potential of pomace is explained by its total phenolic content in the range of 170–260 mg gallic acid equivalents GAE/100 g,45 151 mg/100 g,81 and by the presence of associated phenolic compounds, such as flavonoids, phenolic acids, quinones, sterols, and anthocyanins.84 Further characterization revealed that fructose was the main simple sugar and that oleic acid was the prominent fatty acid in date pomace.85
Date press cake, another by-product of date syrup processing, has been largely underutilized in the food industry and consists of a mixture of fibrous material from date flesh and crushed date seeds. It is characterized by its light brown powder-like appearance owing to natural pigments like carotenoids and anthocyanins, present in date seeds and fruit. In studies on fully ripe Shahani date fruits in Iran, Majzoobi et al. (2019)85 observed that date press cake is moist and contains carbohydrates (79%), crude fiber (11%), protein (6%), and fat (4.9%). Despite the low fat content, in-depth lipid profiling has shown the presence of higher levels of monounsaturated fatty acids, such as oleic acid. Phenolic compounds are in the range of 17.79 mg GAE per g, and flavonoids in the form of quercetin represent 1.89 mg quercetin per g flavonoids in the press cake, possibly hinting towards their antioxidant potential. The quantity of the most bioactive components in press cake varies with the part from which they are extracted and is strongly influenced by the date pressing/juicing process.79
DP is an underutilized co-product of date processing, composed of moisture and residual sugars from date pulp, containing a significant amount of organic compounds.50,85,89 Currently, there are limitations to the utilization of date pomaces. Production statistics estimate that date syrup generates about 52–64% of date syrup, 17–24% of fibrous DP, and, finally, 8–15% of date seeds.79 Presently, some generated pomaces from the date processing industries are used either as animal feeds or feed additives, while significant amounts end up in landfills. Unfortunately, these wastes contain a substantial amount of moisture and organic compounds that degrade, forming leachate and offensive odors that cause environmental pollution.80,90 The deposition of these pomaces in the environment raises concerns for global waste management, sustainability, and public health, given the inherent ecological threats and the potential spread of diseases due to bacteria, pests, and rodent survival.80,91
As a by-product of date processing industries, date pomace (DP) has been documented to be rich in valuable residual biomacromolecules, macro and micronutrients, and oxidation inhibiting agents.46,92,93Fig. 4 illustrates the different valuable components of DP. Specifically, Iranian Shahani date fruit pomaces were evaluated by Majzoobi et al. (2019)85 to contain 79.1% carbohydrate, 11.7% crude fiber, 13.4% moisture, 4.9% fat, and 6.3% protein. Despite the abundance of valuable biomacromolecules, DP remains one of the underutilized fruit by-products, especially in the food industry. Researchers have identified a lack of technical knowledge about the health, nutritional, and potential effects of DP on overall food quality as major limitations hindering the use of DP as a functional ingredient in the food industry.83,85,94
Currently, there is increasing research on DP valorization as a microbial fermentation substrate. Interestingly, DP is rich in antioxidants and dietary fibers that can be incorporated into different food products as functional ingredients while promoting the principles of the circular economy and sustainability. This approach will not only foster the production of functional and healthier foods but also reduce morbidity and mortality due to degenerative diseases such as diabetes, cardiovascular diseases, and cancer. Examples of such functional and healthier foods include bakery, confectionery, and dairy products.95 The incorporation of date and its by-products into foods, such as meat, cheese, bakery products, pastries, and cheese, has been documented in the literature.21Table 3 shows different food products fortified with date pomace as raw materials or supplements.
Overall, bakery and pastry products have been extensively formulated using DP as functional ingredients to replace sugar and flour or to act as a source of fiber to improve the sensory, nutritional, and physicochemical properties of the products. Generally, bakery products, such as bread, cookies, cakes, and biscuits, have a high glycemic index (GI). Interestingly, accumulated evidence suggests that fortification of these products with fruit and vegetable by-products correlates with reduced GI owing to enhanced digestion of the carbohydrate component by the soluble fibers and phenolic compounds present in the by-products.54,96–99 All the fortified food products reported in Table 3 have shown improved nutritional, sensory, rheological, and physicochemical properties due to the incorporated date pomace. Bchir et al. (2014)100 highlighted some potential mechanisms by which DP improves dough performance and bread quality in their study. The increased water absorption (55–60%) and dough volume (166–169 g) were attributed to the hydrogen bonding of the hydroxy groups of date pomace dietary fibers and water. Similarly, an increased dough gelatinization temperature ranging from 66.4 to 69.6 °C was reported to result from the competition between incorporated DP and starch for water, leading to a decrease in water absorption and an increase in dough gelatinization temperature. The interaction of DP with flour protein interrupts the starch–gluten complex, increasing dough stability from 4.0 to 31.0 min, which indicates good dough strength. Additionally, the reduced dough viscosity and extensibility were associated with starch–gluten complex interruption and DP-flour protein interaction, respectively.100 Date pulp was supplemented in bread as a sucrose alternative by Nwanekezi et al. (2015).101 The authors concluded that the nutritional characteristics measured in relation to dietary fiber and protein significantly increased with an increase in date pulp quantity.
Biscuits are an essential product of the food industry and are consumed as snacks or desserts. Currently, consumers are skeptical about the consumption of biscuits owing to their high sugar and fat contents, leading to them being labeled as unhealthy foods.102,103 To address this concern, researchers have suggested that fortifying ingredients and proportions with fruits and vegetable by-products containing bioactive phytochemicals can help produce biscuits that meet the requirements of healthy and functional foods for the prevention of chronic diseases, health maintenance, and promotion.104,105 Based on previous studies on the fortification of food products with date pomace (DP), Sheir (2022)83 investigated the potential of formulating vegan biscuits and protein bars. The author concluded that the use of DP in producing vegan biscuits and protein bars has economic and health value, especially for athletes, vegetarians, and adolescents, owing to the high content of recommended dietary allowances as well as the nutritional, sensorial, and physicochemical properties of the products.
Cookies, another essential bakery product with a longer shelf life, high energy, and global consumption as a quick snack, are characterized by low moisture, resulting in comparatively low microbial spoilage and enhanced shelf stability.106 Similar to biscuits, cookies are often rich in high sugar, which is associated with metabolic disorders, raising concerns about their consumption among certain age groups. The use of commercial wheat or composite flour has been criticized as “slow poison” owing to refining and bleaching.107 Ajibola et al. (2015)108 reported the practicability of fortifying cookies with ingredients, such as fruit by-products, tailored to the nutritional and therapeutic requirements of consumers. Considering the abundance of biological macromolecules in DP, especially residual sugar, Ikechukwu et al. (2017)107 utilized DP as a sucrose replacer in cookies, with the fortified products considered ideal for patients suffering from metabolic disorders and as functional foods. The authors concluded that the inclusion of DP as a sugar replacer in cookies improved the flour functional properties, as well as the physicochemical and proximate properties of the cookies.
There is an increasing campaign for the reduction of animal protein and fats, with a focus on the increased consumption of cereals rich in dietary fiber by health authorities.109,110 Similarly, the consumption of pasta as a cereal product has been recommended as a nutrient supplement by the World Health Organization.111 Traditional pasta is deficient in required nutrients that can foster a positive health status in consumers.112 Researchers have proposed the use of non-durum wheat flour with dietary fiber-rich ingredients to produce tailored pasta with functional properties for health promotion and maintenance. In the past, legumes and other cereal flours have been supplemented for pasta production, increasing the tenacity and quality of products.111–113 Recently, Bchir et al. (2022)110 formulated a new pasta product from DP flour. The authors concluded that DP positively influenced the physicochemical properties, sensorial and organoleptic properties, as well as cooking quality of the fortified pasta. In particular, DP inclusion increased the fiber content, swelling index, and cooking water absorption of fortified pasta while significantly reducing the optimum cooking time. Another researcher also included DP as a source of dietary fiber in yogurt, where it was observed that DP inclusion reduces syneresis while improving whey retention, textural, and sensory properties of the yogurt.114
The modification of products with date by-products has been a subject of debate among researchers, with some arguing that it may impact the overall quality of new products.115 Consequently, studies evaluating sensory aspects and product quality indicators, such as texture, aroma, and flavor, have been conducted. In summary, most of these studies have reported positive quality parameters, including color, texture, and aroma, as well as high consumer acceptance of modified products.116
For instance, Sánchez-Zapata et al., (2011)35 found improved sensory quality in meat products treated with date by-products. Similarly, Martín-Sánchez et al., (2014)34 reported that technological and sensorial characteristics remained unchanged in dry-cured sausage treated with 5% date by-products paprika compared with the traditional prototype. Another study focused on sausages incorporated with date pomace powder also confirmed satisfactory sensory and technological properties, with a high acceptance rate from the panelists.117
Antioxidant activity is primarily explained by the phenolic content of plants. Plant-based phenolic compounds, serving as natural sources of antioxidants, are considered excellent candidates for delaying the lipid oxidation reaction in foods.64 This preservation action helps maintain nutritional quality and extends the shelf stability of food products. In comparison to synthetic antioxidants, natural phenols preserve the taste and flavor of fortified food products. Additionally, phenolic compounds have the potential to act as antimicrobial agents that are effective in modifying intracellular pH, chelating metals essential for microbial viability, and altering microbial cell membrane permeability.127
Date seeds exhibit a range of beneficial properties, as reviewed by Maqsood et al., 2020,36 including antioxidant activity by inhibiting lipid peroxidation and scavenging free radicals; antibacterial activity by inhibiting the growth of both major Gram-positive and Gram-negative bacteria; antifungal activity, particularly against Fusarium oxysporum; anticancer activity by inhibiting cell proliferation in tumor lines; antihyperglycemic activity by regulating glucose levels, performed by protocatechuic acid and caffeic acid; and anti-inflammatory activity via the aid of rutin, quercetin, p-coumaric, and caffeic acids.128–130 Additionally, date palm pit extracts tested for their antiviral effects against lytic Pseudomonas phage ATCC 14209-B1 clearly displayed antiviral properties of extracts, with a minimum inhibitory concentration (MIC) of less than 10 mg mL−1, limiting the infectivity of the phage and completely preventing the lysis of bacterial cells.131 This finding raises the prospect of exploring industrial waste as a potential novel functional ingredient in food systems.
Most recent studies have focused on replacing synthetic functional food ingredients with date by-products with comparable activities. Nowadays, the valorization of by-products from the food industry by reincorporating them into the food chain is one of the main approaches used to improve the sustainability of food production through the reduction of the amount of waste generated, thus promoting a circular economy. Some of the potential applications of date seeds in their natural and modified forms in different food sectors are presented in Table 2. The utilization of date seeds (raw, roasted, powdered, and defatted) and their secondary products, such as dietary fiber, and oils, has been reported by researchers in bakery and confectionery,132,133 beverage,134 meat, dairy, and among the major industrial food sectors (Fig. 3).
Sector of application | Product type | Nature of date pit | Effective level/percentage | Quality attributes impacted | References |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Beverage | Coffee | Roasted and powdered date pit | 9% | 9% roasted date seed powder is a coffee substitute with coffee-like properties and fewer health risks | Venkatachalam and Sengottian (2016)232 |
Coffee-like beverages | Roasted and powdered date pit | N.A | The beverage had lower total phenolics, antioxidants, color, bitterness, and coffee flavor than traditional Arabic coffee | Ghnimi et al. (2015)233 | |
Coffee | Roasted and powdered date pit | C1-100% | Date pit coffee with additives had low caffeine content, no cytotoxicity, high nutrition, antioxidants, and acceptability exceeding control coffee | Ragab and Yossef (2019)138 | |
C2-92.5% | |||||
C3-61.67% | |||||
Cocoa substitute beverage | Roasted and powdered date pit | 9% | Water–milk with roasted date seeds was preferred over cocoa. It has potential health benefits | El Sheikh et al. (2014)69 | |
Bakery and confectionary | Enriched bread | Powdered date pit | 4–12% | Date pit powder added to bread increased soluble fiber, while wheat flour blended with 12% date pit powder resulted in higher firmness | Alamri et al. (2014)234 |
Bread | Powdered date pit fiber | 10% | Bread with higher dietary fiber content can be made to have a comparable sensory profile to wheat bran bread | Najafi (2011)119 | |
Bread | Intact and defatted date pit powder | 5, 10, and 15% | Date pit powder improved water absorption and dough efficiency. 5% in bread created a unique sensory profile | (Khodaparast et al., 2007) | |
Pita bread | Date pit powder | Flour substituted with 5, 10, 15 and 20% date seed powder | Fortified bread had comparable dietary fibers, increased flavonoids, phenolic compounds (flavan-3-ols), antioxidant potential, and limited acrylamide content compared to whole wheat bread | Platat et al. (2015)162 | |
Mayonnaise | Date seed oil | NA | Date seed oil in mayonnaise outperformed corn oil for better sensory qualities | Basuny and Al-Marzooq (2011)145 | |
Butter cake | Date seed powder | 2.5% | Butter cakes with 2.5% ground date seed powder exhibited similar sensory and nutritional properties but had negative bulking, pasting, and baking characteristics | Ammar et al. (2013)235 | |
Cookies | Fine seed powder | 2.5–7.5% | Seed powder influenced cookie lightness and hardness; higher additions resulted in darker and crispier cookies. Cookies with 7.5% seed powder in whole wheat flour showed the highest acceptability | Najjar et al. (2022)133 | |
Chocolate spread | Dietary fiber from seeds | 5% | Seed powders enhanced water and oil binding capacity, emulsion stability, and overall acceptability | Bouaziz et al. (2017)236 | |
Baker's yeast | Date seed hydrolysate | 3% w/v of date seed hydrolysates, rice straw, and date flesh as carbon source | 9.12 g L−1 baker's yeast obtained after 18 h fermentation with Saccharomyces cerevisiae at 30 °C | Salem et al. (2016)237 | |
Meat and poultry | Cooked ground beef | Date pit extract | 0.5, 0.75, and 1% | Khalas date pit extract enhanced minced beef with potent antioxidants, phenolic content, TBA reduction potential, and superior sensory characteristics | Amany et al. (2012)238 |
Beef burger | Date seed powder | 1.5, 3, and 6% | Beef burgers fortified with seed powder exhibited improved cooking and sensorial properties, lower lipid oxidation, and microbial contamination during shelf-life | Sayas-Barberá et al. (2020)116 | |
Beef burger | Date seed powder | 25, 50, 75, and 100% | Replacing breadcrumbs with 25% date seed powder led to reduced lipid oxidation, microbial contamination, and improved cooking properties and sensory acceptance in burgers | Alqahtan et al. (2022)239 | |
Dairy | Spreadable processed cheese | Date seed powder | 0, 1, 5, and 10% | Fortified cheese with 1% and 5% seed powder showed significant differences in total solids and fiber contents, with favorable sensory acceptance | Darwish et al. (2020)240 |
Processed cheese | Fiber from date seeds | 0, 5, 10, 15, and 20% | Partial substitution of butter by date seed fiber in processed cheese positively impacted nutritive value but negatively affected texture. Cheese with 5% and 10% seed fibers showed overall acceptability | Alqahtani et al. (2023)146 | |
Kareish cheese | Date seed powder | 0.5, and 1% | Kareish cheese supplemented with date seed and oat fibers showed improved storage characteristics, resulting in higher yield and total solid content with reduced coagulation and setting time | Basiony et al. (2018)241 | |
Prebiotic | Date pit | NA | Fiber-fortified Kareish cheese demonstrated an increased presence of lactic acid bacteria and bifidobacteria, suggesting a potential probiotic effect with overall acceptability in flavor and texture | Khiyami et al. (2008)242 | |
Probiotic yoghurt | Date seed powder | 0.5% | Date seed powder as a natural stabilizer in set yogurt positively influenced the growth of Lactococcus lactis, enhancing rheology and sensory attributes. Increased seed powder concentrations led to decreased titratable acidity and excellent water holding capacity during storage | El-Kholy (2018)243 |
S/N | Food | Uses | Product indicator | Pomace preparation condition | Concentration used | Optimum concentration used | Outcome | Reference |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
1 | Biscuit | Flour replacement | Quality characteristics | Oven dried at 120 °C for 30 min | 20, 25 and 30% | 30% | Increased ether extract, ash, crude fiber and mineral content | Saleh et al. (2022)103 |
Reduced protein, carbohydrate and energy | ||||||||
Reduced moisture content and water activity | ||||||||
Significant reduction in pH during storage | ||||||||
Better sensory properties and acceptability | ||||||||
2 | Cookies | Sugar substitute | Proximate and physical properties | Oven dried at 75 °C for 6 – 8 hours | 10, 20, 30, 40 and 50% | 30% | Increased swelling index, OHC, pH and viscosity | Ikechukwu et al. (2017)107 |
Increased proximate composition except for carbohydrate and protein | ||||||||
Increased physical properties except for break strength | ||||||||
3 | Cookies | Flour replacement | Microstructure and functional attribute | Oven dried at 60 °C for 10–12 h | 2, 4 and 6% | 4% | Increase in water absorption, moisture, ash, crude fiber, protein and fat content | Shabnam, et al. (2020)244 |
Decrease in spread ratio, diameter, hardness and air space | ||||||||
Increase in cookie thickness | ||||||||
4 | Pasta | Flour complement | Functional, rheological and sensory properties | Oven-dried for 7 h at 70 °C | 2.5, 5, 7, and 10% | 2.5% | Increased energy and fiber content | Bchir et al. (2022)110 |
Reduced cooking time, adhesiveness, and extensibility | ||||||||
Enhanced swelling index, cooking water absorption, water activity, firmness, and tenacity of pasta | ||||||||
5 | Yoghurt | Source of fiber | Sensory and physical properties | 2, 4, 6% | 4% | Improved whey retention textural properties | Hamdia (2016)114 | |
Reduced syneresis | ||||||||
Improved sensory qualities | ||||||||
Lower microbial contaminant | ||||||||
6 | Bread | Source of fiber | Nutritional and techno-functional properties | 2% | Comparable dough volume | Bchir et al. (2014)100 | ||
Increased water absorption, stability, tenacity, and dietary fiber | ||||||||
Reduced extensibility, softening, breakdown and setback | ||||||||
More aerated internal crumb structure comparable with the control during storage | ||||||||
7 | Batter and cake | Flour complement | Rheological, physical and nutritional properties | 10, 20, 30, and 40%. Particle sizes 210 μm and 500 μm | 10% and 210 μm | Increased batter consistency, firmness, density, stickiness, cohesiveness and viscosity | Majzoobi et al. (2019)85 | |
Increased cake density, hardness, and antioxidant content | ||||||||
Reduced pH, cohesiveness, volume and crust moisture content of cake | ||||||||
8 | Cereal bars | Source of fiber | Physicochemical, sensory and nutritional characteristics | Oven-dried at 70 °C for 7 h | 6, 10, 14% | 10% | Low water activity | Bchir et al. (2018)245 |
High energy | ||||||||
Darker color | ||||||||
Texture parameters are comparable with the control | ||||||||
9 | Bread | Source of fiber | Textural properties | Oven dried at 40 °C | 0.5%, 1%, 2% and 3% | 3% | Reduce water activity during storage | Borchani et al. (2015)246 |
Increased hardness and firmness | ||||||||
Springiness was comparable with the control | ||||||||
Significant decrease in the staling rate of 1 and 3% supplementation | ||||||||
10 | Dough and bread | Source of fiber | Dough performance and bread quality | Oven dried at 40 °C | 0.5, 1, 2 and 3% levels | 3% | Increased bread yield and stability | Borchani et al. (2011)247 |
Sensory scores are comparable with the control | ||||||||
High acceptability ratings by the consumer panel | ||||||||
11 | Vegan biscuits | Flour supplement | Quality and nutritional value | 5, 10 or 15% | 10% | Higher acceptability and physical properties compared to control | Sheir (2022)83 | |
Higher shelf life and recommended dietary allowance | ||||||||
Higher moisture, protein, fiber, iron, zinc, calcium, potassium, magnesium, and manganese but lower ash and fat content | ||||||||
Increased hardness and cohesiveness | ||||||||
Reduced springiness, gumminess, and chewiness | ||||||||
12 | Vegan protein bars | Flour supplement | Quality and nutritional value | 10 g | Higher sensorial score in flavor, taste, texture, and overall acceptability | Sheir (2022)83 | ||
Higher willingness to buy | ||||||||
Higher hardness and cohesiveness while gumminess and chewiness are low | ||||||||
Higher in protein, fiber, ash, and minerals | ||||||||
Lower fat, carbohydrates, energy, and moisture |
The significant application of date seed by-products is evident in the bakery and confectionery sectors, leveraging the potential functionality of the seeds and offering considerable value-addition potential. The current trend in the food industry is a shift towards natural, green ingredients and processes, replacing conventional ones. The contemporary lifestyle, characterized by a fast-paced environment and a preference for instant, ready-to-eat, and value-added products, has particularly benefited from industrially relevant date seed wastes. Loaves of bread supplemented with water-soluble polysaccharides and hemicellulose extracted from date seeds demonstrated improved functional qualities, enhancing emulsification, water and oil holding, and foaming properties. This improvement led to significant enhancements in the rheological and textural properties of dough.132 This study suggests that date seed components, particularly seed fibers, could effectively enhance the functional properties of baked goods.
Another investigation by Amin et al. (2019)135 delved into cookies incorporated with date powder. The resulting cookies, except for those with 10% powdered date seeds, showed reduced diameter, thickness, and spread ratio, negatively affecting the textural properties of the cookies. Najjar et al. (2022)133 developed cookies by substituting wheat flour with date seed powder at three different levels (2.5%, 5.0%, and 7.5%) and baking at distinct temperatures (180 and 200 °C). The composite cookies revealed notable total phenolics and flavonoids, imparting enhanced antioxidant potential to the cookies. Traditional pan bread supplemented with 5%, 10%, and 15% date pit powder was developed and studied by Halaby (2014).136 The results indicated that loaves of bread with 15% added seed powder were more accepted compared to the control and other formulations. When tested on rats, the fortified bread showed significant reductions in blood glucose, glycosylated hemoglobin, LDL, and HDL cholesterol levels. Dietary fibers from date seeds obtained by defatting date seed powder were studied as a novel source of dietary fiber.137 Comparative studies of date seed dietary fiber and commercially available fiber from sugar beet residues suggest that the former is superior in terms of dietary fiber content, purity, and richness. However, studies on the partial substitution of both fibers in the same range (2.5% and 5%) of wheat flour for bread production revealed that bread fortified with 2.5% of both fibers was not significantly different from control bread with no fiber content. These findings highlight both the potential benefits and challenges associated with incorporating date seed derivatives into baked food products, emphasizing their impact on different physical and functional properties.
Coffee and tea stand out as the most preferred beverages worldwide. However, ongoing debates question the healthiness of these beverages for all population sectors. Pregnant women and children, in particular, are advised to limit their caffeine consumption, which is higher in coffee. Coffee with a high caffeine content is reported to have major side effects, such as sleeplessness, nervousness, and an increased heart rate.138 Recently, there has been growing interest in studying alternative coffee beans to mitigate these well-known adverse effects. Studies have explored the full or partial replacement of coffee with date seed powder to develop coffee-like healthy beverages. Three different types of coffee were made using roasted date pit powder and other functional additives, C1 (roasted date pits alone), C2 (date pits, cardamom, button roses, nutmeg, and cloves), and C3 (date pits, barley, cardamom, button roses, nutmeg, and cloves), all of which had a higher nutritional value compared to commercial coffee.138 The caffeine content of C3 was significantly lower than that of commercial coffee, with 2.99 mg g−1 in the former and 36.02 mg g−1 in the latter, whereas the antioxidant activity of C3 was higher than that of the rest of the samples. Notably, despite the low caffeine content, C3 was best accepted in sensory trials, outperforming commercial coffee.
The production and consumption of meat and meat products present significant challenges to the food industry, with a growing emphasis on quality and safety for both manufacturers and consumers. Essential aspects determining consumer perception of meat, such as tenderness and juiciness, are closely linked to meat oxidation. Date seeds exhibit the potential to prevent collagen and lipid oxidation in meats owing to the presence of phenolic compounds, such as tannins.24 Condensed tannins form hydrogen bonds with meat proteins, acting as antioxidants and preserving meat tenderness.139 This concept was applied by Nor et al. (2022)140 in a study on the tenderizing effect of date seed powder on lamb and beef. The addition of date seed powder resulted in a reduction in the major textural properties of marinated lamb and beef samples compared to the control, with a comparable decrease in water holding capacity and cooking loss in meat samples with increased date seed powder.
Another noteworthy effect was observed in the improvement of shelf life and bioactivity of marinated fresh meat by date seed extract, as investigated by Abdelrahman et al. (2022).141 Meat samples treated with 2% seed extract showed an overall reduction in total volatile nitrogen, TBAR level, and aerobic bacterial counts compared to the control, extending the shelf life and preventing the growth of pathogenic strains, such as Salmonella and Campylobacter. Essa and Elsebaie (2018)142 proposed another application of date seed powder as a fat replacement agent in meat products. Burger samples with date pit powder (25%, 50%, and 75%) as a substitute for animal fat exhibited improved nutritional, functional, and cooking quality of beef burgers. The substitution retained fat and moisture, crucial attributes for consumer satisfaction, and demonstrated greater stability against lipid oxidation, associated with higher polyphenol contents. Bouaziz et al. (2020)70 formulated low-fat turkey burgers with Deglet Nour date seed flour at various concentrations (3%, 5%, and 10%), demonstrating that burgers made with up to 5% date seed flour had similar textural properties and improved sensory attributes (texture, flavor, and overall acceptance) compared to control samples.
Moreover, the insoluble dietary fibers in date seeds were investigated owing to their potential to improve the techno-functional properties of meat products. The addition of fibers resulted in a considerable reduction in calorie content and an improvement in the texture and quality of meat. For instance, Abdel-Maksoud et al. (2022)143 studied the addition of date seed powder at different levels (0–16%) to beef meatballs, revealing improvements in nutritional, technological, and overall physicochemical characteristics without significant alterations to the sensory qualities of the beef meatballs. The phenolic and antioxidant potential of date seeds prevented the oxidation of native fat in meat to a certain extent. In conclusion, these studies collectively highlight the versatile applicability of date seeds and their co-products in improving and maintaining the quality and nutritional aspects of meat products.
Moving on to polyols, a class of sugar-free sweeteners containing multiple hydroxyl groups, they are employed in food products owing to their lower calorie content compared to sugars. Polyols from date pits were developed through an oxypropylation reaction of natural polymeric material found in date seeds via liquefaction using organic solvents and a catalyst.144 The oil extracted from leftover pits of the Khalas date variety was utilized as a substitute for traditional corn oil in mayonnaise (an emulsion of oil and egg yolk). The mayonnaise containing date pit oil exhibited better sensory qualities compared to commercial mayonnaise, supporting the notion of employing date pit oil as an unconventional choice for making mayonnaise products.145 In a study conducted by Alqahtani et al. (2023),146 date seed powder was explored as an innovative fat replacement and fiber source in processed cheese blocks. They used four different concentrations of date seed powder (5%, 10%, 15%, and 20%) to replace cheese fat, examining the impact on the cheese's chemical composition, microstructure, rheology, and sensory attributes. Partial substitution of butter with date seed fiber in block-type processed cheese positively affected the nutritive value but negatively impacted the texture profile. The fortified cheese exhibited a less compact and wider cheese network structure compared to the control. Cheese with 5% and 10% seed fibers showed overall acceptability.
Finally, the valorization of date by-products towards the development of functional yogurt was reported by Jrad et al. (2022).147 Roasted date seeds (1%, 2%, and 3%) were incorporated into goat and cow milk formulations to develop functional yogurt. Roasting improved the amount of soluble fiber as well as the water holding and swelling capacity of seeds, contributing to the better texture properties of the yogurt. The functional yogurts produced were rich in proteins and appeared dark with the addition of seed powder. Overall, 3% seed powder fortified yogurts from both sources were superior in terms of moisture, protein, viscosity, antioxidant, and water holding capacity.
Different parts of the date palm have been pharmacologically reported as therapeutic agents for various ailments and disorders, and date fruits have garnered considerable attention, whereas by-products are seldom reported.152 Meta-analytical phytochemical studies of date fruits across producing countries have indicated the abundance of essential bioactive compounds in date by-products, confirming their potential as ingredients for the development of nutraceutical, cosmetic, medical, pharmaceutical, and functional food products with a wide range of health benefits.153–155 Accumulated evidence from the literature indicates the presence of various health-promoting phytochemicals, such as polyphenols, lignin, melanin, tocopherols, anthocyanin, carotenes, tocotrienols, dietary fibers, and phytosterols, in date fruits.
Specifically, date fruits have long been proven and implicated in health and nutritional promotion owing to their richness in antioxidant-producing polyphenolic compounds that can work against oxidative stress and scavenge excess free radicals implicated in diseases such as cardiovascular, Parkinson's, cancer, and Alzheimer's diseases.15 Ethnobotanical studies have also established the treatment of anemia, colds, sore throats, hemorrhoids, bronchopulmonary infections, jaundice, constipation, and demineralization with date pulps and syrup, while green dates are used as natural aphrodisiacs.156 Additionally, the polyphenolic content of dates has been demonstrated to be an anticancer, antimutagenic, anti-inflammatory, and antimicrobial agent.65,157 Researchers have correlated a reduced risk of chronic diseases and high nutraceutical values with diets rich in dietary polyphenols.36,154
More recently, scientists have focused on the valorization of date by-products, specifically date seeds and pomaces, owing to the abundance of similar biomacromolecules found in whole fruits.148 The diverse polyphenols (tannins, sterols, phenolic acids, flavonoids, phytosterols, carotenoids, and volatile compounds) inherently present at high levels in dates and their by-products confirm their uniqueness from polyphenols in other fruits (such as apple, banana, red grapes, mandarin, orange, apricot, pomegranate, and blueberry).34,158 Although variations exist in the concentration, structure, formulation, and distribution of polyphenols in date fruits depending on the cultivar, season, location, maturity, agronomic practices, and storage conditions, date and its by-products are generally rich in polyphenolic compounds that confer health benefits by scavenging and blocking the activities of free radicals and ROS implicated in the etiology of chronic human degenerative diseases, such as cancer and cardiovascular diseases.148,151 In dates, phenolic acids and flavonoids are the major polyphenolic compounds; however, the presence of tannins has also been reported. Flavonoids and phenolic acids are important phyto-metabolites with remarkable antioxidant properties against ROS, promoting cellular protection against oxidative stress and damage, as well as positive health outcomes in humans.159,160
Researchers have meticulously documented more than 13 flavonoids and 19 flavonoid isomers in dates and their by-products, predominantly including isorhamnetin, luteolin, malonyl, apigenin, quercetin, chrysoeriol, 3-methyl-isorhamnetin, sulfates, and kaempferol, each exhibiting varying degrees of antioxidant properties.157,161 Polyphenolic compounds, particularly flavonoids, are widely distributed in date seeds. A quantitative estimation of the polyphenolic content in three Moroccan date seed cultivars revealed a range of 1224–1844 mg/100 g of flavonoids.130 Another study investigated the polyphenolic content of the Khalas date seed variety using mass spectrometry, reporting a total polyphenolic content of 5.1 g/100 g, significantly higher than those reported in grape seeds and flaxseeds.162
The abundance of flavonoids in date seeds was further documented by Habib et al. (2014),65 with flavan-3-ols accounting for 99% of the total polyphenol content in date seeds. However, hydroxycinnamic acids have been identified as the most abundant phenolic acids in dates and their by-products. A study conducted by Al-Farsi and Lee (2008)53 revealed the presence of four different hydroxycinnamic acids (vanillic acid, protocatechuic, p-hydroxybenzoic, and gallic) in date seeds, while Kchaou et al. (2016)163 reported the presence of hydroxybenzoic acid in date flesh, underscoring the richness of date by-products in phenolic acids.
Moreover, a comprehensive study on the characterization of flavonoids and phenolic acids in date palm fruits unveiled the presence of 5 flavonoids (myricetin, rutin, quercetin, catechin, and epicatechin) and 10 phenolic acids (chlorogenic, p-coumaric, salicylic, gallic, trans-cinnamic, sinapic, ellagic, vanillic, caffeic, syringic, and ferulic).164 Ajwa dates have been extensively studied owing to their richness and abundance of polyphenols, such as rutin, catechin, and caffeic acid, in the range of 10–290 mg/100 g depending on the fruit's maturity.55,165,166 Total phenolic content analysis conducted by Wu et al. (2004)167 revealed a range of 199.43–576.48 mg/100 g and 226–955 mg/100 g of fresh date in six Tunisian and ten Algerian date varieties, respectively.
Date polyphenolic compounds, in addition to their antioxidant properties, are known to exert various health benefits, including anticancer, anti-obesity, anti-inflammatory, antimicrobial, antiallergic, vasodilatory, cardioprotective, renoprotective, hepatoprotective, antigenotoxic, antimutagenic, and gastrointestinal protective effects.168,169 Pharmacological studies have also correlated the consumption of date fruits with a reduced glycemic index, antiaging effects, and relief from constipation.40
Despite the reported richness of date seeds and pomace in valuable bioactive components, such as polyphenols, they are still treated as common waste with limited applications and underutilization. Accumulated evidence from the literature indicates that the high antioxidant activities of date seeds (DS) are attributed to their richness in polyphenolic compounds.134,171 Thus, date by-products could be explored as a source of natural preservatives with potential applications in the pharmaceutical, medical, and food industries. Pharmacological, nutritional, and clinical evidence has positioned polyphenols as novel natural bioactive compounds, garnering attention from researchers for various health and industrial applications owing to their established antioxidant properties.163
Quantitatively, the polyphenolic content of DS was estimated to range from 1864.82 to 4768.87 mg GAE/100 g, while the profile analysis of the polyphenolic content revealed flavan-3-ols (catechins and epicatechins) as the most abundant polyphenols (47.91–50.18 g kg−1), closely followed by phenolic acids (protocatechuic acid, p-hydroxybenzoic acid, and caffeoylshikimic acid).172,173
Researchers have correlated the abundance of phenolic acids and flavonoids in date seeds and pomaces with the observed high antioxidant potentials reported in the literature.36,174 For instance, a study conducted in China on 28 fruits and their by-products ranked dates as the second-highest fruit with remarkable antioxidant values.175 In a study on seeds of three Moroccan date cultivars, the authors established a strong positive correlation between phenolic acids and flavonoid contents with high antioxidant properties evaluated with FRAP and ABTS.130
A similar study on 100 μg mL−1 of aqueous and methanolic extracts from date seeds was reported by Zhang et al. (2017).176 The results showed high antioxidant activities with 50–67% and 58–82%, respectively, for lipid peroxidation inhibition. The methanolic and acetonic extracts of Ajwa date seeds have been reported to exhibit a remarkable antioxidant potential of 74.19 mg per mL GA using DPPH and lipid peroxidation assays.177
Furthermore, an in vitro evaluation of flavonoids conducted by Nijveldt et al. (2001)178 found that flavonoids reduce dehydroascorbic acid. Similarly, polyphenols react with superoxide anion (O-2) and hydroxyl (OH–) radicals to generate highly stable phenoxy radicals. DPPH and ABTS studies of flavonols and hydroxycinnamic acids showed high antioxidant potency against linoleic acid oxidation compared to vitamin C.179,180
However, date pomace (DP) has also been reported to contain a considerable amount of polyphenols and can be used as a source of natural antioxidants.53 The effect of 100 μg of ethyl acetate extracts from Deglet Nour date flesh was evaluated by Mansouri et al. (2005).181 The author concluded that there is a strong positive correlation between phenolic content and antioxidant activities, evidenced by the observed 54% antiradical activity suggested to be influenced by the high quantity of flavonoids and tannins in the extract.
The quantification and antioxidant capacities of the DP of three different cultivars of dates were investigated with the oxygen radical absorbance capacity (ORAC) assay by Al-Farsi et al. (2007).79 The authors reported a remarkable quantity of polyphenols in the range of 165–435 mg of GAE/100 g of DP and antioxidant capacities in the range of 134–357 mol of Trolox Equivalents (TE) per g fresh weight of date pomace. Similarly, the half-maximal inhibitory concentration (IC50) technique was used by Majzoobi et al. (2020)182 to demonstrate the antioxidant potential of Shahani DP with four different particle sizes. The authors reported IC50 values of 1.46, 1.46, 1.39, and 1.39 mg mL−1 for 500, 365, 210, and 167 μm of Shahani DP, respectively.
In addition to numerous in vitro studies on the antioxidant properties of date by-product polyphenols, there are documented in vivo studies highlighting the health-promoting benefits of date seed polyphenols. One such study investigated the impact of date by-products on the activities of activated inflammatory leukocytes, which are known to elicit free radicals, exacerbating diseases, such as arthritis and diabetes.15 The effect of different concentrations of date seed consumption for 30 days on oxidative stress and antioxidant levels in male Wistar rats induced by activated inflammatory leukocytes was evaluated by Habib and Ibrahim (2011).183 Although the serological parameters, feed efficiency ratio, hepatic antioxidants, and body weight were unaffected by date seed incorporation, the authors reported a significant reduction in serum and hepatic malondialdehyde (MDA) and dehydrogenase. The decrease in these lipid peroxidation products has been attributed to the phenolic and flavonoid profiles in date seeds.
Another study conducted by Abdelaziz and Ali (2014)184 investigated the effect of date seed consumption on reducing nephron-oxidative stress in the kidneys of rats induced with carbon tetrachloride (CCl4). The authors reported that date seeds significantly reduced MDA and nitric oxide, restored glutathione-S-transferase and superoxide dismutase activities, and preserved kidney histology and functions, all of which are attributed to the polyphenolic contents. A robust antioxidant status, as indicated by a significant reduction in oxidative stress, was observed in the experimental rats fed with date seed-supplemented feed.162 Similarly, Platat et al. (2019)185 reported increased antioxidant activity in humans fed with date seed extract, date seed powder, and Arabic pita bread fortified with date seed.
Bioactive ingredients | By-product | Extraction method | Active ingredient | Yield | Functionality | Significant findings | Reference |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Polyphenols | Seeds | Methanolic | Phenolic acids | 44.2 mg GAE per g | In vitro antioxidant, reducing power and antiradical activities | Date seeds can be used as potential functional food ingredients owing to their high content of phenolics and antioxidant capacity | Majid et al. (2023)248 |
Polyphenols | Seeds | Natural deep eutectic solvent-microwave assisted extraction | Phenolic acids | 234.65 mg GAE per g | In vitro antioxidant activities | Utilization of green extraction solvents coupled with microwave-enhanced total phenolic yield and antioxidant properties | Airouyuwa et al. (2023)249 |
Polyphenols | Seeds | Natural deep eutectic solvent-ultrasonic assisted extraction | Phenolic acids | 145.54 mg GAE per g | In vitro antioxidant activities | A significantly higher amount of phenolic compounds with high antioxidant activities was observed | Osamede-Airouyuwa et al. (2022)250 |
Polyphenols | Seed | Methanolic–aqueous extraction | Phenolic acids | 14.12 g kg−1 | In vitro digestion | The extracted polyphenols are bio-accessible, reach the colon as observed after digestion and are relatively unchanged for gut microbiota metabolism | Hilary et al. (2020)251 |
Polyphenols | Seed | Ethanol–aqueous | Phenolics | 750 mg L−1 | In vitro anticancer, anti-hyperglycemic, antioxidant and anti-adipogenic activities | Significantly reduced viability in MCF-7 and Hep-G2 cells with 48 h treatments | Hilary et al. (2021)173 |
Glucose uptake increased in the adipocytes | |||||||
Inhibited adipocyte differentiation and lipid accumulation | |||||||
Functional ingredients in bread | Retained antioxidant activity in the digestive milieu | ||||||
Increased phenolic contents and antioxidant activities after digestion of bread | |||||||
Polyphenols | Seeds | Aqueous | Phenolic | 160.22 mg/100 g | In vitro antioxidant activities | Date seed is an inexpensive source of phenolic compounds that can be used for antioxidant activities | Al-Farsi and Lee (2008)53 |
Acetone (50%) | Flavonoid | 193.83 mg/100 g | |||||
Polyphenols | Seed | Supercritical fluid CO2 and subcritical CO2 extraction | Phenolic acids | 143.48–274.98 mg GAE/100 g | In vitro antioxidants | Innovative extraction of polyphenols from date seed improves their functional quality and antioxidant activities | Ghafoor et al. (2022)153 |
Flavonoids | 78.35–141.78 mg QE/100 g | Antiradical | |||||
Reducing power | |||||||
Polyphenols | Seed | Hydrothermal extraction | Phenolic acids | 1284.1 mg L−1 | Antiradical and oxygen radical absorbance capacity | Liquid fraction obtained after the application of a direct steam treatment at two temperatures allows the solubilization of a high quantity of phenolic compounds, making it possible to obtain an extract that is rich in phenols with high antioxidant activity | Mrabet et al. (2022)252 |
Flavonoids | |||||||
Polyphenols | Seeds | Dimethyl sulfoxide | 3541 mg/100 g | In vitro antioxidant activities | Iranian date seeds have significant antioxidant properties owing to their phenolic compounds; hence they could be sources of commercial and medicinal natural antioxidants | Shams Ardekani et al. (2010)64 | |
Aqueous | 1694 mg/100 g | ||||||
Methanolic | 3284 mg/100 g | ||||||
Formic acid | |||||||
Lignin | Seeds | Klason method with ethanol and benzene | 26.68% | Additive for low-density polyethylene for wastewater treatment membrane preparation | Numerous hydroxyl groups in the extracted lignin cause improvement of the membrane hydrophilicity | Zrelli et al. (2022)253 | |
Decreased contact angle | |||||||
Increased membrane porosity | |||||||
Polyphenols | Seeds | Ethanolic | 8.521% GAE | In vivo hepatoprotective activities | The ethanol extract of date seed at doses of 150, 300, and 600 mg kg−1 had hepatoprotective activity in carrageenan-induced rats | Warsinah et al. (2022)254 | |
Polyphenols | Seeds | 3102–4430 mg GAE/100 g | In vitro antioxidant activities | Antioxidant activities are proportional to phenolic extracts | Al-Farsi et al. (2007)79 | ||
Polyphenols | Pomace | 165–435 mg GAE/100 g | In vitro antioxidant activities | Antioxidant activities are proportional to phenolic content | Al-Farsi et al. (2007)79 | ||
Polyphenols | Seed | Methanolic extraction | Phenolic acids | 2.194 g kg−1 | Date seeds are a very rich source of polyphenols and can be considered candidates for functional food and nutraceuticals | Habib et al. (2014)65 | |
Flavonoids | |||||||
Polysaccharide | Seed | Aqueous and oxalate | 1.9% | Radical scavenging potential, inhibition of glycation end product formation | PS via aqueous extraction gave maximum polysaccharide yield with molecular weight 1680 kDa, which had enhanced capabilities in scavenging free radicals, inhibiting glycation end products formation, and inhibiting lipid peroxidation | (Marzouk et al., 2017)16 | |
Polysaccharide | Seed | Hot water | Water soluble PS | 1.5% | Antioxidant and radical scavenging potentials | Both extraction methods resulted in seed polysaccharides with excellent water solubility. Date seed PS takes the form of a heteropolysaccharide with excellent antioxidant and radical scavenging potentials | (Dhahri et al., 2023)207 |
Ultrasound assisted | 1.03% | ||||||
Polysaccharides | Seed | Ultrasound-assisted alkaline extraction | 72% | In vitro antioxidant and antibacterial activity | Xylose was identified as the most abundant monosaccharide of PS. Polysaccharides displayed superior antibacterial and proliferative effects | (Noorbakhsh et al., 2023)203 |
In the context of date fruit, PS constitutes the predominant bioactive component in both flesh and seeds, making up approximately 80% of their composition. Bendahou et al. (2007)200–202 have documented the extraction of polysaccharides from date palm and its parts. Date flesh is reported to have around 14% polysaccharide, characterized by (1→3)-β-D-glucopyranosyl residues branched saccharide residues at (1→6). Detailed characterization studies have revealed the presence of xylans, primary hemicellulose polymers in date seeds, consisting of β-1,4-linked D-xylose with side chains of L-arabinose, D-galactose, and acetyl groups.203 Libyan date seeds, as a possible valuable source of glucomannan (a neutral polysaccharide consisting of mannose, glucose, arabinose, and rhamnose) and arabinogalactan (an acidic polysaccharide of MW 48000 made of arabinose, galactose, rhamnose, and glucose), were reported by Ishurd et al. (2003).204 β-D Glucans present in date flesh were observed to have a linear structure composed of a combination of (1→3)- and (1→4)-linkages.205 The glucans in dates exist as two major fractions of different molecular masses: fraction I with Mtw 200000 and fraction II with Mtw 10000. These fractions exhibit variations owing to the inclusion of (1/6)-branched chains made up of D-glucose units, with the lowest molecular weight polysaccharide containing Glcp-(1/3)-D-Glcp groups and the highest molecular weight polysaccharide consisting of D-Glcp-(1/3)-D-Glcp units.206 Identification of an alkali-soluble heteroxylan from date seeds, composed of D-xylose and 4-O-methyl-D-glucuronic acid, was reported by Ishurd et al. (2003).204 The polysaccharide was reported to have the structure of an aldobiouronic acid from hemicellulose, which exists as a polymer of (1→4)-linked D-xylopranosyl residues with branched D-xylopyranosyl and 4-O-methyl-α-D-glucopyranosyluronic acid.
Water-soluble PSs were extracted from Ajwa date seeds by Dhahri et al. (2023),207 and the seed variety is known for its antioxidant, antimicrobial, anticancer, and antiviral properties. Two different extraction methods were employed to compare the yield of the extracted PS. Both hot water and ultrasound-assisted extractions resulted in seed polysaccharide yields of 1.5% and 1.03%, respectively, with excellent water solubility. Date seed PSs are structurally like heteropolysaccharides with excellent antioxidant and radical scavenging potentials. Noorbakhsh and Khorasgani (2023)203 employed ultrasound-assisted alkaline extraction of date seed polysaccharides from the Zahidi date variety. Xylose was identified as the most abundant monosaccharide from the extracted polysaccharide, contributing to approximately 72%. The polysaccharide displayed superior antibacterial and proliferative effects compared to standard PS and date flesh polysaccharides. Seed polysaccharides showed positive regulation of gut microbiota because of their prebiotic potential, influenced by their monosaccharide composition, molecular weight, and extraction method.197In vitro digestion studies of date seed PS confirmed their prebiotic potential, as the polysaccharide was stable in the upper digestive tract and later reached the colon to be metabolized by the gut microflora. Intervention and blood biomarker analysis of the polysaccharide indicate its efficiency in reducing serum C-reactive protein (reducing inflammation by supporting the growth of beneficial gut microflora), reducing triglycerides, fasting blood sugar (hypoglycemic effect), and increasing red blood cells (antioxidative effect of the polysaccharide). Marzouk et al. (2017)16 employed aqueous and oxalate extraction of date seeds to yield PS, out of which the former method yielded the maximum, i.e., 1.9% polysaccharide with a molecular weight of 1680 kDa. Water-extracted PS exhibited enhanced capabilities in scavenging free radicals, inhibiting glycation end product formation, and inhibiting lipid peroxidation and protein glycation.
Green extraction of melanin is quite challenging because of the localized presence of melanin in melanosomes where they are found closely bound to the inner cell wall or the cellular components.215 Elobeid et al. (2017)209 posited that the enzyme tyrosinase facilitates the synthesis of melanin via enzymatic action on the amino acid tyrosine. Initially, tyrosine undergoes hydroxylation and is converted to catecholamine 3,4-dihydroxyphenylalanine, which is subsequently oxidized to 3,4-dioxyphenylalanine or dopaquinone. In later stages, dopaquinone is cyclized to form 5,6-indole quinones, the polymerization of which leads to the formation of melanin. An elevated concentration of melanin pigments was observed in the date fruits. In date fruits, Al-Amrani et al. (2020)216 identified that the onset of enzymatic browning is triggered by the activity of the enzyme polyphenol oxidase, which interacts with phenolic compounds in the presence of oxygen, leading to a brown compound, O-quinones. O-Quinones undergo a nonenzymatic polymerization process, resulting in the formation of diverse dark polymers referred to as melanin. In date fruits, approximately 0.0859% of melanin is extracted via chemical treatment using sodium hydroxide.
The brown coloration of melanin in date fruits remains consistent, even in dark varieties such as Ajwa and Safawi, indicating a possible coexistence of melanin and proanthocyanidins in these fruits. Additionally, condensed tannins polymerized with epicatechin have been reported in Tunisian Deglet Nour date varieties.214 Interestingly, Huang et al. (2020)217 reported results about date seed extracts. Unlike date fruits that contained melanin, the seed extracts prevented melanogenesis because of their capability to scavenge reactive oxygen species. Seed extract prevented the inhibitions of the melanocortin 1 receptor, associated transcription factor, tyrosinase, and related protein 1, thereby preventing the onset of melanogenesis in treated cells. This, however, has not been implemented in food systems because it requires extensive clinical trials.
Importantly, among the insoluble DF, lignin has antioxidant properties. Lignin is a complex phytocompound existing between cellulose and hemicellulose, which is widely distributed in the date flesh and synthesized from about 40 monomers, mainly oxygenated phenyl propane (coniferyl, sinapyl, and p-coumaryl alcohols).92,225 Lignin is the second most abundant phytometabolite after cellulose with the potential to produce valuable bioactive compounds,226,227 making lignin an important natural compound with various applications in energy, food, pharmaceuticals, cosmetics, and materials development industries.228
Analytical studies by Hamada et al. (2002)61 revealed that date seeds contain about 65–69% neutral detergent fiber (mannose, rhamnose, glucose, and arabinose), which positively correlates with the presence of a remarkable quantity of lignin.155 A comparative study on different varieties of Tunisian dates also confirmed a range of 19.6–25.4% of lignin present in the date seeds.222 Unlike polyphenols and other bioactive compounds, research into the lignin component and the application of date by-products is still novel and emerging, requiring much attention from the scientific community. Further studies are needed to explore the valorization of this important bioactive compound.
To comprehend the intricate biochemical changes occurring in the food matrix upon the addition of date by-products as functional ingredients, further investigations employing suitable animal models need to be conducted. Additionally, there is a noteworthy research gap concerning the extraction of polysaccharides and melanin from date pomace. Despite the available data, limited in vitro and in vivo exploration of these bioactive-rich components in terms of their health-promoting potential exists, which is crucial for the commercialization of value-added products derived from them.
The strategic utilization of biological wastes like date seeds and pomace, for the extraction of bioactive compounds aligns with sustainable production and utilization practices, fostering the principles of a circular economy. The bioactive components of both seeds and pomace hold significant potential for applications in the food industry. This review asserts that the industrial wealth, particularly seeds and pomace from date processing industries, offers a promising alternative to artificial sources relied upon for the same purpose. Not only does it circumvent potential health and safety hazards associated with artificial additives, but it also helps mitigate the risk of various diseases.
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2024 |