Fa-Dong
Wang
,
Kai-Kai
Niu
,
Shengsheng
Yu
,
Hui
Liu
and
Ling-Bao
Xing
*
School of Chemistry and Chemical Engineering, Shandong University of Technology, Zibo 255000, P. R. China. E-mail: lbxing@sdut.edu.cn
First published on 3rd October 2024
Enhancing the photocatalytic efficiency of organic photocatalysts and increasing the generation capacity of reactive oxygen species (ROS) have consistently been substantial obstacles. In this study, we designed and synthesized a supramolecular dimer based on anthraquinone (Amvp-CB[8]) between the methylated vinylpyridinium substituted anthraquinone derivative (Amvp) and cucurbit[8]uril (CB[8]) through host–guest interactions in the aqueous solution. Compared to the monomer Amvp, the supramolecular dimer Amvp-CB[8] exhibited significantly enhanced fluorescence and demonstrated remarkable capabilities in generating singlet oxygen (1O2) and superoxide anion radicals (O2˙−) in water. Importantly, Amvp-CB[8] displayed superior photocatalytic activity under visible light, facilitating efficient photoredox thiol–ene cross-coupling reactions between phenthiol and styrene, which selectively enabled rapid synthesis of sulfides within 0.5 h and sulfoxides within 12 h, showcasing high efficiency, low catalyst loading, and excellent functional group tolerance. This study introduces a novel supramolecular dimer strategy that enhances the design of efficient photocatalysts for organic conversions in photocatalysis.
Anthraquinone is a highly adaptable chemical molecule that has garnered significant interest in the realm of photocatalysis, which possesses a distinct molecular arrangement consisting of a fused aromatic ring and a carbonyl group.35–45 This arrangement allows it to efficiently absorb light across a wide range of wavelengths, particularly in the ultraviolet and visible areas. Anthraquinone, functioning as a photocatalyst, possesses notable photochemical characteristics such as exceptional photostability and prolonged excited states, which plays a vital role in the catalytic process.46,47 Extensive research has been conducted on this topic for a range of purposes, including organic synthesis, pollutant degradation, and solar energy conversion.48–50 Anthraquinone's capacity for photoinduced electron transfer processes renders it a very promising contender for the advancement of sustainable and eco-friendly photocatalytic devices. So far, photocatalytic systems utilizing anthraquinone have only been transformed into photocatalysts using a single anthraquinone molecule. The non-covalent interaction between anthraquinone molecules is crucial for creating a stronger supramolecular photocatalyst.
Anthraquinone is a very interesting building ingredient in supramolecular motifs because of its ability to trigger catalytic activities when exposed to light. Furthermore, the utilization of anthraquinone-based supramolecular dimers in conjunction with photocatalysis offers a collaborative method to tackle urgent social and environmental issues. In this study, we synthesized a supramolecular dimer (Amvp-CB[8]) by mixing a methylated vinylpyridine salt substituted anthraquinone derivative (Amvp) with cucurbit[8]uril (CB[8]) in an aqueous solution. The self-assembled dimers exhibit a substantial increase in fluorescence emission compared to the monomer, as well as a significant enhancement in their capacity to produce singlet oxygen (1O2) and superoxide anion radicals (O2˙−) in the aqueous solution. The supramolecular dimer Amvp-CB[8] demonstrates excellent efficacy and favorable tolerance towards functional groups as a photocatalyst for photoredox thiol–ene cross-coupling reactions involving phenthiol and styrene. This enables the selective and rapid synthesis of sulfides within 0.5 h and sulfoxides within 12 h. These results highlight the significant potential of supramolecular dimers in the field of photocatalysis (Scheme 1).
Scheme 1 Illustration of the construction of supramolecular dimer by the assembly of Amvp and CB[8] for the photoredox thiol–ene cross-coupling reaction. |
Furthermore, the self-assembly properties of Amvp-CB[8] were comprehensively explored using zeta potential and dynamic light scattering (DLS). Initially, the particle size of Amvp alone was determined to be approximately 164 nm (Fig. S6†). Upon addition of CB[8] to the Amvp solution, the average particle size increased to about 255 nm (Fig. 1c), indicating the formation of supramolecular dimers via host–guest interactions. Zeta potential measurements conducted in the aqueous solution revealed that Amvp exhibited a relative zeta potential of +23.9 mV. However, upon addition of 0.5 equiv. of CB[8], the zeta potential of Amvp-CB[8] decreased to +9.9 mV (Fig. 1d). This decrease can be attributed to the shielding effect of CB[8] in the host–guest interaction between Amvp and CB[8], altering the surface charge characteristics of the supramolecular assembly. To further probe the interaction between Amvp and CB[8], 1H NMR experiments were performed (Fig. 1e). Upon addition of 0.5 equiv. of CB[8] in D2O, the proton chemical signals corresponding to Amvp exhibited significant broadening in the low field region, while the signals from the methylated vinylpyridine unit were nearly completely shielded. These observations provide direct evidence that Amvp and CB[8] indeed form supramolecular dimers through robust host–guest interactions, laying a solid foundation for their application as efficient photocatalysts in organic transformations under visible light.
Anthraquinone and its derivatives have long been recognized for their efficacy in generating reactive oxygen species (ROS), making them pivotal in photocatalytic applications. In our investigation into the applications of supramolecular dimers, we explored Amvp-CB[8] as a potential photocatalyst. Initially, we employed 2,7-dichlorodihydrofluorescein diacetate (DCFH-DA) as a fluorescent probe to monitor ROS generation by using fluorescence emission spectroscopy. Fig. S7† illustrates a distinct fluorescence emission peak at 525 nm upon irradiation with purple light following the addition of both Amvp and Amvp-CB[8]. However, the enhancement in fluorescence emission at 525 nm was markedly more pronounced with the supramolecular dimer Amvp-CB[8] than with the monomer Amvp, underscoring the significant enhancement in ROS production capacity facilitated by supramolecular dimerization. Next, we utilized 9,10-anthracenediylbis(methylene)dimalonic acid (ABDA) as a probe to assess singlet oxygen (1O2) generation by both Amvp and Amvp-CB[8]. Fig. S8† demonstrates a reduction in ABDA absorption intensity upon addition of Amvp under continuous purple light irradiation, indicating effective 1O2 generation by Amvp. Similarly, Fig. S9† shows sustained reduction in absorption intensity with Amvp-CB[8] addition, highlighting its enhanced 1O2 generation capacity compared to Amvp. To quantify the 1O2 generation capability, we compared the 1O2 quantum yields using Rose Bengal (RB) as a reference photosensitizer. Amvp-CB[8] exhibited a significantly higher quantum yield (94%) compared to Amvp (48%) (Fig. S10†), confirming the superior 1O2 production capability of the anthraquinone supramolecular dimer. Furthermore, we evaluated the superoxide anion radical (O2˙−) generation ability using tetramethyl-phenylenediamine (TMPD) as a probe. Fig. 2b shows characteristic absorption peaks at 563 nm and 612 nm in solutions containing both Amvp and Amvp-CB[8], confirming their respective O2˙− generation capabilities. Notably, Amvp-CB[8] demonstrated enhanced O2˙− generation compared to Amvp. To validate the production of active species, electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR) studies were conducted by introducing scavengers such as 2,2,6,6-tetramethylpiperidine (TEMP) or 5,5-dimethyl-1-pyrroline-N-oxide (DMPO) into Amvp-CB[8] solutions. Without irradiation, no ROS signals were detected. However, under purple light irradiation, signals corresponding to both 1O2 and O2˙− were observed (Fig. 2c and d), conclusively confirming the robust ROS generation capability of Amvp-CB[8].
Based on these promising discoveries, we conducted detailed studies to explore the potential application of the supramolecular dimer Amvp-CB[8] as a photocatalyst for photoredox thiol–ene cross-coupling reactions between phenthiol and styrene. These experiments were conducted under ambient conditions for 0.5 h using purple light as the excitation source (Fig. S11†). As shown in Table 1, we observed a remarkable 91% yield of product 3a when employing the 0.5 mol% Amvp-CB[8] system (Table 1, entry 1), indicating that the supramolecular dimer exerts a significant promotional effect on the coupling of 4-methylbenzenethiol and styrene. In contrast, the yield was negligible when using only CB[8] as the photocatalyst (Table 1, entry 2), and modest at 36% with Amvp alone as the catalyst (Table 1, entry 3). Furthermore, reducing the concentration of Amvp-CB[8] to 0.25 mol% resulted in a decreased catalytic yield to 64% (entry 4). Conversely, increasing the concentration to 1 mol% did not significantly enhance the yield, which only rose to 93% (entry 5). When there is no photocatalyst, the reaction hardly occurs (entry 6). Adjusting the reaction time showed a notable decrease in product yield by 57% (entry 7), while extending the time had no significant impact on the yield (entry 8). We also introduced the electron donor DIPEA to investigate the role of O2˙− in the reaction, but the catalytic yield dropped to 20% after the addition of DIPEA (entry 9), which can be attributed to the competitive relationship between DIPEA and the substrate. Notably, the catalysts maintained good activity in the 400–410 nm wavelength range, emphasizing their potential for green and sustainable applications (entry 10). Finally, critical control experiments revealed that the Amvp-CB[8] system failed to proceed in the absence of light and air, underscoring the essential roles of light and oxygen in facilitating the effective function of this catalytic mechanism (entries 11 and 12).
Entry | Variation from standard conditions | Yieldb (%) |
---|---|---|
a Reaction conditions: 1a (0.2 mmol, 20.8 mg), 2a (0.3 mmol, 37.2 mg), Amvp-CB[8] as photocatalyst, purple light (395 nm), room temperature (rt). b Isolated yield. | ||
1 | None | 91 |
2 | CB[8] | No reaction |
3 | Amvp | 36 |
4 | 0.25 mol% Amvp-CB[8] | 64 |
5 | 1 mol% Amvp-CB[8] | 93 |
6 | No Amvp-CB[8] | Trace |
7 | 0.2 h | 57 |
8 | 1 h | 94 |
9 | DIPEA | 20 |
10 | 400 nm–410 nm | 74 |
11 | N2 | No reaction |
12 | No light | No reaction |
Under optimized reaction conditions, we thoroughly explored the effectiveness of the novel photocatalyst Amvp-CB[8] across a range of phenthiol and styrene derivatives (Table 2). Amvp-CB[8] proved highly adept at facilitating the coupling of these derivatives with various substituents, consistently yielding the corresponding sulfides in high efficiency (82% for 3b, 83% for 3c, 93% for 3d, 78% for 3e, 76% for 3f, 74% for 3g, 87% for 3h, 80% for 3i, 86% for 3j, 88% for 3k, 84% for 3l, 94% for 3m, 93% for 3n, 66% for 3o, 73% for 3p, 72% for 3q, 71% for 3r, 70% for 3s, 77% for 3t, 74% for 3u, 68% for 3v, 69% for 3w, 67% for 3x, 76% for 3y, 59% for 3z, 60% for 3aa, and 62% for 3ab). This underscores the catalyst's strong promotional effect on the phenthiol-styrene coupling process. Notably, extending the reaction time revealed an intriguing capability of Amvp-CB[8] to selectively convert sulfides into sulfoxides with high selectivity, avoiding excessive oxidation to sulfones. By optimizing the reaction time, we achieved an impressive 86% yield of the sulfoxide (4a) after 12 h. Furthermore, we assessed the catalyst's applicability to diverse derivative substrates for further sulfide oxidation, demonstrating high yields across different substituted derivatives as shown in Table 3 (82% for 4b, 83% for 4c, 88% for 4d, 78% for 4e, 85% for 4f, 87% for 4g, 90% for 4h, 74% for 4i, 76% for 4j, 72% for 4k, 79% for 4l, 69% for 4m, 73% for 4n, and 71% for 4o). This broad applicability underscores the robust performance of Amvp-CB[8] in various chemical environments. To gauge the practicality of this method, we conducted a scale-up reaction. Remarkably, using 7.2 mmol of 4-methylbenzenethiol and 6.0 mmol of styrene under standard conditions, we achieved the product separation yields of 89% (1.22 g) and 82% (1.2 g), respectively. This outcome indicates minimal efficiency loss and highlights the potential scalability and efficiency of Amvp-CB[8] in practical synthetic applications (Scheme S2†). In addition, after separating the reaction products, we continue to add raw materials to the reaction system, and the reaction can still occur, which proves the stability of the photocatalytic system (Fig. S12†).
In our exploration of the photoredox thiol–ene cross-coupling reaction process (Scheme 2), we conducted control experiments by adding scavengers for various active species to elucidate the underlying reaction mechanism. Scheme 2a illustrates that the addition of TEMPO and butylated hydroxytoluene (BHT) notably inhibited the reaction, suggesting the involvement of a radical process. Conversely, the addition of potassium iodide (KI) as a hole (h+) scavenger, triethylamine (TEA) as a ˙OH scavenger, and sodium azide (NaN3) as an 1O2 scavenger did not significantly alter the reaction yield. This indicates that the presence of h+, ˙OH, and 1O2 species has negligible impact on the photocatalytic activity. However, the addition of DMPO as a O2˙− scavenger resulted in a substantial decrease in yield, particularly affecting the formation of sulfides. This outcome underscores the pivotal role of O2˙− in mediating the coupling reaction between phenthiol and styrene.
In our continued investigation, we added scavengers of various active substances to the products obtained in the initial reaction step to further verify the mechanism. The results confirmed that 1O2 and O2˙− are crucial in the photooxidation process of sulfides (Scheme 2a). This finding underscores the persistent role of 1O2 and O2˙− in driving the photooxidation reactions mediated by Amvp-CB[8]. Additionally, we conducted fluorescence quenching inhibition experiments using the substrate for the photocatalyst in water. As depicted in Scheme 2b, minimal fluorescence quenching was observed when only the styrene model substrate was introduced to the catalytic system. In contrast, a significant fluorescence quenching effect was noted when the 4-methylbenzenethiol model substrate was added to the catalytic system (Scheme 2b). This observation suggests that phenthiol undergoes initial interaction with the catalyst during the photocatalytic process. According to the Stern–Volmer equation: I0/I = 1 + ksv [Q] = 1 + kqτ0 [Q], kq can be calculated to be 8.44 × 105 M−1 s−1 (Fig. S13†). Furthermore, as shown in the ground-state UV-vis absorption and fluorescence emission spectra of Amvp-CB[8] of Scheme 2c, the free energy E0–0 stored by Amvp-CB[8] in the excited state could be estimated from the intersection and tangent of the absorption and fluorescence spectra, which was +2.67 V. Subsequently, we tested the redox properties of Amvp-CB[8] and the model substrate in water using cyclic voltammetry (CV) (Scheme 2c), and it was observed that Amvp-CB[8] possessed two reversible redox warps, and the redox potential of Amvp-CB[8]/Amvp-CB[8]˙− was determined by the first oxidation reduction wave as E°(Amvp-CB[8]/Amvp-CB[8]˙−) = −0.28 V (Scheme 2d). Therefore, E°(Amvp-CB[8]*/Amvp-CB[8]˙−) = E°(Amvp-CB[8]/Amvp-CB[8]˙−) + E0–0 = +2.39 V. To test whether the excited state of Amvp-CB[8] has the ability to oxidize phenthiol, we also performed CV experiments on the model substrate (Fig. S14†). The oxidation potential of the model substrate was +1.58 V, which was much lower than E°(Amvp-CB[8]*/Amvp-CB[8]˙−) (Scheme 2e), suggesting that the photocatalyst in the excited state could be able to oxidize the substrate.
On the basis of the above mechanism experiments and existing references,51–55 we propose a possible reaction mechanism for the photoredox thiol–ene cross-coupling reaction (Scheme 2f). Under photoexcitation, the catalyst Amvp-CB[8] firstly became excited state Amvp-CB[8]*, then phenthiol is oxidized to cationic radical intermediate I by the excited state Amvp-CB[8]*, while Amvp-CB[8]* is reduced to Amvp-CB[8]˙−. Furthermore, Amvp-CB[8]˙− and O2 undergo electron transfer to form O2˙− and return to the ground state Amvp-CB[8]. O2˙− can be used as a hydrogen atom transfer (HAT) agent to interact with intermediate I to form intermediate II. On the one hand, intermediate II can form unstable intermediate III, on the other hand, intermediate II continues to interact with styrene to form IV, and finally IV undergoes HAT with HOO˙ to form the sulfide product. However, by prolonging the reaction time, the sulfide product can continue to undergo energy transfer or electron transfer with 1O2/O2˙−, and pass through intermediate V to form the final sulfoxide product with another sulfide.
Footnote |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available. See DOI: https://doi.org/10.1039/d4qo01454e |
This journal is © the Partner Organisations 2024 |