Radha
Raman
abcd,
Jeyavelan
Muthu
bde,
Zhi-Long
Yen
bcf,
Mohammad
Qorbani
gh,
Yu-Xiang
Chen
bcf,
Ding-Rui
Chen
bcf,
Mario
Hofmann
*d and
Ya-Ping
Hsieh
*b
aDepartment of Physics, National Central University, Taoyuan 32001, Taiwan
bInstitute of Atomic and Molecular Sciences, Academia Sinica, Taipei 10617, Taiwan. E-mail: yphsieh@gate.sinica.edu.tw
cMolecular Science and Technology Program, Taiwan International Graduate Program, Academia Sinica, Taipei 10617, Taiwan
dDepartment of Physics, National Taiwan University, Taipei 10617, Taiwan
eNanoscience and Technology Program, Taiwan International Graduate Program, Academia Sinica, Taipei 115, Taiwan. E-mail: mario@phys.ntu.edu.tw
fInternational Graduate Program of Molecular Science and Technology, National Taiwan University, Taipei, 10617, Taiwan
gCenter for Condensed Matter Sciences, National Taiwan University, Taipei 10617, Taiwan
hCenter of Atomic Initiative for New Materials, National Taiwan University, Taipei 10617, Taiwan
First published on 4th March 2024
Molybdenum disulfide (MoS2) has emerged as a promising material for catalysis and sustainable energy conversion. However, the inertness of its basal plane to electrochemical reactions poses challenges to the utilization of wafer-scale MoS2 in electrocatalysis. To overcome this limitation, we present a technique that enhances the catalytic activity of continuous MoS2 by preferentially activating its buried grain boundaries (GBs). Through mild UV irradiation, a significant enhancement in GB activity was observed that approaches the values for MoS2 edges, as confirmed by a site-selective photo-deposition technique and micro-electrochemical hydrogen evolution reaction (HER) measurements. Combined spectroscopic characterization and ab-initio simulation demonstrates substitutional oxygen functionalization at the grain boundaries to be the origin of this selective catalytic enhancement by an order of magnitude. Our approach not only improves the density of active sites in MoS2 catalytic processes but yields a new photocatalytic conversion process. By exploiting the difference in electronic structure between activated GBs and the basal plane, homo-compositional junctions were realized that improve the photocatalytic synthesis of hydrogen by 47% and achieve performances beyond the capabilities of other catalytic sites.
New conceptsThe exceptional characteristics of two-dimensional (2D) materials, particularly MoS2, make them highly suitable for photocatalysis. The primary challenge in harnessing the full potential of MoS2 lies in its low intrinsic catalytic activity. Traditional methods have attempted to alter the morphology of MoS2 by introducing defects or edges. Unfortunately, these approaches reduce the exciton separation efficiency and limit the photocatalytic efficiency. Our study introduces a novel approach that relies on activating the existing defects in MoS2, particularly the grain boundaries. Conventional grain boundaries show a turnover frequency 75 times lower than that of edge sites. We have developed a technique that significantly enhances their activity to levels comparable with MoS2 edges, as confirmed through detailed site-resolved photoreduction experiments and selective microelectrochemical measurements. Additionally, our research includes site-selective characterization using local electrochemical measurements of overpotential and Tafel slope, which yielded results analogous to photoreduction analysis, thus demonstrating the utility of this simpler method. This approach not only enhances the catalytic performance of MoS2 but also provides an exciting route toward tailoring 2D materials for future photocatalysts, with our findings showing a substantial increase in photocatalytic efficiency. |
Unfortunately, the active sites in MoS2 are mainly localized at the edges and its basal plane is two orders less efficient.6–8 To enhance the overall efficiency of MoS2, researchers have increased the edge concentration by enhancing the porosity of MoS29,10 but at the cost of increased process complexity and decreased efficiency of photo-excited carrier transport.11 To take advantage of the large relative concentration of basal plane sites compared to edges, significant ongoing research efforts are dedicated toward developing innovative strategies to activate the MoS2 basal plane. These strategies include surface modifications, defect engineering through functionalization,12 and hybridization with other materials.13–16 While the introduction of defects is a practical route towards higher catalytic activity, the increased defect density introduces non-radiative recombination pathways and affects the exciton separation leading to a decreased photocatalytic efficiency.17
We here enhance the electrochemical performance of MoS2 through activation of its grain boundaries. Grain boundaries are an important feature of 2D materials that occur due to parallel nucleation during chemical vapor deposition (CVD) growth or polycrystallinity of the bulk precursors for exfoliation.18 These extended one-dimensional structures are embedded within the basal plane but possess distinct electronic properties.19–22 Activation of grain boundaries in MoS2 could offer abundant active sites while not impeding charge separation thereby improving photocatalytic activity.
To date, however, grain boundaries have not received significant attention as photocatalytically active structures. High-resolution electrochemical microscopy by Lunardon et al. observed a limited activity of grain boundaries.23 Moreover, Takahashi et al. found that the activity was inhomogeneous along the grain boundaries.24 Finally, He et al. demonstrated that intrinsic grain boundaries are inferior in HER performance compared to morphology-controlled nanograin edges.25
In this study, a novel route for enhancing the catalytic performance of grain boundaries is presented. By utilizing a UV-assisted activation process, these features showed a selective enhancement in electrocatalytic properties, as revealed by photoreduction experiments and location-resolved electrochemical measurements. Spectroscopic characterization reveals changes to the composition as the origin of this behavior and its limitation to grain boundaries. This novel mechanism was exploited to produce lateral homojunction in MoS2 that enhances its photocatalytic HER performance beyond the activity of MoS2 edges, which had been considered the optimal morphology. Our study reveals the role of grain boundaries in catalytic processes and provides a promising route toward the development of efficient 2D materials-based photocatalytic systems.
Upon closer inspection, it can be seen that many flakes do not consist of a single triangular crystal but are composed of several triangular regions (Fig. 1(a and b)). As identified previously, such arrangements represent joint polycrystalline structures that not only exhibit edges but also grain boundaries.29 Careful characterization of the deposition density suggests a ∼75-fold lower decoration density on grain boundaries compared to that of edges (see ESI† for more details). This quantification agrees with previous reports that found two orders of magnitude lower activity of grain boundaries compared to edges.8,25
Our results demonstrate the limitations of the electrochemical activity of 2D MoS2 films: as the grain density increases, the number of active edge sites increases and so does the electrochemical activity. However, upon reaching a critical density, merging of individual crystalline flakes occurs and their edges turn into grain boundaries, which exhibit a significantly lower turn-over-frequency. This behavior is captured in numerical simulations shown in Fig. 1(g). Grain growth from randomly distributed nucleation seeds was simulated and the total turn-over-frequency of the area was calculated. As expected, an initial increase in activity was observed when the edge concentration is increased. However, a transition to boundary-controlled activity can be seen at higher coverage that decreases the overall activity despite an increase in MoS2 coverage (see ESI† for more details).
Our simulations not only demonstrate the current limitations in 2D materials-based electrocatalysis but also provide a route to overcoming them: if the grain boundary activity could be increased, a significant enhancement in overall activity could be achieved.
To enhance the grain boundary activity, we utilized fast adsorption of UV-generated oxygen. For this purpose, the MoS2 sample was exposed to UV-generated ozone for 2 minutes (see method section for more details). Following this treatment, the experiment involving Au deposition was carried out in a dark environment, and no observable deposits were noted within a 60-second timeframe (Fig. 2(a)). Subsequently, the photoreduction experiments were conducted and we observed a significant increase in gold decoration (Fig. 2(b)). Compared to the un-activated condition, activation not only enhances the amount of deposition at the grain boundaries but also decorates all grain boundaries within the structure. This result demonstrates the potential of grain boundary activation to overcome the previously observed issue of inhomogeneous grain boundary activity.24
To quantify the observed enhancement of the grain boundary's catalytic activity, we conducted spatially selective electrochemical characterization of hydrogen evolution reaction (HER). For this purpose, we lithographically produced openings with dimensions of 20 μm × 15 μm, allowing us to target and analyze the catalytic activity of different regions on MoS2 (Fig. 2(c)). (more details on the electrochemical reactor and fabrication are in the methods section)
Linear sweep voltammetry measurements were conducted on samples that selectively exposed MoS2 edges, grain boundaries, or the basal plane as shown in Fig. 2(d). We observed distinct differences in the HER activities of those regions. The pristine MoS2 basal plane exhibited poor HER activity, attributed to its perfect crystal structure that results in a limited number of active sites, consistent with previous experimental findings.30 In contrast, the MoS2 edges displayed enhanced HER activities as evidenced by a ∼3-fold lowered overpotential and a ∼7-fold decreased Tafel slope (Fig. 2(d)) (see ESI† section S3 for corresponding Tafel plots). These results confirm the superior catalytic activity of the edges in as-grown MoS2. Notably, the as-grown MoS2 grain boundaries exhibit an overpotential that is comparable to the basal plane and a Tafel slope that is intermediate between the basal plane and edges. This observed trend is consistent with the photodeposition results, where enhanced deposition of Au was observed at the edges, followed by the grain boundaries, while minimal deposition occurred on the basal plane. A quantitative agreement between deposition density of Au clusters and electrochemical activity of each catalytic site was observed that follows previous report8 (see ESI† section S1 for more details)
Upon UV activation, MoS2 electrochemical activity shows significant changes (Fig. 2(e)): We find that the polarization curve for the basal-plane remains unchanged, which indicates that the short exposure and low reactivity of UV ozone are insufficient to generate active sites in the inert crystal. Surprisingly, the MoS2 edge shows an increased overpotential and Tafel slope which can be understood by the reported detrimental effect of oxygen adsorption on HER performance of MoS2 edges.31 This poisoning effect limits the performance of electrocatalysts under realistic conditions.32
Grain boundaries, on the other hand, do not exhibit such a deactivation and we extract a two-fold decrease in overpotential and a two-fold decrease in Tafel slope compared to the pristine values. These parameters rival the performance of pristine edges and validate our envisioned MoS2 catalytic enhancement. The observed enhancement of the reaction current indicates that thus-activated MoS2 can yield reaction efficiencies that are comparable to commercial Pt catalysts.6,33
The observed enhancement is confirmed by electrochemical impedance spectroscopy (EIS) measurements (inset Fig. 2(d) and (e)). The heterogeneous charge transfer resistance of boundaries is found to be decreased by 67% and reaches similar values to that of pristine edges.
To examine the activation mechanism that leads to the observed enhanced catalytic performance of grain boundaries we conduct Raman spectroscopy. Raman spectrum shows characteristic peaks corresponding to the A1g mode at ∼404 cm−1 and the E12g mode at ∼384 cm−1 as expected for MoS2 (Fig. 3(a)). The difference in these peak positions is Δω of ∼20 cm−1 and depends on the introduction of in-plane strain, brought about by changes in thickness,34,35 compositional changes,36,37 or charge transfer-induced stiffening of the bonds.38,39
The spatially resolved Raman map demonstrates differences in Δω between the edge and basal plane that indicate the presence of dangling bonds.40 (Fig. 3(b)). Moreover, the occurrence of multilayers can be distinguished from the Raman maps. However, no difference between the basal plane and the expected grain boundary location is observed.
After a 2-minute UV treatment, a significant decrease in Δω at the grain boundary can be observed (Fig. 3(c)) and the value is comparable to the edge region. This behavior suggests that UV exposure modifies the grain boundaries and introduces compositional changes or doping. Finally, longer oxygen adsorption durations upshift the Δω of both grain boundary and edges. (see ESI† section S4 for more details)
X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy (XPS) was conducted to provide details about the modification that grain boundaries undergo during activation. High-resolution spectra of the Mo 3d region were acquired that exhibit characteristic peaks at binding energies of 230.08 and 233.23 eV, corresponding to the Mo4+ 3d5/2 and Mo4+ 3d3/2 spin–orbit split components, respectively. (Fig. 3(d)) Upon 2 minutes of UV treatment, the spectra reveal the emergence of distinctive doublets at higher binding energies, indicative of the presence of Mo6+ species associated with MoO3 formation. After 5 minutes of adsorption, the intensity of the Mo6+ doublet further increases, suggesting a significant conversion of the surface to MoO3. Concurrently, the S 2p region displays peak broadening, indicating a change in chemical order and the formation of MoS2−xOx (Fig. 3(e)). This behavior confirms the selective reaction of grain boundaries with UV at mild activation conditions.29,41 The reaction of UV-generated ozone initially produces covalently bonded sulfur and oxygen structures at the boundary and subsequent loss of S resulting in an oxygen-saturated vacancy18,42,43
To understand the impact of the observed oxidative GB functionalization on the catalytic performance of MoS2, we conduct simulations using density functional theory (DFT). The Gibbs free energy of hydrogen adsorption (ΔGH) was investigated due to its significance in establishing the HER efficiency.44 We calculated the ΔGH for three systems – the MoS2 basal plane, a MoS2 edge and three stable grain boundary types (Mo-4|8, S-8|8 and S-4|8) (Fig. 4(a)) (ESI† info for more details about calculation).45
Fig. 4 Gibbs free energy calculations for hydrogen adsorption: (a) depiction of hydrogen adsorption in configurations representing the basal plane, 3 different types of grain boundaries and MoS2 edge, (b) calculated Gibbs free energy ΔGH for hydrogen adsorption at various sites, examined under different conditions: pristine (section I), oxygen-adsorbed (section II) and oxygen-substituted (section III) (more details in the ESI†); the inset shows the oxygen adsorption and substitution site for the S-8|8 system (c) comparison of the density of states between pristine MoS2 and the system with an introduced grain boundary. |
The results of these simulations are shown in Fig. 4(b) and we observe a value of 2.03 eV for ΔGH of the basal plane which indicates a weak bonding of hydrogen that limits the adsorption efficiency and consequently lowers the HER.46 Conversely, the MoS2 edge exhibits a superior catalytic performance due to ΔGH being closer to zero. Regardless of type, all MoS2 grain boundaries are found to exhibit a lower HER efficiency than the MoS2 edge which agrees with our experimental findings.
Subsequently, oxygen was introduced in a chemisorbed configuration. For this purpose, oxygen was positioned close to a sulfur site and relaxed (details in the ESI,† Fig. S6, ESI†). We observe that this step increases the activity of all systems which is ascribed to charge transfer that enhances the adsorption of protons from the acidic electrolyte.47
Finally, to reproduce the electron spectroscopic results of activated GBs, oxygen was introduced substitutionally in sulfur vacancies on all three systems. We observe that this modification indeed lowers the ΔGH for GBs by up to 12 times compared to the pristine case. This effect is much larger for grain boundaries than for edges or the basal plane and can explain the observed selective activation of grain boundaries. This selectivity can be understood when comparing the density of states for MoS2 BP and GB system (Fig. 4(c)). A higher density of states close to the Fermi level indicates the potential of GBs for enhanced electrochemical interactions.48
One promising application of MoS2 is in the direct conversion of sunlight to green hydrogen.49 To identify the potential of our grain-boundary activation scheme for this purpose, we conduct photoluminescence (PL) spectroscopy. Upon oxygen adsorption, grain boundaries exhibit a decreased photoluminescence yield (Fig. 5(a)). This decrease in yield is found to be due to the enhanced concentration of trions at the grain boundary compared to the basal plane and indicates the accumulation of charge carriers (inset Fig. 5(a)).
Fig. 5 Photo-electrocatalytic performance of GB activated MoS2: (a) trion/exciton ratio at different sites of MoS2 flakes indicating GBs having high accumulation of charges, (inset) representative PL spectra of MoS2 with decomposition into exciton and trion peaks (b) KPFM surface potential map of activated MoS2 flake indicating a substantial potential dip at GB (c) corresponding cross-sectional plot for pristine and activated GB region (more details in ESI†), (d) photo-electrochemical performance of UV activated MoS2 indicating the improved contribution of GBs under light condition. |
This accumulation was characterized by Kelvin probe force microscopy (KPFM) which provides a map of the contact potential difference (CPD) (Fig. 5(b)). We observe that the pristine grain boundary does not exhibit a significant difference in CPD compared to the basal plane. After 2 minutes of oxygen adsorption, however, the surface potential map revealed a noteworthy potential dip at the grain boundaries, signifying a change in the electronic structure at these regions. Under light illumination, the photons are absorbed by the MoS2 and excited electron–hole pairs are separated under the build-in electric field at the grain boundary. (Fig. 5(c))
The observed selective control over the grain boundary potential represents a promising approach for producing lateral homojunction in the MoS2. Previous work has demonstrated the attractiveness of such structures for enhancing a 2D material's photocatalytic properties as it enhances exciton separation and carrier lifetime.50,51
To confirm the prospect of grain-boundary-based homojunction, we characterize the photo-electrocatalytic performance of different MoS2 features. For this purpose, the Tafel slope was extracted for grain-boundary activated MoS2 regions under dark conditions and white light illumination (more details are provided in the methods section). While the basal plane and edges exhibit a slight change in Tafel slope under illumination, the creation of a homojunction around the grain boundary leads to a notable 47% reduction in the Tafel slope (Fig. 5(d)). This performance is superior even to the photocatalytic efficiency of MoS2 edges and demonstrates the potential of our activation approach.
To initiate the growth process, a solution of NaCl + NaOH was spin-coated onto the SiO2/Si substrate and dried for 5 minutes at 90 °C. The SiO2/Si substrate was then placed facedown onto a holey graphite spacer on the MoO3/graphite structure to form a sandwich structure.
The growth process was conducted in a three-stage heating process, where the temperature was increased from room temperature to 700 °C in 20 minutes, and then from 700 °C to 900 °C in 10 minutes. The growth temperature was maintained at 900 °C for 10 minutes, and diluted hydrogen sulfide (99% diluted in Ar) continuously flowed into the reactor at atmospheric pressure during the growth period.
The growth temperature was then reduced to 830 °C in 20 minutes, and the H2S flow was turned off. The furnace was allowed to cool naturally to room temperature.
The KPFM setup used a dual-pass approach, where the first pass recorded the topography profile using tapping mode. In the second line scan, an alternating current (AC) voltage of 500 mV amplitude was applied to the AFM tip while maintaining an optimized lift height of 25nm above the topographical baseline, facilitating the mapping of the surface potential.
The measured CPD represents the contact potential difference between the sample and the tip and is expressed by the following equation:
CPD = (ϕsample – ϕtip)/q |
To create a micro-reactor, another lithography step was performed, exposing windows of 15 μm × 20 μm on the target regions (Edge, Basal plane, and GBs), followed by development and cleaning. Finally, the devices were baked at 200 °C for 10 min to ensure no leakage under the protection layer.
All potential values were converted to reversible hydrogen electrode potentials using the relation E (vs. RHE) = E (vs. Ag/AgCl) + 0.197 V + V (quasi) + 0.0591, and the data were corrected by taking into account the potential drop on the materials and electrolyte. This comprehensive testing protocol allowed for a thorough evaluation of the photocatalytic performance of MoS2 flakes in different regions and under varying conditions, providing valuable insights for the development and optimization of advanced photocatalytic systems.
The vacuum along c-axis was set to 20 Å above the MoS2 plane to avoid any periodic interaction. The in-plane separation between the longitudinal edges across the periodic boundary is set to be greater than the 20 Å to the avoid the any artificial effect arising from the edge–edge interaction.
For the geometry optimization and total energy calculation, we adopted the linear combination of atomic orbitals (LCAO) formalism with localized orbitals. A density-mesh cutoff of 75 Hartree was utilized to ensure precise results. Geometry optimizations were carried out using the QuantumATK-optimized Medium basis set.
We employed a Monkhorst–Pack (MP) grid with dimensions of 1 × 3 × 1 Γ-centered for all our simulations. Additionally, for computing the density of states (DOS), a 1 × 5 × 1 MP grid was selected.
To ensure convergence during structural relaxation, we set a criterion for the residual force on each atom at 0.02eV Å−1. Geometries were systematically relaxed to minimize the total energy of the system until a precision of 10−4 eV was achieved.
Footnote |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available. See DOI: https://doi.org/10.1039/d4nh00005f |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2024 |