Pagidi
Sudhakar
,
Abhishek Kumar
Gupta
,
David B.
Cordes
and
Eli
Zysman-Colman
*
Organic Semiconductor Centre, EaStCHEM School of Chemistry, University of St Andrews, St Andrews, UK KY16 9ST. E-mail: eli.zysman-colman@st-andrews.ac.uk
First published on 29th November 2023
Organic small molecules exhibiting both thermally activated delayed fluorescence (TADF) and wide-ranging piezochromism (Δλ > 150 nm) in the near-infrared region have rarely been reported in the literature. We present three emitters MeTPA-BQ, tBuTPA-BQ and TPPA-BQ based on a hybrid acceptor, benzo[g]quinoxaline-5,10-dione, that emit via TADF, having photoluminescence quantum yields, ΦPL, of 39–42% at photoluminescence (PL) maxima, λPL, of 625–670 nm in 2 wt% doped films in 4,4′-bis(N-carbazolyl)-1,1′-biphenyl (CBP). Despite their similar chemical structures, the PL properties in the crystalline states of MeTPA-BQ (λem = 735 nm, ΦPL = 2%) and tBuTPA-BQ (λem = 657 nm, ΦPL = 11%) are significantly different. Further, compounds tBuTPA-BQ and TPPA-BQ showed a significant PL shift of ∼98 and ∼165 nm upon grinding of the crystalline samples, respectively. Deep-red organic light-emitting diodes with MeTPA-BQ and tBuTPA-BQ were also fabricated, which showed maximum external quantum efficiencies, EQEmax, of 10.1% (λEL = 650 nm) and 8.5% (λEL = 670 nm), respectively.
To date, the reported TADF-PCL materials have all showed a somewhat limited magnitude of PL spectral shift (<110 nm) upon grinding (Fig. S1†) and there are no reports of TADF-PCL compounds exhibiting near-infrared piezochromism. In fact, to our surprise, there are only a very limited number of metal-free near-infrared piezochromic organic materials with spectral shifts greater than 150 nm reported in the literature. For instance, Zhang and co-workers reported a near-infrared piezochromic material, MPCbZ, showing a large emission shift of 160 nm.15 The pristine solid (crystalline) emits at λPL of 615 nm (τPL = 4.4 ns) and has a ΦPL of 60.7% (Fig. 1). Grinding led to a change in morphology of the solid to an amorphous powder, emitting at λPL of 775 nm (τPL = 2.6 ns) and having a much decreased ΦPL of 5.2%. The original photophysics could be restored upon DCM solvent fuming. Wu et al. developed a library of mechanochromic materials in which the emission of a powder sample of compound 5df switched from a λPL of 539 to 588 nm when ground and where the original emission was restored upon fuming with different solvent vapors such as those from DCM, toluene, and acetone.16 However, when a pressure of 14.5 GPa was applied on the crystal using a diamond anvil cell, the emission change was more dramatic, shifting from 524 to 676 nm (Fig. 1).
Fig. 1 (a) Chemical structures of reported conventional wide range piezochromic materials. (b) Molecules exhibiting TADF and near-infrared piezochromism reported in the present study. |
In this work, we report three donor–acceptor TADF emitters consisting of a strong electron acceptor, benzo[g]quinoxaline-5,10-dione, composed of electron-withdrawing diketone and pyrazine moieties, linked to triarylamine donors, MeTPA-BQ, tBuTPA-BQ and TPPA-BQ (Fig. 1b). Compounds tBuTPA-BQ and TPPA-BQ were found to exhibit near-infrared piezochromism associated with large spectral shifts of ∼98 nm and ∼165 nm, respectively. The ground solids are stable under ambient conditions and can be heated to 200 °C without change in emission. The properties of the ground sample of TPPA-BQ could be restored to their original state upon ethyl acetate (EtOAc) fuming. As 2 wt% doped films in CBP, MeTPA-BQ, tBuTPA-BQ and TPPA-BQ all emit in the red and exhibit TADF, with ΦPL of 42% at 650 nm, 41% at 670 nm, and 39% at 625 nm, respectively. MeTPA-BQ and tBuTPA-BQ were used as emitters in OLEDs, which showed maximum external quantum efficiencies (EQEmax) of 10.1% at 650 nm and 8.5% at 670 nm, respectively.
Single crystals of MeTPA-BQ and tBuTPA-BQ were obtained from the slow evaporation of dichloromethane solution and temperature-gradient vacuum sublimation, respectively. Attempts to grow crystals of TPPA-BQ were unsuccessful. Both MeTPA-BQ and tBuTPA-BQ crystallized in the triclinic space group P (Fig. 2a and b, Table S1†). For MeTPA-BQ, the torsion angles of 58.44(16)° and 22.63(16)° between the acceptor and the phenylene rings are similarly twisted to those in tBuTPA-BQ [(51.9(3)° and 21.5(3)°, respectively]. The smaller torsion for one of the rings is due to the strong intramolecular C–H⋯N hydrogen bonding interactions (H⋯A distances of 2.38 Å for MeTPA-BQ and 2.46 Å for tBuTPA-BQ) between the nitrogen on quinoxaline and the ortho C–H of the attached phenyl, enforcing the quasi-planarity. There are weak C–H⋯π interactions between the molecules of MeTPA-BQ in a head-to-tail molecular arrangement in the crystal packing (H⋯centroid distance of 2.68 Å, Fig. 2c). In contrast, there are mutually supporting CO⋯π (O⋯centroid distances 3.306(2), 3.3819(19), and 3.558(2) Å) and C–H⋯π (H⋯centroid distance of 2.64 Å) contacts between neighboring molecules of tBuTPA-BQ in the crystal lattice (Fig. 2d).
Density Functional Theory (DFT) calculations at the PBE017/6-31G(d,p)18 level of theory were performed in the gas phase to provide insight into the electronic structure of the molecules (Fig. 3). The excited-state properties were calculated using time-dependent density functional theory (TD-DFT) within the Tamm–Dancoff approximation (TDA-DFT)19 based on the optimized excited S1 state geometries.
In the case of MeTPA-BQ and tBuTPA-BQ, the HOMO is located on the triphenylamine (TPA) donor moieties along with some contribution from the pyrazine, while the LUMO is located on the benzo[g]quinoxaline-5,10-dione (BQ) acceptor. In the case of TPPA-BQ, the HOMO is delocalized across both the TPA and the adjacent phenylene spacer and there is no electron density on the pyrazine, while the LUMO is localized on the BQ acceptor. As a result, the HOMO/LUMO energy levels are stabilized in TPPA-BQ (−5.20/−2.78 eV) in comparison to both MeTPA-BQ (−5.06/−2.60 eV) and tBuTPA-BQ (−5.06/−2.61 eV). The computed HOMO–LUMO gaps for MeTPA-BQ, tBuTPA-BQ and TPPA-BQ are 2.46, 2.45 and 2.42 eV, respectively, which are nearly the same, indicating that there is no significant impact of either the donor strength or spacer length on HOMO–LUMO gaps. The S1 and T1 energies of TPPA-BQ are 1.73 and 1.67 eV, respectively, which are stabilized to 1.60 and 1.48 eV for MeTPA-BQ and 1.46 and 1.41 eV for tBuTPA-BQ. The calculated ΔEST values for TPPA-BQ (0.06 eV) and tBuTPA-BQ (0.05 eV) are smaller than that of MeTPA-BQ (0.12 eV). Natural transition orbital (NTO) analysis based on the S1-optimized geometry revealed that the hole is located on the TPA segments, and the particle is located on the BQ acceptor for the S1 and T1 states of the MeTPA-BQ (Table S2†). Similarly, in the case of tBuTPA-BQ and TPPA-BQ, the hole is mostly located on one TPA group with a very small amount on the other TPA, while the particle is located on the BQ. Nearly similar electron distribution patterns at their S1 and T1 states resulted in small spin–orbit coupling matrix elements (〈S1|ĤSOC|T1〉 for MeTPA-BQ (0.13 cm−1), tBuTPA-BQ (0.06 cm−1) and TPPA-BQ (0.03 cm−1) in the gas phase. Thus, relatively slow kRISC from T1 to S1 is expected in all three compounds.
Fig. 4 (a) Cyclic voltammograms (CV) and differential scanning calorimetry (DPV) of MeTPA-BQ, tBuTPA-BQ, and TPPA-BQ in N2-saturated DCM solution with 0.1 M [nBu4N]PF6 as the supporting electrolyte and Fc/Fc+ as the internal reference (0.46 V for DCM vs. SCE)22 and a scan rate of 100 mV s−1. (b) Absorption and emission spectra of MeTPA-BQ, tBuTPA-BQ and TPPA-BQ in the toluene (λexc = 460 nm). |
The absorption and emission spectra of the three compounds are shown in Fig. 4b. The absorption spectra of MeTPA-BQ and tBuTPA-BQ consist of bands peaking at 302 and 445 nm, along with a broad shoulder at around 535 nm. Not surprisingly, the molar absorptivity (ε) values for these bands are very similar for the two compounds given their similar structures. A similar absorption spectral profile was noted for TPPA-BQ; however, the high-energy band at 312 nm is slightly red-shifted while the low energy band and associated shoulder at 405 and 460 nm are blue-shifted compared to the former two compounds. These low-energy bands in all three compounds are due to the charge transfer transitions from the donor fragments to the benzo[g]quinoxaline-5,10-dione acceptor moiety, while the short wavelength bands can be ascribed to the donor-centered absorption bands assigned based on comparison with the literature.21 The red-shifted CT bands in MeTPA-BQ and tBuTPA-BQ are due to a shorter phenylene spacer that facilitates increased conjugation as illustrated by the DFT-predicted HOMO and LUMO overlap (Fig. 2). The absorption spectra are insensitive to the solvent polarity indicating weak/negligible CT character in the ground state as evidenced by the small, computed ground-state dipole moments of 4.83, 4.66, and 3.16 D for MeTPA-BQ, tBuTPA-BQ and TPPA-BQ, respectively (Fig. S20†).
The photoluminescence spectra in toluene are broad and unstructured, indicating emission from a CT state. MeTPA-BQ and tBuTPA-BQ emit at λPL of 680 nm while TPPA-BQ showed a blue-shifted emission at 645 nm. The PL spectra in different solvents showed positive solvatochromism that corroborates the CT nature of the singlet excited state (Fig. S20†).
The steady-state PL and phosphorescence spectra were measured in 2-MeTHF glass at 77 K and S1 and T1 energies were determined from their respective onsets (Fig. 5a–c). The shape of the steady-state and phosphorescence spectra are broad and structureless, illustrating that both states at cryogenic temperatures are CT in nature. The S1 and T1 energies are 2.16 eV and 2.15 eV for MeTPA-BQ, 2.15 eV and 2.14 eV for tBuTPA-BQ, and 2.32 eV and 2.22 eV for TPPA-BQ. The corresponding ΔEST are 0.01 eV, 0.01 eV, and 0.10 eV. The emissions of MeTPA-BQ, tBuTPA-BQ, and TPPA-BQ in degassed toluene solution decay mono-exponentially, with τPL of 5.4, 5.8 and 3.9 ns, there is no delayed emission observed (Fig. S21†). Next, we investigated the photophysical properties in 4,4′-bis(N-carbazolyl)-1,1′-biphenyl (CBP) host as this host matrix has a sufficiently high triplet energy (T1 = 2.6 eV) to prevent the backward energy transfer from the T1 states of the dopant emitters.23 An optimized doing concentration of 2 wt% was identified based on an assessment of the ΦPL as a function of dopant concentration from 2–10 wt% in CBP (Table S4†). The MeTPA-BQ, tBuTPA-BQ, and TPPA-BQ emit at λPL of 670, 650, and 625 nm in 2 wt% doped films in CBP, emission that is blue-shifted compared to their respective spectra in toluene solution at λPL of 680, 680 and 645 nm (Fig. S22†). The corresponding film ΦPL are 32, 30 and 28% under air and these values increased to 42, 41, and 39% under N2. Compounds MeTPA-BQ, tBuTPA-BQ, and TPPA-BQ all showed increasing delayed emission with increasing temperature, indicative that these compounds are TADF emitters (Fig. 5). The emissions of MeTPA-BQ, tBuTPA-BQ, and TPPA-BQ decay with multiexponential kinetics, with average prompt lifetimes (τavg,p) of 8.0, 9.9 and 12.2 ns, and average delayed lifetimes (τavg,d) of 40.1, 144, and 42.8 μs, in 2 wt% doped films in CBP, respectively (Fig. 5, S23, Table S5†). Using these average lifetimes, the kISC and kRISC were calculated24 to be 2.9 × 107 and 3.3 × 104 s−1 for MeTPA-BQ, 2.7 × 107 and 0.9 × 104 s−1 for tBuTPA-BQ, and 2.3 × 107 and 3.2 × 104 s−1 for TPPA-BQ, respectively, indicating that all three emitters have nearly the same RISC rate constants (Table 1). These kRISC values are relatively slower compared to the reported carbonyl-containing quinoxaline acceptor-based TADF emitter (2,3-bis(4-(10H-phenoxazin-10-yl)phenyl)quinoxalin-6-yl)(phenyl)methanone, DPXZ-PQM (kRISC = 2.05 × 105 s−1).25 This is due to its higher ΦPL of 88% and shorter τd of 3.8 μs due to the smaller ΔEST of 0.02 eV in 5 wt% doped in DCzDPy (5,5′-bis(carbazol-9-yl)-3,3′-bipyridine) films.
Emitter | λ abs /nm | λ PL/nm solutiona/filmb | S1c/eV | T1d/eV | ΔESTe/eV | Φ PL (N2/O2)/(%) | τ p /ns | τ d /μs | k ISC / × 107 s−1 | k RISC / × 104 s−1 |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
a Toluene (λexc = 450 nm). b 2 wt% doped films in CBP (λexc = 340 nm). c S1 state energy determined from the onset of steady-state PL spectra at 77 K in 2-Me-THF (λexc = 450 nm). d T1 state energy determined from the onset of phosphorescence spectra (1–9 ms) at 77 K in 2-Me-THF (λexc = 450 nm). e ΔEST = S1 – T1. f Φ PL was recorded under air/N2 atmosphere using an integrating sphere for 2 wt% doped films in CBP (λexc = 340 nm). g Prompt average lifetime (τp) was recorded using time-correlated single photon counting (TCSPC) (λexc = 375 nm) and. h Delayed average lifetime (τd) was recorded using a microsecond flash lamp (λexc = 340 nm). i k ISC = kp(Φd/ΦPL) – kd(Φd/ΦP). j k RISC = kd(ΦPL/ΦP). kp = 1/τp and kd = 1/τd. The kp and kd are the rate constants for the prompt fluorescence and delayed fluorescence, respectively, kISC = intersystem crossing rate constant, kRISC = reverse intersystem crossing rate constant, ΦP and Φd are the prompt fluorescence and delayed photoluminescence quantum yields. | ||||||||||
MeTPA-BQ | 302, 445, 535 | 680/650 | 2.16 | 2.15 | 0.01 | 42/32 | 8.0 | 40.1 | 2.9 | 3.3 |
tBuTPA-BQ | 302, 445, 535 | 680/670 | 2.15 | 2.14 | 0.01 | 41/30 | 9.9 | 144 | 2.7 | 0.9 |
TPPA-BQ | 312, 405, 460 | 645/625 | 2.32 | 2.22 | 0.10 | 39/28 | 12.2 | 42.8 | 2.3 | 3.2 |
The compound TPPA-BQ showed an even more remarkable red-shift of ∼165 nm upon grinding. The as-prepared sample emits at 590 nm (FWHM = 106 nm), has a ΦPL of 3% and a τPL of 5.2 ns, while the ground sample emits at 755 nm (FWHM = 195 nm), has a much diminished ΦPL of 0.2% and a τPL of 1.8 ns (Fig. 6d–f). Akin to tBuTPA-BQ, the ground form of TPPA-BQ was stable under ambient conditions and the photophysics did not revert to the as-prepared form upon heating to 200 °C. However, the photophysics of the ground form could be converted to that of the as-prepared form upon fuming with EtOAc. Akin to the sublimed form of tBuTPA-BQ, the PXRD of TPPA-BQ showed a resolved diffraction peaks for the as-prepared sample, indicating its crystalline nature (Fig. 7b). The diffractograms of the ground powder did not show any noticeable patterns indicating that these samples are in an amorphous state. The PXRD pattern is perfectly restored after EtOAc fuming of the ground sample of TPPA-BQ (Fig. 7b). The as-prepared sample of TPPA-BQ showed multiexponential emission decay kinetics with τP of 5.2 ns and average τd, of 60 μs. Variable temperature time-resolved PL measurements further confirmed the TADF behavior of as-prepared sample of TPPA-BQ (Fig. S27†). However, when ground no TADF was observed, possibly due to its weak PL behavior. The 1H NMR spectra of the ground samples dissolved in CDCl3 were the same as those of the as-prepared samples, indicating that grinding did not decompose the compounds, and that a solid-state transformation was responsible for the piezochromism.
In the solid-state absorption spectra of TPPA-BQ, distinct differences were observed for the as-prepared and ground samples (Fig. S28†). The as-prepared sample showed absorption bands at ∼310, ∼410 and ∼475 nm. The ground sample has the same ∼310 nm band but there is a new band at ∼420 nm with a tail extending to 600 nm. Such a long wavelength tail likely indicates that there is partial conformational planarization leading to an increase in the conjugation length to some extent in the ground form (Fig. S28†). The as-prepared (crystalline) TPPA-BQ emits at 590 nm, which is close to the emission (600 nm) of the 0.5 wt% doped film in PMMA, clearly indicating that the emission of the as-prepared sample reflects the emission from monomolecular species that is present in the dispersed state. Therefore, we attribute the large spectral shift (165 nm) for TPPA-BQ to emission from an amorphous aggregate (Fig. S29†). The absorption spectra of the sublimed and ground samples of tBuTPA-BQ are similar, indicating that no significant changes occurred to its conformation upon grinding. Similarly, the sublimed sample (crystalline) of tBuTPA-BQ emits at 622 nm, which is similar to the emission (631 nm) of the 0.5 wt% doped film in PMMA, clearly indicating that the emission of the sublimed sample reflects the emission from monomolecular species that is present in the dispersed state. Upon grinding, the emission originates from an amorphous aggregate (Fig. S29†). For MeTPA-BQ, the emission from the as-prepared (crystalline, 735 nm) sample results from an aggregate as it is much different from the emission observed in the 0.5 wt% doped films in PMMA (622 nm). Upon grinding, the emission originated from the amorphous aggregate (745 nm).
The grinding and fuming cycles for TPPA-BQ were repeated 20 times and showed a high degree of reproducibility, confirming the reversibility of the phase transformations and with no obvious fatigue response (Fig. 7c). To demonstrate the practical application of TPPA-BQ as a photoluminescent ink, the compound was dispersed in EtOAc under ultrasonication for 2 min. The dispersed suspension was coated onto a filter paper by drop casting and left to dry for 1 h. A glass rod was used as the writing implements on the substrate (Fig. 7d), and the areas of the filter paper upon which the rod was in contact showed a contrasting reddish color, indicative of the ground form while the rest of the filter paper emitted yellow-orange emission under UV light illumination. The distinct emission color change of the written text remained for at least 2 months of observation. The text could be erased upon the addition of EtOAc drops to the written region, while DCM, hexane and THF did not produce the same behavior.
Emitter | λ EL /nm | FWHMb/nm | CIEb/(x, y) | V on /V | CEmax/cd A−1 | PEmax/lm W−1 | EQEd |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
a Device stack; ITO/HATCN (5 nm)/TAPC (40 nm)/TCTA (10 nm)/mCP(10 nm)/emissive layer (2 wt% emitter in CBP, 20 nm)/TmPyPB (70 nm)/LiF (0.7 nm)/Al (100 nm). b The electroluminescence maximum, CIE coordinates and FWHM of the EL spectrum recorded at 5 V. c The turn-on voltage at EQEmax. d The order of measured values: the EQEmax/EQE100/EQE1000. | |||||||
MeTPA-BQ | 650 | 123 | 0.64, 0.34 | 3.4 | 5.88 | 5.43 | 10.1/3.4/1.4 |
tBuTPA-BQ | 670 | 134 | 0.66, 0.34 | 3.4 | 4.69 | 4.33 | 8.5/3.4/1.3 |
Footnote |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available: Experimental procedures, computational details, 1H and 13C NMR spectra, HRMS, HPLC data, and single-crystal XRD structures of the target compounds. CCDC 2296442 and 2296443. For ESI and crystallographic data in CIF or other electronic format see DOI: https://doi.org/10.1039/d3sc05188a |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2024 |