Qin Ren‡
a,
Takashi Osawa‡a,
Michiaki Tatsunoa and
Satoshi Obika*ab
aGraduate School of Pharmaceutical Sciences, Osaka University, 1-6 Yamadaoka, Suita, Osaka 565-0871, Japan
bInstitute for Open and Transdisciplinary Research Initiatives, Osaka University, 1-3 Yamadaoka, Suita, Osaka 565-0871, Japan
First published on 8th July 2024
Antisense oligonucleotides (ASOs) are generally obtained via chemical synthesis on a solid support and phosphorothioate (PS) modification with a phosphate backbone to increase their in vivo stability and activity. However, desulphurised products, in which PS is partially replaced by phosphodiesters, are generally formed during the chemical synthesis of ASO and are difficult to separate from the desired PS-modified ASO by chromatography. Therefore, revealing the unknown factors that cause the formation of desulphurised products and proposing methods to inhibit their formation are highly desirable. In this study, it was found that peroxides in THF, which is used as a solvent for the acetyl capping agent, oxidise phosphite triesters to produce desulphurisation products. The use of THF with antioxidants effectively suppresses the oxidation caused by THF peroxides. Moreover, THF peroxide was found to oxidise phosphoramidites, which are the building blocks of oligonucleotide chemical syntheses, indicating that caution should be taken with the organic solvents used during the synthesis and purification of phosphoramidites.
ASO is generally synthesised in the solid phase using the phosphoramidite method (Fig. 1).9 This method consists of four reactions: removal of the 5′-end DMTr group (detritylation); coupling of phosphoramidite to the 5′-OH group; acetylation of the unreacted 5′-OH group (acetyl capping); and oxidation of phosphite triester. The reaction cycle is repeated without purification until the oligonucleotides are elongated to the desired length. The introduction of PS modification in the phosphoramidite method can be achieved by oxidative sulphurisation of phosphite,10–23 which is the phosphoramidite coupling product. However, in the synthesis of PS-modified oligonucleotides, desulphurisation products in which PS is partially replaced by PO, referred to as PO-substituted products (POSPs), are often produced as major impurities in chemically synthesised PS-modified oligonucleotides.24 In addition, it is very difficult to maintain a high quality of PS-modified ASOs because the POSPs are very similar to the desired oligonucleotide in terms of molecular size and physical properties and are difficult to remove by High Performance Liquid Chromatography (HPLC) purification. Therefore, preventing its formation during oligonucleotide synthesis is necessary.
The desulphurisation of PS due to metal ions in aqueous ammonia,25,26 trace amounts of water in organic solvents,27 phosgene in aged trichloroacetic acid,28 ammonia treatment of alkylated thiophosphoric acid,28 and acetyl capping29 have been reported as factors in the formation of POSPs. However, despite the identification of these factors, completely suppressing the desulphurisation of PS using current ASO synthesis technology remains difficult. Therefore, we assumed that there may be reasons for the formation of POSPs other than the aforementioned factors. Very recently, we have developed a facile purification method for oligonucleotides that uses highly lipophilic phosphoramidites to protect unreacted 5′-OH groups and facilitate the removal of shortmer impurities resulting from nonquantitative coupling of phosphoramidites by simple reversed-phase chromatography.30 Cholesterol-phosphoramidite31 was used instead of acetylating agents, which was expected to suppress the formation of acetyl capping-derived POSPs. Based on this hypothesis, PS-modified oligonucleotides synthesised using our method were analysed and showed an unexpected increase in POSP. This suggests that the substitution of PS for PO occurred for a reason different from the known desulphurisation factors that have been identified. Comparing our method using cholesterol-phosphoramidite30 with the conventional conditions for oligonucleotide synthesis, cholesterol-phosphoramidite, THF, and tetrazoles were most likely involved in the formation of POSPs. In particular, THF is oxidised by oxygen in the air and converted to peroxides, depending on the storage conditions.32 Against this background, the desulphurisation of PS by THF peroxide, which proceeded with our simple purification method using cholesterol-phosphoramidite, was verified. In this study, we confirmed that THF peroxide increases the number of POSPs. Therefore, the relationship between the THF peroxides and the amount of POSP was investigated for the reagents used as THF solutions in the phosphoramidite method (Fig. 1). Furthermore, based on the findings, improvements to our simple purification method were made. This study presents the detailed results.
PS-modified T5-mer was subsequently synthesised using THF containing approximately 3135 ppm (ca. 30 mM) of peroxide and the capping conditions shown in Table 1. These samples were subjected to HPLC analysis, and the ratio of POSP formation was calculated from the peak areas of PS-T5mer and POSPs (Fig. 3). First, PS-T5-mer was synthesised without using a capping reagent, and no POSPs were observed (Table 1, entry 1). In addition, PS-T5-mer was synthesised using a THF solution of cholesterol-phosphoramidite and an acetonitrile solution of 5-ethylthio-1H-tetrazole (ETT) as capping reagents before sulphurisation. Consequently, similar to that without capping reagents, no POSPs were generated (Table 1, entry 2). This means that it is very unlikely that PS is desulphurised by THF peroxide, one of the two expected formation pathways of POSPs shown in Fig. 2A. Next, 7.7% of the POSPs were generated when cholesterol-phosphoramidite and ETT were pumped into the solid phase prior to the sulphurisation of the phosphite triester (Table 1, entry 3). In our recently reported purification method,30 the capping of the 5′-OH group by cholesterol-phosphoramidite was performed before sulphurisation of the phosphite triester. Therefore, the result shown in entry 3 is consistent with our recent results. As noted above, PS is probably not desulphurised by THF peroxide; thus, the results of entry 3 suggest that phosphite triester may have been oxidised by THF peroxide, as shown in Fig. 2B.
Entry | Capping reagents | THF peroxide (mM) | Methoda | POSPsb (%) |
---|---|---|---|---|
a Method A and B are shown in Fig. 2.b Conversion rate to POSP calculated from UV area ratio of HPLC analysis. | ||||
1 | None | — | — | 0 |
2 | Cholesterol-phosphoramidite in THF, ETT in MeCN | 30 | A | 0 |
3 | Cholesterol-phosphoramidite in THF, ETT in MeCN | 30 | B | 7.7 |
4 | THF, ETT in MeCN | 30 | B | 47.2 |
5 | MeCN, ETT in MeCN | — | B | 1.1 |
6 | THF | 30 | B | 34.6 |
7 | THF with BHT | <0.1 | B | 0.9 |
8 | Ac2O, pyridine in THF with BHT, 1-methylimidazole in THF with BHT | <0.1 | B | 0.5 |
Fig. 3 Reversed-phase HPLC charts of crude PS-T5-mer synthesised with or without the capping reagents shown in Table 1. HPLC column: waters XBridge® oligonucleotide BEH C18 column (4.6 × 50 mm), eluent A: H2O/HFIP/TEA = 100/1/0.1, eluent B: CH3OH, flow rate: 1.0 mL min−1, temperature: 50 °C, gradient: CH3OH 0–15% (20 min). |
From these results, conditions without cholesterol-phosphoramidite or ETT were investigated to show a dramatic increase in the ratio of POSPs (Table 1, entries 4 and 6). In contrast, when THF containing BHT with a THF peroxide concentration of less than 10 ppm (ca. 100 μM) was used, few POSPs were produced (Table 1, entry 7). Furthermore, substituting THF for MeCN resulted in negligible phosphite triester oxidation (Table 1, entry 5). Based on these results, PS-T5-mer was synthesised using THF with adjusted concentrations of THF peroxide instead of a capping reagent. The results showed a concentration-dependent increase in the percentage of POSPs (Table S2 and Fig. S3†), clearly indicating that THF peroxide is a factor in the formation of POSPs. In contrast, since phosphoramidite is a trivalent phosphorus compound like phosphite triester, the fact that only 7.7% of POSPs were generated under the entry 3 condition may be attributed to the consumption of THF peroxide by the oxidation of cholesterol-phosphoramidite. In addition, few POSPs were observed when PS-T5-mer was synthesised by the conventional acetyl capping method (Table 1, entry 8). The THFs used in commercially available acetic anhydride and 1-methylimidazole solutions contain BHT, which may be the reason why almost no PO-substitution of PS occurred.
The contribution of THF peroxides to the formation of POSPs during conventional oligonucleotide synthesis was examined. For example, phosphoramidites are generally used in acetonitrile solutions, whereas some chemically modified artificial nucleic acid phosphoramidites are less soluble in acetonitrile and are used as THF solutions.34,35 In addition, acetyl capping reagents are often used as THF solutions. As mentioned earlier, because the THF solvent of the commercial acetyl capping reagent contains antioxidants such as BHT, very few POSPs were produced (Table 1, entry 8). However, because the complete suppression of the formation of THF peroxides is difficult even in the presence of antioxidants, the possibility that old capping reagents with insufficient control may contain THF peroxides cannot be ruled out. Therefore, the relationship between THF peroxide and the amount of POSPs in the phosphoramidite coupling and acetyl capping processes was investigated (Table 2). First, PS-T5-mer was synthesised using thymidine-phosphoramidite dissolved in THF containing 483 ppm (ca. 4.6 mM) of peroxide or in a mixture of THF and acetonitrile (1:3). The results showed no significant increase in the formation of POSPs when the phosphoramidite solvent was changed to THF (Table 2, entries 1–5, and Fig. S4†). This suggests that the peroxide in the THF solution was almost completely consumed by the oxidation of thymidine-phosphoramidite and cholesterol-phosphoramidite. Therefore, thymidine phosphoramidite was dissolved in THF containing 1336 ppm (ca. 13 mM) of peroxide to a final concentration of 67 mM, and the changes over time were analysed by LC/MS. The reaction was completed in 5 min, and a peak corresponding to approximately 10% of the oxidised product with a molecular weight increase of 16 was observed (Fig. S5†), indicating that THF peroxide can oxidise phosphoramidite.
In contrast, the synthetic conditions using THF as a solvent for phosphoramidite resulted in the increased formation of shortmers, such as PS-T4-mer, compared to the general synthetic conditions using MeCN (Fig. S4 and Table S3†). Because the reaction rate of phosphoramidite and tetrazoles in THF, which is the rate-limiting step of the coupling reaction, is slower than that in MeCN,36 the use of THF as a solvent reduces the coupling efficiency of phosphoramidite, which may be the reason for the increased amount of shortmers produced. Although the phosphoramidite concentration decreased by the oxidation of phosphoramidite, almost no difference in the amount of shortmers produced was observed with and without BHT (Fig. S4 and Table S3†). Based on these results, when THF is used as a phosphoramidite solvent, the decrease in the coupling efficiency of phosphoramidite during the formation of POSPs should be focused on. In contrast, THF is sometimes used as a reaction solvent for the phosphitylation of chemically modified nucleic acids.37–41 The above experimental results indicate that phosphoramidites may be oxidised by THF peroxide even during their synthesis, leading to yield loss. In addition, common ethers, such as diethyl ether, which are used for the extraction and recrystallisation of organic compounds, are also known to contain peroxides,42 and care should be taken with the solvents used in the purification of phosphoramidite after the reaction.
As a model for older acetyl-capping reagents that may contain THF peroxides, PS-T5-mer and nusinersen (Fig. S6†) were synthesised using acetyl-capping reagents prepared with THF containing 507 ppm (ca. 4.9 mM) of peroxide and commercially available reagents containing BHT (Table 3, Fig. S7, and S8†). The results showed that capping before sulphurisation (Fig. 2B, Method B) tended to increase the amount of POSPs compared to capping after sulphurisation (Fig. 2A, Method A) in THF solutions of acetic anhydride or 1-methylimidazole with little peroxide (Table 3, entries 1 and 2). In addition, nusinersen, presumably because of its longer base than the T5-mer, was exposed to the acetylation reagent more frequently, resulting in a few percent increase in POSPs, which was more pronounced when the acetylation reagent was from a THF solution containing 507 ppm (ca. 4.9 mM) of peroxide. Specifically, when capping was performed before sulphurisation, the percentages of POSPs were 2.4% for the T5-mer and 16.4% for nusinersen (Table 3, entry 3). In contrast, when capping was performed after sulphurisation, the percentage of POSPs was only 2%, even for nusinersen, and very few POSPs were produced in the case of the T5-mer (Table 3, entry 4). These results indicate that peroxides in THF, which is the solvent of the acetylation reagent, are factors in the formation of POSPs and that acetylation should be performed after sulphurisation to inhibit the formation of POSPs. However, it is probably best not to use THF as the solvent for the acetylation reagent because it could be difficult to completely inhibit POSP formation caused by THF peroxide. In other words, the use of a peroxide-free solvent, such as MeCN, may be effective in inhibiting POSP formation. For example, MeCN solutions of 1-methylimidazole and acetic anhydride are commercially available, and their use is expected to improve the control of POSP formation. Entries 4 and 5 in Table 1 show that, using MeCN as an alternative solvent to THF, the ratio of POSPs decreased significantly, which supports this prediction.
Entry | Capping reagents | BHT | THF peroxide (mM) | POSPs (%) | |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
PS-T5-mer | Nusinersen | ||||
a Conversion ratio to POSP was calculated from the UV area ratio of the HPLC analysis.b Conversion rate to POSP calculated from the MS intensity ratio of LC/MS analysis. | |||||
1 | Ac2O, pyridine in THF, 1-methylimidazole in THF (Method B in Fig. 2) | ○ | <0.1 | 0.5a | 3.0b |
2 | Ac2O, pyridine in THF, 1-methylimidazole in THF (Method A in Fig. 2) | ○ | <0.1 | 0a | 1.6b |
3 | Ac2O, pyridine in THF, 1-methylimidazole in THF (Method B in Fig. 2) | — | 4.9 | 2.4a | 16.4b |
4 | Ac2O, pyridine in THF, 1-methylimidazole in THF (Method A in Fig. 2) | — | 4.9 | 0a | 1.9b |
Finally, we verified whether the use of THF containing an antioxidant in our purification method using cholesterol-phosphoramidite could suppress the formation of POSPs (Table 4, Fig. S9, and S10†). The ratio of POSPs was 2.4% for the T5-mer and 17.8% for nusinersen in the synthesis using cholesterol-phosphoramidite dissolved in THF containing 507 ppm (ca. 4.9 mM) of peroxide (Table 4, entry 1). When cholesterol-phosphoramidite was dissolved in THF containing BHT, the formation of POSPs was reduced by less than a quarter compared to that in THF without BHT (Table 4, entry 2). A purification method that we have reported very recently allows for the removal of all shortmers due to nonquantitative coupling of phosphoramidites from the desired oligonucleotides by simple and easy reversed-phase chromatography using a short column for HPLC pretreatment.30 The results shown in Table 4 indicate that the use of THF containing the antioxidant BHT and the cholesterol modification prior to sulphurisation (Fig. 2B, Method B) can inhibit POSP formation and conveniently remove shortmer impurities from the desired oligonucleotides. However, the fact that POSP formation could not be completely suppressed in this experiment, as in the aforementioned experiment with the acetylating agent (Table 3), is probably due to the fact that the THF containing the antioxidant also contains a very small amount of peroxide. Using the same approach for solvent selection in the acetylating agent, it would be best not to use THF in our simple purification of oligonucleotides synthesised using cholesterol-phosphoramidite. However, cholesterol-phosphoramidite can be dissolved in THF because of its low solubility in MeCN.30 On the other hand, in the same paper on our simplified purification, stearyl alcohol modification could increase the retention of oligonucleotides in reversed-phase columns almost as much as cholesterol modification. Because the phosphoramidite of stearyl alcohol is soluble in MeCN/CH2Cl2 (1:3),43 the use of phosphoramidites of linear alkyl alcohols consisting of 20–30 carbon atoms would further suppress the formation of POSPs. Additionally, LC-MS data revealed that ca. 5% of the cyanoethyl adducts were generated during the synthesis of nusinersen using the acetyl capping method (Fig. S8†), whereas almost no cyanoethyl adducts were observed in the crude nusinersen synthesised using the cholesterol-capping method (Fig. S10†). Although a cyanoethyl group is added to the N3-position of thymine under the strongly basic conditions of treatment with aqueous ammonia,44 the cyanoethyl adduct produced in this experiment may have been derived from acetyl capping. Therefore, future experiments should clarify the factors that lead to the formation of cyanoethyl adducts.
Entry | Capping reagents | BHT | THF peroxide | POSPs (%) | |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
(mM) | PS-T5-mer | Nusinersen | |||
a Conversion rate to POSP calculated from the UV area ratio in HPLC analysis.b Conversion rate to POSP calculated from the MS intensity ratio of LC/MS analysis. | |||||
1 | Cholesterol-phosphoramidite in THF ETT in MeCN | — | 4.9 | 4.1a | 17.8b |
2 | Cholesterol-phosphoramidite in THF ETT in MeCN | ○ | <0.1 | 0.7a | 4.0b |
Footnotes |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available. See DOI: https://doi.org/10.1039/d4ra03592e |
‡ Qin Ren and Takashi Osawa equally contributed to this work and should be considered cofirst authors. |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2024 |