Edward R. H.
Walter‡
ab,
Lawrence Cho-Cheung
Lee‡
bc,
Peter Kam-Keung
Leung
cd,
Kenneth Kam-Wing
Lo
*cd and
Nicholas J.
Long
*a
aDepartment of Chemistry, Imperial College London, Molecular Sciences Research Hub, London, W12 0BZ, UK. E-mail: n.long@imperial.ac.uk
bLaboratory for Synthetic Chemistry and Chemical Biology Limited, Units 1503-1511, 15/F, Building 17 W, Hong Kong Science Park, New Territories, Hong Kong, P. R. China
cDepartment of Chemistry, City University of Hong Kong, Tat Chee Avenue, Kowloon, Hong Kong, P. R. China
dState Key Laboratory of Terahertz and Millimetre Waves, City University of Hong Kong, Tat Chee Avenue, Kowloon, Hong Kong, P. R. China
First published on 21st February 2024
An increase in the mitochondrial membrane potential (MMP) is a characteristic feature of cancer and cardiovascular disease. Therefore, it remains of crucial importance to develop new and improved fluorescent probes that are sensitive to the MMP, to report on mitochondrial health and function. Reported here are the design, synthesis, photophysical properties and biological characterisation of a series of BODIPY dyes, BODIPY-Mito-n, for mitochondria-targeted fluorescence imaging applications. Six BODIPY-Mito-n analogues were synthesised under mild conditions, and displayed excellent fluorescence quantum yields of between 0.59 and 0.72 in aqueous environments at physiological pH (pH = 7.4). The incorporation of poly(ethylene glycol) (PEG) chains to the triarylphosphonium cation moiety significantly improved the biocompatibility of the probes (BODIPY-Mito-6, IC50 > 50 μM). All BODIPY-Mito-n compounds demonstrated a high MMP-sensitive localisation in the mitochondria, with Pearson's correlation coefficients (PCC) of between 0.76 and 0.96. Compounds BODIPY-Mito-2 and BODIPY-Mito-6 revealed the highest sensitivity to the MMP, with a decrease in the emission intensity of 62% and 75%, respectively following MMP depolarisation. It is anticipated that the highest MMP sensitivity and enhanced biocompatibility of BODIPY-Mito-6 could lead to the development of new probes for mitochondrial imaging in the future.
Mitochondria have a negative mitochondrial membrane potential (MMP, ΔΨm), facilitating a stepwise accumulation of lipophilic cations into the mitochondrial matrix in accordance with the Nernst equation.5 The conjugation of a lipophilic cation, such as triphenylphosphonium (TPP+) to small molecules increases their accumulation in the mitochondrial matrix by 1000-fold compared to the extracellular space.6
Healthy cells have an MMP between −150 and −180 mV.7 In both cancer and cardiovascular disease, the MMP is known to increase considerably,8 enabling compounds that accrue in the mitochondria in an MMP-dependent manner to be utilised for non-invasive imaging of mitochondrial function, and the delivery of therapeutic cargo.9 For example, such an approach has been utilised for a wide range of imaging agents to study mitochondrial dysfunction by Single-Photon Emission Computed Tomography10 and Positron Emission Tomography (PET).11–14
Fluorescence Imaging (FI) is an important and powerful imaging technique with a high sensitivity and spatial resolution.15 A wide range of cationic and lipophilic fluorescent probes have been developed for selective mitochondria imaging, and a number of which are commercially available. Mitochondria-targeting probes can be broadly divided into two main groups: firstly, compounds that demonstrate an MMP-dependent uptake and retention in the mitochondria, such as JC-116 and rhodamine 123.17 Secondly, probes have been designed to bind covalently to mitochondrial proteins, as epitomised by the MitoTracker™ series,18 but they cannot provide direct information on mitochondrial function.
Boron-dipyrromethenes (BODIPYs) are an important class of widely studied fluorescent dyes characterised by high extinction coefficients, excellent thermal- and photo-stability and high fluorescence quantum yields (ϕ).19,20 Additionally, the core structure can be easily modified to tune the photophysical properties21,22 and introduce biological targeting moieties.23 Over the last decade, a wide range of BODIPY-based mitochondria-targeting compounds were developed,24–29 including probes for dual-modal PET/FI,26,27 and to report on mitochondrial reactive oxygen species such as hypochlorous acid28 and peroxynitrite.29
To date, one major problem in this area of research is the development of new and improved fluorescent probes with an MMP-dependent uptake. Historically, the accumulation and retention of BODIPY-based compounds is either independent of the MMP,24,26 or the experiments to determine this sensitivity are not carried out,25,27 limiting the use of these probes to report on mitochondrial function.
In 2016, Archibald and co-workers reported the first BODIPY-based probes demonstrating an MMP-dependent accumulation and retention in the mitochondria (BODIPY-I and BODIPY-II, Fig. 1A).30 It was determined that BODIPY-I, containing two cyclohexyl moieties, displayed a greater than 70% decrease in mean fluorescence intensity in cancer (MCF-7) and heart (H9c2) cells following mitochondrial depolarisation. Additionally, a BODIPY analogue bearing a [19F]-fluorobutyl moiety showed significant promise towards the synthesis of a dual-modal PET/FI probe.30 However, the late stage installation of a dicyclohexylphosphine or diphenylphosphine moiety with n-butyllithium required the modification of the BODIPY core prior to lithiation.31
Fig. 1 Phosphonium cation-functionalised BODIPY compounds. (A) Previously reported compounds by Archibald and co-workers,30 and (B) BODIPY-Mito-n compounds investigated in this work. |
Previous studies have also demonstrated that B–F substitution with phenyl or methyl substituents significantly reduced the fluorescence quantum yields.31,32 Additionally, such a modification hinders further structural adjustment, for example, the introduction of water solubilising groups onto the boron centre.33,34
Here we report the design, synthesis, photophysical properties and biological characterisation of a series of BODIPY-Mito-n compounds bearing cyclohexyl and/or phenyl moieties (Fig. 1B) to determine the optimum substitution requirements for high mitochondrial localisation and MMP sensitivity. We envisaged that commercially available cyclohexyl- and phenyl-substituted phosphines can be introduced to the BODIPY core via nucleophilic substitution under mild basic conditions, without the need for prior B–F substitution. The use of mild conditions also enabled the development of BODIPY analogues containing triarylphosphines incorporating di(ethylene glycol) (DEG) (BODIPY-Mito-5) and poly(ethylene glycol) (PEG) moieties (BODIPY-Mito-6) (Fig. 1B) to determine how the length of the chain modifies the mitochondrial uptake and retention of the probes following MMP reduction.
Finally, to confirm the importance of the phosphonium cation in facilitating mitochondrial localisation, BODIPY-Et (Fig. 1B) was synthesised for comparison studies.
Scheme 1 Synthesis of BODIPY-Mito-n. Conditions: (i) PR1R2R3, toluene, 110 °C, 3 d (BODIPY-Mito-1–3) and (ii) PR1R2R3, CH3CN, 85 °C, 3 d (BODIPY-Mito-4–6). |
Phosphines bearing cyclohexyl or phenyl functionalities were purchased from commercial suppliers, and DEG-based aryl phosphine, compound (2), was synthesised as first described by Wang and co-workers (ESI, Scheme S1†).37 The synthesis of (7) was achieved using a similar procedure to that of (2), but instead using a PEG unit with an average molecular weight of 350 Da (PEG-350).
Subsequent nucleophilic substitution of BODIPY-Br with phosphine precursors (PR1R2R3) formed BODIPY-Mito-n analogues in good yields (50–92%) (Scheme 1). Reactions with phosphines containing cyclohexyl moieties were undertaken in toluene, and purified by recrystallisation in dichloromethane and hexane. However, for the aryl phosphine analogues, BODIPY-Mito-4, BODIPY-Mito-5 and BODIPY-Mito-6, it was found that higher yields were achieved when the reactions were performed in acetonitrile.
Finally, BODIPY-Et was synthesised in an analogous manner to BODIPY-Br, but instead using 4-ethylbenzaldehyde (Scheme S2†). However, rather than a one-pot reaction, higher yields were achieved following purification of the dipyrromethane intermediate via silica-gel column chromatography prior to complexation with boron trifluoride etherate under basic conditions.
The absorption, emission and excitation spectra of BODIPY-Mito-1 in PBS are shown in Fig. 2, displaying a characteristic absorption maximum at 497 nm and a fluorescence maximum at 511 nm. As expected, all BODIPY-Mito-n analogues demonstrated almost identical absorbance, emission and excitation wavelength maxima in PBS (pH = 7.4) (Table 1 and Fig. S1†) and acetonitrile (Table S1 and Fig. S2†).
Fig. 2 Absorption (blue), emission (orange) and excitation (green) spectra of BODIPY-Mito-1. [BODIPY] = 10 μM, PBS (pH = 7.4), 298 K. λex = 497 nm, λem = 511 nm. |
BODIPY | λ abs/nm (ε/104 M−1 cm−1) | λ ex/nm | λ em/nm | QY (ϕ) |
---|---|---|---|---|
a [BODIPY] = 10 μM in PBS (pH = 7.4), 298 K, λex = 497 nm. Quantum yields (QY) (ϕ) were measured using fluorescein in 0.1 M NaOH (ϕ496 nm = 0.95)38 as the standard. Estimated error = ±20%. b Broad absorption spectrum. c Not measured. d Very weak emission was observed. | ||||
BODIPY-Mito-1 | 497 (5.56) | 497 | 511 | 0.60 |
BODIPY-Mito-2 | 497 (6.45) | 497 | 511 | 0.67 |
BODIPY-Mito-3 | 497 (6.40) | 497 | 511 | 0.62 |
BODIPY-Mito-4 | 497 (5.92) | 497 | 511 | 0.59 |
BODIPY-Mito-5 | 497 (5.67) | 497 | 512 | 0.62 |
BODIPY-Mito-6 | 498 (6.49) | 500 | 512 | 0.72 |
BODIPY-Et | 488 (3.83), 538 (5.74)b | —c | —d | —c |
Additionally, all analogues were found to have extinction coefficients in the range of 5.56–6.49 × 104 M−1 cm−1, and high fluorescence quantum yields between 0.59 and 0.72 in aqueous media (Table 1). Interestingly, the highest quantum yield of 0.72 was reported for the PEGylated (PEG-350) analogue BODIPY-Mito-6. Finally, the absorption and emission spectra of BODIPY-Mito-n analogues were found to be independent of pH in the physiological range (pH 5–8) (Fig. S4–S6†).
BODIPY-Et, in comparison, displayed markedly different photophysical properties in PBS (pH 7.4). The absorption band became significantly broader with the absorption maximum located at 538 nm. Furthermore, BODIPY-Et was notably less soluble in aqueous environments and very weakly fluorescent. However, in acetonitrile similar absorption, emission and excitation wavelength maxima were displayed (Table S1 and Fig. S3†). Such a discrepancy in aqueous media is likely due to an increase in π–π aggregation caused by the higher lipophilicity of BODIPY-Et.
Strikingly, BODIPY-Mito-1–4 were specifically accumulated in the mitochondria of the cells with Pearson's correlation coefficients (PCCs) ranging from 0.92 to 0.96 (Fig. 4). These results confirm that both cyclohexyl and phenyl moieties on the phosphonium cation can realise high accumulation of the probes in the mitochondria. Such a result further supports observations by Rokitskaya and co-workers, that the aromaticity of lipophilic cations is not important for effective permeation through lipid membranes and accumulation in the mitochondria.39
However, treatment of HeLa cells with BODIPY-Mito-5 and BODIPY-Mito-6, which contain three DEG and PEG chains, respectively, gave negligible intracellular emission under the same conditions (Fig. 3A), indicating that the PEG chains could impede the cellular uptake efficiencies of the compounds due to reduced lipophilicity. These observations are consistent with the flow cytometric data, which show that the cellular uptake of BODIPY-Mito-5 and BODIPY-Mito-6 was much lower than the other BODIPY compounds (Fig. 3B). By finely tuning the incubation concentration from 500 nM to 5 μM (BODIPY-Mito-5) and 25 μM (BODIPY-Mito-6), the cellular uptake efficiencies were substantially increased (Fig. 5A). Notably, BODIPY-Mito-5 and BODIPY-Mito-6 were also enriched in the mitochondria with good PCCs of 0.93 and 0.76, respectively (Fig. 5B). These results suggest that introduction of PEG chains could impede the cellular uptake. However, PEGylation does not pose a significant impact on the mitochondria-targeting properties of the compounds.
The control compound BODIPY-Et exhibited poor overlap with the MitoTracker (PCC = 0.56; Fig. 5C, top), demonstrating the significance of the phosphonium cation to direct the probes to the mitochondria. Co-localisation studies with Lipi-Blue, a commercial stain for lipid droplets, showed that BODIPY-Et was specifically enriched in the lipid droplets (PCC = 0.97; Fig. 5C, bottom) due to its neutral charge and high lipophilicity. Such a result is not surprising, and many lipophilic BODIPY derivatives have been found to efficiently target the lipid droplets.40,41 Control compound BODIPY-Et could, therefore, warrant further studies for lipid droplet-related biological events.
After confirming the specific mitochondria-targeting properties of BODIPY-Mito-n, we then examined the structural features that are important for a high MMP-dependent mitochondrial localisation. The cells were treated with the oxidative phosphorylation uncoupler carbonyl cyanide m-chlorophenylhydrazone (CCCP) after incubation with the BODIPY-Mito-n compounds to dissipate the transmembrane potential and depolarise the mitochondria. LSCM and flow cytometry were utilised to not only image the MMP sensitivity of the compounds, but also quantitatively measure the emission intensity changes. As revealed by LSCM, the CCCP treatment resulted in a substantial decrease in intracellular emission intensity for all six BODIPY-Mito-n compounds (Fig. 6A), demonstrating the strong dependence of the probes to MMP. This was further evidenced by flow cytometric analysis, which showed that the CCCP treatment led to 29–75% decrease in intracellular emission intensity (Fig. 6B and Table S2†). Since the fluorescence intensity of the probes was not quenched by CCCP (data not shown), the remarkable decrease in intracellular emission intensity suggests that the reduction in MMP led to the rapid release of the probes from the depolarised mitochondria. As a result, a substantial decrease in the mitochondrial accumulation of the probes was observed.
Among BODIPY-Mito-1–4, BODIPY-Mito-2 showed the highest sensitivity to changes in MMP, which should be associated with the charge distribution on the phosphorus atom.29 Furthermore, cells treated with the PEGylated BODIPY-Mito-6 displayed a larger reduction in emission intensity (75%) when compared to its PEG-free (BODIPY-Mito-4; 40%) and DEG (BODIPY-Mito-5; 36%) counterparts. These results suggest that a longer PEG chain can minimize the non-specific interactions of the compound with mitochondrial proteins and membrane structures, enhancing the sensitivity of the compound towards changes in MMP.
The IC50 values of BODIPY-Mito-1–4 were determined to be 5.0–6.7 μM (Table S3 and Fig. S7†), which are an order of magnitude higher than the imaging concentrations used (500 nM). Notably, the IC50 values of BODIPY-Mito-5 (8.0 μM) and BODIPY-Mito-6 (>50 μM) were higher than those of BODIPY-Mito-1–4 (5.0–6.7 μM) due to the PEG pendants on the TPP+ unit, showing that PEGylation can increase the biocompatibility of these compounds.
The control compound BODIPY-Et was also found to be essentially non-cytotoxic towards the cells (IC50 > 50 μM). These results highlight that the cellular localisation imposes an important factor in the cytotoxic activity of the BODIPY compounds, and the increased cytotoxicity of the BODIPY-Mito-n compounds is associated with their mitochondria-targeting capability. Nevertheless, the IC50 values of the BODIPY-Mito-n compounds (5.0–8.0 μM for BODIPY-Mito-1–5 and >50 μM for BODIPY-Mito-6) are much higher than those that were used in the imaging experiments (i.e., 500 nM for BODIPY-Mito-1–4, 5 μM for BODIPY-Mito-5 and 25 μM for BODIPY-Mito-6; incubation time = 1 h) even with a prolonged incubation time (24 h). These results demonstrate that all the BODIPY compounds showed good biocompatibility and the BODIPY-Mito-n compounds are promising MMP-dependent mitochondria probes for fluorescence imaging applications.
All BODIPY-Mito-n derivatives showed pH-independent photophysical properties and displayed very high fluorescence quantum yields of between 0.59 and 0.72 in biologically relevant media.
Additionally, analogues bearing triarylphosphonium cations containing DEG (BODIPY-Mito-5) and PEG functionalities (BODIPY-Mito-6) showed improved water solubility, and extending the length of the chain was found to reduce the cytotoxicity of the probes (IC50 value increased from 8 μM to >50 μM).
Through the synthesis of the control compound BODIPY-Et, we demonstrated that lipophilic cations are critical to ensure effective mitochondria targeting, and the aromaticity of the lipophilic cations is not important for effective permeation through lipid membranes and accumulation in mitochondria.
Both cyclohexyl and phenyl moieties on the phosphonium cation can realise high MMP-dependent accumulation in the mitochondria, and all BODIPY-Mito-n analogues displayed excellent PCC values of between 0.76 and 0.96 in HeLa cells.
In BODIPY compounds incorporating cyclohexyl and/or phenyl substituents (BODIPY-Mito-1–4), BODIPY-Mito-2 displayed the largest sensitivity to the MMP, where a 62% decrease in the emission intensity was seen in HeLa cells following CCCP-induced mitochondrial depolarisation. Such a result is in accordance with Archibald and co-workers, and was assigned to the cationic charge being localised on the phosphorus atom, rather than being delocalised on the aromatic ligands.30
However, across the BODIPY-Mito-n series, BODIPY-Mito-6 not only displayed increased biocompatibility, but also enhanced sensitivity to the MMP, showing a 75% reduction in the emission intensity following mitochondrial depolarisation. Such a result highlights the potential of BODIPY-Mito-6 to simultaneously label the mitochondria and monitor MMP changes in live cells.
Our results indicate that several factors play a crucial role in the design of mitochondria-specific probes with high MMP sensitivity. As such, BODIPY-Mito-n analogues have the potential to report on changes in mitochondrial function in cancer and cardiovascular disease. Additionally, we believe that our work will open new avenues for the design of mitochondria-targeting fluorescent probes in the future, providing improved alternatives to the widely used TPP+ moiety for assessing mitochondrial activity and function.
Footnotes |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available. See DOI: https://doi.org/10.1039/d3sc06445j |
‡ Equal contribution from both authors. |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2024 |